Karnataka High Court
Jyoti Limited vs Rns Infrastructure Ltd., on 16 October, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
w
«E U E} {E E'? "§'
""§'."§1:i §3§a§m'f.ifi" '£;3»?-:§"=r;::,'r3 11:63. Ilriai. 39:13:' V.
-3"
st':
wazaa r:=::;a:==<:i::5::i; §;A;§*€{r-LE
.173
{§*:1;3:::::'a:7=; §§1_§¥.§fl€i'.iQ{}. :{i'€€s;%3*a§:':-§;:"&g<;§{2: T::::"i23::%:$.~_1 f:'r:s::t:§
'1'!
C€}IIEZ11i.§.?§§_§3 Bay' %3:'r€.a=:§i 'C213 A{hafE:jé3§.:i§-Fésziéfigaz .e5;$€E'2'J.€."Ef:3f§';:{
v_§=:=:¥3t:_;7§£%.r; :§.€+§€::{1a_:3:£i3-i
s«§,:i:é_:i~:*:sg §az1j:;f_ §§~3_§z"::--?' §%1.j§}{}§§i'3fE' €33 g:::c5:=:*§'::,1:*z:::
£336 :}§.é;§::%i§i";<§ .:s"3"«. éK:0z*k ué_I.r1£_'§ Li¥.;§'i§:';s.3 3=r;=%;¢*';1: €:_::.=
E' V 3 ¢ ._ , 3'?"
restraénfijizéé fi32::VfI§_i;.%jV:;';:F:iE14:§1é;%:§§z;i?:!1 f3:::s1::: s§*:«3;2:§:1g2; a;r_s§3:'{§¥a_'§
a113,? f§"§:1.%r<:§ :a;p;§::e:¥ he 3."g3§;r~<3ém;${§. 333; ::i5f:=,*.:':c§a:':'%:3~
hzée; 3;; Smitrzzzgi 27,2" iibti: ; M:_*;::::::~:~€:% Jf ':i':%1§§t-.
3:*s:'§::*;_:: _§:§§"?ifA.f~"5{§"1;E*£§ 'i:_'i:1& f€?~3i.J£§'§"_§1 z*€:§§}:::1{%.§::!:E ---» §=:&":1::4j£a§§e;
V"'§§&t:3r§:§:3.;'E - §'s§§9;;:_m EATKE. {£<§§'§,'<Ei=} "f§'£§'S'?;_§.§£j§§ :";.:3Ei;§<:.€ %_m.:i§§:';§«:
" ééxizfisér an Fj:?{;"'l §T's_1§*_:": E-<:e},!} E3a.~3:iS daifid $2; §:2gi£*:€;§f}£3 f::;:~
= ...f:$:E:;£ $:,::*'%;*:i%fs;, =;3:"z§T;':§<eri:'1g§ giasigzig ¥::§.=*::£rm:._§§:: s%:.:,:§é:::$§
::";:»:§1:_1f:;"<s;*i:im'=:g ggsrgxgzéfgg E-1§'=..'€:§'g:»§?ug:~}§'.E? cemmiasémziisg a;r:<:i {ifs £5
E?! _i:*:c§z.:di:3.§ s'iT{E}"3J;§:§E'€_.§€'f§i,§.§;'1"2 0? §:e:::::%;;; §':e:m:s:~.a<:*:5,i":3 3:7: Eift :2
'x
i:r,'%1¢=~s_:.£3: agisaais as;§,;:,1"i&2;r:t:i by figs ezffifizi :'sa3:<§é%.:E" .3:fi'%::-:=; ':;§'§:«;E
<3? *
iv;
.12"-
*E'?'~/§f'.'i :3?' *»:«;a§:»':§ fr«:*»m Shatira §?<':3.§:e€::r:::i:'* £16} cié:t§.§2Ie:*f§
C§'2£%§L§'}t3§" fifiéii" fia_§§5::1§;:§2"3; :.m.a:"'§::::' :,:;:::§:§€.2' Bivzazira Lift.
Eifigaéafl $£*.§1<:'.m€:. {@318 ;):"r:g§r":::?§.' 3:3 :~_':h::2r§'.} a,::%:§_ "Tim:
géawézztfif, bfiizzg GEE {sf é:;§1::=. iaaééizgg :;3::3m;% :::15,3:.z:;*i'3ga?§._é,¥;:f%3:"S.'
1:"; {E16 €::::a::.:.m:s; hEl§?§fl§_{ vafit. §X3;1%§'t1'§f3I'i€§$ b--:E'.E3.§;1'<i
§_1:i::r- 3 303:1': 1..-*"€:§1*1r.u1'r:*: égrseygzézzé: {-7.E.'.'»;L%.'§ aviéjii %ii%:f':;.;1.;§'f;%v:1=$:¢~vL-E.
-3 ami i:.E:1<:% bid <::§§er:3:r31 by i}:?.& §..7%'u*'sE,,:-z:?§5:i¢§:.
this gééaizztifi" 311:1 dfiffiffiéiaflifir'-E $33 a<::€é€;3fe:":%'£§. €315: .'
f::3m"'4*.'_':"3 :;§}Ef€::§?._5::":i". 31$ $3533' W L¢3§'.i%:;r {sf
9»
15:, §€'.'3}'2€}£}8;
3 Egg 522;?'*fTf;5§;a::..:~:a::%~4T;.?2';"€Z'% "<::_§ ijhasé €}€i?E".§:€??':§'9_§ £f1f:r3:":§§§t%;§:3:::~3 =35
éiiagaé {Tf:3::§2"'3.i::--.>§: §'€§§;fsif;%;'~fm§..9:%3:..-'é:_:ca::£3's§f:.:1 '%3i%_;{§::%:" 25»-*3_3 :'€:.:*g:_.z.?r€:::%
F4
" v 'ta ¥;:ra§":E§----->é,§:5;'ara:":§::&£: aaqzziazgjazzi 2:8 s::s'f' i:.E;;::*
3;: z'i:::?g::v%E9%;*M;%;,:V'w:g-é zszéiéfzifl fiéifiziié éiéiféfigii fmzzz §"§"'£t:' :;*::*:::*.€:i;::*': «sf E1216
Vgwfi
vi._,,»,;
-
W3:
2
'2':;é~;. vs? iéfiffiiliififiig hs::=:éé:z'2.g '%:::a:é_ Z"§§if?:§E3§i?§3--'§} r._§':.:;%;':3i$:§";.:§=:§ E333 §3:a,r:§«: ga§:s,a:";:§§.§"z§$s: 253:": ibfihaéf 3:' 33:3 {E36 t:".3§§i&E' "«.'%§'3gZé; bfiiffi .§:'1:;:§:_z€:§§"::{3-:§ fizéz Q-§a%;§3.2:§ff anzé {ha {,*.:':e§::::"a<':.€ 2=;?'§.:a$ $§g;§:§':::%{i £3311 L358» §.f.T§;'2{}€}8 heixzméiéa €323 fag: aiafaaéazéi r€;3§'§:3€:1¥:i:;§ §.'§2€: :'i:s3:§'1€:'t}' 315%; 1: a:*§:::$r*5s 331:? 1321:? §é:z's_::"I:E":
}:
N Wéféaitrivi V' C30 r:_'ae.fz_>;%..:;§t in :'§;<'~:;;3:*:€=.<.?%:: av?" its £:;%3§:g9.€?§;.§:": '§..';.§f§€C§fii' é:};;=f:
1..
.5z:;::i "éhéz ;:siai::%:§i§ §3&§:':g«:, ifi%3:':::::<1 E32?' %;:}::€.. mm %;§:a=: E't':'?"§'¥,I§.§:'f':fl':fj§,"1§". $3'? §a_.:3';3..§$§":i11g -%:x*,:t_:a§:;::a;s:fx:i£:é§é.,_'t;'§";s:%'._V V 'g)ia%_:":i;i:"§" iéiai :':{::I': 3:3 a§1«::"§ %;1a2;§;?<: is-h<i=: f§'Ssf_ ':}-£T:'€?:1;<{a. itaacj giszaiz Suffi:::';«::;3.%_ time is i:§%j}§=?: ?;{.'3v '*';?.ii%:?:*:§':i¥~:<E,".: ' §§1:"::
§3s;"11<: g§uarm1€:§z=:., 9:31:21. 3:335 i£5B;$ §€:sg;:0:é_:<§é;zi- :23 311$" i:_Lx:'. piajmléif gmazifi %;§:¢:%:'e_§'-',:am{ t.§f;é€:% $3 MAL! _, iiégéziéazga in :::::*:%r:r i:=::.s 331%: the §.&t€:.m:"'«.._é:§'_f. §:.a'€1i~.°'_--'£;<:s 'fi;:y§1i$i": {ha 33:
$1.,-A;;:':3._r:':€&% ééxzezfi " "' " "§ 2}:3rf_i<:-1?; <2}? :31' ffgisi: .;;é"§é3.§3'zti_§f. é;:'::_"'§§ €:Z:2::*::':%i;{3'£ _, 5:}? fizz? , ., ra:.:éé.:.:;:3V:'":'r:>2': ..{;z§§§".':3.?3, féraé: r:.§::=§'€§1gi3;§*gE.;, 1.1%: *'3I§3§f.§i"¥3 :¥??..::%:§3§7.,';=a=*§a.:~;i:i E=1aé%é?; §3::&:": 1::-:'=.A:? sxrgi 33 th. -q.§"%;*'§'a aisgi; H33:-s:tef. 0? '¥';j§:';,e {?€§}'£E'{}.'fiiff'§i sfiaizéz-:'%. ""i2jf:i~;'_§A'§};§§.i§iZ'§8§ fiffiii aiafezzfiéagzi: wiagfi 'E:§:«:~.:*§f:::s:':: ,§L1$%:§.fieé E3} §;3.~'::::s:'23%i'%::~g~§--""i3§e.:,1;'~;e-3if} zzsf iéjgs e}¥f"_s% 9:3 the :"::E;§::;m Sf €335; §3§fi<§§3€:*§'x;a}a;g 32:93:: fhai ah? §3'$§Z dfifaszéggfiii a:"*.s:%z.:§::i 2:423: .§';:;-W3 in i:'Ei'fX€3€313i§.£}E} es? the '§3I'Q§f3{"€l wéziztiz 33323:; haii *5 fig V' "'%;:~uE3Ei:: _%.::§:€sra3*:si: %;:rei;3.1gi, T§§§*§€.%§.'é?€§§ in ii. E.'2:':r,i«*::* Eiiaésgfi €"f§§"{§§}_§3};'S§Z§3"£€3fiS§ ELE ffiiififfi 5:-;::s::sg'f:i;". fin" E}? fizzy? §A§::§.;r:v.;'i_} '?z'.§:a:'&f{§:':f;: ::%s:x::§.¥, §:é::s'§ $34': §§;'3.EZ¥.'i'TiF',1{§4 .rfiE%£é:"3,<§ga.1_1§ §:::§; "'§tE.3 ifififfif' {§a§.e.{'E_ -ifs; §2..2€}€kT¥8 {:3 <::::;i3:;:pij§}'