Karnataka High Court
The Divisional Controller vs Manjamma on 18 April, 2012
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
EN T?-£5 HEGH C?§}%}§? Q? §'<i$s?;NA'EI£\§<,fi.
CIRCEEET EEECB AT saaawaa
§A"§E§ "mg mg :8?" am' @F ;:wR:L; '£2332.21:'«%i§f' ' *
BE?-'GRE %%%%
THE H$i\i'§LE MR..§USTECEVE':"§:§E_}éA§H'S;"i§§I: ' "'
MFA§2GG68!2"£}.;%€i JWV
§'*~'IFAgNGs.2GQ63 mm 29'06:4'f2jG1G 2G'r355iz2rj:a
mass 2§1§;_:~;§G6?%2_G3;0;_AN£} 2§138/5:1?
§'*v'iFA.2§G58 EGEQ
BETWEEN:
THE QIVISIQML é:Qr§rm:_;3LLEj9_5 ' "
KSRTC DEPoT'3E:iLA'_Rx; ..
BELLARY' ;5>.:v:s__I't:,3r%4; 5::2_r,.;A§2_~; -- S
THE APPEV:;.:..ANT*:s;_RE9RE$.E55fE:: 51%;'
:75 €HiEF.V_LA'éA;"QFF'If":E?R; '
€E?\§?'RAi. CE?-.:F:::f§;
Gi}?L§ARGA, - V ~ .,fi.??ELL&?a§?
5%? 32;; §2~é}:%::;::%<:,%':»:.;:g;§; S. 5}a§g2»g§a£G:;A§xi,§
2 ; 1- .. ' £;?i§;£;';'*é}i§;§<~§ §'%'é'i1 "§;'§, ?A§<EER;i5é%vE&,
'- _ ;a--<§E§ 5'-1a--§.%§L¥7'§" :2 '=:*5;2£S, §£iC:§?§§§E&"€;
§§_,f§, __i;AC%j?iv;é?é$%<ERZ; TEE: ;<e?m.:§
§§$?:%;:Q§?§,;,,
$2' éifié': MGTEER §%%éEERA%¥'E§**E§.
L .._3', .' . _?§3g¥#é§ RQEEL; 35$; aaagaigs %?§a;
AQEES :¥'%§Q¥j"?" $3 "5Eé§lSi,
S'€:£:QR§'%:'E§ G? 38% BEfi2§E?*»§§ 1338:
' §{;&~34,z'3-'E2I3, gga» S§§,é%'*'h, '?Q:S$§§§§¥'?;
:1'!
\..mn.««»»n»»\\<\Mn\*M»N'«'éYAWKM>fi$%%'2
§§§?°:$é.,§i.§;&RG,s5:,;
3, g.2.::J,&;;«' §<U;f'v1§R,
AGEQ A836? £3 YEARS, $CC:G¥:!¥\3ER :35:
5:35 BEARINQ §x:0.;<,aa.~3é.;/423; wag S4;
53"" FLGGR; 3AG:'::u'T:--~s: REs:sEN£\r,,
EAST svzoampsmi SECUNDERBAE1
45 THE QEVISIQNAL MANAGER; 1
SRIENTAL INSURANCE CQLTQ,
DIVISIQNAL OFFICE; 15? FLOOR, '
S.L.V,TC1WERS, *
PARVATHE EGAGAR; BELi.,AR":"'."~, ._
m9;EspQ:=.;§£§§:§Ts
{BY sR:.s=3,;ss:~=s1g QR ;;4'}" _
THES MFA ES FELE5 z;;*<3§'E52"sE'z:i:'%:._QN '-;';?_3;::} GP THE MGHBR
VEHECLES ACT; AC'£§I_NST:=_THaE~§UE.:~$%'?§E's"»§T._.;é'sND AWARD SATEB
30/09/2009*, PAS'5E::%;j:;.~g Mvr: §:lQ.2..SQ,§"2D07 Cm: THE FILE <3? THE
FAST TRACK éiOU..F€T~'1'i'~§'xT 'i~:'j:..,'>!.:1-;"»;:.:,,A,.. A"z{Vz2RDING CQMPENSATEGN
GF' Rs.2,@o0;- '§?VR'€£}?«'-'i;_:T%~£E _§A,'§"E 'as PET§'ITIQ§*<é TELL ME SAFE GF
A£T!jAL DiE';:>@3%T?';:,
f~1FAg2GO§'33A
BET':f%!EE§\i;
. f%;':~;§ §§iEE$§$?§;%§., §€;§§X¥T§RG§,,LE§;;
;;§;gAg~;{:}.'§"E?;<3?':%AE;LAR=5; """ "
'-,B§jL§..;*'%R":' s;:=a2€e:£2:%~s, BE§.,é.,%§§{'
'%".%~%§*A??EL§;駣?"E$ RfE?RESE!%§"%"E§ E'?
3%: .§C7%4,E_EF" ;;.,e;:;:é {:s'§"-?;';F5'§£§§;
CE§::":m'; @F?§§E_.;
;:3u:$gAé;':P,<3,:,.; ' . m£:??Ei.L;R?1é'§
" " 5-: Asa: $§:~vis.::;§&;<:;:%¥:;a;%' a. §=§§$fi$f§i§:§g5x{:?1;§xG':&}
" .. §é§§~;:$'§
5
E, ER;'3;?§3.:3\ 3X3. 8HEE!¥'?;3;??£,
&$E§ REGQT 33 YEARS;
Qfifiififigi 8: CG§§iEg
2* HULESEMMA W/G. ERAWA,
A653 ABGLET 33 YEARS, CICC:AGR§ & €§$~§..§Egf~.. '
3372-: THE RESPONDENTS ARE **** « .. T
Rffl LACHANAKERL "§'Q:E<QP?A£;, BIST:%<C1PPAL.
3; NAWAJ?ATELgSg'Gi. RASF~EEE{:f.?A?E§.,, "
AGES ABQUT 48 YEAR$,QC£":,D"RfVER 3? Egg: gagazags §\§G.KA--=34,i423, R/G; §E9AM;__3'€§:_SE§AMi ~ 9 §I§"%":Gi}LBfisRGA§ _ :i.\..
5, vz3m' 2<%.;MAR, AGEE2 A5ouT,45 Y"EARS.; '_<:%.C::--:.Q:;J§\eE?%. 07$, sus BEARLMQ':~.g.:3.;<;;;=34r;s;23p ' ago, 5-2, :»j§;"" --':§L-00%;. :A§RuTa;RES:::ENCv, EAST :x»z:0g--"e3;;=':;_p::v.:.,.s;;f;rf," SE-<'§.3.i§'N_DERBv'AD, ' 53 THE__D;\2'IE"1§§'&;*~;?,, _MA.F§sl;§ER&« §§1i'ENTAL ;:Nsu?s:A::LCE..uCa.;T.Q,§ §¥é;{:s:Q--:~¢A:'-:::§§:'::E;~:_?"*'-§;.,:3€>R; 3.3%; "§"€.3WE.RSg §3s%R"%5;i__'§§"H'E..'--"NéGéR; géagggyé ,=§.ES?G§é§E?«£°%"S gs"? §§::,§%s-»._3;_§?§H:; my, $39; 524; '».',":*;iEfi5'§'«;2%:%;.'}:S__¥::,E:s igmga §ECTEQ§§ ::?3{::; 3:: 'ma ivzéma *§§%?=€"»7.1E'§V";'s§T;'?, £§§§%§%":iST "§"%=§E §U8{S?v'EEE§'"§" Am fiC:;%§£«.R§ amegz 3a;'€;<§;.;;§§'§!« '§;i.4:_S':*+;E'¥@ 2?»; §»€'2!:': §a§z>,2?5,!3§5? ms '%'%~¥E §5ELE g? ?:~:& %~;%3':=f§aA£;<. {3€Z}i;§R;"f~EE 5%? §<§?PAi; AW£§§EE':i§ €Gf'«'§?E?%ES§T:§§"§ :, 5:3? §Sf':5b§$.'E;%€%{};:'7=5 Amrzsg ¥'§E"?"%§ :E\é'§'E?ES'°§' AT 'f'%%§ R£%?E 23;: 5% _ ggew "§"§~:iS§T;f*a'¥'E :3;-f ?§"':?:©:*a; "gm. SEPQSEEZ '§%%§ii§2§G5fiéf2§?:§ gm SETWEEN:
?HE QE'=.5Z§?Gs°'\£!l,L C®§\ITRQLLE%, KSREC DEPGT BELLQRY;
BEL§,.§«R":" Q§'¢'ESEC?f"%i; 5ELL.5J~?'::'¥' THE APPE%..LANT IE RE§3RESENTEE 8?' {TS {IHIEF L5d;!'iGFFECER, "
€EN"E"RAL QFFICE; I GEJLBARGA. j;'.;_éP'PE::;;':VE§"€.. «. "
{six 3% SHEVAKUMAR 3. 8ADAWA£'iéVG-:,VAQEfA.'} ~ Afflfi:
2., ERAPPA S/13$ BHEMMAPPA ' - :
mm ABOUT 33 YEARS,A.€3.CC':AG.R;~.& ::'Qs;';z;E, R/CL LAcHANAKER:_, '§'Q§:%<GPE%K:.,4 D:5T:z<0PPAz.; " " """ V' 2, NAWA3 PATEL; .379. RA,§H'EAE'§.?_FA'?EL;; AQED ABOU"E"~.4~E:' "1E§ARS,._ " ' aC£:a:::":'*;;?eRT.§,fi:~i--* swig E1EA'F?.I§\§G Na §<A«3?4,£f42.3, W0'.-".S«E_§fi.M;'=?fQ":§E§AM; QEST: C§L§LiE5;%RsS'A. "
3. $:v;3m' ;<:j;V5':'~i::,r§P;,,vvV ._ A§EQ --::a$a:'s" 43 YE:i%RS;£3C€:QW§%§E?g. G? 5:35 «E£§EA§:"?_€§ %sa;'%:;:a.:3_4;423; ' 3/{:;a.. g:2:.,;"~.4""' %'?L$§R; .:;::;R::T%~§z RES§§EfiéC"s'; ,§;%';'§,":f gaésazgésasfyg §EC§.,f§'éQ;E?\Saé;$§ "$5: 5- .Q§:i:§:':::.a;;:~;j'mmggag i3R§§E?¥é"%'1&§.,_ :a;s.V:;§.A&s€E'C§5:T§,; QI%fEE~EQf:é£i. ':'3é"FECE, 23"' FLQQR, ',5.:..::. '"%7%"}§?'v'f'.§":"§S; P;ag::;:3%:: Ngasgaa ' vg5L;A%%-:;'v---
~ V ..'§iES=§@§'*é§Ef'i§'§°S _ {E3 "§§;7:;S,$g}Q§%'°§E, 5-33%'. :?"SR 34} Em" , TEES EVEEFE3: ES §"§LEB UNSEE §EC"§'E{3?% }'?3{E} Q? THE MGTSE Es'Ei:£§CLE2S ACE fiQ?:.i§'€$'E' THE §i.§§Qf»§EIf'xE'§ £333 :'§W§§§D EEFJEES 3{3;"Q'?}/2$®§§ ?ASS§3B EN MVC ?€Q;2'?iE~»;'2€}{}?7 9:»: THE gag GE' mg mg? 'E'$E:{Z'§~<: gaamtgz EC? §:'vV.%R1::'£E'$G €:{}EviPE?»ESA.TEef)'Z\E $19 RSaiQ,GGf}/~ FR0;v:.'_;?:§LE::' , "
BATE Q"? FE'"§'§'}'{'1f{ir';\E 3:2, :33 93% <3? AC'i"i.§AL §E?;g::;=.$§'S{" - ~ MFAQOQESZSIS 7BET\NEEE\§:
THE BIVESEONAL CQNTRGLLER;
KSRTCI §E?CIT BELLARY! BELLARY SEVISEGN; BELLARYV '§'E~iE APPELLANT IS REPRESEE\§'fE£' ax'-_ "
ITS CHIEF mam QFFEQER, = CENTRAL OFFECE, ,V .. GULBARGAB _ _ *-.j;~__§_.;::;i?€:;LAN":
(3% SR; sH:vAK§5'M§a' ?.;_:£x:;§;_ga;_§.§_A@:g%av:3v:§W §E'=§§:
:5 %~::;L:'§5E§«z:¥z«;5g a;§;0;'véLés2fi;'P«§5;;... AGES Assgig? 29"':'E;éR7f;, ®¥TZi::%%Q%5SE§~E$L®; Rg'®._§£s.CH;§;'§~§&&<E.R§V;;. 32;}: i<€s?§A:.; §§§fT:§e;<}?P§i'2L;' ._ ' ' ' 52mm; %r>:§§;.§ 39:3: R£.§%%§E§ ?$C1f'E%,; ~".'3*.{;;'§§";%§€.}f;a;§~:" yams;
~ . €%T;:::::;.Rj::;E§;'.T~c'zF- 322$ azgazreg ma, 'i<A'v»%3%;£g:3; §:;@; Sgmgva ?Q:SE§§s%"€; §:.+i5"§: _€T:i*L§.é'a?<€3gé:.
= §;2;§3;%§%§~~:<::%«§A§;g ' ;'=':é§Z'?»s._§§ AEGQT 45 '€§;::2§§ §CC;§'§£?€ER 3? * -3.3%; ggwzfigs §a3Q,§<:a-34;423§
-Va./SR 5»; 4?" ?L@:;'.:% .E§a§€§i3T§%E RES§§3EP»EC%'; ?E§1§'?§'*5§Q¥iE§?@iLY§, gggasgagggggéa. W1 M u-».»mmmmvammmmwmmm 4, "mg azvzgiema gvzmgssg, ®REE%\.iTAi E?~§SL%§;,£i?§CE r::m;m_. azvzgzgmg :$F--'F1€E, :3? FLOQK, gigs, Tezégaagg sgavgwg iaiasgg, §EL%_;?xR';'I {§Y SRE.$,S,30$HL ASE', F1139; R4} THESE MFA £3 FELEB {mam SEE'ai?T§¥:§§*$VE".?1:3§i'; zvzmeg azaazcmg AC3: g%G~A§N53'E' mg -.3:;QG:*xz1%§:a%':i';s,;2$§i'% AW'AR£i BATED 305$?/2039; PA':Ts'S§;_§ 213%':v:v{:__'N'a:;ég«??~?v;f2g:@'? 9&5 THE FELE OF' THE: ms? 'rR;:c:.:;<:"%s":QUR"3s§:"A»;g*; §<;§3PPAL§ §1Wé;,R1T)LE\fG cQMPENgA:§:QN GP' Razf',-:1,$'::a5~ E'R£3E2'§,_'_i_'E%§i mm <31? ?E'E'§T:<i>E\Z TELL 3':-13 §A%;'*E:..m' égsfiggz, ELEPQSET. """ " 3%'? FA 2€3G66§2G 3.0 BETWEEN:
THE smsioNAL§-C'<:¥:'»s.:f:€:2:';§;,E£<;_~,_ :.,,,,,,_V KSRTC DEPOT BE;{..AiE§_X;._ «_ "
BELLARY §:v:S;:.QAN;~.%_8E:§;{%R~:
'THE APPELLANT :s'*~?;E.;PREsE:"e.TE~§v 32% " --_ :73 CHIEF L.€:'§»f iZ!E~'FIC'EV?{;-.
€§E'£T'R,AL CEEFECS; _ * augsgagag - _ ; ).A??E£.§,a.:%§'~3"'§' {$5 $9; "s;_;j;€§x:*;::%<:gw;;a .37; V §A§%§"¥fi%§A§i,§§3J&} = x 3;, ':?<§.;2:§§9?é;'.j:5.$:3VsV' 'ma: :<,&,??§a gag;-2% %.:*x:.::':':.;:.§f*:*" 28 ksgfiasg Q£C:GGE.3%'s§é':%L ; R!§;E7¢%{3§éA§*=ié§<E§eE; '§'Q: §<{*;§%,£\;F 1' §:$':"::«:.g§>:$?As...
s2g;é;;:a2 ?§TELg ass. §;,é'a,§§---%E§@ aa;§§;.? ,--€'éfi'3 E3 ;='%§Gi..§§" £3 ':*'E,3zRS; €f§}C€:$RE¥fER G? gififi §§£§§§\§§ E2336 " ' '""§<i.5'v34;'%»Z3; £533 323%??? '?%:§ESé:"'%; %.RE$mrs2'iféfEfr~eif:*§V,j%'*-T" A' .fl/ ((¢4!{((QU///AI/////ax»-m.» E'2E§"?: §i}LB:5%R§;§h 3% §.v13mI KLSEEIEAR;
ggsa £561}? 45 vaagg, $c¢:s$w;x;ER 3?
5133 BEARENG F"*éC>.%<,5\=»34,«"423,, Rig 3-92; 4?" agcg, 3AGRLiT:=:: RES§§§§'€C'§i Efifi"? %4oR:§?G:.:\:; gsauwagagm, £5, THE §E\£ES3lQ§'~£AL ivwsmsaag SREENTAL :N$::RA:\s:::E $0.313, SEVISIQNAL OFFICE; 13? FLQQR, S;L.5xi1TG'::\JERS; PAR\f§T§--~§£ :~::.;@;:_R;
SELLER?' ' _ ,..?;Es-?§N'Li:a;E:4*::
{av SR§;g$.SsE<f:%$%-=21; A32; FQR saga. " THES MFA. ES FELED :;N:3E1?',"s£§C%§:C2§~:.;'.12.3;3; G? mg IVIOTQR VEHICLES ACT} ;::;;;x1EiE$1"'_L§i;*'E5G:xAE:*sT MB ;'1\,WAR§ SATED 3@;::«9L;20<39, §?.g~'§£i~3S7i:?§' .:_:%.:"..V:~g;:i.?<: f\3¢:>.2?'8;2®G'? QN 'mg FELE Q?-..'::~:g__--_F;:Sf~r_ "i'_jRA<."_:--Kf <.1i(§'L3'R'§'-EE 9:2: KOPPAL, .§CW"ARD§NG CG§~;iPE,:N$A'm3N'~€g-:§":::S,:;:::>@;- FRQEVI mg EATE 0%' PETETEQNf1f'£L:.VTE§;E3,VBAf§E3 (3? ;€E,.<}fTU3%;L 3EPQSI"§, MEA,2QG6'?}"_2$._iS "ii"?-§E §ElfE§:€}?=;Léi,, 5:2:-:x;f?$z§§L:§E:Q;, . _:r<:~:§:§"<: ¥}1£ '?§:Tf':3ELLAR%",.V. ..... " §§:.:;,s:;P35":*>:::*A§$1§':s§; BELQR? '?%%_fE'£.?PE§L:i§?€? 'R§?RE3§sx:TE§ E'? §§"$f ~i':%~§£?E§3 J§.~,a:.\,:;*=§:.f1«§~:a:v?§§:??:_5C_i2-:R§ CLE?a§?%?fi;i;--.f}FFE.éiE-E._ ' '*''~v''»€;:3Lg;&§<.:*;§éx, ,. . ' .H;%?P§§_§_§2?\4T ~ ::g%f..g§;:5 Si%§,:§;i2§<i§?~%Eg?; 3, gfifié-';'§'§§§;%G§;§$§'§,:: ,§§"s§C%:
2. Sfiivfifivémfia vgggé, ?\ifx§'\é€;%??A gag) A5913' 24 ":"EAR§, 95$: aeajsgsaom, R;'§,§.fi€Hfi?xiA%<iE§E, "?Q:E<G?P,£iL, §IST:§<€3PP,AL, 2' mam; PATEL; gza RASHEEQ w:.?E:,g "
.A,§E§ ABQUT 40 YEARS, ~ ' QCC:DRI\fER 9;: gas EEARINQ Na;
i<A=34;'423; RXO. SEQAM; ?'Q:'3EQAIV€;v. 313:": GQJLSARGA; ' s.\;:3A*{ ;<:a;MAR, _ AGES AEGUT 45 \:'EAR;Sj,~-- @C:::§;:rx;5\;sE;:t..0Fi_ 8:23 BEARING sqQ;KA~34,:423;_.I" * "
ink} R53, B-2, 4" FLQQR,.1Ai3RL§'§%r§ERE?,='".ivE3Ef'»3i;?'f',, EAST? MQREDP£}{._;,Y;$ECL}'i25E;ERBé\{}, '
4. THE D§VIEI'C}4?'«iAi_.__§>¥1AN;£x{5ER; _ .. . GRIE§\iTAL I§>§S§JRA'?\iCE"€'.i (.},£;ii"§;; 3:v:s:@NA;'-©§:s:cE§ _:3?f 'E:.,:>s:>_R,, 3; :,.:f; faaagé.-,R§, ";?::=;':':;.i2.v,s;2f:«-<;_%.i §'-jfix_G;«'s';R, BEE;§.,AR.Y.. ,_ -- -
V ' '.,R,E§?G§'*ai§E%\§"§?°'S {$5 Séfii,§;$.}£}§HE;. ;é§3isiEQR R4} wig '§'*:/EE<';% '§gv--..?L;_ §;r; mamga s§;§*?§@;:§ yzsgggg :3?' ma :.' £?x;fE'$'E'{:2':¥; ":5.;E=%~§'€.;$$ Ai'.f:T', mgzgig? 353 JUD€;£x€EE\E"? $3533 '-gmzggg §:%_,é;?:E;§} '3.iZ_§;'S§;'2G§§9§ pgssiafi :5»: was m?2?9/299?
3*:%;__ "1:"§:{ET.a§'_'::.5E%»v Q? mg. mg'? 'E';R2%,C%:: §:@:j§?~:: A'? Kgppggg ;:;J£;::a3f:::.:%§:<:C;« :;:@:::?EN$;;r:@,éa: :3? ES,f.Q§@iL3§/» §i'R§::<§ mg;
L V' msm gzg ?§:?:*?g.s:>é%: €31; '§E~§E ;:za;:*§ G?' é,,{Zf'E'iEAL 33993::
.;;;;_=§,2§:38;g2§:&;
ER§;9?A, gm %%%EE?5§;éFP;%.
_ ;%GE:3§ "*{E§.R:Tz, am: z%§§i§: & £93225; REG, i.}3:C%-=i;3£\3%<ER§ '»s'fi..§..fisGE, TQ: S: §E§"§':§<,Q?P4&L Z. S§'4?'F.%§§j:£GE!*"§§'415:§ W/G. ERAWDA, AGE: 2? YEARS;
GCC:COOL1'E 8: H{}i}$E§*§GL§;
R/G. LACHANKERI VILLAQE! TQ: 8: DZ{ST:KOPPAL. j"';;;';:x«§1s$Ei;:é;'=\:f;':+x;L._ "' {BY SR1 RA}ASHEE<,§Fi SLFNEALLE, :§s§'x/§} -._ ANS:
1: §,'v'E3AY §<u:v1AR,, $29, 3:3"? §<j%*€®'é%f§'é?. AGE:3S YEARS, O€ZC:._Q"JV?\EE--?R $§= 5«:.;3_ N<3.KA--34;4233; _ RXQE Bug, 4" FLQQR, 3,A_GR_uT2-3:: j;RE§~:$E53:::\s: EAST MoR1DP:sL__Lyg. SEcum:ERAEA$ ;gjA..§P;';
2. THE DIX/IS1'€) E\l;"§L_§s*1AN}?,GER; , "?HE ORIEf\JT_?:iL If\i&3.ij.RAf§'CE's*1T£;~§L'f7Q;;;
B1v1s:oNAL--:5.:?,F:cE_g "3_;9""'1:"=:;.;:>__o;>;,? §Lvi'?é:;'vEAR;s PA'§:~;:m"';<£:':\%A$A§<;"' 3IST:B_EL,LA?Z'Y,--«.._ -- J "gag fizyégzawsxi t5::z?§:'?';2.E§':_é;ERg ;<s§'a': £:e1Em';:", ggagggsfg' 5:32": aggmggy:
P») V * ..... .M§.E$?m%$E::§?$ « '€18?:'=%;?.:;%::,§,3®3§«::; gay: ma R2; _S%'?i."i,';'3;fS;3;fi§§§¥'v'ABfi.§§; gay: FGR R3} f:**:>§:$ gézm W333 $§£::€§<>%a2 25335:; @? '§'E~:E:
_?:«€§ji"§"'QE; 15$§§3:::;::3 £€'E'; :-'%GAEi'€ST 13$ é{§$G§;EE§'%'§" :';§D :£'f:7:'i:E§ %f),5'¥';§'E§ 3%/G€3};'2§£3§?, ?5%8$E§EN mz<: :€£:.2?5;2a@? '*-."§>3*s;.r':f:1-i§ :~?*:m <2? mg FEE'? 'Fi%%$§: :;r:::;§'::§ £5'? K@;?PAi§ _ E'.{%iRTL"':'~. éLL£3§§§E'€i} €33 ijifiiéé ?ET§5"§EO?=E gag '<:<;§é;':?§§ssg?:§2€ ma SEEKEEES EEK§§~§AE'*§€€§.£IE§':§T <2?' __"'€:@:2:?a::;$A?:£:::§¢ :33: ?§*§§SE §%??E§gLS CGFJIEEJG G55 ?"§R QR$ERS§ '§"§"i§§ %§':'; "§?%'%E §:§é§R? SELEVEREQ TEE FQLi.C}WEf*§G C€§f"«'§M§§\% 3U§§f""EE§'\§?: ' EUQGMENT m M:-*A.Nos.2oo6s/19 c/w MFA,2oa63;1e;'f20oT54}:§; 20065/10, 20066/10 & 29j957;m»(M*;IJ)*~%%. = Ssi S,S.3$shE; §€5§"{?8Q C@unsé§.__ha::;eéztéréd é';7p?'é§'5%::a?::;:_e fer sesgamdegéi -- §§"%Si£1'°éf'?€€ senipasyg " Sirzfie thé déspzgie f§:'%g...f_?€§Ea%"'d5S'f?i§Z? 2%":"::.b§iii:y'gééiiween i':§'?€ KSRTC and grfiparzderat-«Enégéé%',' vzééifc_§:_:"::é_ f:"§%%f:e§° resgcsédeiéts §iS§€EE$E§ v:z§i:E:, A
2. KSRTC agamst Ets fifabifity _ I35/Q2, 2%/9?; 2??/3;:
2?8/G7; ééséfi afaimarztg have giga fiieé :"v*'EFA;2C{i3{'%f2€§;§§' .s:¢é§<%§z§_L eaéaacemami G? €®§'E'E§€f%§§E§$§"% gm fszjge Trgsk §@:§:**€-Es? and ;%G§§'3A'v'%;%§"§; iiapgiai _ :?f §i;_;%:§': 5:: §%§§a,::§ ifiat €226 xze%;§s:%§ 252223 §*:%:'afi $3:
::=z§':i{§;; E: asvaa faéiig §i"%$%3§'%§ :::s§i%: 'aha §'e$p@:':§e:*£.:«« }Z':'é§:,:;{a%:i:% C{5:7';§§§s:;, Er; égéaw gf ihe gamg, ihe fiaigiiézy $?§§:1§§ gear: fgsiaréefi are 5:0 E§"'§§ irzsagreg §§"%§"i€§d sf §<S§;'§'€Z.:, 2 :32: kéaasvevegg $35 ?'ribL:aa% $;*:*§ne3:,:$§y $253 fixgé ézhe §§ab§_§§:%g 5:: the §<S§f%"C., AS 5:332 %<§;fi;TC $3 Qefem Cgwt, 5;, The Szsbjeci matter 6:' these ap§e3§_$ 'is.:é$%e§f_edT' the <:'?€$§E§QF? reperted in 2011(8) E37; t?!'1o;=.-:_.::is*:=;';aVi;:L1L':"efV:V§jT_;::-F UPSRTC vs. Kulsumg 2;; the §§g4h%: :;:sf the 2%a§ d' {3e:5'§s.§§:%;"~L' ihege apgeaés a?% aiiawecia 915 i?ia_é;:;§e§§2é;{:€xE<SR?C is $ef:~a§§deg '€323 énsarafaézg s§mpé:re§«i_ %;s %~:§ié iiabié, Amsamt Er: fiepzfssét fie §'€'§L§§E$Sfi to thé a§;;§5'_?eiE§§am:«.~.% 5; m L Era_$,S;Z§s:i;§§7%;.:;;§_s_d§ré<:_§é§ §*9._i:V_a.§«§ie i'EC':i§CE far :*espsr:aen:~ S5? S?£:$a*3<v;;:ii;3:%"A.S;'Eaéawaéagég is éiresieé is taiéa _ V ??;§i§C?:% ?'%$§Qfé §3"£3.§'%f:~3; _ . 1v..§%§».§::%:§c:3.%:€i:§ §=$§§e§':é&:3%:~:':. és fiisgenged wiiém V"';%'§:e.%§'T;;.V"3§§e§% ég by {fie ::駧;r*z:a:2% §&%§<§fi§
--sr:§*:a::%:*am*§%*A§%§'éf <:{:::*'2":§arz.;§5i%9§:£ 3'; {:§§§f"§'§§§"'iE$ 55$ gargrzts 3? iféé fieaaggafi géfl €%§§E§s £'Z'?'§§§§ arasgs ggeé 332$ '@552 3%: the éiéme :3? §f§'%% acgiéaaig f Q-my-J1 {V3 Hamsevérg var}! §'§"%£§§€E' C§E':""§§§I'1S3'§'§SQ $233 $683 asgvameé at §§S.5§;C?{}§f--, 4, Nfi deazbtg the chad by §'ES8§1C_....Ift§3:'*,(V %'::§?:« '::;:fize.. *~. éarrzing cagasity. But: ihe garenié i'?:5?fl¥L"V'€j:. agany due is the 395$ 92' §§'§§¥§f'f Chéffig§;§':i:f§F}§3»"§'5;'?§£j.é_f§ same; reagarzabfg c@n*:§ensat%$%é"L'$§3::.L;§d ?é'a-a;e{°§ee:i'gawarded, Ir: my apinisng, (:§5i';¥"i;'_2E5'~.'T_°iES agf1é " --j;e~n}E§*V:ied :3 aaéitieizai camgensation gf Rs,1;QG; Q§ T§,if §s"§'%:e:ria:t;§:,*V"@x;er am absve the CQmpensat§53s€?§'s§§*ardéd ::_:y" t'h é' T§'E'$:;:';*;--a'§. The_.a.Q§éz.<3§"%:;:*§;':4;;:j:ds ~a §§a;_2é:éa? ---E-:2..--a;:5a rt. Sréfihivaéwmar S, Saéawaégii §%&¥fi€§ wifaamééé _:§re :j§r§'£&é5: Ea fie Vakaéaifi ffii" yesgsméaés 3 am:-'v.3'; Azweeké'; "" " A 5 Q