Karnataka High Court
Mr G Ashokan vs Hal Sc/St Employees And Officers ... on 9 February, 2017
Author: S.Abdul Nazeer
Bench: S. Abdul Nazeer
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 9TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2017
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S. ABDUL NAZEER
REVIEW PETITION NO.583/2015
C/W REVIEW PETITION NO.572/2015
R.P.NO.583/2015
Between:
1 Mr.G.Ashokan,
Senior Vice President,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late P.Ganeshan,
Aged about 52 years,
Dept/PB No.0418/64134-46,
Working as Senior Master Technician,
HAL Hospital, Electrical Maintenance,
Bangalore - 17.
2 Mr.K.Neelamegam,
1st Vice President,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late Kannan,
Aged about 46 years,
Dept/PB No.1416/68709-95,
Working as Security Jamedar,
Aircraft Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
2
3 Mr.A.Subramani,
2nd Vice President,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o Mr.Annamalai,
Aged about 38 years,
Dept/PB No.6354/69160-03,
Working as Senior Technician,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
4 Mr.E.Subramani,
Joint Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o Mr.Ekambaram,
Aged about 44 years,
Dept/PB No.4302/61601,
Working as Master Technician,
Engine Division, HAL,
Bangalore.
5 Mr.T.Kabilan,
Assistant Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late A.Thangaraj,
Aged about 45 years,
Dept./PB No.6361/68399,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Helicopter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
3
6 Mr.G.Siva Kumar,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late Ganeshan,
Aged about 42 years,
Dept/PB No.9333/74723,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Aerospace Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
7 Mr.S.Ambeth,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o Mr.V.R.Shekar,
Aged about 40 years,
Dept/PB No.4302/86244,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Aero Engine Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
8 Mr.C.Venkatesh,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late Chnagan,
Aged about 40 years,
Dept/PB No.2378/75992-71,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Overhaul Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
4
9 Mr.R.T.Anand Kumar,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late R.Thulasiram,
Aged about 44 years,
Dept/PB No.6361/68469,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Helicopter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
10 Mr.D.Veerapandyan,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late Dinakaran,
Aged about 42 years,
Dept/PB No.6352/69040,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Helicopter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
11 Mr.G.Shivakumar,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late Govindaraju,
Aged about 37 years,
Dept/PB No.6351/68803,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Helicopter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
5
12 Mr.K.Kumareshan,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o Mr.Kani Kannan,
Aged about 43 years,
Dept/PB No.C322/82530,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
CMD Division, HAL
Bangalore - 17.
13 Mr.M.Prakash,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o Mr.M.Thammanna,
Aged about 37 years,
Dept/PB No.5321/82238,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
ARDC Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
14 Mr.M.Manjunatha,
Divisional Secretary,
HAL SC/ST E & O Association,
S/o late Muthappa,
Aged about 36 years,
Dept/PB No.5326/82963,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
ARDC Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17. .... Petitioners.
(By Sri P.S.Rajagopal, Sr.Adv. for Sri B.M.Irishad Ahmed, Adv.)
6
And:
1 HAL SC/ST Employees
And Officers Association (R),
Reptd. by its President,
Shivalinga B.N S/o Nanjaiah,
Aged about 43 years,
Nos.1 and 2, Old Township,
Vimanapura Post, HAL,
Bangalore - 560 017.
2 The District Registrar &
District Registrar of Societies,
Shivajinagar Registration District,
1st Floor, Kandaya Bhavan,
Bangalore - 560 009.
3 HAL SC/ST Employees and
Officers Association,
No.6/1, G.No.11th Cross,
8th Street, Ulsoor,
Bangalore 560 008,
By its President.
4 Mr.M.Dhanaraj,
S/o Muthu,
Aged about 53 years,
No.G.151, HAL Old Township,
Vimanapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 017.
7
5 Mr.R.Thyagarajan,
S/o Rathnam,
Aged about 52 years,
No.16, N.Type Quarters,
HAL Old Township,
Vimanapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 017. .... Respondents.
(By Sri Kashinath J.D., Adv. For R1
Sri D.Ashwathappa, AGA for R2
Sri Sunil S. Rao, Adv. For R4
Smt. B.V.Vidyulath, Adv. For R5
Notice to R3 held sufficient vide order dated 8.6.2016)
RP NO.572/2015
Between:
1 Mr.Ajay Kumar S.B.,
S/o late Sathya Babu,
Aged about 33 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Hawk Equipping, Aircraft Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
2 Mr.Bharaneeswaran P.,
S/o Mr.R.Perumal,
Aged about 35 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger,
Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
8
3 Mr.Renukeshava,
S/o Mr.M.Krishna,
Aged about 35 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
4 Mr.B.Srinivasa Murthy,
S/o Mr.Chikkabylappa,
Aged about 43 years,
C7 Progress L-40, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
5 Mr.R.Hari Gokul Kumar,
S/o Mr.N.A.Rajoo,
Aged about 42 years,
Working as Inspector, Engine Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 93.
6 Mr.Pradeep B.G.,
S/o Mr.G.Govindappa,
Aged about 29 years,
Iron Bird, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
7 Mr.G.Anil Kumar,
S/o Mr.D.Govindaiah,
Aged about 29 years,
MSD, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
9
8 Mr.Umapathy,
S/o late Kuppuswamy,
Aged about 38 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Jaguar Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
9 Mr.M.Thirupalu,
Aged about 40 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Jaguar Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
10 Mr.N.Ganapathy,
S/o Mr.R.V.Natarajan,
Aged about 46 years,
ALH Final Assembly,
Helicopeter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
11 Mr.D.Naveen Kumar,
S/o Mr.C.Dorairaj,
Aged about 35 years,
Progress Department,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
12 Mr.Siva Kumar P.,
S/o Mr.Ponnuswamy,
Aged about 42 years,
Progress Department,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
10
13 Mr.S.Madhusudan,
S/o late D.Shankaran,
Aged about 38 years,
Progress Engineering Department,
CH/CK Machine Shop,
Helicopter Division, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
14 Mr.Senthil Velan,
S/o R.Kothandapani,
Aged about 34 years,
Sheetmetal Shop, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
15 Mr.Jayakanth P.,
S/o Mr.D.Prabakaran,
Aged about 32 years,
CH/CTK Final Assembly,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
16 Mr.Manjunath P.,
S/o Mr.Puttamada,
Aged about 32 years,
CH/CTK Final Assembly,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
17 Mr.S.Prabakaran,
S/o Mr.Subramani C.,
Aged about 44 years,
CH/CTK Final Assembly,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
11
18 Mr.J.Ramesh,
S/o Mr.Jaganathan,
Aged about 36 years,
ALH Final Assembly,
Helicopter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
19 Mr.R.Babu,
S/o Mr.Raju,
Aged about 47 years,
Working as Master Technician,
NDT/M/F, Engine Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 93.
20 Mr.K.Anand Kumar,
S/o Mr.M.Kanakaraj,
Aged about 38 years,
Working as Planner,
Methods Department, Engine Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 93.
21 Mr.R.Rajashekar,
S/o Mr.Rajendran,
Aged about 30 years,
Working as Inspector,
Adour Assembly, Engine Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 93.
22 Mr.Uma Shankar J.,
S/o Mr.Jayakumar R.,
Aged about 34 years,
Tool Room, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
12
23 Mr.Vinoth Kumar G.,
S/o Mr.George,
Aged about 32 years,
Tool Room, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
24 Mr.Pushparaj K.,
S/o Mr.S.Kannan,
Aged about 41 years,
Welding Department,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
25 Mr.B.Chandru,
S/o Mr.G.Balakrishnan,
Aged about 36 years,
Sheet Metal Shop, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
26 Mr.D.Selvaraj,
S/o Mr.Devendran,
Aged about 44 years,
Progress CH/CTK Final Assembly,
Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
27 Mr.R.Mohan Krishna,
S/o Mr.Rama Murthy,
Aged about 45 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran Structure, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
13
28 Mr.V.Srirama S/o late Venkateshaiah,
Aged about 51 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran Structure, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
29 Mr.A.Babu Karunagaran,
S/o late R.Arumugam,
Aged about 48 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran Structure, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
30 Mr.U.K.Barma,
S/o Mr.Khandappa,
Aged about 39 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Jaguar Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
31 Mr.D.Dhanasegar,
S/o late Durai Raj,
Aged about 47 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
32 Mr.M.Mohan Raj,
S/o Mr.M.Marie,
Aged about 39 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
14
33 Mr.R.Ramesh Babu,
S/o Mr.K.P.Rajendran,
Aged about 50 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
34 Mr.M.Lokesh,
S/o Mr.Mariappa H.,
Aged about 38 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
35 Mr.Sadananda,
S/o late Radha,
Aged about 40 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
36 Mr.Dinesh K S/o Mr.K.Nayaka,
Aged about 35 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
37 Mr.Sudhakar S/o Mr.Wilson,
Aged about 36 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
15
38 Mr.Veeranna,
S/o Mr.Sidramappa,
Aged about 46 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
39 Mr.S.Rajendran,
S/o Mr.S.D.Sigamani,
Aged about 41 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
40 Mr.Rajendra S.,
S/o Mr.Seshadri,
Aged about 40 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran MK-1 Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
41 Mr.M.Parthiban,
S/o Mr.A.Muniswamy,
Aged about 43 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Jaguar Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
42 Mr.P.Rajendiran S/o Mr.P.Poobalan,
Aged about 55 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Jaguar Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
16
43 Mr.Saravanan S.,
S/o Mr.K.M.Subramanie,
Aged about 36 years,
Working as Highly Skilled Technician,
Kiran Structure Hanger, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
44 Mr.M.Thyagaraj,
S/o Mr.Muthu,
Aged about 48 years,
Machine Shop, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
45 Mr.Amayogi N.H.,
S/o Mr.Ningappa,
Aged about 59 years,
Machine Shop, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
46 Mr.Chitti Babu I.,
S/o Mr.Iyyakkannu,
Aged about 50 years,
Machine Shop, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
47 Mr.R.Rajan,
S/o Mr.Raju,
Aged about 54 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
17
48 Mr.H.H.Ananda,
S/o Mr.S.Hanumantharayappa,
Aged about 54 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
49 Mr.V.Gajendran,
S/o Mr.P.Varadan,
Aged about 50 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
50 Mr.Lakshmana,
S/o Mr.Late Hanumaiah,
Aged about 55 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
51 Mr.S.Satish,
S/o Mr.K.A.Subramani,
Aged about 47 years,
MT L-40, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
52 Mr.S.Jaya Pragash,
S/o Mr.Simon R.,
Aged about 36 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
18
53 Mr.S.Gopi,
S/o Mr.G.Subramany,
Aged about 44 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
54 Mr.M.Parivallal,
S/o Mr.D.Munirathinam,
Aged about 51 years,
MT L-40, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
55 Mr.G.Venkatesh,
S/o Mr.Guruvaiah,
Aged about 55 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
56 Mr.B.Puttalingappa,
S/o Mr.Boraiah,
Aged about 54 years,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
57 Mr.Udaya Kumar,
S/o Mr.Baburao,
Aged about 40 years,
MK-III, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
19
58 Mr.K.G.Palani,
S/o Mr.Govindan,
Aged about 45 years,
MK-III, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
59 Mr.K.Udaya Kumar,
S/o Mr.C.Krishnan,
Aged about 35 years,
PSLV/GSLV Assembly Shop,
Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
60 Mr.S.Suresh Babu,
S/o Mr.K.Sekar,
Aged about 32 years,
Tool Room, Helicopter division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
61 Mr.Thirumaran K.,
S/o Mr.Kannan G.,
Aged about 40 years,
Tooling Inspector, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
62 Mr.L.Surendran,
S/o Mr.T.Loganathan,
Aged about 43 years,
ALH, Final Assembly, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
20
63 Mr.R.R.Pazhani,
S/o late M.Raman,
Aged about 47 years,
Tool Room, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
64 Mr.K.Rajendra Kumar,
S/o Mr.K.Kanakaraj,
Aged about 46 years,
Plant Maintenance, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
65 Mr.S.Shamraj,
S/o Mr.M.Shama,
Aged about 40 years,
Manufacturing Inspection (QA),
VR-II, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore -17.
66 Mr.Veera Vara Kumar Gera,
S/o Mr.Koteswara Rao,
Aged about 36 years,
Rool Room, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
67 Mr.M.Muthyalappa,
S/o Mr.Muthyalappa,
Aged about 37 years,
Tooling Inspection, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
21
68 Mr.Jayakumar K.,
S/o Mr.K.M.Kumar,
Aged about 37 years,
Marketing, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
69 Mr.M.Raja,
S/o Mr.Manikkam,
Aged about 32 years,
Sheet Metal Shop, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
70 Mr.A.Prem Kumar,
S/o Mr.Amrithraj,
Aged about 42 yars,
Sheetmetal Shop, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
71 Mr.M.Madhi Babu,
S/o Mr.Manoharan,
Aged about 40 years,
D3 Department, Overhaul Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
72 Mr.K.Selvaraj,
S/o Mr.G.Krishnan,
Aged about 52 years,
Cheetha Chetak Final Assembly,
Helicopter Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
22
73 Mr.S.Udaya Kumar,
S/o Mr.Shanmugam K.,
Aged about 28 years,
Welding Progress, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
74 Mr.Suresh Kumar R.,
S/o Mr.P.K.Radha Krishnan,
Aged about 35 years,
St.7/A Progress, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
75 Mr.Parthasarathy S.,
S/o Mr.Sarangapani,
Aged about 37 years,
ALH Final Assembly, Helicopter Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
76 Mr.T.P.P.Kumar,
S/o Mr.Thangaraj,
Aged about 52 years,
Working as Master Technician,
Sheet Metal & Welding Dept., Engine Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 93.
77 Mr.V.Sunil Kumar,
S/o Mr.Venkatesh T.
Aged about 37 years,
Working as Welder,
Sheet Metal & Welding Department,
Engine Division, HAL, Bangalore - 93.
23
78 Mr.Danaraj D.,
S/o Mr.Danapaul,
Aged about 39 years,
Working as Manager, Engine Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 93.
79 Mr.B.Deena Dhayalan,
S/o Mr.Babu,
Aged about 55 years,
L-40, Aerospace Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
80 Mr.G.Velu,
S/o late Govindaswamy,
Aged about 45 years,
Structure, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
81 Mr.Madhusudhana M.,
S/o Mr.Mahadeva Nayaka,
Aged about 31 years,
Structure, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
82 Mr.Shivaram H.,
S/o Mr.Hanumappa,
Aged about 46 years,
Working as Inspector,
Machine Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
24
83 Mr.Kalai Kumar V.,
S/o late Venu S.,
Aged about 33 years,
Machine Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
84 Mr.Muniswamy S.,
S/o late Shanmugam,
Aged about 33 years,
Working as Senior Technician,
Sheet Metal Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
85 Mr.R.Rajendra Babu,
S/o Mr.V.P.Raja Gopal,
Aged about 44 years,
Machine Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
86 Mr.V.Murali,
S/o Mr.G.Venkatesh,
Aged about 43 years,
Structure Wing, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
87 Mr.Jayaraman G.,
S/o Mr.Late Govindan,
Aged about 58 years,
Sheet Metal Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
25
88 Mr.Venkata Subba Rao,
S/o Mr.A.Gopalu,
Aged about 39 years,
Machine Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
89 Mr.Elumalai,
S/o Mr.Kannan,
Aged about 49 years,
Working as Master Technician,
NC Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
90 Mr.Manjunatha A.M.,
S/o Mr.Muniswamy M.,
Aged about 36 years,
NC Shop, ARDC Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 37.
91 Mr.P.Kalaiselvam,
S/o Mr.Pannerselvam,
Aged about 45 years,
Working as Senior Inspector,
Machine Shop, Aircraft Division,
HAL, Bangalore - 17.
92 Mr.S.Selva Kumar,
S/o Mr.V.Subramanian,
Aged about 37 years,
Working as Manager,
Out Sourcing Department,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
26
93 Mr.M.Suresh Kumar,
S/o Mr.K.Muniswamy,
Aged about 35 years,
Working as Senior Technician,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
94 Mr.Vinod E.K.,
S/o Mr.E.Kumaran,
Aged about 41 years,
Working as Senior Technician,
Aircraft Division, HAL,
Bangalore - 17.
95 Kumari M. Vani Chithra,
D/o N.A.Muthu,
Aged about 29 years,
Working in Out Sourcing Department,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
96 Mr.J.Shiva Kumar,
S/o Mr.Jayapal,
Aged about 41 years,
Working in Methods Department,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
97 Mr.T.Rajan,
S/o S.Thangaraj,
Aged about 34 years,
Working in IMM Department,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
27
98 Mr.L.K.Suresh Babu,
S/o V.Muniyappa,
Aged about 36 years,
Working as Senior Technician,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
99 Mr.Kiran Kumar P.,
S/o late Pushparaj,
Aged about 36 years,
Working as Senior Technician,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17.
100 Mr.P.Murugesha,
S/o Mr.Ponnappa M.,
Aged about 36 years,
Working as Senior Technician,
LCA Tejas, HAL, Bangalore - 17. .... Petitioners.
(By Sri P.S.Rajagopal, Sr.Adv. for Sri V.R.Sarathy, Adv.)
And:
1 HAL SC/ST Employees
And Officers Association (R),
Reptd. by its President,
Shivalinga B.N S/o Nanjaiah,
Aged about 43 years,
Nos.1 and 2, Old Township,
Vimanapura Post, HAL,
Bangalore - 560 017.
28
2 The District Registrar &
District Registrar of Societies,
Shivajinagar Registration District,
1st Floor, Kandaya Bhavan,
Bangalore - 560 009.
3 HAL SC/ST Employees and
Officers Association,
No.6/1, G.No.11th Cross,
8th Street, Ulsoor,
Bangalore 560 008,
By its President.
4 Mr.M.Dhanaraj,
S/o Muthu,
Aged about 53 years,
No.G.151, HAL Old Township,
Vimanapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 017.
5 Mr.R.Thyagarajan S/o Rathnam,
Aged about 52 years,
No.16, N.Type Quarters,
HAL Old Township,
Vimanapura Post,
Bangalore - 560 017. .... Respondents.
(By Sri J.D.Kashinath, Adv. For R1
Sri D.Ashwathappa, AGA for R2
Sri T.Seshagiri Rao, Adv.for R4
Smt.B.V.Vidyulatha, Adv. For R5
Notice to R3 held sufficient vide order dated 8.6.2016)
29
These Review Petitions are filed under Order 47 Rule 1 of
CPC praying for review of the order dated 27.1.2015 in
W.P.No.37937/2013, etc.
These Review Petitions coming on for Orders this day,
the Court passed the following:
ORDER
The review petitioners are the members/office bearers of the first respondent-association. It is their case that behind their back, a joint memo was filed by the parties to the writ petition in W.P.No.37937/2013 under Order 23 Rule 3 of the CPC. The matter was accordingly compromised and the writ petition was disposed of on 27.1.2015. It is contended that this order has seriously jeopardized their interest.
2. I have heard the learned Counsel for the parties.
3. The review petitioners are not parties to the writ petition. A joint memo was filed by the parties to the writ 30 petition and the said joint memo was taken on record and the writ petition was disposed of in terms of the joint memo. Having perused the materials on record, I am of the view that it is just and proper to hear the review petitioners before recording the compromise.
4. Therefore, the review petitions are allowed. The order dated 27.1.2015 in W.P.No.37937/2013 is hereby recalled and the writ petition is restored to file.
Post W.P.No.37937/2013 before the Court having roster.
Sd/-
JUDGE.
BMM/-