Karnataka High Court
Sri M Surendra Rao Since Decd By His Lrs vs Smt N Sulochana W/O Late B N Srinivasa ... on 16 January, 2012
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, L.Narayana Swamy
IN THE gzga SQURT Q; KAR§AT K§ A? B§E§AL§RE
agran THIS THE 1§%flDAfi_QE 5§§U§RE, 2312
9REsExT-"J *'u =
THE HONFBLE-MR, £§§E;CE=g;Lf]Mé$38NAra
~:3%%"/%%§A g§£§§*'§'""'
v__ ____ _% _&v 'E§~__mg
REGULAR FIRST APEEAL.No.1683/2O05
1: *' V'"T_'."§§--"
REGULAR FIR3E;AEPEKL No.2634/2006
THE HON'BflE .iy J§
REGULAR FIRST APE
BErwEEN:__
~,_REA'mo;1252/é§e5;»
fi{Su:en&ré Rafi since deceased
By-his gwRs,ja~
z' l, ¥§i§thi*Ré§KW!G Eate
Saréndka Ra§; ?% years,
"i§?}*M.§gRagha Chafidra S/Q late
;zS§:eaé:a Rafi; $8 years;
$;_§Q§;§a:end:a Raa sfs igte
a' Sfirenéra Rae, Q5 yéarsi
V "m_§L fi.S'§haiiefider SXQ Kate
Sureafira Rag, 38 years;
R
my 3
?.
"X
;
M,S3Harinder sic late
Surendra Racy 36 years,
Lalitha Srivaisa die late
Surendra Rae, 42 yearsj aa 2 V '_ ,<,_V:V
*« *.'AP9E;LANTs
Kavitha Joshi d/o late 2 1
Surendra Rae; 42 ye§rs,""
All are presenfily Rfafi&NQ.3§é;;k V_
5"'B Crass; OMBR Layoufi;' :" L*'
Banasavadi, Bangalore«43;'
AND:
15
{By AdvocaééE££if£fRafiéuE§a£"f§:
M/s K,Rafia Bhgt g A3sts:jV
N.SulQehafi3_wf@,iate," .
B.N.SriniVaSaHMu:thyY ?0--years;
No.442,'2"PMa:n,%fB:fs1¢ck,
ACCS La3cut,'gundaiafiai1ig
Bangalorér37, A" "
Lakfihmammé Wis 1a£e .
s_ VenE§téramaiafi{"?S years,
w"
g.M
;¥,S:inivas sic late
';yén2a::;ama;:h, 45 years,
%Q¥;M§3i£éméiah $33 iate
¥enkat§:&$aiahF £3 years,
;_M§¥.Chasdra3hekar SXG late
=_V%nkata:amaiah, $1 yeaxsg
'§fi$;$hesha§ri SEQ late
"'¥$nkataramaiah, 33 yeazgf
Wfi,¥g§ma dig late Venkataramaiah,
£8 yéazs,
3&2 ta 7 are Rfat No,38§
Anjaneya Temple Street,
Link Road! Sheshadripuram,
Bangaloremzfi. 69 REs?§§§éN§s .
{Advocate Sri.K.Shrihari fer R~1} x _
(Advocate Sri.M.N.Balakrish§a fQr"R~2ztc,?}
BETWEEN:
RFA No.1683/2005:
Masurendra Rae since decéaééé ,
By his L§Rs. '" "'
1.Malathi Rao w/0 late ' V Surendra Rao,r?O year$;
2. M,SeRaghgHbha§§raisf@_l§ig, "" H Surendra Rafi; 48.yéar$;_, '
3.M.S.Na£éfidré.R$§"5}oD1até"W Suren§ra--Rad;=46 ye§rs;~ 4;M,S.Shailendef'éf¢»i§té Suregdra RaQ{_38'géars; = §;M.S@§a§ind§r éZé late .'$u:end:a'Eas, 36 yeazs, §giaiithé S:i%a$sa dfé late Sa§end:a"Rao, 42 years; ~if~?QKavit&a3J@sh: éfs late ' ,Sa:e§§fia Rag, £2 yéars, fiAii $£e §zesentiy Rfat §0e3$£; s,_ 7=_5§fB Crass; @332 Layeut, *._ "gBanasavafii; Banga3s§e»§3. ., £?§E;§AE§S q'z ié 4% {By Afiveeate SrigK.Rama Bhet fer M/3 K.Rama Bhat & Assts.) AND:
Venkataramaiah since deceased By his L.Rs.
1.Lakshmamma w/G late Venkataramaiahf 75 years,
2.Smadevi dfo late Venkatarefiaiah;g > 48 years; " -- '
3.M.V.Srinivas S/Q late_'? iv Venkataramaiah, 45 year$;'¥
4.M.V.Muniramaiehes/e ;a£e-«""_ Venkataremeiahg543eyeers;ifl
5.M.V.Chagdraehek§r Sfeelefie V Venkataramaiahgié1*gears,W
6.M;v.shéshadtiVs{ee1§£ee» Venkataremaiah,u39V§ea:eg _All afievaiat §e,385v : Anjaneye Temple Street;
WLihk,Ree&,.Sheshedri§uram; §efige1e:e%2§e } "=.?$ N;ee1sché¢e wfe late
-- E.NLSrini§eee Merthyf ?G years,
-,'»§e,§4;;%2" xaie, 'ef Block; j,eec$ Layout; Kundaieheilig '*eag§e:o:ee3?e .. eeseeeeeees VH_§Adveeefie S:i.K.§,Eaiek:ishee fer Rei is 63 '{R»? .Q Sexved} BETWEEN:
RFA N0.2634f2006:
N.Sulochana w/o late B.N,Srinivasa Murthy, ?Q yeazsg NOe442! Xfl Main, 'B' Block, ACCS Layout, Kundalahalli, Bangalore~3?;
(By Advocate Sri.K.Shriha:i)2gV AND:
1.
2. 3
m' Venkataramaiah since fiégéasgfi byfi§,Rs. Lakshmamma w/0 late~-:V _ _ Venkatarama:éhQ-75,yeafs;."f"uHm Umadevi fife léiéuvéfihétégémaiah, 48 yeaF§;"K "° 4"V"" E ¢M.v.s£;niva$"s;¢*;a:§=,--' Venkataramaiah;f§5xy$ars, ,M.v.Mgnirémgiah}s;¢':éte Vegkataramaiagf 43 years; ..M;¥¢Cha$fi:ashekar sfo late 'flvénkataxamaiahg £3 geazs, ,M$¥,Shesha§:§ sis Late
-- §éfikata:amaiah! 3§ years, fl §5i'g¢ 6 are Rfat $3.38, ggfijaggya Tempie Street; .§ifik Rsafi, Sheshadriguram, u =B§g§&lorew2%, wflg 3 £§9::;Afi?_%g ?.Ma1athi Rae wfa late Surendra Rae; ?G years;
8.M,S§Raghu Chandra Sig late Surendra Rao; 48 years;
9.M.S.Narendra Rae sfo late _m~_ Surendra Rao; 46 years, 10; M.S.Shailender sfa lata_ Surendra Rao, 38 years; "
ll. M§S.Harinder s/o iate A Surendra Rao, 36 years;
12. Lalitha Srivatsa dfailaaai Surendra Rao; 42 yearsh "
13. Kavitha JcShi@d{d.;a€a Surendra'RaQja42"years{'~ R,-7? to {£3 A'i'3.~T.j'va;~§1E//zég._ No_.304, 5% B Crass; QMBRfLaydu§; ' Banasavadfi,"Banga;éré<43§ '. RESPGNDENTS {Advccata Ski K.§ama Bhat for ,,& vM§svK.Rama"Bha:v& Assts. for R~? ta :2} 1a *{A&vQaaté,Sri,M.Shivaprakaah for R"; ta 6} Rra_;?52}2é§5 is fiiad under Saa.§6 cf CFC " against aha juégmant and decree datea 2,?§2§Q5 _,?é§éaéain»as §e9?48€f§8 on tha file of XI Addl. £*Sit§ Civil Judge, Eaagalcra, dismissing the suit afa:'§édamptica of mortgage. .,_ 'aa=uaaaa i583j2®G§ is filed under aaa.aa sf $9:
v_ '-.Aa§5'aViast the judgznarzt: and éecraa aated 2f?.2§G5 =,§asaea :3 Gfi §@s33?8f%8 an aha file af X: Aélg 7 City Civil Judge; Bangalore; eiemissing the see:
fie: redemption ef mortgage. ' 7 REA 2634f2SG6 is fiiefi under se¢,§s,es,:p:_e- against the judgment and decree dated 2}?e2G0Ee"A passed in as No.3378/98 on the file Of xx eedl. City Civil Judge; Bangalore; deereeieg tfieeseig ' for specific performance and :ozexedemp§ion>ef,_ mortgage' These Appeals are eefiiag hen 'fer ffinel hearing this day, MANJUNATHa_J_ dé1g§e:ee§ the fellowing: . .m_*.'. ~- .
J U D G Parties heVe%eett:eeJthe;fiVeiegute at the instance efie the" eeuxfig :"eAeee:fiing1y' they' have filed a eemp:omieeg?eti§ien;- 2e Today LekehmemmegVwi§ow ef Venkataremeiah eeés_eefie';veze, Mefiitemaiah, Chendzesheker and She3he§fi. e:eR@:eeenfi. befere the eeert. They V"~e§mit Aefie _eeeeetien. ef 'the fieiet Qemeg They 'efeeee, beeee~ ifientifieé, by their reseeetiee "fieeeeeaeee. Ge behalf ef the Reeyeeeeets, "e.VEv§';Se.,§:e:ieeer is present befeere the ceertg fie ejsuEmite that he hee signed en behalf ef remaining legal re§resentat:ves cf late Surendra Rae ané he has also agreed to get the affidafigfig of others and the same shall be filed wi£h£g{§; weeks from tcday after servigg copy»H¢£;[theV affidavit an others and Hérigdefi'3haS"§¢gnq identified by his advocate~'x 35 Plaintiffs have '&gre$é 'é§ Tpgy 'é""s§m sf Rs.55,0o,0o0/~ (Fifty f;§§V ;ékg§ fg5;y) to the legal heirs of "#§fen%a%f§:'2fl &\_é:f%n full and final sett1efiéfl§{5f\$§é§§1a§¢ §§'defendant-2(a) to {g} an§H§":é$f%gfia§£; If EH% amount of Rs*55 lacs is #§§:§éid]%§th$§[§fi.days as agreed upon between the §ap§:gs, §¢i£ filed by the plaintiff i%€e&V€Qka%ar§m%i3h'in *** as NQ.33?8f1§98 ané the suifi fi3g§ fig decease& Surenéra Rafi in G8 '~mQ.?4g5f:993"§hé1; stand fiecreed, :5 the amsunt ~f as agxee§_fi§ca is paid by thé LaRs§ sf §l§int:ff V vg§$a:a§ama:ah within 9% flags, Suit filed. by Ea£gH§Surenér§ Rae in Q3 §©&?é86f1§§8 stands TW A&ésmissedv