Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Dilip L Choudhari vs M/O Finance on 6 February, 2019
2 OA No.280/3017, I87301F & 2882017 ' CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAL ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.286/2017, 287/2017 & | 288/2017, Date of Decision: 06.02.2019, CORAM: BR. FLIAYKUMAR, MEMBER (A) RN. SINGH, MEMBER (J) Shri Madhukar RB. Natu, Assistant Commissioner (Retd.), Réat B-1/12, Amrutvel Society, HKM Road, Model Colony, Pune 411 O16. Email [email protected]. . Applicant in G4 2862617 Shr Narmalkishor R. Paldiwal, Assistant Commissioner (Retd.), Rat Nisarg Pooja, Bldg. 'B', Flat No.404, Kaspate Vasti, Mankar Chawk, Wakad, Pune 411 047, Email id -- krpaldiwal @rediffinail.com. .. Applicant in OA 287 (2617 Shri Dilip L. Choudhari, Assistant Cormmissioner (Retd.), Rat Flat No.B/15, Bhelke Residency, Bhelke Nagar, Kothrud, Pune 411 038. Email Id---dilip [email protected], « Applicant in OA 2888/2017 (in Person) VERSUS 1, The Union of India, Through Secretary Ad-TIA Ministry of Finance Department & Revenue Narth Block, New Delhi 116 007. 2. The Central Board of Excise & Customs, North Block, New Delhi 110 G01. 3. The Secretary, Department of Personnel & Training, North Block, New Deihi 110 001, Respondents nen y rate, & TN } « Bidg., ar, Member {2 io + KCI % 3 er af Central Excise, Heri i - a fae ORDER
Pero ROP Shetty) > ssioner Audit 1, ICE House, {By Advocate Siri RR 417A Sassoon Road, Pune 411 601.
ry e, 41/A Sassoon Road, TM ?
fief Commissior & EE How * c Principal Commissioner of Central Excise & 115 MLR. Road, Opp. Churchgate Station, Service Tax, Pune-I Commissione Mumbai-[, New Central E Mumbai 400 020, The Cony Pune 411001, The C I a
4. 3, &.
vd ved aed ty on % 3 QB "x3 ey wD mw i a3 aS & i 3 Sh Ba Q 3 ke ef 3 i iy @ ba $5 43 8 8 43 43 3 wed "s a Se : my 4 cm Bg ee mo, | 3 ae vt i O 3 "at ti oC a 3 @ bp gp mf MA 6 © re ad e my O Co Mm ua ct 4 O ra ig qt as Gal t~ ey y «ot ad " +e # n as 3 5 0) ws rf i } oe ip iG ! de oy £3 wy a 4 a ae 54 2 ke oi te Te £3 oY cn bf 5 a re ze f 2 @ a oo nef ce os a qs 43 + : es ¢ in a 3 Q rs @ Ye 0 SUR RG Oo orf 4 oS 29 gg &§ Bg wm GQ od tor O @ BO 6 BE a RO OE oO Oh a ® og 6 . De gg a a uy O ey ws a a 7 roe gk 7 3 ee iD ie) « re) q @ "a vA C G if a 9 "tt baat 3 oe a a a j ' od ta Gp $3 DQ @ re 5 a Hi OO , G© sg i Poy pO Qe ay cs ted bd "ed io 5 a ood . 6 age , a a) ea) Q Eg bed * G 'Ly oO & Gr i % Ow : 7 4 a oe oF ¥ He kad ra . 2 fh: "ed kG ty A cod " 43 wy + oO £9 %) 43 ef ee : moog t eS 6 © ¢@ 8 . g@ & - gf OO ® Ht c oa et G £3 a ts ro tt y Pa @ ' O wa 43 wo uy 43 3 a ea: BB oe oy Re 8 be TY w o Y i a ees oS OE cS as HF ua 1) a a ce) : ce ca . mS is RL aed " bs 3 ia Dp is oO rf 2 RB, O red y 8. G ed ni bos eh rt & end oy as bef thy eet ay 4d a % @ & Dy, ey ' me wy vd, ¢ ay vr 3 "ed aha oO Dy 3h * Ct g @ ' oy . eG % $100 By re) o cf % Oy GS $4 ory rs re 3 rr Dp hi ns -- ~ ey Lentral Exwcise anc were erir dents in 1998 Takir . .
Lear BOpLLlcant, ne Was ova we $3 3 erintendent in 2998. The Lory of has career and pay : ¢ § : - :
* $ ¢ < . 4 es Post 2 Pay No. } 'Direct recruit Effective tn oo iz pas, t WED OG {2 Inspector 2 Superintendent _Rs.6500-10500/- 30.06.1998 3 Scale ~----- Revised Rs.7500-12000- No date, 'Superintendent 2 ACP ~_ Rs.8000-275-1 vorders
04. 05.2006 3500, alt. | "15.02.2006.
op 6* Fixation Superintendent.
CPC Pay: PB-ILGP Rs.4800/-
01.01.2006 ron 6° CPC (NFU) 2002) 'PB-II GP Rs.5400/-
(4 years completed in.
"01.01.2006 ACP Superintendent as PB-IIL GP Rs.5400/-
A uae ro | Bot oot oi oN Superintendent.
ed MACP "order 07.05.2012 as PB-IlT GP Rs.6600/-:
dated , qs. 02.2012 _ Assistant .
Commissioner.
3° MACP.
'PB-Il GP Rs. 5400/-. pending orders on 10 Recovery by Order dated.
cancelling 3* 12.04.2016, MACP granted The above is the case for all per whe were eligible for 2° ACE, based on Of as Inspector between. 01,901 Cs A oO rs s oe A ¢ oh ct ® hs £5 O's.
va ff ees "~ ° 288: 202;
O. OA é af & gt xD oD oD co Os Cy vont be spe itd s reg o KS iD 3 ce el of ag "4 ee ad G opt hg us 4;
G ct 8 bt ay ha 2 oO wee 3 ug a <4 seq © ;
43. a y 4 ~ x aoe.
t "ed 44 "et G t & <3 ce "ed #) gct Boa £3 is chet ey wed 3 eid RS 1 LS a weer re Vv at ip etm hod ts be wD ard ef Meg se } fh i if
1) . xf ted ed a] pa oe % ot A x 2 5 OAR Vo 28G 2017, 282017 & 288201 7 Sr. Post : Pay 2 Effective Nan: :
'1 Direct recruit ' 15.02.1982 2 Inspector : | | 2 Superintendent Rs, 6500- 10500/- 30, 06.1998 Scale Revised Rs.7500-12000/- No date | Cas | Superintendent | , '4 28 ACP Rs.8000-275- 15.02.2006 13500, orders dt. 04.05.2006 6" CPC Pay PB-L GP Rs.4800/- 01.01.2006 Fixation :
'Superintendent. - |
6 .6°CPC (NFU) PB-II GP Rs.5400/- 01.01.2006 ec: years: Bose completed in:
2002) | 2 ACP not Kr elig gible} in view:
of NFU. te 8 3" MACP as PB-III GP 15.02.2012 Superintendent BSS400/- we : 'dt. 07.05. :
"Assistant PB-I GP 22.10.2014 'Commissioner. 'Rs.5400/- | Recoveries as. 'relevant. :
6. Howaver, the respondents then adopted x rae ' 3rd ARENT sep Ap ey , eee on gt tty deleting the 3° MACP evidently because the a te} og od oh .
OL Tne Grads ray %, : % ct oT ary ~ PAS WDC, oo APL Poe Pe 7 oot a fn OF nw, 5 3, 3 yy 4 ee z :
ASSistan ommissioner which held the Pay ASSistant Commissioner w i held the Pay bint we eT saw by ay im 7. ge Ay fn PR-TIT with rade Pay of Rs,8400/-. Poo oN a7 nao za Sot ¥ . = So final result as given by the rescondents
8 G4 No 2862017, 2822017 & 28820! Re |e ae MAF ee SSS wed ME AY was Pod ts wit was The Effective '1 Direct ys Inspector
2. . Superintendent recruit:
© 15.02.1982 Rs.6500-10500/-
30.06.1998 'Seale _ Superintendent Revised:
Rs. 7500-12000 'No date.
4 2 ACP 'Rs.8000-275-13500 15. orders dt.
04.05.2006 3 Fixation Superintendent.
CPC Pay, PB-O GP Rs.4800/-
"OLOL2006 6 6 CPC (NFL) rc years.
completed in:
2002) i fed Superintendent 28 ACP as ifs PB-ILGP Rs.5400/-
PB-HI GP Rs.8400/-.
1.07.2006 15.02.2006 8 Assistant Commissioner.
PB-Ill GP Rs.5400/- pending orders on 3! MACE.
216.2014 9 'Recovery by:
1 2.G8. 2016.
cancelling 38
-MACP granted Order' dated Pry oe x Sew tis Cogan' YK ARN 2 oes aA Fs Mases Aimitar to the applicants a ey Re Tee SYR S Watre WaAaK ables acT os wT Ss Uihese Qik ee EAS Paws SPL Te Abo WEY post of ot seed udgmer 3 a $ ay the ko wid bite and 5 <4 we he 4 wD Q ea uy * x} 4 Et "cf a 0 ca] od see i cs we aa ee te wo ca o3 oY E @ w ot c oy ™ UNA.
Trib a ied ay ee ad, a v3 FeAl vb By M4 reg Abed ar QO a aS an 4 w 1 ql
8) bd
q) ft Fs 43 44 oO eG aaa) cf} yy ce O
e) "
\ is} @ Ww tu iD rf 3 et ni a es co tw £38 Cy
i) 7 ef « red (3 ~ at bd a ee ble Hon?) & 4 x8 iy ved A im oh ad a oe Ok sich y Lon aki :
ss :
a & 2 eS S oo " a @ a im 4 3 " cm 4.2 & ag o Oo 4g re O i e . @ ® ae 4 a 2 eB 2 oi va ee SS rs So 4d 5 . 2 te tae a <I £3 & ved ne hes it - th 4 a a3 f 4 B f& sb oe OS YAR ob ae v4 Oy, Bo 9 >» 2 8 be. of G 3 £5 ort re 43 a : ' pei, GQ wa t C ra ae s Sty " ~ fo a Sf 42 4 : a bye sed mB " 6 a ae os oh, fi @ yu, 3 , 2 4 5 QB dM } : on 5 x ee ¢ anh th ay Ch & a 3 o bE gy if re pe Pe A eB ag, Re age Mo os ca 4 ' . a} xy w re) un ag a Oo £5 ay * rod ay edt 6 xe$ a a4 43 {Dp : at @ Lf rst) 6S G4 ag G bh Se OD BS mw @ ' in cs bf ans OO © os a a Shs ea in be mM cud t4 iu C a, 3) oh ws re es me 6 Ew ee , ts 2 UR Yi Dm wo 1 BD os wz he es ope "4 a , * i) 3G +t : 4 a 4 os 3 ee Ea 42 oo O ed uw os 33 D sed 5 wo "pd $4 x 2 6 « 3 ee 4 0: a) Q E3 Cy mo £73 cs + ma ed : ab eS 4: 44 ors wi m4 5 aD Og Re ag c oO 9 SM SS a on EO gad $4 ve "i 2 oo @ @ o eo Ow yo Os a Ba yh od gs ¢ , us o 3 wo * By i 3 g fee se} : MP kn : we sek wo oy ct , 1D My C . {3 (74 g " 'e ; ip heed fa 4 "st BH ty 43 @ "ed Og ny we ay QR pod a aS po ee Oe ; Voy ap Way ~ "2 % So ed ~ g is re ord ahead a ee ba' t § %: wi s, acs } ot 4 et a aed ; aed "ps 3 thd , My vs C ce 3 tt a 44 64 : x 4 ' rh od . 2 3 ry hex eh iF S gd sl 3 ue @ 43 bey ' Ss ae eS - a @ & i 4 a en 5 «3 4 4 i mg Go gy 0 a @ ok os @ Aga Sao me rd o st Ge O Go mt BG Me oh BS + by oe Se ae 6} KGS Word a Ge rd 6 4 or od 3 : ied Os ws a % as B te 3 ' 0 5 "is + Pot we ; Bs reg cea o oa C3 ; % 2 2 tre oe be ca :
ie 4 £5 . fe fs if aa "9 FB ° | 8 6 2 w oe gg iO af cone } ' oot gud j a . : gt ry @ O " int 8 wef ' B4 ty na seek its "ed 2 i a a 3 > 5 a4 tb "et 43 ra a hel } ~ ee th 3 03 i) ta o 6 "4 Cy co wR ww 4G ley " fe Be O 4 a8 As ci "a ches ¢ s > eh oan) 4 9 try ven a aa ? we € 4 oe oe a ras oi 43 ee] 9 @ ey ved . f o + @ &; 43 ie » - ad 43 me . "5 u " ma Dob oo ao) it a ® So se o ~ Som 8 wo 8 co m8 : % 63 a Oe by ed tS Ht uw rs weed bE eg : UT oi «s ; e Wwe 2) j O hs ny 4 7 4 th he :
o Sd Ye vt reat : © wn uy 3 ed 0% co ot re yp 3 © Ooo € 3S ot H 4G Ch a eo) GD et eed z - wt Wh ' 4 "4 wk : 4 i "
3 Bog f y Go op @ @ b o & & 8 Swe Bo Bod g e) faa M obs . P i + 0 - ef hy Shs fe : 3 rs : i £3 [on 5 8 4 vo te Bos OS 9 % oA < nD Ke Mo hs
4. ref : ae os t °e as 7 et "
(6 4 a ty % cy ea oo © © 0 u = a ' fa i 1 \ i 5 i iy u fe 4 P ih wy goa o °° a gges $. * oy wos § Ma 7 is geetae a 5 % S 3 te #3 oe 2 we ~. het TF: = 1g vent ae £ a es BAS 2 FR B22 8S aad ct ayers ny ar Ae eh ey sh es oS peg 2 iw 2 SUN S26 5% cs @ C " BB Ae gg * 3 D4 5 ee :
a sf ear YE ee ae © ¢ geaesy 3 28% eae +4 veh oe Boe "04 ae Sot a 3S Be aly 8223 a ms D a ks ws tf a Bee 23 oe ae ee gopad ea gig lde: Baas ont aod i Bes 3:15 Cis oe #388 * 3 Bs F LB ae . o ut ne ent ay "hy At wee 38 eb tea m Ds Be - sa Eg oan > Ey ho mo AEG Se qa a wee WE 43 "ke se &. % o un 2 > Bees es Bog mon kes & 8 SE gS ot ee BN ane WeeUes ae oo B oo rigid teas eve oes es g 28 ee 3S ~ 7 ee i> c eS . ps ot % ae ane ee z iy i os: Boe : yt | 2 s. * ca 228) Gade : we 8 Bl bees 4 3 Ss oot 245 os § ag eee 8B WB ee? i #8 "* BS edt * ee) Seo! Se t3 ed & oy aa ee ue i S$ 33 ay wee + & 4 Pee 1 8 4, wy bey ee ie ca wh. ¥ at cs ed a is oy wt jos z ¢ > Ma. Srmmeeet se 8 i : ES mers Ses Bg & et 0 a pbc igt ee aaa . re hae oo By 6 as ih © sceshiay eG g225 Z Be 58S | 3323 3% by 3 a Ho Se 3 Fs & at Ms eae 'eo ae 4 ae Be ane age ats " £ roe { 5 -& ae ase a £S Z x J ee 2 rs Ly m8 2 ei m5} os es Q i fy Be Sgauze wea 2 a " fa, iaiee io . "4 ff ans we ae 824s x s % SS . S 5 a Beate ne sy rt oS i a4 * ney (Ao pee! * .
we go vey Wt Maui ae Ses B2es Bga. 2228 % wa : & 2 ¢ vo G voce aca fet "ay b @ ne > oad a a 4 ct Es ep ed a Red A pe ke % 48 zone fy Be pas oer Bat B oa ae Bt aS £45 gg 1s «Bt ne 8 2 Eee og* % pee ' ge Sms = aa pgad a a o 3B #3 i & a yseo3 ea bee G Ci ag ca BOR ot wie & Fay ob pA oo bat Ba me & % "4 ot ot + oi eB ei 3 8 wy. C8 4 3 ie oe 238d 2 a cs) ool we ee J & EB o- a 4 45 - > th G G ci B re Ch oy aah ee eA Me --F.4 vA " a = a Oe vee ey " va : rf £5 < wa a aad 2 a 78253" HD a8 a " wae . Sty aS ra: X03 ioe | Te: 3 ot mG 2 Be » seg 3 ted 2 ooh oe Boat a io why © nd too i Ss 7, S mo, we wo we ad et we oe wt wee Pa xt bet # y an oP ge223 s i 3B po Sos et oa pA wy ae < a, 4 ao ot. Spey a 2 EA 4 he m4 iB ot wo LOB ts : oust <A a ae Gt oe un = Becca oj Bu 5301 Sy one a a 8 iS Ss ee bee % . eS a a gs gig @ a Ae ad Boe w Ee ee oe Se Bos wi 8B B38 oS cr a Et od 2»
- fe x mo ek 2 bag age Soe og moet Bw Fae Rom 8S : a Pbk Diy me ry Q > Beigs , BS ge F < A228 7 an tee aw aS B.S g Me 42 Shes a 4 F Pa na ae ~~ Ge gt @ sn E3 ue wat oe ey 6 4 s a S £ ge a BE oe a . @. aS es co we ie: oA Fe es BS oo} pee ot % e ia at a HS {2 22 m as ee Set ag G eae a anes 8s 3 ae. Bog 9 eee Bo 4 12 25 og A ye yo 3 Be % 8 ' 2 wees 2 Za ee 44 a & £ ae % £8 ae se "5 a a = oy 65 aes wea 4 oy & 5 gga eee Seeuae By 4 V2 Be 2 ' Se ae a os. 8} Bo mms r. Dat e # a8 et & 3. BS 4B ai -. e ae cf Les a z 25 a Pr Se S Gag wv aA Wa 2829 o> o> 2B EB SE oe Bp 4 4 2 24328 ada % g Oe caer t= Pree pataees a Bes : ie Fs ao 3 & Euan 23524 ao 3a HG + hd aa: » a Sf ny CS 2 3 Bg wy YOR ae Bs Qos mcg wy 8 = ge B® feb g ot ey ed % . Bees. alas Soe a o e SgLE2 ZEe = ah ES bee is Boe s&s ee aR qe wot a © 3 m3 iy ia om 'Ss ey "tg Ean eae 44 eR asaa aos gel es Bee ge328 a & & ~ "
ne Fool PE Sas BB ae og = Behe BS & tens . S Oo a Pa wa ang ee] 5 43 "4 st Lins Rows ory pe Goon ype ee os G Bes Pe ee B23 8 i eige Ak gS, ee Sat S232 3 3 Ey 3 by 282 iB see 3 pe | EEO gg seg a aoe we ' BBD B ty 5% Sy 8 x o r ee Wy ZO rs be i 39 a5 tS ob fa "I re US pa 8. 3 252 wes t ra at wee a my ea 8 4 we ts. we YZ go ee 18 Boa x & ge o 3 as ee mers a am a ws ee & x 43 ws aog 3 ss a fb a nee a ae oS Woe mB a B % 5h ea oe a "48 as oe ot) 5 a TER iE Ae ecg g2 2%) Ey i as foe ee we A a > ss ; wa he ki: ae a - Z 22528 Bees RE bss ee B28 yn # ef ys 4 C Bey os aad ¢ ay a SoS oe He? oa 8 aS & oe 3 a ta oe a & wh ee Row 2s z * aye o a3 x ere ren 2.3 ey 4g ao." is & a % 8S a" 3 8 Say a3 « . & . ES meses fe 8 as bese 4, > 3 ant 2S im a e eA a B 2 N77 z Bh et gm 2 oy Cy SS ne "4 3 Bod a " alt & 3 ¥ 8 ae '. : eo. Fr, pon oth 38 '> . 3 a 2 iy og aes Aa oe pg ae) .
itre shy fy \ Rent % Assent Some Besber a os = SY Adis baceneeoe ae voce sone sa at, a wie cos ney ohm ce tho wme ih tO Ok , . ZES 2 B4 Moe yn + ig Re OS . oP By BIEL De ak in a x. iat -. oe S . Os Zee a S 8 Be. eB eM a em' gp eh OR gE : ey 2 ee a" 4 . y rhe i BBEY 38 ES @ mY ELE SYERBAP SP - Boo 8 Qe oe Sue Doe ge ty we Se a 4 bed omens My, op Ce tet "a oe > oe a ee Be om we et Bo Gy Te I se he Ba a 32 woe Re ag 4 a 8 PD EL attr Doyge Zo et oe us BO aa Fe ae CE pe a Ma ae BAe OG pee . sf 4 geen eS wt @ "Be Oo OO? es wey & = 3 wo Ton See "3. ow Bop &S a. oF £8 6° Z2ES 8° Beg * so % o 7 9 % 4 BER FB als ¥ ts OR as rb Hes Wonks te 4 iw 14 BeRAg ES gx s3ELZSe 8S a8 3 Sy a e 8% tee 4a g o BAGH Oos PF Bes ph 'ss gre @ © *# 6 a Ge Se e ' @ » oS ea aoe 2 fe } 4 2B. 8 egh 3 g 2 we Bp Ew B8 Qe Oe BPE. OB of a D. 2 Sues eg : ae f 2 a ie Eo OQ 8 sae "d 3 2 oo te 3 " Be, ON 2 segs 3 D3 be EK a me wD qe ts fla ra fin i ts * rh xs 2 @ TA he 8 % M om & wg Soe b a g as a "e pod Me 2 RE : 4S, Bg i o BE *% wea io a] ' y 1 es wi a wy BE a ae & Boy oO a :
Pe on 3 aA : ; a e Z5 & BS 8 S78 g 223 9 8 : Me : 2 * x ea " x "3 "Me © oe 3 3 ero: a an 8 288 S td te eh Z ph ee oe afk & Bye @ ee 3 wae Bhim st ee 3 ete geo 8 me . fy ee fo ES ERG ee oat ge Es * ; us = 8 e 89% eS ne % ine a = 4 So Spe ee we GP Oe 3 43 we tt ABE o Lee ayy et ey OE weet ot OR SS oa Gee * Uy és te Eee 9 54 "RE be gS ar 8 GT 3 We gs ps cB: 3S C4 vane' "1 £ yw Coe OT gt Sa as Se > ace ce 3 4 ep ORB OES aa fF 6S oF 4 Bee a fee a " a * J Sod car ao Moke pee a4 ee oe eat 4 ¢ Bb ey ie By Bee og 3a oe 8 es oe Et in OS 3 wom 2 ee te : o Se oo 4 i nm A ee ee " Pod aE LSE ot "ct goose th Son: at oo o En wer apd eed "4 a) > ot, gS Bh Seay Se Se MG Poe hee i Gg 4 aoe a ia ef 3 : Be $y Bg oe gt @ 1G Ob on ; red Cee 3 B38 £4 vas. oe Se: oom c gt Bene wie. (hoe gs Awe oy g Beg ww & ar Bh oa See Ogg DD ao " "3 BEB 5 om ao Brg gig Be he o 2 a By Ps 8.28 HUE G wy BEY ow a 5 ABE GB a ; ee i "Eh tt ip vet of # bh cg ny 3: x ao pr my By peg ' A Lf £73: en iB he 3 <4 2. é a mere 5% to AO 8 Phin fan $F aed ghoo™. ett ' & Ae os oo Bo. toa ABO t9 8 MF fp2 ae eo he Mi sek fe +. , & oe a oes $03 Ep ES LA 4 "p x3 £4 th Cs] aS yk Ae Fe ke mes mee * a ws 4 ct w oa ae a Ask g eo 8 EE gy toad ered SE 4 ;
re o 4 "6, oF x 4 r at :
' ty e Z } m ta { f 4 4g 4 a 2 _ i ge pot nek sh me a + Pugster miainteacive. Tee Rawmber Banck Raxabay.
x :
, Dacieat in Union of India Vs. SLP No. 21803/2014 Mohanan Nair tf M. ¥, w% ay @ sed Chey 6 hd g@ «a vont 42 4 wm G a1} es i} 3 mt {A 43 bi sf) ke
- 5 ae 3 Oo 44 ceed "red 4 S) a Ag 43 5 fw . cs ce) 3 a KS Sy a . need OG wed i a4 a ip ¥ 3 Th.
be 4 '4 ® oO & 4 £3 4 end ai Sah mneoda fan a} ad .
att Roe PGYALST o MS uy sft is She ah, 3 formity.
SEL Pree Sat hat 6 6 Oy 0
3) 3 ae of
8) a ee hd me G bd ys fs, a oe a a 4s 3 i} orf vd Bs my w@ a 4d 1%) 43 irther . fic L spec @ f 4 w re Q a af QO it order ary t trout wit
--
% x og os Be = So ee "ois me = (R. a =.
So | ae he a ity © ( te OQ a 2 = es