Karnataka High Court
M/S Jmc Projects (India) Limited vs The State Of Karnataka on 3 November, 2010
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
I 3*? TEE §'§G}:i €C§G{}§é"'3' £3? Kfi§i?'¥A'§'&E§;§z 3%'? 3&3 msym TE-{ES mg 3% ms' fifié?' §€Z§'~s'E THE i+EQ?¥*ELE W, ..§'i.:§S*§'§€::§ &3i'§=:G=§: :32. mi? PE'§°E"§"IG};'€ rams §$§?%@§%§§1%$%%gméggg war? FETETEGE :q:3%.:§¢:«§:é~F§:§* :'§€.§'§§'*' WEE'? FE'E'I'I'IGE¥ z»s€>;%3k::% s§a: @213 ;;:m:L §'§'-RE8E WEI'? ?E1'Ef?EQ2§7.§§€§.:-;'§;:3§§;%§a§.§£ §? 22325 EEWE§E§*§-.
35; 3.333% §=R>c~..:E$%'m§ L£%"§°EE mm TQWER, 23:3. 5% 2%é.e?'§:>m$& 1*€E$mEI%'3""':.'?'f._§R*{i*:,.§s.fi> % M , mg:§§;»AaL§1%E;:s5s:::v£:*2§g (REgF.i_%':E3E:§§"I*§.§E17 53* gm aw " .%3a"2¢.:.':v;;;rr*:%;%cA;, pmm' ~§--=:; * §E%'§."-E"§"§fi?<€E& M' " 9' *mE3m:&;1*E <3? mm gsagammé' 3% fiwfi 1-"im-§rmz%3} mm EERS? figazag .4.-.................. V ";i;'§<E?; $3" 33 QE SE€I«§E'§'§s_K':'; V Qfiifflfié E;fi§%I,«fiEE-5&3 5% L fifiiffi; fix agyyzfififiz, (arm. 3 2; smm-E mm §Ef$F{"}E%§ZEiE€"§E ififififiéfi' E Bfififfi ?EE'i'i"1$E€S} 153?: SEE Z1 £ at' ECGEE T2;
wag' ysmzmaf 3§c:s.33.35'z;2§;§ aim 3r%2_.:«§§:';ifii.€:
yam vgmaztg miagg 22% am 22?.~«~~--{}§'~.__§'f§*§€E m:%$'§*rr:;?:<:%z% G? 3931;. Ffifffififigfi ?;z;j;»am:*1:3% 1 $1333? gs; FQR €;3Q1'§'f§'¥§A'§'§§E§ :::2§ mg §::§m;§::V €1*iE?"$_'i'§ff"" _ QRAHEEB 3? THE E&R§EEfiE§.§fi%§i£%?E T§§§§L, mama 3395;; magg 2323 'ml, 'STE-§E,,.;B§j§P"Q$,§;L_ s:s§:=A.i%:%1a::§%: I A?FEAL §Ei'§ESTERE§ as gm 2;z%s;g%2~{; 3343,: $3? %%2é;z:§%%.L mzg 3? mg FEf§"i'i"E€}£%ER.='§§$§E§f€._'JE_'?;}E .§:E{¥:§{?'%§{£§§§§E~fi§ A% E353.
'war? 9§s:I'*:=*f:m2€~...§$3;;3"§&§a:;§'§.:§ M23" 34532.- fifiéflfilfi ARE §*§E§ $33322 s;j;ai?§::§;§«,%:AA'i2§;§ arm 22'? 3? THE C@E°¥$T'£';€"£}"FIG2€ $§'* '?%i?T:?§fEG?%§E§:: ?§A'.z'§Q -':23 ISSUE 9;. 3F{.A":.:E?€?:$:§:;a§:'v_{}§v" am {@332 .§;p9mpR:mE}rs;*:i§_rr-- as Ei§_£$§:E§Y 'i:.'s~:'2.r1;§a_ié §§RE€TE€3?é' am «.@%;;:::§g@::: $3:
PEEL-E3@§'fi,§'§*'§+§é7;RI¥{§~TfE-{E3 my; TEE cézsgm? ~ 33% §*€}§,Egi'}1£'f§~§€;'3:§V-~ % k §§m§§ $235 immfi ficvarzzmfigat in taim nazfim far €315 rfigazfienmg
-$352 yefiggm §%°$§,3§;;3;'§'?'{§§E£§$ §*$§1£':~f2§§;$ % fiéség ?e%:it£e:: §:::2s..'§ 1333; mm 34532---55é;2::1§ hwré tfigfithm azzzé are éiswamé 52? T -by ikia msfimmm away, 3.3 ihgy fmsm fix game: =iE§2"1g% 'aeffim 3;--=5: 2:" éygeififizs {'K§£;3§'1,* fag' simrigx €233.
' 'V " ~ . A. V aka:
3 3 33% :2; ..
-' {E2-fig iiéaa: Ecamefi cawwi far tha §£'¥:if;§§m:fir smkmiia rim? the §$t§*t?5x3:_§11!,$§:*?;s ~ % $,'§fi.§a,2%E@$,2§88»i2:§§l§ 2c<:e:; £X3TE'm3:§fi%'fi§IifiZ'1 mam tha §{§fi.T. safié 3L. "' 2 the Emfii mg aim granm ir:f;¢:i%'i'z21:§z*s;é;1isz;**':r;*s:i'~'é§*:4;"2'7'§'«s4*.' ::V-T'-.§f:v€-'.:' mm szzhmita aim the gzaesrmmt :3? {km amm.mt;__i;'1 {Ea bank gnmazime far A3 §€$§;f§'; rm am gmwaf €5%j%:§¢a.m%%::::ax¥i;n%%s§:;£g;r smiy fat 2.3% §a}=E§ samrzfi zmgmfiezzt is r@m;ting fgfi éf fizz: ameaznts. '§.v. Li$a*i ' Em Eaasrzifi fin fiaimif 9%' '&m mtiiiam muéalg Em ea ézrms aim': in firm §€.é%ffi ta fiisgage sf '~?'.3f3§ matter as asgzmégitfmugiy $3 gaaagihéafi = L % G1': :2 §€§':.§rt
-- : ézémsatmg Ea? thza wmfiezfi vémas fiat the fiififi 9%" gusiim wmzfifi ' 1% 13%: by §%$£23g ma féfifiwfifi §:*&é:2_f*:»« 8851 é gag mg Eijafii is fiimsixi m ééggsase afr,a, §§s.§§88«-L233. 2; 2::;:;::<--:; L Q eyzwzfiiiauaiy as maaifiki Eb; ms §%'fi%i<':=::&r is &%:rsm m*;iT 3;? %A mfi Emmy g:a%r:'%m in '-rzf fifty garwat.' af fiiswsai 53$ fifié _ za: Su%ié~f:i '%j~e4am.y%yéx% the £39: rmsrt in """ H imiifi mg L % fifmfigasgggga 33::£m*9k 'A QR, r%1}.Et§ fimafi writ gafifimaa are ag fig mats.
3&5 Iii"d§§ A " ma