Karnataka High Court
M/S Skol Breweries Ltd vs The Deputy Commissioner Of Commercial ... on 20 April, 2012
Author: B.S.Patil
Bench: B.S.Patil
3 4 Lszzrzzsci 60313236} 53: ihfi §e:iiéa3r2.€r; 22?; zhfi a:2§ise!;, s*;i§:>;z1ii;$ éhat iélaugéz ihfifff is an appeaé proi./'id€& againgz thé:-.§.:;;;§;§§;;}ééA Srdsrz pséiirianas" is €f1§i§€fi 'L0 appmach 'LE/1i$ CQV:_1_:'f_A*{~--::sV gaggsd by fine Assessing QffiCEE' is: diréC'a§;i"'«s:§{f:*{:i§.:§:j$963' juégmsné; rendersé by the Apéx, C9Vur§;'é;i"-€:;h€ ::a's%':. <if BREWEREES 'T56 STATE 03 :s:ERA:.g "£15598: 1 si;:€:_$=43'.=ar§;i in grasg izieiaiisn 0f the manfiaés <:S:1j_tain€§5m§r: 5&2} 5%' '$23 £6'; 5, The iécis inxroiveé 'fife: the purpase sf examining by {he s'3€CiSiO:3 9f the Apex a:%§:iV :h€r€for€ tbs petitiensr is :19: Eiabés %A:%:?.;'?$f.._%»§>;9_'r:1Eate remsdy can be ugefufly szsiéd 3.3 z;;A:1':§_é':*i_ A b 1 A::£--:3:fdi:1gV v3f,GV"§;§'£€ §}fi5i§'£iQ§:€E', it haé azaéfired igmia: an ag;r€¢€fi1I€I2f'Ai%;s"§E}:AE§3;rna§a%<;& Siaig B€Ef€}"9;g€S C8f§§:'3.'£iO§§ Limiiaé éf::$fi§ 2E3€§8.28Q4~§ Srxésr 2:316 saifi a§_§§"€%i'IE}€z'"i?i1, $333 'gas? 2%sir';§€%*: was :6} $38 Sagppfieci ii': 'Q§'£é%$$ ii} " -'~i';€ 3'E"h€ 'gigs SGEE d§§'§'?§§}{;%§S§ :3? Eiiquar K1 'S16 =.Si3_§:£. _a;§"i£a:"::a%;a§»:a, £3236 <3? '{;"'£€: r:x3::fi§%§@::s :25 {he 5,;g;r§€:::€::"i fez"
"--.::%§h§€§": €525 aéé€mis:>:: sf Q16 Cimrt 23 §f'8C§.V§1 £3 'iihai; 'L116 KSBCL » ._\zé:'{;:::§& Eizaiga §§i'p8$ii égzwayég €333 E3::;s§§E€ Efid ::2:3é%:3'%,e{:i§ :9 rsétmfn {IE3 a:2.:=;%;Z*3:':1 313$ §£E{}EE§u, E22"; azfaszéé; 9%." §a§'::2"€: $133: gigs:
K883; 'U32 §"€EiZE'f1 éhé E:>a',>'£%;%:s wééhizi {ms zrzazzih this 322:1fi:%:'*--g%:aEE be ferfeited by {E16 psiéiiszzar. 'E'h€ :*é:Eev;/3:3: ::is1us§..i§'é.::2g invoice $9363 ass aznérsr:
"E5. Ail baiiies and Crateg 5:6 camgany anéi {be same shouki he re?;uf;1fe<i-- .150 :E:¢»é.a;=f;%1§>;{'ny'é; . facisry wit}1§n SQ dayg 51:01:: V:h_.fL§"~V.:§a:e uéf .__sug51y: V"":§?€<"::*V; Secuziiy 5159053: Callected by {E36 écthpangr 0%: éfgéée Eiisiiéeg and Crates Eififi 3:29 r€fur:£E$:§._}i£2 é¢?'§é"'§:i::5i;9m!d:*s afier ifzséesiien 0:? {bass empéy bettieg a::§4§'ér:::esL_ Vé;%fie:;g;i3g1t €316 game are in geed cendéiifin. 3?-::tf§;f::er§ --.iAi"=.:}":é 'f:::f:§§s%§f.betties and 0:363 are ::*..»;f.;:,9;:%-r:ec1fi:__ :.s:%§E',';§2~:3; ':§§é' :S;€:'};}f;;V1_;C~;€i€fi pgrieé {he depesii caiia: 'is:-'CE @315; $31233 "S'§:a1§ b€:.ffifféiéfid."
?€:iI;§<'2§1er; fiéeéfi }:€vi:'!.iE"i1.' §§Z'f' éhaaf 'gas; §')€§"'§G§ §:pr}i};§ 268? $0 Rfiarshg 2?} 3 § M Vc}g::i%:§.ng[' --- h " 'séiemgtéag an '$25 §§:;i;§:'€:
racsijais;'é;;:*::@vé:._.917:{Egg g-:r01é::& 'aha: {E3 same i"€§*I'€S€fF{€& saée Q5'.a:CC;%3%éE§::'*Eiq2,;s2" azzéwéiias sxempisé in Qrms Sf Eziérjg 34 Gf F233?' S_zifi--s§i';:§€'vf;€:».%:§§;: A33; 316 ezsmpziaa prevédsd 2°22 Efiify 35% sf §i:~g:%_ SsE;§§3';::E§3 'agpléés :9 hear, 2%: 563263 ..s ..s;J;;_ . K 3_ ,, ~,,'h_, » V.,.,,. 7;' 'f, $§~>v~r; zs« §§:§Z§U;{§z§E§: E22: :2, ; *3§:§2}3 :,g:a;}:€::: s,%.1'I{§ zriazéz; Egzségréing €15} *i;%:€ péiiiiészéezx f;h:~: £"€'%°':§%":'ES '€i,7€f€ déiemfid €52 .:"V§EVV€:'i'?a?f'§:,"' §€€f1 3;§::%€§:¥:€%<:§ a3 3352" Sfiaéian 3852} 8? {E35 ,?i.€%; '8f:§:3g '€§:€ ;::::r::;§'£'§{::n, f;3€"§§§.?§{}3"'§f3E'§§ b:s.3:'r:,6S5 §3r€r:'2§s€::«: "=Jv'Ei$ v§:e:.%.%s:§ 13136;, 315 {$33 $3.13 <2? 'Saar ané bc>E::E€:§ am 911$ 351$ iE':€.~«::)::--':;:_'1V'2${'$5323' {E23 manufgciurfir af éhe same has :0 pay asidiiésnai e;::C::%é sguaé is iihe vahze Qf She E:»e:>'£;fl€:~3, in :?;ié"1ig':<s:_ rsgard £0 {ha cfinditisrés ineoyparaiéfi ii: ihfi .a§:i'*€€:1i€%;;{;~..§:€._V coaténds that gals sf battle {aLkés'p_:§é2: aihvha i;_a:::;: :Q1v&§Vé':fZ{é "péfr :he ' igmns printed an 'she 0§ ihé' "F32g.v §§1V0ic€s.
Therefore, if {he KSBCL i%1i£;2jfj; 3333163 sitar €136 fixpiry sf 3!} daysfiiiégh &€g>dS:'§':é§: siané ferfeiteé ané re<:<:»gr:is§_<t§ bcstfies. Far ihis mason, h$__ 'had intended between %:her::s€1\r§V:s; {Q in bettiss far cgnsideratian ::*:de§&:1dem..§;f ihé §:G' a*:*:¥.is'* 211:5 seifi ihersin. 3}. in 'E316 iighév Qf-_:h4:--f: 2:i§?ie'ar€ aianci iaksfi by ihé Esafnaé ;%%g:i§;Z§§V§:2:5;;,a}V _CQ'V€§fifIi€E?§}____§»'§;VGC3§€ and "£16 §'€8.S0f1S assignfid by '§ihs €;77§f§'i:$:: E 31:: Q5 'aha Vififif ifia: ihis C§;u::"*£ 22,115; :19:
336 '§;;,:§i:§§:€d - '::<: :=f€a.p§::*€.c§a*':Er:g the aaéais Qf {E15 Qiauses :.:a:::ainé::~€3; E23 {E25 agresmsné iéiffiééffié '§:2§:waEe:2 {E36 ;:53i§é§_::::::s:: a::§ "§*;§f:.V§3€j§;' sud "$3763; $353? %.§T":€ §3_§€ §:>§; agggéyéag '£326 §:'0v:£§ir:;::2s ..%:§2§:-affiéi uaésr Ssciésa, é{2} 05 "£13 As: T335 scggs sf aygsaé
--«._:§::'a;:" ig avaékibée iii; {ha p€:§f{é£;::3.&:* 3,53 p:*92§'i&€zi uzfisr S';€c%;i0n $2 :3? 33:6 éisjéss CG§&§}E"€:{E€E3S'§'Z€. ?::%i;§?;.:'e§:@r '2..a:%§E, as :3z<:'§:%E€§ C3"
9% 1% f;
"W 2 WE E3 :10: be §::cZud€é in the Vaiais sf $316 Eiqzjer Eb? fins p:g1";;::_<i>5€ GE' Caficuéaiingg $18 agseagefilg éurnowz. '$316 assiigseé..§%:«ré/Bier ::::>{:iené«:~3d aha': {E16 <:a;*§:::sn.s were arséy S€CG11§%}'3! <::r;§iiiai:9i¢:%fs*--A::h--afE * Cauid :20': ihéréfere b6 incltudsd :%:_;...i:Ir1_c3 t:*:i'ii::Va:%§» <§f _"a€5-=j. Dismissmg éigf: a§p::%a.§, {E16 Ape}: C<m,f: hszlci figjhai;.::Ei€ i:r:§§§:*i}§§ii駧 idaa behind Sectians 55} ané figs"v.Eii€:aEa' §é.§:e:a§ -Sales'. L '§aX Act was that §a€i~:ed gsads fge i;2i§::;é:€i:v' :::s i§:e:r:p0s§'§e units, in Cgicaiaéing :heVz'é.1:"i1::fV§é: <55? {he Eurnmre: af ihs Caniainésrs Wifi 313176 mat maE§;€ aay éifferense, if VVf%'<}"";i1av€ been geld and Charged sepa:jsA:3§$I3 ?';V;j§§,7fié:} %:é eXem;ei:ed from iasx; :10 $3.); :3 E€\::%U§§ _ WEE} bs ihe pasifian even EVEST1 {E16 §;§:C{§§ are: said ans': Chazfgéé aeparaéiijg LA éawii fay {E35 Agsx: §Q3,i§,'§1 £2: §3%2'Z§1*3C§§®{E zafiéh {:g$§?:€.§'§E;.%§7§,€§"§é: .;'3;{iE?'§}{?€E.?;€ ;3':&£;§::;g fizaé $.'§::c*:*§ '»3€E%:':9; E353 {:{3i§€€é§€2:e {in $226 ';g"}:£°{:éJ1?s§31:%§*..C{;=::%a§::§s:§ in Eiésiziia fl€:":€:°&E $3363 "Fax A5: £3 %@a§§j:?:§;" 'ééé &:T;$€§V§3;;?%,§:$%2z:~%§ E3}? Eiigrzséé §:§::':§¥::'@::::a§; 5"
._flbf_aéif?5'§€pe$é!: 332$ T3133; 3:336 a8S€$$s:'€ ééé nai; éiaizzi 3:2}? ~ §ééj;éia:Ei§:: bafiéé: :;£'e§{:»s§é i§fE{§€f' gay s5f;a§;2~s§;.{."::*yV ;SE'§V§i§éC2fiS £0 exazzzeiien fmszz 362:2: 5;? £22,225?' aézéi; éghgsé :":€;:é::
Sf E3 §}€'E§¥§iOf1€E"'. ?his is; 31:3': :2 €8.36 9? iack 5;!' juriséigtiim"-:_V"<y=:f ':s;§%;:=;:*:3 ggyéncipifia 55 naturaé gaisiica have 2266:: véaiatsii i; :
auihariiy gs lifrzai, {E36 appefiate 2"€m€d}_I»$&1i: be 5?. Théréfara, {E3653 wfii §@'£if_i<:>ns 35¢ 'dismiss-&:%A." E§0izréi>"6::;ja having regard to the facts anfi éT'f%'§»'%V::.iVL','E':(3."i»5{;§§.§'L§"'{:~';_3V_€>' é-£36 and {B6 nisfié far the §€%;étié3z1s:~§*'f_§ V§:u:%1%:'ity, 3§ éays {Ems is granied ;§f::::1 t<::u:iajg is £16 nsséssary ap§e§;.--::@_':;%: untéi :h€::z§ the: rsspandsmi ~=i5 Réresipitate {E26 mafia? by innjaaxgg2:g«§§§%fi§é§ae$$§§§!' "w*i gig/fl **%*'§% Efifigg