Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Shri Ghewarchand Surana on 14 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
' E. . f 2?
IE? TEE HIGH CGURT GE? ATA2{fi' fig'? Ef}a.E€*d i'§'§;':s; ?;}'2£?= i:~'EJ" <.%21}I 03:'S:¥€;;}1.::i=:z.1§r>m1 ';}3{} §1'E-'%§%3S.£ii'aV§""' A 5 THE §iQN'BLE MRu_;Us i:¥§: ?E N A. THE Hozsmm. Mfixmrfi B£€:'i"J\?EEf*J: V» ' V V 'A VL V' i Th 6 §<zfiz <f5:1":é%.: izzrkg: E2 V V QL§€;_{'.E'.3f.~"'.-; E-«Ea;-;:':*£_» ' Ej3';3.':':gg2gI:>';'<--% ' « . " L' r':-
N) Thr:;*; J{:<i':'1E:' C(3:12:I::f.s;sé:!§~e}::s;%:.° as-f E:';<'i<}§"m=«r fa}:
; ' * 'f:='.a'1'.'I:'1':',t'§/_'§f§'.V,V E3§.:z:{§2;:E §€a2'1___;§e.--2 ' ' C E? 33; :.::'Id ~§;-:.:.{:<im; EE-z'>22{i Ej:§;a:.%j*:gg2?:m_';°z=% . = ,3-='%p§3 f;E.§;.§£5i :2': 'V V 3:": C; Ei:22m.a.§2:{.§":a_:: ;'§a:§a.»'@<:22'i;@} '" °'1I':Ei2f£.§'E{'§ ESm':I;n'.';23:
" "=5§§;':€i€ {§at:%:;:é%2z-.<:"--*,<3.€E E33/' L,E€.<.--;;.§ :11. E:%3:':2r%5:2I:rfEE32:1E S:,::.§';::.n2,1 'S {s Ezazifi {T}E'2e:>s;a:*:%§"z.z:m.s:§ §i.§3";:i.E".a£% :%;;a'i:{i {flail E' E';
S;
i;
' - §§f;§{}§,{,;a ' 2.<5h.Vi.<":V'§'§ '- .. as " %:':&v';j:_t~§<:% i~sE':{;:,z§<'i izszzvss ::E:':%<:'§é:':£§ ihs? 2ZiSi%€SS§1'"i§{ :}€§"i.:':t';": $¥e'§'fl1é;'.1,\E'1€;?E.' the 2:1g:};}ct§§z1i'£é E:XiiU'Z{}E'iiI§€?:'é': :vmf*£% éé:';}".:f::%<::I. in §'2{)I.<:.E§?{:g.;; ffzgzi. ilhif ¥'E{)§_i€'f.'('§ $5,"-.'%§€%1.E€{"§ ':=..§}f"§£§'i?;':_:"'$65?-?.:§(iE¥) .2 58136 0:" §..hr3 mg, M22. :5-:_':2.w..:駧;:r%"V-g:;§:x;.::-gig;':.h:f§"' e.15ss:&:$sz':e: 35 é:§;;:§;.:e; i',m':<::'"£:.e:> Vi £1.63 ._ E336? ;."%;%"£§i:":':_ ;)§"i'n<:{§I'1:<:>'.
£1'1.<.:"2::E'E:'§ arui v;:{m$ér<;LiE3:kT1t:E}?EE':é= :' . ' .'¥;{.:':51'}"£E?ff'2' _,;=§'£;:a;';{.% 222:'2:2'mHer(:i {7*££?'Z€:'§'}E":".~;E?: '€__§*1<;* 215$-$E?L'5ii§Ii:t1i£:?;f' {§fii}.{;f.fif{' sgI°2'z;'11:E--:::§3; §1,1:'§hc:é:' i..i:'11e of c%igii.1;€%i:z': §1'1(}:i'13'h::§":j§}? " -"s:.z£:":g,§ §'r<;*;:e"~sh 1m£i<:::3::=€-:= zméi .:E."1e1"<':.;rz'§¥.'e:.»1'_:é'§"::€":2_ssS;es:s$<2%{:%"fiE'e%«:§ file i*€.'E1i.1§':'1 €31": 29~a~;.9':::@é., ' 5 x 'a-%:'h=,:,i.'E:;§:%.1" fE_.he:$ ' 'y:':{;§.1'A'<:.:§%'-._ :$3":;z::%c:§ 1.2.§:dr3:'z" Sr:;>.::*:i€m. 3}jE=§iE3%{f€;:}{i.}'€:§['é3r;e I/§¥Z."':¥'.1,(1Ei.§§E"1"(VV}fl "be £::'e=221i.::~.{§ as §r1;aii'.<i 1 _si:?:iC:t.: i':.T::=-~:;z:;>i~--.'i-tags«oz-' '§:ig;j%1E.&é:%:'1 m<)1':.i.h.s».: has bass}:
"toézhé'-21s:;a::%és'é':e 2:} {He {hrs :*€:§1,:m {sf i"E"£{":{}E'E1E§ .1???' --- <i::>§:1§%>'z*'m§'{'j; Wm': i:§3:'- §nE,.e1T1'E ami '§sm:";::<>ssé="vA{}i"b_*£:E';s3j'£7>;§<ri a::::» <é<>:'2.E.<:%z':n;'3§a'1éstd mlsietz.' St":<fi'éi<}:'"; 92:-:-3,;:3.~§" me»: ;ix;:}.::?
x QR " .
_ i?»»'"._h<:?4;E2e':f f.?::* 'a.:"EE:»2.:z32::;': 21E;'ée:7-E' $3:-3:2-:£.§.ni.>* 'é,?':€ E"§.<}'§.:?.{7i':
.4 , $3 W:
fir: p;1§<;:$ §.';*cz$}§ <é:":.§m' £2?' 22;§s:;§;%§'-,::e::2.:<::2.':?:. in a<.%{7<}:'{§z?::':{:::% H' é&?iE,§i1; .§;2:w«; E3}; ggzfi-"i:1§g; :'%51_}_€3h §,i§E'3€: fm" 33%.? E}'i,i§E'}€},':§€ :25 {'fE}E'1'1§}§.iéZ§E'§ 5:6'?
:21: ?.f'zc:>,ri1I:'_:;. z'*2'e?m,?z:»x fifée? :?2':ii.I'a> pr:;}::fe*€:i:';'z.g;:%; a.2""«;.> §:2:ci::i. Zaua T326 m}i2'{?:e.> aE;2~§r":.z'I.:'.<> z.><}z'z:i.
3. ii: v'i<>.v=;: {>5 '3,.E1é-2 r:-:.§:>;"<i*s-azizid j1,:gi;§;§.:I';€1'zE,-' iii' ;"i"%§73,i-97, <:Eéru--.§§%.V21§:ai:3 itiim i',§Z1"1€;'. s5§',ip§,::§21'£.€-réi fizz {Em :"m€E<t.€:+._ z':3_":1:;§9;" S:=3c:;§{'>i"1 1 E~3{_ii £5; "
w'ftE:§:': E33 £32133:-'s §.i.1::T1€-3 ii. fies: v(}:i'{§ 'ab 3:131}-{:3 '.E'h<%1'$é:.'£..{.3:':<}j;fil'.j,z3 had .31:
_j'ur§5¢;€ii<%'¥:.3L(3:'2 E10 h'1iE.i2:U[.<-3' §>;'{}<':ee<:1i.:?:g{$ Frlfiéd i..?"}'t;','.'(}i'(T§€TFf§p£1SE§{?C§ in :3; p1*<><7e€c§§:1g5 whizéh is-3 V:.»'----:c.';;i1:c' E.:§»_2,1£...<7;:; f«:<1;§._(;i~ .,;:.{s~.~E_1:%E:i by this C<:m"§'. in §.1'§.t' z.:.fE>3'es3ezi€§ jL:€i§;'1I'2€:1E.,.._ '-
4. E¥';};f-i_ t.§1j:_ i2:.iV{;>:ré:?:;T%a';:§_ r<3_.<1:%r{;:%:z;<§, '€.Ei€tr£: is; no .m.€:7;'.2Z¥;, in {his ;1:}j:>;3£:21§.A 'F'§":<--3 5:-Eiibf:;'£'.Ei§'i'1i駧E"§§§.I€?:§S§L§.{}}': .:3f«v§;1'xs:' gm:-:m«-*€1*e3:E in f2a.x»*:;=§.::' of ééfzs a:=§5~5es:~:;€:€ 21:33 ::2,§,§2:1§.':.7..§sI;f' .{i:;6: "§"._e;?i&:;?;"2"z.:::. Ae:?€6<}:*d§:;g;§§y. Ehss?
zgypifireéi ES €h&?%§"IIEE.E-SVS-}€;'v.{i« "%2/ %%%%% gggm §¥§§§