Karnataka High Court
Ashok S/O Yallappa Gaji And Ors vs The Registrar & Ors on 28 February, 2020
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2020
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
WRIT PETITION NOS.214089-093/2020
& NOS. 214094-188/2020 (CS-EL/M)
Between:
1) Ashok S/o Yallappa Gaji
Age: 41 Years, Occ: Government Teacher
R/o Gomarsi Tq: Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
2) Hanumappa B Hagedal S/o Basappa
51 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sasalamari
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
3) Basappa Helavar S/o Irasangappa
54 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sasalamari Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
4) Shranappa S Marigoudra S/o Siddalingappa Gouda
55 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sasalamari
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
5) Amaresh Gudadur S/o Basappa
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At Hatti
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
6) Shivakumar A S/o Anjiniyappa
32 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Virupapur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
7) Shanthi S/o Herehanumantappa
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Aralahalli
2
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
8) Amrutarao S/o Hanumantaray
57 Years, Govt. Teacher At Thippanahatti
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
9) Basavaraj Angadi S/o Erappa
53 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
10) Kotappa S/o Chinnagiri
54 Years, Govt. Teacher At Haretanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
11) Veeresh Salimath S/o Neelakanthayya
54 Years, Govt. Teacher At Hosalli Ej
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
12) Srisailappa Koudi S/o Gangappa
53 Years, Govt. Teacher At HPS Nidigol
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
13) Basappa M Gurikar S/o Marithimmappa
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At Hatti
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
14) Sumangala S/o Hanumantappa
56 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
15) Somanna Vadakannavar S/o Veerabhadrappa
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
16) Veerabhadrappa Japal S/o Shivaputrappa
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At Bhutaladinni
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
17) Rudrumuni S/o Karibasayya
48 Years, Govt. Teacher At Meranal
3
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
18) Yankappa Bergi S/o Hanumappa
44 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
19) Basavraj S/o Neelakantappa
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Gomarsi
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
20) Shekharagouda S/o Betagowda
40 Years, Govt. Teacher At Srinivas Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
21) Hanumappa S/o Gangappa
56 Years, Govt. Teacher At Hasamakall
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
22) Mallappa Lamani S/o Erappa
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sidrampura
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
23) Mallappa S/o Gulappa
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
24) Chandravathi S/o Ningappa
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At Hosalli
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
25) Siddappa K S/o Ningappa
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At Jangamara Hatti
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
26) Amaresha S/o Ningappa
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Thippanahatti
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
27) Mahadevappa S S/o Kariyappa S
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At Srinivas Camp
4
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
28) Gangadhar R K S/o Kannappa R
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At Hoslli Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
29) Sridevi S Talavar S/o Shivappa
32 Years, Govt. Teacher At Chirtanal
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
30) Dhareppa Basarkod S/o Shekhappa
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Chirtanal
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
31) Hanumantharao S/o Manikrao
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At Pagadadinni
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
32) Geetabai S/o Venkobarao
42 Years, Govt. Teacher At Veerapur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
33) Smt Seeta S/o Ranganatha Achar
46 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sripuram Junction
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
34) Pranesh S/o Srinivas Rao
56 Years, Govt. Teacher At Mullur Camp Ej
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
35) M Krishtacharya S/o M Bhimacharya
53 Years, Govt. Teacher At Kanihal
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
36) Kaveri S/o Venkatesharao
44 Years, Govt. Teacher At Gudamma Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
37) Usha Np S/o Prasad K
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Gomarsi
5
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
38) M Parvathi S/o Mounesha
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At Gorebal Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
39) Govinda Gouda S/o Hanumappa
45 Years, Govt. Teacher At Ganga Nagar
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
40) Sujata S/o Shivananda
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Ganga Nagar
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
41) Shanta S/o Sangamesha
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At Ganga Nagar
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
42) Shivappa Navi S/o Siddppa Navi
54 Years, Govt. Teacher At Malkapur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
43) Basavaraja Halli S/o Pampanna Halli
51 Years, Govt. Teacher At Virupapur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
44) Hanumantappa Talavar S/o Rudrappa Talavar
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At B Venkateshwar Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
45) Manjunathayya K G S/o Jamunathayya
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At B Venkateshwar Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
46) Padmanabha K S/o Prahalad K
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At Malkapur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
47) Yamanappa S/o Tippanna
43 Years, Govt. Teacher At Parapur
6
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
48) Lachamappa S/o Karekallappa
51 Years, Govt. Teacher At 3mile Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
49) Hanumantappa S/o Pampanna
45 Years, Govt. Teacher At
Uppaladoddi R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
50) Amaramma S/o Hanumappa
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At Uppaladoddi
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
51) Basavaraja S/o Bhimappa
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Dhadesugur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
52) Raghavendra S/o Hanumantappa
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Marithinagar
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
53) Vijayalakshmi Savanur S/o Sangappa
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At Basapur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
54) Ashok K C S/o Chandrappa
37 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sindrampur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
55) Harish B N S/o Narayanappa B
31 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sindrampur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
56) Manjunathayya K G S/o Hanumantappa Hosamani
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sindrampur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
57) Mahantesha B S/o Obaih B
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sindrampur
7
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
58) Hanumappa Sindhigi S/o Basappa
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Bheebaraj Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
59) Malappa Barsi S/o Ayyappa Barsi
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Basapur K
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
60) Eresh Naik S/o Manja Naik
32 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Mavinamadugu
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
61) Durugappa K S/o Mariyappa
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Channalli
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
62) Vasant Kumar S/o Eshapp
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Basapur K
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
63) Manjunath K S/o Adangouda
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Basapur K
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
64) Vijayalakshmi W/O Sangappa
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Basapur K
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
65) Prashant Kumar S/o Basavaraj K G
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Basapur K
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
66) Mahadevamma S/o Nataraj
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Jalihal
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
67) Nataraj S/o Nagarjapp
39 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Hanchinal Camp K
8
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
68) Lakshmana S/o Parasappa
32 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Basapur K
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
69) Mallappa S/o Erappa Avanni
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sindrampur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
70) Shambulinga Patted S/o Mahadevappa
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At
GHPS Sindrampur R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
71) Rajivreddy Soppireddy S/o Hanumareddy
36 Years, Govt. Teacher At
GHPS Channalli R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
72) Eshappa S/o Lakshmana
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At CRP Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
73) Nagappa S/o Somappa
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Rh No 03
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
74) Sulochana S/o Gopal
42 Years, Govt. Teacher At Khadiriyakalony
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
75) Ambamma W/O Konanagouda
45 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Sukalpete
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
76) Basappa G S/o Gurappa
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Karadu Chilumi
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
77) Devegouda S/o Mallikarjun
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At GHPS Roudakunda
9
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
78) Vijayalakshmi W/O Jagadish
32 Years, Govt. Teacher At Khadiriyakalony
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
79) Shobha W/O Venkatarao K
37 Years, Govt. Teacher At Aragina Mara Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
80) Jayasudha W/O Ramappa
32 Years, Govt. Teacher At Udbal U
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
81) Vidya H N W/O Hanumanta Gouda
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sasalamari
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
82) Kapaleppa S/o Chandappa
52 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sultanpura
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
83) Duggesh Br S/o Ramanna
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At Mavinamdagu
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
84) Savantravva W/O Veerappa
48 Years, Govt. Teacher At B Venkateshwar Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
85) Radha W/O Manjanna
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sasalamari
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
86) Saroja Devi G Patil W/O Gurunagouda
50 Years, Govt. Teacher At Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
87) Manjula G C W/O Chandrappa
33 Years, Govt. Teacher At Venkateshwara Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
10
88) Shashikala R W/O Ramanaik
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At S V Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
89) Savitri W/O Arjunarao
50 Years, Govt. Teacher At Kanaka Nagar
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
90) Saraswatamma W/O Lakshmayyak
48 Years, Govt. Teacher At Dhadesugur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
91) Durugappa S/o Mariyappa
49 Years, Govt. Teacher At Channalli
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
92) Ereshappa S/o Dyavappa K
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Dhadesugur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
93) Murthy K S/o Mallappa K
38 Years, Govt. Teacher At Dhadesugur
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
94) Nemeshappa S/o Ningappa K
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At Valabellari
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
95) Lakshamayyasalimata S/o Ramayya E Salimat
45 Years, Govt. Teacher At Uppala
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
96) Vijayalakshmi Teggi W/O Erappa
34 Years, Govt. Teacher At Turvihala
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
97) Gopal S/o Hanumayya K
35 Years, Govt. Teacher At S V Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
11
98) Bhaskar M Pattar S/o Manappa K
55 Years, Govt. Teacher At Kengal
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
99) Ramappa Bhajantri S/o Hanumappa
48 Years, Govt. Teacher At Uppala
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
100) Yallanagaouda S/o Sangangouda Patil
51 Years, Govt. Teacher At Syndicate Camp
R/o Sindhanur Dist: Raichur.
...Petitioners
(By Sri. Shivakumar Tengli & Subhash Mallapur, Advocates)
AND:
1) The Registrar
Of Cooperative Societies
Ali Askar Road,
Bangalore-560001
2) The Secretary
Government of Karnataka
Department of Cooperative Societies
Vidhan Soudha,
Bangalore-560001
3) The Joint Registrar
Cooperative Societies,
Raichur-584101.
4) The Deputy Registrar
Cooperative Society,
Raichur-584101.
12
5) The Voter List Verification Officer
Senior Inspector, Cooperative
Societies Department, Sindhanur
O/o Assistant Registrar of
Cooperative Societies
Dist: Raichur-584128.
6) The Secretary
Sindhanur Taluka Prathamika Shala
Shikshakara Pattina Sahakara Sangha Ltd.,
Sindhanur Tq: Sindhanur
Dist: Raichur-584128.
7) The Returning Officer
Sindhanur Taluka Prathamika
Shala Shikshakara Pattina
Sahakara Sangha Ltd.,
Head Master, Govt. High School,
Ambamatha
Tq: Sindhanur Dist: Raichur-584128.
... Respondents
(By Sri K.M.Ghate, AGA for R1-5)
These writ petitions are filed under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India praying to declare that
Section 20(2) (a-iv) and (a-v) of Karnataka Co-operative
Societies Act-1959 is ulltravirus and unconstitutional and
lacks legislative competency in view of Article-243 ZI and
243 ZO constitution of India and etc.
These petitions coming on for orders this day, the
Court made the following:-
13
ORDER
The counsel for petitioners has filed a memo dated 28.02.2020 requesting the Court to dismiss the writ petitions as withdrawn.
Memo is placed on record. Accordingly, writ petitions are dismissed as withdrawn.
SD/-
JUDGE *MK