Shri S Perumal vs A P S R T C on 23 March, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]
Karnataka High Court

Shri S Perumal vs A P S R T C on 23 March, 2011

Bench: Ajit J Gunjal, C.R.Kumaraswamy

:7VE'.1?i_'g3.;s;'}21i Erreiié aE:~3«:3 ﬁ_

& r.':.<;7_?:fj:-¥_4:.._'§}.:»i:::::;V2:3;.

Iiazzzcit-3 1'11 {'.'m>, C1.e=;1.im }}('3{1iTi()§'1 is t'h21§' 'E.E:<:: {I)C.T'(?i.1pE:11"}i'lS wt:-?1"'é:?

p1"<'>{.?::%e{.iir1g in Mar°z1'{17 800 {Ear E3e%a1;*§:;'1.g; reg§isf..:"21.i:i<>z1 N<>.KA;O.2??._V
N--4E33f2.. ne::_-11' E{.C}..$:gu"a:'e1.:1L B2;~1:1g_;a1*L,:;32a1e.1:1., NH~4 1':>é§§§9L"}','-«:_);;2.;e";'' ;.
i;n:1¢:_%k wlrzich wase; <'w;}mE:'1g' fmm ("he S2111': <2 <ji§_1'e{:'i:i€:rn"v:»3{1<i'd'<:1'13§;j

21p»p1.ie<:i bretiktn at '£Th::at: £t:i111£% {me APSR'I'C' E?;'£'.1E~3':' com ﬁ*«:.§'1€*_1 in

{)pp<)sii;e di:'€:<:ti0:1 .1-11". higgjh spa-:e<.i di'1fe::{.1y 'mi; t,i1:3: iihééfiV191.1fj;:$ii
800 Gary duet its which t:h1'ee }'>eé:3ii"ic)_:1é37s3 Z*3i_iSiIafI.i€?_d_ Exijixrités
:»:1me;i '(E1939 pczrsorls died on 'th;é.,Sp(>i:,. ,  ihjss £53 $11.19

-E1'V€'If'I.'l}E'.I"iE xnade? in the p;:'T:€§;i<;r1'1'1:;§ ir"21€:€§'it1121"t.'.i:hVé* ciriver ofE.E1<3

 

Maruti Car was; z1:,«:>"i: ve}1.i(:}.e iéiseif
wouici be. :::c:1;::1:;_m§~V,5; f'§*§§j:<%_  was; 21 pica Of
1*as!r1:1e:+;s and   i'..h.{'r APSRTC E3u::--;§ but
h0's..veve;: iizaé; wa$' L%:§%{;;12iVVi;<:.e;.1'<V   c;1.§§'§S(Z',SS€/{E witli 1*c3f¥::"e1":C;&% to
tins: §;a.~:a,>'i.:_i ¢:2<:{-:V:     §321.17§li€S3s. It  no cioubf, '{.me::: that; PER

4-

,§::v§:"§sf:_ f;:E'i:e {i;'iv{:r :3?" {fast Mzinﬁi {L'a:x "?!'h€:

    

is :"egi:;:;€::~:é{.}~V  

f7é.%E§<::<£ in :'1.<>i.<:é i.?:":;'r:1. 2;1i!€2;1:i;t 5« (sf '£316

 



§:?.Z'v:,:ft VMa1'z1'tE1.i"~Cari, '.V~V'$.*fE"§,§§{7}1 was i,::*3ri;;'1;;§ '£10 2:2a:}i{i ii§"1<3 z.>.11g{3i:1g
3-*<-§§':E{:§<:E.Vi:"; f3_*<>:'3;€;. "ta-*E:.§{:E2 hazi :~e;:.:e::E{§€:'";Ijg; $'t<:;.:»ped, E2  }":{} cicinmt.
 ;§'.§":;;;é;%:_'i"; §'1':7.;;;§;: :'~;;3s¢:<:§ ;>::%:° aw .i%:s'«;£%:§§ <'%::>n§{§ :1 GE. §L?€;'?  g1"{'>:.2 zaszi E<>;*'

 ~.E":<:>%j{;§i=:'é;2j" E.§':}:«:.:':. "':*::Z'":<i~::'e:'-tr 2':-"~; :2=:s:_+:§z:'i<;%;s.a.<:§ 2?z£".§{,'§ :'2{r_>'§% 33(?E'E{'é',. 5% :11 E'"2<7s'=c%;§3'=w:é:; 3-«a
._ .. I g

10

<':E;::i:n2mi'.s.s' 21*s;e_r11::e1":t. At para 23, Hit'? (?§21.iIITa2213'1i"S wo:.:1:::i stme

as u.r1cir3z:':

"Ii  fz..z.r£'I'1.e:%r subn1ii:'Z:'e2cZ film. at c1.f}c>u.:. 13.00 3'-'L ?'§';?.,3  " ». V

 

zwar' K.G.SaiJ'aI'?'1, f3c1r1g{1r'upc1i€I'2'1 §'\-'If1» £3(1I1g}'ai.o;E¢.~% 
Chiﬁoor Road. (1 "I'ru.c!<: z"rcw<;>ZIir1g* €i?'1€€1f€1.4T'Svi@£i¥§.f?5§;'é'
applied brake and whey-1 ii _ was:4'azﬁai§(:'d;  j;'!ie\
APSRTC Bus dI'i.ven by the 2???? I§%2Lié:-iapoJ'1;:.i.eI1i.'.::;ﬁVr':1iIi§.;} "
from opposize directﬁon '_ at I'2ifg_iL;iVV:'».,s;;a{¢d  §:i*ir :égi'ik1V.A;V §
dashed r:1gainsz':' the 1'\»fc;r'Lz.::f*gf 8630  Reg.
No..KA--O2~N«49.32 in wi'1i:L?i1    and

his d.ec8a$<-3d scar: was-:_ 1rc1§§)ei_lir'f{g:g. 

6. indeed V1'_:h,jis  ;'1V<::§":né:1'1..._i_;j;_ (me: 0f the p<3i;iti0'1'1s..
But; h<>xveve:z wg:2 :*.:<f){:1c€ §*,'§1.;§;t:~ if 've.:*bati111 rc:%p1f(:sc1':,1C1:ion of
the avcrmeI1i:S in '2;E'_i; {E6363 ?c1ziim" pE:;I.i.t;i();'.1&:. We are of the 'Ji€'W

i:11at. 4;z2:.,ssp€<::ifi§i: 21s;?*<%r:11<::1E;"--wé:~;g_ ;');1.;1.cie by ihe <:Iaim2;111t',s_:; ir1.cii{:2ii;i1'1g

E,§321'£. ?§,E'z§=.% 'rjfi<,?§:r ";£X..f'»%_R'§'€.f came 31:'. 21 h_.ig.h s.spe.-:<e3r:.i 2:.UI}E§ hit:

  



16

<3<%c:u_1":"e.(.§ d"u:3 to iihif.' raséh axnd 1'1c2§g}_i_g_§e.1'1i': <1 z"ivi1'1;.,{ <31' 
w3E1i<:§<:%s in wi"1§::th <=.2i:.$:-x HIE': I]'1E:1i'.f{i'I." £'f;'.QL,1i1'ti'3§é§ 1"c>1I1ii:.i:21:_1§€:'; " :_.
f1c>w'c;%vs::1~, we do 110:: ;_3:*c:>p0:-ac? to :"<::r:1_it. t':E'1e-? V;j1 1M2;t.t:tTer  
vase find ithai. ifh 9 claim _p&?t'H';:i::>ns we1"t: £'i}s:;§ci  
dllﬁi sir1<:€ i;h<=3 er1t':ire f3Vi(§€fI}(1?€?  3§§%'§7i§*::3 vaze  tit)
quzmtriiiv the (:()1:ape::r1sai:io1'1 vv'i.t h Thﬁ?  

12. "Em first; mi' the <:asVes,si7;w{::;}1;:fvj,1%; 580/2008.
which is ref<:1*abi€ to  1:"70"/  that the
<:iai_n1:«1I:.t: had S-';L.if1f~('.§1"t';'.Lfi'   had s'L1ff€~.1*ed

fol} owin grit-gave J a..V<.,<,i1:.i_'j' 1.1_i*ig%é'--i;;::_ ,_

{a} M 1:.i£ipie ;LE)rfaS£Qfi elbow:
(E3) Su,£:'u_r§9ci :,i.éZ3=.r1;'id. Q:-:e%*--.;~igFé l foot;
V .. ~ {{2}  ggaiggéf' f:'"@f1_I___§5:sv1@(2:
V. Lgci   <fgi"r.z1' zibias;

{G}'--- I%"sfQ:s::i:,é:f§;w*f2}' nih:>Vi;Czcc1r;:2c1f disfocrcziiozz c3f"rz'giz.z hip

 'E['Ei*<r:%:;e'---- 2ia;:'*:;§é this iz'1_§1.::'i@-23 Sé5{.1f?€EE'€:{§ by the CY§€§.i§1"}£iI'§E.

    E.}{§<:1Tm;' wim is esfxa-zmin-sési 31$ &;p€??z';%,E£ abzimi: iihiﬁ

 _ ti4_i:%%9a§;:--iEli--i,:? "§'a:z:;"'é;€3:". §E2:>:;E?'2{} 23 the W<:):.::':<.E {:{§E'§.i§ﬁ{f',£2?{?; X995: :':.s::i.i<%§:2

'.§1.;3i, §E73_§.§j§é'2..§E}<'1, Ehfgft €'f§;;':i§f§3";;E:§'.§§'. wzazag é'§'e:é2,:§'.s~:{i% ai. '¢E%EE<:;z"£: E~~%{}s5g3§.?;2'2E 2'?;:'_1{.% X3

5,2»?

M" *-

'My/"'



.i:%'::*: ::%z"f§L§:>E<I}:;:::§"; .,.v'VV}';'.f;;«.{}§.'3'.'e§.' 

18

p1*u:p()s~;e to a.wa'r(§ 21 $1111: sf R$,3E"3.000/'-- L1E'1€i€fI" the ]:1c=.21.ciiv1:1gg;j__Gf

pain zmci s1.1£'f_{%r°i:1'1;_§ ;-111z:i 2-"1{id1'i:i{>.1i1aI ss1.1.m of Rs.35,(}OQ ;{.=«...1.j:_":"1.c'_i'eei'j~ 

the:-r 't1e2i1{iir1g' ('>f1<)ss,; {)fEiI1}€3I".1§T.1'f;?£é3. I11s:;0fz::r' 215; the E'1<)sp:3;.féiEi;:'::1E;i{>15£ -- 

and medical} <3xpe'1:.:e;e$ _i.:+; <?<}:'1<:<:2r1'1e<fL it  _'£f1{'3 .ciEQuI:i;§: :%;4:,:e¢1:az :21

Ciaim is mack? for Rss.€32_.E:389.54, but }1=:,:(:xx.»'ew;-#9'. Eye-. Ei£'€i" E:'I{)_E'.

i.:1{:}£:1e3(1 tei) a1cc€p£; the said (:Iain:1 anci pmpi:~.s¢é'-to &1'§)\7$j1_I§€i  21 'S1,;1§13[

of R$.20§OO0/-- Lmcier 'this: E1:-3a<:ii11g' :3.{ '1a:;ediLt"a.}__ <:x.;3e:1$"eé§""21:ici
adcEi{:ia:>:1a1 sum caf  10,000/~ 'L_:__2__1u'c'1»::_1' the ' 'hegxciifég of
n0ur°ishr:r1ent:, "I"h1.1s, the 1::<>f:aE s::ijmp.?;:;1:i-;--23'€:i<:;.1':.,;"£*\:.r2:.rcie1bEe to the

c121ime1nt:v'.:-'0u1.d be Rs..1,54,600/»«'; 

14» in M.F._A;N¢§:g':5'81'/§:?§§'O8 %%Wg;  i *71z2o05)§ the

c7£21i.memt',s are féfh  -(if   1.8,, '£'.}"1€E fatheszn
1"H{}iZh€f and s3ié?tie:r__. _1i,h<i% a<":<t§€ier1f., {his dﬁéfﬁél-Sﬁii
Wm 19 }-'f;';8;;!.'-5% (iii. 2::':«"2t:.? w;a;*2f;:é§vi§s*i:}.*Ea:...i__r:*':'i{_§'in. Bi1a1"21t, 83¢:-yizeni, Kiiifiilgg
Eihﬁi'. €.T{)§,EI"S€i": 0%' _€:§"ia.i,'L'£;«}ii{3*£t§%: <::s>;zem1i':":€<i as P.W.'?' 21:16 E16
R*.?(}1ﬂ_Fi  ::ie;3:;1,:;;.%; ui':h~zaE: §§1{%" :ig§;§'§§§£EsE?(i wam Emirig paid 2'1 ssalary sf

§"_€.s+;.é{.'§.';§8{'};*'a§3;.1':.2.i . i¥Ze*".._;":<:>i'i.c:§ Eh:-if'. <':%2<;:te;;§§ {er thzgz s:;'E:z2i,€é:z":atz':£;. {>5

 
 

is .f%}r§%':<%{§.:z:i§'1g§ 'its: 5f=§hi')"sE£ *z.%:at: {E23



V'    §€i§{';':§::"%i  2v:%'E.E  "£;.E1£.<.--:=:»- Cf<é:.:§'§;' §'::.::.-Y9 §i:s:?:%§': 2,§.E%-"£i.§'{f3§'E.'1§§

19

d€3€',{;'.a§,~}fi?{1 was e211'niz'1g 21 s;1.1m of Rs.4,E-300/--p.rn. W's 2;11«s;;<)

r3<>1;1'e::e:°: that the d€?('.€:'E:':$<;';*.C1 mass 219% wail. qu2;1.1iﬁcd, 2153 he 112?.-dV..
pEiSS{'.d SSLC. '£31.31: 1'mwevc2.r., we;-3 E'321$;1,r;m ':.(;:+ add I_,E1::1i_:=._fi:r;% - "
eCi1;c:a3.ﬁ{>11z:1.1 qua1ii"ir:*ai.i0:'1 per SE1'. <:2.1m'1<.:i 'ijiéuéx"§,§:*<:;1.;.:'1ci; 

thee §'{"1C(}T1"1€ wf i;I'3<: (i<:fC.fi'.21Sé3£i« E531.1.*;. }T1mvei>'r:1","._iI"1 t;h€;::; A<ia:'--;-3-+';*--: (xii

}1Eiﬂda we _prt.)p()s3€: to take: the i:*1<#O';%i{:. (Ff "i:}*:s;>._V_  '2V?-it
R5;.4.C)0O/~» and af€.e:r deéd1.1'§:'Ei}1g  x'{::{5a1/f'¢1I'€1%5'V pé:iLS(3I12E1i
e:>s:peI1ses, the C?()E'1{ifibL1f,iQH is  Rs92_.€)OO/--
per m0nt:1"1. Having  T'.€:::3._t':1':1c%;::   40
yeairsa. tile pmp<-3:'  "I"'hu.s, *{:h<=: loss of
depez1de:1<iy  X 112 x £4}. To
i:hat; vvci acici 21 L1r1d€r the c():m'e1:11:.iot'1ai

hészads. H€§1{,f's:1'., _i.he §.é;:£;;ﬂ' ':i1:<>ri'% p:;t'r;$2:t.i.<3t1. e'r:'w'a:"e:1e1?3E€: weuid be

Rs.  w    ~ _

15.V:;=:' 2ss1".fi;;§;;2\fio.532/2003 gzxxm: M3/2605}, Eihe

_=fi£§:Ts:2?.:3;;s=:§c£ xxra1$~~":£%';.y<:%a,rss £1316. zzxmi Was; 2:. -:':'st:1,2c,ie:'1€:. ;<3'i::.:.ciy:i.I1g in 811*

'«SS':._§;:f::.;i2ia«r:"{.i.a£"§i?r2e £.§_1.m% <3?' 'éthc: mg-:i.::%.;=--m. E:':{'ia%e:i§ :{:<>§1:~;;i:'~;~;i?:«::*z'2_é_E3: §,%1€:

 

9»:

..<€\



:f"§i>'€f};IL§E{i EK<'{j§'E"§$1 Exit: 21:)? LA%f~Z€:§.:'3,E">i31 f-- per m<:a:";th, 'I."'he> <:ie<'%::":;:zs<:td was};
..45'«.t;r§*.&r:$ Qici z3.:2?c?; K171:-3 pmpr-5:}: m1,:i.i':i'p1ie:* in {he ('.ii"'{?LiI}'1Sf£1I1{'.€S
"._»ai;}*§i.:§{i"E"%§;V,E_ :3";'_«'§'Ez:J:s;, ihzzr §:i;s;;:~;: 0? {'§?3§}{E§'}{§€?§1{1}? "s.i='<l}E.};§£§ 'J'v"'{"}:'§:{ (mi: £10

N  ~ {5.f:i3E  E2 3%: $3} "$0 §§':2;:'§: aw :=:d.<i sea s;1.;r:": {:25

20

mmpe1'1se1'i;im1 I'::e:t.wee?:1 Rs.1.,80,f)OO/--~ anti R.$.2,25,0(}O{!
{EEESEE mi' death of 23.. mi.m:«r <'1'1i.Eci. Hez'1:.:v;?:§ xve: ;3:'c)pc:>s£: {Q 
i1.:I1':a}:>~-R1311 (i'0n1pe:'1:%;ai1i{m of Rs.2.,00,000 / -1 ' I
15. In M.F.A.No.583/2008 

ctiaimams are the widow and two  
The de(:ea:s€:d was 21ge»:i 45 y(j_a1"s . (ﬁg 'E1"r;:?(iZVE.§;1t":A?;L7:§fi and
his; educaf,i::)na} qL'13;1ifi(:at:i<J;1  .f;I'€: :'{1."'.:.'5>:1V:E§'».\'f(3I'kil'1g E13 21:.
gg11a:*d in Kamaf,ak;z1    ;x~*.21s eztrning

21 5311111 Cd'    imiorne 0f the
de<:e3as3ed, we    at Rs.8,29€3/'-
:ina:~;n1uch as  h§-2   tax  zmcl the

c;12e3ssi,i<):1 of cieci1.1_c.?'if%;--:j>n -mi: i,Jf;<-é'._i£1:;?r..(§if1'3<»? tars: does not arise; If vm

ﬁ:ak§:+"ﬁ:h:: i.:fi{";s£3'1§_: é3: V;_.:iT /-- and 2:1.'fE',<3r cied1,£<':£ti.:"zg 1/31"

i()E¥'£1f{§S :p§%1*5;;m;3;E~ ,V£é>;pe:.:1$@$, th<:':~ c<):.'11':::rib:;1i:i:::»r1 '(:0 the Eamiiy

ii  *&'%§h'K'$'3 .

ma



:§R5:55,QQQ 34;'

". vi?i2:i;r:12:§:?,A §;<>2.1_:"1;,j§j §§§:"E :3? M» :£€?fEi§"E3 231.. Eng: :£rm=: sf ;2z{:<'3i&:ie:'2¥;_

 _   S}h'<:% 

21

RSxi£G.OOO/-- uruier 1111:: Cw1'1w;%1'2.i':i<31121E he2,1cisis. 'i.'E'1.we;§ f.}'Ev:'§'§.V(V." _'i:c:.§.'1._ 
c:c>m'pen.<5211:i<.>1": 2.1wz,1..1f::.§ 211E319 'in the f;'.iE1.§I1E2:1E'1i. \?£:'(:}_'fL£E'.I'('"i'. ;_.
Rs.9,02,836/--.  ' A
3?' in M1F.A. No.585/2008 [wc:% Nrgg'i§'2;'§GQ5i;"'i:}1!§%

C.Eai.mam £55 an injzzrticl person. xx-*i"1<3' &v.aa_._é3 EV'?-,.j'§*é21rs 
'£31316 91' the ac:::id<:m:. A1 t.I';¢   21

studezrii: of"E71'r$i: Year PUC. The .Vl1T1jt3_z"ic:g;~; are on f<}re~

Eieeid about 8 i1":c:11<:.s=--   amd
abrassicyn and bc3c1§1j;*:é§ﬁ;}3p():"iT of such
c(}ni:ez1i:i(}11, \v<j_..«:icv>   ev'ider;.ce. But
however, he1_v_i_§ig  of i2'1jt11"ies, we pmpc)s€

to award 8; ssum T<":r§_¢ Rff~:w5€.LOOQ",f T0 i;:I?1::1i: E176' acici 2:1 sum af

R:-3.5;.,[email protected];{},/-- *5£:.;>g¥é1:':i3 ;é':@<i__i__c;ii; €Xp€i'Z"1Sf3S, Thuse, the t;::::t21i

{:<):11p'<1:-:_1£s;:.€V;'§'{'>3:: é1w':z%:*€i';ai3ié2 to the cizairglzmi'. w<:u,1§d be

 in "§1§~F,AgNo.586/3,2008 {axrivzt 1:94/2005;, the

egg _;%§é:,:{'§yE:':§g E32. §}'ii"= $i";:_:':€i;'»§_r=:E{ "i.'E':er .§§'E"§i.§§.'.if{'7f-Er--Zs' ss::§£%'r:*::%<§ f:"ii"'€'T*.

    
   

 '.'~%' 2  'I ' i."- '~" :".' \'



zs:i§$<:hz1rg;§ii*§%'5'_:;'::: "':3ij%_.,V,'§2.;2Eif}O4. FE)? me ﬁieirii éi1':':e,,1 :=5-he: wzzas

22

C()I1{3L,1SSiE-"6'. head inj:.1r§; xx.-*.i'i:.i'1 C.S.F'i E'~211i:'1<.)3:';*h<::€21., f1*a<::iT.u';"£:.._<5f_
right fmm'.zi11 bcmzs, Iixiztmipké fhciazzi E:}<>1"1e fr2.1<:i*.1.::"€:, ieft:  "
and su_1"'\:iveci with <:0:z1p}ic:2.1.i£:ci 1'15;-21.1mE0ggis::ai £ii:':5<)i*'c3.§-%1"' A_wi{.§: "
dist'ig:,:ra€.iz):1 of f£?£€",iE*I_ r:3qLzi1'«;%sa fziirzriai pIéi.S'£;i::: :.:e;z.1:7;_§<;_%T'r'j,:*._ 211115; I
(T.'h&?l1'7£(3CS of I'€i('iL.iE"i"€I'}C€ of :1_<3.1'v<.:% pr<)b1€7n1s{;._ ' _ 
f)0£:'E:or'_. who has sp£)ke1:1 to abo1.:t t;'h.<;:«--..;'121t:m*s2r '(:5 tE':§'£:jj»1.,1.I'§e:§.
He has aisca nleicie zwailable i',1'1€*. cEe5i'::.<;€¥':':11<3e{.-5%'._iéSuf<::ci ,by a
Coxnpetc-rm: Ne3u'ro}0gisé:. "P116.i31.s21biE'ifyCé:§rt;ifi::j21i:e§ Xéiréiy M151
the Cas<:«sheei's~.'e 2z.r*c:-1 to be found a.;t .Ex--,PF4£iO _::3~--E*§2;:§'Pf$3. PM-7&6 --~
i)r.V.'i"1Venkai:esh, W_£){,é1A§1'_'. dejppseift:i1;3;t~ _jthé ij'c:Ee1in1a1r1t: had
55Laffe.'red C(}I[1CT1,IS$i"5*?§3 ,.i'1.Q§i'ti'«V._ i1j;§--i;;-rﬁg" .._v§{'it.f;.» CSF §'hii}.'":(:I£"£'h()(3a,

f:rac:tt:11.re of rigifié' V'i':"<>n;:E{f21} ij§fJi'1<-?,'"3}i'1.:1Eip'ii:i'"fzxtéieii bcm<-3. fr21ctu.I"e.,

left black eye.  iV@;zE{§:'~:§i:a:}é=..'t:]Exz:€: aim W215; a.€ir:1it:'t:€::i {.0

"v"eEi{}1'e H{>.spi{i:a1 {<'i.;;:'v:?1ﬁ(*,§_ h.£i€,§f~';: '*£,ak<'3_:'i 's':.%~Eéz1t.:11e::'1§:' on 18. 202804 araci

wens.':ii.+3<:}121:*'§§§%ci:_§§::_261 E:{}»«i2.f}f.1»aL Sim was 5_;<:e:1'; and tmfcziieci by

{E22BE'.i1\x'i::;':.i€,'z1yuV:'":j21§;s3;i's=:'i;21 far ':':J51<3 :~ss:%«::<}:'":c£ t:.im<-3: zmszi was

::L1;(§":*:*:§v?:':.§;:{.i imf :~§~y;:';{*:g:=;49%m::;»: zzmié E'":@2'r:<'iaa:<_:h<:% 53:': ?;{}.{}§.2{}{§§§.,

   

 'iiéf_{}3:=k E?;n{;'§é.>,..V__':%'<>;:sjf;r R-¥paE§§' 9? §":"§.§.E'T:€.E£"E"§'E%;}€E£--2 :%;2zs:=; {%<"::'::;:< s.,2;:';<i5-ér" 



;::.§':b<%'§%.4:%:"L.:2"s:% m_c{§is:::2.;E €i':'X}_'}E?E"i we §}1.'{3§'}€.}~f_*5é{f' E0 2.'m:;;::."{§. a ;-msfifz <35

23

GA on 2E3.C)4.20(}6 emci ciis<:haa:'g;{¢::i on 3C).0éL20()6. '\-='i?"1rm.z'1

c:iaiI"r121m: was eX2'm1i1.1e<:1 (1:11 31'O1.2007, 1:136. Dflréfi(}1'j"i'z{).i:i£7.§§(§ 

*é:':1e Ebilcywirig «:?(3r3§pE2ai:'1i'.s:

"'I"Ieada<:f'te on & Q/f, disZ'1zrE3aI'1:;re  €(:i:;s" ' 'V 

long ierm :'m;m':or'y, back f)€1fI'"L§7   ' 2 

19' She W213 mi'&:3*1'ed. to V'1*:e1..i1*Qi'0gi.5t: " .f<>.1:a. ..i'€,1rt.he;t1"
naanagemerzti :»3.:m:1 ciissabiiity :{1sséa{L3s3ssr1 N;é:t?3t;; E~_{é:~v . w()i.:.1d S'{:at.e ithat
Z31'.B.P.MrL1t.hyunj2¢.y2m'ma'---_ "'~..°21_:.-:_1<1' '>a ssesSed the:

peI'ma11€I1t. tum.t"<1:Ef)§gi(1;-211'""'t'5._i5;a'bTE--1iti3;   and Disability

  

Assn-:3s:ne1'1t. Cv\;'€'.'I;'iV,iiA"i€.'ZAfc§1:'.é':,§', \""v:.<'::1VVES--  s_:,<!3{:'1*';L'i:"' ziiong w':ii:h {.116 c21:'~3t3t--

s.=;heei..

 28¢ ",3§.e;ts?§s:%*.re1z'e ¥:'§'1{3:._ViZ"._}'LiI"}€Ei% and f'}."1.t"f reSidu::1.1 6351.':-*t(":t: of 'i;h<-3:

§s:;1.i€iV_ir3}fa1«1ii¢:s:;._V  Wé3~--, me: 0f the: aziew that: in ihe ggiven

L.

:7'vs:ﬁ'i';'C:;,1rns§.--§;t"::3z35%Q'%§.as.:i:?:g m€§21.;"d {.0 {Exes Ne'1.:r<)§T{>ggi<?21J; {iis<):'ds3;>:"

é?¥;.§j:<§ '::h.<%: <iis;i'Lg.§é:zic:zi1_<%:'§t. of f'g::':¢: w.it}";. E05:-asrés {>5 2€:)s'1g;; i;é;:r::3 me;*-:m<>'r}-',

itivg-éA<:§§'::r1§3é:é:z:;z;:t;ion is: :'€:e:;':.,:_i:"e;~:=:.1 in be alaaséisssegi z,:r2de':* varioua

  §?<:;r:'r {§£s§3§;f:.2:'@:11£:1':i. <:;§"i:i1e 5:-:<*:<:>, 231.1%: E\§:%z.::"<3E{.:s§;§<::§§ dés:':»;:*<;Eé?:'r



  '  H

M.F'.A. 3605. Compensation

55%)/2005;;  .E.:E--)Z£«q6'(}0j/i
581/2.008
Rss..f3.6I,OOO/» 58:2/2008 Rs.2,0()Jf)G--{);'-- % 583/2008 Rs.9.OfE;:,83[_5/~-3 A' E385,~"20{)8 §zg...%%_55,0o§j;'; é 586/2008 I%$. '3;lC:§Z3,000/"~'..
(iii) The €:m;1per1sati<:ai:. ig1;v§§.rdVj¢Q " ca;,ri:*y irltcrt-?si: at the rate jvdéiilﬁf of petiticbn d&ii'.(§ the i11sur<3rs__~:: --v_v¢§--§ fgjhcz APSR'.I'C am liabie "*i--,<3'}_: nS5211}'.f§f_f,-f"i"iT13____E1\>'¥T.:;1I'€I in aqua} pE'€J:}{)£"fiC)'?'E;Z. ., i14f§s~1_.;r:%;*--(3f the {tar Shaii s3211".i$g'-'.'y {cm {iv} Aﬁthsga a§f3";3e¢§V;1i'-33..si:.a%1ciA'&isp0sed of ,_mHaw-W
Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Shri S Perumal vs A P S R T C on 23 March, 2011

Bench: Ajit J Gunjal, C.R.Kumaraswamy
