Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/9554/2002 on 10 February, 2010
Author: Ks Jhaveri
Bench: Ks Jhaveri
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?MW?)r=?\??????kL? ?"???.? ??b? ? N'??X????>b6? ????#|? ? M ?? =s??? {? 7?? ??2?1� �?e ??< -N%/5 ?-*@m? .?? ???\ ??
?[??W??? ^?`? ;?$???f ?!@?5=??H=W?2G ?
?|?�?? ? ????p.?d ? ??]?i??3} BfL?) ?{#?; ? i???i5G i?R5?>u?Y"?(??GLL!?#?? ???g?&?
+<4 ?? ?, ???
???d?H??k? ??Z? ??b _J??u? Jc? ?DX? %??G"?J]??R?]?????J???^?c? ?:??U????W??? w?4 ??0?Q#l?JQ+?B#?x?? z?u??">.??QN??z?x ?? ?pU ??A??FzhlX~??? ??Z)? ?l ??g |s0???.? ?M&??yn@-??BeM? ?`X-y;??? ??A?U??5?? M'? ?(1O4?w} KxQQ?d6?
s?W?2_??G???" ? ?????u ?.x????Fx ?G?f/ ?D??w-c ? ?%}??OD{?qe?-?Jg??kY?}[?? o+?S ?~3&?^??{<]?mr?? ,??z|??C ??)??E?/?oK?? ????*?+??L1Oq?~wH??3;"??? [??Hj? ?o?$?"Y??|c zD2A?]Z???i?}?:t ? X? ?
?7w????`?y?=??7?{? ?~? ?h '?m?9?Y?%?{?7??O?VA???^o????{?p??&K????y??m?V??:???? ??R????R?_'N8 3??
? ?J?? $???.?U??)ON3 ??? ?? 'q ? ??p/? ??? ??O'a}^ ???r?S? ? ?B???Gu??3?dx?]?????r?4j?>H }?????g?????*??t mUE?? @??-?VK ?m? ?j?6??? ?==???r]?xm? v?h?? ?? H?jI=@ ? D??i? r2~?r u?ji???C?_17???Z ??);6e?? ??cSvl?M?? ?????|l?Mq);6e?? ??cS?? ?> M?.? ??? ?y? AB??W|>? ,?? ?+` ? =o?< r2L?Yt?w _~ #?8?8 ?mY??9OZQ?71?OE?? ??f&???� k?D?[??z?}Oz?&i??????S?G n'??N?G?o?yxl\G?? v?D?5?u ?W??-?j??oI???}?? ?}??z?R&??S?[? ?Qg?? '?????? ? d aP??? >???e?I~j?_? ???N??k???]??&y??|?Y??????c?8 ?v??/? ?4??s?3?U!??k??Hm? R ):Lx?c0??N??A ? '? ??}Os ?c?????,?jGN???]?\? ??f?E?I??h-?[?Z?%^?? ??\?, ?ZA+??-
6 ??Q???n? ?( ? ??? '?r?* ?? ?????" ? ?fh? bC 5 a??R??M0 ?J? (c3 d ?@ H? ???U?q^?C??JEI ?]?1??? Jkj ??[ ?tr?/?o? !? ?3$Rk??Q? ?g ?"??3? ? "?D #?(K= ud{L?2 ? &6Y ??S0 ?G ?X1-z? &$R?p?E??X x?FiQA????G????@?`#:?? ?m?? 7?h?c??8 ? ??g�?????`2H?? )?? ?d bV?L????? ??%? ?!,??B? ?J??+|???]?]???U>? n?|V??E?J?\??iS??6%;?L??3?Z|Y?? PK ??B ��?Z��PK � � �?MW<������������ ���styles.xml?Z?o?6 ?_ah??dYv??Y??Vt@?
M?Vh??D ???;???L?v? ~X ????x?;?/?$ l0? ?w?? 9 L ??s??{?|??3??]L?S'^IK;? ?? ?P???c ??*??r 'i?? b&0?z?W-z ??SW? ?y ?? ? Y? ? ??7?.?H?Zf???A ?8??? ?jd???(?$?????=%? ??+?q+??x??R???�?!???{?rN? ? KAm???kL1'?(?`? "%"�?l '*???? 1NC ?{O?]?j??]??U??%??>?*? ?d[?e/c??2 ?3??c y ? C?? ?C?By\ "???n?Q ? s 8?V\ ?X?8??" ?? ?3,?]3 ???'4? boC 8?\8???(? ? e?W0 ? ?_??7?
?4 [59??/B?GYg ?D? ?> ??? ?
d?? Y?{???? -?%??3AV{W6 ?? ??f??-&? J??a? Z`H?%.?@ Nv?tk??b?qp?i ?XF?z? g??M?Oq 8 ??fvsu??K?? v? ,??? v ?A??05M?^U? P~3?
???K? EE{?????x? �???? ? ?c z;"?? g?9?n?6? ??&9????2?M ?i?+o?N ?,~~??r ? ??p \?G7~}%s ?K ?QS l2?Yah% {;P(?? MYMd=?? ), O?^P? ??#?????Hq?? ?z �w??^; 5??A[T[o76S???Xm ???}| g]\a?O? ???6i?]k ?4??..????? ??:KA!??V?( ???7??R???m.?fj?jU>??, ??y???J?vc???ri*?ZDW?? ?8 ?d???\ +g1)?????WS?>?X?6?*"m? ???s? ?ow?F? )T???????????O????~? \?? ?PK ?$?&? ���'��PK �����?MW< ?? ��? �� ���meta.xml OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 himansu 2010-02-23T15:16:11 1 PT1S PK � � �?MW<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?zuT\_?%?? w?�??? ?? ??? www?`? ? w ?k?C#?o?7?ykf???}?o?Su??w??TW?D{? ???(?
}o????AA??n? ?``??d?t?r???? ?> r? ?? %??VeAPB?o?i d ??L D? '? ?H= A??N?N�IHx ??< v[I ??M_?9 ?X??9%? q? ?< ;?)8 ???s??[???A2'AB?K?)?c*?$ S???-,c?? h^?n6Z??_vC???|]Y?c?8?}M? ??ST? ?tY?(R [ ?9?*5@?n??`???oG1?3?z?#?xb 8? 8n??{X? '??e???,#?? ??!v??0- !p?Q?^??? h????0_?j????9???}?/???%?OGt??e\~, S??:??B5F sb ? \?&7 ?>????s?V; x S??DP9gp?8*6?;[?m?!s???p[ @a? ?7)?E?|? ?????n??@? u??zr??z {??N?ncv???yC???b??;!!a_?????D ,?????e???)?K??
??K=?| C ?? ?uC? ????3?)~}m???Y? ?8Cq?].?x???1??)x? ???? >?^?????jj?U?u 5?????&rI /?7???[??z?C?o ??F~?P????p???? ???dL?:???}3? ?tx ??G?B????fT?&???t? ?]IY=|? ? ??t\a??r?? qjeAq7HY??U???m?????q?4?%W????v?I ???????uH?? ??? ?E??
??_?[~ ?!?p??8o???g?[??*A??????|?
V! ?????D)?? ? 8???n ?? ?*b?? ?_?_s? lz|???Y?B??6z?rv??>?]t?r??=H?P????*???s? ?>xA? ? ?
D%??Q??8X~?H?M?C &? ??}h?@? 3?????~?i???$???????'??w??I G???|uD|Z?z??? ???x??:B? ? ??_?
?,?{??P??^#?/?{El?_U?l????n?O\?????v"?? =PT??C?H'+?e%-???k????d`? ??h?]zg?U????`?U3???0??Q). ? 4??1W??? ?x ????o??e??Z? ?? ?6?? *G??? ? ?N????p &?K ?D?,?OY?'??|? B[??R?xJ?D? V?k ?/?H b??l????tw??t] R???? ? {?m+m? ?2?V ?6 ??.b ]?r?H?Ad??9? !???e(?s] # L,??Z % ?i?J????8@????W?-?I v??g?????:kr?? ?H?? U?????&?????? ??;? ?GxY??d?? VC?X ? " ??? ??' ??Am:?=?[?ka? O%& ?F /?,g??
???D&?? ?v}?&Ek?0+0[??H? ?g:.7??S??>?D M!?r???T6c>? F/?i??G K_pZm Qr?Mw????{?M O)?b? ??? ? ????*bp? ??C}?; #C??1???
s?.bv?? ?? &1=d?W?+-1??^??? b z#4 ? ?3t?
??? g&?d?k???
-? X?? ???J?$gwb ~?l??Q s?? ?/s ???]?1?; ?N?%3??i? s}?????=?zF?? | ??f?~X?]??f???F??n?A???"-^D?># ??ST?j?j ? 7?6??8W)P*?`? wt?? s?P?\W4* ?6?'?. ^O(?x?& dv??j"&( \?~ LD? ?�?????> 3?= ?>??I?(??X x??&?lM ?
? ?R6?? fh??E?@?F???_73?Fqa?bm ?hn?M??O?????SeZ???k ?3 ???b ?29lU?{?^P?ts y?Eg \ ?q ? ??? ???DU1LZ e??????? ?? ??R ?? ???^ \ &?? Y? ?:??^?2'?F)??J?Y???? z"< vT#?sl;?????/? ?Q?J3??"&?? >? ? ?? ?!6? a??,?J?p 9??6?Qf? S ????? ^ ? ?V?y?i?&? ? ?r?? &???m ?? ?�R ???L?}"??=qd?)J?&?d ?"? ??? \?Op1? *?[???I???5??? ??/?ep???/d?g� o??A????>i ?;??:2?I???? ?qT5????X?T6?C??Jf??u ?O(?.?,-? 7a? >gJ`zS?"?&"?$??????or?|[????1?HPO???D ( ??)J ? D?*?? g?{??s 8?6W????t? D?8?u?:&o&N??3?d?"?a{? NR?I?'## 4~2??w?H???s(???A H ?? F?{ ?EQ?~?r?KIFR?m q|?@??gL?L?-Q?V? ? ?
w???.u]???0?R &5 ?r~; K? � ?`????i????`???2? 7z?�?)??O ?~?i?7_?? Z ?e ?8 ??z??c???[ ?D? I??@??X?? ( ??W?K ?[,Faf?t�?N1?Xl??&??q?Z E?? ?u?.?.???f??u?Q?\? h?? ?"2mq? ??? ?? ???>g{m ?k???) cR[J???ur ?C??_? ??'?Lh?e?
??? f?`h?T?I?i?^ C? n?\??,D????V5m ?)? ?w N#n! ?? ? ?5?Ec? ??# R?Y(?F1??uz^bi?ZSDaUjw??? ??2??n?O2???7?A ?,<+??,?[?? ??"?y??D?�? $b~?} ?(%?T ??8F??\? ??M?>??z? &??q??*??ZM??C_ms1??D??}O??t?l.?`?g???? @??P?@?|???R?? !??}?j j?R?x8 9?w?� ??\?s??? b????[:? /?Z?l?`?h I!SX? ?K?;Y??{B7'F3Q? ]I?R ??~??ZR *uB)??o?>?A?GQ# g?? ??U?B??~?op? 6\I?o?5l??? ?n???Cq?v!R??S? j) 5x 8-?'?8?g[??
s?s ??z?&]g? ?rtH�0ui??? D ? ???"?o9? ?Fl?"Wi*(?Uk ???)jx??3 ;A???u????'p? D,`77?? ??!L1P ??wc?}?g????n2 ?U????4} ? ?)b??f? !r??},??? (????????? r??E?u ?R ?N?T pZH?m ??p???G??= ??_H}=?? %? x8?)??(QZ 1r ?? ? _jG??^??? ?!D ??? ?5??&[];? ?0??jP?? ??
??dBvp????8??3E ???M ?sIXv0?{d!k??.xX�?j??oa?@A? ?`}\??8 a_?? ? 9\U#?C?`Zm1?m E~fs P3? ???^w?? Z??? Jr T??_>L??5 Ta ?PH? R??
7C L< ?%? &?b?r? ? ?=];t?]m V?? ?? ?? ? ?=?qi g T ??FrPH5=J?v? q ? ? ?? ?Mx,?%d [? ?4??2??;I0$r\?"m??%??m???? *J? ????NH m?N #3T???{ b????+ ?d???al?ju|p??{C7?????js,? ?2???? ?Id??wg? ???S? q??l???\?J?2 ??k?????
�? IU 7 ??G?6??i????? ;??L???)x?q ??U q??? @G???Tc? ?cq? ?V|`n& ? ?L????;6, ?~T?Z? a ?k/Y%x?*`?? ?"??c ? ? ?Z J?qPF?q,y?? ??I??`??B?? ?D5?? B?l ?v??T? ?!???^XIU j??Gy? ???xlS????!? ??l?{?M??u?\?5???Z ? ? [?|)nEa,?t????$K�L?$A??]S?Q?? o?=U ?]??s?[X???DkLEK?#?? ?_;?_? ?SK?6???? ??"Y?x??? ??98??J? ?? ?[?s?l???R4???/ ??? q??? `?e?9oT3sq|???"???,!? ?G (?G?bP?- ??DS ??=? ?e`????,?U? b??G???r O8}�$ ? 0+?hB?V?603Uh?L~?V? E ? e&??%?????-}? 6??
+?% ???9?z???F???9?P^? ? ?!?HK?>??M?y?2?r??E?/%%b??l Z+?dGN?;U> ?????g? ?^?? T?r]??�?g?l5 nB??
?C:?R? *y2?QI V???F??Z?@?G( ? :?7??l� i? ?? ?, ?N 3??????lD ?p ??cN #a??cL?? H??
0u~?? ? ?? ?B?,?rV? ???f�?_(???! ? jk?^?q?F?0??? ?.b???????D8 ?B?aC: ???)JK"???&V?skW? ?#ca0j?;v?%O ?kw2? e ??? G? u?????y?q n?
?S|????N??u AE??L??Iq g??)B???w ?Ey? O `?}u?[ !?n? M<5???-?;t??
?yb??o?K ?2??oJ?r?E??7? N? ??? r?R??G ??* e?!?j?? & ?y?).pL2c?L?w?? / ?~?MQ? F}??? m? ? ?? ??z B?w F??
?
?2??i?R??2??6? ??|?t? ?.??? ?Z?q# ?I??p?m?C? ?B?|?)? $ ?? ??n???_&? ???? *?v???#?{????Uh??jX?1o?o???@Nw?? ?O& ??{#5? (?1?? F ? ??z?h?? ? $?????? 6%?* ?b1@??PV ??Sr" n????????v????)?M ?+??=???Se ? N??C?[?m| FT??C??,o3, ?g? ??
^e?:I8%F',?:;!B' i[??�??o.?$j?w?[???gZ ??P??"?u�?? )D?^?? z?D??y ? ?s| Jo??I??h????X? ?N????XV"V g???/qf9 :?C?)??y?.?8???k?h? ?]?W? ??#U.??U???p??A?X\ ?m? ????R-?$ t ??(?? ?z? ?o?hDH??6CI? l@;??(?a/. f? _C ?E?d???mf?z?%{? ???(?H?I?>?H? ?3?F??` 3? ??i?O? ` 6g O???%??|?v???? ?Dc? s?n]*R?????m??N??qS????)?!x??Tv?? ?? )?LP b4??H?k?~~ ???G?m ?D?d???? F? ??�??�.?LF ?????a1:lq )?
?#X?g?? ?R8?(J ?x?Y?�tD?Y=g? ?? ?ecX ? O?? l1?F?p%}?N7?PS?v|??MZ Z??&K ?^X??Z???Z? :??? ??b??]?? ?> ? ?qn?N?D ?? j?#&???? ?
V???&J???I ? ?? ?- ?MF? ?:? F??' f 3?*Tp?> ; [b? u? ?M?VC? ?lI?B??3 ? .?:hb
-?L%&b?`??Q~???2??F???t?/? ?=XP??? $R ???j;k.o? Z?? p? PK .?P ? ��D ��PK � � �?MW<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r?
_H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i??O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g Top