Arun Bhaurao Kakatkar By Lrs ... vs Ashok Rudrappa Chanavan on 28 October, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Arun Bhaurao Kakatkar By Lrs ... vs Ashok Rudrappa Chanavan on 28 October, 2010

Bench: Aravind Kumar

 

2 3. ;
EE TEE HEQH iiéﬁﬁ'? Q? K.;§R§I§;TAKA
CIRCEIYE' BEEFCH AT EERAWAD
EA'§EE THIS THE 281331 BAY SF QCTQBER3 2Q',:'§3.

BEFORE

HQBPELE MR. JUSTICE ARAVIND K1f1_'§'IAR.:   T H

HRRP No.599 19§9(:iV£g 
cgw.   "  
I-IRR? No,59 «S~3 _1999i--- smrxg

BETWEEN:

AEUN BHAEERAO }£xfkzi;<i!3§::'}£:[§':A§""  '
SENCE DECEASED BY *;,Rs.,L__  ;

1, SE\1IT.I\/IANGAL}:'£3E\Ji-3§§{UIN7f K2':E§;%?'§{A§;  
M33: MAgn;>R,'~'{3ir:<:: =§_iOgL§?:3~}E<3E~E<f)i;§}',« .. 
E50 ARUN'--BU{%$?<_3ALQ'é?  _V _ 
NEAR :1 5R§{£_.EﬁR[¢5:Y'*V--G,A'?E§-   V V'
T§LAKWAQI,"'§1§§LGzsQ34  «-

ax .§i\;EETV.13;Rﬁ:"§'x§   
z§GEf'_EfVI§a.JCé§:g :'T':~:»':"iJ,;Qg%;r~.ﬂi

3:\zi'§*..?1j;;;:*: P:vPUEE._ K;»:,%<;:;:*%;;aR
5%§3'E:: _%'%sEéXJ:}'?.,_{}€$€: '3*:'a:sE,m.

1.")

  , 5B?'%%UE:¥§;%:€.A§U:x? E<AKA'T'Kﬁ:R

'  'i::G§;':..,§;;"§;g%:3'R---,_ ecc: :S'E'UﬁE:E\§"€,

* ﬁé2ivS55'L*"--§:-Eéifx m;<;;::§:<;%R
§;4£:§:ﬁ_;v:::aJ~:~:>R? 653$: S"§'§j§E%~§'E1

L} i

"  S§E'f;§:%RE'A?§B£E WK}. BI%zi:UE;¥3 §x:;§<g?;<;%§a§

 A' ;£,.-:::gE:; Maggg, @953: RQUSEHQL

   £§éUE\E B?€;%U%%@ §<;AE~:£--'»JS§{A1E€;

 AGE; f's%§;§GR; GCC: §{}S§?€ESS;

A    RA§:f§?2E§§%7 R913 %;!%;9§A'§%£:":§?

ESE: §\:l%:§{}R§ {}C{§: BE§i5§i'§;E%i'?;a



 

:3:
§R§ER

?h€ RS beisifaﬁn 33:6 31:3:-:1:":i€s 'who am ztiiaisd {Q 625:5:-.»@'ih€r

is perzzéing fer G16 past Si y€a:/'S and {E26 §%3puj;§__ : €Ea:%;<3.s'"~tf:>

sviéciiim p:*0c::€€ding$ in §"€Sp€C§ of a prémise b€a:*i:.1_ g E'€33€;§'_}% V'

situated at Beigaurz: Town'

2. "file pariiss 5:36: :°€:§5rr€.<:'é 5:; as pk'; '€n€i:* 3."é{f';f%<;§§: 1:§1_é3s ifiaf»

cauri.

BACKGROUND or THE

3. Ths landierd izzitiajqécé_e\§i_{§t.§i91':'"p:4o'$_§§:§i::g$ againgt the ?€3;SG§1fi€E1€;/t[€§13:%ﬁ:"€::§ddEi'::%€Cti§gf'1 'ghs Kamaiaisa Rem:

Canimé Act, 2ié§;.:;_iﬁ, ii§§:§<:;:§7§ii;f 119239 ':55 me sf Munséf Ceurt, Belgaurnf 'E'he7 Ex3iCfi:f> f1'«.P§ti:ie:1 Gama E0 ':36 dismisged by an aide: daisai {%7?z$;2 V1"~;§3_}*--*§.. '"--»§gg:'i%:v€d 3:3}; 8213215? }:a.:2£ﬁo::*GT fﬂsd a §€'%?iS§G':f; Petiiéézé V_iV§:V§€.;--R;{Z, Ne.C?7§ 298%. Thé saié. Rsviséon ' §:?1?f_'{ZE'i§€j.{}':'E/'»7;j;1-$3 aiéawea' ::I:':':i' a:*d€r daiecé QEKSQ, E§8é Cams :3 be $6? :;:s:E:'§:':Tzéi:':.diV"€E*:§~;».'i:::_2:=£a;€§ Cgmﬁ to "$5 ramaaéaé bf; {he Qsvésimisl Cour?' $0 }i§,'E_*:j"'é;'§:"i':'§ Cour? far éégpsgai aff€S§E in accarcéamss wéﬁf:

iggv by <}r~~rie'2:£af{e<i §?,§é,§@8f;y Q22 suah mmand bang made 'fay ﬁts Rsvésiaaai Cguri, '::*5%<:é§ar: paiitiaa was €(;n$éd€:€é affssséz bf}: :32: 'aria? £01232 'sfg " ""33 a3:*d5:* éaliedi %.Z%ii§;2,1i§9'f3 %i;":€ §3'--J§€;'§"i{}:E gzeiéiiasa éiisé mzcief V»-«o\ S:i%<:%:§{2-_ 2'i{E}{E:} 15:: be a§,%<;2=w~:<': iii: 33:": €::*&%::*§:1g ggartigé Qvécﬁezz and hoééifzg 'ihai {he peéiééenergﬁianéigfé was €r;'i1:E§& {G evéci {E16 i'€S§}O1"3§€I3€S frag; :<JEsi€:":: haéf gité §@r*;iC;»:j1..{:f.;sV<:'§'f3L%::€ii*:3i€ pr€:21:;$€$ 313$ rssponéantsfisnani wag éirecisé EG"'}}aIvE§§-.Qi/€':f"'if§€ vacaztrz pegsesgéen {>5 '£126 sams w§f:%;-'if:A ':%':':5€'..:n<;:1ih::_ frcrré its data G5 ihe OE'<j.f:':f.

S. 5% Grisevéd 'SKI this saiéi. Ezriiai %:'V§€*?:§.0_}1 éa:'&€::' daiéfi 2:: ¢ V' __ ;

§9eE2;E9§7 bot}: §a::d§o:*C2.__and.V'"':'ér':éif;§Eiisd r§vi's§:'}%:i petitéans befgré the First Add}. 'Belgaum. The f€S§:}Gf1§€I1tSf§€§}.8\IZ:?;: fiijiédjb ?\'::=.§;' 1998 and géstitéaner/1g::d5Eé":_=ci 5;"19§8. Gm ailawing the appiicatierzs-vfi1ié:£ ;$a;§"':i§%s"§f0r aédiiienai evédsnce by sensent, z=e22§*sio:':é§f¢:{i>1As%i*t»T.rﬁ§;L2;;§¥i§:e:i EZx,P~M is EX.P=~,28 on behalf 91? {ha jgetitionéyf§é_::ﬁ;§Qf§iLa:1ﬁ%'_.'LEx;R8 is EX.R~E6 G3': behalf of Ehﬁ __§"€Sp0:f3§ﬁ€§}§i:€/fﬁiiéiflii.' 5132:? aftér sgasiésring ihfi azgumsnts V_ac§.a%a::;€:ﬁ._ Egg E§L3*:~:f:3erf: aévacaiss appea:*§::";g fer parties} '$3; <}§'d€!' d7§3::r;is3€§ ihe f€'§éS§.<}E1 getééien %E.R.C;R. V .§'€0§f'.E'§§§$:§§::'§i bf; €316 Esnaézi and zzlieiaréd E~LEa€.R. ?*EC:.EEf E'9§8 . "f'i §:€§ ihé i§€i§§§C3ﬁ€}"f Eanéisgrd _ :6}. Aggriavéd by {ha abasze srdﬁrgf, {E16 '$622332: ﬁisé "=..__ '§€;s:§r §,3é0:: Fsziéiasﬁs 'befaszra this iiourt in ?€€n5§--8;"'i9§§ a::C§ f'}99;'E@§€}. '?h€:'s;€ évaxo r€aI§s;i<f>:%z §3€:i';'22§é;";§:*;:~; 3:2}? €:»t'€_§€r:' ciaéeci ZE%».€i2,2@:$3 aaméz {<2 33%: 5:§f':L1fIE§SS<'"ii"§, i§g§f:;€¥'€{§. '$33 same, 1 , r€S§3G?E@€ﬁi;;gE€§:8iE:: pysffsrreé cm f3;§}$€§/ii §'*~E<;as,"?if§*2'.2:;2:

ow no §. is Sugpert GE rsspészéve Ceﬁisﬁtians, §a:'°ti€$ ':§15:(E€z'€:d iheir svéésnce zzanaeijg petitismsr gs: hémseif €xa:::in~s.¢i_» azzd 9339 examizmd 031,6 witnsss :1a:::e1j; his br<:::th€:=,as' I?"i5§»2 552:; '' go: r::arke& EXECL :0 Ex.P~1C» b€fQf6iv.:?ﬁ%€:"§1"iEiiE'.'C@U?§é..Vé1f¥§§v"§€i'§Gf€ {he revisionaé Cour': by Way :3? ad,gii':i<>:1af.._ svédencsj_'j;f)$'£i%:i:>:1€:rSvgétu marked EX.P~iE is EX.P~2€). §V€f.§V§;<2?:"{3§f' '3i: ;?¥?§C1f§G1');V p1'QC€€C§iI1gS} origiaaé resp<§;3§i€:1EV*ééqéiyff-?éidV }§:':;_@ his: '1éga'§ 1r:eirs was an recerdz by order datézﬂé thérsaféerwsrdsg Re$p0:1d€n£: No$.?1é# an rscsrd. G21 bshaif Gf :es§5f§$§@:ié'.~-3--':;;<§n:%;: .._§V%§"~~ti}é4'$é:"._fe§pondenis namely EA :9 EH Of atismey holdar and an €rr:p1<:;§'T<$e'*:§.?asv '--R:'%/'\;"'»«i Whg was an Accauniant in the :63 <3»:/;<:I.ué:'11:+';<:~..fa<Vi::.<:::*'~;. " Threu h the said wiinsss 'wafers éhe . _ -_ g .._:1i*;aE iZT.<'£%.§':::,3~E;V?:"1'*?38p(?é$C?E€Z%I"3;\'v£v$ gs? marksd EX,D--§ :0 $X,§~? and S€§G?€ V:E::<§'::§é;:3f;a3:3aé €ia:>ar:; by away Qf aédiéionai evééerzce éhey gm:

. _ ;g3.é;':éeé';*.

méﬁééa « §f§:,f;:g.8_ 2;; ' 2%;

T!_C%".V Eéearci ihs i<3:s;:'§:e& aévaicaézss &§:3§€8.Z'§i"Eg 5:3: 'ihﬁ Szré Ravi G. Sashsaiéia fiaazinszif 535233386} a§§ea:*§::g on .._4E;~r:§*:5£%f :3? 'aha :'€3§3«:>né€1":§;'€;€::ar:i: zmuia' 176?}? fairéy gdsnéé aha: in 'Si; 53:" as ins paytéaé €iV'iC'{§.Q§1 aha: 533235 E; ha paggszé 'sf; {E26 aria}. 501:1"? wE:§:::h was qégegtéegad by 32%": é22a:":d]s:>rd_ §€§R,€3E.

2 x' fAs$~ / 2 wet on €QE'§'€C'Ef1€SS 0? ézéai <:§u.§':?$ erﬁsr 0f aazktéiori in r€sp€C: Qéher ?{}fEi§E'3,, 12» Per cazzira, Sri A,G,R%uEawaéma:h; ':ea§;:e<;"i"€<i§:,1::S§4::_§::r tbs geiitiansrs, éraws the atisntien @f {his Ce_:i:§%: é=:% §§sa~.4u ' fermulated by $326 iriai csufé: 3 whérsunder it has been heid; that §:}€i'i£i@:1€:is.A,.afé' :*1;ini:é:r1gg é::'a::sp:m: buszlnsss and hag awn 'S-7§§C§{S anéjl .i_.$ 'a:ES-G iséskizig after' 'ihfi ?:§'3.i'1SpQ§"'E business xx/*e1':VEV:dE évﬁbméi that trial cam': having aa:<:<:p:£:=:&# cef the landlard and ha§r';»--;>:;eg;,%é*_;e€i<§¢%§6L 'C;3mmi::€d a serieus SFFOE' in :efuSi§ig :._'{.:<g%" respsci ef esntérs scheduk "'s:E'€*3"""I"'v€§3'\/'iS§€}1'Ii. namely E£.R4C.R§ N935] :20: Gméy examined £12636:

aspecis wE:i1€:4-..a::a,Ej;zi;:g*.E§s::;1%: N04 ﬂamed 'my the irtiai gear: at

-V,parag;'é;§;léA'E>?&EE; "::}'iltV__a__§E1;~;) Cams ':0 g camciusien that pstitioney ".':«sqf;:7§~:'::Vs 'fE1€.'§€f{%"iv%§H schésduéa §E"ii'--E1fiiS€S far 333 5>GE"i& fﬁaié 2.3.86 ané :}{:<;%:pa~:i0§": .:.{:*:.é;V':{§3 SEJCE'; $26 erdar 95 {he zaviségyzaé cams? é0€s $2.0: :::S.E§ fez: §f1%£€f§€?€E§C€, B6 avouié 3380 Szsfﬁméi: 'aha: rsarésgésngé "'C}.;}1;??f.E'18.S "3:3.]:<:€Q ézgia ceasicieraiéaré fséxaa subssqusni €Ef€§iiTiS 333:3 _' »::a§:r:%::E5,:"' 'aha paiiiisﬁer 35266: 3%? {?'u'.CkS ané accazziéngig; haﬁ Ezéiﬁ ' ";g:re:§1:§@n€r E"*$€§'L3;if"'€S €315 §e*:%':§<3:: Schséziie gremissg $23': its ezzéifsiyz " E16 wauid aha guémii $231 gjezéiiarzsr isﬁafit Ezave neiiézar paié {E23 §"<f:'§1'£i~; ézzséng £375 §:,>r3':zt:Z¥$;§:{:§£ {>5 ihﬁge Raivésion ?<~':!ié=';i$::s; rm? :13: C1€§{i3S§§fid. the S3316 bsfaze tfrzis C332": anti as Susi: R€;é§ss__;§a1":a P€:i::§$n aré 133%: maintainablsg 8:: these gmurzésg he E133 fey digmissai of the rgviséan peiéiians with exe:::§§ary.g:*£;sts:;

13. Having hearé the isarrzed é7:xdvQ§{;éL:§:é§'~__ag:$;:e§:'§.rz::»g:L"fﬁij parties and having perussd the 0zj{ie_:f; péisshéé "by in the eariier 1'{)L1:1£'f{S of iitigaiiczn, as $315 'H§§»*'i':E1e revisianai caurt and the er:§;¢§..e£§i§'%iiir¢c:io§§é; iééued tine Henﬁble Aggx Ceulft, this 'E :$_ View that feilewing paints ;'s.:'*§s§:V1" fQ:*: _ c{;;x'%:V?;§ici'€,*»:A{:é2L;i;§:C;::V I these zevision peiiiiensz 1, *s!*;hetr:er% ﬁ;':-;~«V:gn:::Tcmj"'bgzsaﬁde and reascsnabiy reqﬁirg 'ihs Te::_fii§é'v;>éii%;:&2. "schedu§e geremises fa:

his ownizse' ar§:iv._oé:%§#pai»§on?

2V..»'.5é§&f§';e"'i?:e§ %:%n*ie'--..%§;f}_2g_;}?, Eras made cm: 3 sass far pafféi évigtian as srdefeé by trial £20122? and side: %;;a[s%se;:a:;:%%T;;;:aa 533,35/1998 is 2:; be set aside 0? "%V:or;:Fs'm%é;:-;:a'A'Ti1ém seﬁsegueisiiy, Heap i%Is.5i9§i€§§9 53 $3: $35 ééésxazeé es' dismissed?

V'Q%:§$hs¥ the mast gassed $5': HRCRP i'~%§.§i'§§§% _ Kjiaied 3'§.G3,'§§§Q« ﬂy {ﬁe %'€if§$i€3I'33§ aszéﬁi ?S§i§§%'§$ E ' "is be esséfirmeﬁ er reveyseé?

ﬁﬁhai Giééf?

1% :4. 93% £313 ahexas paizzts 'aging iniar-Eizzigad '%E¥i'¥;§fE €3.62}: sihgf and 322:; ﬁzadiizg gisazsr': am 3:26 §§:"::::'£ ::22*:3:2§,é: svsziagt; wéiiz 52313:; they 3% 2236:: 121;} ii3§€§3€I' £9: csrzsiészaiéegz, :13: E5. '§%:<s: §€{:%:§<>n:3r E3325; gisackscé 13:2": 'aéia E15 reqzifrss p€'i?;i'£i€_§f(2 ssheéuis Qremises in its ergtirczijgsi---fi3:Af:::i§=?2:im,a', ﬁafe 'J36 amﬁ eccupaiiozz. E}; has b¢e.:?:,_sf;a€::é "E::$:A;-Vcéé-i3:r:

Fatitien ihai §J€§}:€ii}E1€fF is dang Era:§~vsp:€:*tA~ psssesséag Ehrsé tzucks and désirss tG'i*:a2~f:: :T1C:I'€; Lf11{:kS am?' intands $0 start his awr: RKiOFkS§}O::}"':i%:3».:§2'C.§§1C§. .3i.'G"'L;.if1:v€:'AI'§}v»":?8iI'S of hi8 trucks which is e$s€n:iai ._p:§c::si-S sf materiala and Eabsur ané as agch, :vS"C .heduk: premises, it is aise gasgséss any ethar suitabéé he car: star: his own bus§ness;,Ya::_d'_A 1':j V§i':«:«'-'.,._ii'3§_€'c'gﬁé3;:'£ that ha réquirss petiéisn scaeﬁuie fsmésés Eﬁrxsiiidé---..{o":" Ens own use and seem atien. 9 . M -- . K! § 3%. Secéiazé 2?;{E_}.§h3'«.;3f {ha Karaaiaka R63: Cantrsé Asa

- »:§é}_:'<§i<3:<'iS'a$ un§é:":.~.. _____ " .V ".?Sv€'{.i__}(h} $233? 'the premises are reasenabiy and requéreé by the éandéeré fez GC{iE.£§ai§€3§":

'§:§%g'>3sé§f gr any parses ifs! wages bezseﬁfi iﬁe }:>§%%m%Ses are 56% as' where the ianéieré $3 g trustee ef 3 §:;b§%<: ¢%:gz%ia§%e émsi, ma': the gseméseﬁ age §'§qé§¥?=f§§ is: Q<:Ci,£§§§.'§S§"é far {he gwgﬁges as" 1:523 Twat; gr EEC ii': {:16 '@a<:kgrou3::€§ Q5 S{£%iE§ES§fy' ;:i:<;ﬁ;és§::s:::; E326 gzésagééagg anti éxamifzezé. wiéavizzg géeaéed 3:132: ;;2:3:%:i<}1": éscxcéciuié: §*;?€§§.'}§E%€fS is; ,E,"€*C.§E§§.f"ii{f: 5:3»? Eﬁig aE"i§. acazgpaiéenﬁ pétééionar saéersé $316 W§E§:€SS bax and isgésrﬁd his €2»*i&€::::€: as PWEE;

:12: pies-Qésd is the §@H:}w%::g sf§€c:'i:» _ V :~8.

"--«.:i':*: é.6:*:~ V:?i'§.'Eé'f'iCJ'?"§«E§gf €ej;>a5' '£4. E am dcing the werk of transpori..':a?'genT'i; :{%1"' ﬁemmissiors basis sinc:_eg§S76. E"oii_.fn "twé. trucks. My brather Gwns Ewe :t§.';l'Cf+:S4j._§ 'La tf§'1'--.io4::§.<'§vr:i;g: f after the trucks sf my V§:.r__o1::h_g.r is? ;_{=;s'§;e::€ transport businessj' {hays ﬁe"E:j§:3Qé§::ie's';1?:"i§f§§r;é far my business: Repa1i'r's;€0 agar véfsiizifgsn' aréfgbeing attended by V A_roae_:i éééé, abgfeﬁotévv of the peiéce and thaed é_T§':<:rj':3xg%*r}:;e:1}§'ée:V:%.V'bV§""ihe pubiés; 1 require the :peii»t§«:::>*n Vprem§é?es.f(§E'.running my tra_éﬁ:s;§;:.:t Gfficeiaﬁﬁ 'ft:»:f_V;*~:.§§j13:2:§r§V.;1g the vehicles: ";*s_"ijy %ha-- side cf read, even tfiegfé '§§;;p§_)SE~_ijbé!_i_'£V§LeS 'sfigsiiing gsods, i have :19 _ p_:9é«m§s¢e;§vQf my own Ea Beigaum exceﬁ ééie pet§:ii_QnT'prsfm§s--es. In 19%? 1 was awning ﬁne %.g<;§< amé :%:%,z"%::{sﬁhe§' was ewaéng iwe imcks. My traﬁs-géﬁfé buéinesg has S683 expanéeé frem 'iha: gear {iii ii is mi psssébie fer me te .§;: *:iimse the regairs and té sasztimse business maﬁ giﬁe. %-ieﬁceg E reguira ééze geiéiésn ' pfemises."

3:: éiéize Cress sxanairzatisgz £%2.1:€:d C§f§.G8.E§83 i: has 533?} am? ?x£%E§~52'28§ aﬁé ?x;'1}C§.»«5§§?.

{imgfzasés s:::p;:r§€ec§ 5;; me} __ "":>::-::?;: €Z'>£Z'{E"8;C€€é a%: paragraph ':5? xvhereuzzﬁeé PW»: E38 Sfﬁiﬁé a3 iljéy '§¥'"§}C§<: numbers as ?\2E,XfL»~§24?, §v'§}<§.: 3:3? 3? $2633 €925" \x'§§":§$§%$§ we éseésécée is giaaéiiag 5:1 my game and 1:: his €Xay::iz:a:i0:1»~i:§~C%:§ef,31¢ hag :14: giaisii :15: his sariéezzcé namééj»; <::<:am.%;aatéen--i§--chf£€;fV_:"€g§ -._'aha feiiawing a3§f€Ci::~ '£2. Petéticsner Es éoing t:ff§vnspasft--"'c;:3§%§s:1i's"éEoi:} agent business, He is §n:: pos»§éss§i:x_[n belonging to him and aEso»'§:~ne:?--.§ﬂé'hic%é ..if§eE:mg" my and cne vehic¥e"é§f'----.yeun'g€=rV' §3rot§§:;e :9;.:._'v«-vS;;:z§e 'mere is no buifdmg fo'§5L'*.h:'§%s Iofficég. g{e daé$ that business by ihegédg <3? €iV§":'fe r::}3'§iV 'C.?:avan 'Aé.:'to"Mabiie garage was céoséii is ?2 years back" in shat ve{};..p:f;e~m§ses:.,La gjiafrts Shep was open. ;§\f§§$§3_i§ anici my ~;§E)ung}é';j'-:fi;r0_iEjé;Ar by name '2/itha! wer§,%"'§§%L:=.§§Vi:§§~ --:fté:'«.§§ta:i"é'>gS*?he$s it' spare parts, En that sgare.Vgé-:*'is_;§hv0;{_:2wrf:éa':'b§{ ii} vtiéwere is as space fss' the re;éVa"ii":?.z;§ sf' veh--:'<:§e"' . :(Vl1:?%?T"£'£Ei?';'£>:C£F>'fVZtSi~-;S';:;1.'-i3j9ZZ.é'3& by me; E': thé $:*§sss'+:3;:2:;;:f::é:3at§~§§r:§ nething wsrth whﬁs 2:9 disczsdif: '€213 S8,_§5'«:§vi:§1e§3 E:aé'§:>$e.z2« '€E::§{€@, ._;-2%?! ~. T'§f3é §}3§§5£iGﬁ€f has pzeéucsci tbs é€)CU;§§f}€1E3:S §E31'E'1€i}F E:{;§3»8~-..__:ta whésfh, am iééé aizjsuments éssuﬁé iafg ﬁgs " }' "?§é'g1'.Qn3£ 'E":f@;:"1sj:3<§z**: Authoréégr nameigr Riff; Beaks? §€§'§"§E§?:S, maﬁa "?ér.:::éi;s_get:'§ 'as ézfiéancé '£16 fad: ihai 8536; afsirzéclég are sanding "--3Z:::_.€:_E_§e name 0:? gciiiiones ané Bis b:'o:Zne2"§ namﬁéfi PE'?-E ané ~ éiwgge 2:; "$26 geéiiiersfaf w%1i§€ :#§ai::z2:'.;:':g;: :;3€3SSEii§S§€:EiE ca? 311%: psiétiezé $<:%:€é':2E5 prérzzéayss 33:}: his; Eaarsczfiﬁé and {}€€'zji§3«8f§i{}E2 :*$q::::5,:":':{§ 21:3 313$" s3e:§a:% E1865: wqészss :15: Qaniégus 1:9 exégé, Thé said ciaém £3 :0 be examérysﬁ 33 :0 wheihey E: iii: 5922a ﬁdé ans? gsnuirze. Th»: P§o:1'b3.€ Suprsms €czu;'?:--___§an Ehs sass af BHE1¥iANAGG'U'BA BAsA2~:A€;o:IDA 9931; 1?sL'}=§§:<.';§i+£.;B. §UDUSAHEB repaztﬁé in (2003; 3 Supreme so:;.'£:t C,fa';:?'ejsT has hﬁld as under:« 'The cams beiewg ha\JingpA:'§<:_3:}=.--1_5éA'(thé»"é3Af§d!.erd'§.: ". " claim fﬁf eccupaiieti "-~;;b.e§ng"~ geﬁuérggﬁ' «fw-%':e.Ei_e cgrzsiciering the quesiégﬁ'v°é3§_V Campa%ai§vé'ﬁardghig, Qught is have '"i'a_ken ;'§é'€IéteVL.:§sf "'iLhe hardéhipdv éhe Eandéord weuid scgupyéng his eswn premises asvV-3§;ajzi.ns§. fme the tenant x:veuEd;s:§ff§f;§5 'by §§;a\;§5_1g~{0 ?"}'"i=3::i.iéV'€Z}vLE_if___'{V%2' another p§ace. Th§s"w§%g«sV '*Eh e"'9;o'i:_:fi:3,V_E".>eEow, The District __J_uég'~;.~'; éc§€3,§_de:"e_G"' §:*:'§:;"th_;e; affiuence cf the Eandisrd wé:h 0*"ufv_..c_§3r'V§sVEﬁe.:vi.h'g v_ fhg hardshép :3? having is .;co7niEn'L::% V§:é ;::;:~.V:'e§}ié::§ £i:.euse? whiie the High Cam": tick 5 €;s:i§:5fa§%$':§n§'_.:2§ew ézx %ega:rd ia the bang Ewes ' " Q? ifzé ,'3%;s_'éhV'a$eV'::>f the Fzgase by ﬁne iandmé, ét afsa i,_"2'i§§§" E'}§i :*e'a?'§'f%"'"%;9:2'i§are the §3a§d3§:%§ if the iwa in the §§'SSS§"%% saga féie csmpagative %*%é;;f§_j§'%;;;§;:>"3:%:ai may be saffesed by 3&2 éandimd wéii Ea v_vg*:%;é{':é§ ihasé $33: 9:' ihé iengzsﬁ, ﬁne faﬁ 'ma? 3 pargoa has {he sapaséty is p§3E'€:)§"§38E ihe prsgeriy :r.:a:'::"§:;>': $3 €316 geie gmzmﬁ ':2: .?:§§§ agaéﬁgi the iaﬁﬁiéfﬁ w%"':i§e dgcéﬁéng Eéﬁe qagesiisa §'? Qsmgazatixsg §?§i"§S§'§§Q= if ihe pagcézase $3 §L§%'S§.§8¥2§ is 3 gsmsiﬁe Weed? $5 iéwé iarzéioﬁ me 332% §i3?€§33$€ has is $3 g§'»;E?"; we weégiééage amiesa 9? €:G§.§{$€? §":% ﬁagcﬁase is acwaieﬁ $3; C:Q§%a%§§a% caagiﬁaaéien, in $313 éaaiaai @239? 599%: {ha 2-éégh {:%§L%%'? 352$ 'me §%g:§§Q§ >, ,/v xx E;

Cam'? ?7§:.s%:'1g Lsgheid ihai: Ciaém sf the Eandwrd as his 'ssﬁa féde rzeeé umer Seciéen 2m>(%:)§ cauiﬁ not have derzieﬁ ihe relief $§§e%y er: {ha 'V' that as is an affluené gersgn. Rae appe_i.%an_§":3.uciéiéz _ under Sesiécm 2'!{1){h} be§ng"57oha.f§d'§2§ %;i2e; $ia§n}e"- game'; be athemsise §@{ ihé':.'pa;--.%j§oée ':5? 23(4) ofthe;'1\ctf' gpagss 9, ?s,»'g*gAm§__%;

22' in the backgreuné abévs sf the §~£<;sn*§:ﬁe 31.l§1"€i1TE€ Caurt, 1«1fh::§: petiiésner and (evidence tsncisréd, svidenca am sxamined as bong: ﬁdes in tbs: claim put' ' The materéai avédéncs ;>r0duced_~' t *{,2i'r{;:;;:~1'; cleaﬁy egtabhsh 'that petéiisnefsfécféim reascsnabies Admitéséiy {E13 peéitisn schséiiZ%;.11€§3r€2:f1isr:s§ E.§.7'i0ca*:€d> in a csmmerséaé hub and it «is €:1§LS:':}~3g. azti' induséi-*iai______a:€a anﬁ the requjrémsnt Whig}: ihe ':Gﬁi}:Vi1'{Z*'(Ti'«Ei'.§3'<;1.:?$"§j}§§;E?.'C§€§§ ?:§:'if:§€}}7 :3 COﬁ";IE'i€§"}C€ iranspazrt 'm.:s%::€$s? *:2a:0':,;:E§--.,§ii ififizz :3: {Guy CGI"1'€}€E'S ':3 E33 requirernsent T3333; $311: nﬁsé; gf*:d zﬁaéﬁi of '%:%:e §€':§f:§€:::::€2f is gsizuine ami Eana jida 253:." v §§'s gagging: ibis ciaéra of {he Ear:d§s::s:é,§ €318 rsggenséeni fdﬁxzslszi ihe regjaiyemﬁgé {:25 3&5 §=€i§€§Gf:€§ if; fééing S§a'f:a5::T}€E2?: sf Gbj€C§iGﬁS; has for this rsaseas 'baa: §<:::£}'Ef£E'i3 . _ ¢§%:ss?;;:§a?§; §T";§1'Z?":§€é'ff§§i€E"€?';"1, é::";'5€::€::';g hate 335: i?£'§?;Z'§ﬁi§S isex amii iszzcizsz" észéaﬁﬁﬁcé, {E22 {E35 €f2%:}E€3E' Ezaitzd, :::z:;:;k>jgi%e Q5 12%;': seggggﬁésaé 'bx: 3:6. Eighwzzézas €'§"2iti'3if'%3i§ *%5:é%:z3$s;:e; E:><>:<: aésd :E8:

else er: §?eer:e-SengeEe§'e seed the ehee Qhavers Ame Meeilee ie Eeeeéee, ! ee me: knew ereeéeusiy if %he_;e was cézexzan Auto fviebiie gerege Es": its eéeee. §?:_4%e _:€r2,;:e~.V_ frem ihe eegineing tee eetiiéener has got ﬂee) it Ee false te suggest that petétienefj experience ane knewtedge of__re.pe_Efing_*ee'iereeb%V¥'ee§_' AIV do net knew E1' the eetitiﬁ§':er:..hee f autemebéie business since 6 evf? fears; §.€:!.t;f est ' if the petitioner eeee eééfepeiy \é?<ii:'ke efVVA{?2.e 'f:;aT%1'e;:3ejri vehicieb Et is true pe§EtEe§5er..::e-q_giree'eereméeee for repairing transpe4§i'~e_veh_i'e§eeV; 1%; .§e'~-t:ue e éeeewn is required for Eeedihe;_eneE>-eve§ee:f§ﬁeV"_'geces. Ei ie a§so true an effie_e Se :e'q"u;r:.-ie fe;<._fu.n::Eﬁ.gfeeﬁspert efﬁce for eureeiée <§f»e'e'eekVi'agf; §t is {n,:eE§'e'::~e;3e:E$ repairing and eeéemggbig"e'eare"'V;§er§e;§e%r§eee* ere in meaty at Fert ,.~reedVB,,§g.é3;;:;m_. ' ' I 25}; 2"ee';uci.:E:2_g"~€;f"»i;19:e__ eeéire eresswexaminetien weuld Cj%€:8§1§ esta'eE§eE: :Eet".fpe:i¥;iee:1er requizee eeeeremedetien for V I'il§'I'i1§;1i:§;g'v 'efe::;epe:7: effi<:e33 premises {or fepeieéixg zrenepert x:<i:A'::§<:;»1e::., fer Eeeﬁing eed Igzﬁeeéfelng ef ﬁne geeﬁee Tige eeié"-T'__ezéé':e;e'ee_ eﬁzeéie in éhe eéeve exireeieé erase- €X&:'f:§.'Z'7:8,E3:._C§f} .%;1§ef{ t:?*e,::see;{°'€ business; Eepeéring em} euéereebiie ""*..e"i;;e§e peﬁe buezleeee eye in péeeiyﬁ es: §'er: Read, Beégezzezg " iéee geéeee e/§1e:"e eeheéuéi: ﬁe Eeeeieci, '$39 '=..e,:_e,er Wéineeeee Exeve beer: exaeaéizee' ez": eeheif :35 she ..'ree§::ez::%ee§e, ieeég {he eheiegeegﬁze gsreiiuced éuréng 'See ef ergemeeée e? eeeezfe revieéee ¥€§L%{%:%(}§/ES} ii?'{}"£.3i§,€§§: Efeeét :'ee§ee:iee%,:~; Eéeizze {he eeéé §E'<'.f§'E"':'§'E§6S e. , M"

:2§;

és hesaggsg W§":€E'€ iése Eanéiaszsaﬂ whs has p:em§3e5 a? his am": am éiakes a premises 0r§...§.é ia1A:§é__; L- V be wauié be unde: pergeiuai ﬁbres? Qf @%.2%::%:'§:5n his §and§©r§g ﬂzerefareg ﬁne» may'"p's*éfs¥ 'éQ"., camprsmise and give up genie §fp'_t;E:j5ejfakzjééifiéfs'--:5;'h--§c%3_LLA'V A he may; in the mime? ¢§r§umé;f.adc§s, §iké €:_0A fer eacugyfng his own"Tg3jfé-:r;1§sesA":har2V s<ﬁ:up3£§ﬁ'g~..a seated gremises. Thesé"'v«a:fe_V:he 'sieaiiéfs wéaéch Canmi be weégﬁaﬁj xn.!é_tTn "ﬁg-§'h@:%iLai'§CaI ekécfiéuée» The Cwrts wéii §i§\ge- ':§f;€ o".V;aVCcGunt bread grobabéiitéas Q!" re;:--§§i§.e$=Qf 'E-%fe.__ v_st}éié':§ earlier% the su§tab§§'ity"'j;VjV§§f the =iQ:'€:§:{¥':i:S'v8$V --v'iLE>§v...ETé'<Z§i,3§E"E3§ to be cor:'sEVdé3r:e:d"- thé§-i:§t3:sV{t"' _of:v¥y fax ihe pumose Gf V_e_;§a:':*aé:}'i'§*;g:«1.;32$ .5?:€3:*»'?j%3;V 3'}"(gié.'%<;§V'VQ:T.§V gemsineﬁeas sf}? the c:a;:;é'::;fV:hg ;gna':r;:@_.'f_ % 2'? {fig LO be*.né:.é;Cé:+d.""i%1é:£ I'€SpO£1§.€f}¥:S havﬁ admizteé ané <,*<>r:ce:é;j:C§' 'chat: i%§::§,§ Vézéreuiti bs Satisfied with, parééei evictisn as <:>f€:i5::'€&i :E2_€*i;'§al COU.?{'§L ﬁzés aizeuid. cisarify" gar} éie Show that 3:§'iE'.1"$VS§} ¢¥f'ii§;:'%*;'f'§f€;' éérgazzég am $30 accspiéiag that pséitian scheduie premiéaas ifs' :'5§*So:*:abE}; ané §<::»:rz5zjE&e requires? by ﬁns iandéards _ 7€§?E€ifr. ' 59:/2:: ﬁde 33.36 and Gcczgggzmn Eﬁd ihéa :é:;.;37<;:v:%%én:;'t€na22t samnet h,a<z5 griavaacs rsgard ':9 vlféiiglﬁfﬁﬁéﬁfki piaaégsd E33»; £16 Qéiéiiﬁﬁﬁf, 28, Exiarasd Ciéuzwsi 50:" éhe tsnaéai: wezjéé Cﬁﬂiﬁﬂé 'aha? 'E g::a:'::%a§ s:xsi<:1:i<:;r: axis? wzéicéz @3632 33.3333; E35; {E26 E::"ia'é ceugfi wag 313.3%; ané g_:}:":i>§3€:' éié :25}: 5:53? {C}: azgy é;::i:{:§§§:f€?:{:€ iiy 33%: rsaégiiérzaé {§é'}§.3i§E zmcf; 325; sszzsh} c<>§;i62":::i$ aha: e:>:*r:§s:» :22: Eeeing heeré 'iﬁe ieemeé adV{}Ca,€ee epgearizrzg fee geertiesg it Weuéé be neceeeaiy 'ﬁe mete ﬁle decéeileim. ef '5h.i'e}"-CeL::'%: in ihe Case ef R¢$(}%i1i':E'€Lz%,L gaze ve, 2:4.eeeeeeeeee._:?c;e'e;¥I%:ee;=«%;: 2993 :3; Kare LJ. 351; wherein 2: is we ee enee';«¥.:_} ' "E3, ...... ..The abject iiﬁebrrxd. '_e"::ie:i5:geV':'».;.;eft'§e:§= evictien is is pretest a :e:%'ee'€1'\_éve:":e ﬁe'~net_.'eb«fe~Eie i7.A secure euitabie aitemate eceemV_n€edai§:3~ri'%'e§'ﬁ§e§ fer warn: of er ave§¥ab§Eét§f"ve«e.e7f'e.aeeemmVe'ee§éen"'v;ermen eeeeurzi ef hie fénenciafV-e~ee$:re'%nise Ae'ebeee;}ed by me earéierg ih§s'«-_ée" rgeﬁ thge ;_n the case on hand. The tenefﬁg iTe._ea§}V_eVbf§»e e§.Vfin.§_ia.§_'.-gut aétemate e:'em§e.e:s ene as 'me 'eaiiéere eftemative e§e--m:E»eee:A;j: :_wered'e§"e§iab_£«e.f«'. 'nxﬁiefeiy because the ieéujneQd;V;»Sme'i5'€;}ét§:.$e_§i'udge;, in the course ef the 'eree:i;:, r;a§§§"ebfse:};;ed i'i}£e:*§"§he Eandiezd weuid be e--ai§efie'd":i;ss'i:f: »etv§4'§ee.eA§r-eétiieee measuring 8 x 23', it 'eemet :ekee'.e-sjeetntege 0? by the 'seneet, is my xzieiegwe ihe e*:e§e" gudgmeai with iefezeeee ie the V__L'ex;v§eenee'«e.e_._.:eee:'d ie eemeee; it is ebvieueéy e éyeiingverrez. instead ef $6' X 232 it has eeee :"eferree ' 23'; Furéh :1 {he ereméeee €"{':€3SE,§f§ﬁ§ 315' X _23~'L_eer: §'E€\i€%" be eeneéeeree ee e very éerge V"'V.p{'ee:ieee. Tee eviceee eeiiiiee is G? 'me gee? @283. :The deveieemeeteé eeevéiéee fee? 33% feeieg eerriee ease eee aéee fee eéemeee ef ﬂee éieee eeee ef eze éezweiem for $26 ezeméeee in queeiéeeg eEee came? be igeeree ey ihée ifgeeri em; eeeeeei <3? eeeeege ef téme. ?%';e:'efe:e? § ﬁe nee ﬁeii erg: §'§18§'§"§ in ihe eéeéeé ef ewe iieeeeé "Ea: eeeiéei evieeee ef the éeeeeé"

:23: 3%. 'E'E::e Said judgmegtﬁ E3 3?; Estes, agpiies ':9 téfgzs A8.é::'1l/.43 ﬁﬁé C:;z*:::1gms€aa::<;€3 G5 the pregéznéz Case. 1%: is ':_%7;'=:"a. 's:a4*§:;é::§§i<: cantention 91" 'ihs Ea§E§.}O§§ 'aha: he Eequireg 'aims p<:_'ii3';:G::§.{ s§§?}1€d':;lé~--.b prerzzisssg ﬁr: 3:3 éziiiraéy fer his busérigjsfs pLn*jgj«k:§$'c':~;;_" né£:':t:'='eEy,.:é" start E0313; 'iyangpsrt busimiss. Tha ?i:ia1:1'CQ1-':rt"}:ad, 3§")ﬁi5~;i:3:VifZ_L'7';€'§{"§"8. Caurt C{>I:1:n§S$i<33'1er and {E15 "$8;§.~.*j_ c§rf;:nis:$ia1:é:*J..;%:3.V$ §33§€3f3.

report whféeh is net disputéd by BaS€é 9::

ihe $aid yegerts iréai V concﬁusésn that I'€SpC>f1d€HES wéﬁ have is existing on {TF8 N<).iG36;'P; &'§:,ér:€"peV'si§,€sSi0n Of {hes span site to ﬁche ' "é§§0i:»1d cause hardshég} is res§onde:::ﬁ't}f§nz;:if;_:Si:& by the: 'aria? ceurt that gremisss are smbeddﬁd €10 earth arzé gains x22ri'§1'4'::9_5¢s-: is bé. reéacateé aarhish aarauid C3386 hardship 3:16 "{}}7' C{}..1"'}vSE;Ci~€?3 §'§:fE§ i:h'iS"f€§®;<'i; sf Cemmissienar, aréar for garzéai ' E5./'%C= aids'; . cV3;«:=:;1€- f::s's:--.. pagsed. ._ éf}$':%is:§¢:maE Ceura, 3:; :5-aggarscéaéief: of 6i;§ﬁ€;"1C€ _&1"1d, 3:33 93:: avﬁingiéﬁrigg :':1s': a,dd.éiéC::2sé evé§e::a:& §:&:::&1§; EZXSEXE ' x?*I§};_f?-2'%i§ zafhich ﬁapiség aha': j3€§fE§0E1€§ has E3036 :}3&:: E8 _ -*gir:?.{:§'§s,:"f0:2:"::§Z {ha}: parziai av%,e:i;Z:e:1 as 0;=fé;&:"::€§ 'by {:26 'iréai sear: is ' "n~§:i§%3as§%§§: 351:1 Ezsié féndiézg sf {€3.33 Cauri gs 3§:'::>::¢3au$. Sagas is "e:§i$:;*.:,:ss6§ if: gsayagrapia :3? E33 *;:<:::€$é{:s;r:aE gauri V "gums? {FEE {f{}§"}S«§:s'j€3f'§f3g E326 ::::€<§§§%z:2;r::»;{§ €:séc3~s:r:<::3 ansgii 3333 @233 a§§§'€C§aEi€3§E sf svriﬁsrzsgs avaﬁabié an razcerd ihaé §€':iiie:>}:_2<3;i W33 awning €621 igrréas and ha is in {ha buginess <>f :g"a::$p{;:__:"zT afzii requézas the schsduls prsmisss for §OCaiiI:.§_ll'§;i.SV*fi§U$i;E€S':..,V gsdmarn, office} ate, Ths said €Xer§:£se:3 sf «;;>é;=_:aréz"<:}_f"::::fisig}::zLé jurisdictiara by the caurt ca:r1:1::st_br3 h'<.>1dW;*.G SUff%ifAé§{h€§T fr=:}nip materiai irreguiaréty {Bf net 'b€it:g'V"w:E*iEf:Mo11: jﬁrisﬁié-{£013. in these circumstamcas and alga: tE'1a3: psziiéensr intends ta start zransperi admitééé by the r€spond,ent§..£:é'::.:§lf:€ CGLIIT is af 'zhe COI':S§d€i'€d viii:-{$7 far by thﬁ tenant is zleithey' their raquiramént of tbs iarzdlerd

33. «E'.,v€::"1 0i§:é:_x§;~'vi_sé;._«_dz:. vpausai 95 'Lbs rscards éncluéing iha §§'§Q?Q§fa§:'i$V_éV'&f:13bE€ Eecorii, ég wauid €§E1=3fg€ that tenant E*:«f.i$ \2'v1&.1'é.f2éAi;'gi:§§a"'é3,.b8.§"Eié€,;é§\*§1<§"{"i7E'Q16 gaetiiian schsduéf: premisés and £2':

€;i€§::%'i::3_:é' :'éC.,_b':f:$§:1€$$ actizrit}? is carried Eizerein, In {E1636 %3};E'€.?E1'§E'1VSt8.f?5€§!;E"E>.;§'V.8.1'I} 0.? E336 conaiﬁsred visw ﬂat <:::'d€r passeé by 'the re<;%2is::f1;§E agar: ix: EERCR N0,Ef:":»§ Q98 5:063 :30: suffer €333:

._ éﬁfifmizéﬁg sit':/zsr 323:: 13%: (3? an facts and &CC{}fd§E1g§fg', W:i€s::}rv53 '::::s 'Se Qonﬁirznéﬁ and Sams £3 h€::'§%;:§r cenférztszsdg

34. E': ﬁg net {:36 case 05 $336 £'€S@:3§§{§€?;1'€S that eé:*,h%:3: @263' " :33': QQSSSSEE 3:' have gray a:%:€::*' aE%:€:'na:€ grrésyaéges aséaiéaisle is ﬁzsgrza 1:: 530%, a psmwl 0? éhzi cr<>$sA€§:ar::ina:'é:igr2 éxéracieé Ezereézi abeva} Wauid rsﬂecz that ?es§<>2*1ﬁ§:r:*:s are 1"'L3E'.}f1'-i_§ig_V éhe fGEE=:3Wi::g bus§n€$s:« {E} ﬁgexm Meter Werks;

{S} Arum Engineeying 'x/'aic§é§<s; "

{iii} Arum Faundries am F;;:abr§::3fééns;"-- ..

(iv) Ramesh Hedr€<%na.>§; ' 2 {V} Arum Theatre; V V {vi} €ndrabha:s.han Reifuiivgnsi

35. 'FhGugh} in the=«.:i;r'Jss':_6x:jm1ii:.aztiaii, {E16 wi€::e3s;'§W~E_ has made an aiiemﬁ :0'.::f3§:<0vi\6¢*~.§1§éi".véi5%.i*::'i/1 by cantending that {ha saici c<3?_::1céﬁ<';i $ §}3;f%n€;5sAhip'}:*:;;r:{«:erns, no endeavour has Tbsen méds isSié$3§3I.3Vh:@158"521$': E3}? grociucing either zthe par'!:ners;?_1ip deT%:§:f;é:;_» er '{:.$rréﬁ¥caj_:<: issued by the Regigtrar of Firms to establish jihagi €h<3_3Q' z{z'e:% §afiiiV:érship firms; On the athér hand;

%:he said wésincizaés ..a::§'mi'iis ifzai: peiéiiener requirés 21:16 péamisss far E'€--§,'§5':§1"§},"E gE= EE"a.f':S.§Gf'{ ?é}i:ic§es; gsdowa spaca fez? Eaaééizg and {;.:1%:s;5;§i::;<g,f'V':3:n'::§AV'esf§:a:e ggsace far trangpfaré f§}'§»1S£:.§.E88e E: 2153 aésa aé:n£§f;ed 7:3,: éihafi §€é::;ti§::er;'§ar:&§0rC% is féagzzmcaiaiijgr viaﬁs:

E1s;i%;sf:;?;2:r:: a rich famiijg, " ".36, in $326 basfsigzozmﬁ. 3'? aha 8.§OV€ éigczzssisn ané an . ':_3v§<:-*§<i*%:<'ite being azzalfgsaé, as éégcussgd Ezsreiztz ab@:?€, I am <::f ihs '«. V<:'i';':ré3id€:-*€<.*E, "§?§€":,R7 that §s€§':ic»§::«:5§ reguires schadzﬁs §§"€§E"E;iS€S bézzaﬁég '§::«:* his §W:} 1:353 aﬁd ssasczggsazéon 8.ﬁd @6633 p3_SS€é 3:336 :'evis%§:)::aE <:@z:.:°%; £3 £3: €{}fZf{}?1'IEi?L§-' ﬁmih £36 Q23 ?€CGFd and said ::>ré:*:'rs a:§€;es am; $uf§€:<* {ram any meéazégj ;~ i:°§*€~gula1'§:j»; vsﬁzéch Caéés E035 ém;€:rf<::"€:2€c: ix: sxércégsj x::=§r¢:z.%_§§c>naé guriséicéien undsr §:?c:i<:«:1 E15 (:2? {E1212 ﬁede of (2%-'iii E9'G8< siicaoréiirzgijg ?;h.E: paints for:::gJ§a':€e:1'.'hé1"%3if: é'b::a%;¢ gréﬂ answﬁred by hoiding zhai p€{i€iQ?1€fJ'1"?iﬁ.(jU§E'f§!S=. V?i'%3€" fg:._:f;%ti*€;f;::;§:

scheduﬁﬁ }}F€B,":iS€S fer his 9w1:1>:::~:::j a1'2.d"€zVcé;1pa€::§.§:1fVa:i;d ozldcéi" evictéen pas3€d by {Em {ﬂak «ceu:'€>ag\:.r§i} agﬁhé Iférsig zevisiansﬁ 3911?: §€serv€s is be co§:§'ir_rf;€:d £'%.ﬂC§3~?§é€~.§E'§"f$§GfE petétians fﬂéé by the ::'€$p0r1d,€:r1t/tésrgazat d€§'€1_1f.$'t3.$ :6} £36 c3i§r::'§~:éj;3.€ti Accazéingkjvz. ihs same are h€{I;€b:f_~'EZ§.iéZﬁ"iE.SS€hG:}J _ 3?', CQ~;:s§%;€.$fi:f:g:_ :h&__§<_~:1a:ie:;~;%isE:ipEéetwsen 'sha §83"i'§€S and 5.130 }@:1§.----d:a$.>:%:§_ '§}:ﬁ:§€:f?§.1:E'\O'1f3;V§;}_€"{'.K7f:'G}73.,,_tE1€EH} 335$ C031": is 95 the canaiﬁamd visvs fig':-._<:{:.st"'--::~;AEi;@::Ed bs made easéy and 155: is he barns by :'€§'p33t: :%ve p_af'::§e's..A §;:;:..<Q

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court