Karnataka High Court
S. Surendra Babu vs Government Of India, on 7 March, 2017
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 7TH MARCH 2017
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE L.NARAYANA SWAMY
WRIT PETITION NOS.107412-107473/2016 (S-RES)
BETWEEN
1. S. SURENDRA BABU
S/O LATE S. NARASINGA RAO
AGE: 65 YEARS,
R/O. HOUSE NO.1230
SONIYA NAGAR
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BALLARI.
2. SUSHEELA K
W/O LATE K. KRISHNAN
AGE: 60 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.326,
WARD NO.30
NEAR MARIYAMMA TEMPLE,
AMBEDKAR NAGAR
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BALLARI.
3. C.MARY MARGARET
W/O LATE S. AROGYASWAMY
AGE: 66 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.1140/B,
BHAGATH SING NAGAR
NEAR SAI BABA TEMPLE
HOSAPET DIST: BALLARI.
4. KHURUSHEEDA BEGUM
W/O LATE M.S. ANWAR BASHA
AGE: 67 YEARS
R/O. OP: TO TSP LTD,
2
INDIRA NAGAR, TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BALLARI.
5. K.C. VARGHESE
S/O LATE K.J. CHACKO
AGE: 69 YERS
R/O. KUNDAREYIL HOUE
PAOOM PO
KOTTAYAM DISTRICT
KERALA STATE
6. A.LAKSHMI
W/O LATE A NAGAPPA
AGE: 60 YEARS, R/O. NA-129,
TSP COLONY
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BALLARI.
7. B.DURGAPPA
S/O BHIMAPPA,
AGE: 64 YEARS
R/O. OPP: PRAGATI GREEMAN BANK
TALVARKERI DAM ROAD
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI.
8. R.B. SHINDE,
S/O BALU SINDHE
AGE: 69 YEARS
R/O. OFFICIA COLONY,
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI.
9. GADILINGAPPA
S/O CHIPPAIAH
AGE: 59 YEARS
R/O. BTR NAGAR
31ST WARD 3RD CROSS,
BEHIND RTO OFFICE
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI.
10. M.MURAIDHAR RAO,
S/O KRISTA RAO
AGE: 62 YEARS
3
R/O. M.J.NAGAR,
7TH CROSS
VIDYABHAI COMPOUND,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
11. SAWRIYAMMA
W/O LATE AUGESTEN
AGE: 63 YEARS
R/O. 30TH WARD AMBEDKAR WARD
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI.
12. PRAMEELA W/O A. JOSEPH
AGE: 60 YEARS
R/O. HES COLONY,
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI.
13. H.M.C SHEKARAIAH
AGE: 57 YEARS
H.M. BASAIAH NISANI CAMP
14TH WARD H.NO.80
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI.
14. G. APPAVOO
S/O. VOGIND SWAMY
AGE: 69 YEARS
R/OP. NISANI CAMIP
14TH WARD
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
15. RAJAMANICKKAM, S/O. RJUN
AGE: 53 YEARS
R/O. D.NO.72/73
AMAMBEDAR NAGAR
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
16. H.M. GURUSIDDAIAH
S/O. LATE SIDDARAMAIAH
AGE: 54 YEARS
4
R/O. H.NO.19 A
14TH WARD, NISANI CAMP
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
17. C.VARADRAJ
S/O LATE CHINNASWAMY
AGE: 66 YEARS,
R/O. SONIYA NAGAR
PDITI COLLEGE,
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
18. J.HARIPRAKASH BHAT
S/O J. SURAM BHAT
AGE: 61 YEARS
R/O. 1ST MAIN 1ST CROSS
D.NO.400
BESIDE KUDLIGI DR.HOUSE
NC COLONY
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
19. K.MUTHURAJ
S/O KANNIYAPPAN
AGE: 65 YEARS
R/O. INIDIRA NAGAR
OPP: TSP
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
20. K.BALASUBRAMANYAM
S/O SUBHAPATI
AGE: 65 YEARS
R/O. D.NO.149,
T.B. DAM
MAIN ROAD,
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
21. SOLOMAN SELVAKUMAR
AGE: 66 YEARS
R/O. HES COLONY, G58,
NEAR FLOOR MILL
5
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
22. G.T. CHANDRASEKHAR
AGE: 70 YEARS
R/O. SIVANAND NILAYA
1ST CRLSS, J.P. NAGAR,
BELLARY ROAD
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
23. JOSEPHINIE
AGE: 64 YEARS
R/O. DOORO NO.11,
NETHAJI NAGAR
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
24. ABDUL HYE
S/O LATGE A.C. KHAJA PEERAN
AGE: 64 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.375,
MIG 4TH PHASE
5TH CROSS
CHS 707, YELAHANKA
NEW TOWN
BENGALURU
25. T.I. MATHEW
AGE: 62 YEARS
R/O. ARUKALIKKAL THUNDRATHIL
MANTHUKAPOST
KULANANDA (VIA)
PATHANAMTHITTA DIST
KERALA
26. S.RAJENDRA KUMAR
AGE: 67 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.744,
KIRAN SHEELA NILAYAM
JOLADARASSI GUDDA,
VIVEKANANDA NAGAR
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
6
27. B.MEHABOOB SHARIFF
S/O LATE HUSSAIN SHARIFF
AGE: 56 YEARS
R/O. OPP TO ANJUMANN SHADI MAHAL
NEAR LANDMARK FLOOR MILL,
ARVAIND NAGAR
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
28. S.SOMASEKHAR
S/O LATE SUGAPPAL
AGE: 73 YEARS
R/O. NARAGILA NILAYA
6TH MAIN, NEAR BALANJINAYA TEMPLE
M.J. NAGAR
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
29. R.KODANDARAMAN
S/O S. RAMASWAMI
AGE: 62 YEARS
R/O. NO.71/22 1ST CROSS
BEHIND CHIRANJEVI HOSPITAL
WARD NO.15,
AMARAVATHI
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
30. S.MOHAN S/O LATE C. S. MANI
AGE: 65 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.35/1,
WARD NO.15,
100 ED HOSPITAL ROAD
NEAR DOBHI GHAT,
NEW AMARAVATHI
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
31. S.BADRINATH
S/O S. RAMAMURTHY RAO
AGE: 66 YEARS
R/O. A 49,
SRI HARIKRUPA
SAI PALLAVI RESIDENCE
3RD A CROSS
T.G. LAYOUT,
7
BANGALORE
32. S.P.JAYASEELAN
S/O S. PONNAROGYAMO
AGE: 70 YEARS
R/O. NO.182/A J.R. KRUPA
WARD NO.30
HES COLONY MAIN ROAD
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
33. C.MANICKYAM
S/O C. CHINNASWAMY
AGE: 69 YEARS
R/O. SHAIKITHVELU BUILDING
INDIRA NAGAR
OPP TO TSP LTD
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
34. G.SAMPATHKUMAR
S/O LATE GOPAL
AGE: 61 YEARS
R/O. C/O. VALLI
MAIN ROAD,
THAMMNNA COLONY
NEAR HOSAMANE CIRCLE
WARD NO.15
BHADRAVATHI
35. M.JAYARAMAN
S/O P.MUNISWAMY
AGE: 54 YEARS
R/O. DOOR NO.155,
OLD AMARAVATHI
WARD NO.39
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
36. S.ZAINULABUDDIN
S/O J.S. BASHA
AGE: 53 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.63/A,
8
NISHANI CAMP
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
37. G.SUBBAIAH
S/O G. SUBBAIAH,
AGE: 66 YEARS
R/O. C/O. NAGARAJ
HOUSE NO.102
COCONUT STORE LAYOUT
BEHIND DEVANATH SCHOOL
HOMMAVU BANSHAWADE
BENGALLURE
38. P.PHANI RAJ
S/O LATE P. KRISTA RAO
AGE: 61 YEARS
R/O. C/O. VARNUA BAI P.N.
GAVI KRUPA HOUSE
KALASE STREET RADIO PARK
BALLARI
39. K.PREMA
W/O LATE G. KANNAN
AGE: 61 YEARS
R/O. NEAR MURUGAN TEMPLE,
NISSANI CAMP
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
40. A.ISMAIL
S/O A. LALU SAHEB
AGE: 68 YEARS,
R/O. DOOR NO.J-5,
WARD NO.25
V.NAGAPPA COLONY,
TILAK NAGAR
BALLARI
41. S.DELEEP KUMAR
S/O LATE B. SREERAMULU
AGE: 51 YEARS
R/O. MECHANIC NEAR SAI BABA TEMPLE
9
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
42. B.MD.HUSSAIN
AGE: 53 YEARS
R/O. DOOR NO.184,
TSP COLONY
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
43. R.VASUDEVAN
AGE: 65 YEARS
R/O. DOOR NO.23,
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
44. MOHAMMED P. S/O. ALAVI
AGE: 66 YEARS
R/O. PANDARATHODI HOUSE
PARUVAMANNA PA2
HAMALLUR POST
MALLAPURAM DISTRICT
KERALA
45. V.K. VIJAYADHARAN
S/O NARAYANAN
AGE: 69 YEARS,
R/O. KAVERI PAITHINIPARAMBA ROAD
DOWN HILL
MALLPURAM DISTRICT
KERALA
46. G.RUDRAPPA S/O MUDDAPPA
AGE: 64 YEARS
R/O. MANJUSHREE
DOOR NO.1062,
RAJEEV NAGAR,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
47. T.ESHWARAIAH
S/O LATE T. RAJAIAH
AGE: 65 YEARS,
R/O. HOUSE NO.12-4-187/1,
STREET NO.1
10
PRAGATI NAGAR,
MOOKAPET
HYDERABAD
48. T.UMA MAHESH
S/O LATE T.MALLAIAH
AGE: 66 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.8-3-164/C/2,
FIRST FLOOR
OP: PAVAN TRADRS,
NEAR NEELIMA HOSPITAL
ERRAGUDDA
HYDERABAD
49. S. RAVINDRANATH,
S/O LATE SHAMALA VEERANNA
AGE: 62 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.3-6-355/31,
CHANDRA NAGAR
BASEER BAGH,
HIMAYATH NAGAR
HYDERABAD
50. E.KRISHNA MURTHY
S/O LATE EDARA SUBBAIAH
AGE: 68 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.1-1-364
STREET 256,
JAWHAR NAGAR
HYDERABAD
51. M.V. GOPALA RAO
S/O LATE RAGHAVDENDRA RAO
AGE: 67 YEARS
R/O. HOSUE NO.9/989
A SHANTHI NAGAR
GUDIVADA
KRISHNA DISTRICT
ANDHRA PRADESH
52. A. SHAIKSHAVALI BASHA
S/O LATE KHASIMSAB
AGE: 63 YEARS
11
R/O. HOUSE NO.1314,
OPP: TSP LTD
INDIRA NAGAR
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST: BELLARI
53. G.N.PRABHAKAR SETTY
S/O G.T.NARAYANA SETTY
AGE: 65 YEARS
R/O. SREE BALAJI ENTERPRISES
INDIAN OIL PETROL BUNK
NO.6, OUTER RING ROAD
DODA BANESWADI
BANGALORE
54. P.SHIVAJI S/O. PANDIAN
AGE: 59 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.91/3,
IIND CROSS 1ST MAIN,
LAYOUT ENTRANCE
BENGALURU
55. R.UTHIRAMANI
S/O R.RAMASWAMY CHETTAR
AGE: 63 YEARS
R/O. SREE BALAJI ENERPRISES
INDIAN OIL KPETROL BUNK
NO.6, OUTER RING ROAD
DODDA BANESWADI
BANGALURU
56. S.K.NAGAIAH
S/O LATE S.K. SUBBARAYUDU
AGE: 69 YEARS
R/O. HOUSE NO.32,
KANAK VENAYAK ROAD
GROUND FLOOR,
SHANTHILAYOUT
RAMAMURTHY NAGAR
BANGALURU
12
57. G.SUBBANNA
S/O. G.PALLANNA
AGE: 63 YEARS
R/O. DOOR NO. 683,
6TH CROSS M.J.NAGAR,
HOSPET, DIST:BALLARI.
58. B.VENKATESHA
AGE: 63 YEARS
R/O. SRIKANTHA NILAYA,
HOUSE NO. M1, RAJIVA NAGAR
HOSAPET, DIST: BALLARI.
59. NAWAB JAN
S/O ABDUL MAJEED
AGE:67 YEARS
R/O: DOOR NO. 630,
WARD NO. 30,
BEHIND GANESH TEMPLE,
OLD AMARAVATHI
HOSAPET DIST: BALLARI.
60. D.PUSHPA
W/O LATE R.DEVARAJ
AGE: 68 YEARS,
R/O: RAJAGOPAL
3RD CROSS, SONIYA NAGAR
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSAPET DIST:BELLARI.
61. A.VENKATESHAN
S/O. ARMUGAM
AGE:68 YEARS,
R/O:HOUSE NO.29/4,PLC
NEAR GANESHGUDI
TUNGABHADRA DAM,
HOSPET DIST:BELLARI.
62. A.PALANIVELU
S/O. ARUMUGAM
AGE:60 YEARS
R/O.NO. 20, 3RD CROSS
PALLAVI NILAYA
13
DODDA BAMMA SANDERA
VIDYARANAYAPURA MAIN
BENGALURU
... PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. ANAND R KOLLI ADVOCATE)
AND
1. GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
DEPARTMENT OF HEAVY INDUSTRY
MINISTRY OF HEAVY INDUSTREIS AND
PUBLIC ENTERPRISES UDYOG BHAVAN,
NEW DELHI-110001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
UNDER SECRETARY TO
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA.
2. STATE OF KARNATAKA
THE SECRETARY,
WATER RESOURCES
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
VIKASHA SOUDHA,
DR.B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
BANGALLURU-560001
3. TUNGABHADRA STEEL PRODUCTS LTD,
REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHAIRMAN
HOSAPET
DIST: BALLARI
... RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.PRAKASH HOSAMANI AGA FOR RESPONDENTS)
THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES
226 AND 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
DIRECT THE RESPONDENT NO.1 AND 3 AUTHORITY TO
RECONSIDER THE SERVICE BENEFITS OF PETITIONERS IN
PURSUANCE OF THE NOTIFICATION VIDE ANNEXURE-D
14
DATED:07.01.2016 SAME WAS NOTIFIED ON 11.01.2016,
PASSED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3, VIDE ANNEXURE-D AND
ETC.,
THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS
DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:
ORDER
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
Learned counsel appearing for the parties submit that the writ petitions may be disposed of in terms of the order passed in W.P.Nos.107223-278/2016.
Submission made by the learned counsel appearing for the parties is taken on record. Hence these writ petitions disposed of.
Sd/-
JUDGE VB*