Karnataka High Court
Dattatraya vs Sadashiv on 15 March, 2011
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
'V3?
*"'*§ :2 praperiées ~ 3: 3 pi§:C€ sf agré<:z§iw"&E Earééi m€asuri::§;fz 215?? ? gumas sit":,1aé:s3§; 33: Uciaagaazz azifiageg B€':g;:2.::::f:%. "E31:-'§'Lfi"i:%i'V%é1.§:AE& digiréct ané 2 5. hangs YE} EFEV b$arin;§.V_?§}3'~--f§ 49§ €§;:';2,p , ? I3 «/ k.,/ ._ iifiaruii G838, Ucfiagaan - the }3§8.§E§U':f_VC'§8;£'Ej'{'Ei§%'1;3f-__"§,';'!,%3%.E§{'E§A§}iE§E'Ef ' abng afisizh i:h€ firs: C1:é??f€1"1V€§'1'cé.-Eff:
moths? and third c%:fer:dami té€-- '§:§*%':€r.':f:j5:€r1323€2"s sf {E36 famihg, and 5j€f€§/§€l%E;§{iS« 4"'.V:§'iE€ggi§ usérg Sf ans Shankarrao had bean €X€CU§€d "4:§§xé"'é;gric1;:E{u:"a§ £3213' 'wag:
back and the suit ha}véng $;>ee:3 trial <:c~:.::r1: and the yesuit in the first Vé:§§3~3:Va§"piain:iff being T38 dilffisrém, she $€€ z:>;§;d égspéai ungacsessfui piaéiiifif ijfldfié" E':€=::§a::/2 ._ #4 K}: '§'§f;_éS -%s§éCe:}::é appfiai hag 3. 3m's:@2*§; étsehérzd ii, 3:: 633325: :3 ?i>s $2}; ihég sear: «3:z<:e earlier per ;':.:::§g:/2363:: 55:5: "éi<:*£:*€€ ::%a:{zi3::i 22»E~2€fE{}E? digrzéésssafi $5; ihs' e.":Ci2::":é:s;sé{;>:: VV "S€:£sg€§ 33 3 Eéarneéi gufigfi 9?? {his €C>LT§§"{ fsuné as 'Z?
I ésaidefi érronéeusijx E332' E523 €if}§I§'§S Ezujéew iafhich warrazztss a C{}1"1"EC'£i<31'§ wiéiiiéirz {he gasps :3'? 5:2': €%'§"§'§EéE§E 'E;i"§d$E'" S€Cii€}??1 ESQ {ZPCI 8' The suit for partitien by «:)2:}}:V136:5:'1'Ai:énp'i-eafiéiggjhis.._ 4_j parents and his brother a},;::_2f}g \:;*:':AL';;"V'€h€ purchaser of one <::»f the is :10:
mgra}, {Qt Egz'/j§.s:E'1 ':'":'3';é.V_? é*;>.{;>i&>{:1ev';'A:A*3."'fi<3Ar': Ehaéi {he saée €:'a_nSacti01f;_ of of faihér of deferzdaniséé: {€§ _f% Q.'/A131:;_:fi.e;)t_..:_ 9;i vf;駣""'£ransa<:iion; $23': 'the docVum¢'n"I:E but it was a. sham docgzrfzvfinig,.':;§§'{,&g:f§:§ by? the parties; that aha fathér sf Ehe pEai§:z'§i.Lt:"_'fhv%;€§'- v i:1 passssgsian all aia:/zg 8.f'2d €316 Gib??? §§:;i:¥': s€%:"§§_L:§:'3 §>;"€§§2€f7::%{ 3:13,, $131238 fI}1'Q§3€E'€}/", buééfi er; a éggzdf 0%" 'EiJ'§§;§.§l§"iv§$ chimed ta Ezavfi 5366:: a<f:.quir€:i fzsm an': 435 F325'-ft}§4:sZ: '_"g€EfE%§'3"&?Z€é {ram éhs j8iE"3E farzéiég' nzscéeazg arzd ::@:§é£%f:::":::§§:': pa: 2.2;» c::;:z::ri'3u%:§=:>:"2s rzzafis $3}? the giaéfiziff am} ..]..:h§f:*a§¢ d8§€nda?:§, vibe as --s:m;3i<:2§;€d agad éfigd ysmainfid §;%;;%:3ée:E€ théér E"§a7§§V€ xféllagé afié hazgzgs 33$ *f:§:€:"€§<:3:'€ aigca dzsfendani £17 f8:v::;:/3:' of father of r:§€fenda:*n:$ ':0 8. rghgzm transasiézgn bu: a 'ETLES airzd g€Ef:U§§':€.-;:E"$£,§""1"i§§:;a€:%§£';._I§Q~ & bmza }'E<:§s3 §:r'a::sa_cIi<:>:"1 fer valLiablqcezzséc§é:*;€a;:§.¢:i:;":§"3'3: sags no Qccasiarz for the trial €::--.:J:rt;"'ie'TVsé::_ :a~5;§<:§:": ' and i': does bind Gther d€f<=:27d'z5;:jts§ i:f;€:_ .:z;'§?:{} ways Ewing Saparateiy w€r€_.1efi: to _U'.x,.'Vf;':;"vfQf'-._f}"£€I'I'}S'<3§3'A€S..flafid aeitézs? {he piaintiff ::ar the tE':ird * sL:pp<;:"%:€e:% ms garents am} fa? dis:2f:§sS'a}f--Qf tbs»: Suit in so far as the Sui': itsm ..§5Ja8--';V--_<?é}2z{;-:j_f:*3€<:%7anti did as: jam issue an ifrssir sh,ar£[email protected];;?it 2"'}:V9;£Se pre:>p»s:"1:}* amongsi {E36 ms:r:sbé:i"s t%:eV:T3 :'z*:iE5~'., T V _.
ES}. in 5, -5§:uau*.§o"r%'5)f""'----:}/éés na:a,1:*r3,, {ha :53? {::>:mE 982*}; :*2Ig%::7;j,}' "fr.az:":=3d"':..%; € é§:>T§cwi:zg §s$'u€3; , .§3y'2?:;a:'§:a3* E518 aéiegeci S»:§i§€ ciéed ;:,§aEes:;f A % -.?5§?3zi}~f?.L§ 9%? :3 ma: zgzczgd 2499?: Qzzé is ;/21555; "_*vv.$?:;;:'z?z§ bagszés e:::<:>§3:::r:2:E'2§€ écs::z::7::¢e??,:" . ::;é'€}3.o:;?: 5222;; ax/z:§'z,::';%*:2:§zj;?> iégézéifzéf Zhé ffifcziizééff' :3 82*z%::'i§€cf Ear' §&?'EZ€iQ?'?, ;:[email protected];se.3:s*z}:m 53;"
§;"éfi s:%*:r;s.?"e 21:/2 :3";/e 5:2/:3? §:*::;§e;*:;'gg Esg gqzzfiaééig divéséen?
M 'L 1"':
.../ ::a:m2e pas: #26 €;"§€CE'{éS€§ jaihsr 2:35' :§€fis.<i Sc: 5:2 czctzzaf ps:,>s:~;€s:3::l3re cf '.<gQI%2:' pragyerzg?
45 E%fh:2ZhLe?z" def? §'io.§ praazefg execuzeci Qgreeznem'. in j?€i1f{)Z»é?"f7*.J.?{,'V_€'i2?*c7fV€§-'::'§:3:Zi:if{,'€f, Shanitar Rae that ZF:e's*:;:z': Z<:z{ndV42§{}g'i.:;;?5f be enjoyed far 3 p6rz'<>d[qI,f" j.g'é:_«:z%;€f f {:32/zzgoiezion of €216 $aio§°;2€2**.'7.<i>éT éz :5§zS--.;zg.ré.€:§'.
:0 repay Rs.3,;:~:ao,/-- ':o_ €:3'e:ff. gag defiis. 4 to Z7 agre_{é'::?, lie z*5«:oz:.ye3:;{ ;:~";:;§:€I Zand E0 the deft. cygfter Zézfiise }:>f 2:3 Qears? _ {J1 E15 1832182' dejé:::£{iz7,v§u:%::=é5 :é:;« prove :"%2<:z:
{he d€?7liS€_i._ shew f::5:?:€3if;.----Zheg; iiczzié iniieiizasd .f§_F'ee $22,252 5;:2:;:;¥ Vare :32 a5§::§z,§ pci§ssé133§o:/é'--¢ <:ii_2éE §%z;;f«i;'j'j/?V"}'3','.:2';«*é€ of 3:319 SL525":
£"a,;éx_d?'*~. » 9; % """ 4 "t:2"?" prove zhai 33,95? is _&a7;<??2.r.Z E323; Ei.?::i:Vcafi0i;?
1*"! 2 ' E/£73>za':«::=z*{:7f§ 2/i {:isi_;:4€zé*:::*er52? far £f:E{:i"1:%'3§'ijE"%f;§E8JC§€)VfEV€f§ {he wa}5:€ sf {he juégméni am} éemee of :%:é zr:'a'; %:s.:':4:':':vandV {hes S.é.::bE'§:§$Si<}I3S made at $325 Barf V P:::é3:1:S V_E:, 2, 4% 3516 § w61"€ az:8w$r€::§ in the megazéxfe
-eczgci §{.2é:*;3':.S 3 aria? E '%37s'i'i'€ a:'::2'».5v€1*$fi 3:: {ha affizfzmééise aféfi ':§3%=;:"e:%.£'8:"€ the férsst appeiéais 9321:": fguizé ms »:::<:::a;»$ém": ':8 .V {he judgifififii E335 €§€CE"€€ gasassé {hf 'zzriaé a:5>m*':
E6 marmzssg ::hé3r€ is S€3€}§:w.'f 53:" sxamériaiéeg 9? séagch jL§<:§gn2:5:*:§$ fa}? Ci}§'§'€'CEi€}3": :,m€£€:' Sssiion E06' €?C appéaé.
3?', in {he instant <:a3e, the suit thimgh 3-..<;_LuE:.._ fer paftiiifili, in $ub:3t.:m<:e ii is, d%sg'ui..3€.d 'S§Ei§_%: €;E7::':E1',_ of a suit far pariiiian, but _§rs:a1::ja; =;3;V. Ehe Sade transaction in féilfiéf 4 E0 ? sxestutsd by the ark {he E96? and the gait {E26 E992, Thaugh c§u:r*?; and {he first appeliate iimitazian agams:
éefendigntjsg way dzetraci {ram {he rszsrits sf 'zhé Q3:2.€ a.n<:§"'*$h€ 'z'E:§»ii--§.::gs 0:1 fzhés as§{~:*c'E being that {$13 ':re::1:g3€:é;i;en <2J:e;.$_ g€nuine traixsacééery, as i"€C{}§"€i€.'d {he ;:::;a,;r'é;= b::%'§:.°:=.xA5§',««._an& 5243? a Sham E1?'"€'1§':$:3.§:i§€3EE 313 wag Sgugfzi ta ;é;£:V'::?:V5:£§'€> agE;'§f€:S":§ €315: gaiainiiffk E':".é;_%€ cieféndazzts E is 5% 33$ §'i€i:T§ faéaérzg 2; mgiymzzr V*:s:;€:%::§:§i;:§i:2g %:%:e:3: E31933: ::»s*-;;€:"*§'::;e2"":'s3 éirz 3&3} arse}; SW35: €316 férgé: .V _,<f§§::€e:':é£::':':i ii": {$6 xéfiénsgg 'QSX faglk' s3:.;§pa3:"'£i*::g Sm: :3? Vv-"V/{W 20 fix' dégpggai Qf 3333 agspsai, which 333.3; a::::q;u%;::*€:E 1&5? szerzmss as 'sgeyzéar aiéézéré' in fizig zjtgsurz, g