Gujarat High Court
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL/374/2010 on 9 March, 2010
Author: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Bench: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����U8r?D ? ?�W?%? ????e???? ? ?z%!5?? (b ???h}??3???9vA?? ? ?T?L"?3? x? ?/?_p???w?pf?TPR? ??>5?| W?? [??? 0 ? ?�?'??J ?? ?h\P?hwf F? ;b5?? |,?[?E?[%~} `%?JU?8'??zU ;?D? ??-????^;??R??4 ?hb?NaS?d"c?[Z?Q?? I@??? ??%???(Y?Y??)??? ?k?i?v?z?? T\??/i?4{P??1SY?=???? ?
??t??n ??$F0>g?
? )N?n?[?#?y?X9F%hv?" ??#???#/??[?w.J ?????Q ]&??"??-Rq??e? ?`A1?sy ??1?-a?a-f k?m ?j????7 ???X.?????r? iL??:??$? ? ??A?q?` ?(hs?2??}lJ.??-??sJ??~ ??Jv??J^??????u?_?? ?p:?.7??R?:? ?`d^??&T???4 ??0????w Qy >?--?N???>?? Tr?h?J????? ???
?Z}???|??g2???? ?Y??$0 ??q?*????/?I???(L??`N*r ?3G?`?m??={???. C??4??????w?
r3??s>????m_???#?{?F?F?W ??o:?;?c?i?6r????QKN? ?R?^?y??Q?$[?} ????=?tK?p{$G74+,?XAf?0??ja???5??? ? v| ?W?!?h? ?F#hkn??_?3@????nf ?, P??Q ??E??FnSX?NN" ?? ? ????? ?QW ?H? A< _? (?z? ? -?@?K W *H?,F ?Z^?UHt?M&] ?? ??8B ?< d?|?$?? ??@?J?z ?? T?-?:?A?j$?$??8?Kxy�Y?
~ ??c ?L??T??:?}?& T??h??? ? ?
?�?" ?$??j???Z&d?
u?m?C??? ?K ?Hb? Y??? ???#"f? ??"?$l??>????"??U?? V?Pid|???PK ?k? ? ��?-��PK � � �U8r<������������ ���styles.xml?ZK??6 ??W *?SeI~????4m? 4H6@??D?l$Q )???;$E?L??f??9 0??p8?
gH???$ l1&?N0? NC ?t}?|y|?S? ^?J??.?a??T?\ b? 09?wZx?l???? ?q%U?? ?qSu??8 l?Xq L? ????j??z %iI?A -0$? ?I?�g;W????r5?8??? ?a? ???F??||?? 2\ ?;?`:???N? 0??Gk&u??
????\?K?e,?[ }?? ?\/? ???oU? 4???e?? qh< ?fI??j? ; ?O?????|h0?M? ??f>?? ?h'`( ?S?
?Q ? ??j|l F?T T~S?NGm ?????y?m}6?i ^??o ?G? ?i?
?]?
?+?s?]bp???`???
C+?V?B?l?5e5??8?c??`4?z�U?????c??# ???[^?^ ?,?QK?v ??YXC????^l?H????6*n????,?O????4 ? ?m?? (i>n?;??y7} ??u??B??? Q JM?Oe???Y?\???Tj|@?Y<||?o'?? | 4WCSp? ? ??
8?P ?u5g?V9???Mj: ^M???a?S?p??}}??OUW?????r?P?:)x5w????G??A?? ??Vl=?-? PK t?Q?? ��.'��PK �����U8r OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 das 2010-03-18T12:32:43 1 PT1S PK � � �U8r<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??eT[Q?.
? (Nq?`?] Z?xiqw w ??R? ? ??XpKK??.?=??9?;???^? ??????k??j? >?}???A )?? ? ?O??.?$ 00????
??? ??[) nP?H?2??`Pfj y=?u b[ SVZ? ????c??m?Y-???>???Y ? ?U? T??OO???z n?; ??????=? ??:j??�? ? z?4??q???n??mZ? I??? U ??? ?????g??W?? ?q Y%??(~(?kp?? U?????r^| sr.UM?????5k M?? ~???-&??_zs3 ?7[? ??'?f?@$??}??b???s?v??w ?\8?G?p???c r?o 5 6?w??x]g?1????nk???|??Q)??C'???-1 ?( ?Q?^it??/???? g)???/&???y4??=(? _?^??H'???+~=w??^?}x? ?je[& zw? ? ?UOL?vA ? w ?? ?2?jZ?E?v? ??j?qgq??X|?0?{?u??:rW't/?q@? A?3?b? ???r:7? ? ^6?.I{?????/??B**$??L?^?y?? q? ?p1;???rTC?????'??? g 9?!w? ? N ? ^?crg-?? !w??n???B?:??"r7C:?(??Yf]p??U J??a?h,??????_�2? t?u?ZQ i????? ??+5??p{?F?Q? >? ??-?v?? ? ? v 4????-m?B ?g?e~hI,?"O?{r?? ?n??t[?r????nr7?????J ?t?;g4?v??uN ?!#Bt??od??#\?4??@L?bW ??U?U????Q?G 3?2??i? \?2I? ? ?J?l;??Ls ? ?T?5S& ???1?? !4 ?< * ??FQY?C.>[JE n?/? g????A???? 39tvA? ??l?k???J[?D?Os??Ng???M?? ??? ??3mDvW 3x ?? ?4??? ?8^ L ?~?>"t+?sj� ?5 R?? c}q??$zn?$>(t???\ ??]?bI?F?+?l6?d?y?-\???O?-?_?k9?j{???_ \????5?9?F ? ?? N?2 ?s[?=[@ A? Lf) U?9?F t ?=?? [} ???T??qBdB??|?? ??
? n? ?;??[ ?? ?+Qt g???! ?
??FD ?.? ? s?XA? v3H#?]y?Q??j K?C~{<??eq??L ?Q ?? { - ?)?Ka|??]?????
4? *?O?Q?^?Nn+!???r ??)?n??$??}??E? ??? =? T?2?M?C???R$??? R??'?*%?`? ??SC?S??t?}9S%*??s?~ ???J1D!? ??+n? ?i;DN?e7??? !W?w?=LU ?+?#@???|?Pa?e?K??O?A?y??2?9r????T%"!l#?V??=??Z??Z? ???\??W??`G Y? ?d_!?'??I?? ?%????�????k? ^?? ??7??"? ??{'~ Y?'?\?EC;?q? B? ?OR C??x] w ??? 6 ??w?1L??_"?I tL? ? ??f??????? ??f??q=/-?wd???y?)T?6m?0O??N ?/ ?}gahH???k??^|???? ??;???h? +?k?C?I?I?? ?`?8g??c[?kY? j#\?????o?g?]a??H i?w?? kd?? 4?H?i\D??,?!B?P]AW?rws ?SjL??w$?hXv? ?, 7T'???jJC z^????Oc? z/ ?&?? cQNd?'? ?g^s+\? ??ma ?|???
? ????\ ?!jy&?xg??5:gmn?? ?1dN6????| ??yW f [R??!]??7kA?z9?D,?:?,e^? x&n??B?? `? ^? Ws?KWy?y?_?/M??Ee? �~8?G?� ?? ??r?E???`?mgj?? e u6\? ?y{"? ? ??z?]?X ?y?=???6??xY Zb??"???
?? ,zX???bU(a ?1I?? ? B?? 6 ?N???&?W? ? s?*`G ???.k??_ 2?:ol? A???? ?.??op ???t??EK??m??ng{????t?? ? )???4?:?C?2 ???%F?fH?0?t?~y?????1 p????
yo{? {WW?dz???U7?,_Yl?????=?_ X *7?7 ?L?c? .?g-?Z???~>? ??j?? ??$,?4TlU????-? ?5??????!S????N K?s? ??I?? ??}? Nh????ca?? ?.?&??? ?k??Z??4n}??!?? ? @ I?,? B? USM?&=??A?G??Z??8?l ?i?
?|C 1bh ???`?*x�??d jTk??C?#%? 5?\ I?? ^?W??FsVlT,? ???S ??c = )/.?? t 9?????n[?_z?>dK4?l?\?? ?!?!??G; ? h'?3i ?8???? ????sb ?:??? ????FC1?5????>? }?k?}??/ ?cO? ?????b?g?????5{!b???8 n ? ?R 9y?j?? E?`??
??Na?o?e =1,?^w ?????? ??=?? e &?u?S? i??v?!??? &?p-ea?yk $??C^L?? ???Y??e??>?_V3???\U ?
?? !??,?ex ? G??p??r?t?????[M,?(6KMSMG H[ . ?* ??e???a?U?/ @?; ?, ??6?d?? *,?G?'?]*s1???t?8Q?rW?? ???-?W/???m?%?CC R"38 ??R x??�qN ?\? ~kw ??o b?&&??.?? ?\S? ? ??????k?t??i#u*M]w? ?e?O ??'??? sa?v?????r(???%???J ? ?F ? X ? }??`?} ?9?RWw.D??7 j?=?!?(g???i?(?i]?? EK???i?X?*??zc, I~ ? 9=?'???y?\4 ? ?+f?o??"? ?V??l#???w?,??T?rYd?g?^ uz?? ? ?? ?
?-gx* ?&P?>3? E ?? ?6? 3??? q? [? ? ?3`? h? #?'/ ? ?? {???u?:???i?2 ??{av$?O]? ?} ? Q??2{ X? H?? ?????U?%?,*i?R?i??4 ???G????eKN???T ?F?%? ????? K3? ?j?? ??:?? ?}???s?NF ?O???"
> ?? _? uLy?}& ?7?i??H?.? 1z?X?= kQ???A? 5?hg?hgp? RG???bL??v?}?k?) BZo? ??? ?"?? ? ?RI`??\ ?<$ q $???\ [?? {(???7?{U??9?4>F5?? Nbz Hk= #z? z ?
?; Z ?l?v ??0?O Ra$M?t $?�??Ys??p??x6.3 r M%?? Yfi&???_?a?WN[X?I?!? ?5?iPu?? ??} :?kW&?? ?R?? r ?sV???? ????:???&&?? 3: },?B?*? *? }#??I?g????t??; ?M2 T@ ?\?sS? ?????ZH???rY?? ??�??>?k??z?5?A"?ak???[??d? Y?&?4??MIP6?c? ? ????? ?? ? %???
cy??`?"n ??i+?
F???2??7?~8?? hRS'K !vK{ ?7? +TO?? ?{ w? ?Q?eZ B????? .B???s e:? ???S???w?0?uTia[g!?I 7H??f?<5?? ?J??E??? ?????? ? ? ?r?A?a? ?+ ? ??')? L???Zr ?| ??Y?` ?\X ?n?Yxl. &Z C?T?? ?,UK?? ?r??1???(? %Q$Mr}??? Z:? GC ,?-?I??? ?)? ??? x???Q?? ??9? 1 Kc3 ??o] g??y? b???f??h?i??{x?x? 5?q?1?K? @k????3?H4?o? ????A= o +^? c?sb5l?=??O?B??'4? ?CC? c?$?,??s8?[??? ?^?T5??? oR??? ? ~+:?.????P�tK? d ?L 1?5??
~?}?Z?'? ?? LUCF?] ~?w?_??�=? 7? ?? ??|R)9,?=?)?c ? o?V?*l? ' V?? ??
"??< FP ??4hw????j $N?e???(??CH'.?? ??p??u ? OS???DjL?c???o???|-\_K? ?t??f$n?z??u3???}?\?B ?M?" d?I?a?????I????fx9??^ E+{? '?L???1?|O4? ????;??z???U??p? ?k?? ?h}n?t??T?? o?^ ?FQ-??Do?0?c??^V?w( 7????? ?`�?(G? ??? ?s?w??$ N?~Ug??cl??_\-zUm3?? N?: ?s ?? w?? ?x? /??? ???b?r??Kv?,N^?? ??O?h?? Zh?+?W%TB? +?( S?zi??K? ? ? D?>??Y?H ???_?E ??? ??in?>"?)%z?6Uq??tSq? U?`??i???&????D?Y? ` ??>|$[ 3&9 ?` ?
( Y? /?=w;R?0n?%??b8|v??@??!?`=? *?C?A??s?s/?cU???pzU???5??PV?6Q?1 h???{P??g?????? z? ?&c?S????d8??ny??kP%?kYN}?E??$h?q?Q?xP'? ?Pl??? ?_?d?? ^??@? L?gx?Mv???3?{???S????>TqZI d[ 7 -d?^?? ??[I ??Z?"S??/ 3HW?SM?; {#?5z}{s??A Z?C??^U?&?5??,??R?t?? G8o?? ??J3/ ??bWW T??~X `??x? ??,?g ? ?t???J???!>????v?v ,?Sc?zo?D? V?S??< we?u6???"eD ? ? ????j? g? ??=??ao?z??? ? $_???gg? jJ? ?3??c)4m???4J ?U?.?? ???;:$?A?Ff ???1? ? x??{`B?}???'&??g?? 6?'\???????w?????????G?c?$ +3?T ??? {?? Yc ?F? 9L3.??2{? s??,?5E???<(9?2e<>??[??????T?p?d;}0+?%n? ?g?M&3??(vI?,^=?m?=+? ??K?? ?q_Ul1g12 3?m`?1m .> u?= =?1? /??? ?QK?5-O�?F? >? Cq??(?
?iy7??? `??2?m? ^6;zy?, p=? ?�???-? ???h49??Zk ??TT?
2 W? !rP26a? O?qb1?R??,C? ???x] ??hBVLo JS??? 6n8??? ?B?ZY 8?� ?V?rVQ A???k?Tza???wj?? ??P?y?v ?? ?oZ^ |u???? sa ????? ?#9?? r{??,}?u?7e??xQfo ? q? ?E? ?s(?S?o??ohh?r (I???{T?2??78 h?/%?J?o ?[?&,S ?x???? \%0?-?.?E?O?? ???s??Y?>? ?? ??&t}? I~?I ?Y? b3??1? ?? ,?f?=S ??q?^R? ? ?? ? ??*.???2??T?\>?9.?J?V? ???Wd????V??Y f? xe????CR??>I??? /?{%?8lF? #???q%?????-.?? d|-?W? d ?
\ x ??T�?s??$? ??d??? ]??a???B X? ??
?b????J ???q) ^*?#?lv????>'?:�y= l0??Nrt?x?G?*?U??l9< ?#?l??1z 3????I? ???| ? p?? aG ?? ?i( a?(_???w?? ?}.???EQ??~ 4?II???p z?????lG?/j??@??? ?O?J?????R ??U? b?g r? ? ?n|?/? ? L?|b?P?Tg??k4?o??9 y.? 7? t??�?]?t?^?f?G??c9X?%VF?&Y?$?.9m?M R ??r?6 =??b??�'?-? ???W???z???]7? ?t?b??]?e6?'? Y?)L??;?GR?b?@ ?R"??t??? �?N?F?$)? ?i5?n@[a= ?B???? ??j E?s? c???Yt a 3? ? . ? ?>?e?hx;?????l??(s ??9 ?C? }?N ?V?L? Z+Pz?? 3?? s�? ?# ??m? rY| (?B, J?c??1Z?,???bBpy? ??????%?l??C????k}?)&?;???{?a?i? ???|??'n? " 9 .??1?? { ? ?G? ??d?$`R??S ?????sv??o?9?{ ?" 7^?A 0????{ ?K????8?D \? $s ??@kZ???u????7?L??\? D??9?i?V?T??g/{a?#?Y?X,? ???j?^/?? ?I4} ?ZN??_@?wV_lN??????X[?6?q??g?(E ????k??d?K ??O??w??E?} l???~?W1=??? K???uy ?p?.Lt ?e?S1?(3W* P?J?K?rt)h??A?X\ ?m? ?V?zY- ?D?q??}Y??? h? e>l??? 5 ???-?#?9?????q??? H[ S??C"?&M?$?a?g?? ??0f?a???d? F ?H.l??qD? ??h??]?? ?C2 ?|? ?u?Jy?C??x ? ?} ?U??Q??@ ?H*Mf@??O?p?.R_I ???X?2U??y?:nH p?N+`Fz?mI? ??????b?f?!?d[KNa ????dBD??W? #???8??? 5Q6?? ??wa ?\4#???+ xd? : ??r[dO?`?O4?!?(,[H:? w dn?? Sz?kT? ???gEN7L?b ?r ?fhJ??2a;"; 0?7?? ??l P?J?T ?&w?? s)b:ZL??V?LP?5?u?}?y ? N :? *j?b+h?0`pS?uent!??}e? x T?p??2"( ? [?
u? ?L???7?S??d??
??(??LR%??5?F?UK?] ? ? !?: ?) >?????w?VH? ?u,???V ? C���� Top