Lokayya Poojary vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secretary on 22 January, 2011

[Cites 3, Cited by 16]

Karnataka High Court

Lokayya Poojary vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secretary on 22 January, 2011

Equivalent citations: AIR 2013 (NOC) 360 (KAR.) FULL BENCH, 2013 (1) AKR 555

Bench: N.Kumar, B.S Patil, S.N.Satyanarayana

 _f§£"EC§:  'V 

 

 

EN THE ﬁiﬁﬂ C§'{.3"R3'§' QF   95$ Bﬁlﬁf

E.}222.i.%::{'§ ¥;,E:1i::5 §.E'.';€'3f 22% giziy {inf s§E":§'1'L3E'.£.E'§_-*2 20 E. ~
P:*=<::<:a»:.»>,:§.i, H "  V

31% HGNELE Mm J{§S'i'fZC§E':'€.Ef§§;E;AZ§§ggR_"~  _  V  

(3.1; .V  ' * . ;  
*§§«§g §~IGN*BLE MR. Jfv;¥$'§*:c§:;_§B"S ?Af§'i'§;   

'i'E-IE HQI'§'BLE MR. ';§f£§';f%T1tT_§.ES§§' §§§"1""§fA§ARA.§'m'€A

"'£\f.P, N0.282§3 /Q14;V'C.5w:v'§v%f§?a  /<35

Betwtzen:

L:3E~:ay§;a :P<3e:;j «';3,.3.'j,=' _Ai:<:{.}:«2:':f'~ .._  -- f . _ .'§'{;*é.£'i1Eé}:a<--::°

V"',i.Ef3:i5'.-F" :'13:'iVV'f:~';7.E:~A_. ;'i9$?:3;%;';?§E§z3z1 Se:";%<.>1' C€}'L';£'1S€1}

 rS's .>3.'ETe;2., {ref §':v2.'!;Ei£.'§;¥1"{A.E{:'32%Z;E2 £1 {)i:§":£:2's5 ., Refs ;}<:n£Eem.$s

" V "§?r};';:::<%h_. Eiéséa {i:~:5;', E?  

«   Se,;§'E'}Q;.E:§€i§&1§§{}§§&1§éTiYL §§C§i'(3{?£i§.i3, Ear R3;
_ . {E.::*'aé"<:%§":'::12€tn'a. ;'»':dv<>:::22i'.e §'<"::'r* "RE amzci R2}

'.E'§:'Q;sé~ §R?:'i§. §?"€:"£.:'.'§,§.:>;1$ E:.2,m-rizzg 'wzizz :*é3§€:~,:*:'€5; "is; aha: E'?:.:§§
J1, E'E'E&T:{§i';' é.E":<i% §'<3§E<';:s:£:":§;f:

 

\""WW
\



QREER GK REF'ERE§€CE

'1"Em:':éé Ef}iviss§<}r: §?i€:1<:}_1e.<5s af 'miss; €{::u:*'§'. $1:

{1} Efesabayya Nagappa z\fa§§g;-.3; $§"°s,,.  :*'5§éf'L'£?§€;? éf u h f --

Kamataka 5; 0:3" 2092(3) mg' 53;. 3

E2} $.,C.C'h.andrappa  St§éi'te:__ 'ﬁfpv~._§§';§:ﬁ:Vai3aka;"' 

Seﬁretary ta GovernmentL"1e:r{mi--VV:Gr3. ;  290$ KAR
Sﬁgzhcmd  A'   '.  

{3} Sri.Aboobak§c ;a:r.  A 'éf;-3:,    Iﬁaégfizgréseé Qfffieer
under Secééiorg '??£i"'lej"£"}f;eé  Assistant ta

iilév   Pzzttur ané An?''.,
29:; #252,: KCCRE 2' :2" .   "

hzwe he-Eé 'f;.:}'Ls«.:--_1ai {hé ._G{::S:%2:7:jé%i}.€::.1?;4 ;"'€{:<}§'(§s3 ss.h.<:}z,1E£i ;£<"s:§'iecE; ihcf-3

~.§§1e:f%,i1}f;'i§'.,C:§ v{j§3§i§1?:g:":§f____§§§C land in ax: E:'§%:.aé:ii3, 'M2 &i,'ii§"21CE. éha

_§':v§"i'.'?V','iV.«""V§EZ§VQl'::$' :31?-'f§%{§'i,v*;'.§<}:': ?';?£'; (2.? %;he .E{:1:'::a,ia§~;a Lam? Reébrzyxss Asi.

{£"<}:--:?h;--:::~é, Eie:3,<;:§.:::-;£E.e:':' 1'e£1:§1"r€:d {<3 as éhg: 'fa<i:'E"} ass E1H"§fi'I"£Ci{:'f{i by ACE.

--E_§§2?. *.Z'h€é'*A«;:s}:°?i*<2<::':':1£3ss of EE"2€* E:';?;§-,'3"';:2::'£=.E.a§.1?E}£": f}§.':1{3€{§ an Sé3*C'§,iG}"E

:?f?;% 23:; 5:235 2?:E"{>§.":==::=;=sa?::{i E,E1me §'_}§vé.s;§::,m. §:3£ZfI"§{'f§'§€:"iS  {§<}:.:'E3t,€€E %3jg»* i':E":e



§:3;-::'::':..€:d; :~3i.:'1§:h:* _§;.:{§g§{: 'E"E'::'a ':e21:'mé(.*; Si:'1gE€: J 1.:::iL§€t F233;; é::~;?s<i;}'£_'§2«F.~;§%:*a:{E

E:§2£3 *»;§<éa>« $1.211 €,E1E.5:; zlspﬁci. 1'=r:q2.1ir€:*.$ §=:%{::<}i':sa§{%e2:;:i:§02;"by A;:VV'E,:é::*§;§é--;7

§?3€:*n<'h ::)E"%;'.E1i;<s? C{T,vu;'é;; A.{:<:<;:"(.iin:;§E3?, i;h.i:_+3 »ré;%,§e1"s:§:;:§  z~?-.i;2,:{§.€% Ej,4§} i,E':-£3 V

§?'u;§§ B€§"i{i§*E by é.E":€ E§%a1fI'm:d €ihi6:iUJz3s§.i.éu%i,

2. ii. is; HOE. §1€{i£3S3E§E-lI'}-7 E<3v._;i{§_:;:":%:*'{. €.<>__'€;h?:?_ §"é2__£:'£:§é«:;.. <V:?i""".:%:":y GE' V

"£'.h€s€ {"i21S(i'§:§. as We are grep,---::¢:"1'3e§§V-&x~'.i;§Li}§'<¥§§'E:}r_ {he "C'§U;'«€.'S?§.§v'<;£I1. GE' Law.
3%, 1'8 éfieai' {mm the {}':'{§.e1" i:si':  E€a1"I":<:{% :=3~;'ir1§§1::t
juéige dici 2101; a1g.:ftés::"w§i,11  3 §..t.",<.:§:'%{%Sfc11£<)£1:§z'}7E3;ES <?:a5-:»€,
thaé. Ehe 2:s;;:=:§,'i1'    Stzmza Govemmszni

s§::a'u}.{§ f%.;1<%_p§é{<:c::_.i3"1"<ss<}:*:j;éE€'~.._e§fiC:a.§ ;'e<:<m:i and §".hé3:'€. in the

£:bs~3€:1.£ié@ $i'";1:.1§? S'a:c:§§'ﬁ€£*Of:L 'E.%;€i E'3«;1_Ct:_:£m <3? V€s'{i§':g-_§ bEi'{f{)1'IE€S 3

{ﬁs_~;puE'.€:§% i"?-16%.. ':4;-QC?' E3»1V"£.v~.%i:"£"£L*f€,__i*::§'i'='§' in E0 Ehe same: "£5 51:}? wi:h.£n E;Z*:€

--.$.<;r«:;pe%~"a:~:E§ jSé'a:§.ic,>:': '??'§':XVV§}§_"_§»E:§% Aeﬁgg in c;":':%:@:* vm:"d5s. the E'}ivi.s~;2?£:;1

 §3%E?:_§{tE1 'mgsé  %l'.%2{~t {3<:ve:"§*;::":':a=?:1t: :'@{*<3:°{Es sghimiii i'£%5§i',{'."§f'. 'aha

§';:§sViV'%_3Z<";:i--  "ts: Egzrzcé hzifi %.><;%:m 2?;§zf'<:':ai:Ey '2»'$sﬁ{;*.£§ in ifmr Si,a§:.$

%C§{::V::z*:é':é,::::r1%;:'t:té{:=  ':15; €f§'iEi§T,'%§f;': {Em 2m€'E':{:21*i%::; E10 g.§'2"z::"2§. Egazzci in

'§-¢ii='€}'E§§"i'3E1' ;'£,§ja.€: é.::%m2?:.:'T;14, 3:1 is-:» in §..Ei;§;<.; »::{>'m.e;%<,.'E.§ E'_.I§:é3 §§éa1:.:"°:":€.{i :%;§i'1g§E{%



"E uéigté

5

E3315; Eeig. éhai, 2.,h.:3: 2zf<}':'::ﬁ=:=;21i::i (§"i,£!:}g§H'E€i'1'§.Sé%~ E§é§uE'ET€7

:'<3<?{}:":s:~;iC2<*:r:*:i,i<m 233; ';.he L2;1;"§;,§@3' §§%€m';h in \..~§m>2:' 0? i.§'2<';7.,':'§f2§?'{'iE7€;?'f;'E. '§%235§§é£":-,

g}<>$iE§£m ii}:-2.: *2/%;<.s£,£.1";,;<,:§ of zinc I8.'I'}d €iE'he_2,°»~mTI§ie:' .§c2{:i..i€;:i4--3§ {_3§ii'<}2:f

*9

me §31.:z*§>z>.s:4~:: G?' S::=::::'§,i<}§: ;

'"§'
1'

ag%.{f;S..q  m21{:s1'2121i,§C. E? the Ezmati 
éhssre r;€:<;%<:E {mi ':36 21:13,' .s:»:s§§e(t§§'£c?:  'c::§7§:":.j§:i,VA_;ri§1<;:' zhésre
need be 21:3}? €:<>*x='€:;"'r"a:1:1§:iir:hi'*<'f,(:§':f'T3?3q  _ Vﬁgmléi 0? 33315
§3mpe:*ty in We Si;:~;ﬁ   land 2255 on

i

3.3, §;Q'Z74 in 1;h(;~:: 3S$i:& €3zcw£:rr1P:€::1i_....£5§- by b§) é3}°a11.ic>:11 cf Eemh The

Same is c'£s3a:° iktgain E§)Q§§i11g'--V1_.{>"izize _ s{:h§:jn1e of the Land Reformss
Act. 'E.'he7§)1ai.n E2i.:sf§;7.3.;1.g;;;e e';z;§§53yed." in Sessiiarz 44 of the Act: also
zrzsxéies ii: C3.i:e:1* Vt§:;:::,,_ 'i_.E"ie;:-- %;ri:s:,'i';=;;s§ {if the 'E.:21.12m'i;:e{i Eamd as an

E«3.§§?4§»_ vvi§.}i"=E§3f<;.VSi3.i1%;% €L§EW€:§°.z13':3et1£ is a'L2§,QEI}2.'1[§(E zmd by

'*r::;_§)e:*a,§iié;:: 3;? Egmr. '"§'":1::.2ie:«;}.€e.d am. he am}: {}fi"£{:E21E €}<>v€:°r:§1:.e:1:.

V:"€»:':<,éz*cE_:é25EV{i:::;:{%§:":';; wasting (sf fiizc Ezmci in {he S'i'.a?a%;.£:; Tilisss. ?..£'%.:=3

 apézaea E1215 beer: ilizar L2:":{3;m*s3é.zz:':cE§:1;'; <2? ibis;

    

Egg»: ma?' TE  3 

€{31::9é4»..44§§g§h%:.~.§}j§:?'r:T €.h& 5,,-T*<~:%ar E9731» "{,é..I;i veg"? :"ec<»3.m.E},-* 1.6.4, 3:2: {he

  §3~;¥f€}{1E}'i,§§'}.{f:?ﬁE.t?.E'lE, {)5 i7E'2€é j:.:d;§§3:q€::'1§.S $2': §;.h£;*1 z:§'£é:'%;E:-7521.35. ::19.i£.€:*:§ Eiy

"f--;'; {)f the 'E/'5.:23;1"'::2é_'éri*£7:T1E«:2"£f'~E.€é%;:":_fi E{€i§'3§§f§%J1'S:

45

/'



E1232? E}i=:*is§::}'n §i'3{Zf}'"§{.'.h€';§§;, T116? 'Ea-«;'":;'~3V;r:§€.={i p:'<§;'::€2"é..§::*;<:: wési. ?;.EV:.§*: €.i'£§€:

Eigiih {he {§C}'J€Z"T§}z'§~;€§'i§i. éizygd {fig-§§;€(§é%é?¥é§/,§3r5 €,h.§=. f§.§.:.{i'1_§'ﬂ;..ii§.§ﬁ¢§?':'gﬁgiégv.
iiliﬁtraﬁsig. G'? {E16 Gw;':er$ {EV-"€;'f[" E336 p'1°(}ps3:":.,i€:'5 se3E:g1I§ 
vmh :::§"§':;>.c:*;, from 1.3, }E}?=§», in 552:p;3<>ri._g2§.t,E:§: ;1b{'}é-?é {>:?§:;:s;=; :'*v23.:_?i5&3';-S; 
{his Eezirzaad sgringggieé jzzdgfe E"2as:3 r:3§%:z"3"e{:*;._i..{3 ::'%'£%_;':1'j{)%;}'S

z.hi5.»; C()LE.E'é.. ii is}; in §.h.i;<.; E32:{tkg:*'0;:1"§:i, 'xxg'e'2i.:'e Egﬁééjféfﬂ upégn K3 

ai€«;ii.d€ G18 C{}E"i'E'C'{HE3"SSE5 0:' e:3EE1€nv:'$§.i- '~<3§ E2355"<)bS'€i§f€'21E.iQz1$ ztslade

by aha DiV'§S'i{}E"E B<»:n<:E":<-3;; :2»? ?.¢}i:..§é4s;"vv{_3t§:_;:"'€ ml'-f.?:;<:_%,1£'€}'i'esai&

§*f03a.ba,§;ga Nagapgm i'xf'az'.E<"s~; x{}2":.s;<:¥--,  {E>'EE.g}xa?ed in i;:}":.@ 0!;h<--:r

'two jildg.-§mé3;:£;$.

3.  3;': is' '.:§~r:';§.'.gi§$»§:1:;s%..e'{'£-_;1:":.{§EE: {72:"f'H"i(')'i. bsr": £§is;}'%_1§:€€§ ihai, in

\r§€:w {sf she §;.;1ss3i:1g'<§§' {Ext §{::r:%é2{1.21k21 Lami R<':~f{>zt"ms5 f¥EE"§f3E"£Ch'E1€'7f€':E,

.§%z:ti., 'b3f"2:»i.3if:.1:@ xi}? ;S€{:'§,§r3f:'  21$} 3,§".':€i" iéifidﬁé heﬁci by 0:' in {base

 g}V<f§'::§3£%sé§.~::'§{>1:?': '€>f"~.§€:1a.:1E.S {'§m%E:,:{ii.I1g 'i.<-:na;'1E",5§ ziggziirmé. vJ';t":Grz1 £1

{§.{Ei?§'{:§.?ﬁ? ﬁr»..é§:i§i'::«:"f"'iI%;-K" é:§r§€'§,i<>:z 9:" 2: <>e2*Ei§Ec::E€ fa}? z°a%:=;::':n§>€_§(;1': 

:'::9A:§<z'*-..__ :>;f ~ ~%..f;§S':.m:{§§ i:mm:=::§£aé.e§}r pri0z* 3:} éihéi <:i;a?.£.e <3?

'4"--__z:§{;3:':m:%:1<:s'§§':€::":"£. af %E'ii?', 5m':€:'i<:§:1';<é:':§. §1,{:'é.¢ zt:?z.§.'2.€:' 'E.§f:2m §é1§'":{§€-3 Eiasiizi



£4

  1:7,: éhé S%.j,;=:,é'i«;;: Er: ahiss cz>::§:3:<i. it  z2<:%<::>:s::s»;a.:"}; Es} :°s;>.§%:*.;* 1'53 i':E1e:.

by "§'.h<:r1': u.mi€::° Eﬁiziﬁﬁfré pa:-':r:::§E'.'é.€<§ :.§§'1{fE:3<:* S€fC'i.§{}ﬂ 5; ssI%121.§".§."'wi.t}1

€3§"fer::1;. 0:": and §'r<:»m the .s:aza3«:E (.1;-:té;*,, 5-;£,;1z.:§.{§ E13';-?.:1sE%%:f:f§:3{i» i..'<;»- zit?

\:e..e;::e€£ in the Si,2:s*m Gax-*errm1€%:1E¢ 'i"i":e:":;5i'<;:':n ﬂag #;fé:3i,i:1§' 

i.€:12;_1'1Ee::§§ Ezmii $5; E35: <3'§:sc':':?:!.E<::';*': <3? Ezlxxg, Ni} .'x%*i'i'§.%.é;§ VC<i'd€'33° is 

needﬁtd :.::mi<3;<° E.%';€. p:"<)vi:'=3E{31'::-5 of '$16 5-3€.:i. fjfk:-2': {::Q::3.§3}e;%3{,§.r.}_n. :3?
v%:$i..:ing. Gzleztet 'iestérzg '§..ak€S;: pi:-£1.33', ihié '3:"£g;§l :--i W '§.E":.€f."_;:}"§v";':{é:* cf {he '-

E33153 S€'.3.1"m:E&; eX?;.'i.ngu.is3h::c§ znzci 1,h"E::'§;Ef{}§)t':'§:"i'i§i. \?{:--s§if.;<é'_;  Si'.ai'e V

CzQve1:'nz11em'. f,zfi:*€;: iﬁryrn 21$} 9nC':,a.mb'ra1n<:.s:s. §€@.t'§5.rii,F£s{a1ndi.né;
ssuch vesﬁng Ehs 'E,e:1a11€.~--:f;i::;y éII0E1f{i§1ii"€f_'Wig".§3€3SS€SS}:O§1 ai" f;hf3

propsriy, in faci. me {:0I1d.i.£in_n  pV_r'e%ceé1@;':'i:--.1i7:2:€--~ v<~:ssi'.i11g is, £115:

Eand in {ft.:i:*.St'i(w:"ié%3§:z.e3?;['be's1._?Ef€;-ggzirltési 3.a;n.z:I. i -Fen if the ienam. 'i$
1'10?' in piussgéssgiixizs'  ii)  ij¥fi'I1EiI1E.€ftf E:-ind, E.am_<;i V€S"§,S in 'aha

G/0°w;%n":;*;r:{-:z:%;,. 4"'fFE1vE2'§_ff;'L;§'€fA;~._'i,Ei;.fi.3"E: is; no £i1'ff§<,tL1§?;"3_: in hﬁiﬁing ihazi

'V "E~'9;u=-' aiﬁé-??:s I_f:.{3€1, §_>r€:*s%(:§'§'b'c---::;V1y W:*'i?.t:<'::": zisrciizr for giving; aéffeari. 1:0 the

 '.';T{}1)€3Vﬁ"i.i{V)I'1..vQ5'_E€f§§§S§&':§L§(}EI. Em me ;1§t}:"€:§a,icE §:.:cE;g§ne':'1L in

'E»§"a';:'*$;:'i'?§:Z°r"i'i»~*'2:'«s'é:;*":":<m7?:%:~2"a ii. is ss2i.ai€<%_ éhai. uz2§a%:s:-3 i.h:=,:°£3 31:; 21

w:'§'i4*{.%:~-z7_: :3:°g..4;s--;r"_ {i§I;' '%;i=:s3'%.£ng; iézc ?.2%;mi séa2m{:=£. 'E39. 5;-ii.d is Ezaaxm, vesﬁed

3:



<}bs~;{2r2r2zt.§<>:1. in Eé<3é§22%3a?::;y;»2's <:2::.ss;«:% for whérh <%:=<;e:*;<:p€i<m 

'E'%*:€. $21,121:: is as amci<:*.;°:

"$1 Hazsirzgg £z'2dic:ai:'z2d. :F';e"Lé':.*;--.=sae;3*'_' €:;:vd?.:'j2.V?i,:; VV ' A
aexzazni Q?" Rziie 266 £921 ;as:'~.I':0§.i;._% :;:.«:'};r"s:=é':1..'i.<::"z* u n
;<.;co;;e erg?' am,» Rzgie, $:1N:2;_--_r'z.:ie 5}  5.f':.e:> T§%§;':$?§3 
0:15;; in be ur2.d.e:*$é:a€;£Zrin :}1a>* .:f{}':'2§'é3,%:£ 'é:;_}" 
Secéiorz 721A {lfiéf £.}:;Ts;------ i§v--.z4i.%'E1:::"{2 £'?é€~.2?:r:a=;"2:'1
;9r"o::z'5z'e:m €gfvSéi3£1!.:f:!2' :5?"  §()fr"2_;'.:'*{:sE «:3/f {"329
8i2'.i,£C£.{'Z'{}2'E. The"  under
Rafe  .f(3r[A zfhé'  u (§f":;}'far:Iir1g Qf
{and azjiziézfj53ec::.:{.:i;_}i .1?' 137-251  5:316  CQETYEOE go
bs§;;Qr'itIV;::E1e ;,{V'{:«':*'z.Ls?é;ic?2. z':'h.e secirion is
pr<'_A7é;"£::fii-;;%c:i_%fEv}zf; 1%3.jv§:»5"~ﬁ;_:)If'i._c(;f(i eariier {he Qfqjecff of
,,,,_E.,?"2.e sec::i{;}§«.§,s:'v«ij§§T'*;:;f9gL+vi{ie an {)ppari.z,mi£'j:; E9
§?::2s e _ :$ii2.:j'V '.;?é.£g%1'L;i Emmy beerz, Emsigj and
L..§5z::;f':,z'EE§;gV_VV{€31.55}?is Qf {Liza Ecmcf, wilt; {were in
p:}';~:<§£3s:sti(§rv2:"'§i:%%.5E. c:2£§:§::aE,;ion and atoniinued £10
;;:33sessz'o2'2. aria". cz;.zE5.i:;e:z.§;ia2rz.. who mzigfzz.
 '?:%.{:?;€'7;;.??§:iSS€€§ 5.326 has Egg; zmf. ??E&§<£i¥'£§ aim.
. 'a;:{r§*§:.::s:zf:'éc:2n wz'§i?i::': {Pie s§:'z'p::%.'a:',e€E. psérfaai
" . _ :3::;§T2:'k:*?1 €:':.fa5§: herzii {,'f}?EQ€ {'0 be s2xz'.e,>r2de:§'f}"<mz
5.3225: {:2 {£3729 arm". :30 e:zs:m:> E5255: :,.?ze:'.:'
;'2e:';;'=:3§:;$z'{2zT:, 537.5% {::.a§€:':iz,:«:::.:'Lé<92': is <?0r3f':'z':2.:.@{§

(L,/"'



:.:.%:':§"zo:,::: bzairzgg :iz'3€::.r%é3oE. 5mg; '§'":.z.rf§'2e:: if 55:; 

zgasrgg esserzifai £0 p<:>z'.:'z§ gm: mag.  

£:;}p£icaE.:'c«zz zmcier 8'ee:?z1€<):'i: '}?",?'u¥': £5 :'z.;_3:f.. :':'§'2é"- 

same'-2 a5 a2: £:pp£z'.c:a:i07'2 Eiflfiéf ,§z:%a?:Trz7»:::.?ﬁz"'V

an.z:£ the er'z.5;:.az'rj:; géazﬂerT:'éj2'i::¢E.e€E -::$;:':5{'T€s;%:_T' _ V " '

S<3c2'.:'0n 2??-A {:az"m;c>2." E29 °:':?:é'..$?:m2£"f%$' '~§M

<9z'zqz.::'z:a; c:i}:2€i:z.c&<3cf "b;';.._V {:'E':e '§,«:z;':.'t>i ?'?5f?g}i£;F'i»:"§.{  

a.:r2a'é;>r Sec*Z"im'z 481% g;*'%':::ge' Act. 1%-'é.'§gT3*:*<;3f:a,:3*= éim
an a_p_pEicaf,ia:":' :.;_z1de>r<Sf3c:%£:;;2  e3r2qi.éi:'j;;"?;;g
{he Lanai 'E'2*ibu°r:2*::.Z -- :.§*j_'7(23'%. §}raiL€:'}:,3,?" 'f;f()if§f€3?'}'?'li;'}"siE'I

Q? Qccwpancfg; _.r«i;:;Ei:£::c, 's-tasfzg a;{::.£1é{§€:z§.;';a zé under

Se:%:";:;r;!;";.A fr; :;E::c'=f}e§;::.gﬁg;."G0rzg§rzi.s5$i0r2er 0:"

:3{'fié2:3_'«,é§f}"E{:<;=r "-.,cj:z;,vz1'J:'"~f?_:}?*'a'V<_;;e§s.?f _.I;>g; {he State

 €;G?zn;>,:fz:z:1e?':::T is the purp0::-;e of gramirig 53,5'

 Eéiznd gm,'L:€;.:zzfi3.;fb:::;:i&3;:z cf cr3rfa£.r'r Coz'zd£:.i0r':s

V'r;rg,rz2s2E§,.§.  !:_'b;re::"e' C€:'gi:s3£ii,2'a>:"zs 2ner":.§€@r1e{"§ igfzereirt,

_ 5:: £5 Z-:6'? E'}€"%""£{}§;fiC€f{§ fgiiaz, <::@rz,dz'§.:'<2n:; {E} arid {2}

, am €{;:'zr5i€"£.ié:}%':s azéﬁzfsfi s;Fz::3L.5£d Ezazrezz Exsserz

 V'::%a«§.sé§Ee3(i. andj2}:°<;>g{me in resgx-3cE:' <33" 5%: Eand.

 «Q:"s:';..__:'.ss?~j":'{V2:. an eazzzgzszirgg so <2:;ce:°§:'ai:2. :.:2§:£2:5E1<2r 5:.

' ';>:§§%fS:}:'z car: he §m:7éz'.s3{fE ianzi being; :3: §a>m:zr2§.
as; 53:': szhe ag3p»:>:'r'2£"s2€§. cime: 5«::.:<>?'2 am er2:;:;:':°g;
2.35:3 s.a.v€{§::':'2 2.535 ssmgge <3? Ssiaifiiém ~§e§§a/E Q}'F,(§
220:1 fl')? 552.3 ;;;.:.rp<,>:%;s2.%; 53,5' {T{}§'E€§,§.§§{)?'?. {.3} 53?

E

ii



age

S€::?f§(>?': ??}i§.. E-{"8213 §:'E'ze :3f'3{§i.£iT§; is <>::§.;;jT<>:'

Z:'m2".:',€d §'}E§¥'"f')€}$€' Z10 fiI'2€}f. <;>:,.z:':' :'.§':€ a{:<?(;r}?;2{€S}'§é?i§  -----.

_jE::€z'. 51$ {'23 i.é..*-f'2s3:f':er §:'f'1e parser': was; §f"{"ﬁi.[;?,fI'£.£€:i§"*

§2{>:;:=;9s*si=:>n and e::u££:'iur:.:§::f{;2*?.-5}"{E19 Easjtcﬁ _<f>e*f :1-fig; V V A

a;3p<3i.ni.e{:§ ciaéu E5: is; 339:. a,é.':-3T ~:i?*a:2%;.z.ggE":~ _i.f*:<,4 V

m:£E2(;ri:':ies are 5.52 ?jr:)§{,€_ cm  1e3:v1cf;za'rg3; j*":';%'§"u
pzgrpose Qf ::{)r;férrrwé'E'é,,'ﬁg? <3c7c7L;p::_ré{t;,s  
on {he §3:'€,>znfs{3 :4E1:;fV-----§.?;:.ei%--.$z;ppZiCari.i.sv-.w§a?;i€
Eaugfui z.erza:"zi'.'$--_ 5:'; A the 3,:;ﬁ{gf3;1K}€?iV1fE'3ff§;Cl? ._<ic:z':e and
3:318 e:"zq;,1z'.zja; ;L2;;3_;}'k}:f  pa::Vrf)i€§-;=3.'.'--~ T?1.(=2
%f:Cs£{'f?:E:,£?',T" Iagygificagiéi§3£2iAET5.§@ 'i;V:z;iL§}f-igi: E.(;>ncm.5'; an
2.55"  éj;;_E;é..g;:2€£; éﬁas i:':z"é;:,:E£4?€:;a£T£<3r%: as

Ora», i}Z1e;f  a§;é<,>£%i':E{2L"i..  l'c:ia£.é§. is n05; {'0 be

 eS:T¢iEr:£sE1z;'9ti ?'2QI:£§.;;f{)?" {ma f3F"€?$€1"1{ enquiry, ban',

 A iii'_S;ZhI)i£Ec{. f':CLDé3CeI)ﬂCEI..£.CieCZ fact and ﬁg;

§"g;>p,g 5}? :?':z;_;_pf';=>se:'2f, em:,:uI'.r:; £5 {:0 £85: in

_ eu£d.«;"%izcé' icy s:z.i'isfa; 0:" prove {The exisfience of

' V. 3:;-sch 0: £€§:%'C'E:£a7ed facif. IE: is {far E3262 a;3;2{2'.Can.€;

 <$?%g:.:,;: ::E10;E ii. wags an u2"':dfS;')¥;ii'(3C§ fbzcf, and

  '~:%'é§C0rci and éfzai': wziz"E7;0m1 arzxgéizimg

V' ;_!;_{7:!$:§5'§.§':.ez"?:2ore he wag :2 §:'€nanE Eawfuffig :2':
 §';=:;s.<3£3$s£.@n rjmd ::?::.Z§i:'.§;aE.'i(2?'2 <:»g"' {E16 Earzci. an Eifzsé
a;§§02',ni,e:-Jé {§f3i§"E':'. 'Z'E:.e S<'3€?{}?'E{§ {f{>n€i:EE:2'{m is
€zE:~;0 <32' $i§r§ff{?ar'z<7e ancxf. §?'E'E§}GE'{{if"E{;':3' 2'}: {he

E

%/ M



H léléw

i::}:'zf.'€A<'z'. argj":;?m'2$ic§z2r§:'f:.g :"§':.e a.;>pE€<7cz{fa2'z €63, E.E'z£3;'"

iar2.5£ smjrzgéai. §'Z€i¥_}€ E2e:>en m;>5=;f:€d 2'52 {SE18 Sz"":":::é:=.. "

C302:-emz3"z.e:'2ET C33 on His: :::;;ap{>i;'zi,€5E. (ia:::'e__  '5~s:. *  '

Lama; 55 iTs3:z€znz.c252 Eemd, 1%': £3 Cégéééfj E5. 

as-er'z§. w§"z.:'.z?E'a giwzsid Ezciiié'  airsﬁaéfgg ' A

iaicezz 3:259:65 and 52;: .'f€Z.i{'§'?; {he £:':?i(5§£=3i2i?é2_ i:5'iCi;i :5 

required {:0 be ﬁiarza'-§._ by V£E';§§;{1r)g3E€:*:é:'g§.V:*§Q

sftozv Ehai. 55135; is a:3""L«s§£se?2£[ £:ha*f;. §t'€:a3.V.1£a§{v3ri

giace aZread:;;_fObvicm%:Zy-- if xsf1aul:d'J'?;nc£'§ a
place in some 'aIa__{.',1A"i«':;":i;cz%i§,p'z'fe3§:r;';'.*:é}[av"*5i;'as vesting
6f the Eand iii: ;,';{:"€TI;Ii7:ﬂi.»i'b?"'.V:£:7_,f:;...:ViTs'E'i'Q state
gav¢rmj;:ent.:;A_ fr;   "gf; any 53.5%":

§"§§¢;IL'1(3"?"=C§:  .';ag:c.:.:;;_«_ !:;52cm""nes 0.» d.i.3pz,:z:ec£ f0.:<:§.

 :z§'§i£:%§: ag?i1i'r': .:"$w.¢25z0E, wizhin {he £§C{)p€ of an

 ézzqzgfrig~:'i.sA;';d:::fV"gﬁgﬁégjiazz L?'"}7-A Qf {he Ad. 5,?'

"z':§;e$;r--.é 2--:;':,«<_,> 4i75>r/a<::i«€i;;*v:):<s.:; ar<-3j%.:Z}'%'EZ.{3c£. £:'f1€n §J?'*:<3z*s3

_ :15; :T§"29ArééCéssri.::';; e:2.1r':.cE. scaapejbr :':'2.q:.a.iri:':g z.;::iZ':f'2.

, ?'s35'gare::i z;;:"':'§":e zfzird. CQ:2.a'i§,f<}zL !E€£I"§'2£E§§.}1 GS :10

V'~z:§§%éZ:E3e:' 5:526 appiigfazéi, has; aéaiziimied :10 be in

 « ';2sr3;s*::§2s*s;<}:3 ainof cu§z.z'a::z.zj2iG::. :3? s:,zCE';. {arid 23:5;

A5??? SE15; 5ie:z£:'e zrgf' a:>mr?223:*:<:s3m€:':.z:' Q5" size

 :z:?'z5:2:if:2g ;%::E:' :31, 3.: §,E£§§§§:§, 

3';
is: 



~=i.E«

:4}, E64  {E13 'w:'>:"{i:<~3 °'S§3v'im,1E~;Ey ii. sshimki Eiméé 3; p}é1;;--f:£:r in

ss<3m<% a)§"f§{ti23;'E :"a~2<::}r<E§, 211$ x::%si..§z3g mY':..E'1s;% izmd  in E"a1%,:'{:~_;.%;':'~.{§'§7V €.§?i._§'.

8é.a£::: G-z}v@:'nme23i'."' is 2::n£Ee3z's%i':<:10ci in n1::%2z'1'2 aim; §}"1§:'=,':':€ sEi{:i:§..cE "E:=._$e:'

 

an {>'r'€1e;<' £2: w:'i£3;t'1;_3; sf v€S£,i:1§_}; 0f 'ibis iaimeti 0:' in 'i.h€T.f_ "

':<>:*€§$: Q? 'jht. ._

G-<w€%:"nn':e;'2E. éh&:'::=: s:;hm,1E€i he an e:':E'::j,»= i5t>"*;.?r_1ét. €§:Z§'c::_{ §":3.%j"i.§";§s§;.

E2-LIKE. 32:3 2.': v:?$:.t':d iangi. We are ;1§"z"21i{}é; :2i>--:3 WEN :%;r;3  11é:V23:;:Ei:';_,§§'.:{3a3._

much ima ¥;.h£< ssgzid se:%3f;4;:e1'1{Ee, as §;E§<§§a1:1g{2agt V€:;1*:'g3."§o§.(t:d. §h~':>..z.'em 2 L

E3 very piziim. What {he E€E££'1'3éd_j1.i{§g€iS i¥fi"ﬂ'1€ ;tf{)E'€S£1iC§
0bS€'E'E»"Zﬁ.§(}I§ m€--.az1i. was, i::":_ ap2"{:i:«::s:>_<:§i;5.;.:;'; ;:::a.<je.r Seatiiéin ?°"?~A nc}

s::3qmT:*y ':*€g§a'1f€§'i.':f1.g véssiing of{.226--.'E.£1:':d__is-.f::.s*i).:1i,e:§1p§elééid., Tine

::::;ndit.i<m pr<:*.ct€::1€§v:';.I'4...§'ci:<a§:.pE§<:;?:'E,i<::; of Sf;'{,':'£i(}£1 '?'?--A ES, the Ezmd
in 1"'€5%}}€é'3'E.  &2<zh§(':§':.;1f;§'§iC:£:'E:.ié:":.  ma{i£': $55 21 'vsjagied $338. if {hat

is 320%: in é.iSp:;:"é.&:g':.E3€1'1 the £:~'~;iqL:.£.rj,; Ca:1.é€mpia'u3Ci !.3}f3d€3E." S<3£:*;§o:§

~,'?'"?--1?\L~'§--§; to {End " "c::;V'_E'. §?,:*:':3i:'.E:,>u, ::«;'E1{%§'.hsér '£116 2:p§)1iC:?:m'. W.2é_sa_

 §I'§i§1'E€§{§§CiE£§§§,{ _%3%::§_0:'s3 ihss: fizﬁﬁsi. £3255: af Ma:':é§3., E':-3274 ii'? aC'il1.i£:?.§

§§@3éav€;%-Ssisjzé1:-giié :'s::_1:E~~§,§va_f.§03:2 (:»i'éE.1:-': semi Ezmég :~;t:=,ait<:=r1{§§},2 w.':>.€:i.§f:€:"

ms: Szggésii Ea-'?:_'I.':'{'§;,}};2;T)V.&>.:.%; 21-:3: té;s;{.'<5:r:-id {ms-3 :,:..:':.i€,; i.§E.i:'{E§§,-2 w}:€EEze:=.§' Ehéi

':e;22.:?_e:% §;{:::i:sé'}:; :,§2:$ 'a=:;:.E'i€§:-3.::E  ':38 :"::%§;iss'::@r:::<i 22$ 21:: <}{:<::u;3z1:2§. 9:?

:

5?:
"



4:3"

SE.t€?h Ezgzmi 2:a:7.{§é:~'::* ${f{f?li{§}'E 45 0:" 49; fzmnhiy, av%:{3§.,h<:>.r* s;%;,s;'c:§: 21

;3e;"&;:>:'": bass faﬂsci {:3 agspé}--' ibzz" E'%;':§§§SI.E"ElE..i()I'1 <3? {><:ctz1pa1:i<j§:"-rf§g}§.§,:é

in reggseci 9? such Eangé mzdssry ssL:E3~ssE:(ti',i(321 {1} ::>.§7 ':3€:«:t?£;:1:c}2*:j--

w§f,E*;.i1'z the pﬁﬁﬁii spe:7'ii"ie:.§ i,h.e§"@?;3'2 a.§:';.r:EAA§.V;2-2;s+s?;.§.j';.,I. -'~?2é§*;'€;%i}.i::':' §§:h::* .;~=saiL.=:E 

g}€:*rs5:§1 E12135 {:0§":'£,i.m.z€3ci tat) £36 in Ziifiliéiijiv §?v;3:5%a&§€"s:g.si.:3€1..L_ s21.:§d 

(:uE'§iarg2E.i<2:1 sf {mar}: Eand <31"; i,he4:'§_2:,!.€= GE.giéjmm(:::<i%;::1é§"§: 05:? 'élE?<:"
Ka:°'n.ai;ak:»1 Land Re:'*.£bm'1ss (fXI}1CE}'i§'§1_E€H?[}V. A.e::"?:..._ E-99'? ibis"

tZ§{3E}'{E':X'€. it has brim} hcki that 'iiIiV§€3SS;"§.}f1.ti-;§pp1.iCi:%-Eli. piaaésietd beﬁiére
ihe aui,hoz°ity szzatirs exridmi=g:é~..1§:: =£1:ir1e_£fg":'mpﬁssonie <>i'§°iC'i_a§ zrecorci

£0 shew thai 'she iand in qL1est.1fo:£v'v:ré2£--S ;.1._\§*es:i.€:ci"_.§az:c£ he c3.m':0t.

SlE{'iC€*§€3'd kiss an Vz3%n.c;mL.1V;'_,;-4y.V2:s._;€:2::i;ie:1;p}elierd under Secéion 1£8~A is
210*. §3@z"m§.Ssib1--e. ii. V:;5:i'.§._1ﬁ;.fi_4?1':£;~31b:1£:'k.g§:"0u.x'§£i in <:~rdsi%r '£0 pm: at reﬁt

Eﬁare exissis 2iIE§' cézméﬁ, iii wepiglci be a'p§31'<3pri2ai€ to i.m;e;°p:°<:=';. fix'.

 »»..'~'Zi«3»:«-':,*§::i.ié3i?;-'W E§€€§}':£:.'ag_§§_____§;3 m.im:i :';.he {}bj€f{,"Ei Wit:h Whish iizia

 a.::z1E:n.::%mé3:';.E1 :=.<;é§f:;_V"§:»rm1;:§h§L. is {E26 Ka:":1a'€'2:ka Land R{3f€}i"E'i'7ES AC.§,

2~,"ai":::§ =f.'1":e;x §:&.;r":{;A*Z§£%€';f:.:1:".6i"which E55 p:"€${":1*ib{ﬁ{§ fez' 'gzfzirzi. 05' §21;"§.{§" in

ce:*i:::Z_;j2 <:a$:3.ss :':,~;~:~.?é.h€ heezaﬁ zzasie of the Se«:*:%i:r:=:>z: :1'1s;.§<;€:5;~:e 'iii «::xpE:';€:ié§y

      1
. " .  é"»_éL(-/_,....



(if

{5}}  .. 

"?'7--zL §~z/'an: cf Ecmé iﬁ certain 

N0:,w§£"f'2;::;€'{zs':{fi:':§; cz.r'2;n'.f'sir'2§; :?{3s'z::'{,:zir2.ec§. f:'2_.:§3'i£S'   -1-

gj' {E29 I;%eg3u§;gg C<m2:'r'2iss;:<ma%r, or {my {3:}3":€;: ::;f'}§"z'.:?er

st:
5

cz;s.z§:'?::}r'is;e(i. 33;; {he Séaie' G39:-%'>'r:z.2'%2er§ZV 1"":

bs3?'2,a{f is sa§is;,!1'.€{£ q}:E.er f'z.<:3f£(§ér'z'§: ;<s::'j:<:Eé'r::é.zg;.i'§:*g;u£5,  '

F152 e:iee:z'2§j'z°.z'.; iizizc', Céfﬁﬁ-FfSC}F2. 

1,5;-a:=;. §rm1':£2{i.:"a:is3E;; 5){',:f_('}3§f<-;;'V"':-."',V¢§'E€"~_~,;'V"-1{'}";'§Ef. ziezgg V{gf'!'s;T§3r{?§ie4

§:5}'74- in a:;tz.:aar;{"«30s--$eg;.$if>z:.__ ::;ri'c€_ Cz.:§§,i!_:{11iO3*": sf

any iand nor' ex.€eer€vE;e'2g' s::»m7_,¥V":Az_ zf::VI£.,'_'__zzahicfz EEG:-1'
ves£:e¢:E €r:._ i:}'s4a2;'S:.ti.§x:{:{,}Qy¢Lrz;z72ér[a::. ﬁnder S§€C§.f.OFE.
4»-f.i_CLz;':.C§  . " ' ' 
.E3§3{§1;_{;:.éfé{§_E:Ee:.§. i.::3a__§)e5 z"e5;:V§5,Ev§a>rec£ as an Qccupozm.

:3/' ;§z}.c?:; -«E;::'r2!:i :'..:r1}iic>;:" Sazifon 45 0:" 49 hasjmied

A « :0' Q§p§;,iAh§'?}1*.?'ég'Afi§'§;I'€i§ii{}H Qf {}C?{j."Ii§'}ﬁf"TE(?y rigizzs in

Féﬁpﬁvfflv €25» S:.;cE:,[email protected]*Ea.r:{§ uzrzdez" sub»se<:?:io:1 {E} 53;"

 sec?£.i€§:'z=_é%8A :;:f§:Z'1.:'r: ::'E'2.e period sg/;%ec§;"ie€§ §"E*2,ereér2.,

  

*:i:.zf%:€va£.€{m of smcf': Eﬂfiff. (EH. E:§"z.e:3 s:§.0.§.€ <3?"

'%2.s2s'~{é<i%é€.§.:1z:e:f :0 be in {};{.'§:.£.a§ §'){}S8£3SS'E{}F"£ arzsé

 <:0:'z2:§':.e>:':;c:e:newif .53? 5.3%; Karr'2a;§la:§<:s:: s'.,:zr2d f€e§jE::»m"s,ss

{.é3.:2'za:':{§::2€>;z $1} ;»'§:?§':', E3199 ?1

" !.E:2i:;. 



gig-

Em mag; §;r<::rz:" she §ss;:'2{i 5:52 szzcfi p£3r.f§{}i'?. s;ub_je:::'; _:..<1_:_
Susi": re*s:.:'€«:3E'E.(;z'2.s;r magi {,":meff2'£.'i<)z'zs cmti. §:": ..:.?1s23_ 

mQ.I"E?"E:'-3I'°, as zinag; be prz:S<:r:'§3€:i,

.§3§'();.%z'£§s3::';§ {has Em-3V mM£az'z{i --:;j2ir;:*:'*SV§3ﬁ_
ie:.2gé2§.E:.a>:" z..:,=:€{.E':, She iama'. afireszcfgg' §éeér§;£ 5:1;-(f": "V
gersqcm Shrsaii 5295'. €..'<C8é'3{f 2 E §éa%<:_:z.bizzfés {}?" §"}.'.(.'i'€j§,S:§ 
iancé. or £315; s3€gi,£iiﬁeCZ§€f1i'K?'.:§.%§'%"f£f£€}. A T»  '
52} T3163 pr0:.%fsvf::r.:_s; Qf f$'€f£'§);.é§é;'£;£iGfE$ {;'§}'§}"£::%.c£f: {QB}
Qf secirigm 1"'? iir1;¢§ £§i;<: ;i§b2':}>:,=f£';<s«é'§3:";'§" Qf gseczian "X8
s;f*2a£§ appigg ::1:g:.£:'r1§:{i:»;V--,rI':::;Vi;d;1d'€§$vV ?.:*a:V..':§.>.:§_pe3cZ of {fie

grar1§.~v:3}"«£cé_?i& réiadga u:%:a7'e%"$':.;Ez;se§§£Tio;H; [E ,3. 

5.  Ris?';.;>0_:j1i.{?:;1ds,:ti'»._befb1*e us that whﬁe int:<«::"pr<3ting§
i.hi:«:~ p2"m'E's_--t.£{>:}., iha 'C}:;.:;{,:'*:«$_Vauggizé $381 is §(;.a.vé: :'<3*a.{E "Ema {he

$€'.Cﬁ€§1'} '€i=-*i'EEﬁ' '~§S 'nag':-_g%C3;?;?v<f:1'i§>Ez1i€%{§. by mi': Iegis-31a::::'$, ass has

~,b€en ~«:1=i£ér1;%§' ':53; §.§2é:"--VE(;%_a:'.:3.~i:£i J:1cEg{-::~3 in ihzi 21§:}:"«:*,5;a.i{§ E3?»-'§s:«i<:3::

'r_Ei§6:.§";;2:f§2 1':giigggéa.*S€{t<>:1{i§jg5 ii. is; Léimienzfaieci éhazé, as ii. is; E: S<}<:i:a_3

'aF§f'.:%,E§'2-*s:_ (,1Aigcgﬁsvi_:;::,.é§3v:':Q aha abjeqti; GE" E.§'m Air: :¥}£1S it} be kszpi. in mind

zmsi ':'::.~grs:";_v'i§' .:"§~1€:"€ is; air; {§i&;{:r6pz1::£:;y in tilt-3 §egisE21i.§{3:L Em":

"  §Z'.{:a2;::§*:,:~: é;~Ii":.{iuE{:E .%;£:2"€.i.<r§3 %§;%:a% :':'2£;am.§n.g 1}? §§'§{}E§€ w£:::::"{§s5; 22:) 35; iii:



2?.{.'.E".i.§e';'"i-'€ ms: €}bj€f{?§,, :;2m'1s*E:; {he ggifzzm. of E;'m:§ 1.0 3. '{'.£§i'?¢£§:§\'§"«§_'€E3{}

<:c;né§:'1'u:-ass "is be £22 {}{?1€I1_}.§'}€-1'£'.i{}I"i 21:15} a2vhc3 cﬁzii zfzm. .;1':'z1E<f§:-- 

21p§)E§<;:aE,£0:: far §;"z"2m%;. £~£?'§'i.E"ii'£} 'E.iE'£1f;2 in 'i:.E_::.E:'s. §f{}E1iE§iifE §{5i1,:E'€Ef%111'{Z€3 is 

;)Ea1{=:a{.£ an me: ciecissions szzrf "::E":€ z%p<-35: C_.3<:~?':.;;.s'Ti,, }'7'«:,_ '(1'.é:¥"s:§.;'{ ;"L~:*..%f,i.':';:1s;'

Be::1<*:E": :3? éhszr Apéix €Z§<}%..::"i. in %;.}1€:'?=,;1s;.é_;fj oi" .P;a%§MAS§Z:§I§;E,§ﬁ..R{§  

VS. STATE 95' fmvz, AIR 20a2j11'%s::r,:% :--:~s;»34,':::a.§§g;.mg:«aphs; 13
and 34 has Emﬁd as L1r1c§ef:%-- ' _ i H .

E3. Ft/'3:£§e* i-:"ii5<é'zjg:».%*';2{;§.%':gf._ as  ;;:r<i{risi<;r: {he
§=a:;r3f: or};£;;_ §{:f.<3r;j2jéEs  ' §'f27£;f""eS£F1€Cf. warmer:

Eéggisigiiigs "if;  L!" 5;'«;1f3vIf§§?j§!§i02';£",Qf7{Cm} is mzf.s?u,se<i.

 pfagéti» !:'?1£2.."vVcVzVV'bVus:3 Qf pmsesss Q)"
 & E2:*;;w,'   E€2gi$ia.:'z:re to a.n"2end,
7:":a_<_;£€;'f'g; ;;:e; a  ff" séeerrrrzezi na2«:?essa:y,
 53¢'-3\§  Qiggrcz Ez2oZus;{.r£es L{.d,, :2.
 ;<<_;a;.z;.Cap':a;z" smgees mi, s:2<:m (5,: scat
 'F?':.s3 Eegisiazifve {:a,s:.s:s amésszis carmﬁsé
  '~T.:;"S;:§g:2;;>iz'e:§ by jz,:{§z'ci.<::E §F"£§:3?}*}féB§'CZ€fé>{f
";3§i%§é?ess; §L<:zz':gu.a§;e (sf S'6{3} is gyiaén r:ar2.{§
 z,:z'z5m'zi>z'g;u.zms; }'."§'2.<2:"<3 is no» s{r{3§3s3_jbr' magiirig
s<>:ir':ef:'§z.€:2g z':'2.{.{2 5:1, as: i.{?CiS {:Z{}m;> in

Nzzrszgi:3'2}z52§5:E"2,':; éfiiféé? {z_,:pm}'. En.



='E%§=»

N1::s"§;:sr'25€5:é5:f':'5; :;?a:2;e {$E.£f}?'{',l]e {Egg-2 pcmggi {,g;.r_§,jg., "

j'i.:.2*'i§:er s£'.r{354{.*¥':€:§ ire f'2s:»:z:e {Em §§i'fE€ pe7°€5).& %:.:.;*'2.'_'  '

jfam c2§a.§:'e> qf" §s'?e9f"E:i{?€ cgj' Efigit C<>:.ar§f_:;» "<;zjd.ei_f;'~

3:333': :1 v-z's:w <;>a:mn.Q: be ;=¢9:%l<':m'<>iZec;.i a,:;.éi:%i'-51%: ' A

E€z.r'§g:.za,g€ (33.5? E}. if §,?2e:'A§,:i5:i;i§ czzftrsggji"-(551 iii 

z.:;::,>u.£e:§, nz<2£.:?'2 §.§'2.a:. {3i {,,'::3§Sé;' c€:}"t2_ ff}? ::7<}z,:5-':*§:=*;i 2);;

£202': (wig; Cisgff} cmd ,1' "'a2z;"E€i,} Qf" i.-§2.§g_Vpr0:{_sis€§.»iii"

E§.5{E}, bus: alsga by Q..I3<'}f'2.vr.§)?"'B§S'{'f3"fb€ff'fI%§;'I"i€}iC"§.

Same can r'2e'2V:2--53_FV:73€3 3132:» ;E:v:gzi;=;--§_c':;£.Az':3e _mi.{-2:'z£:;

E 4. '£7ws:; pr§'r'z'CépEé§3 Q;ff__c{:»:*a_s§;9é,z;:§E.i<m worse
:"e£a%gf'i2"zg;; "Q :",aE.:.:ess? z5}%?2€s$z;s"~a':':5§~*£.?":<2 other in

'é?gICiiTC5. ii}"%'ea:iféif?g"'~€!iz;gé, .s¥:--;0.£;1-;z:'e as 5: whoie

 ﬁzppzéar €;éf§ §3:;=_":.i,2;3E§ seifﬁd. Under the firsz'.

 §}ni:z1ci;iZ@:'V"A-Q=_<}::;3z.:.g_ {2zm'ssu;<; Carma: be

":'-:1: 'wiiraiﬁ E261 E.§Tz.e°'£TL'<:ur£T 835(26):'. Er": :':E':.z2 Case 0 "
.__.:_ _.}.  . L

_ ztieészsf. $2!-3e:?'{3ssi'é'g; and :,a:?2en ?'{3€€S{}?'Z for if is

V _,;'1'§a:gr2cE 2'3': E.'E':e,{_',f?>z.:r €?{}?"F'Z€3E'S 53;' {he :--;z;0.:z.::',e z'.z';::~:e§,f"

 V%}:.:.§, "<35. (he Séifﬁéf §"z'me:5 a C£2;$L£.S {}FfEiSS{,£S

  §'E{}f. £36 rg:2e:1f:'.E§,: f:*';}'I3rre{f {maxi far" Ehai.

.- ~;;é.:':';z§<)s{;> QEE 5.32.2 ;}CéI"Z.S Q? a ;<;:':'a:z.1:.:,{> 52:" $e{7E'.'€::§n

 2"?"z§.:5;§. £352 :::;'}r"z.<;:E:'r'zie>c§ :'.<}§9iE'1.er arid ea:g3:"§;

zréazzse <3? 5; :1;es:?§.f{m :~;E20uEc€ P}:-3 e:2t2rz3i.I'§z£-.>d m:'§.'§2.
2"af,f?e:'e_§'2.{:.=<3 5.9 {.519 {",'{f£?'?,E'.e'?X§l' ef§?"E:',§ 525553;' gtéazzses

3,





,3?»

i:§'2a>rz9zg_f"° se 2'.§'2.a: z':}':e <?or'zs:':r"::c§'i<;rz'z :10 be _;m.:4 «:35; 

a p£::"f'i{:z.:ie:z;' ;3r"0z;2's;i{;:': maégeg 5: zf{Jz'zs€::éc.r:_z'. V. L' 

<.§>;'m::z.:2'zs2r1£: Qf" §"§"2e wfzssie 3§"{:E:':.zi.e. 'f'f':.z'sr 'Z€ff€}ai.?{f  '

E36 m,<}re 50 if Ei.z"'s3rczf {_§€}.§1;<§j§}'"§,.i{?'§,§{3*?E.' " E:-;,_§_":V . oz"

p{zriz'c:z.:Ear <:£<:zz,.z;e;e> Eaacissr 1'52:;ma:'z§féi~:::E§;»:r:E)S'z~.ari"é.= 

0:' {:zfzoma:Z(>:;.s> z's35;:£ZE:§; wi"2.z'CE:.. 52:;-:._;£d :r':z;z'.".+A§2«§g'::::-*

been i:'2i"r3:é0Eee:25 by _VI,,eg§:§Z(gz"z[::'¢j.    S

:'r:5,er"z§.z'm1 I10 ;3r<>d.z.scg; '-.Q::u. :.s.r§fé::;S{:gnabfE{3
m$ul€"  Scaici.' §§&:.':ci{:.i§Je;;z.$j§' ~  A 15;': A:r§:emz'.o2..(
5). Pm5opz'<>z;1. {E    ?j:__<>1'; £0 be
Exnpzziegi' $0 a ;3Vi&S§a'4§§fg  V-is'v:£<9;*;':2'2£2 0:316?"
5:a::,<~;3{:*z,::&§i€:é§:1  3 v;"%f':;?*:i:;>:?Le* £0 appzg;

zaﬁiﬁrdfg  Eherﬁziiyé "'£;£}<.>Lz'£:u1'..  "dfe;]?§a:' {he abvious

 z'2r1.i}e:=*r:;{i(}n Qjagf f.i':é«,Eeg:'.siaf,{on 01:25? pmd.::ce 9:

 ziﬁfzoiégig la::%i:*e:czsaE':a£§'ig§ z'esui2'."' we nrzusi, "da

s'3*--<24:?2§:¢ ;2:{:v'Ze:"ic€2 ~'§'(;"_;'-Fee :mm's and $9 achzfeme

_ 51525153 V-.(;EéU€oz.s.s*V' z'z1§ie'3nz.z'<,>;*<s amerf pr'e35iz.z<:¢:> -:2

.A_m~§.i;0r:.aE};:?€}f§::;::*:.z<:Z.i(}:2, {Per Elsrd. Reid in L:.i.?€2€
--._;:;§5§%;z: 5;;-¢;5§ AC 5f§?}wE'°:€r€ a: 35?? Egg

 .{j:§..:<;{2's:}E;:§é;s;*r:3s;*cf. : "§'.§1z',3 is :"?(}§f 5.: I'E€E.U pz"obZem,

.~ §§::}4%,.4zgj?2 egg?" :§zk:zm*§s::rc§ s,j3f':'ir:§f":'ir':g :5 32.5623. :"'§":az

~~  :'af2~3E§,.; {:;r?z¢>:*ges$ '7



»}.8~

 

5. En gm: case Q5 SAN? :  .5 VS. §%%J§NEER.«_£I;$};--«{A§R

}§?8 SC 3691}, re§g;»1:'{1i:':g' EEK? I"'§E§¥;'5S 3!} E39 :'€:3}¢£':I'i.5-i}{i%£f§§{}.:";¥*?"ﬁ'}--€§ *

i:1{€1°;}r'et.§.3.1g s3<1.21i.u..{.€i--s, 21$ f}E1E"él§§E'L'-1E1}i'E 1?' if ..§.s»;_§:€E€§_'as '*{2"1':%f§e:*:"f"'

":7. 'E"':.;:<; ?"'E§§€,'5§ mz,s.:;f. be re:12£%:z1E.%3:"é9? ::;:i':€iz:? _
§n€.er;9§°5:§::'ng deecis am? 5:-:;:£:'z.g.i.esr,. '3'§1<3 ;

53:25: is {2} :

 in dz'r:;f£.ing if; is  e:1:ifr:2g§'z *gai.f":'~z1_ degree
Q2" pmcisian :2_sE1:'.C?'z. (:25 ;2_2;'i€:?(é}1 5re.a;::.cfi .5 gaod.
_faz°i?'a cagz. ~§%}"E£i¢3?'S:§fﬁf1%¢i','V'v:f}L£.f{  r2.€2Cs-:S'Scz2"g its
a{"f,ai_:1;..    Q:  :éfVVV'precisforz

wh.:C§'_z,V 0:i:_;;>%;;>_rsc}E: ':"s;%ét'c:ﬁr:gg%" £3: EJE1d jE1i£[i1 <:?a;m0£

ﬁrnfs:,z?é§é§f::5:*5;fT;j£f?:iA .S€:'COI'l(1. Omar is {more
§:é"ﬁ,I90'rE'a:r:i ' : 1'7§1~;rci Woréd. C0iiT15.fi€S.
Si.a%':z:?:§}ry g:?':ms;Azl;j:_.b:'=.z::€ﬁ.,i'«:::%s'z, so bag as mu: :5: at'.

' 'ffm serié'aa2 <Vgf"  <cam'2::>'z' be e:£iz2e:)r'Cc-ed _f'mm
 éwsggéazi  '§'i:ai" £5; wfyagg s.:.>e§;'cars:'

3  . }§,?e§{zT:$»?5é.:,{£}éz.. Efke {he «$2253 wz'{;E'2 z;:2}":;ic?'2. we are
%'7:ve3}Z.'{T? fi?e§i¥'$.ﬁf€'I'E"£&'3§.. mazsz, be izzier-:rg:}r5§,e<:% 2'3': 3
23:";Pé§.:"5i"'ﬁ"z3rE{§ g:}{3:';';_g;»e?Cz':':iv<2, We are no: on {£323

a E';'f{;§z .5-iv-e;':z.:e er Vsitasi, firzai <5?' i,and<m. 1/E/":3

" Céféf :3': as Ezfiéy 2"s:>g:'{}r'2 agf -rm. E:':5§?az': E"{',}:1:3:fz :::z''f.'f'z

»:3



§?'E.E§€'§}€;'f'?§.'S sfmggiing {:0 {we anzif. ?'2.zé(ic§£f:':§;j%)2*"  T

51:55:': 3, Off Caries}mm<;ref£.a{.i{m.

£:jz:.(3n(ie5E £0 ;3mz"ez7E'

":'"'he;> 3:21;: izseéf ' "

i"e;:*§'E.€i2"£§.S f%'{;:n. V "

z4:n:"ea.s;0§':€,:F3Zé? e:2z'.<7::i<}rz améi  '£3'; -. . §,§'z{5;'<;jf3:>fé§.~ I. '

§{J{,id£3€f ca Emizs in fcz.m2:.:.r {;3;7__ §.§":;:;z;,T ..e;;'f§CjL'::;f§*' 

ih:2:'2<-,j_;"é{:i.5.:;*i£2;<;« §ﬁJ§2ez: z',r;§.é:_r;>;'e§'i:2g; 'E"§1£? :.{32c'i'--".A_Q_f""

sz.:.::E': p?°omisz'0:2;s-- s:;:,nci é1'.'.:;"é%:'..%»§'z.(}Zc£s'.. gz.:o;:€'v_; 2':5:*--  

reacffng ::'1'2e _2i'ne2a:r"zz'.n.g:}...  CE€}e::£.Lfi?€?§_7liS 

regguéaiirzg {he réZ«a_i:'§:'):z5"_be;f::.:;@e;*z{fie w:3a!<'ez*
and zifie ssmnger C-0??Ef?'G{f€.i§'?g--=._§§ZIz'§"f€'f€fSs we
:'mgs:E: reV:'mf3§2":.§}er g;;:3'1ai":1r': _af%. L'e,arZ§es:::E€{>is:i{m

<gf£:?2z1€:.r. ﬁfauigfé; Ems: 'ﬁwlesrrjz oE9;::Qr:2ed{3'}'jV

 §::.§2>rje  (s.z"is{-3% 5:-$12.6; GandE'z.z'a.r":

5€(:Z:é;maf.:z Vt";r§.f"L"?{.)é'"I'§f:,?E§""A.§€" :f<3<)£ Qf z'nte;:;0rs3i.a,£:'<3«z2

'WE?s;:2e:;e:";,§€>é;a €e3*¢°';:'2 aiaubz'. ....... ,, appig; the

' --j%35£E(2w}'.§2§{51953. féecézlé iE1ejE:ace Qf 3.319 pazmségi.

5::-;1a§.»:';?'2.e w::%€z§e:*¢*:;§:. man :2.:?2<m2 yam rnczgg h:::;:e

.5fe:;>;"':;.,_ E5363 a:=:§{ ;;;€;u.rs{2§}'; gf' i"?'2.<.> sérep _ggou

'c.v:§%::,s:é:':%§;é§fg€i:e3 is g}z3§::§; 5:0 51:6 Q5' gang; use ii}

 if 2,5255 re:nemE}§3z' {.§'2.e>;s;se 5.2.9:'; rzjsées' gm-,>

C?i}f'E{f§Zi.?§i€}I'§. is easy %I.§'n::§. z.?2e:"e :15; ms;



a2<;u

as<c£:.:.:;§.:3<3z':e3s Q3" ;3:.:r§3os<2 §.E'2a.§. {ram E36 spa:
{)£.£.f Qf Sim §.«gas=;a.> (£9951; '§'?'2m' Sc:-Ts:>{:E<:s :13: {Fig-,'»?  T

§}{}§.i.(.>2"1"E. Qj' Zfw {?(E§£€_1? Q?' {fie §.(z;z'zc§E:'H'<f. 

7. '§'"E'1.é: z'&;':sex C0:.::'?; in 'i,E1<:=. Qezsmé (>5 _ V'

EAL & SQEQS 'i/"$5 mmzg mA1*H,"A:g .::_§'.86.;s¥¢ s-ggéck 5:,
p2ira§,_:jrz1ph 9 has heki 2:5; uridez': V A

"Q. So we see that'. the p%'§:jréf5a»r;; a1'2a"_.}'2_)é'z2T:?*:().sff v:.a$i«:
Qf Q. 5033"!" in izzijeirgre£:'tirzg;'":a~.$'€':;§5tz;»i€; is E'{}':2;§;z:e:sfi..»::z'n
zihe m£er:.§;zTe:m, Qf £31-é"'< §£?giS§C£{:£:?"é?;' £§CE_:i:2,;E Q3" fnzpzzrged.

I-iaving cz§;cerzair;<;gi.' E4313 viV_I_1i:Q5rz£'1f{}.rfe{'é:fL,:%--';«;:::.»;.:.z'if musi:

 T'  iziferif/§1?;€3VE: {he s§.a:4'z:z;e3 as 510
 ";,:§?'t§m0'é',e_/ §€'€:.{E'/'--f.1;}"'Tr1e:_"2L-':*v '§1.f%éJ_.{)3:jj€C§ and pt.z.rgo<)se Qf She
eri{2:;§i.?;*>;f2;éV€.'. _ ."E'"§:;r ﬁﬁis' p:.:.rpose. ::>%2.ers3 rtecresgary
 5,318 Cx7s>':5{§.":§za,;,rx' €;'§£'?T£ {fepszré fr'om §.f'z:<,>: ingie ifzajg
;,.g:'vf,a2':r7_. w<3r:b§s""$§i<2t£Ed be iz:€.er;;r€£.a-355 acérordzézg 5.0
~v.§:4§V'éc2if«v;::§2£z:_:t meaning. '_l"E':c:;°£-,> neeaé be no zmzek and
 z:5;%f_z_:Q '~:$':f£.%}:?2§s:;i(;:'z 2'0 ziﬁze ;>£.azf:'m.es;5 <3? §:'§2s;>
V_i:z:'?§é§.5é§;e, "F0 aizwézi _gt1*£2Z':'en::' :'r'g;'u:;§.ica'> o:z's,{}§?15:Eg; gr

* _5L:i%sz,::2%iz".£.§:_; or {.0 cazészici :'m;oz£f€ic2€.2iz:>:'z. Qf Em:/2 §.i?;e
§;Qa::°{. E£}{"}E,£E€§ be :.:.:>€,>§£ j:,ssf.§';'%'e{§ in {"»£ep{§r§.z'z2g L 51%}???

éfzzaé s;<:»--::2:zZ£a><f, §;fé.'}£€§€?'E :':.z§<'~3. sgzf «.::oz'2,:s:§.:':::;:ii{3.:'2; 3:3 ass 50



gizﬁe gg;f)'%;>{:E' {:9 {F29 =:)§E;;e{?§: a:':::f, f}Z,£,?'pE}S€>.  

'i
W.'
:7

 

:3:'z.a<7{"n:.er'2{ E33; ;',§E.£p}:3E€,'£?'3.s3I'Z§"i?'E§§, §';?'2.e z.m'€5.!"£3n__%i:%€}i"*,L

:2.e{:ess::£rg;a "

8. E2': 3%}? {E2186 <35" B1'£ATI$ §NTLERl¥£§,T£0ﬁ;};%.:L¥"':§?S, 

mgmnra s,A. 3;. ANRW 200214; $CC:'z'95__;§-a p;gg;_g;:+;:.;s:a 

A§.)ex C::r£,:;rE. haza heid as ur1<;i€3::

"'3"hc-3 C<3:1vr;>2"::.é'i_}f2<';§ twig; _oj" :z':::(3%;9:f£3z'.z'r1'g a siaimje
is {:0 seek the zf3i=_:€j«:':r*ui.:i«:::}*1;'Q;'f '£;.:§»._mc;.icers. if a
SfI'&E'IE£{.é:?f'_Ljv prm-'::s'£:>:i{'£s "=3;}«:3r: f4()a:"211<5:'<3 §.?1&E'§ {me

$.31fJ€'ijY3F"é::§i<'3iif<'3*?f"i §I?':€§ft'V%3E.£3_'C€}£.i?".3'7'e:3;:~§ to Choose Z'f1a:'

 """ Hgvfl'-'?T'€é":':'fV;:C??7€5&35Ti'53'i'?».'jQ"§§§???.iC3'?;."VW%9epresez'z£s the zme
 fF"!}:{"€i':I?.if€€}I;%: "Q)f;3.31%;"§{%§;;2Sidf.l£I"€. ﬂtis ﬂask cfjierl is
"r1{}£:";c;r2VVé;> a.§;g,§  (£2155 §;ez:-eretzi d;',{"]"ic:.z.£§.z'£?3 arise
<25? a;:(?§r€}:;:f2z'  z;ar£e§,;; Q1' re<:z,s<3ns, bui 5:55 3:218

_ 3615718; ":V'.ff""';':'::.'z;<;i: §'}{f Ejzame fr: mmci. §.E2.a2f. 2'5 is
"~€:*:=:g;2)s;s:?)Ze even far {he most. imag€r:.z:2:ive

A  :"":£:::§;z':§{i:;;"f:':»::"e is j}:;:'€3s::'aEE €s:f':a:£s§§.::e§§; 5;§:::z;::E:'f0:25
~r.;.z?2}<§ e:?§.:~C:;.:*r1sf:£ar'2;Ce2: siizai: mag; :3:_n:2r°§e qglﬁer
g:>z'2:az{:r::':"a§ a ;s;§':aéu§é3 aszfeere z'§.:s; appiz'e::ai.£::ms may
E',}'é;' éraiieﬁ jbr. IE is in sage}: cs sEi.'§.£€::E.f{}§'E me

<r=:>am'1"*ss :€.zTzz';; :5} 5-::;~:g:s<}z:rTz<E arfsssasg £é.?§€§'E oz {.'€£E£§€{}?"i.

 //"'



-32,

§Em.§" :"§'zs: :':mm". ;§E'2:>::£{E r'mf:' {'21:} :0 §egz'.§;§a,§e. 3:-§x'i2.£{E'::%_ 

:3,»:s:2,:7'::.m'zz§; ca pzfi;'"§i{i'£.£iaf' ;>m:>:'si{m Qfsz ${fC%§§.':'.;'§;§.3*§i7s:§ " ;_.

j'§.:2::£. <::s:.:§ :,::?T:a3Z"E'2<?:" E"?':€ jm"€sc£:£::.z°c'm <23)" ::1'.§?{}z.s'f_'iV. is

<>:zs§:e(§. 0:" 33535, the g:3ri;mi'3{;;%--§.e {zgf Vgzfzi-z;*;cz"sc:Ef_

c:_g3pEi.<:c2§,i€33': is :'§[:€z3"' {2rd.2ir'ir'1r"iZ;;_';* jig»? 'j.:Lz'a7s:i*2'fc7f'  

mag; 2393:' be €}l.£S§€C§."E.!§"1:.Z€:'SS ' £_f':é:' zragérgj»'§§é:c;é';:a23:):°§j;
gs rouisécm €;r:p£f<':iz.Eg; ""€§a':§Vf{?az.es   ?   5;;
i:':[ere3z2.E"i.aZ c{;z;1.§?Za1.sz"0§jr----§.f:§év--_<?{(;~s..§r§:' c§rf§Z:2.s.2s  {he
same :.uf1.(3:':   'Ea ?;?:a)::*zéi':-3.;.z;§t.'eE3:'2_b is zine 0:25;;
carzciusrion. I\£oi.:i:§=:V}"a.é'£_::iz§dingv " 5.;-36' __ &<}r':z;en:z'.0n.a£
f}r£z':_;7§;:=f,§3 '--z:'_I'z(a:':§;§A§:e  ;?>;,f'.;.%';_,':4gf:i§%;s:é:st  {.0 £,>}.:p0u..r:s:i
4:51;:-§:'--..;;<;~§AﬁL£;{):'_ E8gf;t{_ﬁ*:.§. £35315':§)u§"'§é E20a:>e iakert {ﬁe
z::ica:.z,a;--i:_g':i5:;a;;f 51:?ji£5f(:§CiE'":z.rf f0f z',ni.ez°pre:a.z,i0n ::4.m:i

ozpj;9ré:_isaZV'§Vf.S €:'r€E;%;::ed :;:2i€'3?¥:. crea:{;:'z2:z.;; and r»s:a.i:'sr:rz

 imd _S?Hi :'<?.M "§E2.§l'€f§§'£f{'C1.iiQF1 aimays i2°:r"zp£.ied (2

Egg-_'L{}}'$E? Q;'w'§i€Ef§{§§"£'§"iO}'2. and. :fE'2e:3:'«:%{-L {E16 ::'oa:rz"s

_ ;a><§:.z5.saf V5zi:§.{>,z;§.', par:.{:fz:Ear§;;, in areas; :~;:.a.{:§2. (La

, :.'a:>:"2..§;§:§:z::isf};":s:;éE a:{ju;d:'c(,z.z',{.{3:'1 sfeczimg :,v€§:f*: s;oe::€aE

 ~iIé§1;;Ci; {§§{'l£S€ {5;:'.c} :"fgE:.§:'s¢ C0z.z:"£.s ozre Em-zrgg 'bra;

  "'§>:3i{.§.]V5é;<; ;_'4';{i(?'1i'.=,'I'§2§"£.z'/;"?'--E*§.3 ?"£;jf€?}{3¥'E§' £2353'. §§{}§§é§?1{3?"$ «:3?

~§,e{g:§:'§<;E5;z'§<}:':. :.::§';.:':r?": atamsas {<3 éhem ff'? 5: s;§:'€:;':e

 :'e{g:.zéri:'2§; ::5z:";z':':g;; :ie§;:"»3es_; Qf:fs.zrE"E2r:>r _;'}F'{}{,'€'SS€§"ég

{$66 {f<3r0<*z':;;'€. ipéid,  Parz. _,!§:'?2e2"z'::s:,{:2. .4-='%:'3' , 252;;

1355 535% 23:5. ;),.§J7.§f:3, E-E-"E34? 5:5. p,?3"1, §E.€i'£I€f Qf

i
3%

//'/



=23-

Efarfggarta; v. S0:m.pt.zr{m 8z'n§g§'z. 335% aéj ;3.E§}5T7}3 '»T

if (2, iarmgzxczgge 15.3655. :15: cragyabie 53;" §3{3a.I"'i?"iQM 2':-":,<j'eis;-->'f_ '

ihcm {E3253 e9nsE.'mci;i<2:'a in saaietiiizég _£:?ée :)fr':;:.%-5*  

meam'.z'2g, rzsgzarci z'ri:u.s:.' {gs 3:51;} .--  b 
<?():zs;eq:.:ez':{3es, reszziiing 12.;/£""r"<}s":r:f:" «{£§§)f}I?I§'zt§{ '- _Z;ff:,§%.?"'
5:i£,em;a§:':'::@ c:):z:~';§:'ra:Cii;):'zs,   'c{>2§I':'§§:'rz.é.:::i€é:%, §';?3.CaE': '«.
r€$§.sEi's in §1CL3'€§S§EE}3°._V.'"'$¢3%'"*EOI,.£S V{£?.C{)ff§@%'T§.§£f?i§,Qe_..;
€.;§ju..s:ice, a,bsurd:z',;; or VLE5:a1§):r2:;zig; §2%*--?,§}§':1iéf}1 igzadg
5:0 ir2C<3r1$isi;e3raé§§;..or 'I-,1V.f:£'<"L"'€,"A&""E}""C:41;s'_'!'l:i;i_4}'._'CUICE f§*ic?E=fi%)rE in
{he S§jSi€UZ 2;}};i:';:'?'2 " §'Ef:j??3::'   ggurporis 33::
regzséaze. }1as .g;Q~..Er{:::> Vr:;:?€¥"'SE§¢>§;§..  prgfererzse
sFzat3€:VZﬂ«\::1?3€V 9ii:e'€é'%'A'é. £7c§ ffziivi."--xC{:r:..ss:i£:mc£f0n which
a.%'2{)i0:S:'w.§§'ii:*§'*s. réslz;--I.LiA§é;   J9}msr:;n U. M0re£:oz'1

5&1'?-iii'  " U.  ' ' ' «ﬂ"ar1ic."V Qfértes {Tipiomﬁ .2;§id.,} In

 $»$Eecz:ir:g. "Q1:§.»_<:j;'7__ti§ﬂ%r'er1£. z':2':'erpre€'a.r;i0r1s, {file

VEQEENFEV zéiiii :(id<;p§"'"';::fIa{: mhfciz is; just, 3'E3C£3e:}I"£€£§3I€

_ Cmd Vsggzégsifgée ﬁ'a:'h5:" than ihaif zufzicfz is male; Qf

_ égfwfse ihjétgggv as? 2': nzagg be presurneéé éizai. rihe

 ~§é'g_iéE€:_i':ure sftmzici Ezavés used the word in zizaz:

 ~ 'i;<1§:'s5:f;§?é3zazT.i<}z"; miiigfffz Z8535 51 <2_»;j'}'"'>*r'a::"£s Gar $63239 <3!'

' *;';:;;§4;':€::=:-,2 {:2 S§%arm<m Eﬁszaixfilies Lifcé, :3, E/'2'.£Ee2 558 Si.

 Micfzei. EEC mi pp, TE92~:'.~};'-38 Emrd Sfzaw sé;z:z§.s-355:

':84W"Ww
.\



-24"

'*i%;'here wards qf ca giairue are dear,  
ihegg must; of Caurseg Ere faéiowggg;   
but in fheir Lardships' agiriérén V  'A
where aiéemaézive c{;r:s:»:*2;;c:icé_;ns . 1éz%*éJ' V
equaiiy aspen that c:E§em{;:£:;r§  '
Chosen which ;.ai§L§ be §;i::r_L§ésieni 1
the gmoozh wof'§d%é;«;: of .{?'2«s:j sV§;§§ef%'a. V
which :36 s€a:a{--£'?§:"vp:{F,p_or€s' "Z:<Z.?'.._b§? §
regulatifzg }f;:,ri:d' ii':E:5:i'. 'aLE;i¢£%z*7r;§:;;%t§;}e is So
be rejeczigci   --».IV§{:_i?~3duce
1 5' Lefgjcgrtaiiﬁiyi, :F.':i:C:é{'}:%;?,.'>~T§:: _g0?r§f?m,éian inte
V ~ g,§.er$;§:_;:g  'Qf t?':._€ é'géze}%é§7'
"""  a)§;§§é}ﬁE'ed by Subba Rae, J.

A 'w ?u'€<2: " fﬁécﬁion 393 of {he Sea "{f4_§;,;<s%f"Q5r:;:;~i;_}§'(V;': 'in «:am:é:1g is the cancéusion ' 'V i'§'?LﬁZv-f'§fi €"CEhE',€#;'" 0} Customs Auzheriiy was met an V {}f,;-{M£fE:C€'I".VOL}""V"'i!.1e'i§5VSiG§'§VL§. {Caiéecter sf Qzasicrms :5.

-- __ﬂ§':gé.i§g'a.gSinfyfi Spg. &. Wag. Miiig Lzd.,,% ._ 9 ihﬁ Sugareme Caurt in ihe case «sf MGR " " ';.__§:§§,§;§:Ris,:V/__A'1' mag TR:w$F§R'§" SQSEEEY mg, -253* 83 SEQ?" $9 §$'§?'ERf§§¥r$2¥'§' Q?' '5 V' QQ EARYANA 3% ,.ﬁNR.,, 2§Q2{6} SSS 25$ 21: §§:«:.1";1g2°a§3E: iE<% E2313 hiiki as z.:m'Ee;'': .

"Tim m;>.x:) qz.:€s;§:io:': :.a2?'1ici'E faiisfzw c0r':'s;::f§'é3--r:"»::{i.r3;*: , A' :;:§':.a€: 5:-sf {fie :2c:r::m;> Qf z'.he> 'j;E°.:'zcz;':<?s°.c:;'z'-«.§_%i.:e3;§;>3£" % ::r{)§::2:>rnpEaz'.@:E. by {.516 S£E_f.{§~~ gig)»-s.éc£.i€:z":':;.1» e::\rg:>r'ess£on jErzcm_cri::zE z.nz.¢=;:e3:-.A.:<;.fi»;:apa;2gc- €i2}" 'Qj r"zc:rm:..u<:r as w<:=£E as Q :.m'e:L3.'«?;' ":':1e5:z'ei?1E§; f'z"2" éhé? . :2e:::':'@u:e:' :~;<2z'2ss3, $11'-v._f§.E'ﬂ:§?3ies. V. e"§.£r'e:c:{ "v_:;2té--:f;éi§r'2as£' E')52n{--;jfz'.i. Qf C{}'"E.'_€3C{}F'ZO??f;i_Q;:'Z'£QiE{f'€., !z*:« .836 vvziizyider sense, :5 ITECLQ."";.?1.z:'E§.;dg. .g§1':g.'§'.§f£'££r€S§. direcf: or frzdireci. wﬁéciz a. f._gf)§ve:" s%;:;*%"1:'Vf1.:::5 '£:%_ f .§eE_;:m'.i.<;z7 is {he ¥}"fE"E3CiI}.:'»g:/:">'j§ ggf' 5.1%}: g.£?:5:£§'r:.é::i«:';?:':g. 3 fjgséh. an imeresz. z'r':;§;;eV;?}'2::{$£, _<zj_' an Qffi(?iCi§ who marzages 5265 :mder§:a§ci:'zg 0:" an wham.

V§i¢z:$fA{A,sv. iﬁée. _§9f.;3fC?,:3: %.~" (L:=fj'EFF'?.£1?"I{3EiC{E azscowz €.a§3'iEi!.yg ff, 'Es :h".£.e:_>. V £0 §;agg shat. {he z'mLer2§:i0r2. 53;' 5:319 §é5;i§§aizaré "" 'éézzgsi be jk>:,md by :°z3o:0I.z'r1:§; E1316 as a zwzaésa. T§'f'2e3 :*:;::eu.r§'; magi' QSC€3f'£€£if'1 'V ' '¥f":i;e/3 €=r€$s£z:§.€<>zz Qf' am: 2egz'3Ea::':.g.re 29;; cE.:"re€:;ir"zg {Es '. .:;;€':;I%3:'E€:'§{}:': 3:35: merefgg {5} {.536 »::E5s;;,ise5 {5} be u 1 {::§::.;<;z':'rz:e{§. Em; {<3 z'.§":.e? <3?'1::z'z'<»? S§.C€€.E.£f.€f,' gmzsz s:2n'2;3:,:;z5 SE12 grésszzzsa :::z'§E'2. zfze {3E.'?'2,s:%z"' g9a:'%?s 53;? 3%:

'.§'.E"§"i§if17V1?;'3 "§{'f,§§§E§§~i3:.j§'é2E°€;'f: '"§"E'}€ z:E:22,y mi' J2.§zi%§::?$ E35} <:,=>;;3:_';z.:r1{§ 21:35: z'i{i;i'. =~2{%= 3:12;}, 52:2:/2'. §.Z':e s.<3E"f£;'Egg £3': z.:i?2.i<::'§'2 ﬁle {::Ee:2a.:::;'e ~i_':L%~ a'.r'2.§:'es'p:%5§'e£§ {){,'{,'.EI.3'ES. The f":.£E€f is (ff, -1"

a.pp£i{:aif<3r'2 525 9:25:22. ihe gjiczmessz. €.a{ﬁr_2}§$.%'~--m§;.§,§'~E3§ <ra1'I§mEE<2>€E ﬁg; {T5253 Cf{)*E'Ei€X£.. V~3"ﬁ{3':3Jr§}r§2$s_.€(§§*:.:§gzéédil in 5: Si{3fi'£,£fI¥z2 s}1(}zz.ic§ .r>rd.z'.:':é;;°:'£;;;"bug?z.a.:'i;t{e:'3§€;2:;€% cs SBIESE' in 2,:2?':i:7ET2 EfzeggaE193:VE3§§f7:2'z(2:'2i;:;? :gaff':.sfzégj <)E.;jec{, (33,? the sz.a£:4:z4e."'*.:."4:j:.éf€::,?;. 2525:3332.§§,}j}ée§f:.:.z$i:¢Mi?'ze objeci. (2,? Size £c,»;g:'sEa:.;:V:i,r--"<3:"./.if'}"ie?::f¢fE;r<é.,' ':s..5.?>:€;%r:§ I',a.::e:> in z1erfpre£:cai.€.oz§,s~ effE.:a3%§b§;£>; "vf;f m. :;fra§.zrz'. wiéi _g:;re'jfer E:'?2az' 15:31:62: ad.;:gr£-ass re':rzé>dg:;: sﬁ---.zppress {he mis¢§"a;;<§f'aS {ﬁe £¢¥g$f;§?ic:a.;$%§:3'_g:2_zfLa,%:Z.;€§§z>é;:s3ci. §{eepz'ng :'?_2;e:.§e4;;>25if§c§fpic>$ .;:2ir1_sz.:;:.:>e 2201:: consider ah'-2;a.§i:,_:%f%£cz::§'fri5;T. ?i'§j:;. §z".z;<-2:/2, E0 expressian.

""" 'Vff;i§'z:.§}r§T¢£a§¥i€:2?1Z:§§'s:§.'£ in §iif:;~secf,{or1.{2} {if 5::<:<:E.z'<m.

Qif ' 1%} §E¥':rQ:§;..é.%z€.a§1:}'r'<::Vs;i§ci jm;dgn:e:1i:::~s. ii is dear {baa {her ~V.<?%3IE1'»*'€*£:~i§i3¥1é':3 'W&%}"'"éﬁf__1;:;:i13:';3r€::§z:g a :--3?;.21'{.ui,+2?: is '£0 E'-Eéféfk £326 .3"

gm ._2":°2';+;.;s,€::".;~;:. if :-;1 S"§'.6§{.LiE'.{)i°§=" §:}§*c3visi.:;>§; is): apex: £153 more E4§."}.€":1$i; §)f£'Eii' V::"§.§;e.§"p';*éi;z>:*E,§0:: i,h::=.:1 é..E1<: <:<mrE has 'Ear; {?§.'}{§(}S€3 Ehéiil é:*:"£'.€r§3?é§,3.'£;*:§.§>:é' "wE'1.iz:.§': ra:%§>r€::5;m"::iss {E16 *£,:":.z€: §I1§.€E'E'§Z§{}E3 af i:E":€:

E. L. E1} EEQESEEEEIQ. "§"§'1c;': p:"'§m:~::':; ;,m_€§ £'?:3§°a'%n1::};<;i. iasgis: <35 21: ~ ".§:*:

§3E§.§;'f§'}3E"€;"f§'§X1§§ 2% .5-3;E,aé,"a:':',e2 is; 'C0 2:a:~3{3§%3"i;;'.1iz': Eiééé i:':E.€:2;*{?;;i<3:: ' k%g,_>;i$E2zi:a1r€, E§.€.'.'{?;,§E13. or §m;)uE.e€i. _§;'.i.&vi:'1g_gjass{§ét:*'£i§zé.z1V€d_'* %'..E:r:j= i;2'é.:=,3"::';im':§ the <:<3u.;fé nmsi. 14%":c%r:a si.:"§.ve E0 [n.[i£4e:*'p.r{§%€4 %.'1';r: :~s?i4L;:;:.£':2§::e:% .215; in ;:smI:w§,::: fa1:§v21:1<?<3 Ehe " j<3'£';;j;§>(::'. é3.;~:1(i .§Z3'{%ET§3{)«:€§t*"£35': *:':i2<3= €fri21{fE,§}"i€*,§":i.. if 2: §21::gg;ua1g€'§_2.s;€ci 0? 'ihan ans e::m1:?;E::*u«::i;ia::1"1, in :'::g§21:'{€ nluz-3'z' be had 1.0 iha c<3::$a%qz2§.:;av;3}'V axdopmzg the aiEe'r°:1a'i,ive ' (mi: 0f di£'fc:re::§;

inte1'preiaé'.i0z1s-§.. '§.;.h:i§ {TOY,§£"'§. é%.%i1.3:'é:£%0§2i'. 'i,hai; which is ju.<:;L m21son21b§§e £1E1€§A ;E§£fI1'§§i"iE.E'€f*¥jE"{'i,-hf33T 2_;h.a.n ihgxé. wE*:i<::}1 is none af E;he:}s3€: %'.h.m.g..a as i%;.'?::é:}i_j b_i:'§%;jé%:~2:z:~:1i€:£§ '£.ha;é. {he Ee%§gis2ia.1.:2:°$ sheuicti ézzivae used ":';hé"wG2d_§V:§ €:.£v:a=;%,"' %.:2i&::p:*€E21ETi{>:: whictél Eszzsf. c};E}%::":dS '"."}_E,E2' sr_;%_'rii;«%{-:1 _Qf~§;:§i'.§.«::é; i".Z"E!'.€ in $21}? §',h2:§. 'iizhe §;':J;,@m.ie":>'n of am, VE€g;§i$§2*zé__:1,1:°€::V §':;::x3fL."'?.)_e €'{)u:'1(§ E3}; :*s3:a{§;§ng E:§2»:'¢ .<5EaE.uﬁ.€ 22,9; 3 Whﬁiéix "§'h£:=_ i7i{.>._u;:"if".z:?£_u.§g€.'~;:i§{:m*Ie1§:: aha é:3'£;<:%2'";%,3§.c);%; 0? 'éhéff §€',"§__,§iS§.§;%_§."i2E"§*, by .:'§ira:rf,iif':_g iitéa 2§1;i1'é:§€.i<§:3 :1<:»'€. m<3:'€:E}2' E5} §§'z:=& :::E;::':.:s;£:s&; £1} ha é70:":3E:<*u<*d

77. "?<2z"i:xi,<.} i.h:::'«:§:1i.§:":é %3'{,E'3.i'é.§fl£?I ii' :m1;:s2. {".{}§'Z"§§'}2'-§.i"€;f €,§':€ ('°:.§Z.§¥.'§S€3' wziih éhgé 5.28,, s3iE1m' p:»;n"£,55 {>5 ﬁle Ezzuz azzad {hike 5;-=;<;~:\.',':3'z.2'":gg; in xx-*%';3'.c§.': Size {:1e2:;.i.::;¢_3f"*£.;3"§:§e ;iz3E.«:%:'p:*{:'E:s:t{i :}(:€a,3r:§. Thif: z'uEé1=: is»; of ;g€m*.:"a§ 2:§>p§§<::§€.:<::1A ' {E16 p%&i;1.e55é, §.:3:*ms5 may e::{;:'1t:"{;E.i:::»:;§... by '{h€' <§::r:=:%_;x3XiI; =Th€':§ €XpE'€3fS8i{}§E5§ :,.§:§n:*.€1 in 2:: s1T2:.1,:2{.e3 shimE{i:":Q:1i'i'.:":ai*§13,}'be' ;2:1;d£:%${§§{§€§ £51 2: 8623-36 if} w§f;i{::h 'E'%3.€:jf b@.:'sE. E1i:r::1{):":E2:e%'W§1.E1. ihé? GE" '$26 = SE.z~3.€:u¢;€, and 1-'v'1'1iC':E'E {:££'€::i,uai€ ';E'_1'§3uu'»%Iv)§f}9;'€;*_V<?{, of *£.h e legigfisiaiura' 'J\z'hiE:f;: i.n?;é31';)'reiéng :3; pr0x€s§{>:€'s _'LE1;r_:. {§_<;2v':z1'E.V--.€L)v:"2AI'3?~ %:":£'.s3rp;°eE,s thés. Emit] am? atamnot §.e:%§;_§.issEa_'£'.e.._:iE;' _ "

1 1. ii: is ba?f_§:g:'aw;£m<f:V;§fﬂ weﬁ <~3si;,abii3hed rules Of éin1.er{>_rét:é;f:jQ1_1;«.Z@{:.;.iS- jibe :~3ei:'E.i:1g in which Se(:ﬁ<}n ".?'"§'--;'-% :10 'as 'Ea_{e;"p:"s§:%:d "a{I(':<'.;£i:<3§ﬁzfsarizlg in mmﬁ {Em inE.e-zaiiozz 0f the Eeg.i:s£af,u:*'€; VELE-';¢V{)b§e{:i' zmd pu1'p0,é=3€: of {£13 €i'§£:'i{?'{iYi€EEE zmiﬁ §§E:ﬁ1'€'J§1C"§'§;§:;ffKi'i~ Ej.>:"<)1,1;gN;»_§V§:"'}"'iWa§:s<}3;;1. by 5'-'mi. 23 05 E998.

$.13. " _ "»--'.7§_&"_"§:§:::Vr.,.2Tg;§3_:.. i:§":e:*: .E£21:"1"2.2?z¥iaE»§a Laxzd E??;€;*§'o:.':r2.5; fact? 'W328 Ef§§&%{f§.€E§§ in §...§?w3L'j;;z;%e2§' §9§§.§ 2";-zs:"§:«:*,2ﬂ ;;:.n':€:1c:§::':€n.i:s '£€J~f;'£'{3% bmugghi; is 3-;}L1?:§.2%::i_.%3::':§? :12: é.E1é: lféfifii' §.E}?'~/i i3}-Y ﬁiié, E. 5 1'%Q?'s:§ by wizéitirz by a E a E /» ' G{:w::*':.§;'z::tV:7::: ;3r<>vi{i;::*d 'é2:':{i€§' S§::>:':i;'.§0;<': :33?' st}? E._E.1€: E1<::E.. "£".'E:%3 $29,, &:'i.r:>E»<;e of pan 2:3 ézhzé E&?.§':££'::'1i'.£*.{§ §ami..<s; a>m:*<:% :§ss{tEz~:E*€.<:i'"i,e:§'~.Eféa$;:::

v€si'.€:{i wiéh Eher Gi>m%:"n:1':€ni4 'R252 whim: i:>E3j€<'§_I%;'--af -Sa*{;«§£ aEZ}(iE'3dI'ﬂ€§Ti§'. Waste {:0 Ehilé. 'iﬂha"~ _T3'.,i.1s';:*§" Of"%§'§i>. _"i.21§':d '.§,§<:*:3 <>{:<tu;}am:y :°§gm.5; in E"§i',S§'}I;:"i(tE' <21' !:h<--;*: §21'§2{§ 2:;1'mi":.;:E:~;§=<';_ E152 €ifs€'%:§'i%.;"é-iggé .a1b.s;er:E:ee Ea:':dEo:*d1'S1:L Aﬁei' :1€a.E§§;'2g :ea;'-a:€<;%e:ri3.:*gé::fE_c:':é;§ 'i}?3;,a§E[ . .%a.::::h, L §.:m21z}E,€d Eanéi ve.$':,@:i wiéh Ehe G0ve%'::3V:1.:@.:1§.. ¥h.i::~..r.'-'\.§:::'i. pz€wi.c£@ci E51"

ggrané. Gf {}{T{Tii'f38;I1{?:\.--' :;':%g.§h.E,s é;¢__>:";E'_:0;i;_€ ¥:_t:::12-ii":{s:« 'évhbe '.V€f1"f3 tizuiiix-*2it,i:1._g§ {he Eand iz11medi:,-1i<:Ey §.:>:"£<>:f~-{'14:} the Vatgjpoiéinﬁsid"éaié Lang L3. 1924. Chzxpféi" HE of L§..!§3"<"a'.}.é'5: §.-'»':V'Vi.E§"}L4'€YGZi'f§ﬁ§'}E§§}{ Of {}w:}.er5hip Qf i:e1°1az1t',s» A11 §a.::d'?.%s. Eigéiii "by-'«.§.::'3%».'i';1,_ {hé ggésesessign of *;,e1":2mi,s grim' ':0 the duilﬁﬁ _ £§fV {:':;:m§1"£<3'r1<::::i}er1:. Qf the Amezzdment: Aim i.e::.§ GE,S3a1§'f «fi~. 5-.;é,ao{§ V i.3:'é:::{:_:é':7€::j3f:c1.£1£0 anci vesisﬁ in Gris. Séats CzOi7€1'Y1K3{1€'E}E'.:f' ?§§?: €§f€:C%.;<}ﬁ' .${?;3:::%1 'ves'uing wzu-:3 213;} r.ig.§.b "Ls, Eiiie and §§'£'€,EE°€S'§. 's%s:.:i~;~:;§1";g; i':é:.5i{.hé gm-=*m:'r:<s 0%' Such iazzais €E€i'é?1f§€?€§ and we-s'£,é:c§ 2i§--:>s5&{)1V':2i,:%'1:$%."L2 ii; iii: "mS?;.a%.:=, £§«s}'=J:=.r:1::'1<:::é'. fE"€"f€:f f}:'c:zm aii V'£31191::i;v'§:3:°22;v:1{€a:%§>;;~. "-3'§';éé 53:11}? righé. E9 which éthsy: §2md§0:°d was €::n:i.":}3é:!ijf 3:}; E0 F€fC€;"f§1}€f {he 21m.<}:.m':. fmifzz $5: $1)2:E'.€:r ;

"a if ié{;r1:§%f.'§"e.:_iziT.<-E:-:i£A Lihzriiir Se{:§ii:E'<i>:§. 48 0%' «me ACE. '§'?j§%;'%u_:'z§;:E waias uilaiéz" gzm. <>b';§.g§z':;£'.§a:1 ac} §§;s.~Isu.€ i:2d§2»"§r:.h3a§ z:1e:}é.£<:{%:~3 {E -« E&1I}{ﬁ€}§"{§ wasa; H0: ggivezl E,§'§.¢'3 régglm, ':.<:a {':§£%§m; 'i:h<:~: Eami. EE*.'}j:'°§:,.3'§7'5§:'V'a:"-'i'._3;', 81¢: %_,:'::;'1:3.m" Wzszs gggiven 21 :"ig}1E is ':33 :°&gisE€:°:::€i as=:'m{:éi'§7:éi'n.?:: '7iv:1 ;'e$';:;e<t=1. sf Si1£'l"§ §.a.:1{i. S<3CE'i<311 4% c<>r1i'{:r;j;:~:i; a ;'§.,gE1't.' '{::§;§';€:si';2:;I'1'E:'S 3.5:) gei. ﬂ":€:§1'§S5€i'J€S reg;'ist.a>;r»:*c§ :>c{.::.1p2m'Er.:;; :1§"'§Ta2::d "';%i§f3j<:i*.'(?i"E.'§'v.E.h{ri§1 321t§S'£j.:§r1g {hrs <:<":s:'1c;§'§€.§(;z:sa: :12€.né_4i'<§1'*:<::§1 i:E';s:~1z:e,E§"-;T.V %:§::§.,&f:n'i._§vxsha:. wanicd <§c{:--2.:p2mc:y :°i§.I_§ht:s-:3 {E.l'1dt'.}" Séy-*ii(:':1. 1.123 '<:»§?.¢;h€ A%::*;, has; 32} I."nak6: an app}ic:e1?;'.§:>n K) éhcs. _'.Iﬁ'§b:1:_:1e1;}; . §'}":v._%i}35C.'1€3.'Yf ta adj éidiéfaiiﬁ ¥';hi:: cminze of such §}€Z'f'§-§{}}.'}S§ a.V--:?:1a4chiz<3§:£§,? '€2s%';"z,s3"é:iE.;::é3'i creaied 1;u1ci€z* {he gm in the _ff(§_:*:1": f::'f'_.L2%.;7L'ci F§s§'{br1:%&;_T1'ib'L:1'iaEs. The pewer to CC}E'1f(?:E' 0Cs:upa§;,<_%3}<..1é:ghi,S 'o«z:§"s=.v:;1cii"1."i,e.I1:;£1t'.-S was vesséed with {he T ziibunaij:*:m"1s_t¥LiL,U§1-.v;=:c§ V:z13{:i*:?:;:"' "~§3}_3Ci£c'.m 48 of {he Act. if a tenant. fﬁecii an a;p;;§H?<t2;i,i{>:;_ {:--Eé.§:1i'i-:3;_g"«;i(:cup2mcy §"§§_{h§;S, i.E:':€n Sectirsm é':~.8«A gym-ji€§ed.V vf01'~z»iz: 'E'11.5g_u.i.r}? by $;he3. '"E'»:"ibu::aL which is .235 1% céear from 'she §A3-:'m=-'.i_s3.i<>1:.1.s3 Qf ';":3gT:~%.iV.§_e'f;>r1 48%.. 2153 s=3<:={m 2:5 {he 'E':*§§:»:2r1aE §"€{:€i'J€:3& am a;>'pEi=;:<a':.£s:>n~ _i'§f'::3§1'1 a ieizzmt. r£::{§::e:-si,§:'1g €02" :°eg§i.ssi.;ratie11 0? " ﬁzfctazgbeaziatgf :§%gh.i.;%; ii': EEES fav<)z:_::* xx»-*§'thi:1 E1338 i;.im€:3 ;>:"e&:a?r§E3€d, Eh:-5: $9 Eu / ,/ n C;-5.} M...» 5 "ihe }'f>€'.IE"5:3G§"§8 n2=;*.32é:§.s:};';€€§ in 'i:h<=: appEE:*z:':i<m. am? aééaqv'£.§:'-.§f.;.é¢~s:jh £31:hs;=,rs as §'§'§éi}?' gig};/>::=.z::* ii. is 336: im:en:=,s3:::%«:§. in the: ®b§'€:ci.i{>.:1 is ﬂied d§Sp::'i,ir1g_jj '{'.E"if'. x*21iEidi*:§'»A§:{f_§hc% ':;i;';'_:s5';3§;§':..':,§I;,~§:1;'i'j':-;§ v{:1f€a:zi"!:' <32' s;e3..i.§.n§g; up zivai <>§.a£n1, an @,;1<:guEi':§éi< xv:._§'zs; .{%<}§éi'.§€r2i§E:§i:e ".E';'ibu:12:1 sgkfzztﬁi 3:m§<:E an :§:'1<;L:§zj;; ;'%_§é'.€:" ézzggigéry' was s21£,£.:':;.i}::-.{§ tfzezt: Léze a.§3§i:EEcz?e.'m: igtzaazilxﬁi; Eami in qzzesiien was 3 i.e'na§2t,:%dV§Aa.§ii, 11;§;;:;s.!§i.:i~-._g:t%i':1f;'._ba<:{::2Af3e;r1::y rights in ﬁwoasr of :5au.s::1h A;1§}p1ic;z,'m_,:.. 0b§6ct.io'n, the ﬁfibazilai may aft. 05:33 §é;..ss3_<§.i"de:'s.._ §§:':*:::--¥;§Vng 1.3%: ap§)§i.C.':1EiOI1. §:'1it,2a11y§ :3: V:.i:§:Iié:3V;»'_1i121i%:.'._ﬁéJ21s3_ 'g3'feSV::ri'bed far Eﬂixlg S¥.iCh a_pp1i<:a£i;}'ns. _ x'E-§'s'_:w@§,:*e1g *.4VEi'1c~>.:j:1 _'i;i_m<: 1'0 tims it {ELEUHEE {G be €X*L€§'}€§f:{§¢ '1'E'1:: .1'£¥.S{, aﬁf. S%;:.g_:;i':< éxi'.8§1Si0:z came :0 an and an 30.6.19 '_?_9. Ti:«::"%;:%,i3gé;--::",A'":_§.';€§:*~*"T:'§b1.1:'1a1.s were f§{'3?EU;iC§{3C§ 1x,r_i1,h the . §;sa:;ws:r<.3'-§,<> e':*::ie:'i:;?::inV--3.;r1_§7 gsaiath a§3=;:21i§:21E'.i<3nss aéiaimingg; @€s:;u;3az1{:y V_'ri.g__{h.'&$._ _'i5«f%;<;::1v."*zr,:; a§}§)H(i£1'{.i£}:1 haé beam fikiéi by ihe E.<%r1ar1'E. s3€ieE{i';2_g« fiéi'V.1(}§t€jf'2.§§;%é1.§':{i:X,r' :'ig;.'§:i.; it wzzsa apezia ii} the EaI."s.c:ii<';r::?: is .'*9\r%':<>::?i----*r:<}%_:.§:it-Wag sezai: ta ce:m%::<3&3% {E39 itziaim zgné ahew £,E1a%: E'.h€ &i;:."§')§}E§{fS;3..'ET1€.'v7S'$E3;E:§ :':{::E. 21 €,€E'.i&H'i'i. {If '£'I%:<;*. Eamai in {;m3s§,:i<:}:; zzzzaiéitr hirzz E ----.

W32, 3:353 {E153 $2-Hid in ::§:.2<"3S:'££.:;<);'1 'ax-°'z:§; E'?..€f"¥z'*«2'.Ef" 2: E.€;'.§'.'i£?M1§.f'i{§ isms} azzI.<i~.§\§i?é%fs'~V§I1 his éaeii <>:%»:%u;f:21E'.i«:>r1. Gm smch. z?<3I11,en1.i<m §3ein§-3; '€:;};,§{éEI'i.,""é1: :e:E.:,ﬁ:}f_ W215 cast. aspen {ha 'E'§'.i§3%_3.m22.§ $1.') 3:0 mtg §3rTi..;é3_z:;2.2s::~:g--'z§.1'7(')':?i:" '*a;f_§:&:{.E.'zr:£1é..hs=: Eaméi in qu€:$i;i<}:: "é€Z'L§~3 21 'i.é;%:."1a.m,€;2£i Eamd7;1:':€§"§',E<:z*e1fsf;%,§'E.::%r," '§'€:{ :*f{::{T(}§"?.:§_' a fEr":c1m;,; wheéher ihfi', :;:ppI£{:*a>:::":%',T wzgzs} 21 'é'<»:*2'z<(;-Lat", _V1:an:i in , L <_;:,2<;*.$'Eii{>n and depenciing L3;pw3n. 11E1€§_Efi-STf§'.<u«fZi:§?'z1 bi'/vvV§ii3i'€i' 3%: 30 gram ihfi' {arid GI' rejszei: E:%}{}~._;.%,£Z}E;3§é2%?€?.E;V'iT()%;i:"~-i:f3'§ﬁ{E{)fd€d 21 fiindingg {hat the 12m.:;i in {§E.}.€S€.;E€)I1 §iz--:1::4. r§aE. }_af:V%.£i, {hen such 3; ianﬁ wauid 319$ 5¢£}J:V<>xf%4:V1'}ﬁ;i';%é":'it.*;':The appiictané; had 1%} right: ':10 Tht' '?I"ibL1§3aE had no jxirisdictialgxz 1.§)'_A§i??c-Q11?.g;;§3f (;r'::€'t"t*,;1.:§:__):2;:I_1<::»,«'Vgigms. As 2: {lime iimii, was §3re3C:°ibed',"e}»--"egg if a;._.%:§§iV2§;iii..§;r2:.s';"in <:u§.{iv3.'§'i<}:: sf €,h.s:. Eandg and ::i/1:3 'ian§:i_ has '%,.-;{',""i~T-"1V..(V§*.€;§v 13éii.h 'vi.hé§' .ﬁCr{}'L'Ei3"f1iT1€I"Ei., 'ihé te:2.ar:£'. ztotgici 30%, «have V-s::€a§f<)§:%?<:d his £f§;g§3J;__§1f7;.e1* the »s:X'p§1°y e::a§' ':,h.6 said '£.i:3"m. Tigers '~.xxJ€r's:21Es~:s_ca.$esA'w§;;€:'e. she izmé in q'L:<-:si,i:m 'W355 a €:<::121:1i.<:~{§ Ezmzi axfxri '€3..1r§&é A'E;:'§r§1';..§r§2( ,{?:z::t*§E.ir1::€:{i in 0::c%.s.§3a€E{>:'i <3? 'éhe E.:3:3.2mé.€<t§ ézmd and; wags {§EfE§.i ¥='£?.,i;§IE§§ $26 E~3£:{ﬂEE3'.., <70:z;<5e{;::£;%m',i'y; the $2m1e vesisd _ é%:_§EE'§ ﬁaés: ..{%<';«'§m;%:"'§31":2&'r":%.§ bui. f:,E2:;*-. gzzaizi %iTs3:':&m <*:<3:.z.':.:§ .z3{>1,. jiize gg:'2::':§.&{i ~ 33 ~ 0<:€2.::p2m<7y :'ig§hi.5s b€3{'.€?;US%<'f': he hziezi £103., EE.Em:i an as;;J;L:s§§:«>.ai.~§.e::>'s': witizén E'h{~: p;:°e$<::':£'£:-es:£ iime.

23. Ch.apE.{~:*.:<" N 5192115 w:?1,E?. {v3'::eiE:,:'.%§_..;{A 025;' %8<:%{:'£.1?cm. $3 anci 64 p;;'{:v.ides:; ifoz' :~3u(ih '§'i:T1'a'-:»--

in ex€:e:~:ss:--: 0%' iiéfﬁiiﬁg iaici dm:v':1 be' sLu°r{:r:{ie'zfe:% {<2 EE:<=: Siaie Q<3s"€:*11{:3¢>£;':;.a1f1<:§;: §s.é§:i1a~uf;_1H¥;::A,";:§ré>€:e{§:,:r€ iss p'1"€sc::*ib€{§ fur £%_€.ij"i~3d1:€£?£'§§'§i.?';V:1i:!?i;§_{, Qgzilaing Eand 21116 s-Susi: excegs i21:1d'.'k'§%S%, jw"iEjZ:':1 iihé' 15'me fmrn an s:r1c:La:1'1b:°21:1.z::c §;,.. :§='3 :}':*rer:1cier 0? iands in ::e:s*E:a--n?m <:2:S€é'5>--.2;é%§E 8%}?-:::'i1 IS-':;1z'"r€'11=ﬂ.é€rez.i' Lzzrzd aiséa vest. with the C%0v&:1':1m€:_11 * SVii:'£:iig2;rE§%g _t'E"}"3.': 1iE;'.33.{_'E§3 which are acquired C(}E"£E13"Ei1'}»"

to the p:"0vis1?0;':s <:i§'s1E:éaiA%1e:§"'":Ln C}1&1p'E.{'f§" 'J', giamely Z7§~fx. 379-8 gmaf ézise v<':s;i= {he '£}:}v€:"r1me:::.. S<3.«:é€.E<>m 17"? :3? the Acti; .€§<:.2.§§'vxxfiih'~£i§:%§§{>saE <5:§'"é5u:'p§:::i~; Ezszzzdi E3, Eérevides Eb? éirané, 0? 'sé's'é_%c'h T;sV:;::"g.§§«:;S ~Eé2§:{?,éZ::. §érmL::' of {:§i.$;:»<}s3s1~;{~3s;se€§ i:€:%;;}a_:":§,s '°»'£'E1{§ em:

:":{}§?: :='€<f=fifs:::::°<:ti é;_::~t':;{3::1T:.par1i:;=s$ Eiiﬁgﬁiéiifﬁéi 'é'.e:1an?..s»; E3;-"ﬁring :23 iazxi '§.£:1E7E:'§§{i'E5$,é3;§{'ETi{i?~E§E.'iIi"€3§ EE3.b'f}§.3f§'frS'_ E;:2:}<£.§€:&:..€; §:=s::':°sz3ns; ami méeazseéfi :%V//

-=34« §)<3n{§€%d E21bO::1"€1'.<5. '§'§":<:: gziié ;3:'{)v%5e;i<}:T: sss§3eC2Z§E<tai.iy_.'1:§.:i:EE--._ 'z':<)i4 §}m':.-*1'e:§€ far g.r2i:'}E. of .'£;'1:'1€i§s ii) %';'.€§éar3.1.s5 win} W-'{?§"€ in _€;xf.:.z::%.;z}'i«é:"é'r'§{1--;<1"£3-'if I;':E'§.e Ezmd pricgr £0 {}i.Q3..E9'F4_» v£%$€§3,<;§,...W_iE:§: E-,hv€9 J{}i}:<4;é:'i';€"%;if:é3I1.'%, 'V 'isecaugesr iizésy sﬁici mm Ilééliié? 21:1 e2g.:sp§§r;aE.i;i§':;A. '£'::)§' ».g:*g1:§'%'. :§i7 "5I;3;.:%:.£7.:

ins-sofar 21$ gr2=.:1E. 0%' {E36 v<~:s1c*:%i ':'£.:.3.:";d {£2 :;.:%;*i:.2:*§g€ .p--e.:::s;m=s is. L £:{::i:€€::°1'1ed, it is ihé', §)I.'{)ViS§.{)1"l.S a>i'{§'j::§§*':f€': i;.13.;_1d Eétﬁtés, 198% whieh are to be E1E)§3f,i€C£o gm E326 year 1993?, 1.1%: E€g:'s§z11:,:re ibii, Phat gvfso qtozztixatzeé ta cu§'i:i1fa1§;.e iha Egijéié Ggverilineni; and E70? varimgis regasgiggé %*:1 ef',*:~":i:;VL_'£'r1:I.§"ihé:§21§;3Iica.i.iG:§s, if Eh€_3I had is stancf _if3fQ§i};<1:.T§i.§~?__'i'.h€}? nmight £191: get the said Eanci grairied, EA€,'§;;"§:1 they had missed ihe bus 2-ind as they were ;i'::fﬁ'2:.11i§;"V*.::u'i:§§?éﬁ,i11g the iand prioz" E10 V'€3S?'.EE1g agzﬁ "'a:E;Qz.;t,§.:f§{.:'}:.,:%e:§E is gr::§%:§xié:.i,a:%...--.é3':e Ezmd @5313": me {ia1..e of v::%s'a,i::1g KEEE §>:.'§>'%2iSE.:;ﬁW21s %':Emi.:g§"; 3; {>5 :'E"0§* gfiiili. GE' $t_1,.cE2 }a;:1<:§. ii; i3 i0 r:z€r3.t':3'_;;:c}§' «;%'_'gs:,;:i:§:;;'i§<}::, Secizian 7?'~A E32255 iaeem. §.nimdL:s.::,<-zd E33;

€.,}i:.:r_= K§:':'EE;13.§§§.k&":":€3§§§E3§a%i,i..E§"€3 by §';<:t. N523 <3? E§§8;. E1. is; in {E16 ' :f' "-:EV£'£';1L.i:"€ff G? "g>':<@f<%r€:'2E§zz§ §'i§"€i£i{.EE1¥.'iI.1E, §:;»§" §§r';m'£', cf €':::>:z2a;#::"§.s:{i 3:a:3.és§ w§'1i{;r?: a:'<;>. :f:i%é5'i:e:%r:i w§'{,Efz éhe C:Qvr;%.2'n.1:':€;':é.§ in £'g:*J{)L.z1" :2? '§,§Ti{E §§;'§'1'Tt:&?i?§"§, $:_.:?:_§:é{:é in his; §;;1*a:i§;§E,zi1'1;§ é:E":c:% €:§n<:§i,E.§s:3:1s,; §:~;E,§;mi.:1€.€{i €,§':{%';'<;:i;';~... 5 _.__ ' iii. Eé. E53 dean' {rem tile E;:1::g§:.:a=2;g§ Ligééii.'\Lx;?%'§:;§;{§~sié§%5.é:ri7;3:i;1g Secmm. '??'--;'& éhaft E536 E€giS§£E{,1,'s,E°£f d€$&:;rib53'=d.fi'é, '§,§:*i:?L:2f."¥i%f.___§z>:::»:§ 3: atézﬁaziin »::z:ses:f and mm: in .é.1i..__ ::2:s=s<:?':'=-;,_ Tiéa §::T€é;{j%:v:r;;;§ <23" €;§':e;":_ S€c:':',§{m :§'3.aE<;{-32% it <?:'iez1§" E.1'2a":. ii, '§.E:'>_>bI\1f.§;E. 22 <::iS€' of gram. ('sf {}C{?'§1p8£}C,}=' ri_g;hé.s 9:" ;*€gis§,r:%Eng_{ 'a~':h€;'.§~"§3 ;z§i':";~T,_ €2gfzE:zg3:»::1Es; of éamd. 53:} {he c<};<:i:"21:'*§*, it 225% 2; Sage Qf_gr:«1ni._<}.{ 12':'é.*';!.i.V'~~.."'j{'§--':'!:3', ésaié E}'l'{}'s-'§SiG§1 a}3'Z3§'§:::--"s ':0 §.2:':".1&%%3§V anf§1»i'aéE: :i:'€3v'ési'.s:=€3.._E:':""'.v}";-<5' Séaw G@ve:'nr:1c:rzi? azmeier Se.=V.v=.'.':"a.§é::s.*.;'--'a_ #113-ﬁn i3%€E1€~r we§zdv:~:a," i: is; :1 Earzd u~*h:'ch is; 2:

t.enzmi.sci"'--.I21r:d ;>2r%1fe.'iiA.,is;:-$331615 WEE}: {he Gm--*e2'm.1':1é:n?. ujzder Si§{§'Ei§{}ﬁ 44, §:E'E~.4_E"'§3:3}3€€,1i' {§f_'~;é/'E§;_.§~i;é§2 i:h.e E.€naﬁ€;. £7s;'h(} was éintiiiied £0

--',gf:"a23%:»'é:%§ Gigi,E.E§)€i.E'1Ei:sf"Z"§.§{h:l,fv3 zm{ie.:' Se:cE.i.<:>:2 425, Eéas 239:'. Izigziist 2123 V".;i§3§}VEi{?E1V{3£EI}'E?«,;"i§.§}E:T€ __ ihé: 'éiifiﬁ §}1'<:s3<:z"§b€:=:.i emit tE1<:rei'<)r<>. he has Ec:ss«;é his :"§i§;z;§.'*:T1'z" fb:*."'.:'=:%gt§§SE.€3:'%:':gg his}: 328 ::.:<:.<:z,:pa::?;. {>5 :;"i:}£3 sszssici éanci. 'é}J3i:e:1 "f,~."L'E{§"3'}.' 21' i.e112m'£.§ if he is; {t«:}::*:'.£.1":1,:_s5c§ in am". 3.1.3}. _§."§£"3SS5€§§S§{}§} ";2.:§1:i :,::.;_Ei4§:f»é§1*:.i{}z': <3? szzzth Ea-'s..§1(§( (33: ¥;h£: gtizﬁzjt <35 {§(}§'£}E'Z1€3ﬂ{f€3§'iE*€iH'§ er}? 1:

the §{21:"':'1z1€.2:3~:a L-:-;1:'1c§ R::E"m*:':'1:<s A.:3":<é1'2:?E:":'1<:ém: 1-'%<?i,}, if":-,§;'r ':»_§.%;;:.%i..:'.§_"2.r.»§3'*"i--2V,;5:,-' E.U1(§{;'.I' 'aha' 2:-sziitﬁ 9:1):-*isi0:1s;~s n':a:j§z' g;>;rz:1'1'i'. {he Eazznci re sL{i:)_'§:3C%; is {he étozzdﬁians 8i.ipL118.i,t3d Eh;-*:&:i»:1'%3€i_Ei§' 1:536 By vi:"£,L:e (3? €.}":.:% g}0w'¢:"S by"$'$£:*¥'%(3;'}V ._ the A¢::i., the GG\FEE"§"lI§"§€§1E. of Ka1F§':l¢11;§?ii€;}; hzﬁﬁ Z§:1&1€3.§ V%1':*?L€:V':§iéﬁ'f'1€i;E.&"i§{Ei " igtzld Résfomtzsg Riﬂes. i_9'774g.. {i'e:f SVA}."5.~'~'}.1;'v:'LA-,'V"'§'7:f§i;'f§%Z}E1.ﬁ§§'1"vE7€if€3E'E°€C§; to ad ihe 'Rah-33'). R1139 E'? of :~3zs:i<.i 'E'i:1'I'(+_:§*g_.§:<-; pmessduré in be foiiowed by f.I':'i§3:as':*:éa;'E; ;u)§:0v'ides fﬁl" the procedzxre as 2%: uz":d€-'sr Sectizm 134 ef the 1964» 'E'I*;{:>:{::~§'<>r§%. the p1'0cedL1r€: '£0 '§'3r::V ..I:E":é Land Ref"<>r'r;:1s 'i'1'§bL1na§ is prescribed'S6{:'i;;£<>i3'<?V?'vA ;':'.i'5:":'.=;(} §;3.'£}'£-'iC£€3;'>' {Gr haiding an arlquiry befare sgugth gféigyiv; ézzsgﬁiry E0 336 hiiid Lifldﬁi' S<';>:<éTicm ?'?~A r:9€':_'::i':1 §'f§fii{"L;i..§_'i§"':s,.f ufi:§::.r..E=?:L1E€ E? :3? S36 Ruieéa. The 'i'm:€:1'£:%@n of '.E'.'.§:';'-ff'§.€f§i§3§E?'z:§,1;£§'€:« fi4§'V'féify {fear when ihe €s<>ve3"'nm<~::1E. inimémteeti :1r;:é:.i.§.E<?a{.i:);1 da.é.::éd 3fi,E& EQQS w?:%s;:h ::a1'z1.%3 Him %:.»§}7&:<:E. fi<r:§::..--§2.E £3998. ".i"'h=::~ 2mi.§':<:s:*i?;_y £0 g::°a::'¥1 Kama u.:1<:Ez5*.r s3?-

Se<:i..imT': '2'"?~:% is»; 33%: 11%;} :1 3y {T<3mn'1i::a::<s§<::i:.:;:1' SE' tifie (}'ih§':,1fV:*;:?%§.!:§'€f'E"" ::iL11.hi)2"is;ed by Ehrf S'E,213.',€ Gm="c2"1f::13€,;'":1. in 'ibis §:3<.;':E"12:x_f§'f..."" awards, She §§(}°W€fZ" $.10 gram" §z:r1::i z:.:1d:§jr Semiizszz c<§r:E'l<:rrs3:c% 02'"; 1:326 '1"§b2.:na§¢ firzeté e:§3p§.i{§=;::t:i<>§r3.4§;§"1ﬁ<i.e:§'.: {.9 be fiiétd in E'<m";1 Ne:;~f?, whiia £13': 2';'f§)'§.)EEé'7V&aa35_,jI%§'}T'E 2: M' A is {<3 be iﬁesci in F{}E'IZE N{)x?Wﬁe x

16. §::'{:e'res{,ing1.y.V " gyf §{A{:§.Ve 3?', for {'f03EdL';{i":.iI'1g €r1qL1ir§;,_§..he §3vI{_'.~(}-{3€:3.C§:E;i1%:.V§}'¥?§:S%§'§:g§:§v'v'L£V£i'2d€I° Secttion 34 GE" the Ka.r:1a1i._a3{21 :§E:;'21_nd§V R€§;éI1Lz.§§ "$964; 155 110:". made 3§3E>§ic:ab£&:'I'<3z -A'i'§1i15'1'§L1i'24":;*:«:'7§ 'tzrziiﬁ,'-i"~. Se::'£.'i'£2§: ?7~A 9? the A<::?;.., in an enquiry ﬁzzcﬁer .S5éC:é:i-Q i1 ta-'a.{i with Section 26»--C; the ques'i..i;0:1 €35 '1;:Ef;€i"2:§L:E§':<)i'ii;§¢=§§€§iL}:1g iziio Em": {;ues1;310:1 whethéi" {E16 land .§.1j';.'<:;u.:;n:s;'§iet}:":'»§§:¥::. 'ézaéixznéed iand 0:' xmi, wauid HG: ;1;*is<;x.

g x{f§";:§s;7i"§%"q'ué;%;"{:%Q%2,,'Ehﬁ "§'1"1ibum3.§ {t0z1aiii,1:;':a3d amﬁéir Ehé'. AC: 21103163' is; ':':<§1z§5:§:T€:i.?::::V::ﬁ"~;Q" §;§<:._§§:i.(> L£E";{Z§{;',§' Sésciéién 48 GE' '€.hs:3 ACE. ['~2"<> S3¥;§,{,'h pevﬁéz E}? §:1r§5}:i;i<:i.i<};: has besm <:o:";§'€:;°r£:£§ UE"':C§€3Z' Se:<.:€:a>n ??wE'a an fé,.E1e B6531;éigi€{;§*:m:§:~3&ai<>::<;%:' or $16 Ass;i:;1.em%;'. C{}EIEE?1"§§.8S§{}}'}€:?Z'. ?§':€ {f{1€§§_iii":«-"" s:?:}::é;:s:-:'z1'1§3i2>.'i,:;?::i 1: rider' S::e:":§.iz:m ?""?--A is :30 ba {i{)Ef1f§.1"2€3V€§'««{ii 32:; £0 ihe fol1(>'w'ing;§:

{.3} V'v*"}'":ef,S'"n:5r zfze }')€'}"'S€E1"1_"" »:.:_;Efr,(3 Emgé' In3aLviEa_f_af2_V capp£icaz'.i0z': z..:r"2.e:2.Ier S€3{"E,i.(iE{'; :51'; %:z:cz:~: "':"r2" §:£{j{{}i}';:' g}:3ssess§.{m and' »::z:;i:':?2,.~_a:.'€c>r2 :1?' mtg; §5,:.r:t§. AF§e;f;c}:*€$? Eﬁss jams. day Q; J?/Iarcfz 29 {2} Beta eﬁiéiled fib bé réa "*iS"éered a$"GCéz,: anfs 0"

;:_»a,_ _ sudz Sand z.ir1dé1"_T_'Sec:1f5r;:' 45*._o?;: 4?}, has fouled £0 applyﬂitregi:;£1r€a£:1<i%': Qf'.¢¢cca:p'a:2&_:;" rights in respect; Qf" sé_éc?1f;1jZa%§ci.€.;»:nc?e:*'$z.ib:Se(*tiar2~(E} Qf Section 48%. z.:?if,f"ai;i"z'Eié?p.er.iOc:£--$;15*e{§§fié<:i £=h.ereir1. In other words, " w:ZI."i£;ﬂf4;l'}~}§fJ':§'i<3%iEI?:()I'2.'?;i.ﬁi§'b€€FE~f?i§€C{, which ciaim is " {he Tnibuz":.a£ and if if is ?'--:(gga:.i:;£}'r§, V£J:1V;:.1&'5'§'2ﬁg?»-§.{€;3r;1 a persarz is moi erzzfiiegf tefiie _ an :O.f..?_EA2EVZ'.Cr:'i§1€.f{?}!'V'€ z.e}édez" Section 7?wA;

R/?1eE:f1er .s;:,:::?§1 Cé parser': sis c(:»:1:4£r"z.a:e5§ {go be in, V' ' ,_ '~...=%§§if§4%_ié{E:'.:;{}{}$S§i'SS§{}?'E ::m{.€ :'::.zEf,f:2az'.:'<:=r': 55;" s»;2.»:r:?§'2 §€;m.{"E an . Sfczie eigf ce:>r:*::r::ze;r2:'7er"ne:'z:', Sf Elms K«::m:::.f.aka. LQHCE. E2T£;ffk}z"ms /E ?'E1€ﬂ{§?T2€?"EE. Agra .2. E??'?, 37'. Pr{:\;i.s§<> EEEEERES ii, <::§€:a_r lhzii. {Em Eaﬁd $a:Q %.<)g€e'Eh<;*.;' w::1§::: 'Lhéé Eezmé 2zI;"€:a§§§r Eéeié E33; §;u<':h sxceezéﬂ 2; §*ieci,au*es <3"? 'E? {ﬂags of Eanif f:} :fh En z:}t.}:£3:;" Wcmsiss, if §'hf3: zzppiicgitzi. Egci-aiﬁ 3%-;2¢4§:2A.é£ 2;.=} . ::§X's::é's:é E-iieafmreg {if 'ET c§a$:'5 <:\{ ?tz:n<:E 0:";;iUs__§%q:2;Vi'V;%§{}:'1E. not {zmii.1::{i £10 gfzlili. of Eamci L31/1c1E<:r'v':S*\<:;%.j:t.é€:_;1 ?V'§"::;"-ST {~:v€:n if has was 21 iiegzzmi. of ihef £17;q§:.:'}:§3§i.§;V:%Aggriar E974 and 4:29-nEi§1u.=3d_ {£3 bg ii"; pQ$s§%$:sVi.0L..§é_._V Eiiieﬂ.'§';§;:§1§'_'.--¢;:1d <ra:Ei.ivai,i:1g the iarad {iii 'sﬁié ' §;f;~%jf;sr1§ii~a§t.i%;.rié ?--A 0? 1,171.8 fatti. Though suck; V. Gove:':11:1€m. 218 SE} 81,03. §Q"%ViL 0%" iarad.

3.85 ifewe E~;.§:@;i§ '~t§éa3-..__é%é?f.::m.---'st primtipée zmgﬁ E319 Eeg§iSE21*{.':2*{5: mam. Ezymigad'; x:?i:2:4,.'V~.§*t:I:'v=3rg_;§a~§$ is; Whiie 2:m':e;":cEmg 'ms: Ari: 2:115? i:<7s.U'::}<;§.;:i:i:3,g.A ':3€.*,{:E'.§€)E1 ?'?--«§:; iEr.::=. Eeg.issE21é.ure Wais v€:r§,r afiarrgar in iis 'r::3%§::ii;E;21i;'~v?3§£ ..*$'fE":§§ Said :»m1e:::1{§rne:2€:.;. Ehsy 2xaa;?:°4::% m3? §'n.t.é::1:§:'.::g Ea; :'E?s§:%é:%§:§<,>:2 -€§5':;::i' %;E:<5: .!--':c€:. 'E"E'1a:3s::: E.'2'v'{§ §};<"{)*s.-*:¥s;i:w::§":,=:-a w€§r:~ §.:";%'.en::£e£E 3.9 2'1;/.%_m=' ;::_m;> ::"1_:}':'<;%'3.§?5%':2:12 fez' 1":3=gi:si:'ai.§<}:": <;f'<3<:<:L1pa1§3<t§g-' :"i;,_§I:1.'iss unciez: w'i€}=~ :::.>v€:§.' iiwa i::":£i@p<;>.;:{:i€:::'.'::'_: fiaéids, Si'miE2iu'Ey., E? 21 ;:}c%:'sa'm i'1a;se,v;az'ﬁ%:£E_§%e:E éééaé %;%<:?1'1<:%§.'§.?., (3? S<:%{:é.1E0:1. »i§5--A 1121:? 205%: tfééésr b2';*:.¥i1,Ec, W215»; mist. ;":'1€::»;:,m'. is give him (7:15? ;":'2<):f:§mQg}§>()Eim'::i"i'§}.. izizliiagsa 'E'§";€ p<}w€%:° E0 52:21:-2:. (}(EC??;E§§7:é:i._§'"i(?k'/x-il--£4 46 was; %:€%:'~sE<?{i ve:n':§": 2: qL:21s5i~§udi.<';:-£533 ;'*::.é"%.AE:~;_.§§V:'3:5; Sn éhsi {ﬁzzy {he EiI'£1€E'1£h3"ie2',E'}§., §§1fi.§"<>:'fL;§:4%;3v:?;%i":g,;§vﬁgarné min {(3236, {he '§'§'ib:TzmfaJS x\,r<3:'é.3:.¢_._£.§A% _;1:::"§%:§.A _f:.1.:1(?E.i{:ﬁﬁI1gg, Thtjs §:'1i:€:z3.E.ion 0f£i"1.e3 §€:§3§i,§;§a1i.iI:'€§_ji~§$§é':»§._E'1§§i A j:zrisc§i<:'%.,z'<;.r: E0 decide "§'h§': éiiaiingé Liiadéér S:<:~3<:.'i.§{>ié. "?'?'°--Ak "2'~';v:3€év;32i.1'21t.€' machinery-' £53 n.€sw-' c01"2i.empi::;_ief_i §;3,11r:§é:" S'é§::5iT§<):1*ivA'}'?~£§&.V" The <3:1c§:.:.:;rjJ Ehai was {?0:1ier11p?£a"{E:ci. .'L,lVZV§%Zf'~';Z'.'I'7._ E35?{3{.'f'{}'IVk1'..._5§r5 iomfiy c;§§i'T<3-:'e:*:ﬁ, {rem Eh-:;= enquiry u 1';;=:i.e1° S€<::;§€3;r§;'V.?"'7*:g5;;'<.sis; £55; cileaz' fmm the fact. fihzii. <:{>3"2"€s'p<3n:ii:2g'~'ii{} "E?€€:'5{.i{}X:.;--, 7'}?--"2%. 'E%uE<;=: 2&2} was €n3.a,é{.ed zmd the ~,<"l;:i;1': .»¢§-;§f.1€E<:§2' $8{ff1§€)"£"xvffV?jf§§'}£1{T3 E9 be 2}:ci§:.,§{i§s::21é€?€§ ii': é,e3:rms5 <}f1.h€ W.§3:'i{>{;:téu:":::€;:3:{:s5%€:i§':i>s%d :;nde?:r se<..'.Ei{m. 2€.'3?{1::'ja A 2'e2=:dmg <2? Sé3:e;'taE<:»:'2 _ 5055212" in :=?r:§:':~g'§ €:E2<~3 <::<}:'2£.§3;\:i. in w.':2.iz;%E': ':§»z;*::?§:§:m ?Z?~,5-'§ inE'.mﬁL:{:::--:{§V '?'?«z"x{' :113Té1vE- n if:-.,";~"€§"':,-" <7i€2m° 'Haifa ;}:"<:2v'2'&.--:~i{m hasfe E1'.m:ii.€*.r:£ :?a§:s;3E§;;?.;:£'§0;';.=. ::.;a;:;3::_eS 2.0 zimiy e::§%r:.ai:: é?5f£5~3;f3f:'t:"n E, is E'1¥.'",'i.3£*--55§.'?§é:'L,E":';-' éa

-4}-

"§'§3§.:-5 p:':3"vi::ai<>:'1 fi::{§::; 2: jmiaztﬁ in {iE1z2p§,:=:2' E17. wherm,:§'3{i<::" §}€§§'"

S€i:'.§;,i(}E'E T? 21 §3§'{}%:is~3i<>:': is zizzader for <i§ss;,><2s.aa.E <2? 5;u;:*_;3h.::=.s ssuzfh 'izmd §}€ii§"§§___{ v<?si.::%(i wiih the <L§<)vez':'§_::1<%:3<;. Earzéis xx,-i':7:.iafh :~1§°€ v:::s2»;i.s_-=.c:i in {he Si.a:£,s::. ":'Jl¥;g'§:f¢§":>2"<;*.'_-- :'.3:1' :,:m§.<:~;: S<:n:':i.§<§:: '??u"a, Ehsé €§"'i{§LlE§°§-'" '§'.h&'i.E'.:'».ﬂ4"a.:*:?"'{?'Qf1*;Z€fE'ii%:'}i§2§i"§,éCi'@:2.%%§'5§vE{ S€Ci.'i.€3§} »%%8wEX is-3 £:.xcIiu§Ee=:i., '§'i";is;:7.:§;;.__.;é. p;V5c;:§'i'ééi<>;3. §3€::z°.E~;G:1 who is in {§C{':L£§}E1"{iG§} Sf 21 :t;§' jas,rhi'§€E3. éx-*21sQ§}2i Lenané zgmd C.C>1'Z§iII1Li€S H: be in 'fafggani. *A;A0He1p§>1y for grzmi, Sf Stiifh Ia.;1d.,Aj§" he VA appiicaiian for ggzifemi, 0%" <}{:C:.:pa§§1fi:}i:g'3'f' {:.ii§iS~~v£'%'Li§}LlEaf€d{ Such a. person L9 aim app§.§{:21t:io:1 for gram.

of izmﬁ g?2r£Ajv3gié<:§A <:::§%.ix«-'21§,&. {he Eeand 212151 he wag 119%. h(}i_:,E'};zE§._§ §.Ei{1:('iL~-iI'§V€?é:{',f3é%§f3 G? 2 §{€:{:1.21r'€,s:=s <>§"1a11(};,. "E'he3.'é:§(}:'€. in %; §:s;cSé:£¢:£ §;2:*t;a%é@;:i§::gS £36 {§%_4:€*,S!,§{}E': wfzezher 'S16 sfeguzi Eanezi. 313 21 "£'.{3::":é1:7_:§;@{i .Eé51::g:§" :s'i*~;1_§;;:'§,. <%;~1m1<>§., be g0:1€: En'E{§._ :15; is; éfifzféii' 1':°::§m E§':€:'f '3;-Tu': f:2::;1<f€: &..2;%€fIi'§A in S&<%§.1E0r_3. ??*}§x., 'E"E'1é: €i'2i.'E§'€:Z': €;=,n:u.1Z£'*x;

" 'V.gm;i'.:%:'ng:E;é.§.¥i%{§ 2;1.:1e:i€:" S€~<:1.i§}3': ?'?¥;"; is in :'€Es;_i>€<::é <3? a 3m".:e;'E§ whiath is in '$316: ;$%.23:.€.a=. €}{>vs3:§*2m3<~:m 22:33.92" S€::5.:,§<m IE4. an

-42"

G3 133. 39%} E: s;sh.c1~:.:§d be gm 1,i?'§€i.if§E§Z3';EE.€;?{i E'a<7%.; if §..§'E{'3' szaéci .§73.c:£ £55 :ii:'3pE,:'{,e:§, E..§'1€3i'1 S:-?ci§.i.(}:z ??--,.-X héiééé 11:) 3;;:=g3Ei{:2:'E',i{m._~=__Th@ ju:*§s::E§;c§;,ir:::2 ii1'1€§§€?Z' S€:.*€3'E.i(}I3 ?""~A is 2":"é':*{':121<?i.<2£i (3123; in "of

2.:'nd£:':;pme:{E ¥.:*.n.a1':i.ed Eamds. '~f<;*:s%.m§§ 91' GE Q3. .'£§}?"ﬁ: wi:,h. Ehe G-0x»"::=;1":1z7:1é:m,, wE1i.::h»'E7:I:§:£, 2.5:: Eiiﬁt €i§?:s§3_§:zE,€';._V is E: {?{)E}d§i§€}E"£ p;.°{;%C€ﬁ.é:tm. fez' appEicai.£<;n'«Q.{ i:?;€e::iE{>1'é[~T??'- .9» ' 1.9, If 21 1631312121: .I:1ak€:s=s an '31-}Li,:;p£i{:a-';'1;;i§_3.I'2T, i§1€T.'€§i2'§'~.:V§.§.<)E1 _f»;haf, ariaes for {',(}.EESIid€3i'£i'EiG§"i is; how h€:*p:*<;veS £,h.'a?_;_ if is 7;: "v'€SE.E2t:i Eandk Tifie vesstizag' of 'ihe 12z1:..rj'"i«S by 0;:&*.r'€g{E.io:1: law. No Oréei' G? vesting mﬁed bex;}:€:§s;%{i.,A 'Th?éfr;f_<3 .C::s_':nnoE: '$6 an mrder deciarilzg me *e;<::~;Ei:"1g. :35 the V§é'12 : :€, E'1»«<;3rre.:n"{;=r:::7 §3f{E€IiZEC?.'.§()§"i (3? G'§"€§€::' sf vesting is 2301 :;':::é: :r§éq:1£.r€';}1€:1ﬁ§GE' igwi and ii. rmiz pussihie anci _.§%'. :::2:::§*;<7;fg: be.'~i.:1sissi,édz._.;;§:0;}, §"'E€}'x?%-'€X--"€;E'°, ii, is far Ehs aggyiiztvayzfg wha ._{f{}:EE1£",$x;i.{'3 'E:'E':é?. {._"i<;a,_;:'":. ':0 €iSi,£1§')E.i$§'3§ iE':a'§, '§,E1€: lam: E2": CgE,i.€8?;§.GiE is 3:

E-"%::.'.§§i{(:':TiV"}--.:3§"3§§V;a_ 'f£'§§i.§§€;.$£~%'i.z1%3§§SE1i11§g s1:<':h éizzci, ii: '£3 ::1€(*,€::%S22z*§,? Ehzzi:

, 3:9 s3E';:}§.€E{'§ _E'{;'.E§,?' --:{}="fTi'::1iE1C§5%§§}3J.'§'.€{f {§;{3(:m:2'1<3:":%.:=; and Suifh :_':':1(§Espz:1.e(i L§§Vi'}*(',EE.E'§"1€;".'§') $1213; be $2": i§'§{f 1'12,-m.:':*-2;'? £12.? .<.=s<>zz§s:::% 0£EE<::i.g2§ :"e:%:f:«:}:'{"E '/ éh <3 .-';éa_2":{£ . _ 3:3 " " cm? 1 / .,_<:§j3,..

sham-"inggf Ve:§;m';;;§ of Eihié iami in fa.v<}:.:':' of ééée Si:a,£.e Cv{}V€f§'K}§'?'_Kf:T£Ei,. The viéavc-3:"m3T1<--:m. :'ecc3;"d z;'e{e1':°es:§ :1': in tha g':.,:dg§:1":e:1E', inf: 0:"d€;'..E° 9? w.;%Si,i:2.g. ii is 22. E.'€C{}f"d in §31fo0£' <3'? vesi,i.:"1g;,__--*§.%. IEi.E'}2~j;;'.'.'_:"'*v-'T;1f":_§.'7_ Ema: (:2-:S€ "£0 <:>;1:~3€ zmd d<~:.pe=3.r1<fE§; %_i§_}Oi} {ﬁe s~;i.2u:1s_i' "é,:aE»:jeV31 £37: '§éa::_:%_: C2188. Eﬁzzt, 13:21.16:-393 '{.he:?»i*: ssézzma <3§'f§::.§_23_E ?7i:'iC{:j'f{i'.>5fT\%s7§,f5j_V'i3lA}.'§:T%i"3~g '£.}.A::;r.' vasting of H326 Eand, ihzzf 21:,:%'.}102"i§,T%.¢;<; UE'E5:~{:ﬁ1' 'E'>€3Cf§Q£75 '_:7A;7*~£§£ '§,?§--**;'_3I..'E§.i',i get no jur§&;€ii(:'a:io.i1 'LG hsici an e::a:;f;é£:if_j~,.r ami. g,$:*;s,1f:'i; iii-..:1V&'"Li§}der V Secémzz '17'""/"~mA ':9 the ap;)1Vi.g:*:-}ni:.u .'3.""r.i.:= VQ£'£'i:r:Tt'i;_1E :°<»:cc%.I'dH z*éf€:*red :19 therein may be :1"; the farm"; {$3L21:::§3'Re:%.Iéﬁ%pz¢2uAI'=3.Qeip'LS§ Ff3CDE"'d af :°igh?;S. index of 123..1fit}.___ r*r11:*é"£:.éii0;<:¥ QfdfC»:fs§ étoyxéseiguem mutation €m1*i€s 01: zmgr €:»:'.'Fs;e'_::tV_1'€C0§td"w11i(:i": is maimaixézed by 21 pubiic 0ff'£C:<--:r 2:5 {>'p.§.}{>sAed is ;:;*.iv;i'é.s: "{ib1a':u:n1e§1E.;€s. H: is in this; <:0n'i.e:s§L U16 §€i'Z'9.'fEE€'§ judge3.s;_ i1'": §.héV'ai'c.>res2:id §L§dgI"§1€i3*i;S have' st§:ated thgii, Eh'e:.3;é;§r':d §.E }Vf{TiL§E@' he-we b<:<:--:r1 vessi,€<:'% in ihzzt Stme Gcevzemmerxi ass :23; E.§:_::s> 'e:;3;v;;Lj;e<;.§§1§€a:i_}:Zai,€, The; said evazrni. sshoazid have ah:<--:~a<:Ey iaE<:e1t":---..__pEa;::-:~, f.7Yh<% €"'%----'§{'3€3§3{E€ is; :'§3z:;ui:.'€<§ K; be pfezited by Size '".__:e:§:;i;§§c22;:":.é.v.":10 sZr:«:3w ﬂrizéi. *{,h.iSs 3155 2:13 ax-Fem. §,ha'E has»; .:1§:"«:;~.a:i§; iakézn T;i'§2A1:T::*,_ {:2 i,§':a;é. e.:}::é;,§:-:>=;i. i:E"::.<':> 0§3:9€:m=;1é..ir_&z2$ '€13 i.§'§€: s:=,f§e.{:*é %':4%zaé. "'9%3*vém1sE;.«-' ii. ssirzczizki Einii 2?: =p§21e:t@ in sa<>n.1e <3§"§i<":§;::§ vszésiing af §..h€;". izmd is» in f;;;z.\:*<3m" mi" {he Siam Filéidi-3. "H112: amr3:1dr:"1.f:1i1'¥1 {?8;IE'i€'. i.1:1i,<:» f~_€_ﬁf{3€f_'%1: yﬁzzm afier 13:6 §as:=s'a. dais: pz*€%s«s<:riZ3e::§ §'<;»%1§*i}.i::'1"§':g Sf:'.{',E,i{}E"i 2&5. 2*-'s:}2' E8 §€)3i"1§_;§ y€;azr:<5 21i='%.,T{,§:'«-..;§.f;.£;*, afi tenam: has <:0nEi.r:uz~E:d ﬁr; pe};<_a;<V5<::.§:v_L-;f_~L-:'{§'::2,:::'§ 39:11:: €3V§d€}:";€f€ by' way 05 a pa:'::~.}zi:r;: _:€.ﬁ<t<>3_gE hiés possesaaimzag cL11iiivati0n a11d 6Izj{::_yn1€n§€..V.3§:;._ Gexfsrnnzezm beczzuse afiez' €§1é€.;% V'»'--'s3"'J3*;'h '(ha G{}V€I'I1IT§1€3§"{ and 330: with féiizgs. Cr€§V6I'F11T1€I1L as Well :15; '£316 4:'.-1§:;*.:%v[)§i€§'Z--_E'.'1V'£i','%f?.'£§:\f§§ﬁ':'tZ§'€Ei3:1":'é2%5§_?fb_ €.._hViH:'V-2;. property during {£3,636 E8 yams 23.i5S3.'I'ﬁ'~§€'E!=5 théa {"2G:".Ef.€3§<;i ?i.%i<3 0bservat.i9ns made it: éhéi Sf:ii.£§'-._j'Liﬁ§3:'E}'§{;*VZ"}.E$ itzzmzai, be read 5518 new <:{>1'1dii'3Z<m.% ;§:'s?§~:g<t';r"1i§f:':€%Ci§"Lftfny" jzidgag in Se{:U'.{>1':. ?7~;'5'a by ibis pme::ess {3§' jA'i":~{§i€.§i-Q} :5: ﬁ§j§€%;;~;";fi',_%i~£3§1 as-2 s<3u§§hi. {<2 ':36: zﬁgeci by ilhfi mmlstéi §"{}1° E333 §}v1.'_Y;§';,§.€}:§é%§_';;'.."?E1i% jxziig-33 do ngsi: i€g_;;§§;EaLs:*., 'E'h€y' {3:":§:~_.; .%..:1'E,é:~rg:=ra?:E. " -'~_ *g1h:'2 §;:r€;1:§:s§_:i%ns34 'i"E1e:':::'§0:"€3., iizs a.1*g?;::mez1E :E":2:?;. zmziez' ihfﬂ ggfazisas ' E':-f_§.n_%:1{:%;:::'£3E.z:§,'i:3§':E '€,'ne j'::2:§g_g€.$ E";.a2sir:% r::é~w':"§%;.é€:": ibis S§€{éE:§<>;r1 "1131 ,45ﬁ vizﬁﬁ fmxgldﬁci. if; £53 2: itasrsé.-é of ;1'1i.€=;.ma{§i:'2;,§ ihe j§.2££;;%;:"s1t31'W:.-=i_I;"»_E3--:3€E€i:* i.§:%3s:3: a7§r<:u::r:s;i:2.m.<':<3ss§ '("E'£t-3 im€:rp:'€£.aE.§.{m p."ia_{:ed byi*--he_E}i.*}'2si.§§z':T ' E3€I"2(?h€i"E3 is pmp€;%i° azté Ié:g;f21§.. We: {E0 §'1.(3£:..f%.§':d zxtéy' '€165 s:_i'2:,:'§f},-f' V what. has bﬁﬁié 2:i1'<:':21d§J sssaizfiﬂ ﬁccardingiyg the referefﬁcﬁés; ari;§;s::er*e§}~.T?&é":na'iter§" shaii be placeé before :hevAV..£é:¥a%r;:}ez:l{ si'rig~ieA jzidge far decision in ﬂee light of thcs ansgvé:éigii}§é:2'?:ereirz abeve.

h AA ,;'§Ed,f§{':3§p;'v

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court