Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Nishant Singh vs M/O Personnel,Public Grievances And ... on 25 September, 2020
1 OA 860/2020
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No.860/2020
MA No.1081/2020, MA No.1289/2020
This the 25th day of September, 2020
(Through Video Conferencing)
Hon'ble Mr. R.N. Singh, Member (J)
Hon'ble Mr. Mohd. Jamshed, Member (A)
1. Nishant Singh, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/o Sh. S.P. Singh,
R/o WB-122, Street No. 6,
Ganesh Nagar-II, Shakarpur,
Delhi-110092.
2. Saransh Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 24 Years,
S/O Sh. Pradeep Sharma,
R/O Wb-09, Shakarpur, Delhi-110092
3. Sunil Kumar Upadhyay, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 28 Years,
S/O Sh. Indrasen Upadhyay,
R/O 694/7 Govindpuri Delhi,
Kalkaji New Delhi-110019
4. Naresh Kumar Rawal , Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Mahesh Kumar Rawal,
R/O Palri(R), District &Tehsil- Sirohi,
Rajasthan-307001
5. Dhruv Pandey, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Ajay Pandey,
R/O Ajay Machinery Store Gt Road,
Near Hanuman Temple-Maholi,
2 OA 860/2020
Sitapur UP-261141
6. Yogesh Kumar Meena, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Brij Lal Meena,
R/O Ward No. 13 Rawatsar,
Dist Hanumangarh, Rajasthan-335524.
7. Gaurav Kumar , Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Vivekanand Singh,
R/O Near Devi Mandir, Samudaik Bhawan,
Harnichak Anishabad Patna - 800002
8. Prashant Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Mukesh Kumar Sharma,
R/O 3/239 R.H.B Colony,
Hanumangarh, Rajasthan-335512
9. Naveen Yadav, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 21 Years,
S/O Sh. Satyavir Singh Yadav,
R/O Vill Dhamlawas Po- Pithrawas,
Distt- Rewari Haryana-123101
10. Pankaj Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 28 Years,
S/O Sh. Sushil Kumar Sharma,
R/O Flat 104 Plot 89 Shaberi
Gautam Buddha Nagar Up-201009
11. Vivek Kumar Garg, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Pappu Lal Gupta,
R/O 86, Kela Devi Mandir Ke Pass Saloda Mod,
Gangapur City, Dist- Sawai Madhopur
Pin Code - 322201
12. Ritvik Shukla, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Satya Prakash Shukla,
R/O Village- Gorakhpurva, Post- Gagaha,
3 OA 860/2020
District- Gorakhpur, Pin Code- 273411
13. Saurabh Yadav, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26.9 Years,
S/O Sh. Mahesh Kumar Yadav,
R/O H.No-682 Mahveer Nagar Gopalpura,
Jaipur(Rajasthan), Pin 302018
14. Gaurav Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Rakesh Kumar Sharma,
R/O 67 Raj Talkies Road, Mahaveer Gunj,
Near Shivhare Tent House, Bhind, M.P, 477001
15. Rohit Choudhary, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 29 Years,
S/O Sh. R.K. Choudhary,
R/O D-903, Yashwin Society,
Behind Bu Bhandari Mercedes Showroom,
500m From Vibgyor School, Sus Road,
Pune-411045
16. Nikhil Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Narendra Singh,
R/O 11/2 Radhey Shyam Park Rajendra Nagar,
Sector-5, Sahibabad, Ghaziabad,
U.P -201005
17. Abesh Kumar Meena, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 24 Years,
S/O Sh. Ram Pratap Meena,
R/O Krishna Colony Desula Mia Alwar,
Rajasthan, Pin Code : 301030
18. Uday Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 22 Years,
S/O Sh. Raghvendra Sharma
R/O Closed Gali Rampuri Colony,
Shabd Pratap Ashram Lashkar Gwalior,
M.P. Pincode - 474012
4 OA 860/2020
19. Rohit Verma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Harishankar Verma
R/O Sunita Colony A, Rampura Road,
Sanganer, Jaipur, 302029
20. Purushottam Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Prithwi Chandra Sah,
R/O Vill+ Po+ Ps:- Sursand, Lichi Fulbari,
Ward 5, Near Binod Dish, Ghara Bazar,
Bihar, Sursand, Sitamarhi, Pin:843331
21. Pillalamarri Abhilash Kumar, Appointment (Gr 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. P. Sudhakr,
R/O H.No. 9-1-94/2c,
Medical Colony Bhadrachalam,
Bhadradri Kothagudem District
Telangana, Pincode: 507111
22. Parshant, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Vikram Singh,
R/O Village - Dundsa ,
Tehsil And District - Palwal,
Haryana Pin: 121102
23. Vaibhav Tuli, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Rajesh Kumar Tuli,
R/O Hno 292 Sector 16 Faridabad,
Haryana 121002
24. Rahul Kumar Gupta, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 30 Years,
S/O Sh. Prem Chand Gupta,
R/O Vishnu Bhawan,
Tilkamanjhi Hat House No- 76,
Bhagalpur, Bihar 812001
5 OA 860/2020
25. Mukul Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Anil Sharma,
R/O D-13/47-48 First Floor Sector-7,
Rohini, Delhi-110085
26. Shankar Lal Meena, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Lakkha Ram Meena,
R/O Jagdish Colony, Near Luniyawas Bus Stand,
Goner Road, Jaipur, Rajasthan-302031
27. Randeep Singh, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Dilbag Singh,
R/O House No.-74,
Village -Depal, P O -Dhandheri,
Teh-Hansi, District- (Haryana)-125033
28. Prateek Paliwal, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Ashok Paliwal,
R/O 450, Govind Rao Ji Ka Rasta,
Chandpole Bazar, Jaipur 302001
29. Shameek Mukherjee , Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 32 Years,
S/O Sh. Anjan Mukherjee,
R/O Flat No:-3, Fd-419 Sector:- 3,
Salt Lake City Kolkata-700106 , West Bengal
30. Anik Dey, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 31 Years,
S/O Sh. Ashim Kumar Dey
R/O Anandavilla V, 2nd Floor,
Deodar Place, Garia Station Road,
P.O . - Garia, Kolkata - 700084
31. Mandeep Sawana, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Harbans Singh
6 OA 860/2020
R/O House No. 614 , Hizrawan Khurd,
Fatehabad, Haryana, Pincode- 125050
32. Vivek Choudhary, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/o Sh. Vikram Singh,
R/O 59, Khwas Ji Ka Bagh,
Durgapura, Tonk Road, Jaipur-302018
33. Shubham, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Rajendra Kumar,
R/O Bura Patasha Wali Gali Kedal Gunj,
Alwar, Rajasthan-301001
34. Ashutosh Vijayvargiya, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Deshraj Vijayvargiya
R/O 24-A, Sita Vihar, Khirani Fatak Road,
Near Saini Marriage Palace, Jhotwara,
Jaipur Rajasthan 302012
35. Rohit Verma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 24 Years,
S/O Sh. Sushil Verma,
R/O B-168 Street No-2 Sadatpur,
Ext Delhi -110094
36. Saurabh Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Babu Lal Sharma,
R/O H.No. 313, Prakash Vihar,
Palwal, Haryana-121102
37. Kanakadandi Guru Kalyan, Appointment (Gr 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. K Ram Mohan
R/O 39/435-11, E-Cross,
Vivekananda Nagar, Kadapa,
Andhra Pradesh-516001.
38. Diksha Jadon, Appointment (Group 'C')
7 OA 860/2020
Aged About 24 Years,
D/O Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Jadon,
R/O Vpo. Kanchanpur, Dholpur,
Rajasthan-328041
39. Surender Kumar Varma , Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Ram Saran Varma,
R/O Mansak Purava, Rajapur,
Gonda District, Uttar Pradesh-271603
40. Neeraj Singh Pathania, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 28 Years,
S/O Sh. Jarnail Singh Pathania,
R/O Village Ror, Vpo Panjahara,
Tehsil Nurpur, Kangra,
Himachal Pradesh - 176051
41. Ashish Bhatt, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Sunder Mani Bhatt,
R/O House No. 1009, Shiv Mandir Gali,
Dashmesh Nagar, Naya Gaon, Mohali,
Punjab. Pin Code - 160103
42. Rahul Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Ashok Kumar Sah,
R/O Vill Roshna Po Roshna Ps-Pranpur,
Katihar, Bihar-854117
43. Navneet Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 31 Years,
S/O Sh. Ram Niwas,
R/O H.No. 252 Sector 10 Urban Estate,
Gurugram Haryana-122001
44. Ashish Kashyap, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Ram Singh,
R/O 21/1183 Indira Nagar,
8 OA 860/2020
Lucknow, U.P-226016
45. Kritavishek Mallick, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Samar Singh Mallick,
R/O Madhusudhan Complex, 61,
Sn Banerjee Road, Chiriamore,
Barrackpore, North 24 Parganas,
West Bengal-700120
46. Vinay Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Mali Ram Sharma,
R/O Vill- Mei Rajanpura Via-Danta Ramgarh,
Dist. Sikar, Rajasthan-332703
47. Pushpendra Tomer, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Dharmraj Tomer,
R/O Vpo Bijrol District Baghpat,
Uttar Pradesh - 250611
48. Nitin Panwar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Subodh Kumar,
R/O Vill Naunangali Po Purmafi,
Tehsil Oon, District Shamli,
Uttar Pradesh - 247773
49. Deepanshu Bhardwaj, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Ved Prakash Bhardwaj,
R/O House No 574/15, Gali No 10,
Adarsh Colony, Opp Ambay School,
Palwal, Haryana -121102
50. Megha Goyal, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Rajender Kumar Goyal,
R/O 12, Model Town, Mandi Adampur,
Hisar, Haryana-125052
9 OA 860/2020
51. Soumya Basu, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 28 Years,
S/O Debasish Basu,
R/O 15/1 Sahapur Colony,
New Alipore East Kolkata-700053
52. Prabhat Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Harinandan Sah,
R/O Vill- Chhoti Balha,
Po- Balha Bazar Ps- Mansi,
Dist- Khagaria, Bihar-851220
53. Amit Balhra, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Rampal Balhra
R/O H.No 623/10, Ramgopal Colony,
Rohtak, Haryana-124001
54. Mahima Kumawat, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
D/O Sh. Shivraj Singh,
R/O 130, Ganesh Nagar 5th,
Sitali Bye Pass, Machada Jaipur, Rajasthan-302032
55. Shubham Meena, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Kedar Singh Meena,
R/O A 31 Shankar Vihar Jagatpura Road,
Sawai Gatoreipur Jaipur-302017
56. Sameer Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Sh. Meer Singh,
R/O A-76 Sector 12 Noida,
District Gb Nagar, Uttar Pradesh-201301
57. Parvesh, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 24 Years,
S/O Sh. Shambhu Dayal Meena,
10 OA 860/2020
R/O Balin Wala Raasta, Talai K Pass ,
Vp Hudla, Teh Mahwa , Dist- Dausa,
Rajasthan-321608
58. Anand Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O Sh. Yugal Kishor Mishra,
R/O Kora, Singhwara, Darbhanga, Bihar-847104
59. Ravi Bhushan, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 26 Years,
S/O Ram Kailash Sah,
R/O Rz-45 1a Gali No.- 21 Delhi,
Indra Park Palam Colony,South West Delhi-110045
60. Sourabh Rana, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 28 Years,
S/O Sh. Vikram Singh,
R/O Vill Dehar, P.O.Ambli,
Tehsil Naraingarh, Distt. Ambala, Haryana-134203
61. Akash Kumar Meena, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Sharvan Kumar Meena,
R/O E 24 Vijay Nagar, Murlipura Jaipur,
Rajasthan-302039
62. Mohit Sharma, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 23 Years,
S/O Sh. Kanti Prasad,
R/O House No 206 Police Colony,
Kondli Check Post,
Delhi - 110096
63. Rahul Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Karni Ram,
R/O Vpo- Loyal, Tehsil- Khetri,
District- Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan - 333514
64. Sumit Kumar Kaushik, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Shri Bhagwan,
11 OA 860/2020
R/O H.No. 1050 Ward No 2
Gali No 3, Shankar Garden Linepar,
Bahadurgarh-124507
65. Vivek Kumar Singh, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Surendra Singh,
R/O H.No 47 Village Sondh,
Ps- Rajrappa Project Dist- Ramgarh,
Jharkhand,829150
66. Raj Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sitaram,
R/O H-98, 99 Tigri, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar,
Sector-1, New Delhi-110080
67. Vipin Kumar, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 27 Years,
S/O Sh. Suresh Kumar (Late),
R/O Hn-797/11, Wn 18 ,
Gn 3 Vivekanand Nagar ,
Bahadurgarh, Jhajjar, Haryana-124507
68. Abhishek Singh, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 25 Years,
S/O, Sh. Ram Naresh Singh (late),
R/O, tiwari Campus, Hasan Chowk, Lalbagh,
Darbhanga, Bihar-846004
69. Jhilmil Bansal, Appointment (Group 'C')
Aged About 24 years,
D/O, Sh. Sanjeev Bansal,
R/O, Kapda Mahal, C-29, Kamla nagar,
Agra-282004 UP ...Applicants
(By Advocate: Shri M.K. Bhardwaj)
Vs.
1. Union of India
through Secretary,
12 OA 860/2020
DOP&T,
North Block, New Delhi
2. Staff Selection Commission
through its Chairman,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road,
New Delhi
3. The Regional Director,
Staff Selection Commission,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road,
New Delhi ...Respondents
(By Advocates: Shri Gyanendra Singh and Shri G.S. Virk)
ORDER (Oral)
Hon'ble Mr. R.N. Singh, Member (J):
Heard Mr. M.K. Bhardwaj, learned counsel for the applicants and Mr. Gyanendra Singh and Mr. G.S. Virk, learned counsel for the respondents.
2. M.A. 1289/2020 has been filed by the applicants praying therein to take Annexures M-1 and M-2 on record.
3. Mr. M.K. Bhardwaj, learned counsel for the applicants submits that in view of Annexure M-2 i.e. 'Final Status of SSCOM/R/E/20/08095', the present OA has become infructuous.
4. Per contra, Mr. Gyanendra Singh, learned counsel for the respondents submits that the OA itself is not maintainable. 13 OA 860/2020
5. Be that as it may, in view of submission made by learned counsel for the applicants, the OA is disposed of having become infructuous.
6. Pending MAs, if any, also stand disposed of. No costs.
(Mohd. Jamshed) (R.N. Singh) Member (A) Member (J) /dkm/uma/vb/