Karnataka High Court
Thimmappa vs Smt Gowramma on 30 June, 2011
Author: Jawad Rahim
Bench: Jawad Rahim
' é:§§};i¥§§§afiYE§ and :'§ri,%.§<,§'vEam§:.sna§h fies; we §"%§§*;?E'E{"§&§'3i$, V"V".'.':'€;'h<~j>§:LVE$::f°:8§WE£3§ ra5§a3§':§&n%: E3 agééxzg ssséiéé éhe a§§@E§&:§t. ;;:":::m what giaéntéff wag evsmag eniiééiéeé ta éecree 9% $§S§€$S%G2'2 find iwnce, the sari vvas éecreeé, figgaééing téze game, Q:"'s'.3:~}:2.V.V§;§«.f:p_e-V._ G? the éefendania fééad 'am agpeai which fmiiéess as 'me Eeameé aageiiaie 3§:§§,e...fQ3ur:d_*%:'{§"
észterfem vvéih {he cgnciugéorz ea?" ihe bath f§'1%S@ji.§fig%'%"3&fi§S, he is in S':§v{._'v§*.'..'E.§ _V AA '
5. A': the stage _.::f ad;f#::g.§;{s?'§»<f>_h;--._.LApzéfiz"'-régiié was Egsued. ks f'€SfiOfi$@ ta g%_gii<;§.igi-3::2fi{1'V»?2::':;'*§V:S'~%f:&ve %¥'§'E€1"'€G agpearanca. Farghgf,.__{3@E§: "éi:$é:$ "i:§a..sc§':§r:g the meréé: ané fQ§i§:,e«;*:E':§.§ Eaw as"is& fer c@:1s£§e:"ai§.{3--n~:. V A 9' :3 is €55'fi%j1f.§4nd.éV%:g;jM:"*:r:'§s.a:7,x:a.995 and G.S}.i'EQ{§8§§1 §'§ié3é'-- a7'-..;fe*;::'j'é;a€!£fai"3 $9 far 35 it §"eEaie§».:{> ..c§ai.m'..e"f~...:.%2e agmaéiani mat: ifiey have' seé ..a;,:g'~:*'ég%'é"*: we and Enigma: if': the ._*':§':0§__€'%"i%; 3?: 5@%':fi?;$%€Mi;GVs"%?
*»1{$ '§i{§?i2.§__CSi§F'f and the agwéiaig ficzuri $3 <ie:;;r:_§j§.s*m§r§g %:%":at the aggeiégrzt: ané 'me A '3§£@§'2é5'_'*~.:é%;§er:denE ééé nut}: iréavfi 3ufi§%;ar:'::§a§
-.§egaE~~ _?:i_'é..§E':t is mgégt geggesséom wh§{:%':
a<'§i'z*§i.jfi§?1g is 'a%:e:2;*: %§ gsmgéggéva eccugaiémz? Em -- < ,M,.
E have Ezaaré fiéé Seaweed CGé}?":S%€§ Sm:,§'%§;é§%3a is? V, '\ is geferreé in the greambig :9 mg juégsézantf E': ig sseen that '$13 agpeééant 3:26 ihe $€CC%?"§§ 2*esp§née:"*:E are ac: sang <3? Em first reggcanéeszi. "'E"§":e3i aémii: {my . greietteé am fimazght up by fies"_\;s;Vi:_§f1e3u:.'"a:*:~§:" §§§;'§e'i.EVa reéatisfishép but En 3 fegter $305165 afiucaieé ans gmamed them arfi "cm thug?-fixazig f§h_§3y fiavg get em E9359? mm. fheiy §§%2-?:£e:s:--€:ic:n E 3% had foflzereé them and v§rEu:ai'§§?:V"afiéiégizgcix"tV%ie:%:=.;:3§/éé 'thus they have acquireé {fie eight '§"..5§'ft§"u§:E:":€§v'§§j§'E§.E§':éS§Z §?.""t~§'§€ pragertyfi Heweverg ham'fabs:;1§i%1_._~_a~.g§:Eea§:.E_q3 2':§,:--:%:g3§3%§;:£":}'%§r:g her Eéfe 'céme wag a cgL:65:32:':"'~%:.?éz:'EV«:_;%§_aVe miamsvgarefi by the tyéaé C9 u rt a n d:'--.:§*: e_ E3 *:es,;r§.§;;4é3»VE%31a'i4.:<:"<_ L..»:;_;.z-r'ii.} 8, _ §é"'%.ifiaE 52:3-v._§tA':31Ta*g'~;1' Tm :'§aEa;:*e gt' reiief gaught in .__a;r:§ A{::;$....;é?'>."}",:':@§S bears tesiémorey is 53% fast i:%aaf:;~§fé'§:'%fi;:begéfiningg we has F389;'? agsertérzg am §9§§E*2% iiiée area? éniaragi Es": iése grsgeriy and is reiéef aggénsi the agaeéiaréi azzé iéze aecsnfi . rflr'::;§§';':AA§ §'é§'§?:s':§", §%:e £"§$Si";§"§'E:=E€§ éthem 33 mm? §§E€*:3§"E"§§§§§€; *.._ §%':§§;sir§é§§ €§@§"§"'i€§'éiS awaiting £2 we §:'$§$E'"€:§! Qwrééé $3; '*.,__ §<&s' ia he: :§e%:r§me::":: §§':§ §§$%:3 aué: S€H.«~'&'%°3§ émsiarzass 3:3 ghzsw %:€sw the aggszeééani iréeé :0 fi§%'Eé駀 her flgézizg am' mafia N'.
---- ii? ----
Em fénaiity having regched is '$68 féfiéing an Sud: an §s§ua En we earfier graaaeéing "R33 fact that 'E§":§$ Cauri whééa mating wéth RtS.&§=é0,11§f/2303 affirmativaiy E':§E_4€f§..VV_T'~*t}f§Te»:=.V_ ;3@$$e$$Ea:': EG fie Qrotecteé iééé they are éis;p$$_$éééséfif~ E__n:~__' ascgréance with iaw arid gfierméiténg iéwg férgt _r::3>*ss;$fi:;vé§é's:1§t'--:Ve '4 ffia a 33%: is 3 céiniure to iméé that izhveér gt:<3T;<s;i:e s"T::;§G§§ "%:=:ia'2: ;2__0t~:»::VT A' haaed an 2':%i:Ea£ But, germéssive {3aicupa%E%0::%,_f?{:r :A1i"eE駰;'._:::%3v§ w_,3§ regewed fight "ta gaek poSs§ss§_:%Lfi~«_.'»V:' ,"§fl§"'2€E:;éf"'s.',i@VV%:"_€ v,v,.: séége hm szicceedeé in the éécreevé.§"rgf{i%;frg§»é;"'{£s_'f§fi:"'t'¥j:& pa:§ supra.
?§:";§&:'E§$ ef the €{}E.£E'tS fi§'E§S figfi gugpgré: fmm E23 reagm is énterfare w§1:§f§V remrdeeé $3' the tééai C$:_§r:fiz "Fhe quesicémig 0? iaw framed as*e&a;é3weré;%é""3§§%%'2--§§: E%2&m, Aweai faéés am ég dégmésgggé; Ere E§'1€"'€ff§V_§'v{i{3€'E"ES'i§E"§C§S, me aréer as ':9 oasis. % ..... ..
' 5&3-grgefiaifzt is graniseé {me r:*:m':%2'"s time is ,_é§ié2,%€ef""§§gg&éL§;_%_::T§2 §f the gragegtgz in guesiésn smm it fig T'--«.V__'$é§3n ifaaég. %;f~s;;e firgi :*es§c::':::.%em?: E333 izeeaz afaxsérég fgr jijfiiiié .__'?<;:%?"§3.V §§é':~7_%s,2§ 6? me? :5 giearg am hfiérsg advamseé stage of géaam, must Sfié {he resaii Q? we éergraag 1? E3 fzxiizer >, ?E'"%5§§ Ciéaé' ihgé gm exiangéen 9% iéme wfié ise graniéé ihég '-<¢ ;__#.»";
a:".;as& iimiy an Camgagsienate grfisgnéf a ;':':~;;~::":%;%é'§ témé E; granteé :0 the 3§§}E§§E§"3E am the fifiififsé :*§3§9:*:§$:'%§ '~i4és5~.._ §e§§ver the vacaat §%i§$€S§§Gi"E 5? the gmmégeg tQ----§V:?%'e7"'~§i%i?W1:;E rfipondent wéizheat ccmgeéééng §*2er__."i:,a:;_ :"as1r;~:é°':---.:i'i>"""é;*;y meceefiing, knmvfi. _. , u:m%.__« ._ ' W kt'. {N ,4: , . . ' M3 § _ 2
2 Via?' » 3--r< .9':-
__,,Ǥi.;
§:?{?%i %:% ' .