Karnataka High Court
Sri Mallikarjuna Reddy S/O Chinna Sidda ... vs M/S National Insurance Co Ltd on 20 January, 2010
Bench: N.K.Patil, B.Sreenivase Gowda
Q:
fl
§
£4
5
g
$3
3
E
§
3
;
§
:
3
§
3:
E
i
3?
5
2
E
g
E
» van» -um '4lWE1"b'$'«' W :4 wmrwm-mnn m<;A'"vux4V"Ii:a'\4;c<"m, r; a
%'a~..WW@W W?' Wifiw Cw"?
53' B $RE
§¥ "EVE-E3 HEGH §{}{§§'§ Q3?
mwn 'FE-I13 ':"HE am my 3?
Famgyr
TI-E 2-mzmm M, JIfi'I'1$E Z<§1.--f2'i;}§§'£¥.'jfi.s " V' '
#33
mg HGRELE mmsricg B.
msias. 219;: :;§??; ggaiéfgezxfi * --._% _
BKEWEE:
'
sgmcnmmsmaaxgam; "
AaEn45's:'EA%;_;" ~- *
E[fifi':1'€$;'??4;'F
17% '£?*§AII*§R{'3_¢§33§ .
53?: B§xQClK;_ 4' _
{BY fig S E. \s
V _E§§$f';«;!§ij¥f£{'£{3§£.;%LB}€8:E§R&§€E 6%, Lam
~. '=§§§gi§?:*::§§':;§«;;;£'§«?£{3E-3. §£§§
% - "(ESQ
'
, Bfis.Efi%§§RE~$®
~ : %ERE§';-3*? rm afizsigmg
213:6
vmtmm-vemvuvx-msczanmm wan
"Gk W;m'%W%éR$fi$ WE zwmmswmwmmmm an-awry»-wwrwwwg .Wm-wwwwumm-wwmwwu mum
E*§Q."?$§ $33 3i5;"'CE§S$§ fifigfi $3'?
E§'§'.§§a 1.AY€"}¥J"?§ Efisfififisiiflfifi,
mm ms; 13 F333 figs M351; 0? mi AC'? &GA;£§S'Fj'£EE .;.
§i3fiG ' 53% AWARE mrmfi 4%.-éfifififi P£&S$E3.3 =§~I__}s.§*s;€: _ : '
§@a§738;{§% 32% THE mg 01? ms XVI§&BDL. JY}D_€'.$r.E; 'mfisfifia,
gfimfi smcmsirr r»Z";}; 'mt;K5J.,_;m?raQ2=fimi&3§'»ARE A,
Emaamm fiflififigi-$3, Fagin' A:?;:¢z::'~er.r'n::~:;*1'aa:_":.":r;._
fifffiflfi ESE CGf%%'32°§'EI§§ ARE SEEEZKG
QB' casgmsaszxszg. V
mm mm; cams c§--jézt;%_a Hfiaamzg '-.':~fi;:§""i>za;9:',
::..;:c.m*m J.§ELI'JEREB ms Ftf3L£.G'§ffii*l.'gG:~ *
'§'i':.ia apwé I33: againsf. the
iwymzea award dam
§4m»,2se§k, 9:: the; £223
9:' am §§f§%'§ lMem,bwer§ mm amiam:
Arm, Bmzgalfire
3 £31'
tifm gmsmxfi iiimig éihé wmmrfiatian «ef
in iawur af 3%
. ff
v 'fix mm af appsiiani Eefméa 2:13 "§'ri§3:mai was
[ii &Efl'§.:'§f. 45 yeam mzé Warlézg as
M-n=.Wvo In wwwmw -mm" --awmm-mwmnmmm-- mmwwv wwwesm Q--WM#"""!'%.iW%E"'%;M%fi%&i% %"'W'&§9W V..;-VWUWE" UW"Wfl&Km%§'m'%% "'W§WW
'
Ra3?§§%}=- yer mezziihg Be that an it may;
23,m2wa ai afmu: 12.39 39323.? the: agpe .[:
fiawfiizig almig with his amaze; mmrgmg f
bagging. 59,35 91-K-.3333 as a §i23;i::»:i.41.Arii:};_§§*gV ?w1:wn% j
"vehicle wag Irma' icgn _V
Sa5z;;apz.z.ra briaixm mad, .. a
Eifagfifi-QQf'?G88 mm _zfa§§1 am
iifiligfifzt '.V "cycle, an
amu;-at af fiacture 3f
SW, 4%: wmnxd evezr
% eyefi waunfi mar right
wkk eta, : ghifte& '33 Gsmmmmt
§fi§:;_:pit&f»€g awmmg was: awn arld
::$3*:,Ja}1n§$ I-Easpitalg wimm he was
i V' fa: 3% 93% zzzzéezrwasgt an agfiafiari
* j§;:::;;f ;%mfim: im3az2m$ it Say Efi gaafi t§m§ Em Ema spar:
a mam af
Wwa>>!£\'FS mwwamm mu swwmwmummm msww 'é«.,»m«»mw¢°<Ls: M?" mMm;£'a§.§MMm%. §'"H%w£"§ mwmé
wnwfgafiwg ::e*s..2.r'$h_i% fem mg} iikwafercg he has ti; be
mmper$a*b& 2m,sc:zmb1}*.
3, Sr: asmuzzt sf 'firm smaimffigg
azzcifiiann the apgefiafit fiieé. thsa ?;.>;<'::i.E:'é:;--'z'.*zI_
fiéhni seekirzg wm,pm;£;zr;.:fim:*£'--._fif % V
Rs,}5,{$,Q0§i- agacimt the % T M s§a:a.
dam mama ma mmu? {Em
'£'ribz.maI an mmagms. aficr
wnsiéerfizg an 53.8 and
after ewideme,
a§&fi awafihg 3. sum af
§$g2g%3.§&Z.i':i % 439$ '?"% $1' warm fmm am
_v dwae xggf " éafia sf fi9n.
agzzaxztum $5 mmgsmafian awaxwfiefi
smut-"mwamw 2:
nmwmm wwwwm WK Bw%WH%'fi"*E%fW$J%.J% Maw-"W Wmfifiwfié W?
H VV Emw mfimgmze Eat sf
by the appaiiazxt Wiiifiii am
" ~ . éfifi
wrgsiéerabie lergfh {sf time: azrxfi gang thrasugh __t}3£
§°i12'i.3;§§S mgefi in tim mfirazzdzzm fif appeaia
S" fifiar mngiderafigerz af the subm.§1;5_{ayi£3--I1 9
jt/2é t mzé awarfi
evazuatm ar the swarm what
ewgm 33 that, it is 0f the
amidani that e3¢¢_1.:rz'fi §_zj?1'_ j_§*.jEia appelhnt "
szmtaimti Tribuuai wired
in awarding' IV 2:2' and aufiewzm
witimut that 1:122 appefiazazt was
acimizmfi gm. mafia: :§fé:::*:" 1:; 25 cam £2"; haspitsl,
V Lzz1&e:%§§::%2'z,¥: &r fixafiars. $5 sémpiaxits. The
gsmm gimbagcg at 55% is bath the limbs
- _:; tkm fimmant
whale mg;
am agerzy,
hsstimsmtureaaffszzjznim
"£131
fiim mmiiarafiam the mzmbar 9?
//_//
aauzmei fer {Em wfiw
R'8:.»k"'fi FA 5H$%fi'€fi K WWWM 99:1'! '~'\2'
w-wwwwumu xv-wammm wt4'wIsM
mxd,
n iifi Tfifi
days Em was trmtgfi as invpatiems in tézgz haapital, km
asvarfi a gum af R3e§Q,$§€i;'~ mwards
' £3 t Rs,3G§®$j»
&, 'Z''21aa '§'rib:.3.r3aE :s1i;:1:.i V
9:' §s,§,em;- tmaras fcgéid Vand
attendant C §, fiat
the mama that 2223 far 25 days
in tha has§§.:a7i;,' fiiatbn sf
imghnma """ vwaufi have spent
a@nai&¢:':§hk_~; I mnvwaxwc,
ma ma '§"}mrefc3:*&§ mg ciaam it 51:
$9 as: afiéné--.§§v§$:..3;§§Q%f-- iaawmfis. gmmwmmag
ahamaa' as aminsi:
fig fig Tfihmwés
in away
mg? & mm $1'
A «-- 'mmréa $955 af mm" mg dimmm" . Emtmmi
$2 Esfimiéfséafigg aha aygilgnt. was impaficnt in
/44/»
9b€t¢i'\'O»"'>X'.'§§ "3-<t"9ufl"\»z99fi¥.Ffl
-«W wwmmuwmtmfifim muémms wwmnm? we" mmmf%M%.$%§i§& M§%'..§%**§ %,;;£,%§%%";'¥" %A$5§Ma£»$§'flK% Mififi fifififl
é %%%k:»$;%§%FAA;::§e§pmg aim wzmm Eadga me agwmzz
..
thm Emapimi far may 25 fiays ans} hm undcrggm surgery fur fixmarfinn Qf impiazim. B}? Iaolfing namra as?' gustafmaed by Zzim, we $311 zzzfieré that? fig aimmlzi have taken i'e.1f§£w2§~f:.:p mm' am' am gxiéfi :3? $.hre§ 7T sf thse agwfiant at Rs$?,,5fiG,' gée R3.22,5G{3/- (fiafffiéfl 3 ma:-fig fzéaa of inmmzg dumzg' .'§Rs,1§,OG@j-
awarésfi by 3, in a.,wars:ii:::g my
R$.4{>§@Ki§¥,!~: -- aém$:fit.iw§ éiaaizkility fizé fiEEc9m§sr§*;=-- is . ta mtg firm: the apgxefiant was u.5z7n«m2.§' §'§ss:§a azfi gmrkfirg as fiapawiser as amiézanig Q3 amaunt af fiw ha ha: his if$%i '$23 daactaf Emg gss1a§e;:%%ka;iaa§;3;§: at 5% :3 was gm was wfi zghmztkig ifthme 'V V am mm: £3123 @$:3§.id®z'&fi$:'2, wag fiasem it fit ta //2 wwwmmm Wm mm»--wwmxwawmrenvmmmm->:s mxwewzac L»-mwuwmw '-MMWE n\a22%|r%.:Hiux4*«*:weIW.;iVz\;s"*\1<; alzxmiaeww MWMWW. awazré. £3. mm Gf Ra.,8§5§%G,? - mwards 'bag: :3? amersifégag éiaabiiity 31$ aifmmmims as agafm: Rs,4§§{}3§;3--,i !~"~.v_' awmé& 'my 'fix: Ekibunal.
Q. fiawmmr, 3. aum af 33$ taewaruzis 'meziicak ex§3er$es'>' is §1;$i£,_ &3'3fi 2 mm' Wm ta 'aim gm figs ' has prafitgmci medical bilfi; mi 3833 fer :9.
€:§:§a' réu = wggmmas'. It is 3&3: in §;§.§%'::§'7:'§$T3V -~ kw $fifi a .:§':;:% éfif 33 13% in underga 'Ti _ siigmfk E "inf £wEan*m; '$3 ma tim am. it gag ta ma:-a §s§1Q,§§§;'» $":.h$ nzwwxwab smxuwm /V "tn:2-'Wat"IJu<Hes"i'néb' W awmmawmwmmmm g-wwm mwmmz W?' smmxwmmmm mm»; m,;3im"a%" U?" m%.fiWfi;;Wm;& WEGH CW3? T§§3L1'*§5,_i@$§ sf \\ .
é fi1'£1& EL in fix ligm arf the faéts anfi crirsuxmtaxw asf the mm? as stahfi afimre} the appwi fifi by appdfitj is %::.sad if! Fflfla Téza mmmgn ~ and awmd &.% G-§~.€,'3~4.2§$§, _ \ '4 z~;w.c.1mé73s;99m, an am 32% ex' J11dgg Mmzhexg mm: K Béekaptyiizan A183, §S;€i';~$;V'E?'i51~€:¥}",:»L__.i5' gs-we-:_a;'; awaxfliryga mizm 9?
Ra.§,41,,%[ - at 5% gar axmum ¢:é§é: the date sf 1 gfitian ax:
« braak-2..;p is aa .':e'.I='l'. . féfifiwa:
"?awarc}§* Rs; 5% $36 }» _.v..T§*§§'a*:**§;s Lass"-w_§f_ mmizim Rae swagg- mi agmmfian WTafi?&.fid§..m@Eifiefi.3.._ex§ensm % R3,} 59 gm ;-
Tfiwavfifi xmuzffiifima Rm ififlfifli - f&a5s:3; gnci aiifisfiéani charg ._ *-2;: fi fififiififljn R3.,?5€§$ ' Eaamani a.
R35. 1% $09 [-
§s.3 ,2? $66 !« "Ms W W N m w» r: mwim :5 \2!:F'"fis as 3I"*'!a.i?'%..~;"'\¢: H sewm 'aw W M N § M3' &°"' 'E"n\«}<"'é.§"€ %?"2$»§"*"{» § fiafiflfla W 5 'R; €15? 34,3 3% fix Imurarzm fiampany £3 dimczteci in dapmit i}'3.% ': -.---av»-mé: camwxmafiszz, af §3.86;5$Qf~», with tizxamn at &% pm' azmumg withixz thzw wmfim A4 ' fiata afzmépt afz::a§§' sf fiw§u t V % Gui cf 31% d wmpxzsaigfiazg&F:3'§3§};i'3'G$;"f-%L,_'__V A with prspértianatc izztgrmt aha}? §:=$pt .§'f'n:éd cicwsi: in Elm mm asf the agwfiagigixz Efafiéinéiiéééi ' er so}-mum Bank far §czf£0r;§ }r:sf" gm rerwwahlas Ivy fififi years;-« .326 him to wééxfiraw the W aéf%'56,5ae;~ wéth in favuur sf thus await cf the ammuxit by fixe " .
x %%%%%% « Sd/g IUDGE % M/..
JUDGE:
mm