Subash Patil S/O Tukaram Patil vs The State Of Karnataka on 7 October, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Subash Patil S/O Tukaram Patil vs The State Of Karnataka on 7 October, 2011

Bench: Manjula Chellur, Jawad Rahim

V'§?

 

EEKE THE Hiﬁﬁ Cﬁiéﬁ? SF §{A§;E"é;'5%T25~.§{A AT 3f>\?K§Gﬂ§w§R§E
D£'aTE§ "?%*§E$ T§""§E ?m 3%? O? @CTQE%§R 2932

PRESEN?

THEE E~i®f'*~3'BLE MR3 mgrzcg E'r*IAE\§§ULﬁ~. CEf£%i.E;.?3§§C ff ._

M9   »

TEE HGE'~é'BLE MR, 3uS?:«::E §;fs.},?vA{} '%:;&;'::::§'%=9§_'  

€R§§*»'§§NAL. A?PEA§.. !\$€}',«3r_6?,~"_2 %Of 6'*{§;}     Q'  

cm:  %   
cazmgwaa apggaa :»:0.523i2_§% z;-Cjg" "

3;': C:*E,£a.§'é®.46?/EGCE6:

Subasﬁz Pa:E§      *  
33% Taskaram ﬁati?   ' « --    »
Ageé about 23 \ge:3:;*s'ii__ 
Rye Fig: €'\ée$3»E%~-»  
Sayaéa i»a'~g§e:.;§  L
fviahavaera ¥%é§a.ga":"
Suibarga " 4'  &PPEL§_.ﬁ..E\3"§"

{Ey §§'% E<.;fg;$%*;a:"s§%a~.sf.§f*:&§«.%;a§*'é',; 

Tm 'S-iaiég. ﬁf 

 8}; iééé '?aEé--::'e £3?"  j
 A'§x%aE*za%ak§»%;_mé imfgjzgé
'.§>Q§is::fe S§§z%z:§n; .385;=";§a§@r/a

 ?;ES?G?*~éS§§'--§9"§

, '.£:g'a;",3;s;" §'x§é*:=v$:; Eaééip 3%? }



 }._§;a;;r2g&Eé:"e 

\y\ ;\&;(';.q\,;¥';<<  , . '.1

'%ff,T.;'§_:*:éé--;*3a% ?:*e:;s:::&§:;;"§ sraﬁgéng is

Thm Criméaaé Apgeaé is ﬂied meme? Segtémz 374 Q? Cc§'e.Taf

Qréménai Precadure praying ta get agéﬁe ma order 3? §;;'¥r§v%;z'E:.;3i§§;;s"é2.,
ané géniamae aazsa :5.2,2§s36 gasgaﬁ in §<C'%»:a.21?--';%;:%§é3;'---1%;%;.._f'A.
'aha féie 3?" the S8$SE$E':S Ezgﬁge, Fag: Traék Cs:::*=:_~.'x,ilE.._;f§§%é.§a.§§:'é::"
far the Qfféﬁieﬁ punighabie anger :3€CtEﬂk§5';§§3{}§?;§v 
r;'w 34 9%' {PC am Sectéar: 23 a? the ,&;.9'%":'f:§:1..?£_\ié?I.i 

apgeﬁéant/gccuseé §%£@'1,

in C:'E.,é5'.Na,623;'2OQ6

§ETWEEF\§:
Paﬁmavathé    
W,/G Late Asémk Qutiigdai?" _. . " 

Ageé absut Z? yeeifs  
No.26; ft Mam Roaé  :j,
H stage; xrx:.@;v<:';"Rz%:;a*e:: 
§'*'§ES§'§§§:§§<$§'%E'¥'%E§L%%j{8f _ 
ﬁaragaigmm-86  '  AWELLANT
{E32 W3 S1 Baéan &-.§'>s§3§€iaies; 'géiﬁzﬁcatagj

§'%?'=~§§,3'Z «_

*{a%é::--, b':; §v"§ a.h&2§.a§é<sv§':ni*:%§ 
La:zs,>:§:-- P3,, «A   
 §E§?Q§*§SE§\§'F'

j3Lg._;5»g 3:; ma; E'.%é$%;*§§.:4,, ;u::§::ma: SW 5

 'ijﬁménaé ;%§§€a:§ $3 iﬁieé eméa: S€€%§@§"': 31% af Caée sf

' $8: agéaﬁ we Easiégémeni <3?"

 



€Q¥'°a'v*'%£'{§O!"'E and $e?:te:"2£e gasseé Ey WC 'J11 Ridge at Bav§fsg%:a}'§'cs.re
era [email protected] tr": ga£2Ng:g??;2®@3; '   %

aggaéiantfaamsseé ms': fa? the affenceg gasnéséé-§%§§e.. 'ué*ééé%"-T "

S§C§§C%L§'2S 382 am :2Cr{§} and 28: rfw 34 §o'ff"Z»PC e€<.j;'"*--  '

"§E*:es& Aggeaég havéng hwy': §'¥E $f'f§ ' :8:.E':iﬁ

Eagégment, somigég an 'Em ;3§0;20un::?é::ff2~§=,fnt Q?'~.''}§«se.f§_:"z*2§2%éi._*éE*1..i$.€§ay1 -. L'

MANEULA CHELLLIR. 3,? deiixsereé *ihéfu::§;E'§m§=sé;"zg:i'-  "

3:}   

T§*:e$e twa amaais are :iV5:',s:;i;>'T'§::v.$:;?L..'i_e»31V:'»':f»& if-1'£,=,v2af':';:»"2;'V_~.%:_o':'.get%°2@:" ag they
arige met 0?" £9m€Es'Q%i"j;v[.§L.g:7i§3me§n::"': 5? vV.."zZ_fTT§§§ €eL;rt in §gC5

Na.g2?"?,/2383 gm § §:_1@ f % ig§ E§§"%:§":é"§f.§:'§§é:>'§?:$u§}.§£<:§§e,. $35: "%":*acE< Qeurb

2:3: gt $ar;g,gl:"§é?{e;'AVTf.;:r§§%35':%A':ea%§'*».é;§§eaé""'§:§,é5?g2§% $2: fiéeéé $3:

ﬁaﬁausaé s\:e§: --=,sg arm} arm s~g:;«523;2@s5 $3

§:'€f&r§"€§ by §§c:C:iéed:"§§'wz:z,',2 %"v_S%%:'%, ?3ﬁi'¥"§§'xr'aiZ§§§=
  §ia%:f.i:;:».4:i%§*:;a*:: Eaé is 3% Eayéng 3?" aézarge gizeeé: §§§é2":st

 53%: €:'§%'2~§':%_g:«§e§§é_:f:;.:$'Egg'? Qffeméa gzméghaiig agzéégr §§{:*i%§E"'2$ 3%;

'1;-_:2:s.~E¢, 2%:  '3'4""af EP§ are as under:

 '-%:§~.

 "..f..s'%Aic{f:::§e§NE%§§g2 » $5ﬁ?T:"§&'~f§i§"'§§ £5 zfmm €*=4&ha§aE<$?:m§g§asra :3"?

"L"%Mv<5%a:;:.§ga%:;:re1g'A Wa ﬁgaeaggﬁ ﬁ§E'2a?;%«: Guiéeﬁag" gg mug égiésar am;

mnv%g;€§.?¥§ .  -- ,%E"zé~ V

 

<
/
é



35,

the Emgband sf Accuseé M352 --~ Padmavathi am he haéis {mm

Guiﬁarga, M: the Fﬁiﬁifaﬂi mm': sf time, ﬁsﬁiiiéﬁéﬁ §\EQu.f.§§,_ '?:'*:§&

mme ta Ems' parenig imuge far iziaiiazery sf $€€Z{}E3§ a:E":i_%§§;"--f..g:f:§--%3;j$' 

- Dattaraj Gutteﬁar ig the eiéer brather sf 'me  

Ciuttaﬁasz Accugeé Fig.1 ~«« Ss.;§as§": Pam? §s2:: a5As. 5ras§:§i<;£_'i:=2:gf'*.é:*:.. _'%V§:3§':'

zseighbezsrhood of the deceaseé A;3hr;:_§< Giitéieiiar a§:':§V-AVhVi:s:wi'%fe 

Accused 940,2 ﬁadmavathiﬁ V V

On the Enieyverséng :*:§§§j§'£':':«.0€;F ai :a§ :aut 2.1%
am, a teﬁaghanic r:f;eSSa§§_ mfarméng
cﬁmmigséan 0? a  5%:-.Aa€:_?"%$u§é: é%xV':"'Q.-gha%axmEpmra was
%'e{:e§v@§ 5:! ihe "'§;€V'aVEé';§§3'%§s%;s:':§ iaywgui ?§E§€a
gtatéaré. sf '.§§;§5Vz9$c»V€':t§ cf Acausw N952 M
ﬁaémavatﬁé,  3§8¥'i fmm aiher Enmazag
G? hag' gargrszaé 92$-s:,_{e  é:%z%;§u§'%:zV§' E':er mremis and gisier. ﬁacuseé
?x§1<§@""-. A?§§§f:"%n;§";sa§'h.%' §'§$§é'é""5a5 written cammaérzt Csmgiaéning the

rr::.;2ﬁx:%§2="'gf;§"%;:a«*§}*:"'i%;§;z::%3a;':'é;fi. whemigz 3% §,F':§G§'€'§"2$Q ma? éecﬁageﬁ E235

 . €;:€..'3»%*':"i& is Aiiigéngafaéé-.V.:é gartécigaie is': {she wtéae auaiéaség iiﬁai zwra

'%T'T%i:V:&«:<:;ev-.%»~;§:::; ma ans 2%?" Eune 28%; in am Sigh? 9% :§.5»2s:3£:2

"--:§%'§é:.2f§€*f£'_§.3h§%< i_§i§i?&a:§a§" {tame 2% ;%':%g ?a§§*2&:»é::~§a;a;'"<g iésugé 

 %%Y€;%$\%Qz <'§??e §¥§@5%&$§



.,;;%é?i~

11 93* 1139 gm. am hag his ﬁimer, ﬁe weni aiangwith
Aciuseﬁ ?%$o,2 - szaréfa is 'she 53$ rmm in tha first fﬁasgi sizctcassﬁd

N§.2 ~ ﬁaémavazhé same égwnsiaérs ta: §r§::*:§ has" ahéfé "'S9§z"sh"

who wag Eat in ithe care sf hes" gisteir' by name Vigfaya: €'§~':.é-«:;§e:.g

iaiking with her S§Si€E' ~ Véjayaf @330 was watzbsézwg  .
haif an hear aria then went back :9 her §e.ci+_:fo0sn%s§""'""§"'%{»*g;fV 

the bad mam were gwétched Sff. ﬁafter9,§*~,e*§:ff:'g~:§§'{*i:§'2'e::'bs¢3.§5;"L'~§;Ef'E'e§T.:

trieﬁ as taik E0 her husband, but §:{~: ,d':'a:i:._.:20t"':"e$g3€3§&é;, ' $E;$v«-$.?}6-Vlfeét 

wetness $53 the beé, she S%?\§§'§C§'3€§ 0;_s_fg xf:§1§=..%_§_g§":*'::s  a«§§d;AAsVAa§&s biead

was aezéﬁg from a heie 'E<:r:"_t?:.s-3;1;:-hé3$i ~nﬁf, her hassbaszég

Emmeéiafteiy She aégrieé %:h:@""'?ar§*j;§§§;'vi:he in turn

énfgrmeﬁ Em ?aE§£_€» 1'-..§$'3§§:;e  9% %;_E--"Ta=;>§é' :3"ec;3~5é'é&{§ wgs warm, E9

1'

gave him," m vs;_a g g:'§asf:-33:. ix} ;%2~§%Vgs;-kg'-hgfgggggi

ag @9362

3: au:§n}gEVV._:5m2 'csuseéia, '§§i "'séévegaggaaém. méiégtég axgeré:

miieaieé b§;;:5§"§;:":é ;§§§::::f§7s7'§§ e'22gé§@::::e by aeiéeciigzg gzzazabg fmm

b99é;»%i': :'Ejée.'§_"{a:"§§§'é::A«:?f' %;:§f§§ 5$£€§Sé§a Enqamgi wag aw} mszaiuaiazi

 Sm %<;"§~%§_,'¥'§f»%§"':j%§§":*:§{:'5é.;~=f'{:rem$%£ §>{p€§"%: {ram §§§"2§@§$r"& §'*'§€§§C&§

 '.;-ifaéiazégg §€§':--'&§':5:;'§£§' ~.%iT,f§§ar%m*:é3§:i aaééefusiezﬁ 5:.§:s:.:z§§=g an im éeaé

. ' 4\ ..,W.
 »  'fa



£1 4.

$3

may at Véitaria Emgmtai' Sm: iE"E$$€€t§%{'§ was Game 5%

mﬁhazar was ﬁrgwn. Siam staiaeé C§{§i§'?€§ were :e::@;<~;Ts9:e§

fmm the §ers{>r: <3? the éeaé gem Samgée skis": Atiég'  
buiiet ingury wag aige €IG§§&CtS£§d fez'! 
Statémenis sf gewraé uzémegseg Eng:Eu;§én§ i:h.§'fagvié§f3}..'g=;'§§*1'§'béE'jé.bfV g
$33 ﬁarentaé muse cf' the Accassseé   Q ihe V
zjaceaaeé Came :0 ﬁe recara§&~._  séV%%ieV AfoeE am
paém marks an ihé pagfagei vaaaiiQ"'ﬁV§'g'§i §{$3.-~«§V;g.AA.'§;?é.'---'cééeﬁja' sf we
house at? the fathe:: 'é%'~L§iZ:cuE:%_eéaLEééé.§\ '¥ :§;;3fff§;%a§'aihé, the game
were wiéecteé.' H  1 ' V '' V

4:" ﬁx : "': é*1¥é' :3?  .§":é_é% e g:§gaiE@n, ag gar the
mfarrnaiéan  ..-ﬁﬁadmavathié, suspécim wag
gsasnfzeﬁ mt_:a:3w%*ésV_"?-»'§.§é§<.aA§é:_?§Véésttagarg Sabhagéz §:.;'{te§a:' assd

S;_:s":5&s§i2_ €3vz':E.j'E"*é:es;,=::j.ais*,,V.%.wéigﬁxxg-:3-~;'§ Em révai Cerziraazars in Exam

ﬁugéﬁégs 15%:_i3':4;_§E::éé%*§T§"-gnﬁ ihaas am? aége :§'c=§e§g: reiateé E2: the
:T '=ffi:€§CE§$é€.§V;§§SE'Ea;"}k'C§£;'5E'.%Ed&?'. ;$e:;§E<:e muié mi Q9': a §:r&a§<ihmz2g%":
. é--::;<:jp§*:.$ 9? §:,:g:%'%;. S£§S§§€§§§'E exmsggeﬁ $3; 2% ﬁsaaggeé ?«§::s.2 --

5._?a§r§:§:s.a?:§*:"%A_.a;:ﬁ aﬁhgr §§%"'§":§'%g' §"§'E8§"E"1§'}é§"§.

 



_ €:.§a;:1g:  §:g':.:;;§'én iasccugm Em:

f '§'§é%%5  :3;s.gu$%§ $33.1 ~*$§.i§i*$'S§'i ﬁaiéif

SE ?"§€33¥"%'€'=i§'3§§ﬁ; thraa manths after ihé éeath Qf  *¢'é'2,e

daceagaég

Qzsibarga 351$ stagseé Er: me hzmge sf ﬁattaraj G:;fi;:_sé{§$r_, H

bzather 9? tine ﬁeceageﬁ R:sshei<.: Gutiteﬁar.

Satitaraj Sutieéar netéceé unnatmai

Acmseﬁ M992 as she was; 'Emma can§?'eV§9?sEr:g wE':%_: ":»=;:aS:.v:e"::;;ne"' fer

§"i*3*%_i¥'$ tﬁgetﬁes" an the t8§8§h€t§}§7€~._%n ;a"'§';:V§é:j4;m:!t%%-ma %{a7§§p?§.} mead

§e%'":§nd €E€3$&d 30953 9? the §'€::~0E'":'§V._V_ 'T-®,}Vu°$,'!<;»§"'{:u.-:%_§3A%.:jyf»»_and ausgécéan,

?W»6? garetiy rec@r:;;"§é§;?.L:e9;:§r:i*:"._:e:::"wé:§'a§'&'e.3if;V.iggﬁa tam resume?

iby aging garaﬁiei iiéég  §V_uaV.'§te{§»:<::,.zsed M02 went

ta stay' at Taafkaﬁy ¥}.é'%EEj:%;§;.';g  '{%5r._:'9:'é"§:\;%':e;'e faméﬁy image 3?

€aa.;'§ts@$:* £3 géizészgezi, §Eaie §:A:_LjV§:§é?"%~~%:::§~fr°:.:2:' zziay a? "%'a:,%%«:§£, ?"~J's£A§? haé
resaréeri '§§§§;;:%1§m§é'<:.§§2vé'2'$3:%e€§Q? Aimseé f%§®,2 with atﬁeyg gr:

t§*€é§ 'Ea; {$6 Vr'§e%'<::f§ r:%f's_e':r_  ._

$9;%E'%:%e:"V.'?%é':::§%%éfagytéze remréeé ::e:*°2's;e:"§a'§:§:'z,, Waﬁé? iaarai
- ?§§mava§h% ~ ms s%s%:er¥:§':»~

meigﬁisxgax 5:? ihﬁ §%€&§S¥-Zﬁ

 "_'é'§;:i;§e§7a;: éfier %:*§a§*é:"*;§ we fﬁiﬁféﬁﬁ aenvergatéom P'»5'%§-§? wag

-..::'é;%€zf:%i§ ihai ms gaswgni m' cwggéraag i.ZI%§§i?=§E%E'E §a{Z€§3§€§ 55%': am

'. zﬁ 

éamgecif §'2E§.2 §§§§'Eg¥'=£§t§"i my €jE"§§§ﬁ§'"€E"E 2

  

.cm»:@:.:¢i sand b§%%%amo:.;;%  *

 



Acsuseé N92, éeceasaé Aghaék Guttedar wag %'T'IE.§¥'d€E'E§ anﬂtﬁe

.43 ' .'

masan wag ma éiiécit intimaay ﬁewgeen éaaugeé :"*xiasf.~f:----.'aA;7§:i}_L' ,3 
iicsugaﬁ M3,: was arrestea an )?'rE19.ZﬁB2K E:1.é:.§$~1..:;e::%:f:~ceL"_m5
reserﬁ that wherz the news éf ﬁcguseé  ':E'§A?'§*.é$i;é§iT§r0:V§E_ii'

"?:i1,'2GG2 came 2;: tha new$pap@:*s,.rﬁ,ccus1e":i_ 'E'%§--<;.;'Z -;.§e;3'§cEg':*::é'a=.ré§%;.§*i'§~ V

attemptaci ta csmmit Suiciée by cen$:.4 %né_i':'g $Gr2*'§}e._p5é'§%s j §-§'{3weve:;

ﬁéa ééé mi: aucwed in her ai:t%4_:i"':A:r§t,  §§;eg;::i.E.sC%:ar §E:Eram the

Emsg%'{aE, she wag aise arre$tea;:i;_V_ é's":.._3; her gigs;
in the heagétai, ﬁccu:§éﬁ'}:j§s1:':§,2 ﬁaigi  E'é'aa:§é--V§*;'<:.r:.§%$sed Em: gaééit by

way 5? extra }?aséi£::;aVE aijéﬁflzfiesiﬁit;*;ai§:"§}efAf§§'*a~'E*'ze's§ fét§'§e:"«En-Eav«;, §W--?Q,

1?. ;ﬁ;§fs:@é;"._'§ﬁ§:$2'f{:*v§'§;§'Q:§'§§:""§%€{:€_§§§é§ 1%.: am Accugad 329.2,
ﬁearzg sgéiieti :>xzév:%4_a5:*3§ eif::2_:"é'§s%éq»--a.J§'é';f;t4é3g9:é the émfarmatéen given by
time.Va:£a;§€é:§'éé$g:%e£éa§E§z~Aéﬁcassésé $531, 3 cauntry maée mm: wéih

§%vle~._£ari:"«§.::§_{ge$ :sge3§fv:e"~..§e£avereé fmm a féeéﬁ aé Eeska asiéﬁage af

gﬁfzaépigr Vi§'§;%..V+e.'3{:§':'§é"g_v:§a:{§'évs:ré§i, A z""i"§§iQi"€C"y*C§8 wégsyzgéng ':9 ?'»;'%f~§§§

 41§ré§r2§ $f '2ia£g:I:;;.§%§'j E'xi{;x3;§ wézéch wag asgeé git iéze iéma a?

4:¢;ﬁ;'s'r*:é'%;.*::V§$?*;:§?e:"s.:j: <55 aha C§'§E"3"'§§ wag ﬁﬁézﬁ-Q 1%; ihg ?sEé£§. is? the

 =.s@E;-<é%g.:.a%*:w% wéﬁi G? éérna, ,%§£s.§§e§ %%£g.: ~ Ezgﬁagh ﬁaiéé wag $§i§§§*§:"§%"E§

.__V?'~"%a§.iT§V§V»€"Z'§i"'*:% 3: Quiﬁarga Meﬁéaai éfjsgéiagek

   



 wag E

'  '-.$.i"a'{e§%"2e5r'§€§' $3 3

8. §}L..H'§¥'Eg ma gamma 0? énvestigatian, inf@z":";':ai:%e;r1___=.»-gas

Qaﬁaaiad frgm xsarmug dafcmrg am re%€::§§:: gétiarésjazéae £e.::_:§;;2:':.€;7€:j$

were $53 méiecteé in reéatmn ta attenéarzae cf Azsggseééﬁ  ~

ting Medfécai Caiéege,

9, Wvuéii éngpité Q? a crime being 

iaywazsi §3éZ}§E€€ gﬁaiiorg mGv&f_d§""~ a ;.';:r§v§aAt"e~«._w;:«:§%mp¥ais1':Hbéfore ihe

warned Magistrate, Aiand 3:':€§_ VQrwafsézi5..':_--.r§'§ne étassettés
mntairzéizg the i"@CG§':f§€i€i_VC£}I'1V:S£'S§'§".i.é}ﬂ"bé§§%E--E?fé_{f§:VV}5gCC'i.§S&§ P603: and
Aacuaed §\.§e.2 En 51.'?-r.i~33§£*':'t'Ei§._$§iA5:...-'3.Z§f %:*':«z;z12f§"e--:sf Q? €§--«é}_,=x:%e_as§§ Ashak @a:t':eéa::
Si:bseq:;e'.e3:";t%§,{V,..i;.%3Qé'é:A_Ejaééggttgg' *g3¢f €E":E§f"<f{}ET§¥v':ia§'§€G is the aencemed
§»"§a§ést;'a%E iéyri 'at. §3' &'§?;§'§Aé§a1'%'§;:€§-,._;8fV$- fnéiéaéiy grime wag ?"§§§S§§?"€§
and the Same :ﬁ;7as;_4¢ci,r:*sé*:":§§fe;=%d"ze;§E_i§:%:§:": {ﬁe §:_,zr§=:ed§::Eie;m :3? aartgaégre
ﬁsamtg, Téiié 'said ::a§5;€-Eéiiég were farwarﬁed Ea Mahaéaxmi Egywzmt
:?€:i§Cé";:"3:a:€'Eo?:;" ?<;f i:§3g jﬁiéfﬁﬁﬁé 3? érwsgtégaiian. "Five giatemenis
sag' §§§ag§Vé:jf:a'%e$ "<;§% ?%'lt.z:*;:"1s§e§ 533.: game is $3 :*§{:ar§e§, §§i'r'§E§§§"E;!,

€Ef:€i§I&.§;;§'éE'°S areé ﬁrgfeggmg :3? gipgsuggd §\§{;§..E «-

 $§,§§%§3§'§ ﬁégtﬁ '::'jar%*§é 3% b§ rgagrﬁgé ag §ar%:' :3? Eiéafﬁgtéggiééﬁf

.1 §:§2'?>3';:*:2ai:;§[<;-:3 35$ ﬁﬁﬁiiirﬁﬁféiﬁ ggrzaéésmg Ea ﬂag §'§€2L%$€ %"»§%"i§§'8

éarémg ::=«;§§ gig: CG§§8§%€$ émé %Z"*3§'"i§é§"%

",7



 '%»§:>t<,?142.<f:&wz"é':éV :'»li"'s3;: §f;*;?.'?f,i=.v%'V'§'V"%§F'EK€§ an behaif :3? 3:3 §m$€£'s,:i:§m":. fﬁe

V'  .'}i'%E_"_E"%':€f:€§:',%'§"{§; %:::é:%'; $§£z:e":'*:&;'*::a:";z am: Graé gagéﬁazzca §§"E€ Eeamaé iriai

  '-».}:é€§e:_§e @353 aenigéréged sf %:§"s§ §@s"2':§i%:;':%:g 21:?" miﬁ iba aggeiiamig E3:
 4.

10

énfarmzatian frsm the KSRTC, Bééa: regaréing tha bums bat'./x§és;*3,:f*:
82%;" is Earegaéere via Guébarga was aim aeaurede 
Emegiigatésﬁ, a§'€e:* germéggéar: fmm 'she cancerneé  
vaéce <33' ﬁxccuged Nest: and 2 came ':9 Ets=;:Js;Aé§_ér'd.Vé'€§_ 
Qresesxae ef W§§Z'§'§§SS§§ at Cerstrai Qsisgn, V45&~--3%:'giai@ref,'.."_ fvézé 
\:0%<:e as' Accssged ?'~.Eos.: and 2 with *{E'%é*:%;§CO'§'d.€{T§~f<;f{5':":';?%E;§:ﬁ%§€L;?¥'gV"iE'E
the cagwttes pmduted by  v:§7'.E§«;i'3: 'e3:a§uAé%éd"'%r9m a
wise expat, The Seiged m§Vt§§"E:a E§§ '_§§1§<;é _.i;:;.::.v2v'§;véj'?g:? __5*&am%ver, skin
arsund mxiéei: EE"Ej£§:"fg_'; §if1§.t;:;{i§(§.::S*C?:'£i1?§:é§ ware sent: ti':
?'<:>rer*:§i<: Departn1§§{1t:;_44_" .éi;£§';~»  itﬁe Envegitégatéerz, a
wage gheet amused aerseng for
me afferéaes  35:2; ;::e:f 32%-a sf zap:

reaé wiih S§::s:i;i§:;n~2."§_§ ._§%'%:h§ §~;'rm§ ACE,

°:§;"§;: ~§§§~,"?'8'§§z.f§%ﬁ%SS8S were axamészeé arsé Exﬁi ta

_ 2:.§_efé:r;€& gei ;e$a;r:92'éfr;:eé mm»: aria gig: markaé Exﬁi iﬂ €29. Méa

{E :::2{3.'3§ %;é::':.%;"@ gs: markeé. ﬁn aggraéga af iféa @r*:§:%:"@ §V§§€%"§*C*E3

    



11



we crime in mzagtémz. "E'"E*ze§; savage canvicted and ge,r2tenCe:~{5d"'»i:§

Lmdergcz Empfésanment few ééféa am is gags 3 fine §? 
3a far ag affemeg §£,%E"é§§§'E&b§& under SEQEEQRS  <;":Zf" 
1% am H3 defauit sf gagzment gt" férzg, j§;§i._ﬁé2}ga.:"fmii§Eé§;f :'

 Emgriganment far mg year, The*;z_ we:*€:_ Paige §s3":3:eft2Ced5:'; E6:

undergo émgréganmeni: is? 023%  :é~._§: ai'§ : a. Kf§;§He at'
R$.§,GQQ,,/-- far the gffence §;=;::rfi'E;:%:aE§AEV:eﬂ_£§§%'é¥.§%;:§&ctéaEﬁiéévi 0?' WC
and in éefauét is 933; fgrfzef E¥*':efyV_v§'§;;g';%§."_'::§z§d@'r§éA~b.I§_:f;:i;§;'*ésanmant far
gix E"ﬁQ§"iE§"'!Sg       V

:1. A§gsf'§»§s.::e.gj.V'i:.u.1'E::'§;;J  sf csnxzéaiéan anﬁ

age: 9%' 5<3:*;:$r2_:r:e{"é:.%fse3gé_%;:;:*.:¢a"*«.§;>§g:a§s are §§'°§f8E"?€§ Ey the

a§§§§Ea:"2tg5
 :2,  g.%*Qun§'§'f.fa§V$eﬂ:b§; {Ewe 3§§a2Ea:':t$ are as améer:

 'E"%%2é'{«:1§3é.éé"*as:fg:.5%-aséisééggeg fa? i:%'s& §E"Q§€ié.,§i§§§§ écsrzfiécig wiﬁg

? *=.§a£%": a§E:.e§*';'i%:ém93§%'{,%§é it :-«£3 mi safe is raiy aggmn gash ékféééiéﬁﬁ
_ ?.:;a.4:j:2Vr:v:c%: *:§i€:'é7§::::;§ed gsarggzzg. "E338 gégrsifécané: ﬁaféaéfg :3? 32%
 wag; as énasegiigaiéan wag éarse ragaréérgg E%'*:%5:

V'  §§§§"'§"2€§ én iiéé ﬁg': Cﬁfﬁﬁéﬁiﬁi %@z:§g&§ ééag éqgmgﬁﬁ -?::E$xs.ﬁ.). w

    

 ."L\'.$"."s~'}': i=-x we



12

Padmavathi. gccésﬁing its the apgeéﬁarétsg tiwg tritai juége was
greaiéy énfiamnieé by %:%':e avédema §f ?W--§? am we $3 Caﬁeﬂ

ieiegahsaéc <:©m2€sr§&t%3n ﬁeiwﬁem the acaugad ;1}§£'S§-5"3§ sag'; is

have been recardeé by PW~§?. may centené that :@;g"':§'}'e'a5%j'r:T¢z::.V

Jsdge was wmng ﬁr: géacéng reﬁéanije 0:: $u€;7h_  :"°fe:»::;":¢L':\~=:"i%e*»a'.i5"_4'T 

aomersatégrs 2-which is Ezgacifméggibée §V$§'é._V"vth§ S(;;é3';;?--'?";gi:{}*.':f: SE1-'.f§f:EV§r*:~3§
ef the Evééence Act was wra§~ ;3j'§'g  'maﬁéiﬂati objectg
M6318 m 25 are not :§§C;;me:}_:$ﬁ'  <3? Sectiem
3% 50? {ha Evééenm  an mhaéf af

the ameéiants thiﬁa:  éizédence that Acmseé

E'é0,i was 

 C§&SS€S at Gzsﬁbargg
§€E'~.~'%§&€§'E  €318 ma: jzgége wag W£'$E'E§ én
gaming €33 ghe {i§t'A"Ejf§§§V_f:":'V;'§*ZZ:§".:.."{§"EA3'§"_  the éﬁéarvanéng nigh: 5:3? i§,:'§§~
§:s::Vi3¥&2Aa€f?:;{§$a%'z';i; w.;.§ g %;§ 5«é%*:géEare fa: wmmigsian Q? mime,

 mag as? ﬁaasugeé Réaaz ﬂag: afse was

 _i §é'm§%:ted§ *i{.': §§_§*;*:esg::;;"%fa§ in £39: azéemﬁt E5} mmméit $:§éC§@% aw $?'§€

 f;%f:@ ?és:?§§gE§a§ {mm §$11.2§€32; 3% §:;:1;?;§€}2 3:35 at 5:323?
:r.és§:%:e§ ma §?:ate":*§:e;*":'€s g? mzigrag §%_§'{%;f€ﬁ§%" W mug? gm

'i33::%:2%.;"§§f:*£:3":§ émiigéar, §"§"§€is'?i§"i€3%" $5 %:§'§& §§:':ea§§£i zzagere §**§£$§*'é§§



13

whﬁfain they have categisricaihz gtateﬁ {mt EEEWESEQ' {Q bear the
mam sf her iéugbarzé .&g%":@E< Sutiedaiy we CGﬁ§i;3§'¥"E€§ iabéets,

This is tgtaiiy égnereé by the tria§ iaurfg The Eriai Cam': ;:;';£E'a»;:::eé

reiéanse an the $0 caiéaé extra judicéai cenfegsésrz m;a..t;7_ié,*: §(i§L:i*g*;¢.§9'eV.
W.:"~«78 by Accused E\éo,2 -- ﬁgdmavaihé and    
errenaeus betause cf me fact that t§"'é€ f;E'¥Mét'7€-'3%"ia;E .{"@'*yf€é§E§*1§_ ﬁr?'-:t§"'é'.

aééegeé cmfessier: was aiready ﬁagheé En:'5V ea9§3rza§ r2éé;;sgag«e%;.«;1§ .._v"

14. Even v».i§tE1_?f€~ff:gEs3.sfd VV§':,:.$*'x:'§.2Q__,2§, Cww
3.5, Wis-43, 4&5@:_ .;%ég_g;::i§%§g;;'Ve§%§awmar§Ea% re¥atém
hetweerz A:cz:;=;.m 1::-s;%;:Ag1.;d  accegted by the t:*Ea§
Cami: PW»???  ?W§=2@ arm 63 tumeé
hestiée, §Di!vs.4«3"'--§::§jV  auggart the gage 92' the

gr§_3@€:;t§Q,m_%; 331:: the 'é:*:.§j«,{ aegiégazz wha 393% ébﬂiiij exi:ra~ma:"Ei:a§

afﬁéf §'§e*E:xr§§%::3;" §:s:i;I.v;:'s.s*:3gé §'§Q..§. arm ﬁcsuseﬁ Nr:}.2 wa$m'Yu5:;f Sa§ M

 ?'ﬁ£»«4§}._§"T.s§9s:*ié§'?%%:..__érs~T.,':'§%é wage of the éeaeawd agar? fzgm iha

 '.:--e:§€a5;3nce  ?*2;é§'«6?: "ﬂag wééerzse 9*? @\;'=J-4%6 wag racaréea? wait;

.;20§2"'%m_:c?z Esta? than 32% Siaiamezétg éf geveraé éiézzer

"~[f .;g;s§E§§a%_$§:%V$'.' "'"§%'s§:;gE*: ?:i's:'»»%% %"'f':§§ ggxgasaé game Q§:§§€$E'§ ﬁafiiéi" is

2ﬁ;*1;.fj;§';'2'éf.%{'}2; 32% maﬁa: §'€'v'€§i€é '£§'"§€ 59 §§§EE{:§ g><*::"a~:°:":&:*§iaE a fair

 



14

§&tW~S3€¥"s we Aacmseé 95332.1 arm 2. Tfzég wmess £3 gmthigzg but 3
gm up wiimsg far we §L§5"§§$$ $2' the gmrgeaagiéan. They aise

ajantgrzﬁ thai 3% far ag the maﬁa: geézeé {mm {ha baéy §';'.__i%:e

ﬁmeaseé ané MGJG -« revaiverf the eﬁinéen géve.j{7'T§'§e* 'Lj"t:¥%:'3

éaiiistéa exgeri waasid indicaie that :29 reiiasége maid   

such evidence' when investigating"Vi3%%f{:@;fV sgvéit}-f.  gar: =3?
{Em émvegtigatﬁaa, did :29: h&;%% ":?he.'_'A§.#%f%§%a§§g:E. V?':5arfaver$'étéA® in Eﬁé
casseitegg, the triaé C§§.;:*{ :<:>aﬁ§_ g-'§aj:;;'e'A'§:5VE._'jV:ts':¥'§éar":<:e an gush
reacrdaa {:9nversaiégﬁ:9:} ;~. §f:;zer;é-_AtE2¢".'%<3."':;:§§'E'é€E'V-mgﬁeri 6&6 net mse
her apérgion gr;   macing reéiante an
samgiéng a   {:3 the exgert, iféﬁ
reaaréezté ccﬁasﬁaiéérg  {ha a§:'*r:éti§§ méce ta Eﬁa
axtent 9? 53:9 ?$5:€; _$r;::% %'£;%  farm tha iaasést far €£:§s22;%:,"i:§§§':9

°.z5Q":%:' 935$ 53$ €Q§"§':@%":§e§ $51: whet: Emxzmiigaiima wag

gm'  in Mahaiaémms §§y~=:*;s.5i: Paseae gaazmf

 v._i %;*'E*'é%e:°e wag'-...§}9 §'§é',"*Su*ifivE"§ %;"af§3';;' ?¥'si-é? hgé {:53 haw avg? we aagggiﬁég

"$9g'V"«ff§E'§'n;g j 2*: "§.;:2if.%'§;*ai§ €G§':¥"t§3E&§E":i,

Wétheaé ezzegé gathérimg

3., E*::i?{:-%i%i*::§f:;:2_:";u.--'yagaréiag iééa '§i%§€$?'é§E'2§C s:'§::az€:*ga'{é:3n éeﬁwaan

 :3?'  

.§sZ:V:':li:*:»::~:s§d;T§§'z§::>,»"§K 551$ égizuasé E"--és:::,2_, ma f§§"§%r'§$i§§§§§?"§§ {:'§§§£§§' faaém



"W

15

ivéahafakshmé Eaywaui ﬁaiice S%ai:§@n preceeéeé {Q beiieve the
vereéazz inﬁéaateé by pwwg? ihai the murﬁer cf hég bmther E3: we

E'tan§§%,;*J§s°E»< as? Accugaaé §2§ss§1 33$ 2' ﬁg ﬁaraiiai §3'%1f€Si§g3'E§'<T}-5'}; 0?

enquiry previéeﬁ in the Crimégzaé Waceéure Cadef €h$.§f;,ef':f<.;f%V§*:§~:4'L:4?;:E"V2'Iv;~":«3

€£'3E§§'€3 exereése ﬁarze $3: the 9m$ecu.%;é9_:r3 ta é:.s_"§:*:":_; §n,:*$~.r;V:°:.%ﬁ Ehés st; 

caiéeﬁ remrﬁed Canversatian as am §'E*§:<:jé%fe  evéd$r::<";géTé's7i erijenecagg.

Accerdéng is {he a§§e§Ea:€: s';«. iééé 3.ér:'*;.§_s*§'"=.e><er€Ese of the
preseatuﬁen ﬁafare the triaé f:{}§.Ji'E  :»E3ré--':':~g; ':;%§.€r;;..fecarﬁ seaserai
tércagmstanceg g3@§r:i:%_§*:g }::§;:'E; ti'?-3 gu"é"§x%: '0¥'f..i%*:é"a-fgiuseé ag a matter

a? fag: was {mt SLéC§8§_§'§3.%E é5'g%'é._:i'§§g«. ﬁféai C"c:;z,é'é*t wag mt jusiifimd in

aamzéatimg thyé a§c':3'Se:}:f;..  

16, ﬁg aga5VE's"':g'§: iV?*:Ei$.;;._Eéaa_;"'i:§_'{;? SF? Csnienéeé ﬁzat {ha mstive
f2:;:--v€;§2":"2;"z':v§V»,§§3.E¢ VréA'{sf :%é'{v:°:é:'*;f;_§,i3e§:2§; ééiegitimaie intimacy §€t%£'J€*€E%

Ac€":;%$es:§"§%§uG;s«..:u=a;":«:;§ "'2__,5 $9 aise ta ugurp ma gmggriéeg <3? f:§'°'z€

I-V_d§£eaée«:§§a.3E*';é%é:'«.€;;§s.;=§*:t=é§a:", ﬁiiﬁiiﬁﬁﬁ £333.: am 2 mnsgémé Ea ﬁe

 7a:wa§z w§i§":44é.ié;C'éa$é'§ ﬁsghak Qiiiiﬁﬁﬁé' ané {big E3 evideﬁt éwm iéw

.1 ::%.%;zVi';;?-;%i::;1;:?@a:s§ﬁ ﬁifwéég heme: Er: Em ?"3fGL%S& ef the deaeageﬁf vJ§'E§

 '-4"_¥§;a:":<%2i%'%SAé;§: ééé {$39 éaiazég 2&5? gxaaiéy hagzgerzea? éaiaﬁ-wag": §%£€%.,§S§ﬁ

 '»._.§a§<:}":2:"V$§§ 2 gag %:§":§ §§£§§S§§i "§'"E*:§ %2:i%é§:":{:€ g? §?'a:'2:~»>é?; i§"':& €§I§%?

":2 *

.2» ' *§%h F;c:'""'§x*=" "~ 



   



16

Mather :3? the deceaseé would aiw Eeveai why he was £Gt"1"E;3;r.§§§@é

'm retard C0¥':Ve:'$8EE{)E"E Q? §§:C€US8§ $65.2 »~ ﬁadmavathé 

§"2$§g of garaiiai EH29 af izhe taepémme, we ié stran_§@.§:§:hf aé%E:§:§?   
Aésugeé Na.2 after the death 0? her i::1ug;b.a ff:{5.".T_ Ei;e a~§%ré.:,'§v./_ _ $?;?i

bréngg ':0 the notiite at' the Qaurt, ei~:'%a'§:"sce "a}_f"E3'v%J--~?;F3"'?«*VV$3'§§;§€m'%;2%é§?: 

Guttedar regaréirsg cenfességn ma§e ":a:§ §:ém bﬁz'-?:'§'7sT :f3a;}:ig£hter«én~
iaw Actuseé N§.2 ~ ?ad:";"%éis*.ath?_'AV ;j:fe>;;A°«.g*'t:::«;_a;_E§f:ig«_t%*:e Qéiaéionshép
betwaen her ané ﬁccugeé 3'xE0,§.waé":§;V ::=:.v'EV_.1¥s;£r:%h'é,Vé'§'§ég_é'é i<E§£§r:g 3%' her

husband. .&ccmﬁ§r':§'  E?i"G?$Eif£!,,3§§4€3§,{ §§[email protected]éVid€E"éC§ 93' these

three witnesges vx£a;uEi'3§";2Gi:f:; @;;'E5%f{:r§EE"v-é fiﬁécommissisn 9? crime.

13% §;,.ea s<:;:2e:"i'S§V? ;2%§;«":e:,f9t§é*:i§é':~:i§:§ that {E29 CG§'§'*~£E§"S§iE§§"£ aver
tém Eeieahcme b5'<:%;*;s:;'ee%é'  $305.1 arm? 2 wezgéé {afar "E9
%f§§T.%§L§§ §a,.r:;i§3f$ *0? éménfesi-%:é}g;até§ra iZ$§"E%"%€€E§E"':§ éhe acmsaé with the

C0§'f§ffi§SS§Q§§ :3? a::~§:f§fé?&~%, haw ﬁxsaaggd E2132 éfacéiétatezé Acaaigaﬁ ﬁes:

 E9 §a§%é~.ééi:Vr'§§"é€:_:*:_s;é:;§"§:§é%:%ez: '2;':§E'?§? Eegaré is gaém aria} {mi i§£"§§"§'§:S

 4j§r% the '{:?'é.3s3_§;?a"--i':a§r':5' garageé waif; écmgeé 563$ %eér:Ig abggnt %:§

_ t%§sA:é::g ai:'"§a,2Ebar§a; ﬁaasugw Faiaki ba;"m:;v§ng maigrbéke Q?

 V  §§§'«..%éé§€£%:%*-aﬁéy 3%:
" g.../' " 2

 '¥%§£:3az§r§; gf ééaxg €§F'E%"§§§€ arzé §'$'a.i§§%.:"E%"' =-- ?'=«%ae.::3;': am

éiizﬁ Engiamae iv? %:;%:a éegaazsgé Féabé. Jam; ihage

 



E?

facig wemid deféniteiy agizabiiaéw éegmrzd reagsnabie éeubi: the

Ewmizxeméni: sf Aacmsed E'~éeS,3i am 2 in 'aha £Q§'"§'1%"§"i§SS§G€§"'{}~'§_iZ§:"§§fi";V%;:_.4 

:8. Vﬁiih {he abmza argumersts 5%: m;~§..;em.%ﬁés§Vi§'ﬁ, I,wé %{é_;z;ve:._V  '

game thmmgh the gudgmsnt as? time irsai ;'£?:m;';éfEA~én§'~.a_%'s:§' 

arm éacumentary exgééeme br:};3gPz%f:_ "s;:».ei: retard .bfe7e?.§r5::._ '?c;'?%e --'§:r§3E = L'

Ceurt.
1?' The méni: that wé'{;§'::iT--.ar'--i$é}.V%"e3%7%§:_2,a*=£@r:$§@era'§§er: E3
"Whether Ehe }:;a'g:2*:e_zéz.__grza?"S;f:3i;ég* ;9'£..V:5a;:3x2i€«§j§?§;é arm? gantenae

§§33ed 53/ we §r.:a,'«-'£;{x4;;:5§t_,.:r;3i;§:3_é;s:._.oc;:" gﬁferference ?'""

25. ie§,%s9é*ééd'  géacad reiianse an
gesserai :§E£ﬁ§i':E:'éi§¥"%'?;§ én  Tﬁgy amuisi be referreé
%:§ at iézg iégfeiig <3?'§é~:r;':;:s;§V%:;;2Aé;:5%ﬁéé feéevazzi égsaseg They: are with
§€3§ﬁ?d§ %:i €'§§:;;%;%:§@;2f$ '§oxfV':'E~:&"Evi§ence Ac: regaréérsg msiévé fa?

§§§/§"3}'§":"_3fE5§§';§;f;}'V§"§_€§§&:':§8¥:":% V§:§"V§fﬁ§T§§; haw {W3 E"&CG§"'<C§€€§ %%!§§€§'éi:$ $3 ma tam

1 L"AA.:::;=:§:rcxr§€;é"A  Aémreaéaiaé, mm 2:':x§€:'%. &¥§{'§€§"'§C& mg i% 5%



.. _f§x:<§4{:§;%.§;ere§ a?2:é';.%as€:§xg ﬁevg éézé Cwyéi magi take Lgtmagi gave vsshéiﬁ

'j_§*=;<a§':::a€;§V:'§§"'§f§§"C;,%§'€':$§aE";'?{§&§ §'»;%§%E"EC§9

%<??& "&¥&$&  % 



18

21. Lzéarneﬁ $PP reiﬁes aspen gezzeraé deaégicmg ta
§L:§s:an€%a'ze ané guggéri ma reagamzzg a? "$272 i".§'E8§ Cauri Er:

emnvécténg {ha argczgsedfz-3§:;eE§an:§,

23.. So far as we umaturaé éeath 0% the éec:eia;:.§é;é.§;.':'_'{:;":f';;:>:'fV'§

came: ﬁe any daubt tégat it 53 a hamiciﬁai deat¥'";V__a¥'i:%.{:c;a;:'zif:'E.:TV%'Lé'§A K V'

muréer. The questéara ég wig; wasV,r€3.é'e:st2's%QbEe f¢'r"%thég mw*der.

The mrstemts Q? the ¢9§'r:§i3a?é'1:':_%.:' ﬁ:"i§'$,«*A.V:;§ccuged E\§<}:2 ~

?a§mavathé,£ she e}:§~;§e:f;ce  9? mg
éeaaaseﬁ and aEs€<:;"*:§*i"a$: '~§§xs€§;g?iQ § ::z§<masah§ fathey G?
the ééceageq.._§r}§'§'.:t%:§:s;,;_a   en the £23188? sf ihe
aeceasaéa  "va:':§<a:a;'a}u mveaieé Mia?
wag the CGE'1C§§7 tE(Vi';:3.E:.""%  E,-*a;E'2era ha wag bmasghi ta

ixéaiiége E'2§,$%§§':a:AE., ﬁ:?r:e>.éffTI§§r:g:%:<} {big ﬁsciar, he wag are négh: émty

aéé'~':§;6,:2_§i}2_ 'Aé:?é.?2'Eé£~--E.iVge §'\€&di<:a§ Carma arm 3% aﬁﬁiif 32% 5,§'¥'i. a

 ;a€E&:?§":._5[°;__«ﬁé';"§s'§.__si~§§:LE':'é§< §a;'itea'ar; agﬁé aémui 3% igearg wag

 1:--§:*§:zg§":i :51? iéagéiéé '§"<:"é3§§é:a§, Sr: ﬁxaméﬁaiisia he faemﬁé ma: 3%

4_§g%§§&:€'::'t~%r<§§ rélét mggmmﬁfézzg {:3 2se:"§3§ £®§"§"':§"':'§8§"£§$ gm {haze wag
";:sé&:"%mgz ﬁe aigg faagmﬁ éézai; gasgiig Eéaieraé s§§5te§ aw

 §§:<@}§7.'"'%_"}s*2 ézaiiaérag 3%? '{§"E£Ej*.§% '§3ai%::$ $6 an examénaiégn, he ggénm'

 

 'if 3%

 



21

entry was cut arm gragarveé fer F§L examinatécn. Accwding E9

ihég daitss, we aggaraxémate range cf fire mug: be 5 En<:he§7'§§$"??;§

é§}£E1ES'> "me éeaih wag me {Q smak amé E*:a§msrr_%j:'é§e;~..§s5 ;_3 '~ 
raguét 3? fire arm injury $u$taEr'°seﬁ by the deCeas3d----.Q$?:§:V 'i:%:f§@._§&?t "

SEGE sf the upper park: 3? the ::he$t;. A£{t. erd:i.:§§ 

s;im:e éeath was abgui 6 t0 12 mars' ggfier &*:'e:.:> €§:e cam";-w§!%:V'£}_vienf;e'ﬁi
sf §€)$i§"Y§QE"?;€;"'?"k W examénatéan. So fa:r;V'VL'a;é_V"the e:}%2E.é§aEaz:;é <:>%'}a:; §GDs¥
ﬁcctor, the defence diﬁ  "§"%§:e}Ar<éff3re E326
evéﬁence :3? these twa  <:§9:.1%:0s*"3VV_ Awareﬁtiyg
the Comﬁiaént waé  §:~V"Pa:.d:$é2avaihE ma: her
husbané was smii sf aizaﬁengigzg Em
mature es'  "§"§A:éVV'$é;Vi§$ec:.:Eé€.::': was abm :9
ﬁausé3%?'-ﬂ1®;a'%V§§':%{;»3.S§»  6;?

esi:ai'»§%;r;E"%

r:

a éaséiaéi injury, E: E5

§2@b@é'3i'$ srgagg t§2a4'i:'V:%§ev.<i'.:«3£e'*;r:;sslé£ éamméttaé Suiaéde. ﬂam the
%s*°«;:;:j'<'s$'§'é,=%.;<'_:zﬁ;'.i%:2%%2,;-sizvegéiégaiiéféméag tswazdg muriéer by me enemégs

:3? §§s:_v3'a$jé<ﬁ}"e:%":%;E..éawa;r 3? as is is Kﬁaw wﬁeihar t§'¥;@

 V}"a.~"?»2f2$E§a§*:i;:s;%::¢s.:$é:j'1-_r*:Té§EE am 2 :s:;e§*§ E"8S§§§'iS§§§§ far we maﬁa;
_ E».  V . 

.. Wx ::

-. . i'}{§.§f.§f%€3..§§C@aS3ﬁZ§~%§§'§SE< §é..§f:%i€§&§',



22

23. Ag Ehe eﬁtére C333 9? the gregecutéan bas":§<t§V_"-:.,;_}';:sFs:f.;:':

aéyaumgianiiaé ezxiéansef the éefenm ceritenﬁé %ha§;§'_:éEé:~§ig:--...a%'afs%____'_

evgrwg c§rc:gm$tanr:a mfarreé ta befaw 0393;: 26 ba"€:3vt:§}z>vE§é'%*:.e:;§_E;354 '* V

the arasecutésn and if we ﬁnk in the CE=::aé§2;_-~35f?ci'r::3m$:ai':%§e_g, 

missing, the bgrgefii sf éaubi mu§E.§a:~..__:§ '::!92'&=,.,_a:i'<;:::,.sse;:§';A'   

25. Mating reiiance an ri:fj:e fei.§V'eTiw'é§?§§ §§%"at£ar2s',"'i§'2é ieamed

cemgeé fer the appenarsts car-*zté%1.T_§s_,"Ltééiéi;C;*:';;;%.s;"_»;;f§':_;§i take utmesi:

wecaution white asseésiiing the :€'é_é*gum§~E.$n§éaEzévidence barzkeé

upon $3; the $r@§%:t{,sét'?%'3?'::*-"'.3:-.._  "i  
i (299203 §::f:c ?§§'T{':;?g:§ {),fE-' ':'£'=_§.'.A; _;vSM gmgazf "?:~sA;<m§x3;:
AER 2984 $5:  S*%}§;':'"E 3?' §»§,m§Rﬁs§H"§"§_A:

MR i%?§ ?:{:%:%%::g::Ta  -__§§._ "{§}i;§»u"";"RA 955: 59$. C;%i.££j"?T§

.§i~5g:N§.;$a '8E;w.EACE~§i"'§e"'~é_§;:WQ:%l%E<$)

4g,*7.:2§ @7s*i;:. _;s;:z§ ':::s§:"a;%;r~,:g{:s Véwxazu Azg, R3. %~§EG§~€ <:@:s§? SF

K§§§gfA¥§§ 5""

W

{*5

RM

'  2?; *:;4;§a§§:*@f:i é':'§:;§:§e§ fgir $29 §Q§§§E§§'§§ C{}E'E"{§EE§S aha: in aims

' "a'«b'é':<é"'§§iaLtEana:?'ées':3 fgr Qiraumgtaniéai §*af§<'§5€E'§C§ are rséierafeﬁg

 §§§'§V5.3?§"§§.5"'E'§? :3 Eihﬁ wgeiéamétf gasgéaéars ﬁsaasever grave; Céﬁﬁﬁi

 éa:: $;;;E:*:§%:§%a;Ee§? fa'; gmai

 



:,.»..'V ' ' '
aw' \2_%_ I , .

28. The grinaégieg enunciatﬁﬁ in am amaze ﬂesjégéarzs §%e:."a.s

undﬁﬁ

gm:

LU

'»..}?"E 
»

Circzsmgiaﬁcag C'§§"§C-E*E"§':%é 'must 3:" 5§1§:;§--<'i.'_:"e3;§'2;?;;§--[.::' .

nu: 'may §e' €SEa&£€$h€€ﬁﬂ Thegjé E§"r:ge§ Q-;nE§;{"«:e2_ 

grammaticai mg: a éegai distinctiar: 'E:«.et§'.§_%e?én ':i"i'-,«?3A1:5y--.bE..  

waved' am 'misﬁt bg or ghouikﬁ "ﬁg 3re'as<séﬁ' V 

Fsiiezméng are the "1g;a.~:«_%ﬁe§.E':iés" :'V' <f_;r:&é;fcum$§a's':t§a!
evidence; " '% '  V   %

Tm €Ercumstan§:'ei_§4§«:';§3:§f: v§;:E§r::h_ *?:§ée"_%:®;:f:'{"§§:;s~g.s.z;i§'z :3? gm: is
ta) be ﬁrawrﬁé  §é--LI';-f;,%'%-§';,~? : .éﬁaégééshed. "fhe
iircumgtanvsseg _<'i,fV¥<i'§V:*f;».7cé'::*:fég--;§  a{)'E'~--..S§T}{.i:LE.§G am mt may
:29 e$:ab%§:s:,5he{§.~   j  %_ '

The facta rs. e9 ,§§€:g§%'i:=:;E9zi:::A%.1:ii,i~.?~:§§*s*:%;:::éé.:,'%"be sarégégierzi wig xzaséiéz

the %':3:;pe;:%1e$§§'=.@§" {Em g:.:_§E{>.--{%;f {ha accused, Eiéai: is ta

_..~::.a;y, §j»§:~i:'g;:g s§*2@:;§& ____  axgiaénaﬁie ﬁfé any ﬁihéf
?.§é3? ﬂ<:%:%f:Lf»3;:$§" éfxﬁégsi that %:E'°:e actcisseﬁ Ea guiiﬁya

'E45;-éV:§_§°:Lz::§3-if;;:%:%:§ j:§.§":::;::Eé be 53%' a agnaiugézie naiurg am

»V%§nﬁe§$y,

'§?":e::* §4%*'sr;u"§§ ééésézédg €?'§%!Ei";! @:3$a%bE§ Ezymtiaegég QXSESE

 ". §§T5§:€n*»f"}Vi'§j$ iséa grawdg aréé
"f%?"§:$re_§:¥:u$% bg 3 cézaéss Q?" e:;'%de:":£e Si} €:@:'2":p§§:e ag 33;:
 .._ €:%:3 §?3§:s'% am: *:'&ia=3a€2a§E§ §%'$i§§"':€§ fa' ma £{I:§'2§§US3§£3E'E

"*«.g:§éé§%g:§m; WE??? 52% §§'§é"E{}€:§§"§C§ aé" ':%:§ aaagzgzsﬁ ma? mag:

    



33

éeceageé Aghak Guﬁieﬁai' came is tha h@::s~,%§ 5?' F25 §a:§*2e:~__§n«Eaw
W??€FE hég wife aEes:'1gw%¥:f2 Emir secarzé cthééﬁ wa145V..V_v:'§§g.'.%invg§
Beceased after iakfng hég 5§§'%§'%E¥' went :3 me 
firgt {East ancf Accuaeé No.2 §hoa;g%}Mf'aEiov;'é:i:"' V;:aVn§§éV

ﬁawnstasrg an the pretext cf brmgéng 21$: c%"2§§{§..§'r@m_ d.:3{é;-%sr:'é:9 3*"f..zfs:7'.T1.T.:

3?. Accaréing far the CemgEa§n§.Eé'f-Acczﬁeﬁ E~én:.;.2, 'ifazlgéﬁ 3:33

wént ba<:i< {Q the beﬁ mom;----a.E0n§w§'t%2A _f:f'"eé"'+<::§"2§§é é§f%er""%vaEsh%ng

the teﬁevisienf ﬁghtg Es": {he beidé sféémVlwéreL§£¥§V£"fa§£*;'_9é off and ghe

déé mi switch an; :.:ﬂV;i§__gi§:sQ.;:V$§ d::"§%;o',.2 had given ﬁéfferené:
reasang befa:ie-ééff§':=§§§§':;§.§rs<:§;;; §*eE? A§'x2:;~§{é§§:§§:g 9:': the ﬁghts Eater:
A53 .':ZZ§3€ €93: :?s.;§"3§n'e§$s i3'9'§'.$l'<V,:_:::$;'§'Vj§_:€hﬁviitﬁhaé an {ha iéghég arzé
anéiﬁer mama s.}?i;sa_4$::.h;$  'e.:2*§;' VaA2'".:_vi"sx:"é:."~~'Lf::> Chgrzge her mighty; 'E§¥8§'€'?€"}§'8

$%"ﬁ*é..Vgm:§§c?':.V:;¥.-jﬁ 3:': the §E§§"Ei§, .1: hag afsa/;~ came an E'E£$§'ﬂ E§"§§'GL§§§'§

diff;-€w:r"gs§2éV'w§V:m--3sses:.._%fea: Wham ghe came Ea Tseéwaczm am after

:."».§g%ng  553$ igéeé :9 ia£%< 5?; her haggbané am $3

73:33 $76 rm: %5e;§§\}';5.%2é ihagght he was 535%;

 §%{ZCE£;'§~§§ %"x£§.2 §"§%:m's'":%é $6 552% ﬁﬁﬁ {@3322

3§1;?VT}§'§-§§?%§§§§_".§ ?°iE£" éﬁféﬁﬁf Chéié, we i«E'%§%i§§§ exgeci $39? is %'%f'=£§§i£§"3 $5:

 ag she iéarj 3% gségae 3:5?" shééé  3% hm, 32.3': 36:58 aﬁéé

/"L





 

. mv-.:.:'..~+-«?:v:;~..2.- I. 

34

not ﬁg $0; The €\f§d€{¥C€ af 9%? 21 A <:éQ$e friend <2? :4?:vé 'Eai§':2§§'-g

fmm ghaiapur irsdmaieg there 993$ an ara£ arga:men:..%§ét:%;'é§n.T'tfaé .
ﬁ€§C€E3S§é Aghsk Saiméar and ﬁccasgeﬁ §':3e>,2 --» §3§3i£'§'2':°:§%{--"!iE ??% Sn, {Eye 
Raéiway Statiam at Sheiapur as Accuézsgd §f4Cg5Z: &i'::§§::~§tV€e::i"§%§'s.§:é':fs:;

§u§ba:'ga befare gmseeding 'st; §3.%':?fIta§ %§:'§;;'s'~:% »v£:ﬁ'+"§'&:er_ se_§1:0::5a*_ "»

C§"%§§§, but the deceaseé Ashok Gu{§':;t:e%:§a;§r irés-E5;:;;ecE': hér ta» QQ
straighﬁaway E23 Eangaiere  S.éf9:VoE,é§3;%'7:.:--«::V,_~,:T'E1£_s woufﬁ guggest
that deceaaeé 656 mi want §"§€ Ff_"ﬁiO' §§:s§*'E§=a;.%g{31_a'€ ihat time.

3%.. FW 45;!  the muse sf $28
éeeceaseé ;é;s§':r'.;§<_~.{'";:?'{;i'~':%:*V:'§éa:§A;:;"gii::=an"{§'.V»Aﬁ4§f€{2§'eo*'-'§%}0,2 -- Pmmavathéi At
the age Q5 zfwegrsg  %é<:;:.;§€ 9? she ﬁeieageé as a
gerazani: at Sheéaqmfé:.§éV§f,ﬁ2 ._%9$é:.'§@t marréeé E9 is :1 'years after
?"E€_.;E5.j<='«'AE3"'9°§V_"?"5*';:.?;'€ f%*'%'i"'*?f3< ?V:f»'?""§i:":'E.?.3..._;?3.r:;:,é§€ :3? éfize éeateaged, when the

 l  he gentinueé héa jsﬁ wétfé éhe

'.'= §%caaSea:é}' 'airs %'%";§j---§"2V{I":<=:s9§e_; agar: fmm am daaeagad afsé §3;£€U§$é

V'.:;g1§,2--¢ :¥?*aéi%%2»':;r;aé'i§:2&;t§é%; ¥"'{E§§§'E&§" 6? 'ma éeseaseé égihaéa Gfatteéasﬁ, gar:

;;,sf:%§:€§=:fé::'&ase§ w Abhéiagh ma swéwéé, iataéégs five g3&;"gasz§ were

 " ."::§::_Ve:'eT;.- Aéé' ﬁaaésgéé amg égéng axgése fjfﬁféifaiiig $35 ééza §§¥¥'"%€ he

' "~.:r%;a§"--«gj:*é%:;:.s:, §€£5:§§§ af ?z§'§§$,, he zsgeif is asésfsé: §:_:§%a:~g§ gniy

 

 

.w:semmamwwmmmm»mm."mm..... .



22>.

40

the ﬁeiaﬁs sf séeégﬁbsurg iike R£g§e's hmsseg ?:@uS$V. jei'§._"_[a::.;":&

Lambani eta. He z-was rm': gum abmsé aha namé :22? §i?f'2~%%'_§sé..3t'é'a%Vi':j%*:~.§%'23$' .

émééagiﬁ am ascgrdiag 'ta hém, her nazéfgg might":38.1§%:s;";é;§*:é.:haV; 

Severaf questéens vaere put {Q him iéke %2{h3;_w&;%; t§=':.;é Gi?§?'f?€_é*'%':=i;-ff:%"7?f._~ﬁ

hezzsa air" 3%, Aréitha and in v¢h%Ch.:ﬁ§r.g:t§e§€éj:?ie  Aa;j§:)£:'zV;r"::.29' t¥'ée-- '

image 0!' the tuition teaaher ﬁg   tiféig cre§s~
examinatian was with the E§%fE--.i:fz"i§7"{}f$?€% ._$u$pE<:%r3r: in the
gvédence af this wiing=:_$s. v§:;.f. _§§1Eh"V-fgigﬁ ".'E;-.G.o'¥»;§r§§.%:E'.§'"§'%g this wiinesg
wéthgiieaé tha Cmsg-?;§§%:é§§'s%%'§r;a§§§ré_$%'%§_. ég:é'%%éa§:y éiscéﬁsed S3; thig
witness; theugh   wariéywése enaugh
ts :;:'1é&r$Ea:"?e:r%9.?V"t'%%;e _Aéa;>f:;-@;;%_;'g.VVé:n«§§""E§§§:am5;::* sf asvéfg 9? his amgiayw
am 'me ﬁe%Qhx:é%3§z% ;*'3'%C{'1é;»E§€g§'.§ '%"'é»§:§;'«i:'?°V.'.§L.§bhaﬁﬁ 33$, Theyefmre the
Eeafmaﬁ 3:_:::§%s3   giacimg reE%a:":C% gm ifse evédenge sf
?'a;,»g.«E..¢f4'\a.  ':§;3cfi':3.$ e  Eniémaiy §€EZ':fJ€E§"} ﬁcaggeﬁ §\£@$..§;

am 2~.:x:aé§.3 %§¥e.§§'jv:»{§':?éV§.:"f:,V§:'§':e ?<nc::»w§e§g§ 0% métﬁer sf Aaguged E22933;

E'v_ié$*:%;*e§§ a§*--.%%_:i;§§i';~a:';§'.~'§ €" Agaugeé F2592 {:§$fZ§$S€ﬂ égimia Suitéﬁgrjz,

"??:'&.__Vé:»ﬁ§g.@n£év._.5? ihég witnesg €5§'%%"EGf ba brzgghm aséﬁie as

 =. §§:%::*«::'e§ii§§'e.._a.s}; airéaézz siaéteé gasgé §§€ﬁi..§§€ ha wag 523$ &%bE& E3

§'°%..a?5:::7":':V=%i_yV_§;2"_§i:$ a ggwat in :!%;%f'§§?;§§""§'E §Z??% gigtemeﬁz bsefera the ?@§:"r:e'

«sézaiher 3? &%:Z£L§$§§ §'\§{},§. wése was exéméééﬁé ﬁﬁ ﬁiﬁﬁwﬁié §"%§§

 



43

genuineness or atherwégé ﬁf the rgiagﬁeé sanvematém ﬁat-:3: GT?

vshéie sagzsééeréng 335 game fag me :3? the airaiumaﬁaﬁceg

{he acmgeé §a::<s@r':s* But éf s-we g§es:;m& fm a m$r:¢{é':%tv  "

gasd aonvergaiian wag between A€C§£S8€§:"?§CS.i --}a:":d; ";E-,,VI.'4:%:'§:;<Q;.:!i;§..

dafénéijefy refer :9 Sgverai facta §s':c::£uﬂEn:§ 

the Aacuseﬁ E"~£{:>5.1 and 2: Frorfe-_V_tE:.e aaéivzg-_r$aV:Ea3;"°:;'r :2%;e'~Eéam "

there was ghygiaai wntact i:%_t'ween z3;:<f§_;E;¥;»§g--:»s§ €'»§.Qs,i agézgfi 2 am it
even goes ta the axient af s;;_gg1e_$:§'é}':g :»t?2«;atv 't:b<£e; fﬁecané chéid af
Acassed $49.2 ~ P*;ad§:}_;éévaiE':_é ~ 'te.._é$ 'sham' in the

C{}i'iVEE"§aE§GF'E sf '----t§2'e'é"':h'§£ri Qf Accuged f\£a.:.

Lang £m":'».ie2t$fatE['e'§':'~.j%.x§::m}%é;7_ ';f2.§<;:;$edW'N03,: am 2 fmmé :5:
$ev@:"a§ gageg"-Eszﬁ-iataisag'"5§gjc§T:;::2:¢Ti§~«fags.1 was gaszgiantéy in '§§L£C§"$

with A{:C:s5ed§ §\§$§',Z.'/E V13'-V.;i:.,sb;;§..s:3a;{:e:9s":'..i:e the 58%??? $3? the aziéaeageéi

§iz{:"d'§3;., *&;é'é§é:n2,."2~§§v~- zrms':'§i:$":1}§""'ia5ifie§ the éeaiét af awe aiezaagecé Ea

%<r":mz%é'x__.ara%'§f:af£'~%%a§§gi§ené:*":§ its {ha gmgerties am aha exqiae

1. "i;a;;s%:2eg.§'.§§é ' i§f*:.§":' 's:§_.&'$eas€§: $3 5 mgtier af faci §*'r§:':*': mg

-- :j;;,%..rf%.x;5e.::stg§:%5z:2;Véiae wsiséé unﬁargtarzﬁ ihai 5;C€Zi§SE€§ ?'x§ei'.;n§. wag

 {§§Vé;~war7:§:V'_é::f_>€"'a{_:%§ am €'=J8§"'y' §§"$§§§"§';i 5:2? §€€5;"§§§¥3 §S§"Ei§§< Szsiﬁﬁar

' :%":';-2:.§ éx:§s}':  wheré iémge §§"§§€§'§'i§€§ aw géissgaiaé, Ag 3 maiiar 3%"

 :e€§:"§ is %%':Q $35: @252: we a? 32% Efﬁﬁﬁfiiéﬁﬁ zssgag agaérég Ea

 



:35»

 

:::éz2'%.s§;":c§__:<%g him mat 33:8 aswagéé mi: miaﬁ fénéghmg imam {gig is

?..f::;:;>',:;%.k.."§§zz,:aI'%:§=:,%:"*: amra :53 grége,

44

ﬁe rmtéféed to Came in the munéﬁépai iéméig and it wQuEdT'V.f¥eiV:h

gagd mice: Camvergaééen further rea:aa§5 the i:":te:"ai%§§'%"<:s§,j§--3.&.;%g,{V5 _

- father sf the ﬁaceageé to Uansfer aﬁ Em §an:§_e~;r§-..§§fﬁ::V;b%e§~§?a§eg   '

the name at' miner ciiiidrezé sf ﬁcaasségsé ¥fJ.0 .A2. 

aéésasaseé abeut the ﬁéfﬁcasitées is .§e§E _r3§*o;:a%Vtgs' é;§_V_.efj:ﬂée 

mémrgk Tfze entire mmzergatéozz 'V%e;§;ea¥§  ¥ﬁg3,2 was
mséstﬁng far sale 31' the p:*c}ge-:?:§§f;§\,f..sa;§V§V:;:'::_§'VAsL'I42:e_#§5Le2d p:.,aV:;ﬁ?V1:a$e a ﬁat
at Eangaéare and the 'rest s§"_:f:fé'<::r}e ?,%_V;a'i§%%%..~.%§§L§._§§g_'ggpasét in the
bank 39 as ta mee%?_"'iiifax:f'ek>'§Eé%;3§%?f$.' :0f:_"~é%iﬁ}'ta~:--§§:ﬁ cf the ithéﬁdren,
Sag wag Eryéag  "'§7t?%é§r¥'i§:»§aw in the abmze
fa§E'3§@n as  Qanversatiw betweeﬁ
;51CCi.§:§€§ §'s§«:>§qﬁ;' a::"2:§V  %'e§&s"' {G we ﬂan haw
Accugeé E's§@A;<£--.E xanL§"2._:%{veL§'Eé Aé-§.-aﬁ iévéng égsrgeggraiéwar afiar me $329? $5
Eh:-éV'VV§9':"a3r;e'§%;§  %§'g.g§§ §é§V£:fi%§.% a{E as change a?" E<h&t§'3a 5:35 irangfer

Sf EﬁieL._§%':;_g3'ér€:%gf'»«*g§££;{§é"é€ i3%<e game iéme, The Canvergatéan refeys

 . §:::".s'§@:;b:$i .§;éga:<a"i%§é'§ éC{L€§f&¥%£$ sf ﬁiaasseé 6:39": '$3; the ¥C§'§§§§§"'8;f°§

~%:§.ii"j -;:;g ::;:;.%§&ﬁ E'~éi:;,<_25; Eéiézen ﬁasusgij Na': emresaeé $33155: vséwaihér

 4§%ﬁ'e'----§"é;--%3:; ':_§°_:é_§%§:'er: zsmzjéé aaiagt him G?' 528:1, &.€.t{:%_3$€§ E=a§§¢2 rggﬁeg

9::

%£:f§':&:*: zéigmgaﬁ fzéasi a3§<§{§



 

§
§

 

 

€'§'f\.

  

 4.  1; - " :~. - { 

45

C§i"¥"r5"§'1§tt€*d the crime, tfwrefara it may ghanga ::;;f

énvegiégaiéaa. ﬁméugeﬁ §'~é=::>.3; raéseg i§'%§$ Saab: as 
given ta mm by §"2§§ father revea§s §§':ai_§§7>:}se ieééé'"§:é:"§éér:s we-sf_§ 
net capabfe of cemmittmg any big créméaé §éi<:.~:,~°«'.¥i?3':e s;;*sr'1:E.  a" bV7'§'a3_{°;§.§i§»*

and aéé their astévétﬁes were reyrirézjgeﬂ  te_'313%?" :§}E§V§gvgeV§\  "%*h&=. 

cgrwérsatésn aim refers to the fa:{::*{=.V',V§>;f"..V2ffi':":s:3i:tf**:e«:"t_§A§":§VVf?$§s:er Qt'
AC'C:J§8Cf {$9.2 remavmg   érrgfazdérég the
pﬁotagrapﬁé sf Accused E'é@s,}....{=3:_:r;--2:i 'wﬁjhen ﬁutcuseé
§\fo§2 askeé ﬂow"  they faumﬁf
Acéuged N03:  §he afso chides

Acitégseﬁ £\§G, 1 §sf§'3'3K:§I . §'.'i.1€ vV§§hGii'§C§".__§'§E%\,f€: been c:a:'"$fu% ta remavg
&Kf€'?i§?§?§FE§ an':,§u§':'§::'§&  gamewhere aése mfare hé
£:&me {@§G§3§§§§£' ::§"é%g..,;::e;é'n.$ 'gagzzre he 3&5: ﬁuiharga E0 came ii}

E:£;:§a§.a;*e*f;--..{' 1-."'g';¥::;%;..Aaam:"éVS'§?'é§ E9 Agctiazged §'~»i{3,3,, he wag asnfiﬁeni

€i§":§€:%s§,.§':;§i%'z£§§a:_A§.ﬁ4VA§::x§§*aa*:* saarcﬁéag héa E'@§§T°§ and émékg iﬁ féné

  sa:*2":§'af:;é;:§,- ~

 Téhaé. F<:::%1r':2:§rsatE%3§'; f%;§¥*??"s€§'" rezzeaég: awe: ihe gaﬁm §'§"s§§'"§<$

 §_'%§§é--..:*%:»z5:;;¥j'3 5525 Ezééé @"%ﬁ§§&;'"é£% Cf}§§€€'Zf§§ E3: iifza i§'§'%z*'ESi;§§<3§§§'§§

a§:;;éj:;~::;z:._::f:*: 3% gééajja, "'§"'§2;% CQ§'§'*a§£???§»&?§@{'§ §L.§§§€§§:£ 352$: ﬁgsuggd

  

 



 

"  



  

48

Quitieéaz faméisg very b@§§§Yn Their aamrergatign aéss refegg ia

Ehe fact that éccuaed {$9.1 taught her éréving, S§"E{';§§EEI*""£§-'--.__€".'iC.

Eame Csnvergaiéﬁn miween we ix-«:§ ig vagigar, 
Endiaate, much befere Aqcuaed N32 Eeft ta  V'
gacend éeéévery, the éeceased ﬁstmk GL3-"ct"é<::%'a«?f 
intimacy between the twa, T§'§€VE'éE3,'fGE'":§;é«V..§"':;"'%;A'-".'2z§.%"3Sé§§{';§%§..-.'t§3%§ﬁx :'g.éé-:.

ghwié straéghtaway ge ta Eangaiﬁfe-v..§}%'$:@a§V.offv%--sé:§§»{:§'~ {§£:?§$rga Q'

iraspite 9'? she §ns%s':ing \!§S§€E§?g .§L.E§§£i'f'§§V;_ '  @§?é:§'=z3n»::$ Gf PW»
21 mggests thig am the ev%d:é'r{C;z_':'E'   aim revéais
that the éeceased was1§x;§rareﬁzéf'géﬁﬁsé:Vé'r€£t'§::f:";VaV'cg;§«ééiween the {Wm
The ccnversatiam;'é§ 'j;:f%%\:~5%é__éigéigs_§~~..§'§"f§_n:§'%:§E:3:'érzdécaiag tiae metive
fa")? the m:,.::"d?§:::r~M.,§';;§.ifi:rf;éé€;:.'.?2a$e,;§'§g£;'s§'é«=:~»§:::tieda:: Thﬁ carrduct S?
the accmgaé :§. @)§'éf_e  9%' the afeceasaaf wﬁsuici
csnfémz i%1efac%;'*s:;?§§a:;v:'§%&§3}VA;2{é:=2:§§é§ is e§Em§ma':& téze éesaaaeé ag
%::§3"w af$  %:"§ '%:§1s.§.:f.._.§rz':§macy ag he wag aware Q?' {heir

és*::§%':*3alg:a;;?'a~:2§'a§r%§£%§§é:3%2ed them. ﬁns mag amaze the: éswﬁeﬁ

' =.__Ef~E§.2 §?.:§;:TsE:§  E2a%..::séjjg§.EFa;<3r€€é her hagéand and marriezj Agcasseé

 if %'f;..2;§a;1_§ SQ, aha wmséé §'}§'a»*'§ ﬁgs: we §'E§§ﬁ {gm ha? tags;

'i.':;:%:AéE:;'?%"%;%€7  zfxéaié

2

$3 gmgarégy. "§"%':§»3 $§§$§L§$§§{}:"% Eaiwﬁm ﬁaamgéé

" 'Tj§*é;a}§;': é§§"%§ 2 3% §§:: ﬁss §a§§§:E*m:2é§ £§$'E'a:'€?8§§§{';E'E §%"':§E§§%:&$ thy?



 

49

haé mi 0? future gians, what m 63 with the ﬁ§"C*E3@§"if';?, 

shauéﬁ sgené, §*:a=w they $§""'§$LJ§ﬁ invegtf V°~£§'1€§'§ they sggEté3;;Ed'j"é.:9%:'éx'§32?§'?\§._T' .
am fésw ghsuéﬁ they Eiva haméiy avg? af:er..,__Fhe_::%%é§f§:;é;V»,'i'¢t:;:§é':=;Aeé,_V  '

f\£€:>,,2 déxzarcéng and geztiigzg marriaé :9 £\cé7z:s::é_'t;€ 

Gf 9:159 icwe was mt arise here. ' _ 'E'-"-%:§e SQ"-sitiaéieéT'»E.:3'x§':«§'z:9.u;§§ed
with the ifiegitémate Er2i:§maCy _E:etweeV;;__tt:?ee_ iafge az:?a<s' a,§_a§;f§ taireteé
with their ambétiousrzegs far V%:?:é: 'Tg.;%<:;:;:e;{.;tfy%  i§_e{ZE£E:'§8(§ Ashek

Gutﬁedar. ﬁgs already .§;tvated:."a'E;0é§e,V"v;.E*:et§:&r.. é¥:'%%e csmvergatéon

rammed by PWw6_?1.  a:§§§:epta§f9_E_é;~_§..n »::~c£:j%<,">z9aTa{:r§:: ie with §aw wauéé

be taker: L19 gatﬁé/CE    gm tha said aéspesi

E3 géagatéve, aégtam-3§§:'a.§E-;:_V'éL;;*a::p§v:z_é<",:r2-' with regarif ta the mgtivg

wmié faéi ta §'é*t:~.:,: :":e:"¥;.3 "%"h'§é;%e§é;'E§% ét ihég siagég we are af ma
sgérgﬁan *:h';e ; '§r<33§m,:t'éa..éffé' é§ ésﬁie is &$§a§E§S§'"§ {Em m€}§§'~£€ far

§9é9;r'*:sfr':§$.s'E--*§_:'% cf fr:¥;:.;.:f§7a_:% 3? tha ﬁecﬁageék

 N[f $&mn§"s:Ere._iz:¥;:*»§'%anae i"§"a§é receréeé swarsaiémﬁ aarsa

r/X'

-2.19

§-:.?-;::%;%§é%:*: ;3.a:<:u:¢;§é §"x§*;':iS,

§;*'23v:%é§2vc:j§:?§r3,_

 

 ﬁaééégﬁié ?z"e3:§§"s:§m§ 5:? $328 taéegéaﬁnéz: €£%§"E'%.5%§'$§'€§{'.:%'":

E 353$ 2 §rau<§é*:€c an msarﬁ $3; {:13

 



%g;§%%W

 

58

§£'C?S&{LE?Z§QF'Z ﬁg we of {he mam cégaumgianzéaé a%:.~,=§~<.,£é§:_5z::eV.

ﬁcagréing :9; {Eva aggeiﬁantsg evidence of raw :'eCe:fd§_n:g ""'V-%;7{;'
acsegmd wéih C8L§'{§Q§3 ans §?'§§E§_'3€§?:§;t','.'?,W§iI_ €::}'r'?'§:?'é;€é%':;3'{§iC:r:'_' 

essem:ia§, The czrégénaiiiy 3;? me we f¥"'2'1.=.;:VS{1*._b'€_"'€$Vé'i¥f:§§V¥'§%/.:

cansidereﬁa iisuaiiyg as $3: ﬁg e><peci?T::e:v::.?-$9 $9; éfxe 'ta§§e Vv.i;fev{:<;;Vrs'§E?2g
of the wéae is dame wétheut §:ha  s.gs:v :f§:§e;jV§: 3% the
pergarz czmcerneé and :;é:'*;,.e 'géféﬁng'J§'i'é--. ' :§§'ﬁeéng 'ts*a§@eé
EEHKQQWEHQEY mia it Tfﬁerafgrez";*3§:Vyt§:E.§g';§?§"fsiVs;§%§:'.v'é§ bame out Qf
iriﬁkerv 0? tra99%_:f%.<331¢?:'::.§:%é.v%i!"r;§§§%éV§$.__§?%f§¥§i':§"'6é very' ﬁautéeusﬁv'
and carefuéiy _<;f§s;<3%é:é'=V'?i'i§_" V$e'F<:;re it is actuaiiy

admitted er 

4%, f§?;_"E':{é L.Eeaz":"';é::*I.. {}<,"37e.:r*es§3§ arguing far '$319 aggeiiamis rgiéeg

uésm'Viiéa:'VL"f:3E§;%§L€«3:E:;§g«..._§%%:ai:%@:'s$ Qhaiiengirag thﬁ aémésgéﬁéfiﬁy $5

 ieiegéié:f;%$'_;~:=fx}%e:*sR%§j~::V§ ~§_.é}::'é.;§§3%: an recaré $3: {$39 §s*§$ez::;tE::s;":.1

" 3 M

_. j'::~..,_:a;.j:§?__:§8a 

T A;:;%i§. zgagé 3: :4?

$  'A§,1'§§4f'§€ ?2
 ';::.:{§_:§?3 36:: :5?
 1%: £5 3&3

,\§,A_\ Q





gt?"

 

52;

aéméssiéie.

reatgrdéng mass: be graveﬁ $3: 3 €$§'¥"i;}€f€§Ei vaégﬁég-SV'_~--..,j:_V'1. » A4
and tha vaséaes must b& greperiy é&8r1€§f%e6,V__§:}:i?ge'?.;{:'V. L"
the featurag Q?' magnetic tape re¢<:3 r§'§'r:g. £55; %':4%*:$_.3§'§:§%42;~g" V '

Ea eras:-2 321$ remse {£19 regarding érgeailéuséré, "a;e%.:a{z3e7  

6?' this farcééiiy' G? €;*as2;:'e aif§aL:§-.__re:.:s§é:s.,_v the e;s°'§'§i§§n::E

mugt be receévea with cautiasis.;""E*.?:e c<3':3.f5'¥1:§.'::5t'°'fb§VV

gamfieé ﬁeyscmé reasmzgbie  Emt {%§e"rer:s}'d

has mt been tampereé    ; '

Tape rec3r_f€fé2'1_§ igakiHvbéf;Ee§a.V§VL»--§v§§e:§%{:'é by way
(:{;rr<}bc:}ra€i:~2g_  ._.stai:~a{2.eE%:t _ §:% "'Egjéers0r1 Whﬁ
deposeg he Carried an m&
c0nversvVafi§'an[.§i%L:f aé§}%;r'.-- oiéﬁfif':-2e $ £i'a'i;e%%"zerzt @f a gergon
whs méég d--e9§®§éV%:f::~§ft; fié'-T:§%$E§%%:£ea?é am amvﬁrgaiéga
betw@@n":»h é%%tv%Q~.  W'§"é§iZ they actuaiiy

s*:ate§f-- ifzaé  taﬁe r*'ecé5§*§e§3

 "  z;'%f§%L?a«:nV'+'aQ_<:9:s§"im§@rs':':ét3 a fcaw reaarﬁéng ﬁe ﬁe

@§';§3,«%'_éi:"§. '"'%% §';:;..&€§E§":§ 3%} reg? mtidenca, if E': treatg

§{'$.:@;3»§*:':;§i§£:r% iii?-::V§Eé W€}%'§§ K: ﬁg raéeasani anﬁ §§§"§£5§%"%Es

"??}é':.fa£i tiéai i;8§& Sﬁﬁﬁéﬁﬁﬁﬁ mmtersatim ms":

..fé:%§é 'Ta'§«.%;,§s*aé $3 $33 bmrze égz méné by iiéé Cgasri whéée

éziréésiﬁérég E{ in €"=§§{L'§éEEs"§£€a

"me {$928, §§aC& ans aacuracy gf 

 



 

$3-

Additéanai SP? reiées awn the éeciséagzwén.4:heé V€f§§§--'I,'§§"

NIRMALA .\iS. A§l~§U RAM reporteﬁ :%:?4.v2kf%G%:iV(2'}'~-:g<§';;; 

Er: the abgeate sf éviﬁﬁﬁﬂﬁ :3? any gush;

€@m:es'3atE<3;":_; {Em tape yecsrdeé {:GE':'=.!§E"E&§EQ§": ES
méeeﬁ as grapes" evédenca arm: aanmt bé ;'eE§e§ "'-_

u§$n§

5:. Sa far as ithég agpéct Q? the matter, 

wheran at §aragrapE*:«~2 it is mid aé :.é§"Ea%Ve:*: A

"'8*y Ehe imgugnfe-ai_ﬁr6§:V:"" Eréaé C5u';'§ ﬂag
rejecied 3 crave? is  §.?;g ?v;.,'dé4f'8%§d.'$'::21: to afigw
iageweﬁarﬁing his v:}&{,:e...:§;;r '€;T{:§&:¥f1Q'é"%".§;S;{}*:V'::'"'é,'V'*';Q'«s'§i§": 'W38
azher aaggéttagééé'«%;;:VE*s§C%::=._§c%:<:--V%~§i§*s«g §{éf'*t§fé.§V.T§Ea§§:?:§ff; ihé
é$famat@ry;' "a":"f:_::.%  'E~a;_'a§§_a3££§{g&V_ ' Lsseé by the
§efe:*:da;Vr.2%:._a§a3§'i*:§*:;,__%:V§f;::s.,_j'g:=§:éé:"s::«€?:._%g%~fs§s raaeréeés Twa
:;§§e{:Ei:;;ns_v§;é§vé: :f§§'§§av§§.§_iws:' tine appiésaééarz, Sue
was ﬁhéét. 5-sés*:s%§ér;'j_:a$pE.§§at'%<>r: was regfécieﬁ eartéer
and & §avEé:§_é aggi-%_<;3EfVéé§_u-égaézacsi ihe aréez wag aisa

§"E}f&,I?1Ii€:{'Z§,"'~&E"?"&€ V'siexi: s:"*:cE g§§e::i:éa:': waa that it $3 rm:

V'g;»e:'§4€s£§é'%5E::"a ::.§;éer iaw is géva szztéé a éireéiészm The

§%i;'§§;."i:ji"s§g::;%;:<*,é's*aA..égggegrs ﬁg have bear: émgiéaééy mzagv

:*é,:?§.a§' b:; =:7%é'g?..?'%:.s*§aE Cami éiggif éesaasse amzjier 'aha

e:a:*i.§é;%:%s:" cam?"  wag 3ta%'{a:§ 32%? §§"%€ gziainiéff iiﬁuiiﬁ

 ":'§§;ea% '§<%':é $;§,%§§'§'éE$§§:3E": 3%: 5 ism' aiaegé mg 3% 222153



 

54

:'e;:rea%::a«:i after the assay" 3% the evicéence sf Eng
pariéega The gacmd grmsrzé fer rejectéan of

grayar wag that ii wag in éigmgte ag to which w;,%§Eh§  "

erigéna caasetteﬁ This £3 §§ea;,z<%§:.__'a _ z*fi'¢aE'i:=¥.?{:.aE"~'

érreguiaréty cammétteﬁ by the izriaéﬁ Cég-s;s:9f§sfivx}¥;s-£'}.ér:.'

§Ea%;"'st§f§ gtateg that {he xzzsigaof ii':-e"ziefen?é:.i:¥z%,r.{t 'E§

reccrded in a §artEcu§a:r cagsetteérnd féhr'V%%2é:;+~..;:;_;"§<:yé'é"' 

0? czamgarésez": cf the yams  e§..VV'}:?r:e'vvz;¥:efeEéa?azf;:A 39:9
grayed fer 'me eEefend3:z_.i;$'_A\:'f}ic§,%V.§e.%_:*;§"":7ec0rdaé in
anather cassette fer <:@r:j;_§':«2r§rs:3é'§'ﬁV». was
mt whethe? ';ii':é ;:'g:s.3s€3§;;tagg.¢<.-. 4~;"_:2;g:Vaé gaging?
cassette Q:j..§*':<§:,.__  5e25:.§;€__;fé....3:?--sﬁei?§x;'§r '§*§%Va3 in prave
mat Ex, H4" §»»;a$'7-§éé.;_::§2é g,z4<§:"?<§é a'%1"éheI'g5iefendan: am it
wag suﬁge$é'ééj.5%;_%%§§A§ﬁVhaﬁ'c{§u§d Eﬁtuéwdlﬁna by cemgaring
"aha veéﬁe éfé?:§_ V§s§§'e.§:i§.a;L'ri:: :f;é.§:érﬁ&§ in sasgatte wiizh
the Ex, e£i»V"'C:ua's,::;;e'{Vf:3; '$u'c§§;é ways? ceuéé mt have

baangjrégecized é;::=':_ iiéﬁzie gwunﬁ 323: §': is in ﬁsubi ag is

""'-w';;;':;--%é" zg'=§:§~:e.mg;é2é':"":'asse::e. in gas Sméa gagaraén

 Ewan. zasaizh mg 296% pm}: & éaiar

'\.\\{:-¢,%'3"'

3'i§%=,:' ::§%f;~§  Ewfi, 1422} a Eaamed Sérsgié isgdge

§%a§ "'--h§§r_§ §;?%a:§": 3 ééntemgéraaeaus §a§§*i'8§QF§ a? a

V"'»r§§eva§1v?V__':'€m*ve:"3a%:£@r: %§ 3 yeiavayzi fact am ig

'  '5:§;éz9%E:§§2i2ée a;:§§er Sestéen 1? 9? im Eazééenge ﬁat, "%"%";&

%%'§a§'1}"eer gﬁé m@<§& 9%" its; grass? 3% i§?E 33.33% iézareﬁf Er:

' " -~--a7'::%a§ S 3 :':*2a§%:§:" sf éaiaéi 552$ ii: gar: $3 Liﬁéﬁ 36?" iése

§3%£E"§§§€' 2:3? i"L§%"'e§§"G§':i§%"%§ 3 %;"a£§§:E"§:;'?§S *-xiii": SE3 E§§"§%€%°



 

4?
@

7V_rem:"§e: ga;@uVi§"."_§.?sa'j;;'§§ aggégtance :3 ma Csusi

55

tam-yeaavijed Siafﬁﬁiéﬁié. it may aisa be "

Eegiiémaieiy zmeé fa" the g'.'ZiLE?§$S«€ G'? ghaking 

areééi Q5 3 w%%.:§":e$g, Ekiér use G? as': earéiar 

FECQ¥"diEE:§ ﬁatemeni, 132$ %deﬂ§i§i£ai_és3n,_Q§ i_E§ié'"'£§:§é'§§ "'~ '_ V
xzeiges is 5 £E"L§CEai matter argé inéigegjz...éA;§vc§9*z- §4r:3';3é"r».2.," é
i$EE"'§'€§§E€é'Ei§Q§'3 is tha sme qua {ESQ fa%'~.:§%e use {:'_§' ti*s:s:'
eariier tagaewrecaming. Where tiﬁ¥é"~:s:@§cé' é$.€i9_r§%':§:é°~--;b3g%' 
the aiéegeé maker theregf, § €§VmV§fa.r_%s0_»n ef %c§*:a§a§f;5ée

becames inexsitabie arufi-~..:§%;g ;};1z*c}§:»éé*"~.i_:§»e%:i:%fécatE@rs 0?

voices must be grfeveﬁ bye .§<;%.*:f*é1;§fete~s'>::5:"é=%§'§~%i»{fé:+:ss. E23
retarding sf t?::a~$¢;ig:e eif a }}§i:*§;«?'}e{s §*~bf=1;:,§..§"Vfé:v§'iE3~ gﬁgjrmse <3?
CGﬁ"¥§&E'ES'S0§'i 1, ~«sz»¢Eif§§§ 5i;a:;§;'.ﬁ" §_;é_§ ra:.iféc_a«:'i§f«0ré  big eaﬂier
rgcardeé v{§:--a'.ig7-.£5§_§j,béig ééﬁewad by the
Ceurt avéﬁd T%:_;':;s'::?? _vc§E§:'§§ar:i's§'§1 i§ .§%é§ti'*:er expresgiy net'

§:"n§§Ee§§§;ri'§'é"Q§:§b§_%i§:§f'zgé*:':%.§:*--$§*:f,§ $éai::ie."'

 FS2: ..'gii§§.§:'V%zL'~%:§":ie a:'b?::x..x§§ ggéyzgéﬁégs ire ménéf isagri has ig see

§wi:%:._Vfa:;'~s5u<:,§":=.?£€5iég3§ff:er°:%€ somzargaiéar: recarﬁeé Q": 3 tam

"$28 mgérz

 }:;E":aE--Eer:§e {';::13. '§V§.'§§§ §:§$€';1"E G? 3923 maiiég' wag that ii éa gggisifﬁﬁs is

.; --é%V%*:§'§§a;:T{e"ax<::--.€§e$ §" "'§""?2erefm'$ ?%;"2:'~6'? being 'me eiéai' émiézer §f {he

':-Mr

A'-4"_V-ﬁeaé.-aﬁjﬁg, ézaséih am uiigrésg msiéage ia aiémémam we éaissgeé §"x§asV2

::sii's:,.%%E9g§ %*$r:'2 5&8 gééaiurﬁ masié EEEVE C%"E§§i€§ gzgah %§§§p%";£;n%§

*.._./ '~
'M?
,-'/ ' "

, ¢<.~:«:w/--/>.~"'-"-M 



 

S6

mnzzeygaiiaan, in sther wgrdg, ﬁﬁﬁﬁfdiﬁg is the a§peEEanf£VjS ; _f:§iE*:.$
{age-~reCaréeé evédenzg ﬁg {ha hanﬁy :.:-*m:*%< G? ?*.:':.I»§?.  _
the C323": has 'cg ﬁe aautéeag and aims: E53acceg;%:%V:%§:%4_:f;.%i7§'A-.§é..Qe¥V;
?EC§fd%'53€j exzidmca The avidence 
iyzﬁécaie by mégéng a grivate ce:":":g3E,~:::i:=°2_: a§: zfaJ§r;.ri 
this tapemrecoréed mxiéerzce was  aVe'?2'--:'jf:e<':i<i:>:*::i §§  sém
argument W83 advarzceé tha': ;:§§g'%%e1n.'_%Er§§,§Aa':i:'*;zéErase %} als:AVVpend§:zg

at Mahaiakshmipura Psiéce $t;A;a.%.i9:n-.Va£v._VEVan'§'a.§'§:9ev,.éhere was :10

reason far ?W-6"?  3:%"--s;e€Ffj_:é'%: §_4:"%r'~;,:«'Va1:*:Vf,5»'«'*_i;'~i*:--*.--*:~:+i§'*¥:@Eaé§":f: at Aiané
am tﬁe fact t¥':aj:t,_$35;jé§§'{:eeﬁxiliézgéii' °pﬁaﬁte camgiaént weaséé
méécate thatijhe_!§£:'32%'r--$§V_ ;a;,§   an remré the i:a$e~
reiaréeé :ag3e:*§:ie;.$g  51?', me a:<§§a§':até@ré ﬁf mgga.
é? gr %h§§ ~§'s';;u;e  ;*;;h;é  aha: he wag agg.:re§:§r:s%:;@ 5:?
¢a::§.;;§le§:f:e3<;&:§a;in§§:"§§2§%.«§§ thé§§'§?§«;ere éimgiiy hanﬁed was is %§%se 3%

 §vEa%;'aA%igeE;{$§%*z_;"%;Tég::::Vi;*';%;_V"§?§§.§;:e ﬁtatéimi Tﬁerefara iﬁraugh a grivate

=fiVa':s%_g;§aén:',;'««._§2@,___%§§':;,tsL§§i%';t mesa remrdgé aagseétes ﬁié §"i':3£i%§"ﬁ, ?h@
""f:;a3:%-__rér§f:aL§:2g; v€:§":t'&s"e was my segaraie érsvegiégatém': §$ 3336?: an the
 :g_§*"z:9f:?A.;§a§:":§ 9? §%"x£~é? in iiéée Semi ﬁf 31*»-*EE£i 5% ,5:§&§"%ﬁ. Even

:*%%§'E":@:V:§;;;;§ie 52%: §vEfa§"2§§a§<§%:m§§ura§§: §€}§§€ﬁ§ ﬁaiésﬁg zéaaasseﬁ §'a§§i2

 '-§*§§.§' ~§:'2§§&§ m§*r:§%a%n% éiéééaaimg ifze ﬁ§§'?E§§ :3? E-%'=»f%§'§§ §€?:':§"S,~"~;%§"§$

ff M

.. kg?

»/"'



Kxwiﬁ

 

5?

wém mum be 232% cauge af death sf her Ezusbariﬁ Agézgk ﬁutteaar.

mug? was mntempiating Eaﬁging a ca-mpﬁairﬁt agamgi A{:£;..;_$s§

ﬁgs": aészé 2 fang Aamzseé N952 being the c§m§¥a§::ja';é§'<-._;3":'vvA
Mahaéakghmipura Peiice Statiam gmbaﬁiy he 

gréxzate cemgiaént he wﬁuid be a§§e té §§a.:e::%34e$ei 5?§f'{4é'*:?:V;:§§é'e,i:§s'}-._ 

in the safe custsﬁy of the Court 90 aséW'::::::..'_Et:3:'*EV:'*:g"~2%§§e:..'.;*<a.Eé?;;%:a:€¥%»f

mateﬂai on recoré. ﬁsnather reaps-sag-..._gxp%éS$e:i_$3; ié
ivﬁahaiakshmipura ?:>§&<:e :'efu$.e5~;c§ to Asjes;§fr*L§§_ §:'§*a.,e;. f:§%t'§'zé.:As:.§temmt
3? Pwwé? arzé tmrefare he V<%'.éV:s'.':1r.::E§¥*;jhe:' mmgiaiﬁi
améer SectE{>:2~20G Q.f..€;:=§.mén.§'§V' the Cami Q?

EEX/Wig Aiarzé a§0r:§:~:1%,é:§:~j;._:§é.«g--':'--;a'3$$:%e.§'.  éeameé JMFC fﬂfﬁffﬁﬁ

semgéaiai E0 .i:'%'=::*ev .§igE's:.r:d"';?%§i§»§.i£§Vu.¥i:§ééV*-~~§@<:%ésﬁ~1Eéiﬁj 9%" Cam 5%
§:E"§i'§"§§E"§E'é§ ?*:"::*;:::;e:'§'a:4%%  am Eihé E3{;:i§:_:a after
regégzerérzg Em 3%-%g9§m'z::ffe:%_:"%'€;;§;<;' agairzst ma aitmsseé gergsna,

§Qf.§'%:2*§V§'§€{f§ §;:E§"§@%fig'. §z"s ?:;':§,___§fg§;;:t?v,S3!2Q@2, ﬁa 3 maﬁa? $1? faat by gr:

iéze ﬁearneﬁ Magésisate ggf sziané

@:*&¥*e:--%f' .=;%éE$;§3%._¢'V2i§v;1;}};';iZ?G3,

 f*vE'rC iviaigya Murthyg §E.Eb~§¥"E§§§€%§E' Q? %§E:::e §f

 '4.,:_'§¥§é:.§%3§<?:--s-sﬁé §a'~g~:3e.1'§ §GEé£i§ giaiésn, ganggﬁare :3 take aasgieégf :3?

 [:é:.:f:e-~:-aiggﬁiiag  g maﬁa; ﬁﬁziﬁr fgr gmafamtégn §8"§§§' 33$:

 §§§"%§&§€§;'"§. "E'§*'1e§@ £5 m&%z:er%a§ $T§'%_ :"&:§§'§ 33$: a::::§*:



 

2
ii?

$8

request ané germiggéerz for f<§rwardmg the sassetteg he {he

mncerneé Cami ﬁg farihegmiémgk "Fhere is aéga remrﬁ ma {E13 "fiée

sf 3% aarzaarrzeé Magégiarate méécatérég keegéng the £a;;:,'~;:?s€;3"f:{;':3..,'§g' V§l'g__A'

safe tusiedya

ﬁreﬁght gm record wétmui any greeceﬁuirfg 

$ea%ec§ CQVEY containing nirze c;asset*:Ti;2:~s '¢'2iaS '§'fia ﬂ§€d f§:';'€E'f  SQ Ffw?

5?"? -- Psiéce §§'3S{1)€€?.O§" fa? ma pu:*p5*s:;-*;=_, :,">1_'VV véiét',-9:_x:iciér':§é'§i§atE@z2.
The semmittai Cam": aim pe:f:i§,_§_%:<e'@   s§e c §n4E e§": wise
9? ﬁcauseﬁ N93,: and 2, Wm §.aa:.eE;e:-.;aé s§§}§y'i'§§ §AQ_%;E!&.%:§§a% cusiaéy my
mews Ce:3r2*ae'§S0§.;"g3.§;e:§r'::1:::$_'V355$:°é§§é§ %:%§i %h€----gﬁéii authsrétées is

permét ?aié<:a In3';;.g<:%;§V:;»f_ «»~ '%'x§¥[}'¥'.";'._%'<:s*':*é'§§'§"d mice sf Aamgeei

§'«iGg,1 arzé E3_a§§i§~ _~;3§§é:iaéu§n.___-sgcggré ag an €EX?§§§§§ﬁ Tiée

éifiﬁiéﬁéﬁ éadégsieé'  ;?:«7;§'§';€«.;A;':1{§?C;s"3 *§%":'é; Egwegitégaténag §}§f§€€§' xségiieﬁ
Central Eaéigazad %nVt%'-w§'g::%*'e3€'~z":s€ g? the women staff in tééﬁ Eaéé

§2:i::mﬂ§V$as'V é§zﬁE'''''%>'i;'§?~ﬁ:_2 --- :'G a *~:%§"aéa§pa arté ?'v'%;'~i3 - Saraiag Em

S§ea&ré":;a:2.['_;:€;§A§::-:é"§--«géf §%{:'.s';';'E,£$§d 33:93.1 am 2. aiame is be :'e£::>r§%$ $5

 §§é=:>4:'*'----€vE'%Z."7%$,§3s.a~s*{§ :3" Aégngwith '§§"%€ gpeamen 'e:'QEi::&S §"€'C%i"§€§,.

 §'a%§:{g:::é}$$e%:€&§ ﬁﬁiéiféﬁé {mm 'JEE ;a.C,%'vE,?vE. aware am: is iaﬁiraé

§~::'%}%°i:f::2»$é--:;é Sséarécé iwgisafaiwigf Eeiééi, £5 {ﬁe £5'-migai ?a:*e§z$§£

'« ;j"~;'c:"§§s"°:€':§ L§?§sra::ss";a;, §}§§§"%E exsrggges §:§'"§$i§" égzawéég %;:::: give g

She teiephﬁnér: mgzversatian  j;u$i§'

 



 

E9

ream": an ?'«'%e§.l3 am 14 an mmgarégen wéih ééasiiﬁ iQ 2ié"-'!.:f:'E"Vr§.§"1€

::&$sei%esf; fay was? 3? iranggrégtiazé sf cs}nves"sai:éQm§] 3'§a';fr:.
Emesiégaténg Crfféaer 3§%Qf°G3€:§'E&€§ 'she Cam': 5&ek§:*2g:"'§9i:%';?"2E'§S§<2;: :9 

get the expert Qgmmn 9?: She $a§d méf:@rEa£A.frém.' 

Heayéng Eragtitute, Evixggerek
Caggettes aria the recoréeé cassettag'=;%§"<3<:%V§;cé'é"§V§{ §%.ﬁ£Vfi§7 wars
seat :53 Sﬂeech and Hear?n':u;;._._'Ea$té-§§;::;; a:t--.._'§§f%.::Q>r&, Since the
sgecfmem smash maiegfiai  "i'4..'V§%§:V;*3'::"V"§n$asfféaéant, at
Em reqzmgi: cf Em   Sf;:;ée<:E2 am Hearéngf
ada'it%ena§ v0§<:e    éame to b& receréeé.
Agaén as $92"   a'-géﬂéviéanai ggeajémen wine af
the éccaggéé §\iV s5:::4:'*aLr:<3*T  in iii? Eragerzae of Wéw
68 323$ the §a§LE " $:£;:;:é:»:é.;r*§:"2fA:.é%w*§"z§é':§; the Eﬁ'g;e§%§§£::"§§.""%§ {:3 
?8=f§§%{Eed:  S;-,f;'»'€'-:s:'g-{2'}§3E'% 'ﬁiééviiévef ﬁaccugéé :'é::2$.:% am 2 at §"»'§e$,iE§

am i"£~.e__ ?&%As aV1e::§e:._eME"g5AV§;;:f'{€é&z" a mahazar ~ ETX,?§?, 3%:-at gerggng in

 ?2;¢=%2a:}$e §§w.::=;4;se§*:€-:3 _§ef.:-{mania wag fﬁﬁaféﬁﬁ are gigs §X$§'§§§'E€§

-«%é'g'ef:::§*§-'.:§':§ €Z::2;__,%%a agar': fmm the avéﬁasaé Q? Emesiégating

 "§'h§ S§§{IZ§§".ﬂ§E'% zzaéaa Q?' ﬁacaigsaé §'2§r::s$,: am 2 am":

5is:§a'~i€:VVa§§_:f%§:ir1;::§E $g"2éC%:?E%r': wiae 3% ﬁaiiéiﬁéﬁ z':é@§,: sing 2 sgma is

=.%4'ia~:s};:aa:%§§D  §§":&* emsengse 52*? m;a~z;2,, :3, $8 egg ;é:ci, 52$

 

As .3: -:f_@sa;Et';.V_%§*ae $;;»>;é%::§.:j:*:.r3:i3Hxz3aéce . *

5%

 



60

prasecutien wa§ abie ta eatabiish that ?»?03.§3 ta 1% are the
ggecimen vaiaas at' Aaaasgeé 51:35:: and 2 yecaréed Em ihs

presence cf the wéirzesges zgrsﬁer 3 mahaza: ére $229 ﬁmztrgé Pf:_7_i$@§":¥

"§"he;'e is {:9 reasan ta éégbeiiexze Ehis péece-A-srafl é2»ii.ciefri'ce§"3':~*:L____t%::i3 

S§€§C§"'§ :3? ACQUSES F493,: and 2 ﬂame §7s;_b 7e iiéé 

Centre? Wisen in gresence af t?3e' vL4L';y«:;§$<§.;3' §"::"::'§"2.;Vé:fi?é::ias .fg The
wﬁtnesges in whsse gresencé ix§_€i%£_e;   Qﬁ 2 came
ta be racordea have E;d;_eni§fie aE the re£evar:i:
materiaé Gbjﬁﬁiiﬁs t§":e;:t {ha evidarése at
3405.18 :9 26 53:::;Q:*%;<:§§éVei"i'éiéég PWM5? ﬂag Cmariy
Gegoged hoaf}  .cg;;:;"§V§§ersatEo:2 ans haw the
casseiiag carziﬁfté £58'  msgeiteg da mi: csniaém
:t{:s§§:;.e :3? %,m*;!_  éséiééng §?>':ﬁi»-6*?  §'¥§S E'_'2L§§§":§SS

§r:::msia'£E:i;éf: §§:32é:*e.'5 ﬁzggt <3? hig bL§S§§"%€$$ aaiig wguid Se tﬁraugh hig

mahééa 3:36 ;f:;v$' :;%.;#.3'%ééf:f'e:V:9:* am tea yazmg 7:3 uaa the gimme. HE3

*.__ é'%;*s:Ee:":§§ '@%_~:c2uV_%s3?' .:§§%~*fs§:E@3e zhai: $3: $29 Qriginaé caggaiies vxesa

,\\%f"\;'V' . 

"  §a§ev:*.;$' we Cami.

    "§"%:§ Csamt ms :3 age ::a:§*':aE:§*:§:' ihg gamge m" §§&{§%"'E'E€F'§

%%%%.g;m:%: §§E'"f"%§i?;€§§'=; Qeéaﬁgémg %::::2 ﬁgﬁiiéﬁéiﬁ §2§:3;'~:;:i am? 2 wmgéé



$5»

4_i:,i'z%iiiii'ii:5ii:éaii"xiii itiie i;i:sii:e

61

match with the mica aiieged to be vaicas <3? ziiccused N95,: arid

2 in nine Qagseiteg §VQ§L§{:€éi "Pisa ?€'8E"i$CE"E;}§i§i"'E af a§'i5,_"i:%/fie

caggeites are at E><.P9;Z is mag, Agart ficiriz 

£€}i'"iV€i"S3tEG§"¥ in we Qassettes, we iiave gem t_?4'ii*<.iiig;jTE*s»v

CGi'1{€i'1'{i§ 0f the trangciiptiaiis, So far a$~~i:i'ie i:"its,?:e3js§ii5g§*iji:ia:':":,'_g3.;ici:_ 'V

the axpeifg €)p§i"1§QE'i, we note that ?\J'iiw6:{}, 8:"'Vc.s'i'§::i{I:€"'.;:@:§'<Z.l'§Vi'EE"'t'.'Vgﬁﬁ

§ECtLi!"'€f' iii Aii India institute sf SQ8"€:'C§.§ and?iijiéariiiggi/if,§§§rejiiéé

giveii the Gpiriiaii regarding ihe ¥.2'§§ﬁ:g$J §:¥3 _:'E"'i€V"S§'<';.'iiT_'V$%%:§7v§€ ifasgetteg
and éisguieé Cagseites. !1(I€;;I5.'i'i'§Ef"i§i.?§{?«'VA vii,?1_§,.»V:e?~*.zideii<iéA it}? §W"6Q
Rshini ~« 3 voice exgeift, Mesiig-gA§;§'§';':§g6the Siifféﬁieﬁt
SQEECE": {mice} G?3.v?§'"i€i'i'L'«§€§:';%'SG§"?i»§.:...'iQ«. "§§?:§"~.V§.{}i;Vi'i§3!'"€§ with the
i$§€§§'iGi"%§C isaifce   ﬁiﬂﬁﬁfﬁiiig ice her;
$§éEé§3C§'§ ¥"i'§ﬁiC€§§:?"§v§§mVa'§'§igiiéiééégiVV£i}§'E€ig;i.ifi§'S"§iif.g"?"3i'€I§iiS;E£§ §i.ie,2 aiié iiiateiia!
ai Ex.§89{'a) if@iéifig$  Sg far as iier exgertise,
it iias came $3-.._Vi*@g§ir§4 isi%is"i'i%9i§' eéziitaiiamai Qaiaiiiicaiisii she
§@§.$$as§@§;,.§:iii§ii.:ii:e éT:»:..§::,5:e:Vi"Eeifi:u:e giie izaia §&§i"i€§ iii iiie Sijﬁjﬁﬁii

Sim i§fai:i=i.§i%:~:i"; 1'§i:§"'si'iE',':'¥'"A§'.$'§<§ﬁ%I°'i agiiiiaii iii siiigr iwg £&SQS, She iias

 éigii§;<§»e,§§'-i'__i;iiAii"aif"~«.,§><$':vi,:i;r wag the aiigiiggisa aggiiaé $3; iiei' iié,

".;-Tiaiaegisiia 3-:i5i:gs5i.~3,«-'igiid §§§"{1§§§5i§E§E anaiygig fa: iiiéiifiaaiiifiiii 

ii'i<;i$i:.¥ mi 25 iii

:'§*§='ré'« 2
 _V i.

 



62

éamgarésen with the wise mniaizéed in $493.15 and 16.
Sgezcmgraphéz: arsafygig agaﬁéeé by Fiﬁ?' £5 we ééérsﬁ ﬁe? acsugtis
anaéysés. Sim gaéeataﬁ tar: warég fmm §'=«*§§§.,1$ is Zﬁand

camgared {she same with am vaéce at $3/'i@s,3i5 arm? 16 --$_'&3-- .és "':_{;

evaiuate the mice an the bamg ef vaweéﬁf amasssf:-3%':t$,.T:'né§sa:%s;-T '

am frécatives. "'§"§*:e amustéc para{22'V&E4§fe.;j§; fgr VE'§7e':~'._u;e;£v,:!':aI:;#§té<sn are
éuratéon, format dasratiarz, C§ig;:;._7s§.r-g;_r}e'ﬁéL;V~févL§i§":*2.;*;»,.L' w:;§rﬁ éuratiioz': and
fréatéorz éuratienk The Wﬁﬁfﬁﬁ $;i€°v,*~.§;e'"¥'.;€.i_'£'.:€?§."V§'7V?f"£.;,Ef'If"? €E"§.é §§§"{i;éCI"': Qumerténg
to be af Accuseﬁ  '§e'%éu, maregeé, aata,
Ashwéni, dame,  the mmrﬁs from the
S§€€C§"2 p:;rpcf rtErfsVa;;A  ~.§fij€V§'.§ are "é¥§ammag munﬁe,
aitag. §"§aE"§&§€, A§g3ﬁ'iege;V._.£:;§é*:'§:,4"'*:f§§aé"%2; Témgaté, $0a ané §§°:$:'u_;"'.

L

éaceréérzg :2; --%:?"f;E§ e§<;3.<=,f;*t'_,.,' 'S;':asi::%:G§;%a='a§%'g%c §§"E§§';'S§ Sairag {me {if 'ine

Li}

E<é:'§:;§s5"'afV$'é:':"}:;§:'%§'§:"7V"a~:*j;a§3:§£$ ig $59 iaiieﬁ a2 wise grin: gr végébfe

§§3ea:é*--:.V  *Ef§'s§v$ =:2f:"e'f,§§sg§ is abjactéve meﬁzad G?" ggéaah a;r:a§y$§;§

'»__A%};%§*:a;reas; §2«@:'€$;3E;a£~§ §E'"§S§'§f$§$ Es aubjeczéve mating. as per 55%
"'é%.$§A:"§;e§r*'::";eT§f :§*:.§--3" wimegs, bash gercegttasai anaigsggés am acgugiic

 -»._'&;.reé§gs$§.$"a:éé:' useﬁ in tizég Qasa $9? gewégiagaé anaégsgéa, {Eva

S:§§3§§:?7;€:E$ zx2:%§*& '%:§%<€§": fmm éaééé am £3$$§i§%S ée, Eééagkiﬁ

°'~... "-«§é*é:€"§% am §§S{} i&§E§§§":@:*s@ iageé gggggiiag ané §§'§$';;' zrazgra Qéiéﬁié

    



»2;'€<x

63

ta ten traéneé srefegséenai iégieners ta juﬁge eaah gammis
Er§ﬁ%vs'§ua§Ey. Each wag gravééeﬁ witié asseagmeat ghee': in

zaxmich they haw Eta rgceré Eheér £"§S§OE°'ES§§, The wrameéerg

were Qétﬁhg Quaéity, ram, artiezuiatéon, éntaaatécng r'hythr€:}'*~§{~:ft':+é3$
azéé mzeraéé Emgresséerz of sgeesh sampies. After .§{éc::s%E:if*2'g  "

respmsses 9? them ﬁes": traérzeﬁ ;3e:s0r:s..w~%:+::_ars3 :°eV41%s-5r';=2a§V't{3§'é.a§;y..

3L2ﬂge$ by her, the re$po:':5§:--é :AI--a:_eré t§bT£,§'¥-ai:é5£'~%%_ﬁ order m éraw

the firzai pereentage 0;? res§A0.¥:.é';es.K  :,"?i'1.'é. ﬁéifcéptuaé anaiysis

Enéésaiad that the  s€QéVéc_§§éf;: af:"':'v§'és'1§ ané ié were
sémﬂar ta ¥'~«'§e$,18E $0   gt} far a5 Acsuseé {$9.1 -

Subﬁagh ?at:_:§ a{%§E(AAX€}{'§:3"§}/QVV_%€} i"z~% jr?"'a_;g Agtuseé E2302 -~ ;Pa§m&v&tE*:§.

Thaugh {here ?w;;;:*l§_:r<:§vs:ésj §F:_§*i?.E¥f{+éE.peisgsie at M93218 to 2%; gm

gwé
%

if}
£22
ti?"
Z3"
323.:
E55
"E33
$3}
gr
{La
2?»
$2..

hag? {awn  3a:"hg;5:3S"§% ;»§;£<":ass&{§ Fig;
&5:}:a.:fs';!§ﬁ_ V§'%i'{a2E* « u$?:3«;d§"§*:§vai:E:§ eel? ané net ﬁiherg Ex,P?§,,

Exﬁéﬁ   ihe am:;sg:§<: arsé gercagiuai anaérggég

*._ é**é'g.;:é'}rtg , 'v__T§":;3'§--:2s§%i;£er%ce 9?" 333$ wéigzags reveaég $2./an EQETEQ Q? Eha

""E§§%.a'A§";*:_Ve1&.pT§@?é$§§«%;':aE$, asks am 2"e?&;":"e§ is 53 Eudgeg by PW-éﬁ

-~ ._ '§";3é.;23 é.:%..§§E":s§<§5 

 



".__A%;iés"§2;a':"$§*:é-:35": __:§$ .S'?';& 32233 §'&QL§§E"§§ :3 géve agérzian Gszégz 3-'%1§i?'i
 -»._§-«.;::é:"§é--..aé;:@::':§:5 §§€.'§<§ﬁ up at raaégm ma Eaiﬁs" the (ﬁnger: wag

 aéggaséé ﬁe §§'%{}E_i§§3 ﬁg gézsa €}§13%€'§§@E3 153%??? ragagﬁ 2:} we mésca

1......»

64

54.. Quring the creggwexamireaiigm, se7v@ra§ gue§%§§:§:§-.4:'§§a:g§E
923:: is maﬁa. She has; no égzfgrmatzim with regaré  .
aaéwiéﬁ ﬁg ra<::@r@ aenvarsgzém gr: the Eggs s*e::{3:*:;§'e,';%:*.1;"_w. '%"iz§'i§2e§; 
She had met: Eigteneﬁ MQSA8 to 2% 
neeﬁed fer Camparéssn with the' :"_§.-j_&L§"'§'}§}EVé'-_;CEé}'SVS€§{7.;%S?,g.: $V%'§V§.: ﬁg 
Eistened, She was as: abﬁe is give  Sf"é:?'s*:;:§'fi:V;;'j€I>£"%;*§¥€i'$.E3":C§G§'3
and also duratécrn of the Ca'5S:;fY.§.:..3:??3A.'  transcription
gf the speech wag mtA.§°:e£e$vsar%§_  voéase. She
hag categericaiy   famiiéar wétﬁ the
Eanguageg than   the mice, {ﬂay may
reguére €E"a§'?.%C§'§ §':§:EAﬁ:'f'§.,;v _§»F;:§é'T'  s%f;<'3W imawg even the myth
Karnataka $§'y'AE€.__C?§* %<a'z':i?%«§':';i4%:a*--,»:_fr;%'§fé:§:**%pt%@r; was ms: aeceggary far
head 8% Qaévegerégéaé-%§fVaégzs  awe": wéiéwuf: h&a§""§:"2§ :.?"i:s.E% exinﬁre
c{;;%.,;zﬂs227'z";*;.a;A':§»§Li:';.*é:r4§i?2%: ;g%._;;aa§;'§:é :a give egénészz abcaéi the mice if

§am§i§?réé»:-;f~ gA§'vvé'sf':~...;t9  Pam gpénian was fzmzégheé an the eniére

 ;E39;t%'§é'v.v:'@§C&. ﬁécsréing ta her; aftar hearireg the mice;
 Qnge gﬁméiieé aséé ﬁéggzmtéé iéﬁéiﬁﬁ we fiE?'i?'§§§§"%§§;

',5'



 sgmggpeza, :+;;4,;'§:IE,}A;.;»:g arm 3;; mssmg sag ﬁsgg,

66

Q? the suggects wouéé ragga: the threat waré by a .4235:-e;:4_§*:;f.;e<;£

teéephcme Esme. "Skis wéié pmvéde me wérniner wétiz  _

same ggeesiz s@am:§$ fag" camgaréearz mt aig{>*'~m.é:?2..€.2~3§:;:§bE.& 
mfarmatien abaut the way aaeth sgeeﬁih S-Q?3.§3@ =§§f3;3V§}§éiI€5f£.__. 5:3

tran§E%£<m ta the text sound. Accérgiéng {r3._§27e:;, gr:}i§ﬁ§§:é4r_VVto_:\§gés}a 

eaxgerfs Qﬁiﬂiﬁfi regarﬁing voice V€!'Vi§!"€T§:t§QVéﬁ3,  féfecegsayy
that entire sampﬁe in the caszéiééie  .E*& .»._:'~;=';-.*:i<9::é:~.¥ﬁed  cméy few
geéected wardg ag" S€jI'_'1§EF'EC§S-- to give the
egmien. Leng€?:y3--_:<ﬁ'%§§:s'§_:_Ae.>;;a:§§3;.rf%ti§4%::j'.V;:§é§'i::§*i'§§ witness Endicates
that the §&fe;*2ce:i'~:f:f3e4:€%"V:5€g  éhat it: was gassime ta
mimic mice _i:;§*'%%V¥;.':§i::§5<:7§..;r_'§fVA:,;4.'§u§ "Fs.s}§r»'exk&r accerﬁérzg :0 an exgert,
ﬁaétaiteﬁ micé .. 3E1{§  {as ﬁe ééffarentéateé $3;
gseycegiiveé;3s";a.§ysE_§,  E33 Ewr, §f;E':€sugE"§ eihe same is 59%:
"r::e§3:3r:V;Wié§€e §"&§3Q§'§ gayg geraaptuai ana§yg£s,
ﬁ;cc§"%9cs.é@z_-_%§3;A  car: aim be maﬁa is ﬁégguéw Ehe veiae

Tﬁﬁugh ghe

"'é}>?§@:f§'E7'§$:%z{e§'=---%E"°:§§ gigs; bar regwi égea Em: éégcircage gush

 "._:é:s<§<.*:;;E:2i§é::%;.;'é gm faéréy asméig am: aha hag 51$': auihafaé gay"

%::<;:%§2%:»....a:%% 23% aasbjeaés ﬁiw hag §:3§§w;e§ gsgrraééariigi am

. "-«:§E?§i*3i§m§§a:"§%"*§,:*' Eegft 53 waéék ":""§*:& rgsaﬁ: aﬁﬁiiéffﬁiiég 3% Easy énﬁéaaséag
/"
3:»

 



éiffefﬁﬂtéﬁ if cieseiy examérzeﬂ tug deterzmne whesher the
gimiéaréty ané ﬁgséméiaréty are due ta granunciaiiast diﬁerenaes

éndicaiive Q? déffarent ﬁpaakar. Séméfariiy Eg ?G% ané 5?is§§r;é,:§'§"aT{§ty

ég 3§%. She categcrécaiéy dersiea téwe guggestisn K333':-

mt feémweé we acsepteé Q§"GC€di3£"'é ta gév€.., _'¥j*€-if .§§~§_n§%é%*s ._"

regarding the voice. Accgrding ta hen ;§'9ec ﬁ§g.:;5Agh'1§¢'é::éa.§;a§§'é.V:A§st'

one 0? the acezmstéc anaiysis, wigigh %§"----§$:--"=.d i:<:.v-"-%3§§%€ré€i°';

acougtm garametargu

S6, The engizfﬁ that the mica
test was d:'_§ r"'ae  the gaafseraiéy amegieﬁ
j'I)§'°§€;Z'€ﬁ£,§?'8T U? r3;§<:<:s_;:si:§c'aV§é§: :V§§é§e%%§'t::é§ anaiygésx The €F}§§§'E <'I:§'"ﬁSS'"
.¢.«i~' é-M3" 'V V' . . 

ﬁxagééinaicésrfe' €;:_:.sH§ wétgééﬁs <§%',§€$ ms: <.';€;':r"n§@i 2:5 ta §§f3§§'°EE that ghé

 5:3 .;e %:'jg:5es*E':'§f§e§ the gzsbjeait Ga Eéze ather hand, aw afe

<:er:%;§A:*s-€:.e§«,§T'_t§:aii:"'-:=;:VVi?2é'j"§<:'*:e2.z:; what séza wag ﬁéﬁééﬁiﬁg aaé avéry

'g._é"%é:swa:" ghe g§:'v'e:-éésas afiez %_§E'"z§%E"$ia§"%§§?%§ fiche gagagtéerz §a,:%: is

 if Sim hag §;ﬁ§§%§:§ §§"'§8S§ ivgs: %<§r-zﬁg $2?

 f:3§ffarer2:"eix§er:meni$ may $8 aﬁgzgieé Ea iéerriify the vaééa,

25?: $9-:,%§:;.%":»:*--:é_§'é attagg G? Ehg aggeééazzig '£333': a::a:=_:':';€t§:.f' aw garassgiasaé

a?T§%$§*g§.,ég.T'ar$ mi 3%: 5%? aaggigé sxgegémafzig %:a aﬁgiyga $25

Eiéafyﬁéﬁ $5}?

 



68

verifégaiéan am Edentéfécatisrz 0? voize wntairéed in the aéméigteé
ané éisgimteé aasgefiag, we are 3? the cméném she ﬂag ﬁanéuczteé

the anaéység and %:as géxsezz the Q§§§'%§{'}f'I. ﬁe erxzpeﬁ ::aVr;"-géve

106% aggurance an arzythéﬁg. it E3 aise weéi gettﬁestf 
Qp§E"'?§{OE"E $3 3&9 iiice any ether evééence am uE:imaieE3}:_'E't €s";j-;f:"§L's; 

Court E0 accegi: whether the exgseri epérj-é':>f7é**:'z:m;§r;'£ be :;§;=_»;'§'é;a:::i: 

0:' net.

5?. Qeihé §fC{;*e:{:1S%'c  .§S a:f5e}.: ::ie __?§a.?3 €:%r 1a§':'5eF'é"3z e><pres$eﬁ étg
irzabiiity is give vf<';i?;@ii_té§;: a '§*;'af.:,?1$:§VL;<;  were me: aware cf the
Eanguage sf :.;<3nf«.s_ér*'s1é§.tV§€s_ﬁEn 'i:%i'e.._§:as$e€tes. Acceréing is the

axgerif if iT§""§$ é';;<:;_séri   the Eangasage, tyangcrigiéen

*4. ' V .
«:3? iZ@§}'a:'€§"3;%£Ea3£"§ £5; a 

E. "E": the §3:?"§S:e"r"':i £&S§, ééza exgari ig

S
a:%%g%é"a§ Véézé i?5§}u§§ji":'~.§fiy§€ éfwiianrzaéa ané when we fésien ta 3%

::§s":2:érs:air.é-:»::TA §v:ié '<::%ff§e ::a.$'3&t%€S, it ﬁg mat: éefineézeéy Em Sartgasage E2":

'v.__%?l$ §ue érs E~ii4a;r:g;;;s'%:;§ia7~"az**eé aéé §*v%;*;z§§re. "€53 Kamaéa mnazsggaiémé

 i:§':e.§%.:,2;:u$e§ Nggii and 2 Erggiuéeg gweraé iﬁnﬁég Léréu

 ;é?ﬁs§§'é§.%é.A'§«;e:r§?g« 3% ﬁag exémaégﬁ the garameiegg E}? aging

~;::.s.?§.i.:s%;are azéé Eéza Gginéam ég fuamigﬁﬁé aﬁts? asgmg ﬁﬁfﬁgﬁééiﬁf

 '*--«%5:ﬁ%'é:;*+;a::*§ E5 extzaﬁi égéze awugiéz §:°$£§gg., §'»4;@§e §§S%:"'%£€ si'

'xxx 4

 



69

mentiméng <:0:';r2§Lé'{er ggftware bemg zgsad, we gamma}: £f€.°~':~§3$'iZ£f; §*%E{'

ream? teiaiiy, The §§SCF_,ESS§Q¥"£ by the tzéai Cami are  .

apééce Sf @'%£§ﬁ€§'1€€ vssuéﬁ éndiaaia {hat £:%"2§ f::fEai C.-;j"L'i'§"7{--..§§Z3S 'E,'%!§{}Vfi€£§ 

étg miss ':0 Km evééence given by the @f>'c:_perf:;j ..3£if';?§'r~ Ei§:~§§*:$g._':'§és.::

remréed casgetteg am gang tiér€2*:jg.%; thei'-:éfps:*t €.§ae-..V§><'.;§er§f 

we are satisfied with the e><;9e:fi%1_éL:?s'»">::*<,:_~g,f:,;é;é:*;é.é" PiV'%;'\i--6G in
veréfécatien ané mice  j;}€£'Si§a$§{iI§"E or
presgzsre was b{wght._0z';  she csuéd
have Said that  the semrersatéers
with her am 5h€e... :::"ér::":V.;"5,;V_;£:   E:he éﬁentity at' ether
waxes. T?;_% E<eej: és naiurai 3:26 we find Fiﬁ
emﬁaééﬁghmﬁﬁig' _' .a:"e 9?' ma améném ihat the
easézégnm ':T;;'§*:§?§  3.53  :'e§:€;s*%s ecannei be brugiéeﬁ aséég
a§:'V;:::.§%"::i.."«'«*;V:*«éV:é':':;:§  :jV§W;A~:.=:_._iea?'ﬁé'§':Acmsnseé fair me aﬁgaféantﬂ

 sxrﬁieai wen ﬁg; {€23 €§Ef€E'E€LT€ gr? 3:? 29%:

 a:s&«.._§§":_ '€§'"s,e§'~" garage; is: the C§$E$ mferreé its 33; mg

'ia9§;é'.§'a3E§?:"2r}:$,.. gamﬁie mice wag 520% fawrziaézeé in $§'§§E" is atsnciuﬁe

i;%:*':i';'%.$'a's.%;if:2*»§%:..:r§r3:§ édazziéfésaiign sss" %i'$§€§= in Eéwe §§"€E§§§"'s§Z agﬁef 9%?»

 

E

M



5E%._

 v. "'§'é§§§<;3%,

   

"ED

6% hag samgie VQECQ sf Acaased E"»éeg.i and 2 5.3%'-..4_:'a§_§§

zgomsergatém betaagean Acmgeé §\§33.1 and 2 in mime <:a§ééi'aé1::3..,__j'  .

E9, The expert déd wine that it Eé §e35E§'§é'tf;:{:=. §:*';<:ii:aij§-::_n"=s:;=§A

'a!G§<ZEE3, bat acgerﬁirsg ta ézer, it -gar:  b§'"a$€:e<.rta§,V;":vé;_§ y%3;hér:_ »

mmparad with the angina? mice"  ,afVr':é i€§   origmaf
voice b€§Q{":§§E'E§ m sxccassed    grqergrjeicgrdeé in
acaoréance with the §$f§<:ed:,z:fe_a:T'rf::3  :2"é'?aVj{'e7:rT%';;§"VE$ farthcsming.
"Shem earning ta  21%}?   whether there is
gesgémity of  §{§:3éV§ie3 by aging mgéem
ieshnique,  H 'A V.  ' 'H 

$53. $53 'via: :33.'  3? 'me €:{3r:ver'-5a€é<;::'=':g ii hag came Er:
ifééré'v§.3éLé7;g:_ ,igyfjv' A~E?j'§:*£~6?§'% t'§§a§ jirze mcayded {ﬁe Carzvezsatian
:?2r§§§ég---ifsg  ?x§a,22§222 é_r:5§a£Ee§ at {ha muse at

 f§;*:"gEé;2§~"iie§&p§'2Q:'ze E\§Q.4623§, if; ig féxaé 3: mg haagm

"?§€:"."L*E._:V.;?§f"5i/5*f<'i"3'§"7:'1,?a...  {he siﬁamegéé af ﬁagcuged €633 yemrﬁeé Liﬁﬁﬁi'

. $@§i:,[é.é':*2§¥;;1}»*--;".3A"e:';§' C953 sf Cﬁmgzaﬁ ?§'$€§§éEE"€; aha aaéegﬁrézaééy

iééai 5% wag gigging Seégéé érs iéég E"%:'fs%.§S€ §'§ %'%£:?~»éi.? gag aigg

'$329 §_:'§:;*%§:ra§ E23533 §§ ﬁe? émségné 5: "'§"'a{,':§<a%x 2*: hag Qﬁﬁéﬁ

 



2?};

an ragerﬁ tfxmugh the eviﬁence sf Wu?-S? --~ Generaé Manager-

Tefaismg §§§'=.§i,, Guéharga, zfma '¢=:@:*E<a§ ﬁetweﬁn 2689 3:16 2&3}

that ag gas' the Fﬁﬁiiéﬁi 3? Erzvestégaténg Sfﬁcer - PW'«7f;'*~,. ha

furnished etietazés :3? r;:aE§s made from game E'-Jag.43Q?§f,f"'%$%§f?.§?..V
and 42?:?41? Q? Guibarga with éocaimenig. The car:*.$.§9+:,*§§€V§é§'é:.,:%""_4'A"
betweer": the investigating Gfficer aw i§2E'f$i $35- 
péaéeci er: regard' it has came 0:': §"'f8CG§"&'.§§:".«A.A;{',¥1éEV'  

biéis pertaining teiepif*:::;;z& E'\i@.éy6G?5 ?~..,.§*::~€=;re $.Ear;:é'En;g§'n5a'jme ''

Q2' aégter cf Accuseé i'aIe,:& E><,§?Q(:V.}-~'*{3.56j} $33 ihé ée%:ai§::4:: af mm
going caﬁs fram the saéﬁ msm'§5é;_," v"§'s:i:§',«'%3Q?Q? Stands

if: the   There are 31 mag
géﬁaénéng ta "'whé<:Ez are at E><xP?L EXW2
ég the iégi: %;'1%'.i.""'*';':%§,§§;"*§;(;.;;%.V§E':*-%v;§A{Z'&.§"ESA§§'"%%§%"'i'Q?EG§"E€ §'z§::>.43i3?{E?. E>:,Pi?'3 2:9
Ex;'§'?«S. ﬁg-V-2%?' ;;;<%:ta:;g :o "t':e=;e'fp§'2:>:§e §2zo.42??4? géﬁrtﬁérgg Er: the

maﬁa :.:§ é'::e=;_ ﬁeﬁéamaniv The a§§§§:a'{E9€1 by the fathaf

 &::c:::::;éé--.*ﬁéﬁ;f;T[ %§%Eééegheiée £§§'¥§'§€€;"E£§E'§ £3 aigﬁ gégaeé Q2':

 éi$::sr§¢  %:»:fe"' g%'et E'5§§§'§'§§"%§ in éeiaéi 36% £3? ag Em igragthgz

V

;%:§;V§£e*;{§V2»<}s":%?rggméérgaiéﬁgé gif éaaassaﬁ $95.: 39% 2 gggri fmm éiirzay
 gt Géé hsasrgﬁ Téézég ﬁg wzievani $5": vim; $2" $§af:%§:":~3%Z%

53:? §.§%f:é"'Eé"§@éa:'é E'2z"E<C§€§E£':$ %::"'1i1 Ea fag' ga E§:;P§2 is 29%}, §§'E§'3;' am

 



mmiersatécn in Kannada waeﬁ Erarzsﬁaied by the Cam: iniga Engiésh

?°3

whégh is regrsduaed ag aznéez:

ﬁr: :

A-2 :

A-1

A~2 :

ﬁvi:

AWE :

Awi :

5&2 :

ﬁ%~§ :

ﬁr? :

Q"?

AWE ;
,ﬁg;';';V
ﬁx?'

:--"' ,g;~: :

 %;"JE:;~::5g:§: ;_§@':""VV

if ya: keep the Earség, tiéey weaséé E53, 30; ﬁstan is
me, set: :9 what extent yea; can Sen,

Yﬁﬁ

: Tﬁday is the East: day, 1 «mi? taik €10 E'}'fi§}§'e abcaui  '4 

wars': Eske ta quarrei abeut it,

'mu daéng haré Eabeur T

Teié, what if 1 $3 mm EahG:.;r.  

if yam dc: harﬁ iabsmg i§*i§3§'8 wA9'és'§a:%.V !"{>.§S 0f' EQi2~§.~ E
What :9 $3 §'1(T)W. " ' '  . V .

@8335' wguid bg 5;-2}${$'§«;eé  V'  

Fm' Wm? _ _ _ A 

Fm" gig mi ;-'sg {,a7!C€;§: r§}';I:::f:%§a--:<:éu ' ?a':"é«§-i:.@E'5e;:§"se:'seé.

: wmgh §é2.§i€}fy?  %

Qzemééaé f'a?4:.:ia§;i%g?  ._ 

 $§§'E'§:<ig  }'.€}'«§.:a§§<;§3s

3%.:  -.  H

;: ::",%sa;z';§;; 'Er-1%:



?4

Av: : Mia? 'git, I am iike ihégk "fhink wfzatevei' yam' warit
ﬂu? : YES";

3. : Earn iaékiﬁg in we veéée 5;'? was ariﬁ me'
«2 : 'fag

A»: : fieié ami aét iands ~-- 88 £a§<§":5  

A--2: yea

ﬁx»: : Teié me the idea what Came i'r'V?'7:.'_".'"°:~.Vf:f"!EE'E"A':i"!"IV}('}t»E.'{?}   

A~2 : 'ﬁes

Aw: : Wauéd it: he may ta purc'i"2:;ise .3Lhé{}'a;§7é'*f§::f r:1e in
Barzgaﬁere if we 58%? at; Q? then: '  "

. >;«: 2: aség >:< 35  >+< 
Aw: : E~&<3%:h§'ng we  'after death af
that $%é man;_af§Te'§':~g{§';;g'«:.;g:A§V: ;r§f§§::u___E}a%iii_%,§_§§~;V§,,§§ take 3? Subash
3&2 : '€85 A L V
ﬁwi : "may e:a:::ré<:?;:_"i:c:sjﬁ5e** gge gas": ga: mare

,&~2__: veg  "

,:%§i~._: $?a::g:..sm:"' F§'%Q'§ %..%37.?V§€E"€Si§?'f33'{€ any we

 3&2 : iihéﬁg«é§*§7E_:v_:;_:":;§~T§éé:{. ahagé

 .ré~: .: We 23"%:::s§:.'A§3§é;%§§é%a:2i

_ §é '--'2"':.L,'§'{::::?L;af:*a€'§":§:°& égﬁre, §€33.=°'% ii agéﬁak

\, ';.,,V; V, " J '



  :

':'\''aW'  ,' '~'
,'\k'\  .-

75

'B' Siée"
ﬁwl : Si': Eiéqa th&S, iii! maméng

A»: : $§:a§§ E aak 'gm: is $5: §i'°': my Egg

Aw: : Yes

&»2 : Then what

ﬁr}. : There wmxid be Other wsrk

AMZ : Same

Ari : Vuigar taik

A-2 : Ejuigar 't:a§E<

A»: : Téii 5@«5@, :i'x§;;§§,."2;é%é;._::  mié be éoing
tha game ' " "  ~ iv

$$$$$$*$¥#$%§#$$%##%%#$#&$%$x#¥$£¥*%%*$¥$#%

$43.39 was gééé; Ex,;@.'j9?§::'.V-~._"'   

ﬁr: : ﬁne msré 'gigéu §é<§'23(:r-*%s{."'.VA"E;'*: '§fE*sé'§LaC*E$ry 3:' uriﬁieg
seamebeagg ie §%§s":g iﬁat' -;=%2zV&';--_r*g '-:mé=3"wa3 gcareé af Gutéteéazg, wag
these a §e;:"$@"n.tG ﬁt} "§":.é;j}f2 away,

$2.': 

" £2'?

L§?4"::>;§*'-T%i_Efz§ré": :§*"§*:ea:5éV}3'ia'9e: §%,§%,iE§§E' géiegia aw; arse
bQ§'f§ is §;<:a'::iié:i*s'er:'a,

:.§={e:r;,, Z $§"E"% 1.§:§"§$i séergsss,

»  *:~:}g.g§;g



iik

A~2

es: :

A-2 :

Am}:

es; :

3%:

A2 :

ﬁrl

A~«2 :

E76

: Eeniv meek them
'fee, yea eeé you ere eermg

Yes

if anything is made pueiic

: 'fee, hzmdree percent

I teid if keewn te eié, every e:'ée_ §e=E.¥V_E bee': r}*:e._V   

: I am the eersen te shake.  

Change the teem
Change the tepie
Change the *:egE;::_:" 

'£3' eéee

ﬁei

;1«%~»2 :
ewe :

ﬁs_~;'i_:

. ea

 

: whet E naeeA§eée;je;;_e;e L»--s;9g_:e§u " 
E feeé e€ien§"*._ "

Efajémyeu fee: "ee,_§f yiee sea: ee, yea: mi? net ee
"'E--eeE§ggg'r:é.e.~ ' "" "

 €3%i:V:e\E~§e'E§_ée%ée.%:  eeve gee ﬁﬁfiﬁ ﬁe yea; ie get gee,

'fee §1eveE2eee'T;;eT'e geee, eteeyéegg eiesg E eezre eeeéieeﬁ year
§:§e,._ *-- '

 "-?;F"e See: 

f "%'.'$:1., "

,9 » V'



Leave aii this, even eéaéthre Eeeu ehaéi some be--f§'<i:--:'e  *



"M ' A:«;~»«' A E"

A-2 :

ﬁ~i

Ki

A-Z :

ﬁlo}

A-2

EVE

: Year wouéﬁ be them

78

Even, I we babe

: '€'a:'§'"2*;.!
: Nawv; {my wéié write sniy we Ra§ar:2;=?3%s--a.i._§tQ  

: Puriﬁer

Keeping aii the mutatésn 3Egne é_ é'?7:_er t§é.i';xa: 
Ligaﬁé, everytéﬁng regarééng §am'i'::__w§§E be 5S<£5:§I'€--ﬁ '

: Why

: $3; thés, March, 2_3%§'i;;r é'-.Ei Ezél-ini~,tc3'{»2:'*";":$:*;'%'£%:+V~..... f«

: Aéi the §and§ §{¥§§i§.TE%:EV.V§i;;§"i:--§¢}4é':%7*§v,.f3ﬁi!;'E:/::jx'§%'Vi;§"§§'§§f€f'E; I {:an

m': seéé. -------- __ '~

: iﬁébai 1 émaiéaf V%e §'i'. '-~ 2 

wag: ta tag: ":':cgar.§i'g1§g~.éa*E.§§;. 
if ﬂame, €'xf€E«i'_ff;?{§7}§E'E§.WiZ'§§,§"E€T§ %38 aérigiét.

 Ré§%:?€§,b;;': E €;ar%:"%a§~%.f,Vf§;_g@ _§¢§«.;"2aair"E3g S8 3383 3% in their
"ma:zé;:§. ';'?s~:: :;:s-:; §ee",

:A *i:'\§'é E5 zfé Li  :T$it;3§:' V' if:~€=: 
3 : EEG 

:"'»i£?%:eré',€.V_f,§:"a%,g 33:33; sﬁaéi Em': stay there
~~i *E'§ i*1§"§%.$ me

 '2'é:j::a: 53 mi %<:"a:m; if iééﬁzz ﬁg: §§ﬁ"%&'§E'E§?E§ in ayzgﬁ its
" V. ..._%*?é§

 



 'ﬁs;+;,'?§ 'i'VT§:;§3: 532% 
   '€'"}&S  

3'L':.»*.:T.-;--«:§€...~:"§:*@ agsiu asrrggg éaéaam were ihmga ES £9 ggiggegégk

'N1

81

;::;§'

Es Eike this, they WEE mt Came befara us, because Gag?
QEGQEE have $523: faith in them.

: What mare

3:?
FM

A-3 : E want :9 teii anarthar €_i?'i§f'i§ E? EVLGA iander ég  1- 
wiié be free, I want :5 be very wait we $?'§{}LE§d"§;easii.h7'&
Eife Er: §er"ssi@n..    '-

AWE : Yes

ﬁvi : if ewrything is céeared Eéke thégf timss-9 wiéé ﬁat... 
$f€E§f3 keepiﬁg their mad iawaégﬁg me E. _ ~ 

.5§-Z : Wm are thﬁﬁé

Ami : T§'§€EE" bmt%2er$ ané iE3¥E4Ij ;;;.   i    

héc>§¢=§<$3Ié<:§<>£<>>l<b§<9mZk2< 9:=ri<>$*t=!<>§¢_.":<§' >E< :2v>.%%i_4:$<:'>%:...'=§:>i<'x':'_<"2~}<:."<"

ﬁes: : ﬁefcsre E c::3m..<2~frgzf%¥g.3éi€g3aEQ:**»si.g  'r%°se>iE.%2§r ané géstw
have ramaviw §E"_z<3?t;:%;e:, _j%Vai-i:::e:1,--.i§§:::é:Vha:e _{w@a§e:*a}

,§E*2 : Gar @3320

9%: : Yea

A2 :  %%%%% "
ﬁg: : E¥§:--%vg  gage
 mi:  w_é"§~E ' :2 ad

_f%i~§; ':':AEi*§'%3:%§r:jA§*g§r:g ES:-;:..§"'§'Qs_:n§

 



ﬂvi

ﬁx-2 :

Aé

A-2 :

Ad

§--2

ﬁwi

83

E ¥'<£§§§ gs ta sstfeams

330, game geejgfa ﬁﬁd tam a éég

: Thereafter with yea iakémg iécensae

What

: "fa keeg begiée

: GK.

: Srzce we are driving in ::«%;a:i:«:m', aA;é*-:é:@;»§§\:ié ha\;é§t3§

keeg a Eeg there

: tam, N65

ﬁg that, t%1ere:-_Vca:§'fﬁ§* a '%f"E;""53<4; 'E§:§f.§§§'{3,,i".?'ifE::?E?G§"e, I had ta
gg that  ....  _   _ ~ -- '- - 

: Leak, anywarg"E""';A;§E§[_r2:)i:"b:§;__£§10§r*:§;.:€ﬁ'ai: ngéfveftem, what

: ééamraiigs '-- '

: "€52 aéi, ac§2;s2a£_%g? avézfz  {5.§3ve?;é::%"2emt,., esztére wgriﬁ is

m:'1;r:E;7:g, iike t'E'sa_:;wvE":er:~.gmaene wha gar: £0 mmea we

 «_ %':av;;:'5~:{;} 6:3 §§:*r:e"<'z.%*z§;f_:g* _

A-:<:_

<z_Er§:§? ., 'V

: E'ét§.::z3'%2§§%§§'é;;..§§:.é%§¥:és'2§; dmzésxgi €'s.?€&"y"£:§3.%E*§§
 ii: még :*1é.:;q{:§§;e fa: rther training :3 iamgéeie

';,E'g»,;;§§.§_§é §:a§E<%n§ near, gm aha? me éewr:

 :_f§§-zéyzéa %:%:§% Z am E§$€§§§)'§gg $3? an aiéagk :2 ::::: ﬁe maﬁa;
gﬁaai am Eaiigrg ivy 3% wa%<@ 2%.

 

   



 



84

W2 : YES
Saw: : 5&9; aﬁiar §§'%Q{':t§§"%§ wa§<$ me? 3:93 we ma': iike thai "

A~2; : Ba mt iaék: smut that    _

 .:' V

A~2 : After saie, some 'US Sangaigre, take 1:;me1'f%[aiiV, §é'2:.;e"~ 
%1a§§i§§r', he said  _  2 

A-1 : What abmgi me am my gm

A~»2 : {am with yea: __

$*xxxxxxxxzxxxx$x*$%$gxx$«#¥%$x%xx%£$x#$*

§~§: Shaﬁ §§@mw§Eheﬁ§i§xﬂﬁ3§§--:¥V
%»2: we 'W
Ax: : ﬁéoi eve3r:..<;}.n:§é'~E_ €:éaifge_ "

£»~=2 : Thai: is %;2»;ha--t'1:  335 mt came here, wit

ﬁiwi : Zbéczﬁs ééjéfﬁ hé '%<.:.;;e1%~:~E.§§<:e 

  

_ A-:Q7£5gtéx:fuQ" 

 : §_E£;}§_§E;E€'3§_1;~,~'§Z:n§§..§:ﬁ${ §<i"%Q%?£

W$x#$$$x$#xx§$*x$$$xxxx$xxxx$$x*x%$x*

""ﬁév*~'s'A:.__:""!%§i wé%E"b§s'1'§£:*§'i£h&ﬁg meér ?E§§éS aﬁﬁiéi aw

"-»._"';:'i«§?2 ':&'i'*rg*'&§,  55%; gm; wm knew; aié ahsagi: i§*zé3, :*:$§§§'y

  §<;'f;8r%%i§; 5%: WE: ﬁg agraiaiéiag ihaés" héaésf my §%.§F"E§§ my
 , _M;;_:é§§€,( aéi aye cgzgégi, ﬁne mag iéééﬁg, shgzgéé E ieii

 Tait 523% E ?éa%.s'--=£*. heésaéw

 

 



ﬁx:

R~2 :

ﬁx":

AWE :

N2 :

A-3:

ﬁe?

ﬁwl

iR--~2; :

A~»2 :

86

:Oh

13 E: tima

: What

Wm wiéé $3

: 'ssifha

Before 'gem deg M.@, 'tamer

Lei: ug dc

: Thereaftar, everything wiég Ii:.§é§A;Ejb§f..easy ii:

rim {ha bugénesséai.:?;om§¢tE»::3EE~3{

: Thereafter

if not $0;V,--m~m_'E*é'g:%s$'e"E:"}_ .wc:§;:  ﬁe? %:we:3Vye5ar§

: fwa years? '- '

Yes, afiar é1eij':§€¥3*aéz':f<:~.f "§:f§:zp&:°iy $3 méraa; éeaigim E3

 ?\;!¥.;;'.a:67}'*'7'%%'*r:a§..i«ni;e:'§§4éié§ that iﬁiﬁgmeans iwéaiékaiah

 §jL;'i:i:e;éa.2fVg"*aer:%;c25'1e3:j means; asgagginatissz

_ ;3s-E

 " ».%§g§a2é st::m:,': aiV9* 

' ':V'?'@:; §§§%§§»;;e§§€a: sameasza €i§§§ '3': pagtsergf E': has gs:
"  ':;:§r§ite:"2 ax" aaééqéée

""-.i_@$§%=:e $2553: gig: kaaw amsihéngf égrﬁ. ii

" V: "fag

 



8?

A4,': : 3%, Saw £33323; guicéde £5?' muréegy as §$§:.:%*; game is 
tham '

A-2 : Lateg; it is giver': sayirzg that E': $3 a muréer, {mt 
suéciﬂie.   _ ..

Awi : when 3:51: imcsw

33:."'Z : 'fag

Aw: : Euiy 3.6:"

A-2 : After one mentﬁ

A4 : After eqnuirv gm '?'.9¥uf area" -- 

A-2 : After fassaeraég'   

ﬁr: : was t§2E_§V'9;..a;Ef'i"§V.?'v'2,ii'v'::.E:"§>§§;::_E"If1<;ETé'i::V§*¥§?¥f;:£$V%f%'€£t énfermatéasé
abazii: :53':  *  '  ' 

§»2: Shaﬁ zggagw A

A»: : "{€S

,&1i§§':«1.!;x$V$%p:::€'%§:: {:.§'r:é:.,;Cra:e%§V%E§*§'§"' 'V
ﬁr E '  V {:2   FE
 : '¥'$:§L;»..4%;:*;Aar:~;g.§c§'§%~;;a:%,§:§i;":§
"   ~»7{§;: '

 _*~--p:g»':2T%'i'V3§':+:<":;;.%}g::«: '*Q%ie§}§§'

 
 

  
  
  

A .AA...  

  



,v,»,x».A»'wwxwm~mw mm%¥$%¥%%%

>};_$'»,.... ' '

89

é»~2 : what §uba5h

Ami : H€§§C§, what if maiaheg

53:2 : Ewiif 333%;

ﬁn: : Yes
A~2 : Lei: it happen
A-1 : "Then what
AWE : Then yaur head 3:": my  "
A»: : Na E wééi not g§v:ef"ntnsciég'é$:e_§{:§:t§®.%:;;..:V;§é§ '
A-2 : Yes 1  I A
&~1 : Oh? Regggii..vg'§ﬁ'a%é:§is;§:;_t  A'

A-'2 : Z $93363-§ e'af@:~'::Vib'{§§f%V"gL4,:%:T§*;és=$§:;;fj'e; iézey am ésgéng 32$

ihese,

 A 51* 5%-:f:ejzf§§rjg '::§":=§':s5:i___§.e:fm{e; tize rams cagaeiieg $193.18 :6

26'§:f-:_V this'*§':as:-iivgk'-.-%a:§;*:::é:*§<.9?" PWMS? - €3ai'€ara§ Gzgiteﬁarz We have

7" _§Q5zsé €§H1%=<§é;g;:~h ¥E.V%i$".":;:*aé§'§:V§crigfcésns at E><;P§2 is ESQ:

"  Se ..§'7<3'i..?'":§&S E><w?§2 ta $135; meat 3? me ﬁamzergaiéan in

 §;?eif§%--:§*eeﬁ gﬁagsggaé §':§§.: »- $%2?'§&S§"§ ﬁgiéé am ﬁsiiﬁuﬁéé faéegi

-?~ P'as§s::,aT§;§%?;%. Egg aéga fézsé gamseysgiéarz ésﬁiweesé éaaazgéé éiéaai

 >--§{'gi"%%3:§'§"r:aa;&%§§":% 32% §<a2:§'€:%:§ 552$ mica $5 52% §"§%§§§¥'{§ Sé aim ffééié

fr
3*'
,/

 

 



§
2
§

 

QQ

servant, Algart fram thég; we 3% fmé cenv&r3a:%:3§éf~.._ :22;§!t?3

different memﬁﬁrg 9? the famééy sf deseageé_.-%§ré'd""V.'§arﬁE'Efg{A.
mambers 0? he?" Qamntaé hesgsex Tim CH{}}}"1'2f€f"S8'ifE{}i'E'--ES,§{?'t*§;"i8$f'§ 
geveral persazw. The tape :ec0'r§ed.1 C{*_:rvv.zé93r$1'z:*«;E%<3:é"' 5?' :%s«i2a"*:s:;?'

aéerzgwith the trangcriptiéag, nam:-:3s~..__sf f@"E'Z-<)\zir§nVg g':{éé€s;<:if:.:5HV%::a:':*1e--. L

mi regard. Setaiis are as unéer:

2, E§<:..?92 - A-1;A-2  
- §<avEtha--_   ,    I
-- Muthgxa  _   ,  " 
~ Sa$:'gée.:E*éa---':~_V_  '   J

2. Ex.=?93w:%{§-:g;a;;:i'_%.V _
~*--.Gsw:*amsn'a_ _
1:Z'%_a:"§"ara}, 

-« §5'§'?§*'§'."Ev3',ﬂ"'E!?c:§-'
 ;rv%a:i:?'es§: - =

§aha;'2%5'@g%f2.H _____ 

3" ';%x;.;G§4 _ *..§3i'".i1';.._é3s '=*Z

* ,, I] H 1/ ¢ '?;§§"§:%S§_'§ 
S;2:'r:--géyeééﬁa
%R:_:§<';fi:*:'a3i3:*&

i

-4V;§i_;: .Ex;'f=?T9§ -5'S__é%-ngeeiha

Maétegh

ﬁagzzarna -'§§§€S 8§?~»E2%
Kaviiﬁa - mga 825%
Samragf »- gage 836
ﬁézwamma - gagg 835
Qakmgygg -- §§§§ 83$

,\;;{,%£%h 'V'

 

 



93

ﬁatéﬁg they fefer {:3 Rajmahaik The entire canvergatém between

téwegé tam gergws énéécateg that there wag nzsrmaé reéaticmghép

mtween them aféﬁ Kavitha, sister of ihe deceased wa;§§§Vz;é§§.§ég.'
Accuseé N92 - Padmavathi ta be carefui 50 that  "
cheat her 59 far a5 {FEE pmgertées are £:§%;1'§ier=:2AeA§~'_4' V 2
arse Magigi Kaka as weft. 'may aisg 

"més Canversation impiiedw éndé£atés--._§f"'xiaAt ev.én__t%";e V$§:s'i1es é $5" zifthe "

ﬁeceased As%*:0§< Gutteedar as-zgre §2<:vi;é_§n§~-»_.;'31c¢L§se{§..v F~£Q.2 «-
Qmmavathi KG seek Em asgéééaﬁcé' getiéerrzené sf

mspertées a?' the éeC;ea¢$ed,

64, T§--.pes._ --ﬂfi&é'i'jz§§«f x€:§%*7%§é§v§'} tine cerwersatéarz between

ﬁccuseé §*~§§s,1é=an<§% E "a:":¥:;€-.'A';:<t:¢:n'é':+:::"5z>f we mnvergatémz §Fs§§€&i:eS

iaékéng §§_; e'?a::E"% et'i:@;_§f" Eanyéaniﬁy,

it dseg mt mféecé 3

:9:t.ye%$a:_§® <"}%"'. fs'_§én_;d§ G3' gcgziaizziames. E: ﬁg sameihéng mera

tha:§A§§éé1m_T§§;'  ;%'§'t.é§%~:ac3s bemeen them, 'aha way they ﬁﬁﬁfeﬁﬁ

 :$i%:§%'%ar:§ %:%_§_%<T::§f Gﬁaaene Wﬁéﬁﬁ Eﬂﬁiiﬁﬁié tiiai ﬁsera wag

 '=§ 5"E%Z§--._V?'%*'é:%:§?€§§?'§..=§Tf%é'v*€ aim} $§::»§<€r2,

 ?: ;::%'::;$%§a§ é:*:7'?sér:"*::;§<:3;'v¥.3'eivs;ae:*é faézem, in '£:é:e3e £:B$$€t:§@S'3 Sanggezha

'§E2&3; aésa mfg? :9 same

 1*aVS§--ré§éA§V%_:§";iaik am $'5a%a:':'z§:*:': e:::=§ 3'£<;?f§'§§$§&E'§ {hat éuiura as?

. \£";'.»;'

1%;



'7'z:a;E:aiV hag it; x 52?.' @652

94

Amused Ncaz ~+ ﬁadmaxzathé and her chiédrerz E5 airéghi and they

wéii rm: §';3va am; pr':3§§emsk Azxzéged §'~§:3t2 -- Padm;% 1Ea§:§3i

reguests Sangeetha 5:3 g0 and Enfsrm aéé the detaiég :$:.~«a--s4i«rf3'_§'¢§§% 
$9 as is get wrrect Enfarmatione The c:<:>::verg;a_:£ §f:n_ 'b {g'E:é;_eé::*'[  ' 
Maitash and Acjmseé N92 ~»~ PaémaazathEghérwgriéééaag'.ﬁg-Ia; 

a devztier ané he is the iausbarﬂ af ens: <3? ifge 's%s$:ers <~i%If.év'ecﬁea'£:éd~. 

Accused 330.2 --~ Paémavathé refers ':E?(:a:1ii:e i:aE§é~.bém3ee.§*:;: her Err
Eaw:-5, whish she mzerheard,  in_#§ §{QVTsL':'ésgé»E&~--.fee£§:'§§ b ad absut
the mégfmtune Q? beg: They refeigj E9}:V§%?ér'§.é€Iﬁ3§gE_'.V§¥'?Ut§°:3f3. Then

he chideS Padmava:vh';"~j:5fat ééaéar":§é:2;3'E§*§:§"éE§€:._ §s§hGuEd ask abaut

Maiiegh am :Véth§éf§;vsé§éw..§s ays --fﬁ ey ééﬁ net ask anyihégzge
'ﬁse géaae is a'*:'*I§Véa*ag§,' a;§ﬂ§.}c%"é[>i'g._:é'b:';'é,gE m kéiameéers fmm ﬁaiamd.

Tﬁen She §r:;smEsé:§" §'v§Va§"§';e'Z-Z'. ';~:'7?'i  she Wm take him if} tééat gaérzi:
w§§'é:s._he mxé §éf:'*:a"7a§ we giace £3 very mica They

é%$c.§L:--;'35g:§%§ T&§3A{1i'i;%i"§§'i'éi€E$§fS§€E'E"E€?'ét 5;? gain: {mm Jeﬁagit Thﬁi? Ehey

:*"'vL,/Fﬁiéiq a532.3%"':;§:":"éé\\"'.Z?'?3*§A§?1='gm the facé :3? 'Smrgh', "§'E':eﬁ he aéivisgg

"§%"s8 mmsersazian beiwea": ﬁaege Ewe

.§:§é':*sé:a:::g*%::%{f§§§5i:L;% Em}? Paémavathé gages Eéavisﬁg csréégiéiy with Ehe
"»' '~.§égi'§1:f.§7*f:»%"233$ égmaseﬁ am 5539 ééuémsné 5;? gégtgywégvéagzg by

 Evéaéiégizn ski! ihe agmaergaiiem w@a;§§ méésgté aha: ihay

 

 



93

wage tryéng ta azjvisa Padmavathé thai: $323 magi take Care af

Cﬁiiéren, pmgerty arm she Vaiéii be iaaked gftez" $32 garents Q1:-'T___her

hugbanéfgashgk Sutisééar. They iaik $1' same we as f;§1§.::;§.é;;:'r.%T:t:5r,'

$isiie:'--~m-%aw af Sangeethak The entire digmsséan  "

they were reférréng is we wife cf Satt;e:{§3'}§.'----.T%1s%§--:f _,§':§§<:9§'4:éf'x3.%j.té'v..A 2
the {gag cmversatéoa between Dam;  "aVné--A. §ar*@£:éf§$a,/. 

requegts Maitesh ta advise San§eeVt%*:.§"n:}t £97 s__pea5k".§35§§vii5t'"ﬁiétm " '

and fvianjzg Akka Qpeniy. The.£0:w.r+3:--:~§é';§Q%*:*-.betwééiz...S&}":geeEE"*:a

and Padma wcmid Erzdécaie wﬁéétbﬁer"A;§;:sé:ﬁ f§\iri§,2.Vwsuid be éahie

ta imk after the  »§e3} ﬁ%.§s;:V§s*9;V"g'§i;je:é'is her ghare, "E"?:a\;
%:aEE< about   tease éach Gihes", Yhey
ass: iaik ahﬁzéé; j;=z'§~€3e {;E §>i?%;'».é'?~,_:%«€}'at%ara§ Gu:§§Gas: "§'E:e EREEFE

taék between.,A<::€{: §a$ §*éa%';2 9 §?%§mava:hi am her géstermm-Eawg
%<;a~<;i~*;.§}a_; F_3§La:':*3gg é':E%V:_a azéé {'::.;i....Maite:$ %": ééscéesas m§s--w":&erg:an§Eng

be€%kv.1e5&a€Sasj:*§.e"ei:§f;«:% 'a;f:§ Kavéthﬁ ; wife 9% Eéattaraj Giﬁtedgr xrszag

 mi §é%°;a3%»;s€.;;g§V"g;';;§vé;f:__e';?iE.§,£'éemga{$3 ;5~;£:CE,§S€é $492 - Paémavathé am

 % §::o:V:%--: iéwé §$i$s"'--'-$.$7':" V'§::%":e ﬁéﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁ Saiiaraj Guiteéar asasefé aﬁasismg

Hﬁﬁéug

%

<1? §$é@A2'=-4' ﬁaémgazaiiéé is b% Ca§"%i§E£?§ mgarﬁéng gmgwiéagk

 '~ '«.§"%%é.é€2i;§V:"€ -€;f§§'3'%£§f§&§Ei"2{'E wgzsié égéééaate ihai ihéy wag mi §"'%§§§'y'

-':2' a

.  /_¢

3.3%. .



Sw-

"«. '§3"2s€f--:??:f§. 's:;e%*e haagirsg gsmgaysatiaﬁg ﬁcmgeé €'§:3.g:

99

the saie 0?' the §3E'G§€¥"t%€S Sf the éeceageci Ashek Gastieﬁar, $,§§'?£

 

in 5 factary, wmie stares, Ear $2. Restaurarét 3§*§'77<;i"'*.'§fc:'4f'§".§_é*3.V3.i.i:"'%_v"

;Z'2§'%§3€f"§'.i€$, He was Entgséing is iirﬁnsfer the ps0:'i*:&§':ieV$  jti;é" 

deceased Ashek Guttgéar ta thea rsameés o;_f .=?'§~.A€ ?::?;,2é;'e'é}~...:

Paémavathi am he? ahiédren.
Severai cassettag net aniy between A«.{&2:a.;sx1\¢:ri_E'xE0§"1. 'érrﬁgi Zzﬁsut aéga
f3xCCE£S>€€i N92 with ééfferent m%3%%}.ber.fé Qft:'E§«e; fé':'t3§Ey as %"é%e;*:'ed ta

aﬁeve.

69. "ﬂag ex:idiE€__if2ﬁé*§;:'»L:V:{.§'f  fi§':;§§:E:ﬁ§r'Vftigaéogeg staging a
gaﬁhyagraéza' at  g--¢§§;;1é.§a%%§'?§§,§aQér::y was not abie is
tram east 2\::s%;;'2_:VVr'%LV'V 1 %a§av@$E":wa:"a Ceiszsrzgz
at Suébargg-.1  ﬁaganiharaa Muégi égzfsrmaﬁ

?\f%§--~"?Q t%:a%;'§':£:§:::s:e3;:..,V%"féf'<3;i2'; v§%'éiE 'bie arregteé by ?e:ic@ as get" the

§'zie}2§ss "%7E3$"§'i'€~%§ﬁ  %§'"@_ ?3§i!*s!v§H § §:§€€' ﬁisﬁegérzg Em arregi sf §CCL£§%§

 Eééﬁ. E2": Ci:2.r2z*aeV{_a:z§§§A§i%' Azaséiﬁ :§:§ mama? sf €33 3%?! Ashak Gggiiaﬁagx

§%;a5_§;3  Eswge $1? WE-§? at Qajiibarga, %;"afh@r: §%;':f~5"? mm

H:

ﬁﬁﬂﬁumﬁﬁ

 i§§é§;'§-3%.":-§ gééig gag? éagi: £€}?'2:E§€:§€_'§L§§€'2&§S, T§%€§'§?Q%"'€ §%':% wag g%:&%":&z§

L".%;%3"'%asas;%g%2::m:a ééaggéiaéi Sr: €E"§§L§§%"'§ 27%-iéiéa £%a:;:'::;:':;e$ §'ia?.Z daring

- -A »::ww»:<»~2«4\~2v>ww-'¢¢~$>'ru~:'mn&>Z$'4?5T~Zv"'r4'-hm'-wv¢' '-yy\(:;l//S

rags ég '-mas: ig g:i§'~S:;Es§$e§f an



100

mg visit to the hesgzsitai abaut ihé reperts in 'the nev~;$pape:_;":.§§?3;e

azmfegged mfare %2%m evarything aéméttérzg iEEegiitima%:e~«~§-::.:§;z~a~§§g:E:,»f:'"
%&¥E:w%en hergeéf aisé s&:CC§.§S€§ §'»é@E1, She {'ZQ§'3f8SS%d..?T§§u$*§: S§:'§_§' éégaé 
intending to Eead maritai iéfe with A<:cL§§eé:.:f'§'c§;i'.TTa%*;c3~...:f::.g«..§§'§ﬁ;_ :'

deaeaseé ﬁkghak Gutteﬂar wag aV.T§*:;;:"d!e&"'.a;E*;:.% th==,:**§;i°:f':f3:t*é' §Efséi,2 

piamed his murder at Bangaéore. Hé'L§ as_V5hC:i9ck_e;A'?Q1  'ms
ff"C}EF': his daug%::er»§n~Eaw  

398% The defe;:é%é'«§:'E§§.§a_i%Ee:%f:g§e§{jA§y$§§:'ra-h...§:V§é:ii£EaE rconfesgéesz
before pw~7a an    hés Staiemeat that the
deceased as::i ﬁxc c'_§:é;::"§';f§V    am seeconé E$ he was
agaaéged wit¥*': 't.Ej:é  it hag game ii': 'me
§';«'§5€'§"§£€ "5y§'v'w"§4 G  hA% 2i:. V;é?.§'2..:%: 3:33: Subhagh ﬁuiieéar was;
 éiiecéagieé  Csutizeéazy stag bmther an sea;era§

&3§:§és '--§§§<;5;§ e'E:s:ﬁ§:i.§'r;$A';Ewziga auajtéan gaégsg meﬁeiary iransactiam

"v é§:}:4. %%e'*-«.aés§ ':;"§%§§%';§Af@$e3 %§"1E"§'":§§'y' between the éecaasesri .§%S§"%G§{
'H"§i§i.§%;%f$':§3zia;'ﬁ'v...:;%?€aEE<aE&%'1 Qﬁiiﬁﬁﬁfg firgi gm ~ Subéﬁag Sutieﬁar

 §§%§i§"§ faméigs wag ihiaking £3: that éézecéim §:*'§§

 :§é>;{":_;§:é*;z.;;%:2$§€€i:e§ the hgséé éf ﬁsjszzaéﬁ Eégwiﬁ ﬁg 5 maﬁa? 9?' sfaii:

éi§"2'g'§§§§§%**;§§"::s: €£}€3'*=.F8E"§§§;§Q§"'z zashéatié ég :*aé%.2:::eé mia 'EE'"§?E§€§"§Qi§$€'%

..\\f&js 

 



181

indicates PW~?Q was taking mi 0?' irzteregt ta secura the future sf

Agcugeé !'2£@,2 ané ﬁg? aﬁiiaren as $338 wag vary 2;<3:mg___a:":é

furiheg ?'v":5~?G faét that it wag hig :"e§;2§r:$%b:iéi:y bang the:

member sf Em famiiy 30 a%s*0 being iha fatiwer :3? the  ~

$afegLsar*d the interest 9:' Aacuged E\§e,Z azréé her :f;¥5*: i%§c%"r'*§,§;§f'1}V.:  

matter sf fact the Cﬁmpiaint Esdged:" by1 T;'i;%:C:.}::._ef'd

Padmaasathé at Bangaiere aigo Eeadsfp i: <i'=.51u$§§'<::Qrs.agT'aVi:i§:"$s3az:éra!

Qargeas whe were bugirzess §"E__'*g'8§S csVff...eié::e;a";§;e;é ﬁ§s'§*:<::E§ giéitedazz
Tim the abczve teiephenéc convé'?3§;i§¢'n__<}aQ§.néE,::..§éEg»?;i, even W.§-46

«.:E3%::€vs:ee:': aiiccu 59$

déd mt aésciose §efare 'a,;1y€:s:'aé" "iéxé; <:.E'i3~sf:*s§.;je$$

N93,: am 23

 't'<:;' }"fs_A;:r*n..;_  evédmce he was
awaksﬁe is Sag...%5s:.§f:§Vf{=.§éé:'--Efi%;§.§   tag ?$%§£e ﬁeéng 'the
iauge far sxgaéagge-é'  Qiiiﬁg He wa$ mt
evan a5§§ {Q £:@i":§"T.i_4s:'r;'":_ xhaé ataizaé befaze we §r3Eice
§hv:ai..:§c€u§::§f§' 'Vff§'.i£';,2: £QV%:'S--;§%§ff§§§:§i&e§Er:g giiés wt 3? ﬂejeatésn in ﬁfe

§@Ca.;;$@i '-:::_§  her §""ii.E§@§?E§. Sash guggegtimé azéé

.é;:;z:t;e5i~"sf:es":*i L§E"::§e3é."' the circumgtangeg ﬁafénéieigz aannai: ﬁe §{"£C$§i€§
ﬁg': f%;%:é¥«: }3§":.%7e fgat am: am wag waiiéng fa; "E§'§§E §§'§§E¥'i%€$ :9 §&

":2si§:%f§;&§"~.%,V;s%" ﬁe? :2a:"r:e 32:26 wag éﬁ §'%§§§"y' mass aréé 2-aggg 'aﬁéhégifég

§aE;~.§1a'~;:z*...§%:»3s* iémg in égiézéng mi $§'"§§'§ wiih §C:":'i§S€é §*~§$,3; but gigs

 



102

with aﬁ the faméigs members Sei"§®L§S§'y discusgmg about the

§;:rep@rty igsayea If she wag ﬁejected bécause 9? the d<=:afi;"E'*:,§f

ms %ms§a:":§; hes' reactéar; vwuid haazg been déffemr:;...s:3§*;é::'~ f§*§.ié'~3
€§&3'{i§'E. "fhés PWJFS was addregsed as Baba  --
Censasming sieepéng pins £3 azimétiteé by ;'5~§ic»:A:§::..s»§ie\:f;_ i\% o..-ZZ 

statement: recorded under s&::t§orf:,--_313 Qf '--C9de'C:*Er%:é§a§ 

Qaceéureg A :::§Em%na% case wag regigiﬁeé fo§*";a;n"'0§'§e§é':je {ﬁnder
se¢tEsn~3G§ 3536. Tim §"'£"'iﬁte§°.§§:'g'~._§§$;§§§€'$= §if"§éi~'si of ﬁxécuéad Na":

6:': SALEQQE. A? that time; 2%c:<::;:§§V_e§L'V"%'~§:»c:;:.2'_.s,:;§ai~:.jaz§;:y mach in me

§"'€S§é€I"'1C€ of PWW67 at"£T~§;q§i3ar<g_aKg  théi'--:E-a$§___§fﬁ'Csméng Ea mew
Em rzewsgager :"§:z«'=,_;;;:e:; *b:;;..'V"éb-<3.;;:%'5f':?'§Vé G?" Accuseﬂ E\§e,1 if:

gmnaztégn % ';<2_u   55e'.;fééé@é xzshsk {3ut'5:eéas3 $.he

2"§i?é&:.»..e:.:;mversa%:§Q:ﬁ 'éetweem ﬁaciugad

sgnsumaé gieégjng g;:§-EEv;<=;' f~._ __ é

€'x§:%2.§i.i"'§.:i:A§"TV2; %éf§'@%'s~.:@ :§°3;é'"élféf9:"i$ 3? WJ~?@ far seiéieméni sf the

Sm§éE'*§;*§'-Iéﬁzi %a§§:é«~..;§'&%f:\% @f Agziuged N92 and hie: chéidreni Ha

 8§3::f'i'~._3§{£'{é.§*; '§§:V ggearg 2-*2s%se:"f: ha gage ezséﬁenae E;-efsra me
'  xE2§§>né 3:38 ?amEiy me::i:b@;*s sasgsecigé auiciéai taaﬁescy
 3:"; acsioaggéi: $5 éaaﬁz ma? ﬁe? §'°?%_§S§§:f's§= £3 a

"§2{¢3f'::t£%::<--%&=f fagi 52$ 93% fmm hes" §3rer:":aE masgﬁ wag %'€§§§§E§§ 2ﬁé§§§"%

 gt Ga;§?s§§*§§ ﬁgs?" %,:%éa éssaih £32' 32%? :§"'§i§S§&§"%':l§ asazj 3% *<¢»sa§

if
'I?
./

 



_E\ée...Z.~:'eeeeee"2ee eieeeéne eéiie.

103

reeieieg with he? eeeeee ehéiﬁ in ihe image ef her brei:iherwée«§ee;.

if ehe wee eeebtfeé ebeui the Eeieetierz ef her éwéewe eeeeesee

me: eeeféeeet e? be?' feEher~:e~%ee; PW-"39 Securing her  
weeiei eat have stayed %e the §'¥QL£S€ of PW-6;i Tﬁ.e_»'e"e,§d'efeCVe 
iczéth ene kin ef tee Aceeeee E'~ée.2 eiee re\:%eeEe _§het"'eheA  

Sieepéng eﬁie ene on receiving inf0rmetéen,e':he**;x eam,e'.eAie"see'he':'e V

in Guibergek There is we reesers te"e'€i§'s»:ée§Eeee~téﬁe--'evi.{§ence ef

WK!-79 wee made sﬁeeere effc:=}:ie._te _'§.i'f.;a:eee'-¥;§f_se'.V{:a;.§erétsvVfeéeeneibie
fer the death ef he see esheég e>e.ee'AA-'.$ie§;Eng 'ehereee'

and wee trying his"  %:Q;i_gej%E:%'e "€i'é"ee.__..;w€:;mper'{ies ef the

deeeeeee eehek     "hie eeeghter~%n----Eee;
eeeeeed    '?%1e eéreureeteecee in
eahéeh the   Eta; eeezzeed §'sie,2 eefeye
?W--«}"§ ie eiee. eeteﬁeég   eeeae es: reeerﬁ that en 8$:_i=2:Q{)2

e<;;;:.ee'e<iV§%:ee:'§j»~.'eie§ ..erree1t'e'd"eee ereeueee eefere the eeeeemee

%'v'§eeit§e'e%:;e;'  en seeing tee reeeee ﬁe the eeeeeeeees,

Ween gee wee

V"«.Q;e4ee_%eeéegireeifeeei ie the heseiieig eeeee eéeiiee hes: gee

 r;ve--:%eeieee eee wee eeeeg ee iéée eee egézee eee $§@§<';§ ﬁe

§e:e=e;

?§':£§"€?$%"E teeee ie he eeeee %::e eeee me: eeeeeeeee



134

méuced, coerzseﬁ m" fgrced Accused Eé@,2 ﬁe make gush

wnfessien before ?W~§?8. REE Iaiang £CCE.£$8§ §'xEa,2 wag %::_.._§he

sempany sf PW~?G am} £)§§"i€%' §am§£3: membars am {here

 

ﬁéﬁé te piay tﬁég drama cf extra jugiciai cesnfesgian E%+--:§i%:  '

Sm wrrsumed gieeptrsg §§§§S§ if reaéiy 5,35%~::Q:":sf_§z:'%;§é{?E.--VI,s%éé;i'_§:;j;g'L-.,. V

§§H$ because cf depressgéon af murder 0?  j§§%%;:s€T5a5a{%%%*:.;é%e

members @f the damaged w0:,:id ~§t%;L§t_»reé't:.__Er:__§§§§':.. 'f'a's%"s§'§nt
Therefare the entire evédancewjﬁ ?'x;':i':V*}"-é:.'a';:;'1ﬂ€"*»€}.i:§'3&:%' 'tirvg:A:,§sf;*:3'{aE':Ces
under wﬁich the mrzfegsim ;f§aé%';'e§3efere mm by
ﬁmcused No.2 is C<f3f7'3'¥.\§$Ta"9?'%.i:¥"";"Z3 arifgycumstanse is

aise eﬁabééshad   
ﬁg Feurth ti;-as:nASfa§.mc§3'{§b'$e*.%§ce §;>f §ccuseﬁ at Guibargagz

"K. Tiia ;j§e><t:.V<;%.;r;cé;':"":'%$t$';*2c§e $3 the §§f}S€§"1CE gf §€ELES€G 535,:

m7 ._;~g:g  f§:'.Aa'%'§@geV%{","§Aés$€$ 3: Smbarga en :§¢a,23a2&

 V,%c:€:>.:iééé'2g iL:§'1'::".h§ §m3e£u*:§§:':; he 5&3 51$: ﬁiiéﬁﬁ £§&§§%S {"§E"'§

7_3«§4}§ §§Q2"§$ Eéé was at ﬁangaiere {Q 30 away wéti": the Eifa :3? the

  f}§E;_Cé&S{¥.§§ égﬁsié gazzaéay. wzgwggg 22*, 3?, 38; 3% 4%; £1, 42,5,

f "--w.§»{:'%;=§:,'§ éég $5 552$ éé gm aha giaggmgiég :2? &::€%_:s:%é $43.1. E: :3

,W,,,.A...,,k,W,_»W.,,A«,..'_.-._,w,....~w...m.a.....».....¢=;;m;:



135

mi in déspuia {ﬁat Azsjcuged N31 was in {he '§"' Semegt'§§%f'_:i5£.B§

in we gags" 2962 at §'~'?.§<2; fvfeéécaé éjaiéggeg. 
same 9+": recsré that he was smgeni ;§A§f2§0s*:   
reéevani paém: of Etime, §'4atz;raE§y aii  
§*«ée.2 have turneﬁ hasstéée ia the caszagf tié..§'r's;:seC:.:§'§§§;:v':'__: 
sf them have siated caﬁegoricaéhz  kzsjgs V:§'ra:= $:e rV°§t  aiasges

an :§.6.2C%Q2 and some sf' :::;3: §tAé:§_Kthe\gH cfauid not
mmember vazhether he was '?%§~?:'Vé'w"reéevani QTQEFEE

sf tésrsa geverai éaiégi';  PWMZ6 ~«~ Er,

Kumaragwamy,  §&?%§Lgaéf?2'V'BiV%ja§ar ané §3*W~4§ ~»~ 3;:

Qéiég Ma Rarrﬁjuévé"*:§§*:§,Qaifiagsag 9f 23*" mtg: <3? 9"

gemeséa st:;é:'1&«.r§£':§-"V  -~ Si: ﬁiéép M Eiiiamgurﬁ
handieé ihgwry }§§?¢:$}§§§ v"bé"%t:s§?é;2:: 8  ans} 9 am. an
 §2"s;%\,:'-"'4*s»5§§s%}'~' DV;V5;"""RL:5:"awa§£ was the §'"§€§§ 9? the
.  ms gpecéféaaééy giaieé ihai: Aicmgeaé

 §"'§«:;n.: wag' ._:;:;%':a  ?§'§€" iéwea giuéénég éegagieé fmm Mich

«-.s'%%i['§;;=;?;;'?;"~f:® E3'  fa? €§EF"s§€&§ :;':§a5§eS and £2: wag !PVzz'§~2§ anﬁ £6

 %§2%_'§'%cs._a:é;=%_s'&Ségsgeséeé ta hanéée ﬁes ﬁaggegk écagrééﬁg 3% ?'%.%?*~45_,
   mi: %"zar:§§§ any géagg G5': 3.3"" ans 1%" }m'a€>~2a';E§2 fa: {ﬁg

£er:g;.gé§*{:g at? ﬁaﬁﬁigiﬁﬁé §"'§{§,§.g %**J~2¥5 :§{::%< {$253333 3;:

 

x: N'?
5  §%x<-.>e-"s§ﬁwx'-<i= "'%:-w2~z~;<*:~' 

 

 

-L'£r»I.ww)~ »'\*'r""""\W.4-~/rt'



w»

 ':33?

106

15.6.2802 fer 'B' amét studentg and ifxacugeé #33': wag one of 'she

'B' asst students. §'W«-2% hag caiagaricaéiy Senéeé Em §§:'e;§:ans:a

G? ﬁs§CE.§S€§ man: ';:a aiénicai céagsesg which hé {ask on  V'
He aim denied marking of pmgerrce in 'cm attendaiiﬁe .sf e§iLé4Tie%.:_4'T 
Accerdmg €23: ihég Glacier PW~26, an 1'5';76I;'.2«£30;Z»§é h.s3:AT¢':érf:t:iﬁ£cite5'.

aiénicaé céasseg an pzﬁmonary t:.,:beVr<:u§0§%$  orig :pa':e«.e:4'2~%:'."%'~:?§'~_

ﬂame Kaiyanaéah was $§"1OW¥"i ta thé ségaients:  . 'fie: j':f;e§%;:é%%12'ihéreﬁ
the Raﬁ aumbar G? AC€iiS€d §'-=£g:;.;':   "J;f_~£K8 i"éa':: mt taken
any Ciagsag either in '*9' unit 94% #E=f._>"2'S.?5'b:at:;%'1 :.e:s_z3Lvi,-E§E§,20G2, pww

49 wa$ net msétéve_:<a:%§a::.:%éis":§"%§i§}§rr§As~é';f:.¢V§:V' 9'? Ranged §*«.%§.1 in

%:%2& iiheary d;¥3§S$é$   wa§ bmughi an recmd
zézraaégh t%:e§é e§§c-i:Q:*§' %:;?ie*':_§'%r::*;~acEf:§:*;g Acwgeé éxéeﬁl ma: ii Eg

very mrr§:":*:€}:i2 %%:aé:" §} m:;<§$'* gﬁéﬁ-"e$ér*:¢& woaéé ﬁe Lziiared whergever

t%;.aé".r;ame_':§sf  ;fegis:fié:r.._;i':_:;A:'°nber $3 Caiigd, "§_%ze'r@f0re ii wag

§@s~s§bEé ':3 §".'E_f§'¥'A§§ ;2;'<;;.><_s; grggerzce §::adve?te§2i%y. E:::<,?2§ csntaing

 ihg a::%"3iw{%;*g;TA the Queréea af ?W~??a §:x.:,?»@5{a} gm

 : ";*,'~a*'?5vr;a',"; agie-.:%:eV_.at§$4%~e§anc& gegigiefg 3? Em gméfenig, §><.¢§%6{a§

'éiéifigiéé Q? gggneg ay 92%-2;%. Ex.?§§ gg we

£§§&

{$%2,§e*?i§'me§@E'§'£Aa§ yeaaré S? ﬁr. Eégéyanaiaéw 5:? whsm ?':.?:;'»~2§ has

'_:§:@">%g§%i'§:§§%§,f 3§:>§<§§*': 'gas, §%;°%;'~2§ aaiggsrécaiiy giaieé faafsre 32$

 



10?

Cam"? that ,£x:£a2§ed $60.: was abgaret far {he ciasges §3g§.<;?__§n

i5$6'2Q"Q2§ ":'E"1& medécaé reaoré :3? gatéemé Mr. %<a§3%ta¥réé'§--§i%;..
mnfézrmg the fact that in Em céénécaé aéasgeg 9:2  "
éfwk C§8S$€S sf puémonary tubercuéoséa  'e%:.?asi:l'§'<3V§g§E§ié.f%;0x'- 

mark gregerwce an aacmmt sf waxy éjr':ié:*.;aL:'3€:e  ::»f '

marking' éf Qi°€$€E"EC€ 0? accaggeai En éné'-Vs}; twé .:jeg%§5fter§'~-.:é'é'a'yL Em?

be 0? much heig. The murder 's"'§"::.:'#ti'Ai:Vja:aze rung
t§"E?'§i.£§§'¥ the ﬁéstréci 0'? §Vuiba:"g§V_ news item in
the State: ?'~«§atu:'a§Ey5?;:'2'<53£.V;f1%<3s§d:%::§'2t$  Gva;§::§§--§%a*§.é..:V.%§§@£iaiiy Eiteraie
ﬁergems Eéke  Seen the news
gertaénéng ﬁe  tE*éé"   «{§{sV%%:$i§ar. Subgequeni ts:
arregi mp ﬁgcgutgaaé .'§_'é§}§:. awraagheé {he caiiega
auiémﬁiéag e$3e£xé'a'§«%:g; 'vt§3 :ﬁ:~v._§EAa.§'S';'2;§éEes arsé 'me feashéng fagazftyg
wE'§_:;e"V.i:_€3ie%E< _@n :"S*«,v§...2f3Q2; ii xézwéé % gasgmie 53:' the

%est:\,§':-*im*:;V..V"'E:«:'2T~;:§:~:'s;e:?§9éé,:~e§* M39 aitendeé 3 Qﬁfticéjiﬁf 55353.

.1 ':§g€j€%.£S&{§.?'"§Q5';'§ §é%2'é%;;_ Q52-*::':;:: ﬁﬁaﬁﬂﬁ, hég pmgsnae weagié be rgaiéaeﬁ

 :?§;fi:§ §,~a:iiL;:":€«:§$§ "§"§'2e:*ef0:*§ taking mm C{f2€"%S%§E:§'§Ei§G§"2 €538
 a%3.:s§§:§'e:fé::séA éf«-..?%i*§»2;§ aaagzséeé with thé $35: 3:53 waxy pregeszce
2' ~-., "'és%;a$."«£--3m§?:§:: gné mrmai in ma ::§§$§€3; the ma? Qaurz hag

1_";.%§;;:§2'%:§':; £35239 is {he ii{:2?'%§§ié§§§%'% iziéai 5CCi.§'§%§ 53$ 2%: éiiﬁﬁé



188

céaggeg an :S.6.2Q%32 and we register éadécaténg has gres-9;.§*;c&

zgeulﬁ bﬁ éuicsme @f waxy 3?:§i€E"E§E2?EC€,

takes Sﬁﬁiiﬁﬁ mntenétéan Sf aiébéf E: ég éngugeasérzg M
defense m esiabéish that Acrsuged M0,: 22:-gazg»«gxses-%§én%_ ,$% f"§_:rVEVb'aL%igé§- 

er: :5.6,2Q§2 am it wag 525% $Gs§éb!'é*.fé §; A'?2én€""i.'§5?*

B3nga§0s*e., The Q§"{)S@CUt§f0£'"¥ haSV»g3.5'f§'aV_%b:'b{:g.ht' .§h".:%€:{§:7é'?d'V:€he 'V

evéésnce from me Trangmrt €;f;erg@r'aVi*-E-e>r":"'§'°;i§'2r=:_freqiéeni :39 baseg
ram betwﬁers Gukbarga and" '8¢:zri--gg}.--g%'e,V"=V:i:}ef:wss.ie:z Eégar ES
Samgﬁaiofe via Gu§%3&rg:«;s;'  §a«'é§€"é'€~v§:,»;>.s%4rz«éV:;':=.;7§e V-igaﬁeg Szﬁbarga én

3&.6.2G@2 by :*';':e:f_;zi~:*":i'x:_r44,_' §5i§js_z4:a:§_$:%u__1b.g in" Eégngaéare by evening. If

gomesrée aﬁJarfV{VeV' §"é.4$   early hoawg er in the
méénéghi, if  ﬁuibarga by aféerrmam
"';i"E*"2§ref@;'@ €:%§:r'>;_:?'sat é'%'§afV%A :34?' ;*é?:::::sV;&?:'i:.1§ w:;:a_s§c;§ ériééaate it 2-=v=3;a gmsgébée
f9;€'j'V'V2ﬁ§'€;<,?::$e'§':-§:':'§'»§:1-7:1 ":3: €@'§'%é§e Wi5éV ﬁangaéaré 952 1§.§§;3:§Q2 am tém

mat§{é§§"';a'i$*§§,;»:§{:'éV§%i;_viéggtaéfégheg ihat hﬁ wag absent ia his

 é.:§.;§3§23$ 95*: .?;5t§,.Z'i§_:{;§',Zi aE <S%:2§§arga.

'.\/xjgf/m%   '  . 

 :::'§:"'§:::%'2%'s'Ear§a ﬁgrmwing ﬁf §'§'§Qi§f'€ £5 ' Sm; ﬁcaaé aﬁ

   

'zféézers the "

  

: Zx ' <  ..\» ;-    



 

. » " 

139

an the Ea$t eacasiang The eviéerzce $5 theae faur witnessas 'iéaézgiﬁ

émicate ihai ﬁéough they £<§':&§:2.r {he exaat ﬁates am  

iaking momrcycée by Accugad Eiiai, they were re;E.a::: §§2za:ﬁ::wA£:::'; 4g:§é" 

evidence with Certainty; The fact :'em2§§n§Aj:§u":3T;eéE4A'N-<:>;';.,'igstiyf

vésiteﬁ ihﬁ mom cccugéeé by PWs,i§ is 'i§ 'EWO y§2'é;féV p?r§<}§f  t's:;s 

3.12.2394 am the same z»vou£§'w.V.:.%*e3§Vte  {$3 mag.
$Ub$i8E'Et§E§';Eﬂ§ thég QEE: gf  ~ '1:%;$Avé;VstEgai§ng
Qffécer was cméucteﬁ Vénitiai EA§"_:3;/Vfej;<A;.§§'§faf%@"":="%§é$'.ﬁ'¢_gYE_é~<:ed an recsrd'
that ha visited the rg}0lé*rj§;. é3:'§   imfarmatéan af

PW$,:5 ta :8 far  was as 99:' {he
inf0:'ma%é<::*:    msmdy. Gf csourge
?i!1i53::§ afzd :§éga "a<m§t :~,é;§:'{§jsge%e;--.V.:;§%»»«:%2'a:erayaze= $2; ?s;:;w?4, :?'§%.fs.:?
am 18 <::>;::;°_i:f§:*1e& :;¥':_{¢as' ~fa"£;'€ i;.%?»'V;£*=;.;gEsta;'":t CQ§"t."E£"§"T§$$i0§"'%€?' sf Psﬁce

c€.2?'%":VE'{;vg :e':L. €§2am Efféﬁ a?V§9?'§'3'é§§ng them af {he factg 9? {he gage

%.-%z'%§§§e9' meiercyaéeg The evédencg sf ?PW--?é

:7 ::a;:.:§Ee5'ésgééih f§TI;".'£é }v.E"i::'§§e§*,%"E£€ $1? ?W§,3;E ta 3% wauiﬁ imitate
- {"§f;t:«ijé':?§;\,z§§$ 2:§;§s'i~"'5&éz&§ fram iéie £;.:g:§dy sf ;9%i2f-i§ am ihég was
 éfsi «.;3g%  %.%f;é"'A_%m€srmat§aa fi.iE"§"E§3§':Eé E33: éasageﬁ %\§:3.:, "§'§':e fag?

:§%f%%3?<:'§i;€:*:§=é %r§m iése wéaaiary §§Z§'§Z&§ﬁ&E"%? sis? ésaus;-eé $33,: $3

at:=.:_:*§%:wg%  msisrgyais $3; ﬂags/239$ rm: an :§.5=2§€I§3 ans

 



111

acasrdéng {:2 Em grsgacutéara, Ehig is the §'%":QtC2E'%:"§fC§8 ugezi,

Ea armza 3% the gzsgéne cf sffgrme 9:': the nigh: 

T§'?€¥"€f§¥"E ibis mesa sf}? $2;§§e:':£e,. anatéwr £ércu§%';v5:a.{§::e"'ié 335:}?  V

esszabiisheé.

ﬁtsixth circumstance {Accused«N_;e.2 ¥f:35c'i'EEtati€n;g;\f;,_§*§§g§§ed 

§\£o..1 ta gain entry to scene of c}'E'nx'fe3;

?3é Accmﬁéng :0 the  fasiiétateﬁ
ﬁcazgsseé Mai E3 gairg   3%' her' father
my: Rajashékar a§."~'%_B$'f}g&§:g%e fer CGf'?'}i'Z"'§§3$§G§E
of {Eva mu;*de§iz3f.A»53'.$'%'2'%§§<::'ii35:sf:te€§'$§;  A' ':--§:-£2a§'s game on rgcazvﬁ ihai
ﬁacaisgeé §'a§Qk2: v2gx:§"3'éE'e  émmeééateiy afier Em
ﬁeaih :3? her haéswnév a;%;r;y §3'§_3'::'::'é\.::433$ further stai§men: $1? her
%'2a:;_,:;:a<§eé':;rameé;'%:e §;__§§&ieniereﬁ {E33 beﬁ mam iﬁraugﬁ the

éaiﬁengri  {;:::g§'9r%r::-%.::Ee§i_' izhé mazréér cf éxer higgbaradﬁ ﬁ§pa:"e:*:t§y

giéie Sea; :*_§:§-sijsé a%;éE'*;?§:':*e  §%C&&$E§ was fsasmé mméezeé ég in ma

 'a;2j§5:'V':aé§"g :';»':*'"".'§2;';*"ee"--«'£'§:e:;':'$:ez it is :z:3§§§y's Case amt Em grééégﬁ ésar
 ¥:::T%:§1éE3?§§:@§:y mg': mt be céegeﬁ, E':-Easmaiégg by geighz iéza

"' .."_':--::_'h':%§_§§s3"'$5 {ﬁe hsasgg wazééé {E5658 the éssxs 'fa? gafgiy gaka

ﬂ '"»_i.%;é§::%§§'"'::"sie:2§ée:':3%§§; $$m&::>:2~:3 Ream E"§"%§§ ﬂag? $;:;§§: G2?

  

 ..

5%:

112

acaidentaéigs aameerte keepg the écerg apea, as 9% weuid be abée ts gain eﬁtry Ehraugh tizég deer Ea ﬁtter the bad roam V%_r+a___t§*:e first ﬂees: égart fram the bes' mam Q? Acaugeﬁ EHEGQ5 mom of her parents is aiso E2": the first Elem': It "

record that Ehe bed raem clear of her Qareais eutsiﬁe when 51%: foam her iréugband vxgag mbo§y':~; Ca$e that gameme games? t§'€r*<;L;g'§'= tV%*;,a.e 'V§:§V'é':'r:' 500:' " ' aw ciimbed the stairs ta €ﬁi%E' '€E'¥€ be-di..ff_@.é§:~':_ef A7c:'<:u--se.s§'§?\§G.2 ta %<%EE the ﬁeceaaeé ﬁsixak @u:%§eé_:§r;%%f'3A}s %{g*i%'?;gm,; sf fact was zrjsnvematim betwee::4_fEsc§use:;§fd awifrfi Z7 fe"}':}3m E><.P1GG, iha trans<:s*i§t§a{°: aﬁaut how Acczjseé Em: §E§'§"§€€i e::'*:*E:f'§"--*:::§ was very maxi": within 32% kra@w§e&§% §}.f_A£c:L.4:7s:>;§ %1E0}=2; ' V '-?%x €<;:::§y:es;3LVa:E=t'E§'%':'v at Ex.E»>1§® a$ iadigaiéé absve §§sc§%:s;:;_;eE<:,A ﬁ;sff%.,}i::§a§4 'ﬁéai areguérérsg with ésaugeé §\§@u2 ag m :7 w'é2:etE*:€:*§'L}"%_;;§§%é£eV.§é§'%fé2"é: anything. $92" that ; gﬁcczggeﬁ {H392 wgééag "7.'§.'Ef5%i A<::'i;,sé%é Exégi ?LEE"i§"'1€E' $3323 a-a:%i§*:§;r': ma GE" tam éayg mere 4':é§'%§§._ a:t§_;sé"A\«:a:he€:%2§:" E: ii szzéaiée 52:" maggﬁsr, "ééza mmxaysaiéan 254%;-zéié iéiyg-aé §§?§§§"§E'E§: zééraciéasas is ¥%:'?§§€?"§ ﬁzgcmgaé §x§a$.§; amj 2 'K 113 were :a3ké;1g abaut the death 3?' Asmk Gmttedar am they were menﬁerrmiaténg mat Paiice wouﬁd ééaide yvﬁether it was a ;":*:'i,::.'%st§e:"

G5' a suicide, when éié aha cama to §<F'1GW, she regéies that sF:e_.;c_aEn§a=; t£*.§"~khca2v' one mmth after making enquéréeg in th£g.'aref}a1';§€ier'i§E*2é '?s.gnje'§é;§.

ﬁcczsseé §\£§,f: was anxémgs ta knew 2;;a?j:&t%'ie7:~..;a§:§z ath?e.$.%A¢:'Eue3 vgzefe feuné and ha insists that he c:<>:4:":;--°§;:':"A:'§.nf@t::§;ét'io§:. Teaséngéy Acmseé §\[email protected] says:'::s~i3«_eu§§ '§Vﬁ§'jgééiraif i!§3Ei7e1;*:' ;€az*,€:s§eé Na: insigts Ea angwé_«i%?.%[41.%'grt:§3€r§,L confirms that Actzsséd N43,: {f3i;;'f:}:v:@':+:E:é.3;'.#':§"E~ﬂgmi/:'.~:V.?;.Ej§.'.:'ﬁ§'§:§£,j'$'SiOE'1 beiweerz ihem sevealg thai ms the 'cE':e;7ja', "Eirse zenvergaiign gexféegaié 2519 738%? sf ﬁgzcuseﬁ £'=§@,:

whather there; aaseﬂéé a;§13:.:,g.u;é'$»'a§'r:':$i he further says Peéice mm: net g€:}§i 1a-:73!' :::"E::'e§2..w--LA,:a3~~.;;f;a:§9'geepie must hava waiéezeé an we gaiﬁ ggsib §z;Jf;_ "$3,; saw as we haé gme :§°:§m Yhegz :i 'aEv:2;§ ﬁ%§é:,,:§s €é a.§::;':V;:T':§am§ mgrkg Sang aaéieatga $3; exgerig am .ﬁrsszé:-;V%;§ga%%ﬁg €§§"fE€er was ﬁgféfﬁﬁeﬁi awe? gatimg caaiam §_éf*%§::r1::%éé:%i§@%é;';_. fxaczsgaé $3,: axaigims Em namﬁ $1? §%::,:§u$ed E\§:;:.2 ' faf2za_§ §§£€::ss§§ ?-------é§,Z 333:3 magi wezgiﬁ §"%5§§&E'E a? it maﬁchegb "§"%:a,;3 §X§§'ES§&é Emir §§7:a§?"€§"%ﬁ§'"§S§:';'2%'i %z"z:"§"E§i %a:$:.;%:"§ §"E§§§@E'E gs' $2 when Acwgeé Nap: aguestéerzeé A<::;;~::§§i»:'_§_€'éj;§;:"

(<%'éé§i§ﬁEE{K ..m'lg£4¥ 114 matthegg '§%*:€n Acaaseé §*éc:.i brugbes aside this §ﬂf§EW%§f§Qﬁ saying Em: ﬁe wauéd mt give mach ai:?::er;t:'G,zf2"""s:%.'_~v--...$;g;:-§'j;'_ énvasiigatéezm §§{I€L3$€@ Pia} cmaaﬁeg ésccugeé F'éa_-:2.iif~§a5';z§:ngA agu she ﬁaubteﬁ evetybacégx, émxestigatmg a7ge;3§<:.yA£4:é::» 'id§§'r"zq"V31":-§L,§__:%a:i& érzvegtégatéczra, This definéieﬁy §ndéga.ie§_ thaf..§€'c2;seé'"§'€§%;.§S:a.,% aﬁzé V2 hag cangpérw émw Accugeé Mal g?2z:>V{;!'E'~;i_ le,*'z_§e;" i§*seA_VV§%Qf:.1séVf;t%zraugh éhejja and baécgrrg am Lsreies'$_}é7%;::C;;..§,;@&§V. £F\V£"c:',..;f'»v%ir9§;""€>_:":'¥:eé thee aséséiz sf her hugbanﬁ and has keg: EhQd§:§,r$."§ﬁ;fen;"'ii§€5§a$'V"§mp0s$ébEe for Acséggeé H021 to ga§§*sé§;::.i:'-%§; :t€:.bé"-:§_a7' V:"0.{_i£rrf:V ;f'+,~::é:z3sed ?\%G2, The Qraseeutéan W&S afbvée-::_é;.'_esi'&§E%_S;E*§ i:?';:E'3"<kié:*ﬁ'e;:%é9:Sia§:Ce as wek E ?E' "?£*:€ «Ea:-:§:*:'2e;§_ '::.9::j::.%:9:'§:?:{ '~%:§§ the géefeszw Q€§"S§Si€&"tE§';i bmught 5:3 ¥:E'e_§ m%ic&_ <3f..f%:é"§§Ifa:§i;mi that iha gregeauiéam mi: §§'§:'é Ef{} g&if.%?*s:.,'»:-%».;@a~£§jr*: m3ri€'s?"'§r 'E391: markg fezmé 5:": ihe baimny ma'€£ §':e£:* éﬁikéijczsgéﬁ E'x§a,:.£ T%':e:re'%s:*a {ﬁg <::§r£:;m3%:an§e :i "§=::::§; E0 fa'Ei__é;§' ¥:E=;ér:».§_. és Em gaéezziéféc ezzéﬁemca F?":§§i€§"':§E'E§ 392$ mim .. ;%°;:_j:.a:j§:é:~;.,;a:~ fee?" EEEEFEQS feasné rm 3% a:%":$3Zg'a aaé ba<§::@n32 %;':i§§'Z§'?; ma': 9%' V' '£§;»:::4e:§"£_>7;% 115 :36,' The ieamaé Aéda S9? wag justiféeﬁ in saying thaié»-E53529 §€'GS€éCEf{%G§§ faﬁs Ex? gei the exgerfg egénégra regaré§_rj'§'E«E:_::;-- f§;é:i"'_ marks, it wmﬁé net}: vxaaken the C$S€ 0:? rim m§:3a2';:--'*é§§fE"=§.,ai§*;~z..: I53.' Samar: :3? mg cmterztéaa, feameé éecéséen :3? the Amy Cami in §E'2a_ caSé._V €':"§' G£'2€.? EEj_: wsawsagaga .213. STATE 3? 212,79. rei§or%;ed_VV§n '{;aé--::>;§:'}5 é;s;<::£ 2&3 wheraén at Qara§:agh--21 it is afé P:*es&:*:c:& Q? a fs;";§_»s?';'QVr:§9§;it :&E' "'t§"'2%s::V..';_:s£e:*:e 3:' §C€LEE'°i'§£"3C€ is 5?: «;:« 9 s€.§:§a;é_ €'§'§'§r~é§R€E::;""§E$2.§§ _i:§§@* abgermé 3? a ?E2*:ge:jm§%::t;_ gélé..';'-_vr1§:.:_V-$%é'a_gg'%: ~ f:s:3__ farecﬁage the pregemce sfti}?--ggsézsfgfséng-.§§§§*s<:..."§;ff2Ve:£,:?at ihe 3{:€§'E€s if daréng igje:*$é€:"g."$é':.E0_;f% i§? -€::§:'e§_ _:;'E;°2f;§ the féngergréni Q? the ca§§§:%i.;: '%:':§£,:'%;:f. Veramiiieé at am SCE'*E"%E?, $2 is =3qa,sa§£=,}*g "é;:>;3s5é§;bé2§Efﬁy" '§".%i.3€ such a remnant wmgéd "sat ":es':*s§t.i':e*:;:?__V3i' aévf, Piﬁfiﬁié abgence 9%' fingar '*::f§3pr':e§S§c;'-:<1 mt a§'""§i:;ara;2iee 9? aﬁseréae mg §:§*:% ._a'e.~*,;rts5{m 1a:g:re.;r' €é_:*;r1gVés§. at ithe saene, }'Z?. '§:T_:é%m,t.?2éj;,-iiégsguggésgn agave; Em €€§f"§'*=;*'§§"§§i%$:*é ééii-"*é€§§"§ §'~é@3;::.___é.%nﬁ 2 wgmci déiﬁiieégz Enééigié the gragaréce sf §'=2.<.ﬁ::az$"e=-5,? V?~;§ss4;": ané mgr? abgancg «:35 {:Q§3§"E?E"?"s§§E?<}%"? af iéée gaém «:7 7 __ / 4%:

117 {Ewe revaéver, Thég $3 ggskere ta by 9V'§~?4 anﬁ the \/{}.§§;.%-§'ff%f;7*?_V§"}i giatemerzi :3? ,s5'§€CEi$€€§ N31; E'"i'3§£iC€'ﬁ is writing £5 Qna Pw-M« - Pemmaf zsazag am 3 wéirsess ':0 {big reveéver was ééerztified by PW«?é%«. Ex,PiA.4 §5..i;*.&§j*:fia= :<rj%%§a'2éé*':;Lsf§é'e=:§: whésh $43.19 ---- rev€3%ve:*' and Eve Ca;s"'£t:.i§_;ﬁ§e i.?a:§z*?e :*er:~r;i;'?Mt:.*%V§'e=}§..V fihéy were kept in segamige cgmrs and se§',Vi7e'<£:'»}' _VVE~'%CV):'.';":1~«;§._VV:$.'ra;fV':as ggierztifieﬁ as We €';'§¥"fE"Edg€ gazed a§ "¥"h'é"e:zE§er:<:e csnfgms S?'£$G§2§§"1Q éegmseﬁ 3 revgﬁverx Yhe evégegm cf Pw'%g§i'j::ji1én_é1--.2%:';%5i::t§£é%}é"mé Fvéaaiﬁ am 32 were recmzereé at: and but 5:}? the géctzzgeé 5;j;>.";"vj':V%,.VE"}C¥§"§E3 wsufé haw came ta knaw §'«"s<'§$:3:¥§::* V é:**sﬁV Lmﬁer the grsurﬁ in a ﬁeiﬁ. Yhegefarg ébﬁ evé¢u4€'é:[email protected].é' §§%;'s:."f;4 am 1%; ganfirms §'€€§§%.:'€s"§ af rv§§? :5i§.,g« rié:*:;%a§..é;'ér"-and ~ Ewe carmﬁge at the mgiance sf"

§<'::;:§*&_1€§'"?fAé;C¥.'f: V:»>;"{:»,;:.:% ;é:.§$@ game er: m::r:;:"@ ma: ﬁecéagaﬁ £s§z@E<;

L{;'§vg;»i:§eéam=:§a1§ mzﬁéégzféé by zﬁéng a revaévar am Ebuééet injury wag

-4':?7§}::f.r"2i2:@E:*§, er: §':%§,§%:esi as Mr" éaéwe evédeace 9? {ha éacim" aréé afgs} °:a-:_V%f:i:..a§';:'--: af~i§§ré"';3? the dateaggé iméuééﬁg ﬁzjzmggé §%3{:"2';:

ﬁuiéei ihegi sf 3% éeceageé. "ma zageri @§ ?"'-:1§:é?::"§': "'E"§*2§ raggri 0? Evmgeiﬁ mg 32 :5 3?: E24. 9 ~ 1&2' V .,_E'%§::;.":{,}% Egg qeass'2*:r;~r%r2a<§a fsreérm gas ﬁf? tﬁe ﬁgia Q? iegiéag by .53."; V /1 118 8? Eighth aircumstance {Exserﬁs aniniom:

1?'§. it was argasw by me :§€f€§"":r£8 aim behaéf ma: the evééence sf W'v%78, f§E"EI'E§§€ §~é--:<"§e:-ii whether E»-'€0.23 wag the revga/er murcéer ;i"x$h0§< Qufttedar. In the e2..?n;*i.;{.§f:":'1=::fe 0%"P3354i?T$%' :%€é V»Eé'3'?réte$ 'V 'ihe eﬁazaatianai qua§%fEca'§£Gr:;_.§;*;é ¢;x<';}éE§_:erit@€_.hej ﬁ§:a'::A §'é;Ef'2€§ at Centraé E-"arerzgia ,§c§ence £nsE'§4i§Q;f:a*', «gm exgaert with :"eq:.:é§£'s:e expertige Err §§:'v3,arm§sf;é:*:e%;2:;;'rr§f'§--Qn 'a:'".=:d éngasrigs aauseé by firearmg. Aftggs §"c;.§_v§Aﬁ§':g:';V--_V§he;:% ;§%§:;»:2EV§:-:"_Q:'§_:'E?§€=' ariiﬂas he receéveﬁ frem Mahaiaiz;s;hmé_A}"a.gg';§§;:::: £?GE»%:¢g:;"A?*:fe';;efaa;:$ :9 me deiaﬁg G? each articﬁeé E-ée a"%;§E@' 3;": E:§':e iefi awe? gar?

and {ma z'ev0%2§é':*._'_ b£;.§§é%i._a§fVA'._v{},§;: écaiébaei, burnt skin, arm fiva r:E":§.%";rj§er&;é«.%:A:%é*~§'eE2§ergV.' {;:-:%:e£V_____;j:fsé%:;<; f°§§'§é §;%a§§§e{ $3? $.32 caﬁbre; sane §w$f;>s_ Eéféiréyeréfy ha-még of the éecaagad aﬂé we fémd :3;<afr--;VEn3:éo§.%% §§'-- a§%' %?*:e €ﬁ8€E§"§3§ excegt §'rv-@515.) M revaévez ans? VE:sz;.§§&%:"'rem9v§§§ frag: {ﬁe éngzgrg §E'"€ at Ex,?138, $3.33 wk;'<2?<{& the cage sf the pmgecutéen.

$20 rgéezxant aﬁﬁ Si {M63 as unﬁer:

?W$ 4; S and § have béen cragswexamérzeiﬁf.

iength. Excggt eiéaiimg $3335 smésgéanss én r"e§§.{:.%i:t"§:f" i"*--.u ' minﬁr ﬁetaiis they have net been sﬁ §ai<e2*:,, « the meéiacai evidence and the '€«.$.€i":}ie§1§;--e:_': respect cf nature af the we apa%{s*_ ;§f?:2:i; '~§h=:* distance fmm which the S?_1_fé't:s; were fE:¥'€:*jV,' csncerned, W3 :19 net came 'a:::¢.sks a:'1'y._:Tsér§Q'§;rs infirmity in the QE'QS&£iEAi'ﬁE@'ﬁ cf:'1ié'§A*"§4'E'§éi;'L3§ct§;*,VV'Pifx;? 3 Wm mnduz:tet?_;" t'h§ V1.*p:a5§:-mcttiefnig' =§.t:_a.Vi:éd that the ingzsrées fauihéﬂ_€«.r€s"""i;,;}3E%:_e: "@j::ﬁéa$é§_§"'v.;m:3'st have been Caused _hg.a..fi_r9éa_%h9§'$:;,_gs-é' :§"é'aEterVV§f»»§fac:t same peiiets aise wégfe _§e%é "§€}i;st§%zi_::'fm'm "'%:§f3_e. baﬁy, Therefcre there game? bé Varéy é::;»§£'3ii1'i§'ééi..;i%2«s?~~"férearmg were saw. He was ::rass~«?exa'min:3dA'~.vbuign' he asaerteé am: the §§St;a:5-3:8 §"m:':": :$$§'*-;:?;r§ iiize §@§E8'€S were E"€C%'v'&F€ﬁ fmm ﬁne_»ér:*:§4'&§j::"§":::;9:.2;'2ﬁ an the heaﬁ may Se mare thaﬁ .;_3:féé 3%-;<=*;AV%:"§%:;;;.«,2{'r_fA2,e§ iﬁésg. 3 arm 2 zﬁsara ézauseé fram a ve§s*§g"'EC%e5@' ;5;f:s';§e: Er: agiaw 9? {mg gagiiéage @\!Eé€§"':C§ 'V aiggnéa '?$.{}§%:é: 9? im resevereﬁ waaggng $3 gas' me i .L'b;3i§§$t§c'e§<pe:'t§$ eaziéencﬁ mam mt have been uséé, "'%:a%:a::".--"ay étgeﬁf gg mi a germg mférmétag, we ' eggiewézmggas Eiaasa €;$€€§€%E"§£a§§';;' stiaiaé 3&5? ce::s"a::"y~ *, é*%2a§$ géaieéa. was ugeﬁ ﬁﬁﬁ {he mgaéaaé aviéééncg ?ara@;"agh~? Q? the saié éeaiséan is §%¥§§$& 'ma%%§ § ».-

W "

12.3.

shews that the deatt; was date ta injuries tauseé by firearms" This asgect has tees": CG§"§S§d€£'F€ﬁ by the Sasgéatzg Catstt tr: éetaéttzttﬁ it has mat: tigtttty {}b'S€E'\:'€§ that the gttatg haw teen ﬁrm fs'Qm.f"--- T ccrutttrgwttiade §i$€:t:.si3., There was QVEFV passtbiiéty {if the tstzlﬁs gauged being sfightéy bigger than -1- We have carafutty gone thttmgtt the eviﬁent:t2¢.,'_'éjf~..tE*::t9:»::' ._ eyewitrzesseg and teaserts giver: ti§"Vt?*:e« txésa far beiievirtg their evidence, Vie $'t-ze 7éb's*@EL:'te§°y.,'mat gtmmds ta some is a7<:E«§..t_Vferet2:t. 'c;3s1e:§tj':=i.§.<::.s3.,_VV Atcattﬁngfy, the aggeais are é%$'s'n.§A$V3$es;i.

81.. i.£arne§i'"3j§3,§"~tg";i%_£§.;er; the §eCt$§«::}n at" the ﬁpex Cami i:st"tt:::e;--.:V§-ga:;;e 5??"€,§t;i'§t,t3'ﬁH;§§{ﬁtat'V:§ttxiGt~§ DVS. Stﬁffﬁ G? ﬁttttﬁﬁtﬁ t§§tstt7r:;=§"%:;'t 2-ttttatettt at §af"§§F'§§t'§S 1% and 28 Et $5 tgeéﬁ xatS'«.V£;.EFE'€§;é2":._ A t ﬁaftia §in<:§ta:$ are gattstéeé that t'§"t€S@ tam "::_0'Vt:Vt:e"r:té;§':2'$ %:5':<§"_';g~:etE-- §GE;ﬁﬁ€§; arm have examined ttie "j;3<§eat:¥§'f_ éﬁétmaefente §t3t"$%§Kf€S 33$ it": tttat _ V . ttent{é<:tt:§tt§":3§e have C§t"§SE58E'"§§ ttte stat gtztéetzta Vét§.§V;:.:ce:d"..§3;\; 5i?°"i8 gtﬁgetzttitm. it Es tttte that Gttttiév atzé Qtztttzatgtt §§t'§§§"% tar": tg gaétt tt 3% *T--'Ettt;ete$te§ WE§§"£i3ESS&§ antt tr: that garage, ttzeit éaétéstzce ta ttta azstémcat :3? §§t'i§$?&t't ttttneggea atzé 6-5//ﬂ $23 a siéckg H-zywever that may ﬁe; ﬁavéng regaré :3 the E§8Q§.§§t"T€€ af evenigg H: 53 émpogsiéée to accede 'm the argument '{§'%§% Surahasarz §mgh fired {mag fmm the firewarm iv; awe? E9 Savé hémgeéf, Para 26. In thg Qmseni: cage, res ugéfuf maid have beer: gamed by examining an expe.;fi---- 'V'. the purgase sf gnawing that the gufrximhaﬁ b€'3&3¥':= '-

by Surjii Sirégh, because, as vfe painted mat, Dafjiéii Sirzgh t@o§<Vca§*@a%:=;r;a; »'§«;:<-gép E§"°s e_ gg§';,;:r':: V' wéth h§m§e£f far over a week,'§§é'{§~Vc.Vt%"'zéh' s;urr,e%:v{.§e3"gj3¥(§*"

it, it wouid be ééie in such a ca§é.,ﬁG .$;:;gg7e'§;;¥i _t'§":a'»':}§'t was neéesséfy 4g::§'f;::')'g::4%3;€;'%_;:-?:§e9r;§§ iii} examine an expert V-e'~;?'ie*::. f:;;:;>a.:é§E§&"--é§"»E,$"- e><€%7ém'é§y Lsniikeiy that traceg iig' hb-i:_ 'b-eeti ramaszeé by magi:

3§§":gE"': §é§<,;5r4"€:. §"£f§. it "fhenf ag Ea S:,::"cE*2A3%ias3 S§'§§':=:~§:3\"":,V.§i':'« §s '.a§é*%2étteé thai he fires: '§iW§€jE ._vBf§'%£§._'§§§;EE§j,E_{V.iZ'§__§3Qt§";§§'§'§'§..__.€}ﬁ' the recmﬁ ta §E*s0w iihat me iﬁugéieg_ §:.5::§§5«e§ ﬁg; tizg mgr rmrtem {gates anﬁ {E-e;g:::3_:%;»e:5Aa*'v~.v4§':'@ E59.-iihe a3§:::a:' gmﬁé mt have man cau';~:_§é E§§~§ a "§<;§.:': whécié, it was aéiégﬁﬁ, 'aseigngéd 5:5} '.Vﬁa:"}:;;':":"$g§r;*:g..E: grzé whim wag ;::%<:é<e{§ upe my Surcharar: V. S§E"":§§T} afEt1@:*%?:fe§§ dawn fmm hés hgnﬁg. Therefamg is"; .w~M_"3m%~'_' J ' _ _%,?:é*»€%.:9g*:.:n":§:§§é£e$ $5 ﬁéig am, we ﬁe eat :%:i§*:§»< it

-. w§€:;:§§ 15$ gaggmée is §§<:e§§: Em {ﬂea mat mg §'aEE:§§"§ 'La? 32% g:>§e§a§:;%:§${: ii} ﬁiﬁﬁfﬁéﬂé g Eaiiégiéa away: $252 aw 125 83» The éégauggian made by as an mm as'"a;.§~V. é~:».x%e:t-sf'); airaumgtmaa zégaaiié reveai am: the §ra$e<:::§ien__--*§g e$'§;'a§§§§h me éﬁiegétémaie éntémgcy §etwa9_;52,,§3;:£a;s--5e5é'E*<§::%§;i°a;%:§V ' reveafatim': of such Eéiegitémaie §n?:éma?:::y ;'t':;..'T'dé::?e3s;éa§ '§r{s-%j51i>{ Gzsiteéar ﬁead ta wnggéracy be{w@:%V::"--A,.c§u$?evrix£'é«ra:s$.i 'aA's3;_{;....yZ..%:s:3 dc = L' away E/:£'§%§"1 the Eife of Asiwek $iL_2ti€éaé"ff__L'_L:V;§;'s::__t§':gé;y h.éic3:;3iE._a;¥:V$D§of Ewing tcrgethér after' {he death ofV$:--:.§.V%ﬁo,5;'A-VSu%.;z:§§§"af': the msgertées §aft 'mféind by Ashak £3r;:t§eaa;3;-:5%;:§;s§{s:£A.:'»§?3i'{}:2_ garaiiing far ma appeﬁzagnéty is graﬁ was very Ram:

an ﬁccused E'a%;<2.22.Tvsé<;2_:"§*§e*%'ic;;;:A.£:§wa%_§e'-;3'r§§&~:<%:é.z;>'é befere she feft her inw iavzzg mam féii g@?§a§- V";*"*éV§'§~..L:§3é§4 '<;§§é::§rz's%an<:es am grayed $3: the §§"G$€Ci§iEQ§'1 Eé::_§'1" am. éa,{_e?':°yz_".."'c:?rcumgtance ex§Ea§ne§ abové wasswéd revaéié E':§2:~4 ;ﬁcC::"s--seAGf,___§?s§§vsK1 am .2 cmspéreé :9 §<EE§ ﬁeceaseé §s$§éa§g§§ G;i;%:ea:§§:n.A _a maﬁa: 3% fat: ihe €VEﬁ€?§";CE3 Q?" 9%-21, i'= f:*§€m§ '.::s' ':i.e'€é.§a*:é'%:%':f§. V;i%iT-'*:z.,.$§'"z§.%<: Qasitéséﬁar weuié észﬁétate that éﬁhﬁx sijéssagsgels ihés M5: mgwgz. Ag a 7?'§:s'::::«z}§ar %.z=;?§:>:f*:%""i§c€'§é§$ ér°s-Eaws hmgsg at E\s='Ea?za£a§<§§*2,:'2"*:§;m;;*a;":: s2:§::h Si; 1:-.%§mViV%.s§£0n éf his ﬁrgi gen ébhé 2:": we gsfsaaé 5: Saw. maiigr $5 faéi wig: m ﬁég V .._:;§gé':.V'é9éSanga§§:;re, ﬁﬁiéﬁﬁﬁé éshek igéégiieéar as-gag in we :§m;:»a:::g 126 Q? Ei>W~«21 ami Em aisa reaeiveé phcne caéis {rem ﬁsecaised ?a§:rsavathé agkéng for her hugﬁand. ME Em sérazgrngtaiéﬁeg--«%:;;'f§§E.:.§- : _ §33%%F'E§ mg? guéét ﬁf Asziused $303.: arsé in %:,h:3_ deceageés Name 3?" the iércumsianceg 39$ égémgfévsisiérjé"--w'it~?y..?%i§%2e'3;T.' gasiét Sf rm accuseéa They aii g0§ni.»3E..é~.c£L§'§s::é " .?'%§VG$.;vE'y :L;} §"¥'%:Ci;V':.V2, §era,;saI 91' tm Judgment 9? the triaf C;r;V:r:VL4:L';"e«*.:§§_:v.r'*:.::*,;':.,:icVi§' §':1§t%€:§£e':i;hat the tréai Cami took pains 03? d%s;:.:x7:s:s_éAn§;; _»»eve:;yVAVre!evant matefiai ané hag graperify C0ﬂC§.:§5_§*{§ reasaningg the gaséft ef A€:<::,:s@'a3._.:vF§é'£<>:§:;L;:.i_V agsaﬁ fénﬁ any gaeﬁ? gmzmd to differ friem' tvfiai' Cami, ﬁzcaardingéyf am gasg Em f:§E§@wE_'réfg§Tvi'V_--vV .------'--'-"'-'-*"&'J€§:2' ﬁgfé §.,.'.w5V..>?'§.f Aﬁgé

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Subash Patil S/O Tukaram Patil vs The State Of Karnataka on 7 October, 2011

Bench: Manjula Chellur, Jawad Rahim