The State Of Karnataka vs N G Shivalingalppa on 30 November, 2011

[Cites 8, Cited by 3]

Karnataka High Court

The State Of Karnataka vs N G Shivalingalppa on 30 November, 2011

Equivalent citations: 2012 LAB. I. C. 929, 2012 (1) AIR KAR R 712, (2012) 133 FACLR 9, (2012) 1 KCCR 263

Bench: A.S.Bopanna

' ma

§_";;>

WA. 243113.593! 2!} 1 1 8:: WA $195, 399()=«9 3; /201 1 (S~RI3S}
BEHVEER:

E. The State. a-f Karnaiaka;
3:3}; is Secretazga
Depazimani caf Primary E*c:§uCaii.Gr;., H  
M.S.Bui}c.i3;ng, Vsidhana Ve&é;?3i.,    
Bangaiereﬁ. I ' ~ "

s>~>

The Cgmmissiener V 4_ ._ --  A .v
Department efPrir:1a,r§¥-}:§L%.:;c3.ii{:::_,    
Nrupathunga Raad, Banggjzsral, ' " '

L»)

The Beputy Direaféf c3f:P1j.h1'ir:.__'»._ "' _
Instructions Admini_:_girat.i.5::,    . .
ijepartmerti of P't3,§3.§iC'II1;SJC;'s;{CtiC31'"iS;  ~ 

Davanage 3:3 Bistirict, iﬁavazzggefel

4' Tha  
Ngrﬁh  :DVa=:.r_a3;;::f_age1"e _.__ V 
"  I I*'  "  ...APD€113_ntS

" _ ' . .£i§ySi*i.£B;Kfe€rappa, A.G.A.}

" NI 1"} .SI:iVa1inga}ppa,
"  Aged .3333-GT1}: 55 years,
~ __ .S','f§' Sri  Jayadevappa,
V  Gcci 'ﬁeéd M39161; Naikunda Pogtg
 Bavazigers Taiuk $3: B§S'§3'?iC€.

__ KVR E*§aI1j&p§3..
. _ '"'_«ﬁs.g€é abawg: £5 yearza
" Sfo Sri 8 Rudrappa,
Occ: Assistant Teacher,
R/0 Kandagal Past,
Davanagere Taluk & District.

3. Shivakumar M K,
Aged. about 42 years,
S / 0 Sri Kenchaveerappa,



EM!)

DJ

AN£):'-- _

BezI1;§a1¢:3§e~56O 001 .

The Principal Sec'ret:ary

to Gm-'e:fI1rr1e.r1i of K21rma1t'21k21,

(Higher E}£iuc:ati0I1},

Bd1,:cai.i0n Depa:*m1eI1t, M.S.B'L:i1cii.r1g,  .. " ;_.
I)1".Ambecikar Veedh.i., Ba11ga1c)r€~560 0%")   ' 
The Commissioner,     
I)epa1'trn€r1'i.of C<>11€giai:e EtiA_u(:ai:iQ3.1,A--T_ '

Seshadri Roaci, E321:1ga1<3re~Ei{§O 00.1. '

'i"'he Joint Dire<:t:0r of C<sv}LI»€%'g_§ie1t.<;2 .Ed.m:£if§i_0Ii';  
Umiv£:r$it.y C<)i1ege Prelnisés.  " «. 7
Me1r1ga1c>r€*«5"?5  "

The j5L("',(,'.()i4II}\'{'.'c31'i'{' Ge;-1é:1':.ii=i::?:'VK;iff;i3;{:;i1<§E1 {A 81 E}.
B21:':;gf:*§<:}:°€=V5é§€} 'C}%;C?ri".;. .  V " 
.    .   Appeilanis

"1,  Si.~§J'f_33f'lfé'§€:'211;313a1, A.G.A.)

  

V /O M:-2yan;3'a, Egg:-id about 80 yearsg
 Earlier wcqfking as Seleciiiexz Grade
" L§3{',JU;1~1ff31' at I\§"é':"1'r1,: Menxoriefi Caliege,

SAE1'§1i£}.; 'i~),.K.Disi1'iC'£;,

   ira3iii1.t€{i and F," 21%. "Pree'£:.hi ixzepzsz",
=  Nos'. 1?)! '3;ﬂ'*3 I\fIaJ11, £Viaha_;'ar:a Layout;

A  "\figQ:sT§;*;3gj:':aga.:' H Si:a.gc;'x §\»'Ey$02"z3~5'?G 61?,

S.:f;"i'E., K. {E . §"§{}§i :1 21:31:32 2?: E

' *- ._ E3 ;"<>  EVE . {}2::1ap21§,h}¢
 ikgaai a'%:2<mI:4 6G j,fsE?:Ei§"£i%.,

Ea'§'Ei€'r wozﬁaizlg as Se£e(:t.i<>n C???-J;€Z3£€'
Lectturer at Nehru Memorial Coilege.
Suliiaa B.K.D§-strict

Since retired and I'/1:11' N0.208,

V Black, Kerpala Road,
Kurunjibag--574 3279



2é T1716 Principai,
Van}: Sakkare Arts and Ccmmerce
First Grade Callege, Hiriyu:*~5'?2 144-,
Chitraﬂurga District, 5  __ u _._ 
 R,espt3n dcn':s

{By Sri P.S.Raj3.g0paIAssociates,Ad¥;<Qca'f§;é'é f0EV  

This Writ Appeai Vﬁ':s:_d uiydéi" Sé:»«:t2:;:sr;_ 4  of the
Karnataka High Court Act'-pfa_ying' to €~€;t"v,aS"'id'é"'the oréier
passed In {ha Writ Petition N~a_.28?188/"$3909 [S3-RES) dated
15/02/2010.     

gszmr APP5£2;A3;..iV"i).f§'1hf3;'?}',?~?§0 10
5'    _'   % 
x§m*L:A1,=PEAL No%.g;g_ 2932:: 1 2 [S-RES)

BE'm*'E'E:<;.%L%L::, 

::. Stakaf K.ai"niaié;i:;i;'- 
by 13:» Secrétaij; tQ"{30vernment,
_E<'1nari'<;2€ DeVpVar'€;fa€:;it (Services 1),
V» ._i V1dhanafS.Qudha, Dr.Arnbekar Veedhi.
_  B,anga}0re--56G"{3O 1 .

     Secretary

' -._:t:<;? G:GV€':;15riment of Karnataka,
 {Higher 'E&u{:aii0n§,
" E':§u::é3:.é0n Bepgrtmeaiig
'§»s,E._I$.Bz;%§d1?.§2.g; Byﬁmbeékaz "~f€€d;}1.i§

V 'A  Bé,:':gfaE@:*e~56{} my

 H The Cammiasieneru

Department of Coliegiateé Educa'tion,
Seshaciri Road, Bar1ga101'e- 1.



M3

The Jzsirai: Director of Coilegiair-3 Educaftiiang
Ejrziversity Collega p1'€YI1iSE3S,
Eiriangaiore 5775 G61.

The AC<:<3u.1*1£:aI1t Gsneral in
Karnataka (A& E),
Ba11ga101*e~56{) O01. 

 

{By Sri B.Veerap'pa, _C}:A.}

AND:

gx.)

B.K.Ning€ Gowda, V  -_

S/0 B.K.K0mari G0Wda_;,' '

Aged about 62 years, _    V * V
Earlier R3\.7OI'}€i'E'}g"E1S i3e1¢(iis0nVGvfac}e A'
Leiiiurer ?\?e;1':'ru .§1r§@r§:®ria_}_ f:--Q§}e:§§?c%3f
Suiim, §:;K.'_;:~is::'~§x::, ';'3j§r:é'c.__zf<::ti'z<;ed;-- '
R/at Nc::.;'.fl.68--, 1'¥:§Z;1r::a1*a'i§r-Uggéia Qiaﬁ Gate,
Su1}.i2i¥'5 75 :1iZ39§ffD. K;~D i3tric_ii;"" V

S az?areg0'wfcia;' ~.. _  .. _ 
S/o=Deve Gox%;'da,VAged about 63 years.
V _Ear11'ér x§¥'or1:iﬂg"v_a$"'SeI€C£i0n Grade
,,  Lecturefz' v.PrinC1'pa1 at
 N.ehr'L1z Memdfiéjl College,
_ Su'E1ia<, D._K.District, Since retired and
V ' --'R;}''3_t "'rf€3f}};$;23.'£I'&II163.E1&}}F8.SE1(i3«a

 Kuzrgpmjxbag, Su11ia~§?4 32?,

 B_.K._Bf;§=;tf§'ict.

" an

E3':f_i:'1§:E§aL

 Eﬁehm; '§,€6m@r§aE. Csﬁegeg

 E{'z,:§'"u}:;§% Bhagg Suﬁia,

DKK E}iSiriCi:+5°?4 239.

... Regpondents

These Wrii Appeals are filed under Section 4 01" the
Karnataka High Court Act praying to Set aside the 011161'
passed in the Writ Petition I\§0.M916~9127/2009 dated

16/2/2030



ax; A' 4  

ii

WRIT APPEAL 330.3134/2010 (S-RES] 
BETWEEN: V

3. T I716 Prirzcipai Sacretary
to G0'U€IT'ﬂEI1€I1t of Karnat:ak&,
(Higher Education),    . 
Educaticm Department, M.E-3.BuiIdiﬁ;;_2;,  * _ é   f
Dr.Ambedkar Veedhi, Bangéalofszéﬁiﬁﬂ  _ " 

'2. The C0mmiSsic:>'ner,     
Departmeni of Coliegiate"£}:iiL:;f:ati01:_ 'T ' '
Seshadri Road, B&}.I1ga§Gi'C--E:}€7':G"'QQ1.

35 The Accountant Cé.I:_.i€r'éz1V K$gr:éj:i£:i12:.a (A&E],
BaI1ga}or€r=580 0iZ3.1%,_'-~. '  1» "
   V'  ﬂP13€H317itS

Z , Pfrgf. Rfij aya; ' §'£'ei?1*:a[Vj'i*i:.:.;*;2a:_ri@
W/5LW+.S.EikiaE>er1.; Aged about 8k yezazxa
_E;arHér w'0:'1<;%'ng'._as'~'Selection Grade

" _{ Le;cturei*' at P1318 Evening Caliege,

 Mandya, Sii1'(:'n;:" retired and
3 Rja 1?'f'§;'s:.i, 18/13, 91-" Cross, Subashnagar,
" V T.hkia:;.:IVj; :.a;:"1"{'?}; 401.

__ The Pziincipai,
 FEES Evening Ceﬁegeg
'3';/§a}=;":@}ra~§'§'§ 483
V'  R€spGn&e:r1'is

: This Writ Appea} fﬂeé under Sectiarz 3f the Karnataka

 V' N High Court Act praying to set aside the order passed in the
' Writ Petition N0.16969/2008 (SR) dated 15/'€32/2{}10.



WRIT A17I'EAL N03800/20140
3% _.
WRIT 2'--&I"}?EAL NC}S.2172-76/201 1 {S-RES}  

BETWVEEYG:

1.

§\..)

State of Karnataka

by its Principai Sﬁcretarywli,   
Department of Educatien, '
EVI{.S.BuiEd:i,ng, Ba,nga.10re»{}1 .

The Camrnissioner for 131$§_§}.i§j'~./IfiS'£I;i}C_"iiiO1:}S';I  
Nrupathtmga Road, Banga1é';:@%O§. T '

The Director for Pui->I_i§: Ir1;étr§1V€f::ti£1:1:3 '
Department cf Secondary 'E.::'£u'Ca_tiG.r'1;... 9'

O /O Cornmissioner Afe-::t:'. _P=:.1b1ica1r1sit:r1ii:éﬁia3{nsg
Nrupathunga. uR£'sad,[ Ban_:ga.EQr€L'_j  u ' 

The Qepiiity.EZ)iféé{£*:;>r'-ii;-3? "P13_E;V}i<';Jig:-siructiong.
Banga2oreVS'01fQﬁh E31}-s¥"r'ie:§t'--  
Ka1aSif§a'13r,é;; B3i1gaI c;r§-i-'-V2.  V

 _ -     -- I ...Appe11a.nts

' * V [B39:3{§i"S4.4'§%?eerappag A.G.A.}

- . _ S.AC,E¢'?4:éiCl.hu,

'    :":x/' 0 Late C.Che1:1r1aiah.

 as izbcharge Head Master.

 8Z"§£a }§:adsvaiah,

 §;€a:'sg Sfg Javarayee Q'{A}§'§f€:iEi«-)

AA ' ...A&"\?§0rking as Asgistant Tﬁacheax

Srti Boraisv»-*am§?.H ,. S. ,
44 years, S / 0 Shivabasavegowda,
Working as Assistant Teachar.

Sri M.S.Ravindra,



LA

_}--rwv
Ekﬁ

45 years, S/0 K.Siddaiah,
Working 213 Physical Education Tejachex".

Sm.t.In:;1irai:hayi,
57 years, D/0 Bikappa,
'Marking as Hindi Teacher.

Smt.N.SudhamaI1i,   
49 years, I3,/'c: S.Nara}.;*an,   
Working as Assistant Txi--:a<:1'1'(=: r.  "

(Ail ans: working at  Sé1*:.Q@L.   
16"" Main Read, 41" B10CI'«:.,_  _  
Jayanagar, BangazI0r€~;5€':8  11}

The President, _   _  u
Bharath Educ:ati0n..Saciety_(R);  
15*?" Main--.RGad;;4"'{ ' "
Jayazgajgar§?'Baz":.g'ai{;:°em 2} ' g V " 

Head  "  V « "  

 Iiigh S'€?ho0i';.«V1'6"1 Main Road,

ilﬁh BEOCk;'.,f~a§,*;a_na.c§ar, Bangalore} 1.
 . --      Respanﬁents

  V'i"h€se V\f";fjt Appeais are fiied under Sectian 1}: of the

'  Karf:a;.éakaA.High"C{iurt Act praying to 56%: asiée the order

 . }3ass:?:_c1Vm.4tE2Ve Writ Petitien 1\3'0.l89O to 1895f20}_0{SmRES}
  <.::ate<a.,%'€~;9';*V€33.f%2;0 10.

'  Apyggu, 1m,432gg2§ 13 {S-RES}

 BEé%@;Eg: ~:

 192:"§.n_cip211 Secretary :5 G02-*€rnmen{.,

"  (Higher Education}, Educaiion Department,

M.S.Buﬁdi1:1gs, Dr.Ambedkar Veecihi,
Ba}:1ga10re~56O O0 1.



N?

The Commisaioner far Caliegiate Educatian,
Seshadri Raad, Bangalere-560 061.

The ﬁcceuntant Genarai in Karnataka {A 8: E), 
Ba1'1ga10re--58O 801. ~ ' ' " '

(gysaa£3xkxfappa,A;x;y) W"

Sm'i;.E\/E.C.VaSudha,

Aged about 62 years, ..
W50 C_V.Keshava Murthy.
R/a No.-4944, 8"? Main,

11 Stage, Vi} ay'ar1agai';.. _ *
Mysor6~E37'O O17.

Saradavﬁas .E«~:£u':?.ati<§)na} _I:'3r13tif,u't;i0n's;':' V
§{I'}i$1T1ﬁ3i"E1'§,gEi7§i"}}f:§.)}'%§;f£%VE'§?:§  _ ' 

Mysore 5??O  '1*vc:1»0t';-.i3y'V"£t;s':Sééregiary.

3. S2i3*é;da$}i},£asV': :£é1'*.>v"' (3 '  V
Myscre V E3'? ~rép.t_. by its Principal.
 . --       Respanﬁents

(By Sfti~vPV.VS.E{ajagopéV1 Associatesg Advecaias far R4;
 LR2~Se"nr..e;i) V

'_'i'E:§.is~:4A."»£Sfrit Appeal {ﬂed unéer Seciien 4 of the

 §{;x'»;.f:1a;{'a1kaVM'E{_igh Ceurf; Act praying 'to set aside the erder

~p3s:=,s€§ ' §:::--__ 1136, Writ Petitian I'\E0w8583,z"2@i@{SwRES} ﬂatﬁaﬁ
zggasgggga.

Wm? A.FPEA£ N9.,4331! 2313 {S-RES}

* gg?wEE§:

  .. _  The Principal Secretary to Government,

(Higher Education}, Educaiion Department,
M 8 Building, B1".Arnbedkar '\fe€dhi,
BaI1ga1ore--56O 001.



The Cemmissioner far Coiiegiate Eﬁucatiorz,
Seshaﬁri Road, Ba'ngaI(>1'€~56O 001.

3. The Accountant Genera} in Karnataka (A & 
Ba:1gaE0r€~56G O01.  f "   
.  ;ﬁs.ppé§1_é1:?2.T *

{By Sri B.\?eerappa5_;A;G.§§_)

AND:

1. N.C.Sha1iapu11ai,
ﬁged about 82 y€arS--,_
S/'0 Lam T.C.Na11ar,«.._  _ 3 ,
R/ai No.28, Devi.ramiIiaf1n.i-,7   . 
Agarahara, Mysore 5.70, _G'O~<L   ' "

2, Saradaxzgiaia Réitécatviénégi 'inséiféﬁs ;'?:2{:Lr:;<;s:';
Krishnarizurﬁ;h},fpi;;§_ram;j -.;;s{;ré 153 004,
rapt. by i::§S€é:§etaty--;  ~ §

3. Sﬁvaradaviliis-..  CGEJ age;
Mgsrsm:-e 5.70'.QQ:;;«_._T'T'--- 
rc~;~:p'i;~, by me F'1*'ir:c--i.p'2:}.

 "    ...Resp0nden:s

_ fI"i3i.:3. "+2's?ri'{ Appeal fﬁed under Section 4 of the

  'K53_:*n£;ia1kaM'E<£i§,§h Cam": Act pr:/,1§2"§1:1g to set asiéé the order
*pa7.s;s€dV£:f;-._tE:aé3 '\,?Vri':. Petitian N0.858%/281$ {SEES} daieci
:&/03z2§;@.

Wﬁf AP?Eﬁi ?€G.435§j2ﬁ}ﬁ {S~--RES§

  ..  SHWVEEN:

E. State of Karnataka,
rept. by its Secretary to Govt,
(Higher Educatian},



Education Department,
M.S.Bui§di:3g, Dr.Ambed}:;ar E-'e.edhi,
Banga10re~56{3 001.

2. The Director of Collegiate Education, . .. é   " 5 ,_ 
Sheshadri Road, Bangalore ~ 580 001.     

3. Tha Senior Accounts Officefg. _ '-- _v -._ _ "
Office 0f the AC<:0untani.4_Gen€;:_aI'*LA&}Z»}"M-  Vv 
Karuataka, P.B.N0.5S693''''..V_M " '    "
Residency Park Road; L  '

Bangalore - 560,001.   
V    ,    Appellants
(333? Sri E'.'Ve-efappag'-.53g,.G.A.)
'L 833%.  ~  V'

Karnataka High Court Act praying to set aside the order

8/  Sri"f:E~.?I* N ;Jéa'nard}ia:1asa,

aged -abo-';J;--«V.(;§1€E';%  Lecturer in Commerce,
?'§f}T&.¥' rﬁired' ':f:n:;r'?rz« Se-xvi-c€,

V3? ;-Pu:'a:1£'-- EJi?:3i;:rig_Co11ege of

Arm  C?om,;mer;i:e;'~'K.R. Read,

 Bangalei-e; 560 004, and r/at No.1,
  °'T;._D.Lgr1e, 2ﬁ<i"Cr0ss, Gotten Pet,
 _ Bangaglmfe --- 560- 053.

' «"Fhé"_'Sec§é{ary 5
'  VQ}5:ka}';'gara Sangha,
" §{';-§;?_.E{Gad, Bamga};ar'€~56Q 8%-4.

35:4 §€S§9E}§€§ﬁS

{By 82*}: 1%? f S Subbarazé £2 Ca" _<,="3§_ﬁ"%;G<:aée$ far §;~ iw
Sri B.R.S:"ini'vaSa Gawda, Advacats fog' R2,}

This Writ Appeai filed under Section 4 of the

passed in the Writ Peiition Ncs.£819?/2009 ESMRES} dated
01 /02/291$:



WRIT APPEAL NBA.-351/2010 (S~«RES]

E. State 0f Karnataka,
by its Secretary to Gevernment,
Finance Department (SeFvi::eS--I],  "   e
Vidhana Soudha, Drﬁmbedkar '\:'eed..h.i.,_' V  V'
Banga£0rew580 GO}.    I  "

The Principal Secretary to A'
Gevernment. of iiarnatalga

(Higher Education},  

Educatiorz Department'  b _  ._ T'
M.S.Buﬁ::1:::1gs, [}f.AII1E'»€€i}€%ir Veedhig 
BangaI0re~58O i")---€)'i;_  " ~ u 

aw

3, The C0mmissi0ne:2,.e'_ '-

Bepa:°::f:.2e§;¥;'---$3? C§?;e1§eg§:.3;ie:V EE»:°::7_f:,1ef2'.t'1':::%% 9
Seshaéiﬁi  a3igaiQ1fe§.f§E§G' 03;} 1 .

4. ff'f:e'eJ\2¢§i1%;t D«if¥t'eet cs:f'0f Cziiiegiate Education,
h}niVersii;-'ye --C_vCBege_ Premises,
Mar:ga§ore~£">'}?'5  

'J1

V The ;5§eCndu:1iaﬁ'£_ Geheral {A & E}
 BangaEere.¢55O (381,
V'    """   Appeilants

V  {By Sr": B.Vee:rappa., A.G,Am}

 M .VSaU;2f:§3;}:a Raj am.

  Aged. e:%..3:§e:,:¥i:. $3 yeaxe,
fr. 35:3; §,a"::.e §;'EsAjgappa E*§uE.i§a
'  }§Z';erf£ier 'E-§TGE"E{_ifig as Prefeseer in
 __ ~ Economics at St. Aieysiue Ex.-Yeming Ceﬁege
" = .---Mar1gaicare~5'75 003, Since retired and

R/a No.5-6-528, Varkady Lake.
Kodaﬂ B2111, Mar:ga.1e:'e»5'75 O02.
 Respondent

(By Sri }?'.S.Ra_jag0paI Associates; Aehxoeatesw)



' 

The Writ Appeal filed under Section 3: ii"-.Tt1':e

Karnataka High Court. z'%C't praying to set aside T:1*1sé "0_:'é_€r
passed in the writ. Peiitian N0.274?3f2GO9 (S-.RE7$}.__§:iaiii§iﬁA
19/02/2010.    

E.

2..

WRIT APPEAL No.4é22}%2*0'1é~~  

& WRIT APPEAL No'.'1.:§3Q/26 1.1   

BETVVEEN:

The Staié of Karnat3E{a,,'    V * V
rapt. by its_.P's*:i;1€ipa§i. Ssc:feiary%E$_  ' "
Separtmeziii. @i?'?'£§uciv}J{§'an§  V V' "
M.S.BuiE'é§r1g-,. %B*anga1g;+¢:  _ '

'Fhé°C9.:{:1mi§é;iori'€:V'f:)r  Instructions,
ﬁérupathaaga' ,' vv-Bangalorem 560 001 .

Th€""§.)iI'€Cf {';Y ' £:",1-E}i('3 Enstruciians.

V .D€pai'tr1f_i€n: he-3f E3eC'ti¥ndary 'xilducationg
,,  Off? C0mmiSsi.Qjner for Pubiic Instructiens,
. 'N.r11pajthunga"'R0ad, Ba_nga1ore~ 1 .

  Birector for Pubiic ingtruciiongf
A  Ba:1fga£Q:re Rural District.
 E§ _,.:='} Risada Bangaiare.

 BEGCK Eduaatian. Qf§€.€:€.§"2

'T   Eaéciabaiiapura Tait; kn;

  Bangaiarsz Rurai Bigirici.

KI! Appeﬁaﬁts

(By Sari BA/eerappa, A.GsA,}

AND:

E.

Sri D . Pévenkataram aiah,



Karnataka i~§1:i'gI';_"';'CV5i,i:=._E »A£:'j:-vpragiiﬁgg ii:-Q sat asida ihe erder

5?

S/:3 Lam S.N.Narasir1gha Rae,
Aged about 60 yeara,

Retired High Schooi Head Master,
R,' at Thimnzasandra Xfiliage,
Doddabaﬂapur Taluk,

Bangalore Rural District.

Sri N.S.Joshi,   

S/0 Late Sripada Bhat Jashi I

Aged about 641 years,

Retired as Assistant Teachear,

R/at N0,167, 31"€'iCr0ss, "    
R.K,Garden, Behind Gewri £%;par':ment--  "

NEW BEL Read, Mat-hikerr3,""' ~.  '
Bangalore-54. V  -A .-- . h "   . _

  " ; .5 Rﬁspcndents

These '»?sE:{€.:i   f:§4é;:EV":;-ésgeﬁér Saciiam «IE 9? 'aha

passed in the-.1 "'ri'ii;_: Petj £10117' -N-0.__28'?f28~28? 29 / 20 ES {S=~R'E)S}

dated 09/G9/zzmo.      '-

L

' M NG.504f2f)}.}.

Q
 jwmr  Nos.275e-53/201 1 (sums)

   

 The  G? Karnaiakag
yégjti $5: ﬁes 8ecm'ta.ry.,
§j>:=:§ar'£ime::t as? Primary E«§Ei{f3;U01'L

x 'T  ?¢E.8,Buiiéing, Bangaierew 1.

The Cammissicrnez' far Puhiic Ensiruciiem,
Department of Primary Educaiion,
Nrupathunga Road, Bangalore" 1.

The Deputy Director fer Public instruction,
Administratien, Department of Pubiic instructian,



-34;.

"Bi?

Davanagere District.

4. The Black Education Oﬁircer'.
North Zone, Davaraagere.    
.. Aj§;peEi .a§1i;<;_ '' 
[By Sn; Bfifeerappa, A.G.A.'3
: __ ._
1. Kalleshwarappa,  
S/'0 Sadashivappa,   '  
Aged about 43 years, O0c:Head»«I&Ia§t€rw  T' '
:2. Sri B.S.G3ngadharap§é;--  F
8/0 Siddaiingappa,  ' - 1   
Aged abeut 45 "§f€a.I'S, C:'@C1zf3'gSSiF§jEz?}fI1T, "'§.'m;"C,If1€r.
3. Sr: Q.?.Rf£21E:e_$3ﬁzI:;%%:*V3%§3§%i§  J 

8/0 D. Da1=i1naf3e--;33;' "

Aged ai :§Qut;=. _"§?;:j--:»3.rs,  'I'%.<:her.

éé.

E3hashika§»a';._§5;;~ ' %' %_
3,50 5§h:':v--ar'2;2 'idxiappag, _ 
Aged about éﬂyzsrairs, Occﬁssistant Teacher.

, [S1-i. H.L:i1g_.:ﬁ€aju,:
.   Sfﬁ H ar1um3"1'1"iThappa,
' 2 ., _V Ageci-.ab<3_ut 32 years, Qcczfassisiant Teacher.

A"[A11":heS;é'Respondents 1 t0 5 are Wcrking
 a:.Sn51ii.'1"%€agamma Higher Primary Sr:%1.00},
" Bfasaigéurag ﬁgadhya Layaut,
Eégiiazapura Read, Eavanagere Ef)is€réz:'{.§

 Resyanéerzig
(By R} to R3 Served}

These Xvrit Apps:-ais are flied under Section 4 of the

Karnataka High Court Act praying to set aside the order
passed in the Writ Pﬁtition No.203?2~«Z?>'.78/2010 [S~RES]
dated 14,/07/2010.



WRIT' A.¥'}?'EAL N032?/201 1

& WRIT AF}.'-'EAL- NOS.4357~6G/201 1 (S~RES}; ite

BR'I'Vv'E}3Nt

I .

Ex.)

The State 0fKa:mai:ak.a,.  V
rep: by its Prineipa} Secretary-.IE';»'  I
Department of Education, 1 ' * "
M.S.Buiiding, Bangaleree 1.

The Commissioner for "Instr.i:e:i0:';e,",  
Nrupathunga Read, Ba11ga10ure_%1._u ' T' '

The Director for Publifi'11'l&§fFE§€'.'Cii}1fi'S, a _
Department of Secorlciaﬁz E'rii.L-::a_t_i0r:f;... " .
O/O Commissiener ()vfvP1ib1i€? AIr1s§".i*:.;:ef;iV{31*is.e
N:mpa1:,hun_,ga «React; Bangaioreéi. u ' 

The Depiieﬁy:.F;ﬁfet.{ebr"fe:fre AF1.:;3§§iev--:§1e::etrueﬁen.e,
Ramanag'-a§ani.;':Disnfiet."-- * 1
  ' M"    ..'Appe11ar1t:S

V .  'A{gy:'S1fi"'Bi.Tifeerappa, ASA}

 .'.'..'...

 M;I{arui"£é.ké:ira,n,
 2 Sc:V;:'*¥.V,E\zE.2;nisWarny, Aged 4'? years,
'V,\§iC§f}iiI1';_;§va.E§ Head Master.

  Sri Rtﬁreehaiahe
SEQ Late ReVa:"ma.E'a:'§" ﬁged 46 yeareﬁ
'VEe"rE«:£z';g as Kannada '§"'eaehe:1

 Sri e.N.'€ara,
B/0 Late Zﬁanjunéappa, Aged 41 yeareg
Working as Hindi Teacher.

Sr}: C.Krishn3.ppa,
S/0 Kﬁheiuvappa, Aged 45 years,
'Working as Science Teacher.



lx)
Em}

Sri Gufumaileshaieth.
$/O Late Shivarudra, Aged 50 years,

Working as Physictai Educatien Teacher.

Resposndentg 1 "[0 5 are warking at

Sri Chockalinga Viclyaiaya High Sch0<3E__.--=  '

Hejjala, Biéadi Hobli,
Ramanagara District.   

The President, 

Sri Checkalinga Vidyalaya HigI 1"$ChOQ'§;.   "

Valliappa Niagara, I-£ejj;«'.+.1_a;.. _
Ramanagara Digtrict.  %

Head Master,  . . 

Sri Chockalinga V'1'd§7a1 aya:Hig11_School,
Hejjala, BidadiHQbv1"i,V.,V V   .. 
Ramanagafa _Di$;'tri{§i;' 

65% Respenﬁanig

V"f'hésaiWrit7*IAp'fj'e§i1s afé"'i'i1ed under Secticn 4» of ths
Karnétgtaiia High.._VC0tir£:"'Ac€ praying to set. aside thé order
§as$e:3,i.1::. the '1?'sifrfi"€'v«}f3fé':.i,';£3:a3I1 NG.189@--19QG/ 2018 {SEES}
dated O92/'O3/2€31C'.,  .-- 

 ..  A1=?§;.AL NO.'?39/201 1

..... .. &

(S-RES)

  APPEAL Nos.4Zo4~o6/201 1

  

 :3§§t:.aie 9? E{arnaE3.£~;£:._

'1*.;e_§§£:, by $3 Prirzsipai 8€=:§e€.:»3_:'ja*--L

Eképartmﬁné 9f Educaiésnf

1. E2;'f.S.BL:ﬂd:£:'1g; Ba::gfa§0I:'e~1..

Commissioner for Public II}StI'L1C'{iO}'1S?
Nrupathunga Road, Banga1o:"e~1,

The Birector for Public Instruction,
Department of Primary Education;

O,/O Commissioner for Pubiic Instructions,



4. The Deputy Director fer Pubiic Inetructions,

Bangalsre North Bistrict,
K. G Raad, Bangalore.

5. The Beputy Directer far Pubiic EHSifuCi_i.O1ﬂ$';V..V  L.
Bangaiore South District,    '  V '
Kalasipaiya, Bangaleré. '  '     f

 2 'A?p€',1'mts._
{By Sri B.Vee}af_;§pa, A.G.A.3     '

hi
2»:

Nrupathunga Road, BaI1ga}0r€~ 1.

-' an g

Sm1;.Amma§amma,'  1

W',/0 Lakshmishaiah,  '

Aged about 37? ;:ears,w- _  ' .A _
Working as, ,:'?ass'i.9ta.i1i. 'Ee_;a,;:::n.¢f;v' '   2
Fathféma  Fiwivzfﬁaﬁy Sshegi; 
S M Raad, H'?¥i°"'§*'--._?;0'S»i';--.,  "  A
Bangaiore~.3~¥_;'A:__ 3 

S:mL., :%ra;£i;;;;f;':'1%.a."«._ * ._ ' -

W9?' 0 'x/'@eraf§b}i;:1:1ra,§V8;h, ..--~

Aged about 4ZLAyea"1'f'-3,

V _VVQ1."kf1'1g £:iS_H€3;d Mistress,
,,  SE1, K<3dEa:1drama Higher Primary Schooh
 "'<3+,c»r:i Pjaiya, B"3;f:'gai0r€~ 18.

_ 'V '   zgrashree,
'  ' W] 078 Vii} aya Raghavan;

A  L'a_bou¥: 58 years;

' :¥'\2'<}:'§:iifig as Assiﬂam, "i'€a€ha:;
Srf; hakghmingrasimha Swain}; Eighésa"

 Frimary Séfhﬁiél, Suzziéadakaiieg
_ _ ;"\fi$hwa::€:eéam ?0S%;, Baz:ga.Eare--5§8 €33},

Smt. K Sowbhagya Lakshmh

XV/0 B S Munirathna,

Aged about 51 year-1-3,

Working as Assistant Teacher,

Sri. Somavasha Sahasrarj 1.1113. Kshatriya
Higher Primary School, Bale-pet,



Bangalore.
-.. Respondents

These Writ Appeals are {ﬂed under SectiQ:;,__4-T.of {ha
Karnataka High Court Act praying 1:0 86': asi:1é"'i:E:--§:"'vr3rd£3r
passeﬁ in the Writ Petitian N0.20'?82~2€3'78$f2(.}E.§[S;Z{-{€83
dated 2?/O'?/2010.  "    

WRIT A?PEAL N0.1Q1'2;*--2o171    V'
I. The ﬁirector far Public: 'Z.fiSiruCi.:Vi{}I1S,-..    
New Pubiic C)ffIceS, '    '
Nrupathunga R{?'a§i, Begiga lg:-re';-~ _ _

2, The Joint DireCto1*$<:_f'Puhui'i(;: II_iS'£1f1.;ti:--:ZoI1S,
Bangalore .DivisiQ.:1. _ Ba:r1ga}_o:r'e5;:  L = "

3, The Df3put.}}j%'L'13ir€<:.:d: éf PilbiicuE:':St2'u<:t320r18;
Turrlﬁiurb_Dii>'i;§i_Qn';-f?1,iT1T}.ki1r';»_  '

Kdﬁ Appellants

V -- : eerappa, A.G.,A.}

 "  , 1 .   Smt P3:tta'gaf1'gaVmbik€,

. _ \7V;'.Q «ﬁﬁemashekaraiahg
_ _ V' :2ib:Qi_;,t 53 years,
'  X£?Voﬂ;«:ing'as Assistant &EiStr€SS?
 Sivdriagganga Rurai High Schoeig
" }~'£'i1fe§1?a§.i§ Tumimr Taiuk 8: District.

   "F56 Qiiiﬁf §,§£€{fE.1Ei'i?€L' ﬁfﬁcezy

" --  Z332. Panciiayan "§'um§<:u:" E}§&;E;i'°:c€,
Tumkur.

u  The Pregident,

Sri Siddaganga Vidya Samsthe,
Sri Siddaganga Mutt, Tumkur.



ii. The Head Master',
Sri Siddaganga Rural High Schaoh
Tarooaz Sim Taiuk and District. 
 Re-sfjeﬁdentg

This Writ Appeal} ﬂied unéer Sectiiéii'-«»..%;~-.1:"the
Kamaiaka High Caurt Act praying to set"-.a's;icie._th€=Qrciézj

passed in the Writ Petition n0:f34§U/ _L1'3'}O:{'S{£?;{3S) :;iéﬁ;«:%d'~ 

29/O7/2010"

WRIT APPEAL NO. 1013 I 2;): 1  "  
E. The Director for P~1,;b1icw* VI:i9is'in:91j,zcu:>tiir;§&I1s, « --

New Public fZ)ffic:r'c:s3.," _ '_ _ 1 - AA 
Nrupathunga Road; Baf;vga101_f¢{'-- .  _ ' 

The J 0:313; ' §}r£_':'-eetégr Qt" ..§5'u'@.E§t  §_'E1Sif:1§3C€i{}§3S,
Bangal are 333115153 07:}, =F3>ar1'gge:¥;i::r@.'

gm)

3. TFriéVTDef}jfutyu':f;3iré{:~i'§51' of fiﬁbiic Irxstructioxiéx
T_11m};1.n' :}V,F2€jSiQri';'.l'E1_IIl.}5§3Ir.
' '  V  H Appeiiams

  ._(}3}f"Sfi"'Bﬁfeerappa,A.G.,&.}

     A.   ..... 

'  __ Sr? i€:§:"aseéy.ap.pa. E' ,

~F3';'Q%'EEfa3?:_:1_a.',~,Aged about 45 years?
A;:3__§ista§3:y%t Tgiiaster,
S,¥{.R:;::'a3' High Schaeh

 Rsreiekére Madhugki Téﬁiukg

 V. "§'=::.:_1f1§«;1,é:' §}}:SZ§'§CE.

K15! Regpanéemgs

This Writ Appeai filed under Section 4 of the

V' Vvflarnataka High Court Act praying to set aside the Grder

pasased in the Writ Petition No.8¢:334/2010 {S-RES} dated
30/07/2010.



WRIT AI'i'}§2A.L N0. 1914/20}. 1

8: WRIT APPEAL NOS. 190'?- 19 10/20 1 1 [S»R..ES]

BETWEEN:

1.

U1

The State of Karnataka,

rapt. by its Principai Stzwgtzretaryﬂ,
Department cf Educaticsng

M 8 Building, Banga1+3r€:~ 

Th6 Commissioner fo:t_Pub1iC:'i:r1strL:ctis:*':As,  .
Department of S€CQndar3§~.EduC'aii0:L  V' 
O/O Commissioner for ?L_biir.: I:'1st1~"uéi:ibns¥,
Nrupahtunga Road, Ban-ga..Ieré--~..}. A' 

The Director for PU7.biic"E1iii3!;:"uCE£c:nS,,
Department of S€.CQ.ﬁdaQ-'I Ed"{iCaE.iQn*;'

Q,/O C0:::.:n§;s;Si@::er {Gr Pubiég Emjxtfuciians,
Nru pat§:ur§1g;aV Rsadi  Bang3.1§fé+* 5."

 fOf H¥'i§11C31iC Instructions,
i3_an.ga1Qr'é, Rpufal ' 'Di;3,t;i€:t,
K' 4% Road , 

The  v1$du c8.ii'i§i1 Offiaer

,%  D<:;ddabé1E.apu1'a. Taluk,

V B¢.ar1gai0re Rum} District.

g§{§. : 
Y

 Appeliants

{By -Sri Bvaerappa, ASA}

S1V7{'"§;..C Krighzzappag

,   Aged abaut 49 yearss,
" E3/0 Chikkamuraiyappa,

N

Workitng as ASsist3.1'1t Teachar.

8112 C Srinivasamurthy,
Aged about 49 years,
S/0 Chikkaramaiahg



Workmg' as Assistant Teacher,

 Sri Hanumanthappa.
Aged abauf. 53 yéara,
S/0 R K Srinivas-aiah,
VV0rki1'1g as Assistant Teachar.

4. Sri K R Ven}§atana.ra:.:a;n.a,
Aged abaut 52 years,   
S/0 KRamaiah,   _
Working As Assistant Teacher.  

5. Sri N Eviuriirajm
Aged about 43 years.
S/0 Narayanappa, 3 ---- _  
Working AS Assis_t}3--nt ' I'ea..r:1'ie3f.' .  ' " « . %

Respondents 1 i£}...5 EL3i€ wo:"k1"%:g  --- 
at': Sr}: M.&;:'i§:::hi §§_ig%:, S{:i;9 G£;"--.._ .«
Rajaghéita;§?'% 'i}9<it3ab_aE§apé1ra"'T 3319;,
BangaEo5._=evRLi11ja1'Di.si'r_icE:V_  '

6.  " _V

Sfi Maruthi'VE;ﬁ_ﬁ'é$.'*-ibyia Seciﬁiy,
Rajaghaita; Daddabalaiprua Taiuk,
V _Bangé1§Q_r<::. Rural Déstrict

 V,  ,   T1143 fiﬁad  1V\/Ié;S'tér.

-. _ Sr:i«.13ziar~11thi Elducatien Society;
  Dodéabalalprua Taiukk,
'  Bé1n;f.g--aI}:[;i"€ Rurai District.
~ ~ "  A  Rsspandents

  A§§°§; Sﬁ. Ravi '1s'a§d§J9.., Adaragtate 59: R4 ":0 5;
 V  3: R'?wS€:'v€5{;

These KVr'if. Appeals are fihed under Sectien 4 of the

 = ..« K.arnataka High Court Act praying to set aside the order

passed in the Writ Petition N0.85282~286/2010(S-RES)
dated 18/' I E/2010.



WRIT APPEAL NO. 1460/20 1 1

8: WRIT APZPEAL NOS.4586-95/201 1 (S-235)
Bmw: EEN:  4' 'V

I. The State of Karnataka, 
r€p'£;. by its ﬁrincipal Secrataryely  
Departmént of Education,  " .. "

M.S Buﬁéiragg Bangalare. '

E\.}

The Commissioner f0r PiLibV£:iC  
Nrupathurzga Road; Ba1*i'g.a:i0r_ek " VV  V'

lg.)

The Director for E3'{i«b1}'{.3vII1Sﬁ'1ECtiC3}f1.
Department of St§C:¥3Z1'C{E1'}f:Q*i'»I7Qd!ﬁ§43§{§Cii7i,

C)/Of Csmmissicmef forP1;b1i'i:~vIr1:=.t:ucti0ns,
Nrupathuiiga Rzfafad,' 'Ba£1g'a.Et;=;fe.'  '

4. The  E'f';'_rée:::?_:' 'fr}r" ¥_'u§ 3Ei€' Inatruciisns,
Bang-551036 ;'§$§E0rt1i 3j:*;:-v:V;.:;~._a;£:'1:'," 
   
 _      _ ' ...Appel1ar1ts

' = V  ;3§}.i" §.ir'eerappa, A.(}.A.}

VA  S":'t':i. G4A:shxvat.hnarayana§

T  _Sv;.'Q7--{?E'é:}§}a;1:appa, Aged abeui 52 years,
  V. W'af§s:i::g§as Head ':_¥"Eas'i.er9

Za  33: K; 'iianumanthamyappag
'Sf Late Kariyappa,
Aged a"b<:ui 5E years,

n V. _ H Working as Assistant T€38JZ3E'i€¥I

Sri S V Sridh3.ram.urthy,
S /0 S Venkataramanaiah,

Aged about 54 years,
Working as Hindi Teacher.



10.. 
 v'Sgf0 1'VIAur1iyaf5};)'a', Aged abeui 46 years?

2?

Sn' R Suresh.
Sfo 2331 Ramaiah, Aged abeut 46 years"
Wsrking as Physical Edueatitm Te3.eher.

Sri M Gopalakrishnaiah

S,/0 Late Es/ielapeag

Aged about 52 years.

W0r1«:i.z1g as Assistant Teacher.

Sr: 8 H Venkateshaiah,

S1' 0 Hanumanthaiah

Aged about 49 years,   
Worliing as Assistant Te--ei:iher.

Sri K Anjin3.ppav,-"'   *  ' 

S / 0 Krishnappa,u5§ged'.abp11t'  years;
Working as Assistant '£'e-ae};}.€1i~.   '

Sr: E-1s;:s:,:.;"m;2::a*:hé::"aj»gs_ﬁ'ps, '7  2 V ' 

SJ 0 A:1_§'1:;;:a;sp.a, ..A;ged _ absué: 43 years,
Werkingas 'C1=aft"TifesC*h_ee5:.  

Eéri 1-3?: N VHQ}:1a§mst'1Itiha.ra§%appa,

Sis Narays1§3,pp's.,_ Aged abeut 52 years,
W0:f1<:_11ngv as See0»ne"i'..»s.DiVisi0n Clerk.

Sr} Venliategehalspathy,

A " -»  '.7i§s:'1<;i:r_ig as Lab Assistant.

   '::§?:jes{?:VVsPetiti0ners are Werking at
 Sré ~Puf:§;€amma Ks-st: Bsssppa High Seheség

,éﬂ§'a,§*as3.r:d:'a, Beﬁdatumkur ?'esL
%}a:£"3g§s.§e're Earth Bésiréet.

 Sr': 8 Eyiappa,

S/0 Byiappa, Aged absut 51 years,
Working as Peon cum Night Waiehman,
 Respondents

These Writ Appeals are filed under Section 4 of the

Karnataka High Court Act praying to set aside the order'
passed In the Writ Petition 30251-61/10 dated 21/9/18.



1.

'~..oJ

WRIT APPEé&L NO. 1462/2131 1

8: WRIT APPEAL N()S.4622-26/281 3. (S-I«m_s;[

BI3T'W'EEN":

The State of Karnataka,    ' --_
rapt. by its Principal Sacaretaryizpif,  f; 4'
Depart.me1'1i: of Education,   A
M.S.Bui1::1ing, Bangalore-E'. 

The Commissianer fer" P'ub1iv{%'*I§§:~:t;'uc:tit;ri:S; ''
Nrupathunga Road', rBfang.f3.i0'1'e,_  -- "v __ ' '*

The Director for Pubiiz: :I:{'3,s":L-.z".I;ji(:"t;:tZcfr.AI.:T;:-:« __
Department O.*.7.S€COZ1v€l&Y':,é"vEdL1.'CafiCI1.,   " '
O / Q COmm;.i$'-':'@(§_n€r ﬁfe: PijbiiC"*Eif::a:fLig:*:ti0ns5
E'~i:":ipaiZ¥31,:_'?§g:3.  "§?§a§;a_gjaE§3:;'{«3< E} 
The D¢jpu'EyV'Bi:r€ctor"fQi* Public §r:strue::ti0r1s§
Ban:gaE<jr'e.1.'€.ortf:5'§V District, _  V
}3aI1_ga]Q1*é."'~.»  _   ' -
7 « -   '  ﬁﬁpeliants

  V..(B3/'Sff'..BaVeerappa, A.G.A.}

H h '  --.E§§iS i1nareddy9

__ S _,5c> .E§a:1umanthareddyg
.A'g_;eé; about 5} yeara
'\}'-f.i:%rk§n§§ 3;s ASS-{Stag}? Teachsiz

 Sr: 'EVER. Ravikumarg
S/0 C. Kempegewdag
Aged about 48 years,
Working as Assistant Teacher.

3. Sri M. Nagaraju,
S / 0 Muddaveregowdag
Aged abaut 49 years,



Us.)
i\~,_}.

M S I3uiEcii.r1g, BzmgaEt:>r*e--1.

rd

The C{)II1I}"£iSSi()ﬁ(E?§' for Pubiicr Insi'.ru:::ii0ns ,
Nrupaiihtmga Roaezi, Be1:1g&1(>:'e» 1.

3. The '[)irec:t.«:>r far Pubiic E1"1:-st_ruct.i0ns,
IZ)ep21rtmeni: of S€{',()I}d&1I'}-' Educat.i.<>n, _ . 
O/O C(3r11.m.i.ssi0ner for" Public h'1St1':_£'c:i:i--0.f:.S, '=_ 
Nr'L1patEm11g21 Road, Bang21§_(>f€"~~«i.   * V

4. The Deputy I)ireci;c>:" for Pub };i<: E--:1s4;ruc:i:_..af<)'1'"2»$>;;. V
I:3a_r1gaI0re Nerf}; E)ist,rfc:t...__ " "  " ' A.
K G Road, BEiI"1g211{31'€;',. ' 'V    
"   Exppeilants

(By B  CSLA.)

AND:

Sri C Ratmzégiéizh.7j...';1 " A

S / 0 I,Vai é"[vI; z1riidéire£'yg}ip:p21, _  V
Aged :a_b()_Li'E'.  . }_;*e_a:ss .' '  _ 'A ' V ~ ._ '
R€'<.ir<:ti-- Eflgia §€«<:i'L:i§ 0ji_  EE.¢é2;:.§ i%fie1si:er,
R/21': N0;*1 .'2,4.. 3?" i'\/E:>A1i1=3., 
Pnzcﬁise :'v"i'2°:r§s5E£>.ré'-P'¥'}, Ikizzizeiiaksfzmigouranz
I_3-'%.1'::%i;he:t:t ExE;eiI~:siQ11, Ba.ngaI<>1'e~ E0.
     """   Respondent

. _    Ap}3e;a1_ .i'iEed under Serstion 4 of the
Karé121t.z:K;é'j_Et§ig§1 C<,)U..:°£t. Acéé. p:"22.3;i:':g in $93": £"1E§id€,' {be erdaz'
«--"€,E':€ Wrzit ?<;>'{.2'.?(.i<;n F\5z}x3G262:;'20E{}{$~§9;ES} ciaieéi

'  2:;@Q;29:@é

WRKT APPEAL N0.2II3f23} 1
8: WRIT APPEAL E'EOS.53?'3-5374/201 1 (S~RES}
BETWEEN:

E. The Stat€ 9:" Karnataka,
rept. by its Principal Se<:,1:et,ary»IE,



33

Department of Education,
1':/E"S,Bu:i1di.ng9 Bangalore» 1 .

Z' The Cemmisgioner for Public: Enstruciions, 
?€rupathu'§:ga Road, Ba1i1ga,1<:»rr::-1. '

3. The D'i:t*er:t0r fer Pubiic Instructions? N  .
Department of Seceridary E(113.€:'_3fti0:i, "' "V _ .V
O/O Camrnissiener fer Public E;f:SE:'1;;:t§f;sI1§;*  
Nrupathunga Road, Baz1ga1t3r£::i.__1T. * 'T T "

4. The Deputy Director figrviPtgblié"£:1s1r1;€"§tiGi?§S;"  
Chitradurga Distrct, Chitradurga.   ' " 

_      Appeilants
(By Sr?BuVce%ép§a;%'§g:&LA.)

3N3:  H V % A' %'

L Sri    
S/' é§VC5V{')V'¥V,4£t 38 years,

W0r_1:ing ':3 si;<*:r.

2,. Sri '£}¢éV*endra"pjja3':  44 V.

/0 Laﬁgslzrzivama, Aged abeut 38 years,
"  Wmrking' as 'Assistant. T€3.,Ch€3'.
 , S:ﬁA.}\Ji'fa~r1jan R,

V _  QI3Z.éng;;.ppa, Aged abaut 39 yearsg
"  « W'c:*_E§::.:n'g '33 SEA,

 {:;'§"€§'%1;6.¥E:'.:.'€"ES@G}'1ﬁ€1'E{.;€§ Neal ':0 3 are

ix; iking 3?. Sri Ra:'r23;k:"1Eshna Eiigh Séihggig

*  Yéiakagpazéa Hﬁii, Beiéikere Post
_  §icssad'u.§"ga 'E'3.E2,1k, Chiiraéurga i}3§s'f::':i.€t..

The Sacretary,

Sri Yaiakappana Hatti,

Kalikamba Education Society {R},
Yallakappana Hatti, Bokikere Post,
Hosadurga Taiuk, Chiiradurga Distrist,



3552»

L1'!

The H6301 Master

Sr}: Ramakriahna Hi.gh SC11001
Yaliakappana Haiti, Bokjkere Post,
Hosadurga Taiuk, Chitradurga District.

..

These Vvrit Appeals are f1'Ied;under tE2.Ve ' ' _ Karnataka High Ceurt Act prayirig i(»31__$t"'.T"IZ aSE1__GTTL€._f§1é3._ OIj$;i6£' passed in the Writ Petition No.101331:§U833f20_}.C§[S§'R£;S)_ dated 05/04/2010. "

WRIT APPEAL Nc%.g;a2;2e;%;% , 8; . _ WRIT APPEAL Nt3S.4;s:§7§.5 i]*_:;di,,1'V"(s~REs) BEfra:v££;:x::

1.. The S taf§: Kém--a :"z;}gé:;§:":

r€f:>i:°.' "Dy:X'i,fS I4?:"i1i2cipﬂa'i Seéfétarymil, I;)ept.« 01° ti'0n} ' .--S..Bui1ding ngaiGre:~ IE; V W gm V The C¥3r:i'I;:iS,siC>1i1é1?" for Public Instruciians. .,N:'upathu_r.1_Vga Rcad, Ba.I1ga1G::'e~ 1. . _, The. Director far Public Instructisn, V _ Df<'«:pt.»» éf,S§aC9:r_1c£ary Educatienq " -._'G./'C3"_v»C€::tifnissi0r:aer fer Pubiic Instructions, A Nrupésggthunga Road, Ba.ngaE0:°e-- 2.

";§T§*;A%é Direcim" Qf Pubiic inséruéruismgy ., ' Bégi, 0? Primaijg Educaiian, __-'S,/'G Cammisaéenﬁr fa}: ?ub§;i<: Enaiizruiééiczns, Nrupath unga Read, Ba§1ga}0r€~ 1. u 3' The Deputy Director for Public: Instructiensg Shimoga District, Shimoga. Appellants [By Sri BR/'ee1"appa, A.G.A.} AND:

1. l\.) Li.)

6. Sri Y M Shivamza.

S,'/0 Myflarappa, Aged 38 years, Presantiy working as Head Master, Sri AH. Basavaraj, ..

Sm Paiayappa, Aged 38 years, I Working as Asst, T £i'2':1Ch€I1 ' = "

Sri Dzmappa B, V. ._ S/0 Basavarmeppa, Age._:f1*8O yaarg, ' Working as Asa. 'Feae::he1i";..__' _ ' Sri Manja Nail: _ 3 V S/0 Eswarappaé Aggd' 3L-}, y§:a:S»L;~. " 2 Working as ASStv'.:¢,aCh€Ff ' "

Sré Nag?;;m:;é1*:'t}:yi ii'. E; _ V V S / 9 EC 8 h'é::*i':.£ra;;<?;.§j;$ E§--s_7{é:.p';3pa ' Aged "yé§:§_f{s, 0r}{i:2g__Aas 1:"~;.ss€.. Teacher. »:aga::g3%p::a% SEO '§?1}::imm'app'a',' 4? years. W01*1<;i:r1g PE'1j~;s'i§:a--E VEduC.ati0n Teacher. " 'Sri. Kalién Shivanagawda Patﬁ. '- "'Si.f<3~ :3f1iv'an3;g<)£xl?da, Aged 45 years,

2 'Wo.ri<.1;1g, as Craft Teacher.

" 4 Si: ?;§:*;;~-:35." H J § Sfc: §§5._gannatha Rae? Aged 4-5 313333. W-Qziéiéﬁg as ASS? Teasher. xfil SE: S *5' C-myapathy.

= _ K6 "Fhj;av8.ra Naikg Ageé 2:8 yeargg Working as Second Bivisiem Assigtané. Respondents N03,} to 9 are working at Sri Bhuvaneswari Rrmidentiai High Schoel, Gopala, Shimaga Taluk & District. Sr: K Jayappa, S/0 Shivappa, Agﬁd 40 years, Working as; Assistant Teacher. 81': Suresh M, 8/0 M. Thirthappa, Aged 39 yearg, Working as Assistant Teacher. Sri L Dhyana Naik, .

S/'0 Lakka Naik, Aged 48 y€:j3.rsQ ' _ Wgrking as Asaistant Teachér. T Sri Veeranna Gewda S/0 Rudrappa, Aged 48 3%e;a'1's, Presantly workingas Hzaad, aﬂ'-.€f:=f;*r ' Sri B K RaIIgaI1a"£ahV%, "

S/0 Kariyappa, Aged '€34! yg3.3,ré;'y ' ' ~ "forking z¥'~:ssi,§.: '£'ea§ijh6r."~.f' .. ' Sri _ S / 0 I'"}§&:I1'L?E3}f$'3.I1'f_1['}E5.~f)}.;)F1,'- Aged_§39 yeaxs, W i}i'1§.'i11gj as ' ?eac31éf;"' ' Si'? Kﬁlfﬁﬁi" Fa? ' S / £1}. LBasappa", . years, V _W0rki'19gV'asVPhysi<::ai}. Education Teacher. j5°'R§;$p@:3CiefiiS"'1*€ds. 10 10 16 are working at ;.Ivna_:1a:g--aI1gothri. Higher Primary Scheoi, Tifvippu i'%_ag;ara, A Shii:1Qga;"'Ta1uk & Dimrict. .,,, R€S§0"£1d€§'l'€S ﬁg: Rizée Rﬁ, R8 &:_ R91, REE ':9 R14 are Ssrveéi T'h€S£:~ '\?s7r§: Apptéais are {ﬂed under Sectiarz 4% Sf the Karriataka; High Gear': Act prayirlg to set aside the arder .. __paSsed in ihe Writ Petitien N0.2'7693--27'?f)8/T2010(S--RES) dated 06/09/2010.

'WRIT A}'?EAL NO.2I6-3/203. 1 8:: WRIT APPEAL NOS.15168-184/291 1 (S--.RES] BETWEEN:

1.

Ex} The State sf Karnaiskai rept. by its Prinicipal Secretaryfsli Department sf Education, 4' t M.S.BuiIding, B3.I1gs10r€#1.'"g ' 'T The Commissioner Nrupathunga Rsaé, Bar:"g.sler_s~}.' ' " ' The Bireécter far }?'1"1b1ic.':VE'r1sﬁ'u§;:11Oz}s, Department sf Sé::t>.:1'da:rj_,§:'»f;dLi<3é1'€J;0'n, Ci/O COIr1fI1iSSiOI1_€jf f0I Publié"i:1;3f:Vjz.1--é:ti0nSg Nrupathuﬁga Rciad? 'BaI1g'a1§e:°_e~'} ' The ~- 'fsgf Insiructians, Shimcagga». .}T;i-§vs1;:"i';*i;.--. Siiiigmdga.

" """       ..AAPpeHa"nts

V -- : ssrappa, A.G.A.}

AND;

E'.

 as n

"  S171 1383} efiiirappa,

Si/Ea Efésyappa, Aged absut A14'? years; 3 sWQr1::::;;~ as Assistant Teacher. _ Sri.S*a,I;"ésh S9 8&3 ;T:§;:zm5:a Naika, gages sbsui 3% years?

AA E17i?"b:"ki:1g as Assisiam, 'E'ssch€:'1, Sr}: D V Vagesh, 8/0 8 V Veeirappa, Aged about 28 years, Vxferking as Assistant Teacher"

6. Sri Chandra S A, 8/0 Armappa S B, Ageﬁ about 48 yaars.

Waking as fkasiatant Taacher. Sfi Ramesh H R, 8/0 H M Rangappa, Aged about 35 years, Working as Physical Educa::i0n»T €aac11ei'§A" 4' ' " V Smt J K Sujatha, V 4_ W/'o Parameswarappa, "

Aged about 34 years, _ _ Working as Assissiant T€'aehjer." Sri'1"V Raghavezdafa,' " . 8/0 S Veeziabhadrappa,' ' "

Aged abmgt 35 }Ii:a:<_s,_f " "

i?:5"ar%££:f:§;j=;v as;;l'S§a::s:a:f:é 1f3§*.:£a_%éjr2;. 'Ciéfii, Resp0';1dTr;>ﬁ.:s N55-.. 1 i¥9«-- '? Aarefwerkjng at G K H igh SC'h€;m1;' 'f1XSh0ka"Nagara, Sghimog.;a'--Ta1}1}:: D'1ia__irict. Sfi Radragcaiﬁa /0 Maﬂappva, Agéd about 89 yearag " Warking" ag 'Head Master, Ss:~m: Venkatesh, " A S2'<:v N3-§:a":fa3appag 32 years, A WQrki:1g as Aasistani Teacher' .311}.

H " * S29 Lakshmappag Agad abaai 34» }-"€3.l"S. = _ Eﬁgarkimg aa Asaiaiam Teagﬁerb aka; agaga Sr}: P Maﬁeshappa, S / 0 P Rudrappa, Aged about 34 years, Workmg as Assistant Teacher. 58 '18. Sri £3,154. Shivamurthy, S/0 E'). Muéiappa, Aged about 42 years, Wczrking as Assistant Teachex" at GK. Higher Primary Schooi, As-haka Nagara, Shimoga Taiuk 81 District, E9" The Sacratary, 1 Sri S1": Guru Kabirananda Education SOCi€f'y(R), .

Ashoka Nagara;

Shimega '1'a1uk & Districf;._ ' _ Bf). The Head Master.' _ GK. High Schoaigh ' Ashoka. Nagar. V. . 3 '-

Shimoga .'€.'a£1.1k 8;: ' V

23. The E{€a»;§;~-E¥i'a'$:er','---.jT'*---.VL _ GK. 1»;.:ag::e:; %Pr:mar5z.hSch;:;a1; Béfﬁ'1112{;f;ha "E'Zaf,t%:~,. h ' V Ashrayah ' _ 'A ' ._ ~ Shémaga 7£'a;§;:;fz};~; 8:, f:3'i.S4'{JT:'iCi.

22. 'TE_v'he GK. Higftixvéa' Prinlary Schooh ':'G,f3¥>&:1a Maiﬁﬁoad.

'A Shimgga. aiuk & District. 1'. éviasterg Eiégher Primary Schasi, A.ShOKa Nagar;

€'sh¢?1:h{;g2: "E'aE1,:E<; &. ﬁigtriatf.

" R€S§G1'}.§€f}§S to R22: R13 5: R16 ":0 mg & R23 are S€;1:'V€&} These Writ Appeals are fiied Llfliiﬁil' Section 4 Of the Karnataka High Ceurt Act, praying to Set aside the Gréer passed in the Writ Petition No.27042~59/2010(SwRES} dated O1/09132010.

if-E WRIT APPEAL NO2164/2011 8: WRIT ALPFEAL N0.52{)6/291 1 (S-RES} BE 2 WEEEY:

1., l:'\.) »J;r :

The Staﬁie <31' Karnataka, _ . rapt. by its Principal Secretar'§,'»-H,_' I Department of I3}duc::.atic»n, ' A * u M 53 Building, B3.r:ga10re--1. Th6 Cemmissioner fer In-é'ﬁ1'1;CiiQTr1v$,7:" "

Fﬁrupathuraga Raad, Banga1ore--_}. The Director for Pa.---15}*iC I~r1st~r1iCt.i_<3.r1's~, _ Department of Prirnaty Egc-i:jiC:atiQr3,;'»... "

O,/O C0'mmissi0r:e:i-ft:>r"}?'ubIiVc Iri:strt,i.;;fi:3r1s, Nrupath1mg;{g Roaich ,E§3;r:ga,1E0'r_€; 1} The t§£r€crGrr'j'f_f§r- 7;Pv¥;:Ej'3v§:bC VZr18'é;ruCti0r1S, Shir:rQgaV.D-E-é.:ricé., _.Svh€3-nroggsr.

T' if Appeiiants V -- : ''.{VB§z* Sr_r ''Bfﬁﬁerappa, A.G.z%.} Sr}: B21-'ééiiréiryajappa, V SVf{3%E':V B'iff$.?8¢I1I18;}3§a, ' V 339:1: 32 years, ¥i?0?r§§;§.r:g as Assistarr: Teacherg Sriﬁ!' E2; ﬁéghar Primary Schsai, g%;S;§:GE£ Nagar; Shrrrrrzga, 'T B 8 Vijayakurnar, _ S/0 B Sarmakariyappa, Aged abaut 42 years, Working as Ass;istar1ETeacher, Sri G K Higher Primary School, Ashe}: Nagara, Shirnoga.

Regyandents F" r Machsnahaiii, Gauribidanur. 8:': V R Prakash, Father name net knawn Assistant Taacher, Acharya PE'E3*Uﬂi'«J€:I'Sif};' Coﬁege, 'Macherzahaﬂi, Gauribidanur.

U1.

{By Sri V.S.Na.ik $2: Szninfxiianjfuxia Naﬁgaikarni. A'ri.+;f<§C'aies'=--;fbi*MC;r*'VR« This Writ Ap;:;$ea_1 {£166 =~é1;1ﬂ'e.':f Seciidn 4 cf the Karnataka High CoufiVAWCE'-Lpi§a:¢iﬁg"'t.{$% -set asdde the ordar passed. in the Writ PetitiQ1';. 'N53,1-8f?Q1*f2-C}O9[S--RES) dated 25/11/2330; " ; 'V , - g:?§1;:,a.L%'2¥§3.g;:'S5éV?;2m 3. 8: xxrgxrr APPEALA~1*§0S.~44";1 4420/20 1 3. (S-RES] BetW<i:§}3_ _ L 'rhe.sm:.e 0:" Eiarhagaxa Represented" _By, Its "Prin<:::ip211 Secre5ta.ry--E _{ 'Departrﬁani Of Eiiducatien, _"*§%.f§;LS.}&3uiEciif:ig;*ﬁanga1ore~O1 '_ 7Efi1§.VCtG:;r:1:;3issi0ner For Public Ensiructiona.

" --._v%«Nfvfpa£h_u'nga Road, Bangalare. The Ifiirectgr For Pubiic E1'1S":If"1}:C{iGEL Béjjariment Sf Sﬁéfﬁfiéaf}? Educaiian, A' ' §/Q? CG1'ﬁ1'ﬁiSSi{}E1€E'" F03' F"'u§§i<:

_ .-'inazrusiiogm, Eﬁrupathanga Rsadé Bangiare-0 1 NJ V The Deputy Directar For Public: Insi:ru<:ti0nS$ Bangaiore South District, Bangaiore Appeiiants (By Sri Blfeerappa. A.G,A.}

-: '. _Rs:;3;§Cﬁ:iénis7. __ £25 A1'.I€kE'£1TE1i'L1k' Bangalare Urban District

6. SEI1'i.BaE{Sh&i§fiI1i Aged About 36 Years, W/O Pzmhpaprasad, Working As Hindi Teacher ' .;.

Working At Sri. V€r1ka1;eshw3.ra High Scfioo-.TVV' '*- ' Subm21r1ga1a,SarI1ar1dm." Pest, . An€ka1'I'a1u}«;, Bangalore Ur1§8;11--DiS7tri{;: " V

7. Sri, Mahantheghﬁ.

Aged Abeut 38 Years, W/0 Banginb0mmaiah*,--.._V, H ' Wozﬁiing AS Physical Edziczgtion Teachéi 3 Working At Sri. '?.v'<§fr1ka1ie'SE1K$§}*'afaHigh Schsio Submarzgalag Samé;nd';-Jr 1"0s'i:;..% % _ Anekal Taluk, BafigﬂiﬁfﬁvUi'b8,1*1'--I:'.iSi;IfiCt 8, Sr; :migg:;%. 33:1.

Ag€di'AbGL1§'5§._Y€E3§:*8L V. S,' 'W0rki;1g,As 'f3€<".011d'-Divisibtzal Clerk W0r__k1ng '\:?eﬁ.k__aT.e'shwara High Schoo Si};bmaﬁga1';aé,"wSéim&:"1dur Past, Anekai-Ta1'uk';' .E>a.;ig;a1ore Urban District.

9. V, ._i The Seci'é:$3.ry °'C;_ener§3.1 I~1os't'ei Educatian Trust , NI1;fza.R0aCi, Amelia} ' --F3:a3:1gva71Q:'¥3_. Urban District §i$,:._ '§hé Master ' Vén.ka,i,€shWara High Schaai 53.2,2;bma:1ga§8g, Sanizmﬁur ?G$§ AA &z1eka§TaEuk Bangaiﬁze Ejrban Sigtrici. ill Réspgmdenis These Writ Appeals are filed under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Court. Act praying to set aside the order passed in the 'Writ Petition N0s.31660~84/ 203$ and 31665- 6?/ZOICXSWRES} dated 04/10/2010. WRIT APPEAL N0.27ﬁ5/201 1 8:

WRIT AJPFEAL NGS.5304~{3M8/1 1 & 15164/1 1. fs;nEs) Betwéerz

1.

Ex.) hit The Siam? Of Karnataka __ j V _ Reprﬁsented By H13 Principal Se;(:fc:.§a"ry-"}i-- * Department C)fEdu<:af;io:r1» "T L J3/LS.Bt,1i1ding, Bangalaimwﬁi Commissioner For Pub1fi§:u:§:1s:ruCVi£af§VS,' Nrupathunga Read, Bax:-ga,EL0ré».Q1 T116 Diracior Fer PiIbiiCL.I:i$»'trg:2iaon" , Department Of Secghndary .Ed't:u:atié;e1'; O/Of CQm1_i;S@i0n{-2%' E-"0'1f.: P1,ﬁf5l:C._£ns'irt1cti0ns §%rupafE;ur§g:;j*a_V Rgéié _Eanga_i§1°é 4«'{}"1 The Dep§M;§,{VDi;;éei{5f'FE§f'VPui§)i§c Fer Public:

Iiisif L:T<:i§3*,0I1S'ff ¥{an1a11aga_fa"DistricL '1"'hé'*--§_3'epVutVy Pubiic Iamtructions, V .Tum1{u:'§3ist'riC':9 Tiimkur C"I{'=Ti:1:% Dgputf Diféctor Of Pubiic: Instructions, V Dva1€anVagf§:re District; Davanagere .,. A§pe11ants {By Sri B.'v'e€:"a}::9a§ A.G,A.} 'T Szgi Govinda Raﬁ

-- S /' 0 Late Venkoba R30 Aged About 43 Years Working As Head Master 'Working A1: Sri Sharana Channappaswamy High Schoei, Lalaghatten Charmapattana M'?

«£5?

Taiuk, Ramanagara District Sri Guru Shankara S/C) Late Puiitegowda Aged Abaui 48 Y€8.I"S Working As Assistant Teacher Whrking At: Sr} Sharana Cha.n.nappaswa,rI:j§~--.:. ' High Schooi, Laiaghatta, Channapattajna * TaEuk,1'{aInana,gara District L Sri Ramachaﬂdraiah = 8/0 Late Doddahanumarﬁziiegowdva.__ ' Ageﬁ About 5&9 Years ' ' Working As Kannada 'I'eaC17:c£"'L'~. Working At Sri Shawna {ff1ha:1i13.ppé1«sWam}I High School, Laiaghaita, Ch3a.3»'1napat:ana Taiuk, R.aman_agara.Disiric:f " in S1':

S/Q Late"-N""E%iE-..S1'ﬁ;z§aﬁizggéxgiégia A Aged ¢%b¥:;--=:£:__53 'ieafs ~ WtSi*k;ing'As ';"P¥1yé'i<:V:3;]{ Ed"é§1'ci'ati0n Teacher Wor._1--:£ng S}:1_éi§'.2§I1a.' Channappaswamy Higgh .S<ii1.00'i{. "La7iv;:,g§E--:,3.1?i:a, Channapattana Taiuleg, *Ra1VT:af1ag-ai"as District: __;f Sr; Krishngiv V V' :E;fG 'Labia Vyiiuntaiah Aged-.Ab,0ut 5%?) Years V Eﬁs Craft 'E'eacher \&7'Gif'E:iI1g.§'At Sr: Sharana Channappaswamy .4 §i37,.gE%:'if$e:":4h90§, Laiaghatta, Chamzapattana " 'f'a};u.é{§ Ramanagara £3355-tri€:t % 'A 324: N zvzaahazsa S/§ Lats Naz'aSi:'z1§1a.§.ai'; A S11 Sharaéa Vidyay Peeta Composite Pre--University Coﬂéige. Thimmanahaﬁi Chikkanayakanahaili Taiuk Tumkuyr District _"-~1 Q3 Sr: A H Paramaeshwarappa S/C) Aliadahalii Hanumanthappa Agad Abeut 51 Years Working As Head Master Sri T Hanumanthappa Memorial High SCV1;1{§£';eEV.V"..4"». " Jakkaii, Via S0ma§3.pura,Channagiri Ta3E*{;_:}<; Cf . Davamagere Qiﬁrict V L" ' (By R1, R3 to R5 are Sewed) Thase Writ Appeais V$'¥1fé"~.fi§€dA.L¥.ﬂd€_f1 of 'die Karnataka High Court Act 'p"::_3;ying ié>~.Sé':-- asiifie the oréer passed in the Writ lifcftitiogtg.----N§'.vLZ8529--26535/.2-010[S~RES) dated 01/09/2010. ' ' «. . warp APPE;#§;1}'E\IC}'§_i';?7:?:'/V2§)._'i (S-RES] Betw€€:£1 H "I...

/.23' The S*:;:i%* Qf I?{r.¥:91V:§"1:"':'5y. :i':s Sé;éréia§'y' H (Efrimary '§;n._¢1"S¢cvc3jfz:1_a3"y Education ) E<'§13.<":at'§U:1V Bépaxftﬁiegi Sachivahaya E} M SBuiﬁIi:1g"Bang*gT1ore U1 __§l 'f.'}:€: Corfirxxéionﬁtr For Fubiic II1S'E£'L1.€fi0IiS "G<;:~Vem.meni"f)'f'Karnataka 2 K3 E~?._Cui:'€V1§, Bangakare C31 0iLéi'V.TDirec"§0r Gf Public Iristructians M§;;'sg<3":*.s--3A [Division z1'v'Ef§_.2js{:':re Bistrici. Mysore ' 3&6 EE}; E}3Z:r:€<:§@z" Sf Fubiic EnS'tru.<:?{i0:1S

-- Eviaxééya i}§s€.:'ic'E, ?sz<E3.:1éya, ﬁppeﬁants [By Sm' B.Veerappa§ A.G'A_] " " " 'jRéSp'on:i.5rii:.:~"s_ Bekkalaie, Evladdur Taluk Mandya District R€S}}_§}11d€1'}fS (By 5:': Satish M "Doddamani, Advocate fa-If"

R2 & R3 are Served) * L" T' » This Writ Appear} filed .unci,€:

Karnataka High Court Act pra};1ng.,.t0j;. Sat" 3;'£S--i,_G' f3,'1:h€,_(}1"'C1€1* _j passed in the Writ Petition No;'20¥;§25/20!Z§'F€i--at€& ' 2?/10;2010, V;_ 'V WRIT APPEA:}*2§G.36sé'/20 1 WRIT APPEA¥,;j.*¥0€-§.5;6 123191201 1 (S-RES) Between ' x V

1. The Staig Rep By its Fr'i3:;:§ip.;:1KS3C:"¢tafry:ii De;3ar*:§ri»e:::§Of E_+2'<i1i'caf1f§7;1"1 ' a » " "V Coﬂtmissiénﬁ.A}<'e:>f"*?':1b1ic Instructions V _E$§rup3%:hunVga Rgati Banga10:re~O1 g\.) ' " C'"£'?i1e i13jrect£}i*'E'7 'Sf' Public Irzstructiens V' » '. éxnd Depgrtrraent Of Secandary Educatian CV3f:V;missi0ner Far Pubiic Instructian §\Eru.;:;LAatE:unga Road, Bangalore

4. iiépuijgr Eiyeciar F0: Pubiié: En3?§§uct.i0n$ Eﬁairangere E}i$1;:ric%g., Bavazzgezzﬁ

- ﬁppaiianis {B}; Sri B.V€er'appa, A,.G.A;E 3' S M Rudrappa.

S/O S V Mahaiingappa, Aged About 49 Yrs E») L») M "

Wx W/A As$istar1i Teacher Sri Haraumanthagpa Mamsriai High Schsei, Jakkali Via Somaiapura, Charmagiri Tahik Bavangerﬁ Diatrict.

S C} Umashankar S/O Gurubasappa S, Aged About 49 Yrs % W/A Horticulture Teacher . Sri }E~Ia:r1'umar1thappa Memorial " V V Jakkaii Via Somaiapura A Chamaagiri Taiuk, Davangerg Districi S Vasanthakumar ' _ '_ "

S/O Shankarappa K; Agedﬁpoist £16 Yrg A ' W/A Assistant T€:aci2.ef%«~ 1 3- . "

Sn: Hanumanthappa Me_:7';o1*i:;21:»HigEz. Sci':-(301 Jakkali Via S0Arna1ap:A1_.:"a_ ' "

Channagiri T;-11au}<_., §}avan_;:§¢=2r€V°£)i3f£riCi:' V Manjappzi b _ v S/O Gur'u$id:3i?,ppa. ﬁgéd Abeuti 46 Yrs W/A 'VASéi's.§$;nt T' ' Sari Hanu5m.--a:i'thappa' __Me'1n0ria£ High Schooi Jé£Kkai:i.V V13; 'Sarﬁzila-para Chan:1a,gi1*i T'éd uk.'B.avangere Dist 5; K {vi Shéjzthoshkumar S,fO Hanuma1'1'thappa, Aged Abaut 45 Yrs VV;'.A-f?h}Jsica1 Education Teacher V _ --S'1'«1_Hﬁmiigianihappa Memerial High Schae-1 " J é11»:}s:f~_11i~ SR? Ea Somaiapura Chamj:;~1g'iri Taluk, " Kim-*ang€r€ Bigtﬁci.

T v. if Swamy '~ . SXQ 'Jeerabhadrappag Ageé; Abcut 44 Yrs W,/A Assistant Teacher Sri Mannam_ma High School Muciigere, Channagiri Taiuk Davangere District The Secretary Sri Ranganaiha Education Society' Somalapura ChannagiriTa1uk, Davanagere Dsitrict.

T116 Secretary -« -.

Sri Mannamma Memeriai Education Se.::i€t:;<, "- "

Bychenahaiii Madapur Past _. ' Gubbi Taiuk Tumkur {)isi::*:'cfI 4 The Head Master ' '~ .

S371 Hanumanthappa Me-m0ria1.High S.Ch:jiv.4_v_V Jamaal}: Via S0ma1ap'ur3,L>E3737 218., ' Charmagiri Taluk _ " ._ Davnagere Dsitrict, E0. The Head I'./Iastei; J " V' Sri Marmamma Hig".h"SChQ0i ' Eisiuﬁigeza "if%:anr§;agi:*'§_:'§'a%:,ik;_j u H Davan_;a7g€r§;'L "Di:3i:'ici.. * ' V' Reaspendents 33.9% fﬁsd unﬁer 8€Ci'£0n % of 7:216 Karnafaigé; VHigh VxE3;C:*.;§f'a:«.__>23i.;5i: praying to set asiée the erder paSSEd if1"-- ':£h{"' \?\f_I'if~.vPCf'i:EiGH NO.14375-1438C3/201U[S-RES) datfgd 26;'Q?";f2_O'1'0. % é vmrr APPEAL N0.3682]2G§.1 " & WEI? A?§?EAL §€§.5§21;'2@3.}. €S--»RES} V' ' -- §_§§*s€€ﬁ The State: Of Karnataka By Its Secretary, Department: Of Primary Education, Multistoried Building, Vidhana Veedhi, Bangalore.

WRIT APPEAL N03683/201 1

535..

WRXT APPEAL NCL5723/2{)}. I [S-RE-S) Between: g K' .1. The State Of Karnaitaka 83: RS S<eCre€:.ary, Department Of Primary Educatien-,.. A _ M '4 Muitistoried Building, Vidhané: 'v-'€»€:dh;i_, --_ " . ' ' Bar1ga1oI'e~};. A' "

The Ccxmmissiener, Department Of Primary Edu'::«a;£i«:f::1g Nrupatunga Road, --

Ba:r1g"a10re--01 V' ' The Deputy D.~"ii'€C'iO:'~C'f .1%1i:>1i;:v.L?}Zr§;;é,';f1§§jvt1éns, Administratizégg Beggar?/'§t:.en-tV C3r1"5 ?1,;._b1jjé'c §3'iSE,Z"LEC§L§{}Ii$, Eﬁféwai §§é::*az+_VBi;a.'::r§<:'§i, V Davaflgﬁiirﬁ ' .

4. jrna;a:¢%}c%;; Gfficef, N_0rt'h .ZG:'j.;:;.. _VD'a1fJa:}ge__re ~ ' - --~ Appeﬁants V{By'Sfi'"B.Ve€rappa§ A.G.A.} .. _ S}1VA.E-Ramanagouvda ' "4%§Qﬁf 48 Years.

' S/C§"_'Lir'1g3a,ppa, (}cC:S. DA"

'A Eﬁferiéigzg At 88.8.8. Rare} High Schosi ' §§é:a.<;ia};?§'. P033 Davangjere 'Sq: & Bégérici ' Eéiiazébasappsig

-- _,-'Ageé Eﬁaui I-E35 Yea.r$, S/O M. Bheamappai. GCC:At*:&nder, Warking At 8.8.833, Rural High School; Kadajji Post, Davangere Tq. 8: District Respondents [By Sri G M Chandrashekarg Advacate fer R4.) S373 Swamy Y MI S/O Madappa Aged 531130211: 39 Yﬁars Werking 3&8 Assistant "F€aCh€1"

Working As Sr: Swami}; Vivekananda Kannakda Higher Primary Schooi u _. Kakanur Chamriagiri Taluk Davan.ager€..'_Dis'£., "- S1': 8 Basavarajappa S/O Shekarappa Aged ékbeut 41 Yearg ;

Working Ass Assimani: .'i"e:»3;Che:t' V' . Working A3 S1'; Swamy ".Z1i';€;}iana13da-- Kamlakda Higher Primar'ySc;ho0i ¢ ' Kakanur Channagiri 'Fa1'1ﬁ<L_I)a€!a:1age1*€"Di'Si Sri H B Kumar _ S/O H E B.asava:a§a;i}*§3a --. " "

Aged Abe":-gfg. 'fgeazjs Woricingi A$iT'LA_s$.§_S*:ai1t Tear:whé;"' "

Werkiﬁg»_¥s.S"'E5i<ii Swgztriy.__V§\f&3.k_a.x1anda }'1éLfif1'a.1§£ia . P1'in1':-ii*y"SCh00} ¥§akanuf'--'€Zhgin 1f1'ag§"r:. __T--aIuk Davanagere Dist:

Sri H 'S~ Ka11eé;k§'api}5a:'4' J /' O §44E~r>saI,].,§ }3h.21nniukappa " _§ Agszci Abmgt éiéi Years '\*;_'--gyri+;ing As'Fi1ySical Education Teacher' Woriziﬁg As Sri Swamy Vivekananda I .Ka;:m;1;_d;; Higher Primary SCE1091 ' Klak§:_11j:u}?"Channagiri Taiuk Bavanagﬁre Bis:

" ?Séé<:z*+e'Ea:j,r 'E§a_E~_;a:11;:§ ﬁagatépafa Sangfha {R} " Ksiaanur, Bcharzmagiri Taiuii r _ Davanagerﬁ Eﬁigérici The Head Master"

Sri Swamy Vivekananda Kannada Higher Primary Schooi Kakanur, Channagiri Taiuk Davanagere District Respondents " lad UM'.

€35} {By S1": R Padmanabha, Advacate for R~--1; R2, R4, R6 8: R7 are Served) These 'Writ Apps:-ais are ﬂied under iifjﬁfge Karnaiaka High Court. Ac': praying "ta set "a$i<i.§:".th(3T'e--rde1t passed in the W'I'it Petition Ne._3.7250w3"?254';f2O'EC;{S~R§:s3}"--.. dated 02;' E2/2010.

WRIT APPEAL No4.36 &5/2o}'1'.%1 ' "

WRIT APPEAL Nos.56_t;s3g1 1/'20Q'1T1'(s4REs} Between

1. Th6 Stair: Of Kar13a:§aP;av._ By its Sg:{:1ffe€;a»ry;_' V ; Depar%:§.§t1e:§:»V'{_}f _Pfi§§E_8;f§' ET-d_2,ié;3;'»§1ia::n 3*»/Euiif.'s§'t:3%'i€{i " B;1i1§1ﬂVg";- "3/'°i{iE*:anVa Veedhi Banga1Q:=<%§§) 1 ' « EN.) The C ' __ -- ' Dsparimant. Frifﬁ 3:-1&9 Educatisn Nru'pa£1mga, V .13angégiQ:*eAw~Q'.1 ' "

C"I'?:3E: D.epu"€j;.r Di'1'&3ctor {Bf Pubiic Instructisrzs _ Administration _ . V =}.7,I:t&;~;::)'a;';'f£:f2?;€};'1£: Of Public Ingtructionﬁ A ' Déﬁsézngczézfe District BECHZER Edilﬁaiiéﬁ Gffieer R And ' Semi}: Zgné, Eaiiangera ' ﬁgggzeiianis (By Sr}: B.VeE:rappa, ASA.)

1. Sri L K Thakrya Naik S/O Kubya Naik Aged About 30 Years Occ:Head Master N rm", 1%} 'tvorking At Sr}: fmjaneya High School Yéragunie New Extensien Davangere Taiuk Arid Eistricii Sri G M Aanda Swamy 8/ C} Gurunahaiah Aged About 37' Years Oc:C:Assistant Teacher W0rkiI1g At Sri Anjanejga Stjthptal -1' D' Yeragunte New Extension .

Davangere Taiuk And Distr'iC'i-- Srii P Ramanjanaiah » S/O Padmanabhadass ' Aged About 88 'fieézrs _ V O(:c:Assista:11: 'E'€.2at<:Mhz-:r'* _ Working' A': Sri Ar:§"a 'I25;y3§__I*{ig1*i"~SC1<i(:0--E Yeragumei New E£xt€r1:gio:1"A..ﬂ_ ' ' S35;az":g3ére'}1j7§aE;:.1%i*-- £*:;131é' Biéézfiitf " - S1": Ga:1g»a,1:*gjag.ha'ia;;1{§'21' ~ V V ' S.2;i+;3,baLS§apj32;AV"B _ Aged Ab'<;'i1t._3€3 Y'e_aj*s__ - O€:c:A$sista:<i*:.TeaC§:1€1?~ 'Norkirig; A? S'f'§ .z3'.1f1j'a.rie}ra High School V _Yeraguni€. N+f3W'=_EXténSi0n " Davangér-e_f'I'a1u}: And Disirict H . F3/E~anj unath He:rii_;manthappa ' -- A'bs:§ut 28 Yaars Occ:_A§;S§s7tant Teazther }¥'<}r§:é::g* At 82%: Anjanéya Eiigh S{E§}G8}L ':':::';ag:;2.::.E@ New E:»*{'§€ﬂS§.0§T. x 'T Eavamgere ".E'3.iuk Ané Bistri<:'i H Sri E N Rarnacharidrappa S/O K Nagappa Aged Aboui. 31 Years Oc<::P E Master Working A1: Sri Anjaneya High School Yeragunte New Extension 5% Davangere Taluk And Bist'r1i{:t

7. Sr}: K C Srinivasa S/Q Cha.m1abasapp& K Aged Abeut 31 Years OCC: Sda, Wbrking At Sri Anjaneya High Schcoi Yeragume New E:Xi€I}SiGI1 _ Davangere Taiuk And District? A I "I .' ; ;-.R;€.s;;£jf1;:ie'ﬂts~ 4_j E".

The-Se Writ Appﬁals ar_»5-fiiﬁd Vuude: Sé<:§jit'>':'1 34} <31" the Kamataka High Ceurt Act p'2=3_.:;Iir_1g to'--361',' "aside 1:116 order passsé in the \?Vrit, I3€?iii.iOI} 1"-£,_-- 1 14/201.13 and 251 15~ 117/2010(S-RES) d3;:.e(':1~ 13/08./2%} 1 g;%fJ£z.:t;*.A;§._vm;aLﬂ':~zé;3a36/201 1 " APPEAL NOS.5522~23/201 1 (s-ms)

1. The=--Si.at',€ Cff "EiVarr:éf.aka _".E2ep1'é'?s;er1:egiV-.i8§;=._£i:s"P1'ir1cipa1 Secretarywﬁ Departrﬁent Of Education Iv3 ,,S Bui1di:ig';"'Banga10re--~ E ;.(._ T.{:'<33;r:.{2€iss;':;)n€r F01" i3u'0Iic instructions ' N'rL%pat'?{;i:{nga Roach Bangaiarai

3. Eiireettar F01' Pubiic insiructian Qgparimsmt Sf Secsridary Educaiisn A' Qfﬁf Czymmissiener F01? Fubiiect Enairuatiisn Nrzzpathmlgza Rsaﬁ Ba§2ga§0.re--i _ The Deputy Director For Pubiic mstruetiens Davanagere District, Davanagare Appellants [By Sri Bﬁfeerappae A.G.A,} A passed. in the Writ Petition No.£.3.'368-13368/2010{S«~R}33S} dated. 2"?/O"?/2810.

WRIT z%.P'PEAL 1330.368?/291 1 :2;

WRIT APPEAL NOS.5613-141291 3. _ Between

1. '1'heStateOfKarnata1:a Represented By its ¥'I'iI1Cipal'.S€CI'iE:'i3.I'},?'*~_H -. _ _ "

Depariiment Of Educatﬁtzga, ' " > MS Building, Barzgalor-§f"€}V1k

2. The Commissionﬁr F01", P'z;bf_ii{: Vfnstruéiiansvgé Nrupathunga B:-mg3,1Gr.¢.«Q"1.% _ 3' T116 Directpr Far '}??u:biic '£t1;§;tr:iC.tiGi1V'-- $epa:'i';mé:i--1"§.§.'---{}€ Efrirnaggry E'ﬁ.é;::7:a.E.icsT:z,' G [ Of C§f}IZ1£§i1iS5i;G1'1€'1£_ Fm:"@E,1_b'1:EC"E'.EiStI"1.1€ti0{1Sg Nrup21t_ht;1n'g"a' I.RQ3.--c}., _ B--:»:_ri;g3;1.Qr€,'

4. "ifhe__Eep":1:y._}3iM:r€x:r:6;f___§'{)15 Pubiic }jn_siructio:0.s, S133/az":2iger&« {}:§§'E3"f}L€';i,, < V... Davane.gefe é V' V ,..Appei1ants (I33; 'Sri B.Ve£:rappa., A.G.5%..] xi S§'i'V'°§a;$;§,fiiag0'uda Chaanagouda i{&r€g9ud..€:r g;5;;g:::d g:'f;'t2{>u': ~/E3 'fe22rs;§ " Sﬁf 'Chamn21g::>Lada§ W_Grk§_:1g B.-3 Bead ?v'£asi€:' ~ AA Working At 8;}: Bﬁeyaﬁngeghwara * . Higher' Primary Schoolg Yakkanahaili Hannah Tq, Davanagere District H "2. Sri Kumaraswamy SH Aged About 33 Years?

S/O Sangaiah, me i.

Working As Aesietant Teacher Werliing At Sri. Beeralingeehwara, Higher Primary Seheoig Yakkanahaili Heannaii Tq, Desisanagere District Sri Govindappa Aged About 39 Years, S/O Kubendrappa, .

Werkirzg As Physical} E-d11C3,tii3'1':--T eaeher '4 Werking A1: Sri. Bee:ra1ingeShwa..ra} "

Higher Primary School, Yakkaﬁahaili -. , _ "

HO1"iI1a3iT(if¢ Da.var;ager'e.4_Distri::t"' ' The Secretary Sri Beeralingeehwara Education Soeieiy _ Yakkanahaili, Henna}: ii-'--a1"L1'k _ "

Davanagere District, _ ' "

The Sri. Beers E.i.31ges+haxre;ra.«- A Eﬁiiitatfgn S«':{:é€:'ie"t'§;.&V"- 'Kak}§:eVrxéh.5s!1_i',' V Honf:a_11 --Ta1'L1k Be fx-r'a3<1ager'e'« .'£3§,e7{:"§e":., é ,.~ " e ' é Respencients "These A'pf3eaIs are filed under Seetien 4: of the Ka:*na5£.'21ka..High Chart Act praying to set aside the order » Writ Petifiien 368'?2«~74/ £0 dated 26/ 11/ 18. 2 APPEAL NG.3688f2Gi1 8:

Wm? APPEAL N§Ss531§-Zgiﬁﬁi 1 {e~REs:

Between The State 0:' Karnataka By Its Secretary E' Department Of §rimary Education MVS. Buﬁdingg Vidh.ana Veedhi Ev A115 'NJ Bezngaiora O1 'I.'h€3 Czjrxamisssioner, D€rpa:;'£:mem. Of Prirz121:'3--* Eciuctaticm 1'€ru-p21:;h1,I:r1ga Road. Ba11gaI<>re 0?.

The I)eput.y I)ire<:i".<_sr Of Pt:1b1iC: I11si.1*1,s;{:t'i{;§'nVs . Administ.z'z1t,i<}:1s. W ' I)ep21rE:n1e.m', Of Pubkic I11s;'i.r;;(:t,i3:}.r;.s§v {)aw}.:1z1gere £)i:s1'.1~i(~.t. "

{Jen-'a1'32»1gere The BIGCK Edu<?af;i.0r1. Offf€:£::19 . E\E01"<,h Zo:'1<;*., £)21Vas3g&%r§éV''''' "

' Appeiiants V. {By Sri -JE1.§,?vél'L5iE31'§7,&1})}3-E1 «. A Aged .'rZ3.}:_)VC'}.¥,:1i?.,V_45t5 yeai' G30 :' g_%:3':'~:%._s§tz"a:':V1.%;, §x€.;z';és*:.5e: 1, VV<'né7Ki1?aM_g At: High Schﬁoi Reamgmm, V K:1d2:.jj i ' P<:>sL ' 'D3,va1'221g::1_"£% *§'e11i,L}<, A:'1d }f.")§sst:;:'ict:

3 S'ii fi4F3..._P2}re1sa1 Nelikar _ TS/. E*§Ve::;g;§g;-rfzppei ._ .Ag£é'd,,_ab_{}w:1i. 54 years; 'V ' 0<§<jE'1%::e:5'éisst;2:1:f:E;'"i'6a:i:E";€:3<* W'<3r§s;;§'§1g At Rurai High Schozﬂ 'i'{2::€:E2;.;'_§E iE3'{f::e:E:e Baa»-*2?zr:21;;§€:r€£r '£'a§u§4:

AA And §.>§g:m-::':

SI'): K B §a;'m:'I1a1*1{'happ2;1 S/O K Bheemappa Aged elbout, 54 years OCC: DrawiI1g Teacher Working At S.B.B.B. Rum} High Schooi Kadajji Post, Bax-'a13ager¢3 '1'aiuk And £1)iss'{rici;

4. Sri F33-*a;»: Ahmed Thalezgeré S/O 1fj)h2:1v21i Sab 'I'h&i}¢3gg€%ri Aged 21b(:aL.1t, 48 yf-3,::H'S OCCI Perm Cum \?'v'at'.ch:ma_n Working Ai. 8.13.3.3. Rural High School 5 _.__ é Kaddlﬁi Pcyst, I)22.'v2u1a§§%re Taiuk; .. V' 'T And E)is€',rH:t:

5. SH 8 Basavarajappa Aged, ::1.b()u*<. 47 3-rears Occ: P€€)i'1 V' VV 0rki:1'1g A1": S.R.G.N High "E3~;:h00I V'£{2ir1'1;j:.11"a¢; Kadajji Pesst. I)a1va:'1e1gcsre Ttlilik ' T' And I)iSEri£3t _ ' R€:5ponder1i.S {By Szri {E M €Zh22.:vt%.§i;*=;.%.:'-§;§':.<-319:gar; xééiif»-*V§>7'f<:::;§i',é:* far R3: '''::::,> 5.} ~'1'h"e:3-5:3'7Nrii.':?:A;1;5e,3;1s: 21fé"'i'iIed under Section 4 of the Karnéﬂaiigz Hi§;h.V_ 4(:v€)L1i.'I'Tf'V.'2'vX(t'L? praying, to Sfff aeside the order pas$e{"§_ 'gm ' *§.:};'1s3 '*R?'\é?r:1_?; '--~,,P§:'¥:éti0z1 N:>.2Q9§1 and 29962» 965/20 };=Q[S--RE-S}."'dé:IT§3ﬂd.23/()7/20 E G. 'V ,3§rIiIT";a.I$PEAL No.-422'?/20 1 1 1' " «. APPEAL NOS.5568~5577/2611 (S~RES) ._B"é.1.:xréii1i;' .,__ ~. 'é° '§_'E3§;% ;'E§{,s.r<% Sf K22r_:n2:E:21_ka_ Eﬁy $1.52. .E3<é<i:r:??:2::*y " 4_ 'Ef}5é5_5*.§3z?a.:*':*:;m?.n§ 'Sf ?r§m£:z"3;* E:{§i.i{TZ£{ii{}§?, v _ 'E?v'Z1:§%,§e3€,<:::r§€~::§ B'u§i<:'g§':"1_s_._:;5 '\f§<.'i11a:'13. 'sfei-fdfzi Ba3:1ga1oz:<:~O1_ ix} The Commissioner Depanment Of Primary Education Nrupat;u1'1ga Road § BangaI::)re~0};

The Deputy Director Of Public Irastructians AdministraI':i0m Dapartrnent Of Public Instructians. Davanagere Bistrict Davanagere Ths Block Educaticsra Officer Jaga1u'r,JagaEur Taiuk 1 Davanagare Qistrict (By Sn B.\,9'e€r8;pi§%i,_$.G..?;.._} % 1 Sri Gurixsiédana G<}u.dé::-- D 1 V V SEQ Laue Mugana Geiida 'ID Aged About 52_Years_--- = Occﬁead _, E5Je;'}z§2';:';§_>; At' & fziz-'E _}§i;_§h€;t Pr§;f:::»3;:*_3% ;iE§:%%':§oE H'osa%:er€i"ifii§_agé;' §;£f_ag3]j#;2 :"'Fa§*a_:aZ%:v._ ' Davanagezﬁ IE'-i:i:,i};~ici4 _ «-

2. BaSé:v':a.::2gj Y'__ -- ' 8250 Late T}1i'pp€S*g§Ja;:z;~y Y T Aged ézkhcdt 4 '7 '1'£;:i1f.rs V .Qcc:A;ssistaf:t Taaéher V, W"arkngE%.£_.S J M Higher Primary Schooi ﬂﬁasakere Vilﬁgé, Jagaiur Taiuk _ Dvavanaggre District:

A §i¥i--ahTa;é$ i'1wa1"a§pa E K S_f~{7} i;!:3§t.€ Eiaiiappa Vi Aggsd skbaut £3 Yeara {L¥:é:,Assi$'iani Tsachar AA ~, 1E?'@r§mg A'{. S 3 IVE Eighar §r§m3;ri§; Schggé " -- H@$a;k€:"€ 'ifiiiage, ﬁagaiur '£'a.EuE<; Davanagere BiS%{ri:::§:

4». Sri Prasanna Kumar R 8/0 Kotranna A Aged About 38 Years Occ:ASsistant Teacher Werkng At S J M Higher Primary Schoel . 5 ' }.'&p;§e}_1af;1'7Eé U1 GR hm} Hosakerae Village; Jagaﬁur Taiuk Davanagere Diatrict Sri Chamaappa K M 8/0 Kaﬂappa K Aged About 44 Yaafs C)cc.:As$ista1':at Teacher Workng A1: S J M Higher Prir11ary,'Sch:<.3Vt':'s}b: "4" '4 é Hosakere Viiiageg Jagaiur j; ' Davanagere District A' Mailadappara Kariyappau K S/ O Maliaéappara Nanjajppa _ Aged About 43 Years A Octcrﬁxssistant 'F€a_C}1er*_ V .

Workng At 8 J M 5355901 Hosakere V_i11age.,Ja ga:u;";a11§>; 1 " "

Davarzaggerg 'ﬁistricri H a Sr: R:'=1vig.Ef:a"'E§"--éf'. _ S,/0 Leif:-}3Iarapa'th£'--S"

Agéél About Yéafs _ V Qcc :_Assisi ant "I'éac.h€:r' - Warkmg :'~'.».ﬁ; £33 ..EfZigh€r Primary Schoﬁi Hesakere V'i11é¢g€',.J'_aga1ur Taluk V .Davar:'ag"€re. .3iS":riéi " V -. Evian} appéiﬁ' _V S/Q Nibagur Virupanna V ",§¥£:>i31_}u*; 47 Years A "-.V'Oct::7%j{eé;:di Master ¥'\§€;§'?»Qi§'g Ari Sr: Marathi Highﬁf Primary Séheei, Sowripura Viﬂage? Jagaéur Taiuk §}:>:.2?a33a§;§@r€ E}:7$£;r§::i:

* '8ri P 'IVE Chandraghﬁiaaraiah 8/0 P M Channabasaiah Aged About 47 Years Oc<::Assi; Teacher Workng At Sri Nlaruﬁhi Higher Primary Schaoi, Gowripura \»§Eage, Jagaiur Taluk Eavanagere Digtrict E0. Sri M V:ishWaI1athai.ah S/O Maheshwariah Aged Abeui: 49 YEBJS 0cc:E-"lead Master, Warking ﬁt Sr}. Basaveah 'Nara Higher Primary School Male Machikere Village, Jagalm" T'aiu§<; Davanagere District I E. Sm: M Chandramma D / Omaiavikappa Aged About 42 Years V é ._ - , Occmksst Teacher W'ork:i3:1g--Sr:i, Basavesh Ware Higher Primary Sch<:>0i=.._ ' _ "

Maia Machikere Viilage, Jagalijr Ta}uE: A ' Davanagere Dis'£ric;i'i.---.i_ ~ "

Regpon-:i<:-rnts (By R'1{;;=~seV:'-vc_-:3: ' A These '?~.3§7rit."'~.A§:*f}€:aiS--.jT'a3% .fii13<Vfi-_u2:de3" Secﬁisn 4 9f the Karriataka Higgh'*--Cigurt xAr:t"-'p«rz1_:31kir;gé to set aside the arder passed m°tE2e:7f,VVri'i:§ Peuﬁon Nt3'.'38294-304/2010{S_RES] daiecl 02,3 1 1 ;*:2{3 my. AA é A}'i*EQ§§';#?§'O.4235 ,/201 1 (S~--RES} ;_l@§?{zaé:e1:1 » E}; _ '3The.V:'3"£é1~t£: Of Karnaiaka " _ . V Sec:'ei:ary T9 Government EL

-- A ' *-.V'Ed'ui::L.3.t'1dn Departmant, M.,~S.;Bf:ii1d.ingjs, Drjambedkar Ef'eed.hL ' ;Béig3;1g.fa}.Grew5§Q SSE «--._Th€ Commisgianer ?§'€ Un§i..-?$rsi£}*

-- Eciuctaiion iﬁépt, 18th Cmgss Govt. Boys 'High Sstiheai Bidg. Malieswaram, BangaE0r€--58GOO 1 ~%-*f'

3. The Deputy Commissioner Pre-University Blducation Department Government Junior Coliege Building Bangalore 560 O0}.

Thta z1Xcc0utan_'£ Gerierai In Karnataka (A&E.-1} Karnataka Regiderzcy" Park Road, Ba.nga10re 5643 001 (B1; Sri B.Veerappa¥. -- ' Smt 1%/Ieera Nayak W/O Sri G H Nayak Aged 60 Years I .

R/At No 5187, Behin._d'i(ama Kuvempunagar Mysore " "

:.sha_ﬁ_ €}3pitaE Manasa G&ﬁ.f§{3i~hTi ffjdu' _'a}.:i§Q4ri'~.E3:)_ciTet;;»* I Mygme €}{§%:'3_V _ By its Sﬁicrazft-aI"'y"3'..__ b IJ'nVivCr$E;Ly '1'*/Iytaiire 1'9..5Ianase£ ' €.§§a«1j:g:)i:e:2fi"ﬂmvaford Hail M§;sé;~;;;_'€' Rep By "§?$'T'{<{;éigistrar » _ " Respondents Bﬁz N Raghupathy*, Advscaie for R 1. V " ( " " _ ;_ T_.}%Raj€nd1"a"Kumar Swarny, Advscate far }:'--2 £5 3.) Appeal filed. under Sesiion % of the E<i3_._fr:atvaE<?a---_.'i*iig§1 Court. Act prajsmg to .36: asiée {ha 0:663"

pas':-:€<ii Ainfhe Writ. Peiiiian 2569Q/2905 éated 8,/8/' 10 Wm? A.'??EAL NG.4;»465f2§1 1 § WRIT APFEAL N035? 19=~2{}/29 1 1 (S-RES} V 'Between

1..

The State Of Karraataka Represented By Its Principai Secretary Primary «Si Secondary Education Department:

_ H H Ap'p<,§i1;;n K 4-V §~J M S Buiﬁﬁing, Bangalore 580001 Thfz Birector Of Primary Education Department Of Public instructions Péew Pubiic Office, Nrupaéhunga Road.

Bangalore The Deputy Dirécior Of Public Ixﬁiméiéidizs A TA Bangalore Sauth Distrzf-=:'t V' ' Kalasipaiya V --

Bangalore 560 002% The Biock Educatién "

South Range - I '  _T     '
BP W3.dia,R0ad,   '
BasavanVagfu::3_i  V    
    V   " 

       ' mﬁppdiarzts

j. 1] _ f; S'rj:'B-V'é'€ra};$pa, A.G.A.) ,, .3: D Vi} 3.jg'é;ka1Va V . ~ Agxfad-~44 Yez::'~'s'''' ' * .. _ W,~',G-- .Puttaswam§? V' --A$'5s_isi.é1:1i_jTeacher ' Gﬂajizarnandira Kannada Higher i?'ri:a1:ég':j;r Scheal, Kanakanagaras e} P Péagar Past,

2 " . B°;a;;'1ga£0r€ 5890 "E78 * N 'iﬁ'er;E«;ai€:s-;E1

-- Ageé 4% ':"€:ars S/Q Narasimhaiah Assistant Teacher Gnanamanciira Kannada Higher Primary Schooi, Kanakanagara, J P Nagar Post, Ba1'1ga1_ore 680078 La) Lakkanna Aged 5&3 Years S/O Muthurayappa T Assistant Teacher Crr1anam.21I1<:£1ra Kan ada Higher Primary _ Schook, ¥<Ianakanagar3§ J P Nagar Past, 'V u _._ Bangalore 550078

4. The Administrator Gnanamandira Kan.nar:ia 1 Higher Primary School, Kanakanagam, ' J P Nagar Post Bangaiore 560078 :5. The Maraaging Tr--u;§:."{.e€':_C':;;m1¥'€s¢cfea';ary Gnanamandira E?du.1c:atiC>:i é'I'r:__1_éi; u . V D' ' NOEOS/A ._ V' E{anaka,m§§§;::fa, _ J P E\E'aj.g§:u** §% <§s:{i ~. 3 I _V fa Bangaiojhe 5'£E3G.Q7 A ... Respondents {By Advacate far R43 ,VThe%§€ §?€'rit...'--Ar5'péé1s are filed under Sectian 4» of the Kamgataka High_Cop.ri Act praying ta set aside the erder pé.;3Seé'>iri*.i1f,he Wiﬁi' Petition N0.26650~28652/2010[SmRES) A V;¢at;cd._Q:?%/%1%V2--;;201.0. APPEAL 2smg4534/23;. 1 {$333} B€té£=f€%.:jg V V. f » ''E'%1'€:. P1*'in£:i§3aE Séiﬁfﬁtaf}? ' = {P:"1:ma.1'y 8: Seconéary Eézzcaiian} State Of Karnataka, ' = .-§\fLS.BuiIding, Bangalore 1 .

... Appeliant [By Sri B.Vee:rappa§ A.G.A..) And §\J

--«X La) 81* John Vianey S/O Paui "RP.

Aged Abeut 56 Yeare, Oc:C;Se}:1i0I' Grade Lecturer 1_n.».Histe2'y,: " _ Xﬁferking At. St. Annes Pre~';Unixgfe:esity -- "

Ccﬂiege For Girls Rammurthynagar, Bargalore' =1 Mr Narayana Bhat H T S/C} Thimmenna Bha'é;V_-----« Aged About 53 'x'e.ée's, T Oec:;Seni0r Grade'Le'c:fu.re»r:»'£n K§a11n3.da, 'Working At' St. Anr,1,'e"-as Pre:U"ﬁ:"x*e:"=Si--t3f College Fri Girisgf Ra.mm1;%_§'ih5;1':_ag jaégrj, gage £::§'r'e I':"§;"

Mrs -Su5pS1*~a1'};sha :f3V€ti V'171.1'!f1{:1"EL D/MC) V3;:ima"fR"aja'~.AV"' V fageci -A_bV0":.:':..;'?}i') * ' Gee;:3enie: 'tZ'§{:=:z;f}'e__§;e.eturer In Engiish Wefk1'ngAT;. Sij. .é¥.ri:'1j2e§s Pre»--Um'versit:y V College E"0r_("}i1*£;=s Ram.m_urEh.§:.;1ag;a.r, Bangalore 16., Esfiary George ' Aged' -.A'i',:.eu€ 60 Years. Oee:Se:';i0r Grade Eleeturer in Hindi Waérking A: St Annee Pre~Ej"mve3:e1E'€y Ce§.'§ege Eb: Giifle Ra;mmurt.h§:nag8J:; Bangaéme 18. Mrs Lissie 2'-'mteny D/O C A Arrteny Aged About 41 Years, OCc;Sen:ior Grade Lecturer in Economics Working At. St. Anne's Pre~Un:iversity Ccdlege For Gide I E. St Anne Eciucational Society No.3', Miﬂer Read, BangaE0re-560052 By its Secretary _.

R,e.S§0:it;1€fnt1:§ (By Sr: E L Manda Kumar & AS$0(:iai:€S; z%df.'S;8--:atéS £02" K Respendenfis 1 ':0 3, 5 £i9...'.7_,'9 85:10)" "

This Writ Appeal fiieé _und€3: 'SectiT0i§.A 4 ' of 'Ehe * Kamataka High Court AC1: id" SE1' _asvidé._ t":'1€:: "?:>rc1€:1*"

passed in U16 Writ Petitian E\§tsV,.I'?23/2{3Q'?{S"~RE',S) dated 02/02/2011. , .m_=s*. '=-_Hx qnqﬁAAPPﬁé¢;§cﬁ454g]2$1:

av. xzsrmif ;ai§:r:¢:,A1;L,:§:7o~;M15;3::9,£2o1 1 (S-RES] Betw§;§'uﬁ"' - V ' ' E. S%.a":<sOf E{3;:fi:.3f€fe:«Es:é§.~~ R€fj)"-Bf? Its°U fids:r f5*:?:C1'etary To Govt 'Secoﬁﬁ avg/. Vﬂducatibn MLAS Building, D3" Aﬂibﬁdkéil" R0311 B¢.ang§_210re~ SEKEOO 1 »_ General {A :3: E} Karnataka A ' Pa1'k_' Hi;f;1is€ Road _ Ba;}g;3;}Ore~ 580601

-' poi' .

';i"E:z.é 836$}: Educaiiam Qffiser V. x Ex/iarzgaﬁora Taiuk "-- ES:-'i3;ngaEGra=:~5'?5G81 Dhakshina Kannada Appeﬁants (By Sri B.VeE:rap-pa, A.G.A.) p--M Ms Ver1kai€$hw'ar1' E)/O Late M ishwara Bhat Aged Abaut 50 Yeaw Mudraje House, Kotekar Beeri Post Kotekasr, Mangalere Dhakghina Kannada I The: C0rresp0I1Cient V P./}Iacia.r1i Junior Coﬂege UE1a1*5?-4159 Mangalore T3111}: z Dakshina Kanna<:ia.._ ' : H ... R€SpO}."1d€I1iS These gage "Q2 :'15:§er Seciian is af the Karnaiaka F'%ig§ii".C'{f>'13T.r{: ﬁﬁjgeii "pta_§gi:3;g---t0 set agide the order passed if}j§l'l(:w~ErV1'}11ifr.;?$1I§§fO'Q"§.€§§5f685/ 10 dated 12/1;' 11.

L NQ4736/2611 (S-RES) BetWeen'*-- *

1. , é 'R639 By Its Ciiiéf Secretary 'The Stairs" Kafnataka 2 Rduucaﬁian }I)epa:r':meni; N. A' .

,$au<:ihe1, Bangaiore 560 001 'The J{:'i_'f1t Biz'<e~C.i<:>1"

Bfsgtié _Educa:i07;";;_ Gfﬁcer:

';\%<.*::'Eh §}i'1§§;SE{}i'L I'¢EaE£e$h1.a;ar'am " 'T%.%,,«Banga;c:re«5§§@@3 The Aétetountani. Gemzrai (A&E Karnataka] RB. N0 5329, Park House Road Bangaiore 560 001 Appellants (By Sn' Bﬁeerappak A'G.A.) The Deputy Directs? Of ?u.bIiC Instructions Shimoga Office Of The Actzzountant Gﬁnerai (A $3 E} Bangaiarté »V K _ . . . '. " A;:--peé'E3;11tS (By Sr: B.Veerap_p;a,'A.G_--.'E%;;}" ' : _': . "

Sri K Keriyappa S/O Chouclappa Age 83 Years, j _ _ Reid On 3O~ES-2Oi}{§;'xs'-I71V§'§?\:{}V Mainad High Schocd, '"f'a"ttur, Tq_,'SQI::i}3, 1ZZri53t.SI;'£i;Ts3-;">ga R/O '1'ava_;:'ad: '.£'q} S01?3b_; A1)':-3: Shmoga Sri M 'i'€§1g'E{p;,*%1§1_ " «.j "

Age 8.'3.V':*'»Eéa'f:is, ' V. «. A Reid Q;f:;'31'3f.EQ-2G0'6 Asﬁm' Maland High Schooi, v'V.F?:3~{3.fE'ar:'\ﬂ:i'V;' -7.1.'_q_.-- Sorab, Dist SfV§"§:r5r;.{}g'a;. . V ' R/O. T'ava1*:ad'£. "§iTq'}"'-Scrab, Dist Shimoga V' ._i $1'; M igozvida 'Age 6.6 Years", ""

R€:td.(3'ﬂ 30-1 1-2003 As H M Sr: Shiddhaveé : _'E}Zes« 1*:wé'aT_r High Scheoi, Mead}; ._ " R';'C}rvRag1E§a1: Nagar, Chewti Road ' §s_:1;::a't,§_i;"'%'c;. Sarah' DES: Shimaga Qhzgnnabeisappez ﬁgs 8} 'fearg, 1" Reid an 3:--5~2@®5s Ass Hm Sri Séhéddhavee Esghwai' High. Schaei lviodéy, Tq. Sarah, Dist. Shimoga R/O Tozcavanda, Post Agasanahalli; Tq. Sarah. Dist. Shimoga Sri Sarmappa Age 63 Years, Reid On i31~8~2C*06 AS Sada, Maiané High Schocal Sigga~-Endmraiki, Tq. Soirab Dist. Shimoga R,/C1 Siggavlnduvaiii, Tag. Sarah, Bist Shimcga Sn' K. \firupak$happag0uda Age 81 Years, Reid On 30-41-2008 z'3aS.»H.§\/E. "

War High Schooi, Mavéii ' Tq. Sorab, Dist. Shimoga _ R/O 4th Cirogs, Mar00r--Ka11keri, Tq. Scarab, Dist Shimaga "

Sr: Nagesh C Age 62 Years _j ' _ " -.

Reid On 31~»5«»2}OQ'? As_.EI.1X5I.l%a'Iaj:n£1t§V iv .. High SCho0E.VKégi1¢'--3.I1Cfj,ur,' _ ' Tq, Shzdéapimgj;1Esi§s:.,E:a:'r,;zér R/G Ganglia-:'§<§V0 i3":;:'If_3 Tqf=S{'>':.*3;E:? ' Dist Shimagée. ' ~

8. Sr: ShiC1'd'i:7aVL=era.ppa_ Rudrappa Kanneshwar Age: 88 "§'z8a1'«§;~. _. ' Reta} On 3€1~4'=-.2QG3,_As Asst Teacher Sr}; R€nL1'}:;;I;1ba._}i'igh_ School, 'Ch.andragutti T'{::_. Sorab, Dist, Shimoga " Ff._,!O .Chanti1aggutti, Tq. Sorab, D is £'. Shémoga 1" .9; « "i"€[':b $':'iivappa Age: 'Years?

R:e:d*<:>n 3G~«6»~2®@7 Ag H,':\x§.MaI.z1ad High 33$-;e::e<:§§ Eiirejamburg '33, Sélikaripmz Sign Sfiﬁgmagag R/G Shiva Niiaya, ii CFOSS, 2%2':*».?a?;?z','i R€}a§g Shfraikepga " Tq. Shikaripur, Dist. Shimaga V' S1': G Ramappa Age' 62 Years, Reid On 304-2004 As Asst Teacher Mainad Highschooi Siggwlnduvalli, Tq. Sorab Dist. Shimoga, R/O C/O Kappa}: Ga.nga&har $\J Tumkur District:

Sr}: M R. Nata.ra_j S,/O Ramaxma Agar 50 Working As L€C'§11I'€1"

At Sri Ranga Vishwabharathi Prezwhﬁaiversity College. Tiptur~5?2 201 Tumkur Distri<::'i: 1 M C Manju:aathaSwamjy'_ S/O Sri.?v'E.C.Channapp+.a§*'..V_ Aged Abeut 51 Years, _ Working As Lecturer --. V' At Sri Ranga '¢'ishii;abha1;r3;ihi.V__'._ '=_ _ P:t"€--Um'versity Coilegtz,' w . Tip'tur~572_201 ' Tumkufaj I)i_s'Efr"iCt§; Mahc§S'h;_a3Zah"'3'--.__ 9 x S/O Sri ":37Rank&.:r'aV1i:;3Ag--aj}3;h "

V,VOI'_k..i mg Lect a:s_f£~:sf _ ﬂit «Sr: R2:ng"a%L"'£i';$v§1€9v-21b.?3 araithi ?:"€- U11i<:e1*$ity"C::§'1}.ege";'----Ti'iptu1'-- 5'?2 20 1 _Tumk;u r"D.ivs'j£-:ri<:--i: * "

V» ' I-'::ras€,g_§o\,vd'é;' 'V SQWC) Thimmegowda A 3 " ' _Ag§ a'. $T{§}ci':; 1: 49 Years;

A \?i%'e:*}:'i__r:g 'AS Lecturer W:.;2~x "

Ag Sfi--_E?';anga Vishwabharathi ?re» U-n§vc'r31?:§f C<>i1ege,'1"i§€u;:--5'?2, 20:

Tuénimr E'§i$'::riCt. H 4' "iF*edamuI'€.hjg; H S50 E33": Eﬁahadevaiah Aged About 48 Years?

Working As Lecturer At Sr: Ranga Vishwabharathi Pre-« University Coiiege, Tiptu1'--:':372 201 Turnkur District Bangai«:31'€ The Dir<=:::t.0r Directosr of Pre-University Eiducatian, Palace Roach Bangaiors {By Sin'. 8 Veerappa, ASA} And:

i, Ex} A " ~ 2 V By' 'it.S..P1*.i_I_3CipaE Smt. Suiechana S.L Aged 51 Yeam V x _ W/O Late Parame53§1fwi.i1rapp2;'v " ' R/At N0.3202, Ambi.ka.T_Kk'ipa' Met 8 Black, = 1§)ava.nag€r_:.=,.: i ' Peura S&*{%va_..E~3»5;ff1'i§t.1"£,i 'iloiiege Bui1d_'i:(1 g _SCh§301 EXt:é:1siVo'mfﬁariiliiar, _ I§aV-._a:1:»1gé::e~- _.D'ist:"i{:t"'~:'3'?? 60 I its "

_ Smt Kéirzthappa .. SrE:sht,i, W'-'o:;;_¢;1:~; Pre~Unixrersiiy C--{1E}e'g-"er, Harihara 57?' 801 Regponcients f'~'€£}'§§{ Appeai is filed 8/3 4 0f the Karnataka High Cgéjrﬁ 'Act p:'aj;ing is 36:: aﬁiéﬁ the eréer gagged in the 'iifrit .1.

.;p;e::::{::2":'%g,449z:/gsgaggaea; Dateﬁ zggasgzgm 2.1 WA N3 18338 SF 231 I(S~RES} WA. Nos. 16'?O§~7{)5/2011 Betwﬁan. :

The State of Karnataka By" The Pyincipal Secretzzry Eciuctatiorx Department M %A§pe::gmgA EM} M S BL:;i.1d:'mgs, Ea:1g3.10re~1 The Commigsionez' Pre~Uni*s:erSitjg* Educatian De-pa.rtment. Sampige Road Malieswaram 185:1': Cress Banga10re~E§6{)012 The Director Pre~Univers'ity Education Palace Road Bangaiore V T '.V.':. zﬁypeiians [By Sri B veerappa, AGA) And:

Es-

Srig Ei Naga15a§a;Gp3. _ 1' S/O 81°31 Hané§;'m§a'r:t:hba'§.§:-ax"~ V. aged Ab<:su~t_4'8 5;{§3a1r~:,_ " R/At Ayéi1'C}f3; fR€SiiiV€U'{',§{V'} F'10€3:"""

Main7R.0ad,  -- I
Shimagja ._     --~

2.

V _S:'1i }£{Iis;Ii1né1:ni1i;thy Sf?) Sri"D.__S Nigappa ' ':*Aged»J%;bout £i;'?a"Years RfA't,C'/V0 Mahaswamy Ramanna, 2nd FI001" V --SidAd5:faT::i_::shwara Raad, Near Railway ~. A" Staiiv<}_n;[;;Ea3jampura, "I'harik<:%re Taiuk A ChiE<; §;~;?.magfa1z1r §)i$§.:'§;{:'£', C Piaiagashari " G Chii~§%:av€€ra»:ﬁ*1a.r * . Ageé z%E:3{:22;2'{. §§ 'fears Bi 0 Chikkaiveeyachar. R/At Chikkabangaia Pest Tharikere Taluk Chikkamagaiur District Sm': A M Geetha 13/ 0 Late H Maciappa EN.) (By Sr]: 8 Veerappa, ASA) M -S Buihriizlg, Banga1c::'e+56G{)G 1 The Cr:;mm.isson€:r Pre Urlimi-rsity Education 18th Cmgs, EV£a1Ees.hWaram Bangalore 19 -

1..

Sri K Ramesh S/O Raje Gowcia-' A Serving As Lectu-rc$:" Ir3*_;Ec;c>nt;nf':i%C's% _ Adhichunchanagiri L-Liﬁizregéiffxg, V " ' Caliege, C}3,annar:;g--*a,pai:é$3 ' " " ' E~IasSa:1_..Ei"l5i/?'iCt " ~. Sr: R'a}¢1'V»§"3.:'E5;/'ii 13':-5-.<h:;:;x;;§j;§a5"V.i} ' 8éf's;1'11g':iAs I;%:i:i":,i'1.=V:§f' in PhySi<:s,Adhichun~ Cha.:1--agir5:. '1JfxEV.€vFiS?y _ Cvciiége; Charznézray-apatnéw, }~Ias:3ar: Di;~:tr"ii:ft . ' 3 _5 Sr: She}{a3: S fOv::3ri Ch;'.k:ké: Gowda _ . . . .

Servi--n g..As Lecturer in Economics V T..P_I'a:thi§;3a_ Ere University College " ...VV«Afa_$v_;.%s_:e:e'Ta1uk I~Ia.s;san District Si;-'F; 2§msapp€: S ,1' 6 Sri Eiamazma 45 * Sérving AS Lectzzreii" E2: Physicg _ 13'ra§thf:>a Pm Umversiiy Caiiege Ar3.sﬁ<;ere T 221:3}: Ha$sa;r1 ﬁistrict 81': S M Jay21C£eVa S/O Sr: S M Malieshappa Age: -44» Servixzg As Lecturer In English Prathiba Pre University Coilege .15.

' *;~s,[%M %_ 9'?

Smi Latha Devi I)/O Sr: C':.A.Krishr13.ppa Age: 50 Lecturer 1121 Ecerzomics Prasidancy Coﬁegrz-3 HaS5an Town, Hassan District S1': V M Ramesh S/Q V.R.M;.1.<:ﬂ,a;§>p€; V' " : j ' Age: 48 Lecturer In Socialogy * Panchajanya Pre University C-Qliege Rajajinagar, Ba11ga}0:*:-;.._V V Smt. Veséena Sharjna Sa.f;y"-zaﬁaragzfana W;'.Q.K.R. Shivakumar . .

Ag:3:51_ ~ _ Working As Lecttmgi" {in 'P;ng}i&f;h P.V.P Prve.{{§:<;1*'»-*&1;fsit§r' .:0i1e;g.e--I_e?_'0r ';?€cj:"ne:1 Est '~ ' 5:-3m; 'Shobhé; 'C ;'V€E3¥ M 'C'hi'kkarevanna Age:_ 411' W -- f '.A?'e3rki:1;_;; [As«&{€u::'«e3:i {:1 Cammerce P.\f;=_P Pre--E;?ni"are;fsit§; Coiiege Far Woman _ IS: N""B10cI:g:V;-.Raj_aj'if1agar Bangaidia V Sjﬁf:§.t' A:1napu1'namm.a 13/ O EVLC. Thathappa L&7"3C{1II"€I' in Psliti-cal Scienca 'A P."~f..P ~§~':*ewUr:§v€rsii.}:' Coﬁege Fer Wmmeia 1:275: "B1:>{:k., Rajajinagai"

Eﬁigfzgfaziere ; Smt- Ga§;a§:§nz°§ E98. D/Q K. Sarangaparzi Age: 55 Working As Lecturer In History P.V.P Pre--University Ceﬂege For VVGl'1'i€1'3 1$t ZN Block, Rajajinagar Bangalore

38.

19.

23. Z}.

§i3."

Smt. Ahzliyadevi SD.

D/G SD. De-xzadas Age: 48 'N0rE<:_ing;f Asa Lc-:r::tu:*<3r In Kannada P.V._¥' Pr€~Univer$ity College Fer Women 1st Block, Rajajinagar Bangalore:

Secretary 1 , SriAdi<:hun{:har1agiri E.duCati§«€a Miys01'€R0aci, _ Channarayapattana 'F_5a£i1l<;_ °' _ Hassan }Z)sitri:tt. 3' V' President ._ Grama Vidyabhivrudih:'Smfigha_ ' ' Bekkalale Maddur'fa1V:',ﬁ:, ' Mandya Dgiiizfjct A S€crei.ar§} _ Pratibha-».E(i.u'%gja:,tic'»f;'--7i':'u_stA E A:as;1«:e:e * }7§{as_s9..n' 'Esist_._2:'iC:t: ' « ' - __ -- ' Secretary .

_P1'atibha' Edi-1caiiC%:i Trust gf Sa].agarIie._Road§ E{e,ssan Disirici Pé1:?.'{:»h3;j,3;1?:}73. Vidya Peetha EduC'a_.iiT0n '?ruSi.

" Is: Bkﬁck Ragfagmagar: }31§i:.ga.£<}re;

V , Se€:re£:a2.r§;-

Sa.:"x--*aja.z1ika Vidjga Samsihe Hosa Agrahara K.R.Nagara Taluk, Mysore District.

Respendems Thsse Writ Appeals are filed u/S 4 Of ihﬁ Karrzataka High Court, Act praying 1:0 set aside the ordaa' passed in the writ $2' petition n0,557:'i/2009 and wpxzos. 1 E 15962/2069 and }12G2--214;'2OG9{S~R€s] dateﬁ 20/'04/261}. WA No 3263 0? 2{)11{S~--RES) 1 8: am Nos. 553.3-29/2ox1%[ ' ' Between : .

1. {By S113 V€§§'}'ai3:Qa; * V' E6 'm~. "

The Secretary, .4 T0 Government Of K%»f1a=:a.ka," "

(Primary 8: Sﬁcandary E£1i:::ati0n}._ ' MS. Buildings, Dr. A1nb€i:';,karVVVee€i13_:,' fg Bangalore. = The CG1'fi1'I1iSS?iOE'i€§i'/Di}I'!€C{C1'i' "

Dept Of Pr€mUnivr3r:sity Edu.{:ati1@n"" " "

Sampigs: ;~:'£,;:a:§, 138th. €j:m~sS;'E.;j-_ ' 'V Ma}_i€:s_%i:3Ja.*é8;f:1, .fE5a:ig§iaar.e.j-- V ' " Appeliants Sfi. K';£\€.'E«'§2:i1j:i:1é;tha Bhait; " S/*0 Lat5é~Ka.shi Narayana Bhatt "'Agé:d»»~.4,7 Yea:'s;" Lecturer In Commerce, M,E}.S,'S.J\xi. RU" Ccsliege. 2' Ci';ik17iagé;}ur» Sift Cha.né§a$he1ia:§3;%radhj;a, " S30 Haiariah, Eiggééé $1 ':{é%a.§$,

2. A' L€{':§i.EE"Eii" in ?0E§.t,i:":aE Science? " -- H Chiknaagahuz Smt. Psi-T{.B. Jayashrets, ' W/O Motiiai Ch0Wdhary,L Aged 45 Years, Lecturer In Chémistry, * M.E3.S.S.S.M. RUB Caﬁegeg Lil

-

Chikmagaiur.

Srnt. BS. A11am':haiaksh.mi, W,/O SN. KrishmamL1rt.h§;3 Aged 4"? Years, Lecturm: In Sacieiagy, M.E.S.S.S.M. RU. Coliegé, Chikmagalur.

Sri. MS. Yathiraj, S /0 MP. Shada}iaha1fia.I::,L 4' Aged 49 Yearsg L.ec:t4ure:1"I:r; Hisiﬂfyﬁ _ M.E.S.S.S.EV{. P.T__.?f Co£1§%g€..A "

Chikmagaiur.

Sri. Effthakar Ahn1_€€:§i_.'--., A 5/ G Sages: Ahmad?

Lecttgrei' 1§3."E:idu;--_j~._ M,E.S-k..SfS.;'§y1, 1'>.::,'Tca1:f¢ge§ C'hikm.§igai1}fE:."-- -- . 2 . é ,.

S,/Ct LLa€;e D. i\%'£a3,r3.p.g;>a, Aged V? _{ Ixzcturef' in Mathematics? °Ps€i';E.8:S.S.W1';"'*§§U. cenege, Chikmaggalur, S/£3 ' L;-its: H. Rudrappa, Aged' 58 Yaarg, E.e_£§:mrc~fr 1:1 E:::a§1{2:m;{:£a " M§E.S4S,S.R:§¥ ?.U.€<>§1eg€§. = . Chikznagaézirg Smt. GP» Puahpaiatha, W/O R. Basavanna, Aged 55 Years, Principal, M.E.S.S.,S.,M. RU. College, V99 Chikm agaiur.

Ii}. The S(~:cre'£a.ry, Malnad Education Society, Chikrnagalur.

_.;;';"'R€:sp:0r:de:1t8 (By Sri. /Smi. ; H N M Prasad F01" R1-9; R10<.Sers.ze§i1L% T. = 4_ Them: \¥';*i£ ;'?x;3;3r:z:};\': are 13166 4-~0Af?tuhg€.' .1 Court Act pmying to set; aside tfm-:j order pa$sed«.iri.:_€h€'1:;frit petition 11926219 /' 20.30-{.8-ReSA}.af1d T.""'i?g*;)_._1'10:§§.38A 186% 193f,2010{S~«Rf3E3) dated O8,g"1.2'/.2010. . ' H ' WA N0. 5250:'? QI*' 2Q'1.,1'ES§-RES] Betwaen: A ' x V E. State Rep By ifgts S'€:::¢t3ﬁ.jryf "E1__ " _ ' P1*ifﬁary}iAndf*§Seé0;idar§f E;Ciucatior1 E_du_ catic'{1-£)»épaf'€;fi1ant ~ Sa£th%vaia.jgaV 'i3u.-ildings Ba:*1g4_aiore4'C§1"AA »-- "

The COfﬁ117§.iSSiOfa€f of Pubiic EI1strucii_<::r1s " 'Public Cjffices:

_ Nvrupatizunga Road V 'ti7é1fs:::ijr3 ' Ba1;}§;::--11 ::=fe~ 0} ya.) ~ _ Appﬁilanta (By S3118 V€€ff'3.§@7&, 938$} '3. Mrs Gayathri N' M W/O Malathesh Rae Aged About. 50 Years Near Sipani Hindi School Teiephonre Exchange Road. Chikmagalur 5?"? 101.

E63 Mr E?v'Ianj'u;:1a.th C E Aged A3:aou'r, 44 Y'ear:~3 Asst.Mas*ter Opp. F1921; Miiis Basaveshwara Street Jayan agar Ch1i~';memg,aEur 57? 101 Mr Narendra L , Aged Abeut 42 Years " ..

Assteh/{aster V Op F1013!' M1133 Basaveshwara ems:

Jayemagar ' ' Chikmangalur m%:»a1 1%'I0uni.afn iew Seheolf Of:f{}e:i'e1_fa£ E',d€ic'ati0n{R) idyfesilagiear-2_ Ch.i'k}§inaga.iur .37?' 101 Rep. By its Seegeiggf'-jj.' ... Respondents A Wriﬁ'VAp'p'eVa1 is filed u,/e 4 of the Karnataka High . CO§.1i'?_ A{:t.4p1*aying to set aside the order passed in the writ 'V1r;;e.f:Vi'te§<:;'h,;?1::>V;'eZ4'§;§¥L'i/2GO8{SeReS) dated 11/08/2008: e {we E36 169?': ere' [email protected]{S»=---RES} 8: WE N68; 1?G'?5»'?6;'2ﬁ1} .. Be*tween H The State Of Karnataka Rep. By its Principal Secretary H Department Of Education,

5.

(B}2'_§ Sf1uB \,r"re'é'T;'A:«"-1V_3_fJ::1.V:'*»a, 23G } '3 , ':3 M S Buidiing, Barigaiare 1 The Commisganer for Public Enstructiorzs Nrupathunga Road, Barlgalora 1 The Director Of Pubiic InStr1i<;tit§f1S'T Department Of Secandary Eduaatisn O/O Commissiorxer For --,£_3i'sbEic ' Instructions NrupathL:ng"x3;..RaOd, Bangakvre 1 The Deput:;_Direa:jE.Qrf F0r'§1ib1iE?"Efi$§i:'ﬁCtionS Chikkbaifapur Df(:=STLF:iCfC.;; ' V ChikﬂE§a:%_;1E§zg:lp7u:',.V 'Fhé"'B3.c;ic:;k Eiiucaéiiié-n Of'f:it;:-Bi' (}0WFfbi&i>;Y3 .u"a< T a43_1i;:_. _ I C'hiEi}:b'z1§.Ea§3.£}«:rV E3*1%._STi--".=:':f5{:.1:.

- K1 é Appellants 3 Qﬁhaniha WXQ H N Nagaraga Rae Ag€i:T%E%';

E?'e3{}rE:éi1§; Ass 'E'e::':2:<:2*1€:11. ~33§7{':g_?"}§i§1§§ At. Shri Azthazgza §I"=f:'twUIi§VE§FS§'€j€ Qamgazaiée Janiar C@§€g.§s;: Ctmvribiﬂéanuy V Chikkbailapur mstrict.

Smt K T Sheeiakumari W/O K N Raju Age: 44 'Working AS Asst. Teacher, Working At Shri Achatya P1'eAUnivers'1f:y

6. Sugtaanikvﬁana Higher Primary School Koratagere, Tumkur Disirict Sri. Shivagntrxa G A Aged About 43 Years, 8 /' G ékrasappa \V0rk1'ng As Assiatamt Master" A S'ugnanike:ta.na Higher Primary S§:h3:§»' Koratageri-3, 'l'u1':r1kur" District ' ' Sri.Ma}imariyappa--' _ Agedzabouz 52 Yea:_r_:gj; £_ _ S/O GK. Siddagiah Working AsJ_§ssiste_nit.,T€:ache'r ' "

Bapuji Hi.§§h¢r--Prixiaarjv'.:$=Ch¢:i@If ~-.'V ' A' Pazfagezdég? }T§'§;E}3iLE,?.E}'£S{fiCf, ' Sari. T.K'E".€aj{,2L1ﬁ9.j _ _' Pggeci 4AbQ:i{~.T€>14 Y_eéu_fS'; __ S / Q K}iishI1ap;:ra_ " b "

W03:k:«r:1gvAs -Ass.is'tai*1t Teacher ; T3a..puji Higher Primary School " Rayagadag "fu--:3<3:}<:ur District _. 2 V . " amma A '=.7,:'%g§3E:\::¥"g'3;§f;i:=::3';1'§. 52 Y€a3'S, QI%;he€:mase12 Rae 'v*£€r;z"§s:§z2gg As Head 'a.'%fE§s€r€ss§ "sJ'é;._2iay21.ka Sayaswazhzi Kaﬁnada Highs? 'T Primary Schaoi, Pazvazgaéa, V' ' Tumkui' Di5str'i<:'{ Sri RV. Venkatesh Babu Aged About 410 Years, S /O Varadaraja Shétty Working As Assistant T eacher 'SQ %fi€7 IS. The A(?<:m,mts Officer O/C) '1.'§.'1.<~3. Ac.?c01,m.t C}ene3'2.11 (A&E} PB. No New Bwildixlg Ba1'1gai(3re

6. B1<)(?k }3(i:41(?2:1£i()'1'1 Offiﬂﬁl"

Hossaciu rgzs.

C11.if,raic1z,11*g_.ga i)is3-'{ric:{', ._ {By 81': E3 '\/'e.t-érappiei, ASA) And :

2.. Sri Emmi E}21s;;:.pp21 V _ S/' O Hz11"1'L.-i?3f;:1ni.éi._pp§a1 = A . 84 Y:?2::'€-4 [S3;_:_>,11i<)':' 4C-__1'tji:5.€n-,5' V I7:1et.:i;'e;%ci "}i«::23.;:I*u:r ' « - . _' F«1';_'A'{. 4_K{4;:';dz:§;n_,1r&. ;1'L}:ik<>1za;£u Po H<):~;:_1du1-ga. Té?ifi,l'L_{ ' C 31it.r21£1'L:1rgz1- I) E mL.r;t%'1;:

'T}1é S€e«<jI:et",a1ry _Sz:ib "a?,imf;1§;':1ka J'u'r1i<>r {3<}i1eg;'e . T»"=IaE;;axE;3 .'VE'v'3{5S£1€i€L11Tk-£§é1 "§7'a11,s.E<, ' A V Chi€jr~é:._:"%inrga Dis~5i::"i{7'€:

W Res'p<>m§;s=:::f.s Memjappa N D Far R1; SE1 H N Ru dra Ku§r1.ar, far T1113 W1fi"£: Appeal is ﬂied 1.1/3 4 of the Karnataka High Court Act. pmying to set aside the order passed in the writ petition 15158/O8 dated 1/2/10 H3?' WA. NO 2243 OF' 201 1(S-RES} 8:: WA Nos. 53?'?-88/201 I B€f'ﬁ§€€ﬂ :

"I.

1..

Th€ State of Karnataka _ Represented by its Principai Saczretary V L. Dapartment of Education 5 " = M.S.B'u11c1ing Ba2'1gai0re-- 1 The Cammissioner For 'Pufbiiazz EI1sLt:;j"V:,1£:T.'I:.::::(1«é ' Nrupathunga Road ' ' ~ 5 Bangaiorew I The Director For Pubiéc §1V1:"-§trt;iC1ii»:,i:_r; ._ Bepart-:11e_:':'$.,__0f S€i:én:i2;r3z=EZ£§u::'a,t}{"%»:1 G;"Of C§j1:*1&:.i:,is;%i::S:1e:* F5E)1'" p1ﬁ)--§i(*;.i.3T'£S"E§'{1C'Ei0I1 N111 V BaI1g3f1o3féf.V1 * '" ' ' Th'e_f}i3¢eCiQf Instruction Depa£f_tm.r3I1t . 'Oi7_Pri;1*:ary Education ; 'Q/'Of Ce.Inrr1issi:'3ner F01" Pubiic Instructien " ' N;fup at.hui'1g3,._R@ad B"'-9g11gVa*~iQr€~ 1 Director For Pubiic Instructiens Bangzgigére Nerth. Districi Qoadg E%anga§0re~1G .. Appaﬂanig ' '~ (E3-3'~'§S:'§ B Veerappa, ﬁ;G,./13} S1": K R Prakash S/O Ramgaswamaiah Aged About 41 Years Working AS Physicai Education Teacher Sri. V Baiaraju S/C3 G Venkaiarama.iah Aged About 53 Years Working As Lab Agsiskant W0rkj1z1gAt. Sri. Sharada Giris High Sch00E..~«~ Doddabailapura Bangalore Rum} Districfg "

Sri' B Siddaganga S/O Bheema Naik Age& About 48 Years v Warkingzxs Head E_\»'£aster_..._ Wcyrking At Sri. C'E1€~tana' SchoQ1,DoddabaIié1pur _ _ Bangalore Rura1D:i§'_[figj; ' "

S1f_i,_VSafh'3*2i;§:;1ra§§a.r;a "

3/ O V ' 1" = E;5.R3.:i*ga§sx?s%a:1*13r _ Aged Ab§*a';:*».5'i% ., ' Working AS 'i'3§1ySi£;éE. jfeacher ¥V0fi;ir1ggAi' Sfi, Ciict F121 Higher Primary .Sc:hc::n:3i, Vbasciéiabvaliéipér , Banga1o r<~aR§1ra1 Dist {jet ».?%*:¢~:1:akum&ri M V' « D";'«C_r v.X3'e:.~¢3:1'a11 agaiah Ageéf "gﬁfijaut 38 Y€2i."£"S 'éﬁi-' 0r}é;i%1g {KS Assistant §\£Eis'{.resS E1?' <_;é1:'§<:;ing At Sr; Cheiana E-Eégher Pyimziry " Stihiéei, Badﬁabaiiapur B3::ag2::.E:}I°€ Rafa} §}:i.S%;r§<:E S1': A Jayaram S / O Anjinappa Aged About 49 Years Wo1rk:i.r:g As Asssistant Teacher Sri. Kongadiyappa High Schooi Doddaballapur

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court