Karnataka High Court
Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt Premakka W/O Late Murthappa @ Murthy on 22 March, 2012
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala, K.Govindarajulu
$2: mg wage mag? gr §<A§§%ifi{E'A§<$ £3 §.§J\iSAifiREW ~ §§{§"E§ ":"%--a:$ ':":-:§ 22% am Q? Ev'E,éRC%=§ 2a:,2--=:j* ?RESE§a§T ,,,, THE HOWBLE $2. §§jSTi€E 9: 3aAK%§<:A\;%§Ai"§'S§:~.§_:'%'~ mg %%:3!'§'8§.E MR, §%.3S"{§CE KS.{3§§§§éfiARAj{jLi§....,_ .... ?v'¥%SCE:.§..Af~éEGUS F393"? A§§'E.;i%i;-.§*»§'€3'S§,§.$'?'e§.§;5:§Q'.€}é mgaz 1Qf?3?f2Q:'{§5}:'{§1§'§'j;._A "§f;%'%7A5&5}-_g1{§?_4ie%_S£;5§: _' M L A BETWEEN 1 % ' §i"§€!'§t&§ insuramia €:3T';~i.§id;;, 5f " » "
Regime: fiffififl --. = . "
Residegégy R3331. -
gangaisfa, * Tfisaagh Eta ?§.jE§§§£;?%'T%§§ Qffégé; gee §vi*:$;:s§%n§§..__€3~@z:xp:'a.x, ***** éfiz»-éiag. §R§g%'z:.Ss;::3z ';%£:s3§'«{:r$sg§ 8a§2§§§@%--f饧§f:"}»§2-§t_,'% _ _ fifiy éis £i$3l5% %»§g:f;a'§ée~*.__ ' §§§e§§a§::
§8;?$§'§__A §{§'¥E.%"$§)§$.:'%/駢£%.§ji;.:fiévwg far a§3§z%%%3:"£:} , .
..:é§;§j~.§§;i€«-'§v'§::§:*E%1a;§§% Magihyf gagé: 2% ..:s,ec2'{'s, 22 éizgmg §¥'L§§§§§, Sfa iatg §'v'!:2;"i::%3a§§§ @ §':éu:"iE"a;a zfige: E2 yea:'s, 3; Kum, veena, B59 fate fvigsrthapga @ Mzgrthy, Age: :1 years;
2%, Kavi.
55:3 Eate fvéurthamaa {£33 fvéaggtéxyg £98: 9 years"
3, Ehéipa, :
35$ iate i\?::::":iréa§§a @ §vZ§;a*i§1y, gage: Te' years:
5' ééadarsggaé, 35$ §<€njedag:2*§a§ age: §? yeass.
?5 592:' S&i"'¥;§"§B?¥'E'Ii"%'1é; "
if?/3 Kadarapgag; ' Age: 52 yéarg.
R2 is E fieing m%n9';:*s, - _ ._ 3% §'§§§'"§S€?"§";§i§ my i§'ae§:i ' ' ?F'%Qi§.7i'€.?T_ a sa?,_*:*2';:3i;;_r1aE» gaza r§'%aV2%z... « 3 mi; §§'5e"mg $:§<:a g i ~ _ 93% 55% §*as §€§;§a§ §€:'%{e§§f§§g'_%5:'§%§§ 'ziéiiaga i:;;$§fE':§3§§?8::'§§§ '%§3:§ :.";"%;.3§§::%<§§e '%;"%%:z§:§ _%"i'§'%%3 é afga E Siijfiéfli <3; ;§5"§,"'£%?}V§é'§;§i §m%ée.§*~%<§2an§ a _ §,!3-féfi ';'>::;z.:_§ '%<§-13:2;
"'*..'?"?'?3!§f3:"';~ " ' ' ';=§:;,..;2~3e::3, "
V fig ::%§'z: %:;s;f2_§5g Em fig .. 'E ' --;§é%;{§'*:,__V§a; ma » _ 1~.%%':f®»%§<ie::*%.%?f&i::é:>a;; saga-: S2 %%:'r;$::;:>:::'a, fizédhra gfiraéeghg §{:3§fi;'E°§§f sf "Eta Sasfig 1"€§'E§i§E %'«éa.,&%Pw§E-£5' 3§:?} R€§§$:2§ez':i*::: >' . {Egg Sri i N? Kempggawdag Aézzig fer Rfizgé am} 3?} MFA §\iQ.:§?3? 2$§6 _. ....
BETWEEEKE 1 1; 333:, ?§emakE<a, Age: 28 yeafs.
%A!;'§ iate fliagrihapga @ fvéurtéayg »»»»»»» H 2, §{L1ma;"§Srui§*2§§ V ége: 3.2 years, _ j Qia late Masrthappa @ Masrthvy, -
3, Kgzmaiévgesxa; ' £95: 1:. years' V
35$ %ate Mzgriizaggg:§'-.!%{i::r:§j}»: 3 '
4. iiasmagé Kazzi, ggg: § yaarga _ ' _ gm éaie §V?a:{§§°1ag:}p§ §%:;"iufi%f*:§!;;' , 3% Eiumagé Shéiud, _ Ag€:_'§-
§.?;'§ §E§£§ ?¥E:;{i§"ea§;;:>3 @ ~f:%§:;:*i§':y? 55% Sr; ;%<§§aE':r@1§g,.LA'=._' :33 %§:§a§§§;::;:";§;:aE »;_;_$':' 5.? gag W :;§aC%:§%$:: --'§%?':%_[{Ti}T' vv€;:%'«V.«:'%;«:¢;';-.f§f%§:a§' '£e%':§£§e§ Ac: $23! agaimsi ihe § §:;:ejg::":e§':%"_a§%»§ s:5s_a.r{i= fiateé E%.4.2§§6 gaafgsé Ea %éZfC § .=Ia%.::--*«s'j:fg,:§«%_;jj:§».__C9%3':§é:s:2:'§a:§Q§"s Q? %":3;8§§$$§;'~ with iazeregé @ §% 33%;' § §:::'-um: ;§m;%:':*':;?_}e £313 Q? agiétéaa i§§% degagii. § ép§e§%a:*:§3 E :9 § are méamg, regregented by their msiher gm agturai §{}§i"§§€:'§§°%, Sm: §:'e;:2§§:ka~3*i": Aggpeiéanifi Aii are residing 3% Reédyhaiéé 'ifiiéaga i'3$§ar:ahaé§i ?a5i§ Cha§§aE<€€e Tania ~ _. % - Chitraduyga Distrégt, '&g§§e_§.%4£:3:'g.VV {By Sr; C EV: Kemgégawfiaf Adm far agpefézgizétgfi' j; ANS E. Sf: Ahfak Amheé Kh3{§, ffiéajer, S19 5% gifgaih Khan?
?\§sg23E;
Pennakanfia Read;
Béndugura, éndhra firaéesh,
2. The Qréefiiai §:*:§:;§Vaf--~z:£'%--V:;"§_§. ~ R S Resifiené?' §;<€3'a'<':i,'~ "* Bangaissa Re3§<§s'3§e:'fi:§ {fig Sri ii} i€¥%a%2e5§'§; --A§:;é., §s:::f §{;§2j::_ "'«- ifififa: ééaiiae §§§§e§2s7:a;:§ ass%f{§':}._ V§¥%_§s£§ea'§§'§._§%§--f2v::':: Agpeai ?s§e,E.$?%»§,f2§§§ $3 f§§$§ zméer %'~§§§;'f§'£:5$j2§i}--:§_ 3%?' =%%_1§}§é. f%§§ sf .€X:'§E% fiddi, jazfige, Caagfi $5 Emafi \ €;';§§;_3$S;V §'»'§er:;53e?':: §%?s3€'§"--i2zi §&%§im@§§%%an égga} Sggzgaiaégg E we §v'§%§s::aE§ar:§s3z;§ F533: Aggggé §'s£si§;81?3?;"E§S§ ig filad Qfiééf §€C'{iGf'? §1?3{1§ 3? '$39 Meta: Vehiciég Act, 3385, agaiasi j§,§%jg£'"?"§%§'§§ grad award éatéé 24'4,2QG§ Qasgeé in ;m35§8;2@§:: 32'': we SE3 §% mg: ass; jadge, £eu::1%L%;§%g;é+:¢~:\;":.g". Cgzgaea, Member, §'é§ACT7=§"§, Metgsgsaiétafi Agea, Ba:2g;_z:r:.é.:'.s:;{e~~,.VV V;:a. 3§::*'a§:,:
aéawiag the iiaim peiitisfi far £an'%§e:';5éét'§:3z*2&_ '-351$' $*'e§,j-§<;'?1;*§7' aghanaement sf Cemggnsatiem T§'2%S€ Apgeaég ggméng an fe§V§::%'§s=§%¥?§g %%;e=~; 'SaT:ff:eu '§§é:%§:%§ fieén hsarfi sag rasgrveé far gscgnsa:f;_:ie':=%f:':.é:*:'%*;_.§f j§;':;:§g;:;j;;f;§:f:§: Sr, §?:ai<:§';avatsa§a; jg, éeiigzeraé iiiéi;-..§é¢}'§§ e§%%§n§;_:. " ' ' ji.;ae:a.:sr:E§:§'1 V Thege {we £.§§;es;.§$ a.g§:fi§*nEs::V é'%é'é and the same gfaségmefii: am __ made in ?€§VC ?2§®¢3E68;'2G§§+ an :§:e1TA§;§eVmé[:.<;;sgm?hszmi; C§a;s&$;'§fié%. §*£§A::T ai gafiggéere City:
£2 §§*f:'E{=erj__%;%::2;f§§; é};;sg;'z.e;%.%«%:': 21%?-'E :'%£§.?i§'?'£§f2$§§ mg base": féieé Vé-jg....§[:":§*+_:;é;'a§§£:ééemgagty ggaggigeg $23!: $276 émgugneé :;§é§;d;§ ms§:i"é.:%'s:§" §§:€é':j"a§%'V.'Ti;é:é$$%d agaéngi £25 §§?Si,§§§§'§€€ £§§';2;Q&::3s §¥3}a.i~§ §:%§5&% $':%§§i&., égégggi Em Egg ?£§.E.§fE."5:?;'2§%§é fias §§§:': féiefi éy--.7:%§§,%1 --s.:§é%':*:%§s*:%:$; 23%;", Eegaé §'§§:a2aE§:a%%:§%§ Q? aw éezaaseé Z"'71:.-_ §'fi%;:V.%j:%;a§§;3'§: @555 §%Ea2{:%2y;, gfayéisg ig gififfifé 2;T{':z§§"%§€$'§$a§§G?'§ $5 E"
'm,, C§%§§"}"E§fi ém fiée ciaém fiééiéiififi if': %%'a§C Ex§§g3S§8;'2§§»:'£ by §"%'§§§§§'3!§%"3§ {$23 §f§§Qi§g§"i%§jL§fi§f"%"'§€FEf and ;&.:?s;§a*§ §§E§<:% 2%;§4,2C%G6. 35 Sinae these Exam agpsaig am d§f€€iE§ a§a%s:§%;3?4 é?::i«T§'%25'% M éhe game judgmemi, we have hegré gsmv-;I:'1:"<:::-.argiasgrfaéfiiga%2";c§';» prgcgedéag ":§ fiéggssé sf %:%":eSe Afifieaiéig $.;§ "Ti§1i$}".,V%::;';s:f3§z?'{;§;~..
jzgdgmgnté 4; Leamafi Cazmseé aggeajgérag fééé :53'? é};f;.§.§;§a::2:e §§9§:§a:';y $::§3m§€:~;:
hr ".%i:§'%:a:s~E.:2a.§':'ae:
'§$éea§e§:
that 5:313 as? _:_f':és;.§é§_:'z§i§=;gvs;§i' ;§~?'§'é:V'§§E?:a§éi viéiage, *C%:aE§ake§<-3. €§'§é§t:§Ia.:::§L::é*5'g'a: D:'§'L§s'EV:'"§c:': and ties mats: agciiééfif ,,,.:i};:;€C§«%§§%}fe'}::§. gurisdictéarz Q? f%%§'§'§aV¥'?jT:gE§§£a' Chiéradmga Sigirigt am i§3Eré'f;<§:~'?g zhé é:%§§'r§' {gm zmfisé' Ssaiésm 2&5 :t:;§_._;:h€ '§:%§§'::: vs3?z§7::§§s éaé, E85, séaéming {::§€:'§'§§§§"%S§i§§f§ §§-§%:?«§'€ ?«§§.C? ai Sgnggégreg wag fig: *%:%éa: %§é3e *?If;f»%,;§.§1ia§V§":aé €??§§f $2 $§£§§ir:§ the fiahéééiy sf fise 9é%1.a€§:e§*.'A.$i:*§"' $28 §:'2§a2;*'§::§e Cgmgagéy Emggfi am '~-. §§::.:e:?a*:.::<;£--::§ wag a §§S§E%"§§§? $5: 3 gasfifi 'i§§§"%§€§€ amé .V%§§§";:;;rs::{e §€:s§§£§i $963 mi awe?' t§":@ 355%: Q? 25% §§} 525? 331% ?§"i§§,§?'%a§ arrafi $3': aaasagfiiikg exgybiiarst Qfifiégéiéfifiiififig 55 fié hag giteé ?:§"'i€ fa§%a:é;%€:g égaiséans:
{E} U§'IE'€§%§'§E§ decigim fiaieiiié V made in as 9 2s:V::--%:2j??§'::2:':{>9 "
zennected sages {T§é §E"'V«, S ;&SSL§RAN£E fig i?3.§A'.%£;é:§'vv§5{}£5'ES§€ "s2é"sE.._.,E§.,.f éx§x§§'§"i-€53}; ' {ii} gm 2&1}. $132 353:3"{§S§:Q?é%%.,";§§£i§; c§%2%'éR§ ifs? 3H%*;?;§sf;;aA;é,¥:;¢;NA£é_?%A $53 %Z'i"?E"§'~§-:E'RS} ; {iii} 3Li__ég WA: ,j2}§§: viiénaéé Er: MFA ;%%$@,$§§i;?_2QiV@?? a;§ Egg §:§a.$§§3:"E§%? (:i&;§.g :3§s'§§:'T;aiT:.%:'t'T;=g$}g»_sRA%x:£E CO;M?AN':' §..?$V'.'-§.';i":':;\ §\'§:}{jéi:;%a§'gE~%§,§<.&\ ma A1¥'%Q?"é~E§R} ; 4-tic;,L%3éfé§fi3§§é%_§3S%?§'€;:*~--é:.§%:e €§&§mar1;ts sazhmiis 32%: ihgrrg is § gm -fiizsfi by $33 Eagagsaace fiamgaayg §~%% \ $235 ::%:% §§'3S%.§§'§§'°i€% {:§§§E§8§"%}? ééé §'%i3?; %"&§§€ abgesiiéa § fiégf: 3% °§"r§§:::23E 3: §a§'§§§§@%"§ haé :23 §%.§§§Sfi§€:'E%§f': ifi §
-- e§::$§:a:r: {€23 ziam géiztimg § ES ihai $§m:e3 ihé §s*;§u:"an£e Qgmgayéy garréeg we bugéaeag wiihéa me éogaf éimfig §f§iiE"?S§§£§:§Q€'2 Qt? at Ba :':§a§s;*e, ii isms? 7% saié {hat ?~€.égC'§"j45:ci§§.._ V. at Saggaéare ciiyi 3335 as §gr%s§§£Ei@§z ta an§;€;~'§r€a§i;é "§:'§§'f'e%« \ M ' :§3im §e%%f:§a:'2 flied zgnfies' Ssitian 1&5 _§'?'€.§:":}:%..:?\'e'¥*a;?:t"G;?f .4' ifehécies ziaai, 3388;
iihai the deaéased M:,:a'%:haV:3§§ abaazt 35 yearg, dcing §g§"§Vi§_L%u§'§%}§E é§*:»«:i "a§§%3 éégéaféég sheeg fifié thereby e:§rn§ng§8€§;{§§§!_-- §1§:;E;;.gi?Ji§,5!{ ting Eéme G? a££§§e::t',~-._ :%:_'e {:?;»s;:e7a§;_¥§V.'»was iakiézg Sheepfgaat fmm Redd§'%§a3§EE."'_黀§» ...€:anihe; the gcciésnt G£§%.£~Ef%'€.§ §§§€ fta}_:';'a§4if'§"~~fa*1_:;";§ ':zé:1g"iEge;*2i driving af the $5333: av :9fje:*g1:3.§*: ::f4*§:§éf§2;§:§':, perserzg dieé, 15 9i:he%"$_ '$__§i§:a§§'%3d_V_V'['§:%:§é$é*:'és asi'§ as gas' 599% pan§f'%i§'7§ig:rzjé, gaats sad ZQ shseg ciEedV'v.;am~§"i§w§}'e§§.:fé,vé:*s§"e:§§::gass§d was ir3::€¥§f:*:g $5: we §G%5r:g é.a:: §:a;%':§e":5'§§ €gi'ie:i.;§§s 3:23 mi 55 3 gaggengesg arzgi. _ 'a§1€ ' mi agsgaifiw §§€§::&i% :.:3'§§%:?§.%'?:?§i:i§>:*:;'""~-- ..... E; Eéz€32.32?"'s:>4?§.€_%'2és;a'é§"§::m€§%i§ gsiéggsggfi $5323: $318 Eeamsd £§i;§§"'§S駧$ fa" éfisrz §:3%§:::2"§, avg 'fG§"?%'Ei.,§§§§$ £22 ;f§§¥::;:ss;§§§g ggémig fa? 32;: fig f§'§§7i;1%é'%*E?z_?';EE§'s:?% :17: :__ éihetha? ?:?::% ?'v*§@%::3§* fiac£§§§§::§ fiaémg E'":'iba;:*:a§ 3: V' '""§a§":§§§§:"e, fiaé $523 §;§§§3{§§{%§{,>r§ 3% fiféiéfifiifi iiée fiaém w»,W.M.~...
geftéiém fiieé iéfiééf §E€i§€3§'% 1&6 §f éfhe §»'Z$ia:' ':§§?':§£§&$ gga 29% :2 $3: ¥'>§h€€?'3éf we §€C€3S€§ §VEiEf"iha§§5 @ V. tgaveiiing én ihe igrry Qearfizzg iégisiratian ?%&:§4*.';5%?u;£fT2;5??f'--% "
3%? 33 gwneg' sf geeds E' éiié if afiswer ia the abmze 3333: éj $ £5?'%.:§§é'=._af3?'§:*:fz§;«%%§%;5§;':
wéaeiher ihe isssurame Csmfgazégg is "'%E,%a¥E;;-fig/. méemnéfy ihé mevrzer :2?' :?:€='§:;s-sfgjy E' ' _ _ .. $25) Wheiher the :§r:':;3e;':3a§%§§: émggésffiaé §"3r--:§iaeL':T{i1i}:::'2a§ is imacfisq :§3§§;'€§C8SE':i Paint New 8; S3 as ta ans:'we;"'*;gé§:%%.*,~?4éé';§j,'$§§ i%:£3 駀'essary E3 ffifé!' is Seafim 36% £12? Vééfééiiié%;»%7$§2V§A5§:é';':.:2i*x§j.%:; 1§.88; Accerdéng is su?§~ Eégtiaré {2} 9:' §e§:é§e;';:'_'1'é2'§Vg ijiééfif $:;:*;=§e::§a§2 {E} s%%§§§ fig mafia 4§;;}§§€.:-5%' mg iéaémamg giiésgr £3 2% €:§§§::*:;_;€:"V"37_%f'§§:_::t"g:»:§f'~?. §:§%§ga*fi§.f:i:%'§:2 aw: %:%:e 3533 if? aamish Sig §:;i§%§eA%13*:._ €';%<;;j::C'>T£:§7§»ffEi:i_v% ,,;C}:§» %:§£338 Ciaimg "§';*§E;s.,:r:a% ::¥%:h%n 'Em igagi §%:§§"2§.§$V'@f ihg séaisééamé §'%S§$f€S GE' {§?"§'§€S :'§§'§ igxzéésgaggw 25* %§§%:=%"£§:. Véhe mag: Eéméis $1' ¥:;§":§§% ':,::'§$§%:':%§:2 imiz , E561 féiifiefi ;'e,z:=¥§3§:a§5§ §a{;:2;:>ff§;f by 39$}, Q. in :he irzsiargi sass; Sig giaémanis are §"€S§C§§§'E§ ygétéain €578 §:;:§s§%€t%<:::% £3'? Chiiraéurga ané ihe aacéfignt 3&9 éfiflééfféé £576 §:2:'E3§§§t§§:§ sf Ciiiiradurga Qistrigi. 'fherefijra it £3 £Q:f%%é';%5.§*-.§__'7 _ that the fiaém petitéon fiieé befase the C§a£:'i:~~«é§f'~.. Caugesfédéh MAC"? at Ba:":ga¥a:'e City, '$1183 rig? m,§T§Arf:té-§§;é.,§§§'e§' insuranw Camgamz hag net qzgestéaasgj t§3e"'§§u§'isdi£:%»:i*f;».¢f'tthég 3 Qaimg Tr%bama§ ai Barzgaéare; .féEe§ ""s§$:e;?:mé';3t Q? %§§€Ci:'%S§"§$, Aémiiteéiyg {E39 1;eh'§§EE:_ £§>H§é %feé ay msurafice fer the geriaé fmm Sectéarz 3,56 8% ihe Maia? 25$ 'aha Qéaimantg ta ChQ€!SE am the basis Q2' s*es§§er%:::e ef deféefréfiaz-nfi:;:, T'§5:§::%"'%.§is~:;é2::éc§§ §'駧§y is': quefiiiar: was Egsaefi §y iihs <3§§:?'$§zfa.§ !:::;_::%§€§é'2L:%Ve?'§:V§Ts%%:§;3ay fig Eta Efafifih Gfficg at §~%%%2§upu§<, Sirzie, {§:f§e:*:.f:a:~--. :;*:§i:s*&::§e Cfiififiaféy s:a:*§*§e§ an ms§?'§:€;€2_§§ %§§§«:ag;§ §§>r%e 32€§~:.:e.:.%%:%;§;% éihé }L駧$C§§£i§§f"E $35 Cfiiéfé $3' fimaii :;T§§;:§éS;f§?%;:'%.£"§*, ~%::}%&--._;§n:ar:i§s3a rafiasé fig éhé égzgufarzge €::;.?:@f§§a:3§»' a':r_¥;:::>~'t?:€§:é':ijE%3:§§1§¢':§§§% §§ S73 '§:'§%:.m§§,, §'§Q§§5 fig sésaigi". ' "« --1'i;-fig;-'§g:'*i%':§%;._V%% E3 322% ggefui :63 §'$§*"€§' fig §€€%§§E": 2"; $2? {iii 2? C:
V "--.§V:;5=:.§&::%§C%§V%:§.-'§§ §E§i§§i"'E E3 9% 5; ? Q $5 sxgésgééé ag mfigr: "{2} %<§§ e§;'e::t§§:: a ia the gaiacg Q? szgéng Shaii §e giéewaé by any géxggeiiaée $5" Reajésicmai €sa;:"i %.z'§"ii%SS sacié gmeciiem wgg t3%<er: an the Cam": 3% firs: §%'3S§&§}£€ at She earéiegt gassibigi A sgpertanéiy 5:36 in 33 gases waere %ssues..2;ief':~~.VvV'V setifed at 9:' befare gash $eit§eme::'iWé':::j: ::s-3§e§;:;_ there Etas best: 3 Carzseguené fa§¥a:'é"'«;3%";§._'§§;',1Ts?"a:'f§:e:;_§* _ 1:. Even; if? %f§€**i%? 32° Seaiim raigefi E3}; the ifigurance §u§§'§§5AE'§%§cn Q2? me Qiaims ffréburxai at 8a:"*:g23:'E::o%'é_f, is mi: maiaiaéaahis, Em a;ieaaz€§é":_%»r;:ff::'j:s: 5E:;_:3v§:§.:'.;;sn:«:*%§:::;ié§:fdégésigyé éatgd 2i1J;%;2Q13 maéé scgrmected sagas {ME §%§E'v'%f i:f:"§§';'f ':55, YOGESH ma §2§2§G"§"HER} 2':'1a§§,f§§,r.'_Sea%%%é§;{%§~ :%a*:.§.'i'é: j';:'d§e gé iézis Cew: ig cf 33 avaéi ii} tie :a§?e--«.,%% c;?_g;::g;g'Ep§§§a:§i;§§3Sura:1ge €%i'2":§§i'§§t é{£3:§::§"§%ff;§§*3a._':?§5%?::i§j:§'§:i§,§j'%} ES' 'a.s§.§.2!g&§§§ is? i%*:& a*§"f%:"mai§2;s if? faazguy £3? %%3e ::§AaJ'§::»é§;?2§:§;v., * ;§f}§r:% :@%::;.g2i§%i.Jf;'és:§§; V%g" gm éa_..E:;§ 3% mini éifiiéfii} gm {iii} mgeihgy fféf '"'~,§§4§'£:,§§~$T§?s%r%é 23$ fééae ::%a§e§*%a§ as': mega mégzig age %r;i§:*§%:'2§<e§§ :3, Agaafdéag :9 gmt §ar1:?%$:"a§ma {Ex;;?s:;}£ 33 the 2% gné 2% sheeg beiszg Qargéefi Er: the Eam: diéd Ea me §{;C§_$:§fé§fi§j_~ that timeg the d€«:§aSe§--E'\4::rt§*sagga @ 3 gwtsfgizeep 5?": the iesry 5%; the §i§f"§OS€ gaigisf: Tmgsg the fiegaageé was izaxseiiing in f£:;§**.g §arr§%----AaS~9wr:e.§??I:;sfVgéeéjgfg 3:36! rm: ag a gagseszgez, The i:em:é%":::§;:'::'*s $f "%Ef§§e'*E-hs:é»:ja:':§e izsmgsny ihat ihe §€C€§S€d ¥v§'§ii§§:§v€1«'%§.§fi_gfi ;a;' ';:5gss§n?g7'7ei% E:2 ihe goeés ¥§§"§§€§E is witheut any basis asfid %%::a1::t:;§«§¢[5, .%;; §'::_Pé4 Sémce the deieaaedwémthap;';a"_§§'j'.--§s'§u::jih§,= .é:;:as«.}§'::s::;e,%:_i_§é?§ as Gwfifif G? goeds, the Céaimantgsé :'Cf:;v;:'en$at%:3n 'fram {fie §§'iS§.§£"&?"1€€ Cam§>a'k;g%', 'fi§3'é"i'n;u§an:e Cémgeaséy is ééabie 'eta ir3§§%f:.;;%9f3,§ fig §§§§"§f in Qi.§€§§Z§§§3.: fisicarfiiwia s1ei::€x%\:«3saV{i%éV§ gaég 5258 aésat: aagweééé ifé the a§f§§§f_r*:!'a%.§f:f'% §§j'§>_ §i'«a:§Q_;V:;:fVV§3f tfxféé' €%..3:.%.s:e~':a;*::5. by 591% éegmaé £@i.i§'§§§§ fa' iiée §;%_$7A§:é:":::.r;§e i;é;---§é§:§a;r:3f G_j':'éA%%:§ peg}: :3? Eéafiéitgz géé mi: amsiécafiie %:€: ~*§§'*:e--1'€?:a¥£:i_;Vs§"'-aAr:§ £i%$_;:%::$%a:':£§3 3% 33% $5392 '§ V-.
.§f:_%f:§§ aéaémarzis 33 gsaégr:
§Q§::t ?«EQ.§§::§
15. E: %$ ihe age 6% 313 siaimaais 1&2", wife; tam;
éazzghtérs 3:16 {am ménsr smzs and §1%3E"€§"%i§ ef the Msrthappa @ ?sr¥u:thy§ ageé 3§§L§§ 35 yearg, that E23 %'SG,QGGi---- gar arzmgm fmm agriggsitureflj :.é'§.§§:. _ s§'2ee§z!gsai:s* The §CC§éSE'§'§I cgcurreé ;;rf;_ 825'»VB'Q!g$%» view; the Earge mmber Q? famiiy $353 'tan agséiaiitarést arid aiga §§§?"§§ §§3§§ $.§§ §:§;:é.En§3%§§'é'€ an be safeiy fixed 3: ?§;§$G;'- $6? haé E' §E§€§'E§€§"%?Z memhergg gv:;'€:;:%:§f:§§-ingitsg'itééé $2 Saréa 'sierma 54 Qthers ,'€:Lj'7:§~$_:psfat§ar2 & énother gsegasfiséd is: zaegiiisfs Enfiame Sizafi be §%§:;§%:e§ i@wa§'§ §:.é§?ex§5si:;?%é'%':V§é}::§€V%§.$'é%1&2'? $13 §E€§3S€§. "flizsgg $5 g Sam as"? %L2$G;_'= §3'VVVia"'e.,§uv:7_%§e:f §er§s;r':3§ exgeasas $1? $628 §ace:;;as«:%,§§_, %{}.;¥ $"3<.@f_§::*»§_e§"%$§,§§;A:3§...§}f iiae C§§§f§":§¥":tS mmég Ea 2'4§8G@;» §Ei'" :%§§:;t'%%§, §§%§;a:s :§:§'«évfiiiéagaaéé was 335 §*'€§%"S ma; m:§§*:§§§E§:" 'E5? Elsi' a;§;§§%£ab§é.
°E'%§%§:f:{2a§ baa fixed Eaaa Q? §EQ§§"%§E*§E{}§' 5% %2;fi;{i%€§!~ V '- §f;.§§-v§;?2'i"%§;%'?;%§;§_§:§:sE§8§ maséiégéés? 35; am avsgaséafi %:§i'E"%§§§'E§§'i§Q§'2 $52 5 E R2:
%' 3?.
mmgeizgatian as uafier:
{En 3} Lass Q? éegendemcy {?25i~;§§§f~wx:5} 3§§@;§G§»=§§ Tr'a:3s§s;*tati@€2 af deafi beéy and funerafi exyenses 5,§O$-QQ L953 af estate .?:§',€¥i?§;,£3"',V' ' 2 »' Less 9? €G§ES$F"{§L,5§°'t"% ' Tami $2': 911:" view; thgéi'~~..g;§aéiL'%ié;éVi:$ _ fiaiigg &r:'t§'%%'éé far Lass 9f §'e:35en€§:}é'§§_;:y ' §?4,8§§,féx1g;_,'<x;;:2'}=.._; §;21.;§S$*§§
3.93:4V§€'%:§J.:§%;sr%%§{,s;:>; ggmawea L@$s '::«1?'§»<é_$;e % :a;§§$~§a L333 a%é4;;:sgeVM X F :§;@e§-9% V ?§"§;s*z:%:<:;:Q3::3»%f%:;3§§aa :v':7'fifzégzad ._§'{:r3y"'3'n§['f§;::era§ axgfingeg E&@§%~%G % V 'gm: §§§:,§$§~§3 'EEEES: {;:::--'%_j{;§:~*.-%:%'22§i%$:'*: aaggséeé ' _. fs;si i:f:":e "?:*§%L%:':§§ 3§8§,¢§§§~§§ fiaiagéigg S;?§§§§§«§§ :8, "%'"%7§ aiaimamig ar§ ariiégigé fa: enhaazemént Q? CQ§2"1§€?§§aii3C3F'%, a3 gigtefi ahasgeg A£ca:*é§n§§3,a, téée gaéréi arzsweéed Er: favaag' af ihe Qiaimaaigiaggsééantsé 3'9. 5:: iéwe reszgit, {3} éggseai Er: iaam %¢s.1'é'?§§;20é@%._:*§:e§~ :
%§'2su:'ar:£e €§¥?'§§a%'}§i' f§§§§,...r§éA£i_:7v-_;i:;§f';eL' sarééel' is ..b<§§eby fiésmissefi wéih £as7i::': --> "
{ii} A§g::ea§ §:": "--;f={§FA S}: the C§aE:%":a.:';it§;.. '4 §::ifj:'_':_;3a:*{§;:_ '1-zaziifiaézéiév,_' iégédiség $13: the §§§§V%%3':3§sL;*:§«:a% e§:i§f:%€é 3%?
:::::<;fs*:p_§:':§ a :E'%;:~:é: ~ BS agairsgi %3,$'r;,§@§3;% me 'mbmeaé, amg ziugiéie 4;:1Q«g;?:i$ a'%%§~.,§,_§%;é1e'%a5:§ figs 53:5 ef §?»<'s gs? 3:¥3§'E%3%'*i§ V§%;': '駧3éi:ii§{'2;"1 i:§§§ §§%§§s§%§§:'2, as ggaiségi észgmga' $1: $39 i%;:":"3s %§°": Qi§@*S§'.'§%%"¥ am :2: "-..f£*§§§§T2Sé<':' §__§$b§§§g.:,f §S}§E%'%§ agéé gaeraé. § "§'l%:=é eniifé €§§"§"§§§%"ES§§§S%'E &§:};fé:g %'%'§?."§'E maia am? § ' * §é?%%:e§"es% i~,f%z§%§ ég ggggriigfiaé §§'E'%C2§E§ 'tag aiaémgaia § Er': E313 ggiig $5 S:E:2:2:2:2:2. "fie ghage gmfiagiei 3%? § (1 mm W / (Ea?) S3*£'v' . _ {hag §T:§§"§a';*§' £%§%s":':ar2§§: ghazéi be $169? ér': Eimd Sepgsét :,m%:§§ ihey aiiam iha agé 3:' magfariiy am 5§§§:s2:V_Ea;3fi:~.._V Nae}, §i'}€§§'E§ maths? 33' we §'¥'%i¥"§§§' £%§§§;%:§_:awf:%:§v;.'_vj"fig entiiied :9 d§'8%fi;' §ef§aéicaf iateresf: t%"2s;--tv--§::s:§*a;>é;2:.:§'s*§ '4 we fiepasét.
Accmdingéy, {he §§'§'"'§§i.,.§ig§'.§_8§ §Ljé£.g%::ent 3 age madéfieét "fie Gsiientai %r2s%:'?a;§;céé'--§;i:.§j:f.:.g$é'§é§r.: :§$»fiireaieé ':3 éépasét ftéze-.@t§:ie:%'" aiarzg with £..94sf5--§§44:4€4§9VEV'§:3reaE withéré 3 .. V %§i§?駧f§§§}fMf$£ Th§ "a?:*%z§:g?%if. §%%1';::e§:;s§:§-é%:";..§2s:m§ §; ff'?;7é%fi'%7"33i""§}§:§§7?é':;s:aa§§ . _ % fie tsa §:'s§;°'f': :*:'%:a&§ 3:3 ~%%°::$.- "?§'am;§'aa§ fag § :3bm'$emé?w%:WMW 'ffififi $?':%?2%*;:@§ §?%%?'57?i*i?