Karnataka High Court
Kumar S/O Doddahanumaiah vs State Of Karnataka on 14 February, 2012
Author: Jawad Rahim
Bench: Jawad Rahim
Qmga $5-::§2--2z2€:§ 3%;
yawsgzg "§:--~§§ %~§E£%*% ::::::;a? :32? ;<2;2;§\s§:aa;<a :2? gmggzgaag §%£1J?§§§> "sgazg mg 3:?" §,&C'§ @? §E5§z:;§%A:__;§.:':._V% 3 WT?
EGQ ' WT "ma %é{}§*£"B%_.E §*f%R, }E.}§"?E{Z§ 3%:a;;§.$..?;§§s%§':%é:
C§i...§%. saga' 183:5 4' EE?"W'EE§*»§: -
Kififvififiéf 35$ fifififiéfiééi§§'*»*EA>';;ixi~é;*».._ J ._ ffififiééf _ .a:s':'@ gazvga. "
:~s:*:%~é:%sus:;<5§ °?:._3§'-*§§+<i}Q "mééfiéi ":~M:".),:a$9§:~:;:e§i@"§ {$25 '5§§;§~"- '§S:' Q,_?..§'»§'f§}Js%_E§'; ;2%§':ii_: "
Afiéfi:
3%?
* % % .;,&§g§v:s:*§§;§§¢§"
s;g%*"::~,.gJ;:VM?\,&a§,é1 S:§5§;.;:§vm§=syé 8%%§%"EL J "':,%::.$'4..;:"§§§;aa :5 332,55: agggcgm $3? $2.35
C X Eéé §ki:§'a§i:i£§§g"if}§} §I%3§'§'§E§I'§"§§"x§§ 3&5 §%§3§?4;§§_§.§z?=§7?j'§%§Cii§§§} §'=§i;%,§. §:iE§ ?%*%'E %§7§:E?'\§:':E .;€.§f§ 3.255:
if}? §'?'5:V;'%A?%§§} §i:§'§§"E§3§i:§§*§§ YQ 5&1: ;F€f§%?i '"§?€?<',EE "~.E'§':§'%R$£?'f§%. ?§"§E %3?'*'?EE'é%:§E ?§é§;':§ 325% €73? AA ?€'}:%i %€E§%§§§"«§§§ "§§*§§;':E %if{}i.};§fE" §'~'§§§}E ";?§€E §{}§.,§,fi.:"?%"2fEZ§*1§€7;€:~ °%%%s>m§~2awx<mmwmmwyWww.. / §E':__§%* €f§}§'E"'§:'"'f"%:C'2§"E ::1%3::V;%s',*<:i £2? kéiééggg 9&3 §§§%:§":$: %"3'E?'%§ §;§':§ $33 '€"E"§{1%§§"§§:§" ?%£:s';€ - ?:,%'€§%§'if':é"?'§§' %:*:°:g;§§a:%:% }.E£.§:§§i§§§f§E §iZ§:§Gi*"% i:i}§"i'<;"§£i€fi aacazsgefi :3 in §§§€8§ agaigzsz §"':§%3,V:*;-aéésaz $9?" 2% €3§§E§":{Z€ @:,:§:§$§":&§§€ :::':£:%:' Sea:"%i§§;§ CS§§fé€QUE{3€ sessiensje' 2, §~%e::2%'§ the iaagmgé €§:',i';.i_§";'é;<s~>»E %'=.1;%9';'§"'%.é?Q;§_:§r;i§3§gA ;'.®%= §p§&£§a:>:: am isameé {3G¥'%;f§3::3Ver3i *f3.%§é'é€:%9} $5'; ?::a:z;%a fiubramafiyg 8%? f#..:">.sf'"'é*§3;§Gz'§--£%é:;~i_'».f"~Sia:§, Pgmgeé the ;"§:s:3:*ég are 3:; §'}gig3§?§"%€E'E"'%?;§%:§§.§§=.§§%'§jf§"E:%ZQ; %'§§§§i:;«§::"'§;€'*sz'€a§Sf The ,;§::é"3;e€§:,%€i~_:3_%: «é§;--a1§'v~._%_;2:'f§a'*a::§§V.agsgirzsi iéza agméiazat ~« §<az:r:ag'a%a:*}:é'~V§é:%%-i'::§i:.~_@§:"E':%s§ f"@:"':§:-a%'::3ffe§:s;€ §:3%""§§§§"'%&§§€ iifééfif . - \ §€é:i§a';%?2, :43?' W"
24; 3,345 3&4 am? 3&1? msfi A§?i§;.{!%:/ me basis sf iéze regwi sasémééiaé a~m~4"' w%%:§": ;'€ez:§V§'E<::»4:f:_%£«fi2§ @f mi .»§%i€?. "~ §%§§g§%L;»:;§.,¢:_%_§___éiE2§ }:;:"§3é%c':%@§':§§ ?€:%§é::€ Eiaééwa §sj§ j%.:§":& ragga? %:$ géigsgaé ighfi %§gi§€§§::"§?"%§ §§%i;»§fs§ :s*g%.i.%s"_gi-:%.éé;§§": $%:§":a€§ §""§5:§ §'::;m=se:::i 3:"; :;::%§zé;§:;% ggsemgfgs QM "'~ §n»::;»:fi:M;%'é;5;s2a:,"§": gm §§S{'E as irggzgrg ia §'"§§§"%"§ :;f%':§§§2§§§§:2;§§:%} 'X :e:?§»:'§e'af'A» éééeér azaismeai $5: 3&§??§;§§§; éfig? §::;:%§aai:'* Enggecisg sf ?z:;§%::§; §<*ga%§33ga:2és'a; Segigiergé $2: €35 3% {§f'f&%"?{:% §a:n.%$%:ai;:§e i§%'%é§-Pf?' Seczézm :43; 355;}; 324; 33$, 59% gm f;$?" reagi with §€{?§i§?'% E329 §'~§<3.:3?;'§8 am €G.r':s*:;a:*§@:j FZQ ~ E:><.?>§2 K;é:§":~::%_}.:§:3:'§,';"--%jfie__5§S:% vésééeé Gawgmment fiéaggizgi 5;: i§_'E}%"'f"§»§~<2€,§A:§";; %;w%2éA§é"-%'s黧*--:%:_€:::%j:j:.§@@ . '§L%§'"§;?E§§' gtaéemamé 2:3? ifie £6'-?TTf§§§,év§;§;,'»3g_?¥"'%V§.;,?'§§§='f%';%:§3'T§f}V€?'_f§?¥'*J§E }¥: ?é}§'f3?'E:'"§¥3"§3 3% mg §m1':§'2es' his then gmcgedeé 2% 337% $;:2';:.: ";+~;%§é%e i-33$. §'v'%a%za:zar gg §€%" E:2<.P..2 am geézgé %::«<;>e§:%;_;gfl%;Vs:é:":5:afs:,_g%%:;:§<Zé"'?é._**§%f{'}3 €<:>:2né 3%: Em? am: éiwé .$V§*-3%z€i.:_:;%? z"§_é5€<.2£'§%i':i;';':'; éiseé Staéneé mus am sag:sje§:i;gs:§j_':%f%%§f§'?:<:>_?%i;eh_é':'é§ 3: E><:g?}4, He aim ieamasrj §2;§§:"2s;é' .%;2a:é$T:§Té;;_;a:§§7'§3 §»>:5§2~«.~;':'1?:éé;:%a:2é§:éa iwggs §?§§fi€§ ii} Vfczaria %~:S3§g2%!é:5'%'_5é §a§*s§2_é{%a::és<s§ '§_:f%':§"%*:;s§"':a§ §§"§%§'E* 352$ :"e€3:*§3é 32%: Si8'§€§'?T%€:§§3§;. 'V ;%é:é*:';"%§:€:;',; ?§?E": Q%§r.'3f;13Z§§§'%E€.§ asiééer wiiaaggsg 53$ mt:
;%:g:::=§% ghaei §§§€;%%§?:i 33 (23 £332"
5% E:
"K ff? ' 'W.' e'"i""
m 322?' 5%?"
aim M §%'=::2+:%".: __4i'.~'£2:t%':§':a§"3 §*é::s:" 331% Qffifgasgge énéiaaiaé gbaagé 5:25; " éa flag géwéefi 3:53: gaziéig §:&<:§§§%é§%:%s%§ ifiaé, 5%': 2z2;%';§é:f': g:*§:§§:::g€:§s:::": éégg é:'}<<§f"%"%%%'"§€{§ E55; :?*=é'§§§'2§?2§%§ 5353 \ ggmaéasasié 5-Ezzésjgsmé 23% S€>£:§§"'§38f'I§§ '% maieréa§ "§?:e §€ZC%.é;';i€§ gag: agg fiaféfiae 5;? gma: simgiisgiiase ' 3* ;§§":a§y::i:*;g zine Efiiiéfaféifi 13% fgai-;:féé§%.%:%i';;%?f"3Té3.'i§gm4_ hgié $23: $3 Eaéégtéis méy §§§eE§az:é:~~~»é<4a;m.%§§9é 4%§§. ':é§%§: .§n'é;2;:é'_§; @:;:*:§2h&b§€ i,E?":C§€§' §8C3:§§§"E 324 e"1?éE:%*%"_:T"z;:é;r:é["gfi;;-g'§=:';::'i:§:§:j:"has éfiifeé is eséamgfé {$35 gu§it_ 7{;-f_a:c:2§$d'._.§§?:;g 8; xsizgf §"'§3!"Ei§§"i'"¥3'fl;§Z§'3£3i"€§§'}f %ed§3;....{éf.é"-_;$%%'§%,_ Qafiégg-.....&é:i;§a§:5§3?% Emgaai, 5a§a§£§ .§;§v%§<:gm§s; §é%~€?
ééagaragug %{'%a§:§g,:V;sa€?':§;""'iifjéé"A§:§::{§_a3§V§:§{§7 'ih§m Q? 3%} we C%"¥E;§"§E3$ §s:V:é*é>i§é?§,._*;'.a'g§§.§s§?:._ :.?:el':s%_V w%s%%e CQ§3;2i§{$'§§§"§§ fine §§§e§%a;s1€;,v E-2sé5%§:;:_g_z;§?:é {:_§?.}§?1v"'§€«?Z§V,£}?:§ 35 33% £5 5;: agrfiegét 5;. ~E'?'2s}_§é;:%_%:':e':§~._:i%:;4:iéé§a§ ?f%r,§%§¢§?%;:§:i§§ wgagié S§,駧'é"'%§§" %;§*:§%:V§:s§§e;r":::é;";V' {3f...'€@'§::§%'aim;s§ %?s§?;~ ikéaggrggg egg :*:2§f;*i%:s»3«? ?':;*'g;?.:'«i "-2,.A;%'?'%:.;%:'£A§:'2"*:§':'2aéééégé W33 W» §%'¥s3:3§a:§:a€§@ §€;}€§ mi: §$§§§§§S§'E ». <=._.
agzggéiggsé §&';¢'£'§§"'%£§ §"€§§iI3i?EE>%§§€ fiszgégi fig S%j§T';§'§"%%7§§}V.§'§;%£f'.:~'§:%§'?"§§§:§3§?"§%§§%€ $55: --~ §'x§;3g;§§*§§ fiieegeg iizai 3&8 \.,é:*zs:%§§§;é:§;_%i;£i2;s"§2$<§ 23%? es? ¥'é§'2§§'§ wag 5;"; \.
KR §:
5% __§§:'%§'é«:.%§g:s."§5':"»,f_ §C{ZE§§§%f§= ééggiéfga. €33 :.:2:s:,:§§ :<;z;53§':?:§i i";§'§Ei €'2:'§d&§'E§€ regarfiém §»§5§::& G? &::<::m"§s2:s :2:.:§§§f§€§ §§'"'s%§ giiggaiigig, %& Séibffiiifi @253; ~ ééagamg 333$ 5{rj§V3»'§'§:3:?'_f'fl'._§i§w§ mg ssmsiaént échaé: ms; §§'$'{§'§€§" ?'*J'§3- ?«'§arsjamai:E:_;'é%'z£%.,'_ ---..:_ §.' Kumarg hag? §§§f€f'€*§'3£ES ?'E§ai§:"}§ ta mme_*g=V--r:":fi:i§&;**~.§}e«{;azgégesj» whégh éhere zmg érzzigiéemt €§%"§§_€':'%" %:.a fjv2éa$«?.;§§%"'~~f ,,E;*:~a:; i<§*2€" §§'i€Z%§§§":{ E??? a§§5e§§a:':%: Eg %§§€:'s'_Z§.§§§ i$V'§*é§i;"{:>a'::a:T;»g';"'§é';§;A .é'§{3§é v?E="':fi:
--~ ifiagarag bus? he iezéggé §V'"'§?2:;'§7s:=%_ §o:é*é;:*%'fia§§%§% gééegéfig ma? §§§€§§E§"3§: ma? a3§aa§i!é$;£''~§§m.'; ?: §i€;__:Sé'i:§.§;m%§f§V€ié*:*ef~fi: §3%§*£';":%"=</:_?v§,:§§3%":"%:':*:3 ms égégaé a §;§r:駧a%;é?:€.2::i:i';:;§§A~-::».:E%§§' 1:*»;%§:7£%3 asmefiesszafiiy §§§€§§§.€"f.i"..%{f;%i;~é"1§£%'§§§f_§§€§'€:§iLf; $5 55352;}: G? T£%m& a;§g{:s@%§:';3_é:*;'--%":aa:;§V v%::2§€n£% aw? '§§"%€§"€ WES am; §;rém%§y. 'VV§%e;f&:;§%§9:'a;_%{;:'._V§§':%'.."'a4¥§egES §.:§:%§a:":i, he gafiméig éhere Efi E::LA:;§§;;:*e:2§%--:":.%f,___§g%_y§§€§:§:& :3 gagggyi: §:§§€ €§"%&i'§$ §§}€3%E'°%S§" f"""f"
§7§V§5;"§§_:'%V§f,§§§§§§ zésarss wag §Eé:a<:§s: ii? §jj§'§§ §§'"$L§§ :2? Sig??? zasgg €:%":::% ;'}s':f;2?<3{,":§*%:§{;¥%': ':3: €S§§§§§§?E 'f.._i:A;?:%'---?j§§§ gésargaé %:w:; &a::%": if iééem éréasg ézamg $333 9352:,
-tr.-:r//.w»..w...
$E Q;
§:
\ .
\-.
\-.
\-.
: .
\ RN '§'\= K .'~\ .\ $2 fix §:a:::'§:§ §C<:%§?§é iffig 53$: 323%: s3%;'§é€§'3::% f'€?"%§S§"€{§ by éfigifié ix 6 wig; %'"§§%$ aagggégém 53$ fiéffvfifi :23: §$§&駧$§"§ :_%fé--;=»-.4§";;_§§?{ 3:2'?
acaagsefi §§:>,2 :2: 8, amgéé §'"§§%J£:"f zsgéé 5% is gasrwifgé $18 aggeiéam was standg at §a~;<'-wéih>f§éé'-e:;;§§':?;é§:*'§~., {£0 §i§f€¥"€f'§§ {safe is aiirifiataé ilj} *{E2:AeTéA:§;:;Té3j§.§'a.§":':1 é::5§:--9__§:::V_[f;%:£ faié iésaé: ?2§ sagas [}?'€$€%"'§§" 3.33.: ihé";3_%5a':::e *;=;§":§é%é'.jjtj-,,i_§;§ _%;:*§c§%s':i:§'r are aiéegeafi iii} haw béem '§§":€?€ éa as €<:>§§a?sQra:§@;'"~; :13: ,"§§2:.._'§:v%iZ:§.fie§{:§A§%§::;:*a ef ?%.:'%§:~ fésgaéag; ?W2__ -» »~ §'~;":ar2§:;:25i%2é Qagarémg fag {§%§"&W§ my ai%:s{:i%§:'": has mi fgamé 3%?
éée gzgmsitg msden sf fiffiéffiif « {%§:' fagiigg mg EE)'§%?'%f£E§AE§g £323 a§e:;::¢%£i.3aé as %«:&:'2:§i§'e::§ %>§«z2<~;s%'§%: 3% a::{,§:;%:§:.a§ iéaamgé 5.3as:%%r:*sme=:":%: ?§:9,;§::*§&:' fir: ?;4§}T5 ' §§§f_ii§i fa}? §%g§:';::2§f:§:,§é%; W $駧& €253 Em 3v§i:V:§gm::~§::%;1 .~_:
Iv V g:
3:
~.-.
3' x-:
\\:~ \__.
fl/&<?.-rafl// / §\ :28, ii %i~S m:;§:f::'&z37 ?%:"*§E -~ fiéaggfgjf i'::é§%'?':§§&§E':§%""§i g;€:«:;§<§ S? 3% §§*:=::%:§€§%%: at: 2§.€}7:§8, §::§§z'§%:*:§ :5 %*3§:":':_v.i}é..4;§:2V_é his fiyaifigr ?%2%;'3 --- féangsgrzgifi %:a§ gene Ea 35:} 9 A': 55%: 318% gm §§:>§€3§§8§"1?; ~ @Z§i':é'2*::: msbgé asmw zszzfih <:§"%%'.3§§E§', Sm'-gée 5~?-Egffiv§'§:§;3,§fé=..é'?3§"}§:"§.§§"i;§v§:€{j " his §:'£%§j%?§€§' bmtizer §a$"v.:;%r4_a§g§V{:¥..é"::sif%2 :;;'f"""vff:%"%§:':r: _f§i'§ ééfzer factesgz Q83?' E::§,:2 fie giiggeé ..a;Vv;;;3a,§"§'§'5s§2V%§"'éuéégtéaneé flirt: vifiy his msihag" ?%:'::'3 is ;f3€}§§¥:iE r§ga;"§?§2':Ag ?%§33;'%{'2§ is Quaryeé Azéjarséaizg fiiégzéizasf Sseaag ¥i:9:,a5r:¢§';§?:eé"{}'g:' j_5 f'a'%":é_§:, *g. '?"%":e{§§a;*e,. it $3 $665'? am: we §:<;':§§e:§?£€"'f1%§é"::;a§{§ :9 $3 éhs saagai '-ES the §:ér::%§?§:"2¥:§;:"2§;§?L'€i$; V' 2,:<é;f::§,'4..§~'%%;::;@§§§:':zg %:«:.:: ?%='':?: »» §''§§§&§"§;§ §§§§::3%§§:"é: aggaafisé €35"; 32% ;*%g%":%: §§'E§%j§§€~E§' {.Z§%.§S§f'E§§ §§'§§¥Q§,§§ ~ 2 iawgéé 32% aihemfisiag ii: €ji3L§§{§ ézava aazgagsé ggéwaéagg §s":§':m€~:«§. Q:
: %:§':%§ §;;:":£%:;§€ ézég ?':T'E:§§§E$§' ?%:":;'2 §>'a.;%:%;a::"::":"a3 §3;§§ %§'§§;%:"2§%?E§:i'§' gm aésgié £535 ggagazéééai %.:s:;%§"c3 ms has at: §€§%"§:§{}§': '1?%§§§éC;fE W1' 4?EZiérzs:s9sr(az.:«««cw..
,§§ama%§@wg%@m (I;
ac<3:;§£%:ég ix} 3&3 iaémgéaénaséé wgg as §i{€f3"'%§§Z 5% %:.§§§ ésgr, R33 f§.3§"§%'"%%f §€§3S%i§ 'aha: §t::C:..sS€§ « Amgamagga §§_a:;».§f;%é,%:€_g héra :;:;%:é§s:* &€£i:S€i:% - Rafiégg gmsesfi him ?§iihy_;'%é'§:«;§;;;s3.§$:.»V;:&*:§ :.a;%:e2: he 59%? flew: aicuggé :<§r:i<e5 fzim, '-53$ ?"€S§€§.i:EE§ by ms ymmge: §:§¥:h§r z»;r_§*m §:.aT:;'§§"i«;",%"%:,§*:¥z3- sfigiésiégf AA :2, "%She GE;;iii:ZZ9,':*Sfi§Q%'"? ~."'§§§__3§§.§a§: 'éééée mitéé gfiammawafi ?w3 » rm gzsifieézca tézzéergé $3;
Manjméaéét, Egsiés we #3? ésésa aagegi: 39:3 sf €339 a§;3§§§a§j_:"'a_§:e§:'%"§si;é**3 §;%*;;§%.%,__:aé:2'€i«r駧::i§§n ésééeiwefigi Q5': §::a§3z::;:.:';*z§".:%*:§..';';3_~a?::"E:::.:§:;aé_if i§i;:;5%::% fie gaié éhmzgifa éhey make;§??..,a_§'$&é§2'%%::*1@351 E.-i§':é~ are 51%? :f:C2??§§§%'€:"'E*§ wéiéz ;::9§a::§§*%i{";!.,L4ég.;:%»T§'§"figs siiéer aagageség Em" "
3;, "§'§':é""'--v.i~%iaé.€3§'::a%:i: :3? W3: CQ§'fC@§}fa€€S 35:9 ma ¥"%§§'§E'{§%§"§§ £.Z?:'%_i'€§'§ §§§$ :3? ggzggészg 3 Q? Sifafé wéiéz am 3:" 2* §{iCi§;§§€Z§ am zggazj is C§§,i§§ §§'%}7:§§'§£*§ 23 §§":€:2" gfiérgégsé, "?"§2& ?"§'E%i§§%f;'§§ '¢z?%'Z?%2§§<<$:i«m:xe<mwamwm.mw..
Eaégégaés gags rigééi $3'? §":<>§§%:";g éééaéj %:":;%:§::ée§ $é§S§5%E?E€:é:§ ivy @5252 53$ 3 5% :';'::}{':SfE€§L§€%"%i as am 2:? accasseé §'--é{aE.¢:_[§«:.;;T;:f:5:*a;
34. §G far as 3&8 ::sté:§:* gaézigeé 59% ai?:}__%é€ej;"j:3e7a;§ Eéaaéifé was 9;'~J§§€§§{ZEE Carrafiésraizingv-'é'§§e§a€§;::§§;§g3§&.§_:2§:"'é:%éém 5 figfisa aC§L§§§§&§ §""§§§:? §£:'i'€§""é §e:::3r@€c§';; fiaéégéte §_a:=§zé3:2§~% §:"§.i%mé::f:;% aaamsi fénéén 5 E am s§::*:::.f§;%:_§ %5:*sé=.§éa'mé;:G *?::§a:§ Euézs «J S > .. . ;
axamésed $39 evééeréce. CZ{"§§'?'§€§..§}€?$§§€§§'§"§ am 3% §e§${::r:§:*sg zégarfiefi éiiéé' §§{}§"_§f§f%'£5:'§'V{}§¥"__G§' €523 agxgsiiaééé §r €358 $%"fe::z;e §f?L}i""S?EE':§§¥€* :;:*;:§:3::=;'S&:'ts<m 324 3? ER? Hgaceg 1,35 3*~;:'<;~%.*;_.{¢3;5Ve7é:,V "i--.a;§*%~i.,,_;§Er$::§£ea? :@ 3:58;: {he regaesé §§2é'$ §j§'E§§: §€:':%'€§:<:€ %§7"%§§G§€i:§ ég %::::{> $25 igaméaf <::5u::g9:3.§ 5%';-<§%é--:s:
§"ss:%€3§"2,., ?"?:€":%:;%%:§é3'%s:eV' ?%f\5§.{",Z%~{:%§: é";£:€::§:§§as2%;£f§;r ::2;@as§a:§ ' "'?€'¥*3§§':.§§E%?;iA?, 3&3 ééaiff éégéaéfiafi ?':;"i!_E €33'? .ZE§§?,§.§£f§ :*'{:a:;;':£ "":;::'§:;[s:=é3=.;%:»:%:;";:§'T-.Vmgasaxééég izéég ;<;§é::«:§»%.§§es .;3§<é:é4j'.v':"%ae;2 §§a«3§§:a§ '§§":&%; zswg 53%;
?:«::__%'%é gm 33$ gérgfsra "?§":€: 3% §§§"E"E§§§ 3% 3.2;??? %3 E526 ::;{;}s;:2s.§ g:§:*E:'§§:::§E§.a 55$ 32 5:23; j?:?gf§.~§¥é§§§s>:'::§; §,'%€%€E"E aggesé §é"%§é%§"§; zasazgégi fiave Saga '\ .;z//027:7//(((4¢,W{4%;;§-&- //$825}; I I V j?
::G:*:':~3::;:e§:;L:s1;:%.§:§€;r: fig' §§....;§1S?::駧§%§§& i§%'E§€§' §&::i:%3:": 33,? £2? %;::"R:,,§ :"":*§:::::%'z §§*§€':§Qi§Sx '§§":& §§::§; 23:3: %£':§§':%§ gkianeé 2%; is 2'§s:mz :::§r:s::::: ha fieazéébéé ggéeasgug.
1%. 2;: 332% circumgéanaa, iisa SE§":E§!""%€:€ far imgzégenmerzt £53? a §:si%'§"§'{}§ 5:34 i§E_V?T§§:v'§f'E':3f°§:Vj»§SH?f{;"i§}b_j; A' §"E§f§§3; whésés ég 3e: asééa "flee §eé':fi:2§.;}{{ égzgsésgssi '9§?%S $33: agaeééaai was is: %:3;:..§éz3§§y V7{:'--,aé!§"'V'§;;r§:é1§' imvagtigatéms; arzfi hesce i§§<§§ét§ .:":_:;~.%:e'~-»:};' ih§"é:¢A;%a2»s:' eg 3535 {E33 Charge fig! G§?%§'§€i€ am§és' $'€€.C "§§.§:i§'E:.:'32f'%"'%§§E§3"f:; amjeg" §€§§§':§Er2s§ §€;%":¥:§§3:::€ :':ge§_§" Egg éég éiiiififi $3 3§:""::ez":c:s3€§::-ié: '§.§?:"3§;§%§.§$_;§.éé:§§'§3_%%:%:./_§_':§*$é?3':a'_%.::/ééergaréa :3'? him sf 2§ gays Er: §e%3:;%§ Es": gaymeai fiéza, gégaiéé' 3 §€§§<3§ sf E15 figygf {E2 s'$£ex.r'ée:<§,{%<;»? $23 ge:2_;é%:<>;.~~§'%; S§"§5§§ $3 gggié {';Ef§§' 32$ E'§§§a§"5§ £5; %«§}§€§._§§ $21; dig