Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
R Brahmaji vs Shobhana Joshi on 27 October, 2018
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
New Delhi, this the 27th day of August, 2018
Hon'ble Mr. Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman
Hon'ble Mr. Pradeep Kumar, Member (A)
1. D. Ramesh
S/o Shri D. Hari Prasada Rao,
R/o No. 201, Ist Floor, Sanjay Aptts.,
Chandagiri Colony, Safilguda Neredmet
Secunderabad
2. G. Rajitha, D/o Shri G. Mallaiah
R/o Flat No.504, Shivam-2, Saptagiri Colony,
Neredment, Secunderabad
3. Bitra Padmaja, D/o Shri B.V. Brahmaiah
R/o flat No.204, Satyam Navya Sree Enclave,
Road No.3, Malkaji Giri, Secunderabad.
4. P. Eswara Rao, S/o Shri Narayana
R/o P No.80, Thorrur
Hayat Nagar, Secunderabad.
5. Abdul Shamim, S/o Shri Abdul Rahim
R/o C-50, DAD Quarters, Lekha Nagar,
Trimulgherry, Secunderabad.
6. K. Sita Lakshmi, W/o Shri K.S.R.C. Murty
R/o Flat No.104, Durga Emrald Apartments,
S.K.D. Nagar, Vanasthalipuram,
Hyderabad.
7. S. Srinivas Rao, S/o Shri S. Lakshmaiah
R/o Qr. No. 4010, Ordnance Factory Estate,
Yeddumailaram, Secunderabad
2
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
8. S.J.S. Venkata Rao, S/o late Shri S.A. Rao,
R/o C-22, DAD Complex,Lekha Nagar,
Trimulgherry, Secunderabad.
9. Y. Ramakrishna, S/o Shri Nageswara Rao
R/o C-21, DAD Quarters, Lekha Nagar,
Trimulgherry, Secunderabad.
10. Raju Koppulla, S/o late Shri K.V.V. Satya Narayana
R/o C-56, DAD Quarters, Lekha Nagar,
Trimulgherry, Secunderabad Telengana
11. Chinni Srinivasa Bapuji
S/o Chinni Venkata Swamy
R/o C-30, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Karkhana, Secunderabad.
12. V. Anil Kumar, S/o Shri V.K.V.Prasad
R/o Flat No.202, Near Uppal Bus Stand Depot,
Medipalli, Hyderabad
13. P. Shrinivas Murthy, S/o Shri P.R.K. Murthy,
R/o S-4, Vijay Residency, M.E.S. Colony,
West Venkatapuram, Alwal, Secunderabad.
14. Manjula Shrikant Balarao
D/o late Srikant M. Balerao
R/o 1-5-109/A, Vasavi Enclave, Old Alwal,
Secunderabad.
15. M.M. Jaya Babu, S/o Shri M. Muttaiah
R/o Flat No.301, K.R. Jade Apt.
Near Tulsi Garden, Yapral, Secunderabad
16. Ch. Bhasker Rao, S/o Shri C. Ayodhya Ramulu
R/o H.No.1-30-517/1,Subash Nagar,
Secunderabad.
17. G.R.S. Sivakumar, S/o Shri Venkata Appa Rao,
R/o Qr.No.C/12, DAD Residential Complex,
Karkhana, Secunderabad.
3
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
18. R.M.R. Maheshwara Rao,
S/o Late Shri. Maheswara Rao,
R/o C-61, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Karkhana, Secunderabad.
19. Suneel Kumar Returi
S/o late Shri Returi Rejshwar Rao,
R/o 1-3-77/102, F.No.102, Acropolis Villa
St. No.06, Habriguda, Hyderabad.
20. T. Seshu Kumar, S/o Shri Parameshwara Rao,
R/o S-4, Saneep Residency,
Opp. Hanuman Temple, Adarsh Nagar
Venkatapuram, Secunderabad.
21. S. Krishna Kishore, S/o Shri Nasrsimha Murthy
R/o C-33, DAD Residential Complex
Lekha Nagar, Trimulgherry, Secunderabad
22. K. Gopichand, S/o Shri K. Buchanna
R/o Q.No. 28/06, DAD Complex,
A-Wing, Wanowrie Range, Pune, Maharashtra
23. G.V. Sridhar Gou, S/o G. Venkat Swamy
R/o 17-1-391/2/35/1, Subramanya Nagar Colony,
Saidabad Colony, Hyderabad - 500059
24. V. Kalyani, S/o V. Ravi Kumar
R/o Flat No. 102, Plot No. 7, Street No. 3 Bhavant Nagar
Nacharam, Secunderabad
25. V. Dora Babu, S/o late Shri V.Pullanna
r/o MIG-76, GF-2, SVMS Residency
Phase-I, VUDA Colony, Madhavadhara
Visakhapatnam.
26. D.Gopala Krishna, S/o D. Ramachandra Murthy
R/o 58-12-19/6, Flat No. 203,
Simadri Residency, Old Karasa,
NAD Post, Visakhapatnam
27. Parasaram Chaitanya Latha
4
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
D/o Shri P. Sita Rama Charyulu
r/o D.No.9-66/2, Narasimha Nagar,
Gopalapatnam, Visakhapatnam
28. Y. Lokanatham, S/o Shri Y Papa Rao
R/o Door No.31-23-32/7, Kurmannapalem,
Visakhapatnam
29. Usha Kiran Lankalapalli,
D/o Shri Lakshmi Narayana Lasnkalapalli
R/o 21-53/4, FF3, Sri Datha Enclave,
Kakani Nagar, Visakhapatnam
30. Y. Ravi Chandra, S/o Shri Pandu Ranga Rao,
R/o 21-83/2, Kakani Nagar, NAD Post,
Visakhapatnama
31. L. Ravi Kumar, S/o Shri L. Bhaskara Rao,
R/o 21-209, Kakani Nagar, NAD Post,
Visakhapatnam
32. D. Ishwari, W/o Shri D. Raja Rao,
R/o 31-11-4/1, Satavahana Nagar,
Kurmannapalem, Visakhapatnam
33. Lakshmi Satya Prasad Chella,
S/o Shri Nageswara Rao Chella,
C/o K. Gurumurthy,
D.No.38-19-36/4, Jyoti Nagar,
Marripalem, Visakhapatnam
34. S.V.J. Mohan Kumar
S/o Late Shri S.V.J. Ramanayya
C/o S. Satyanarayana, Door No.38-19-59,
Jyothi Nagar, Marripalem (PO)
Visakhapatnam.
35. Datla Kavitha, W/o Shri D.S.N. Raju
R/o D-1, Nirman Park, Industrial Estate,
Visakhapatnam
36. G.V. Ramakrishnamma
5
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
S/o late G.V. Satyanarayana
R/o D. No. 50-93-5/1, GF-1, Sri Krishna Residency,
Shantipuram, Visakhapatnam
37. Matta Ravi Kumar, S/o Shri Sampath Kumar
R/o TF-1, H.No.58-15-81, S.V.M.S. Residency
Shanti Nasgar, Nad „X‟ Road, Vizag-9
38. N.T. Babu, S/o Swami Naidu
R/o House No.5-145, Sanathivanipalem,
Vepagunta Post, Pendurthi Mandal,
Visakhapatnam
39. P. Rama Rao, S/o Shri P. Suryanarayana
R/o Flat No.506, Annapurna Residency
Santhosh Nagar, Vepagunta,
Visakhapatnam
40. M. Sateesh Kumar, S/o Shri M.C. Rangaiah,
R/o D-7, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar Karkhana, Secunderabad
41. V.R.B. Sastry, S/o late V. Seshagiri Rao
R/o H.Np.1-6-37/13/2, Sri Durga Colony,
Kirayakunta, Old Alwal, Secunderabad
42. K.A.V. Uma Mahesh,
S/o late K. Goverdhana Rao
R/o H.No.5/148/47/3, Sai Ganesh Homes,
Raja Nagar, Upperguda, Moula Ali,
Hyderabad
43. V. Rama Krishna, S/o late Shri V.L. Nasrasimha Rao,
R/o H.No.3-3-35/101, S.V. Residency
New Gokhle Nagar, Ramanthapur,
Hyderabad.
44. N.B. Sarma Regula Gadda,
S/o Shri R.R.K. Siva Rao,
R/o Flat No.303, Mayanak Hills,
N.G.O‟s Colony, Srinivasapuram,
Hyderabad
6
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
45. G. Anjaneylu, S/o late Shri G. Ramulu,
R/o H.No.13-6-119/4, Kulsumpuora,
Karwan, Hyderabad
46. T. Latha Rani, D/o Late Shri T. Shanker,
R/o Plot No.430, Pragathi Nagar,
Near Kushi Garden, Nagarom,
R.R. District Telangana
47. K.N.S. Kiran, S/o Shri K.B.V. Subba Rao,
R/o Qr. No.4276, Ordnance Estate,
Eddumailaram, MEDAK
48. B.N. Raghvendra Rao,
S/o Shri B.K. Nasrasimha Murthy,
R/o Plot No.26, H.No.1/21/290,
„Vivekavardmini‟ Chitraiah CHN Colony,
Venkatapuram, Trimulghery Post,
Secunderabad
49. K. Rama Kanth, S/o K. Subramanya Sastry
r/o Plot No.62, H.No.4-12-638,
Dwarkamai Nagar Colony,
Vanasthalipura, Hyderabad
50. K. Latha, W/o SH. M. S. Raju
r/o Flat No.301, T.N Raghupati Sadan
Opp. Saleem Nagar Park II,
Maslakpet, Hyderabad
51. P. Balaji, S/o Shri O Parthasarthy
R/o H.No.12-10-336/5, Venkat Nivas,
Sitafalmandi, Secunderabad
52. K. Srinivasa Rao, S/o Sh. Krishna Rao
R/o C - 13, DAD Quarters,
Lekha Nagar Karkhana, Secunderabad
53. P. Samyukta, D/o Shri P. Sarath Babu,
R/o 10-216/1/401, SVS Sadan,
Vasanthpuri Colony Malka Giri,
7
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
Hyderabad
54. P. Sreehari
S/o Late P. Satyanarayana Murty
R/o H.No.1095 (New), 1-3-183/40/57/3 (Old)
Street No.11, Baskaram, Opp Kotak Mahendra Bank,
Gandhi Nagar Post, Hyderabad
55. T. Srinivasa Rao, S/o Sh. T. Satyanarayana
R/o H. No. 1-5-432/5/16 Part, Suryanagar,
Phase - II, Old Alwal, Secunderabad
56. K. Ramadevi, W/o Shri K. Janardhan Reddy
R/o H.No.5-3-49/4, Gautamai Nasgar,
Vanasthali Puram, Hyderabad
57. Pala Padmavathi
W/o Shri P.C.B.D. Prasada Rao,
R/o Qr. No.C-72, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad
58. Ramesh Chandra Pattanayak
S/o Shri Kanduri Chandra Pattanayak,
R/o Qr. No.D-05, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekhnagar, Trimulghery, Secunderabad,
Telangana
59. Ch. Ravi Kumar, S/o Ch. Bhaskar Rao,
R/o Pot No.87 Gruchlakshmi Colony,
Kakaguda, Secunderabad
60. Srinivasa Rao Vulichi, S/o Shri V.V. Appa Rao
R/o C-49, DAD Residential Complex
Lekha Nasgar, Karkhana,
Secunerabad
61. P.R. Subba Rao,
S/o Pl Satya Narayana Gupta,
C/o M.V.N. Reddy, 21-186, Road No.9,
West Venkatapuram, Secunderabad
62. T.V. Naga Raju, S/o Late Shri Chinnappala Naidu,
8
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
R/o Qr. No.C-60, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Trimulgherry, Secunderabad
63. K. Ramakrishna
S/o late K. Gopalakrishna Rao
R/o 1-5-563/, Plot No.350,
Chetna Housing Colony, Old Atwal,
Secunderabad
64. Vijaya Kumar Pitani , S/o Sh. Rama Rao Pitani
R/o Qr. No. C - 76, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad
65. D. Sasi Kumar, S/o Shri D. Sitaraman
R/o 201, Tarun Residency,
Saptabari Enclave, J.J. Nagar,
P.O. Yapral, Hyderabad
66. A. Srilatha, D/o Shri V. Sridhar Rao,
R/o 2-2-1144/A/B, New Naslla Kunta,
Hyderabad.
67. Sripathi Nalini Padmaja
W/o Shri S.K. Pavan Kumar
r/o Qr. No.C-9, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad.
68. Panuganti Kanka Durga
D/o Shri P. Narasimha Rao,
r/o H.No.2-2-645, Sai Krishna Nagar,
Near Ayyappa Temple, Bagh Amberpet
Hyderabad
69. Meena Kumari M., D/o Shri Sankara Gupta M.,
r/o 103, S.V. Lakshmi Nilayam
S.B.H. Lane, Warasiguda,
Secunderabad.
70. N. Sri Ranga Nath, S/o Shri N.S.K. Charyulu,
r/o Flat No.G-2, Aiswarya Residency
Bala Saraswati Nagar, Malka Giri,
Hyderabad
9
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
71. Suresh Parmeswaran
S/o late Shri T.P. Parmeshwaran,
R/o Qr. No.D-9, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad
72. T. Appa Rao, S/o Shri T. Venketasara Rao,
R/o C-3, DAD Quarters,
Near Hauman Temple, Trimulgherry
Secunderabad
73. P.N. Prasad, S/o Late P. Sreeramurthy
R/o H.No 30-647/5/5/1
N.B. Housing Colony, R.K. Puram,
P.O. Secunderabad - 500056
74. K.V. Rama Raju, S/o Late K. Malleswara Rao,
R/o Flat No.312-A, Sanman Belmor Apartments
Near Gromor Food Nursery, Pet Basheerbagh,
Kompally, Secunderabad
75. K. Ravi Shanker, S/o Shri K. Mallikarjuna Rao,
R/o Flat No.102, S.R. Residency Officers Colony,
Plot No.G-5, Nr. Sainathapuram, Water Tank,
Hyderabad.
76. G. Srinivas Murthy, S/o Shri Mallikarjuna Rao,
R/o F.101, S.R. Residency Officers Colony,
Plot No.G-5, Nr. Sainathapuram, Water Tank,
Hyderabad.
77. U.Srinivasa Rao, S/o U. Appa Rao,
R/o Qr.No. C-51, DAD Quarters,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad
78. P. Brahma Reddy, S/o shri V.Venkattappa Reddy,
R/o Plot No.51, Lakshmi Towers,
L.B. Nagar Colony, Neredmet Main Road,
Secunderabad
79. Chavali Srinivas Chakravarthy
S/o Late Shri C.V.S. Raghunandan,
10
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
R/o H.No.5-9/44, Sai Chandra Colony,
Dasmmaigudda, Hyderabad.
Keesara Mandal, R.R. District
80. V. Naga Prasad, S/o Shri V.C. Nagappa,
R/o H.No.13-9-135, Panduranga Nagar,
Hyderabad
81. V. Udaya Kiran, S/o Late Shri V. Subba Rao,
R/o 102, Samaskruthi Akash,
Yellarddyguda, Opp Mallareddy Gardens,
Kapra, R.R. District, Hyderabad
82. K.P.M.V. Gopalam, S/o late Shri K.Sesha Giri Rao,
R/o Flat No.103, Madhu Sai Apartments,
Street No.24, Gautam Nagar,
Maklajgiri, Hyderabad.
83. Partha Ghosh, S/o Shri M.K. Ghosh,
R/o 505 (B-1) G.K‟s Pride,
Balaji Nagar, Yapral
Hyderabad
84. Tangella Vanaja, W/o Shri U Raghu Veera,
R/o C-34, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad
85. G. Saidesh, S/o G.Vittal
R/o Flat No.04, Somavarapu Elegance,
Street No.1, Arunodaya Bank Colony
Nagole, Hyderabad
86. K. Vijaya Kumar, S/o Shri K. Ranapratap Bapuji,
R/o C-49, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekhanagar, Secunderabad
87. J. Madhavi, W/o Shri J. Sanjeev Kumar
R/o Plot o.884, Defence Colony,
Sainik Puri, Secunderabad
88. P. Anji Reddy, S/o P. Koti Reddy
R/o C- 42, DAD Quarters, Lekha Nagar,
11
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
Kharkana Secunderabad - 500015
89. Draksharapu Sridhar, S/o Shri D.S.Lingam,
R/o Flat No.102, Sneha Residency,
Medipally, Hyderabad
90. Suvarna Jyothi Kumud, W/o Shri Kumud Rajendram
R/o V.No.58, „The Neighbourhood‟,
Kompally, Telangana
91. S. Srinivasa Reddy,
S/o Shri Sivarami Reddy,
R/o Qe. No.C-20, DAD Quarters,
Lakha Nagar, Secunderabad
92. Md. Khaja Mohiudin
S/o Late Md. Shariff Ahmed,
R/o Plot No.19, Jupiter Colony,
Kakaguda, Secunderabad
93. K.S.R. Anjaneyuru
S/o Shri K. Lakshmaiah
R/o Plot No. 24, Phase-I,
Vijaypuri Colony, Vanasthalipuram,
Hyderabad, Telengana State
94. Surekha Vani Ch.
D/o /ch. Venkata Ratnam,
R/o C-52, DADComplex,
Lekha Nagar, Secunderabad
95. J.V.S.S. Madhavi Bala
W/o Shri J.Srinivas,
R/o Plot No.85A, 1-19-166/6, Road No.7,
Joshi Nagar, West Venkata Puram,
Secunderabad
96. C.V. Sharda
D/o Shri C.V.R. Murty,
R/o Plot No.20, H.No.33/44, R.T.C Colony,
Trinulgherry, Secunderabad
12
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
97. P. Aruna Kumari
D/o Shri P.S.N. Murthy,
R/o Plot No.42, A.P.A.V. Colony,
Gaddiannaram, Hyderabad
98. M. Nirmala Devi
W/o Shri P. Narender Reddy,
R/o A-51, Madhura Nagar,
Near Yousufguda, Hyderabad
99. P. Rama Kishore,
S/o Shri P. Appa Road,
R/o Qr. No.C-04, DAD Quarters,
Lekhanagar, Secunderabad
100. A. Eashwaraiah
S/o A. Ramulu
R/o H.No. 13-137, Kamala Nagar Colony,
(Uppal Depot), Medipally (VILL), R.R. Dist - 500058
101. Ch. V. Ramana Murthy
S/o Late C. Subba Rao
R/o F-3, Sai Jyothi Apartments, Sainathpuram,
Hyderabad - 500062
102. V. Sridhar, S/o Shri V. Satyanarayana
R/o I-19-114/6, Kothabasti
Venkatapuram, Secunderabad
103. S. Sailesh Kumar
S/o late Shri S. Rama Rao,
R/o D-11, DAD Quarters,
Lekhanagar, Secunderabad
104. P. Madhu Subramanyam
S/o Shri P. Venteka Rao,
R/o H.No.3-272/10/7, F.No.303,
Santoshima Nagar Colony,
Old Safilguda, Secunderabad
105. V.R.C. Kumar
S/o P. Malleshwar Rao,
13
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
R/o C-47, DAD Complex,
Lekhapur Trimulghery,
Secunderabad
106. D. Srinivasa Rao
S/o Shri D. Syamala Rao,
R/o C-200, Sachivalaya Nagar,
Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad
107. G. Ramesh Kumar
S/o Late Shri G.S.Shanumagam,
R/o 24-3/40/11, Vishnupuri Extn.,
Vimladevi Nasgar, Malkajbiri,
Hyderabad
108. B.V. Satyanarayana
S/o Shri Ramana
R/o Plot No.8, V.R.R. Enclave,
Dammaigud, R.R. District,
Secunderabad
109. B. Usha Rani
W/o Shri P. Balaji
R/o H.No.12-10-336/5, Venkat Niwas
Sithafal Mandi, Secunderabad
110. Shobhana Surendran
W/o O. Surendran
R/o Kukreja Heritage Blding No. 5 Flat 404,
Dhanori RD Pune 411 015
111. M.V. Subrahmanyam
S/o M. Pitchaiah Sastry
R/o Qtr No. G-38, Ordnance Estate,
Ambarnath (W) - 421 502
112. Swati B. Deshpande
W/o Balkrishna H. Deshpande
R/o Plot No. 27, Shri Shankar Darshan 50
S.No. 4 Dhankawadi Pune - 411043
113. Ajit Kumar Prasad
14
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
S/o Shri Mahavir Prasad,
R/o 03, Liverpool, Panvelkar Green City,
Ambarnath
114. Chaturanand Jha,
S/o Shri Shashinandan Jha,
R/o 21/7, New Ty-III Ordnance Esate,
Ambarnath (W), Ambernath
115. Mahalaxmi D. Pabba,
D/o Shri Devdas Pabba,
R/o Jalabam Park, B-201,
L.B.S. Road, Bhandur (W), Mumbai.
116. Deepa Parameshwaran Aged 40 years
W/o R. Parameshwaran
R/o 88-A/23, Vrindavan Scoiety, Majiwada,
Thane (W) - 400601
117. B.V.S.Kumar
S/o Ranga Rao
R/o Flat No. 09, Rachalani Sadan, Kher Section,
Shiv Mandir Road, Ambernath - 421506
118. P. S.V. Nagendra Kumar
S/o P. Satyanarayana Rao
R/o Q.No. 6/7, DAD Quarters,
Chitragupta Colony, Pune
119. Susarla Ravi Kumar
S/o Late Ramasubrahmanyam
R/o Qtr No. 6/1, Chitragupta Complex,
Hidayatulla Road, Opp. Poona College, Pune
120. Sarath Chandra Babu
S/o K.N. Thampy
R/o Kavitha, Pilathara (P.O), Kannur
121. Vinod Kumar K.P
S/o K.P. Narayanan Nair
R/o B-1/1 Pao Staff Quarters
P.O. Burnacherry, Kannur - 670013
15
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
122. Manju. R
W/o Baburaj. P
R/o Flat No: 2B, Sreerosh Midtown Thalikkavu
Kannur - 670001
123. Tomy. G
S/o Y. George
R/o 12A, Heirloom Skyline Apartment,
Thalap, Kannur
124. K. Rajesh
S/o Late K.Narayanan Nair
R/o "Nikunjam" PO: Mathamangalam Bazar
Dist: Kannur Pin: 670306 (Kerala)
Aged about 44 years
125. Shaji .K. M.
S/o A.M. Govif
R/o "Sreerangam", East Ponniam,
Thalassery, Kannur (Dist.) 670641
126. Remeshan K.V
S/o Paithal K.V
R/o Thazhe Kottoor House Vettummal
PO, Kadirur, Tellicherry, Kannur (Dist.) Kerala
127. Harish Kumar. N.S
S/o N.K. Sankaran
R/o Devanandanam (H), Post Kiyilandy,
Kozhikode, Pin 673305
128. T. Sundaravadivel
S/o Late R. Thangaraj
R/o 8-B, Pao officers Qtrs, Mill Road,
Kannur - 640013
129. Gifri. A
S/o K.L. Antony
R/o Jothis House, P.O. Pilathara,
Kannur (DT) Pin - 670504
16
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
130. Janil Raj. K, S/o K. Damu
R/o Vaishakham House, Near JTS, Nutstreet (PO),
Vadakara, Calicut (Dist.) Kerala - 673104
131. Anish VK, S/o Karunakaran P
R/o Q No. C1/2, Pao (ORS) DSC Staff Quarters,
Burnacherry, Kannur - 670013
132. P. Premanandan Nair, S/o K.P. Janardhanan
R/o 8-D, Officers Quarters, Pao (ORS), DSC,
Mill Road, Kannur - 13
133. K. Ramakrishna Rao, S/o Late K. Appa Rao
R/o Quarters No. VIIIA, Pao Officers Quarters,
Mill Road, Kannur - 670013
134. V.K. Dinesh, S/o Sh. M. Balan Erady
R/o "Sreeramyam" Mylampadi,
PO: Nellicode, Calicut - 673016, Kerala
135. Deepa Roy, S/o K.C. Roy
R/o Quarter No. - 2/3, Type-II, Pao Staff Quarters,
Burnassery, Kannur
136. Biju. K.T.K, S/o Balan.K
R/o Kunnoth Thazha Kuniyil,
Rajarangoth, Vadakara
137. Chandran. C, S/o Kannan.C.K.
C.K.Niwas, Pakkath, P.O. Padimaruth 671531
Kasaragod, Kerala
138. Sudarshan, S/o Shri K.P.S. Unney
R/o Judicial Officers Quarters,
Thallipuramba, Kannur
139. N.P. Manoj Kumar, S/o P.V. Nanu
R/o „Padmashree‟ Thamaramangalagh,
Post Kollam, Quilandy, Calicut- DT
140. Om Prakash Gupta, S/o Late Sri Jag Bali Ram
R/o 9/D, Type IV, Ordnance Factory Estate,
17
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
Varangoon - 425 308
Aged about 40 years
141. Pradeep Paul, S/o Atul Chandra Paul
R/o Qtr. No. 28/D Type - IV O.F Varangaon
Estate Taluka Bhusawal Pin - 425308
Aged about 40 years
142. Sree Sai Prasad, S/o Bhaskara Rao
R/o 9/A, Type III Qtrs, Ordnance Factory Estate
Varangoon - 425308
Aged about 38 years
143. Manoj Kumar Singh
S/o Late Yadunandan Singh
R/o Flat No. - 04, East Block, DAD Complex,
Dafnala, Shahibag, Ahmedabad - 380004
144. Vijayan T.K., S/o Late P. Kunchu
R/o „Sarayu‟ Padinjare Veeda, Pattorn,
Manappadom PO, Pala Vkad
145. C.H. Venkata Rao, S/o C. Muthaiah
R/o No-4, Type - IV Qtrs, DAD Residential Complex
V.T. Road Perurranoor P.O Kochi
146. K.R. Sathish, S/o Late K. Rajan
R/o 64/1876, " Nivedhyam" House, Counollor Road
Kaloor, Ernakulam - 682017
147. V. Ananthakrishnan, S/o Late M. Velukutty
C-5 DAD Residential Complex, Defence Lane,
V.T. Road, Perumanoor, Thevara, Kochi
148. Reshma O.M., W/o Arun Kumar.K
R/o 7/644 US, Nakshatra, Elavakkatt Lane, Star Valley
Jbrikkakora PO Ernakulan - 682021
149. N. Pradeep Babu, S/o Late N. Velukkan
R/o C-9, DAD Quarters, Defence Accounts lane
Perumanoor, Thevara
18
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
150. K. Jayakumar
S/o Late Shri K K Krunakaran
R/o Qtr. No. C/24, DAD Residential Complex, Varghese
Thittayil Road, Perumanoor P.O., Kochi
151. Remya Luxmi R
W/o Shanker K
R/o #106, Santhi Pavana, Yuvajanasamajam Road,
Kochu Kadavanthra, Near SBT
152. Sandhya R.V. , W/o N. Gopalakrishnan
R/o Deepthi House, Meempara P.O. Puthencruz (Via)
Ernakulam - 682308
153. Pillai Mini Sukumaran
W/o P Biju
R/o Peringalil House, T.P. South, Haripad P.O.,
Alappuzha - 690 514
154. Smitha Biju, W/o Biju P.V.
R/o Kunju‟s Pandathil Lane, Eroor (N) P.O. Thripunithura
Ernakulam - 682306
155. Arunkumar K, S/o Shri K. Kunhiraman
R/o 7/644 - US, Nakshatra, Elavakkatt Lane, Star Vally
Thrikkakara Post, Ernakulam - 682 021
156. K.M. Bose, S/o Late Shri P.M. Mani
R/o Kavunkal Karote House, Lakkattoor Post,
Kottayam - 682 502
157. Binu K, S/o K Kuttappan
R/o Ambili Makkuni, Champad Post, Thalassery,
Kannur - 670 694
158. Ramesh M, S/o Late T Madhavan Nair
R/o Kalanilayam, Karumalloor P.O. Manakkapday,
Ernakulam, Kochi
Aged about 42 years
159. Harikumar V, S/o Late Veluthakunju
R/o Lalitha Bhavanam, Muttom P.O. Harippad,
19
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
Alleppy Dist Kochi
160. D Suresh, S/o Late N. S. Damodaran
R/o Ramanilayam, Vellopadiyil, Irumpanam
Thripunithura - 682 309
161. K Manoj, S/o K.R.K.K. Nair
R/o D-1, DAD Residential Complex, Varghese
Thittayil Road, Perumanoor PO, Thevara, Kochi
162. Vinod G
S/o Late P. Govindankutty Nair
R/o C-3, DAD Residential Complex, Varghese
Thittayil Road, Perumanoor PO, Thevara, Kochi
163. Joby Varghese P
S/o Shri P.M Varghese
R/o 3G Tower of faith, Vallathol Junction,
Seaport Airport Road, Kochi - 682 021
164. Varun T.D.
S/o T.K. Dineshan
R/o Thacharayil House, Thalayolaparambu PO,
Kottayam - 682 605
165. Rakhi Joshy, W/o Joshy K.A
R/o W-4, Moolamanil West Pier, Thevara, Kochi
166. Nishi Syam, W/o Syam Joseph
R/o Suhaz, C.C. 15/51, A.K. Xavier Road,
Kazhuthumuttu, Kochi - 682 005
167. Rajesh P.T.
S/o Shri P.K. Thankappan
R/o Dream Flower Evita, Kadupathu Road,
Ponnurunni East, Vytilla, Kochi - 19
168. Lalit Narayan Mishra
S/o Shri Ramjee Mishra
R/o Village Pratap Chhapar
Post: Bankata Station
Dist: Deoria State Uttar Pradesh
20
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
169. Kumar Roushan
S/o Shri Dinesh Kumar Singh,
R/o Moh. Saraswati Lane,
East Lohanipur, Post Kadam Kuan,
Distt. Patna (Bihar)
170. Gunjan Kumar
S/o Nagendra Jha
R/o P-14/2, DAD Colony Solapur Road,
Ahmednagar, PAO (Ors) Ahmednagar,
171. Vishwesh Dixit
S/o Sh. Vishnu Dayal Dixit.
R/o P-8/5, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar
172. Ajay Kumar Gupta
S/o Uday Narayan Prasad,
R/o Q. No. P-19/1, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar,
173. Sagar Sardar
S/o Subal Sardar
R/o Qtr. No. P-14/3, DAD Complex
Ahmednagar
174. G. Bhanu Prasad
S/o Late Sh. G Rajagopal
R/o Q. No. 13/8, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar,
175. Ashish Dvivedi
S/o Sh. Ramashray Dvivedi
R/o P-7/3, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar,
176. Kalyan Ray
21
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
S/o Late. Ranjit Ray
R/o P-14/04, DAD Residential Complex
Solapur Road, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra
177. Zalte Hilalsinu Jamsinu
S/o Zalte Jamsinu Mahadv
R/o P.13/1 DAD Qtrs,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar
178. R.S. Royer
S/o Late S. Royer
R/o 1/8 DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar
179. Smt. T.V. Bhoite
D/o Late Sh. F.X. Lobo
R/o 13/2 DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar
180. K. Gangadhar
S/o K.S. Rao
R/o Qtr. No. 13/5 D.A.D. Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandni Chow Ahamednagar,
Maharashtra, Ahmednagar
181. Kamesh Kanchan Katariar
S/o Tribhuwan Nath Verma
R/o Qtr. No. 8/2 DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar
182. Kaustubh K. Jalgaonkar
S/o Kamalakar S. Jalgaonkar
R/o Qtr. No. 3/7, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar,
183. B. Venkateshwar Rao
S/o B. Narsing Rao
22
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
R/o P-13/6, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar,
184. Vandana Vilas Wadekar
D/o Late Sh. Vilas Vithalrao Wadekar
R/o 19/3, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar,
185. P. Rajalekshmy
W/o T.D. Ramakrishnan
R/o C-1/3, DAD Quarters, Phase-II
Singarathope, Wellington - 643231
186. Sandhya M. Khurana,
W/o Shri Manjeet Singh L. Khurana,
r/o 7/2, Sadguru Sai Sadan,
Kolbad Road, Khopat, Thane
187. Ashok D. Jadav
S/o Dhulabhai Jadav
R/o 499/1, Sector- 5/A, Gandhinagar
188. Mahesh Prasad,
S/o Late Shri G.P. Verma,
r/o Flat No.204, A-Wing,
Vishaldeep Residency,
Chandanagar, Pune - 411 014
189. Chetan Kishnawat
S/o Raghunath Singh
R/o Village: Shyampura Post: Punia Ka BAS via Bisau
Dist. Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan
190. Deepak Kumar Pandey
S/o Sh. Nageshwar Pandey
R/o 13/3, DAD Colony, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar, Maharashtra
191. Himanshu Kumar Srivastave
S/o Shri Rajendra Prasad
23
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
R/o 14 B Saujanya Society, Opp Bhavan School,
Makarpura Road, Vadodara - 390009
192. Bhavana Chauhan
S/o R.P.S Chauhan
R/o 205 Ratan Plaza Santra Market
Nagpur
193. S.S.Dhole
S/o S. H. Dhole,
R/o Plot No. 103, New Subbedar Loyatt,
Nagpur - 440024
194. Deepankar Das
S/o Late Braja Bihar: Das
R/o Q.NO. - 2/1, Lekhanagar
Kamptee (Nagpur)
195. D.L. Swami
S/o L.G. Swami
R/o Plot No. 47, NR Phiv Pesidency Barde Layout,
Borgaon Nagar - 13
196. Sanju Makadi
S/o Tulsiram Mukadi
R/o QTR. No. 3/1, Lekhanagar,
Kamptee Nagpur
197. Kishor Kr. Sahu
S/o Shri Ravi Shankar
R/o 5/3, Lekha Nagar, Near Asha Hospital Nagar Road
Kamptee
198. P. G. Bahadure
S/o G.K. Bahadure
R/o Qtr No. 4-5 Lekhanagar,
Kamptee Pin 441001
199. Dileep Kumar Baphna
S/o Madan Lal Baphna
R/o Type - IV/ 2, Lekha Enclave,
Dafnala - Shahibaug, Ahmedabad
24
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
200. DSRL Narasimha Rao
S/o Ramachandra Rao
R/o D-6, Lekha Enclave, Dafnala,
Shahibaug, Ahmedabad
201. E.B. Mathwes
S/o Baby.T. Mathews
R/o H. 46, Bholeshwar Co. Op. Soc, Hansol,
PO, Hansol Road, PO, Sardarnagar,
Ahmedabad - 382475
202. Vikram Pendharkar
S/o Vasant Pendharkar
R/o QTR No. 5, Type IV Lekha Enclave,
Dafnala, Shahibaug, Ahmedabad
203. Sunil Lukose
S/o Late A.T. Lukose
R/o B-702, Ratnadeep Towers, NR. Arjun Towers,
B/h. CP Nagar, Ghatlodia, Ahmedabad - 380061
204. S.N. Iyer
S/o Narayan N.Iyer
R/o D-204, Setudham Apartment, Viratnagar,
Isanpur, Ahmedabad - 382443
205. Iswar. P
S/o I. Parameswaran
R/o Qtr. No. 5, East Wing, Lekha Enclave,
Shahibaug, Dafnala, Ahmedabad
206. Amar Raut
S/o Madhukar Raut
R/o 51/3 Mes Colony Bhuj
207. Robin D‟souza
S/o Joe M. D‟souza
R/o Q/o The Lao (A), Army Area, Bhuj - Kutch
208. Vidula Dinanath Bhide,
D/o Shri Dinanath P. Bhide,
25
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
r/o 102/12, Vijay Park,
Kasarwadavli Ghodhudar Road,
Thane (West), Thane
209. Sunita Tiwari, S/o Om Prakash Tiwari
R/o 502, Lime Building, Dream Citi
Nasik Road - 422 006
210. Shamsingh. M.Pardeshi, S/o Late M.M. Pardeshi
R/o Plot No. 28, Iehhamani Colony,
behind Sapana Cinema Hall CIDCO, Nashika
211. Rahul A. Bidwai, S/o Ashok Bidwai
R/o Shriji Palace Flat No. 3 „B‟
Chetana Nagar, Nasik - 422009
212. Raghunath M. Patil, S/o Murlidhar Ramaji Patil
R/o Flat No. - 1 Maitra Pratik Apartment,
Near RTO Office Peth Road, Panchavati,
Nasik - 4
213. P.S. Chandra Shekhar , S/o Late Sh. P. Sudhakar
R/o Qtr No. P-76/4, DAD Quarters,
Lekha Nagar, Nasik - 422009
214. Ashwin P. Satpurkar, S/o Late P.S. Satpurkar
R/o 3, Yashodhan Apartment, above Rassang
Sweet Indian Nagar, Nasik - 9
215. Tapanasu Laskar
S/o Late Bisuddhananda Laskar
R/o P/314 DAD Residential Complex
Lekhanagar, Nasik - 422009
216. Shivmurat Maurya, S/o Shri Udal Maurya
R/o Qrt No. P13/3 DAD Residential Complex
PAO (Ors) Arty, Lekha Nagar, Nasik - 09
217. Ashok Kumar Singh, S/o Bhurey Lal
R/o Qrt. No. P.76/01, DAD Residential Complex
PAO (Ors) Arty, Lekhanagar, Nasik - 09
26
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
218. B.S. Patil, S/o Late S.N. Patil
R/o Plot No. 56, Sr. No. 66 Sarthak Bangla
Shankar Patil Nagar Trimurty Chawk,
New CIDCO Nasik 422 008
219. Ranjan Kumar
S/o Bindeshwar Prasad Singh
R/o P 73/10, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekhanagar, Nasik - 422009
220. Sushil S. Hulsurkar, S/o Shrikant Hulsurkar
R/o Flat No. 7, Praful Apartment, Infront of ICICI,
Indiranagar, Nasik - 422009
221. B.Srinivasulu, S/o B. Venkateswarlu
R/o P-5/4, DAD Residential Complex
Lekhanagar, Nasik
222. Sandeep Kr. Shah, S/o Shri Ram Babu Shah
R/o Qtr. No. P/18/3, DAD Residential Complex,
Lekha Nagar, Nasik
223. Vaijayanti D. Kulkarni, W/o Deepak Kulkarni
R/o Flat No. 2, Praful Appt, Near Janhavi Row House,
Indira Nagar, Nasik - 422 009
224. Lal Bahadur, S/o Raj Bhawan Singh
R/o Flat No. - 6 Vakratund Avenue
Samrat Sweet Indira Nagar, Nasik - 9
225. Archana N. Sonawane
W/o Narendra K. Sonawane
R/o Qtr No. P. 75/11 DAD Residential Complex,
Lekhanagar, Nasik - 09
226. Sanjeev Kumar, S/o Late P.N. Mishra
R/o Flat No. 14, Pratham Apartment,
Rajiv Nagar, Nasik - 422009
227. K. Nagaraju, S/o Late K. Venkoba Rao
R/o Qtr No. [/14/1, DAD, Quarters,
Lekhanagar, Nasik - 422009
27
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
228. Pramod Kumar, S/o Late Damodar Singh
R/o Flat No. 08, Vakratund Avenue
B/h Guru Govind Singh College, Indira Nagar, Nasik
229. Sanjay S. Petkar, S/o Sudhadarrao K. Petkar
R/o B-2 Shivdarshan Appt. Shriram Chowk,
Near Gajanan Class, Indiranagar, Nasik - 442009
230. Manoj Kumar Girish Shrivastava
S/o Shri Girish Kanhayalal Shrivastava
R/o T/176/01, Shahibaug Enclave, Opp OM Tower,
Nr BSNL Office, Shahibaug, Ahmedabad 383 004
231. Babita Singh, W/o Upendra Kumar
R/o Flat No. 10411, S.B. Heights Lane No. 14 J,
Vidyanagar, Pune - 32
232. K.A.H. Raju, S/o K.Y.Ratnam
R/o Quarter No. A/4/15, DAD Chitragupta Complex,
Hidayatulla Road, Comp, Pune
233. C. Samba Siva Rao, S/o Late Narayana
R/o D-1, 204,Gangavihar,
Near Gangadham Chowck, Pune-411037
234. B.N.C. Srikanth, S/o B. Visweswara Rao
R/o Qtr No. 27/10, DAD Complex, Wanowrie range,
Lulla Nagar, Pune
235. K. Phani Kumar, S/o K. Subba Rao
W/o Flat No. 702, A2 Building,
Gangadham Phase - I, Bibwewadi, Pune
236. Ravindra Pawar , S/o Suravan Pawar
R/o 15/9, DAD Complex, Wanorie Range, Pune
237. GNV Viswanadha Gupta
S/o GRS Prasad Rao
R/o Qtr. No. 28/12, DAD Complex, Lullanagar
Wanorie Range, Pune
28
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
238. K. Suresh Babu, S/o K. Raghavaiah
R/o Quarter No. 3/12, Chitragupta Complex
Hida Yatuwa Rao, Bhavani Pvt, Pune - 42
239. S.T. Pinjarkar, S/o Tulshiram Pinjarkar
R/o Qtr No. 27/15, DAD Complex, Near Lulla nagar,
Wanowarie Range, Pune - 40
240. Santosh, S/o Late Ram Pravesh Singh
R/o Qtr No. 5/5, Wanorie Range, DAD Compex, Pune
241. Bolla Mohan, S/o B. Sudarshan
R/o Qtr. No. 28/2, DAD Complex, Wanworie, Pune
242. Ms. Elizabeth Rene Sooppa
D/o Late Rene Sooppan
R/o P-1, Mantri Aangan 81 Mundhwa Road,
Pinglevasti, Pune - 411 036
243. Suhana Arief, W/o A. Rahman
R/o 5/15, Defence Residential Complex,
Hidayatulla Road, Bhavani Pet, Pune
244. G. Praveen Kumar, S/o G. Yadagiri
R/o Gangadham Aprts Phase-I A2 Building 703,
Bibwewadi, Near Market Yard
245. Tusar Kumar, S/o Late Murali Singh
R/o Flat No. - 103, Swami Samarth Nagar,
Telegaon Dabhade
246. Ravi. R., S/o R. Raman Kutty Nair
R/o C- 1-16, DAD Complex, Opp. Poona College,
Hidayatullah Road, Pune - 42
247. Sudha Rani. R, S/o Shri Ravi. R.
R/o Qtrs No. 1/16, Chitragupta Compex,
Opp. Pune College, Hidayatullah Road, Pune
248. A. Vijaya, S/o R.V. Prathap
R/o 4/2 Chitragupta Complex, DAD, Quarters, Pune
29
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
249. Umesh Kumar Roy, S/o Yogendra Roy
R/o 1/14, Chitragupta DAD Complex,
Hidayatulla Road, Pune - 47
250. Dhiraj Kr. Jha, S/o Shri R.K.Jha
R/o Q.No. 3/13, Chitragupta Colony, Pune - 411042
251. A. Jaya Simha, S/o A. Manikya Rao
R/o Qtr. No. 28/5, DAD Complex, Wanowri Range
Lullanagar, Pune
252. P. Mohan Kumar, S/o PBL Charyulu
R/o Qtr No. 27/16, DAD Residential Complex
A - Wing, Wamorie, Pune - 411040
253. P.Shirisha, S/o P.Rangaiali
R/o Qtr. No. 4/16, Chitragupta Complex,
Hidayatulla Road, Bhavani Pethi, Pune - 42
254. Samir Mandal , S/o Sri R.K. Mandal
R/o 89/4, Ordnance Factory
(Estate) Dehu Road, Pune - 412101
255. Dwairath kumar Some, S/o Deb Prasad Some
R/o 26/6, DAD Residential Complex, „A‟ Wing,
Wonewari Range, Pune - 40 (near Ganga Dham)
256. Arnab Saha, S/o Manoj Saha
R/o Qrt. No. 2/15, Chitragupta Complex
Hidayatulla Road, Pune - 411042
257. Partha Roy, S/o Late Barid Baran Roy
R/o 53/3, Mes Colony, Army Area, Bhuj-Kutch
258. Shahzad Ahmed, S/o Mohd. Yaqub
R/o 3/2, Chitragupta Colony,
Bhawani Peth, Pune
259. Debdoot Chatterjee
S/o Dhruba Chatterjee
R/o 27/07, DAD Compex, Lulla Nagar, Pune- 40
30
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
260. Firdose Asias
S/o Basha
R/o C 5/5 Chithraguptha Complex,
Opp Pune College, Pune
261. G. Anuradha
S/o G.S.V.R.K Choudary
R/o H.No 1-23-127/1, Bhoodevi Nagar,
Venkatapuram, Secunderabad - 15
262. G. Neelakantam
W/o Shri Adi Narayana,
r/o C-37, DAD Quarters,
Lekhnagar, Secunderabad
263. Deepa Roy
D/o Late Sh. L Pappen
R/o Quarter No. 2/3, Type - II,
Pao Staff Quarters, Burnassery, Kannur
264. Krishna Kumar
S/o Satyanarayan Prasad
R/o P/253, DG Lines, Devlali Camp
Nasik - 422401
265. Preeti S. Bhalekar
S/o Shrikant Bhalekar
R/o Qr. No. P/4/2, DAD Quarters Lekha Nagar,
Nasik - 422 009
266. Vikas M. Waware, S/o Shri M.R. Waware
R/o Qtr No. 4 Type - IV, Lekha Enclave
Shahibaug, Dafnala, Ahmedabad
267. Satyabrata Dutta, S/o Sh. Sunil Baran Dutta
R/o P-8/6, DAD Complex,
Solapur Road, Chandani Chowk,
Ahmednagar ....Petitioners
(By Advocate: Shri Ajesh Luthra)
Versus
31
CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015
1. Smt. Shobhana Joshi, Controller General
Controller General of Defence Accounts,
Ulan Batar Road, Palam, Delhi Cantt,
Delhi-110010
2. Sh. S. S. Mohanty
Financial Advisor (Defence Services),
Ministry of Defence (Finance)
South Block, New Delhi
3. Sanjay Khothari, Secretary
Union of India, Department of Personnel & Training,
Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievances and Pension,
North Block, New Delhi ...Respondents
(By Advocate: Shri Hanu Bhaskar)
ORDER (ORAL)
Justice L. Narasimha Reddy:-
This contempt case is filed alleging that the respondents did not implement the Order dated 12.08.2015 in OA No.2868/2015. The case has undergone several adjournments. The respondents filed a counter affidavit stating that the Order has since been implemented in the form of passing of order dated 27.05.2016. It is further stated that the actual adjudication has taken place in OA Nos.966 and 967/2009 before the Madras Bench of the Tribunal, which, in turn, led to filing of SLP and as of now the 32 CP No.209/2016 in OA No.2868/2015 Review Petition is pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in respect of that case.
2. We have heard Shri Ajesh Luthra, learned counsel for the applicants and Shri Hanu Bhaskar, learned counsel for the respondents.
3. Two developments have taken place in this case. First is that in compliance of the Order in the OA, the respondents passed an order dated 27.05.2016. Secondly, the very foundation for the relief granted in the OA, being the order passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP, is said to be under Review.
4. In this view of the matter, we close the contempt case leaving it open to the applicants to pursue their remedies depending upon the outcome of the Review Petition, pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
(Pradeep Kumar) (Justice L. Narasimha Reddy) Member(A) Chairman /vb/