Karnataka High Court
Sri R Venkatesh S/O Rangappa vs Sri B T Gangadharaiah S/O Late Thimmaiah on 28 September, 2011
E CE:-EA €383/'£}£3 <1:/w <:::;.~i. £384 3; «:»35a"s;'<}:% EEK? "§'E"3§7Z E:§§{}§"§ C{}U'E"%'§' GE' E§:%§€N...!5{{}"'iE§A 2'3'? ETEAEQ Gz'%.LO§1iEZ E73&'F§Z.§3 T.ii§§S "E'§'"§E'§ iiééém EIE2'-';':" G?" $E%Z'§3"E"§3'§"E7§3Ei:.E99; 23 3,} BE§QRE 'ET':---iéi E--é:i§§%£"§%E,.§':="; .?a:'§E{, ,5:_:s"§*:<:§e: 2%.,S.§'i4'%{,'iE-"i'§"E£§_'%'*'%fg§§%§3:' . <:R4:§y2::*a3z:*s.j,. :'»'§..E3§3E££§L zx:m§é;é;;3 Q1? 21:3':3'z;; f , C.E{E1Efi§NAL ;"\,.}'3'?EIAL ?\EGS.68«5E._£':§: {3I£?15-'OE*"7 293% " A Em cR:m:€AL APPEAL r=€0,583;2i:¥::3;K@~:....
§%.Ei'.§'WE{iE:E%;§ R, 'af%::fi§a'i,eSE1, Sm, Efiangzippag -. = §€es-3§d.§r1§_§aE,?%E<>.?83 V {V Cmgszz, EA;a£§3z:§;:f}:«:€'%j?{§a{i, CKC Gziffiiéizk H ;i='_, _ g _ Efizingggaafiéam 565%} A.E3E3Eli;'E,AN"§";fS £332 1':/U L:}k::5:§h;§ E"':.'§.%:§:..E€E.%§:§'-ix: 52::ixs'ss,§ fléét ._ '3 V' *-E-§, E" ?}éi;::;g2:e::23,21:"21i2&3:; ' " ~~~~~ ~ "
A ' , Si (2 L2»; €163 "".§fhi.z':A:;a3;3a§£1E:.
*.??;€::5s%.c§ 733%, E"%3t:i; E Eéfi iassgz, '§2:s:::. A' :§§j'<:r:;s;s:a {ii:a¥.':{£'z°23 L;2%;§,:
_ E§a:.z§;a..E{)r§:'§' . §%2§%:$§5}{}?§':§§::\s?;;% " " E'§§3rT:?§':'§, "E71;'3. ,§3';{§":f3} " '~ .§%{%8i
2 <::::.;x ۤ8:3;'{)ۤ <11: iv;
(fir? 1%:-".~;, E384 €f$§4*'§E"7";,5{i'§€:'% "E"'h.1:5 C.=:"§.z'm?:"12.z§ 2'-'§;:a§::»:*2'.11 E'i3e{*E :::*:<:ifii*.r E:3<?<.%i§<.>1:'; 3Z'8{'i.} {,'.:*1.PJC.T E73}? '@166 z::Ea?{}{i72'.:Ik;? Eli)? ':..E:'::"-: ;1p§é<%E§z1z'1§4 _gi3r:I3§,;"m;,g; 2:} 592%" éiisaiiiéft 'zhéi <.>§:.€ez' £2? E-%;{?{§£,é§ii.2:1§ (ii, E3} E2~{}E§ ;i};=:é%$é:<'§ FE}; ihéif }<;}<iI .5'%.{ff:"xA-'E }C>{Ei.._5iS(TJ, ET%2i:'1§_§a:§<:»:°£*. ii": {:.{:.E\:€.}.3f2i?:)3.?f°;®:E., :;::*.<';z4:§§'.':§:z_;;§j Eiw :%;%_;'~';§}%'3";3_{ix:;i::':is :1{ts:.:,.1s%<;%{:§ fan' §'.§'T:»:>;% <s§'E'7:%:':<'::a: p:::2§:»e§~:E:2I:§>E£: ém<;§€;."' -S€{'*«§1iiE'S-i.'E," 2 i__3§:'-'%_._ it;-5 1'~§.E.A<'.é,.
IN CRII§fiNAL APPEAL Nfl¢68ég'2§G§: -
B £§""'i5§ E: EN E21. 'J<:é:";}s;:;i'i',%3s5.h.,
-S / ix §~'=Z:mg21§:}_§32}:, Re$idin§_g§ 21:. I'\E(:».Z?'é%§.
Es' CHESS, I,-a£E323.§;.§h I'{{}a{§, , CKC Gziraistn, , _ ._ V * E3amgga§e:3':fe? 5% 92:1 ' f;j..;z,;_:>§J:£L1,;1r«:'i/:3 gay 1% 'EVE';' E.. §§§%;:%ss%ié§" ::;.$;--.:«-gm-£::;:';V,; z'7§i'*§'§} ;
E.é§':g§2m1§::'12,%, . -. --.
'Q/';'{>. §i?;,'§'I 5%»:::':g;§aé;a:§E1é7é;é'2:.:§..2§§€E 'iii E. '"9. E.<§iZf3',~- ----------
E133 . Bi},-2;::%, '§"§§_ {?;:"'{;:$;>?2, 7 :'ig--§r22 'V §.,,2:}r;:€;' ---- _ E3?-é::2;;§z:i§:é:*s%;fr.2 RE-%Z7.E§'§:3{}E?~EEZ%.§%Zi. "' 153:3 €33; '§'ff:%; E3/'Z'aE:T:;a1:zE.{3s:~;h, :'7':«::§:/~',} v':-'séa=€<>?".¥=*E< y . . 2 * ._ {fi:*'i1'm':'1:~:E g*a§:ép:':%.:1:§ 3°?-=§ §.%§€'3{T§ 3.§'z.'¥:I§i?:' =?§a;':<T':i"§:'m I§?%%{ $3 {_'f:*:Ef>,{f,'. ' z-':s:'E.*=:«:";<':';4:_€:::% ism" §%'3<=7: ;:§};>::=%t§'é;3.§':'§.. §:.>:;°2.:};%'::;g §.s:3 §9s:'%': ;'?.'i33§§{'§é3': é"%:a'? s<':5:."{Tia:;%:*' 3 Ci:'i.A 68.;-§;'{}€3~ {Ti/'W éiiriy As: {$84 5; €585,;'{:H?% mi' 21<*:{;:.z*i':'.t21§ d.L1§--E2--0E3 '§?!§?;E%3;'E~3€iz:§ ':33; ihe XX 2'-':{','E'€§ 8.: §<_;'><;Z.§'§ :'*xS{1}¢ §3£iE1§.§é:'fL{}§'f§?§ in {?.C,?€s:3.3i«3Ei4§1j{}E 6%: 3-*:.{:::§1.1.ii.ii:'1;g 1;é';€ §"ET'f,-";§3€}.';'}.{_if;'.T{'i3j.-- a;::<7z:s3€:<:i .§f:}:° tEE':s:: «:>.§.:':;%11:::€;% ;m:'":ii~sEf:aE3ie u.m'£<3:' E'3€:?(f"§§{}§1 <:s.i' F*é,E.!'%.{7.L V "
EN €RI§«fiE§$§"« A??E§§i» §'°§G$§8i§f2§§§:
E3§£'I"§.¥'E£EZ'§'i "R. KF€5:1§<;a*:_%..é:=é:§'£1, S,/O. R£1§}§§;E1§§p£1, Resaiciizzg 22:: 1'\E:3f?'8._ IE' Cm:-ssstee 'L21E%32:g§1 E'{:'>ae:§5 CKC €%a:°cE»:=.n., .
E'%a:1§;&."E.s:>ré: 5&0 82?: £7'aE--?§3£%1§.i.¢5%I'é'E'3fS {By EVE 'EVE. L-{>kes;h;: 5%: £2s:»...;_é';~ E-»£;»;:«is::;.. _ 91$? E} i E332 §;a§;vg;:'§:::a;§'::;:3:4}:2:
3 5 La E}: 37%;? :"z":z::é::§:§2'::.§jf: « . M R6:-";id:§.I1g§ ":«;2_i. Ni), E. ~ . . ' $8 ikéei §{c;~;:<.§._. SEE" ' C§*:2u";{§1'2-1 §,e2a3.rL<:.:g;*;:,~v _ ~~ §.%&"i§E§';§E3;:E{}£'E"?_? A' V " " V" §€§f:S§§'QN'§')§3§L?€'§7g'S " ' {B}; :i . "LE2./E':-§':a :2 i:ésé'Z%: , 5% {EV '} _ _ A' ~ " ..f3;:'E§§ss«{jv:?§.m.§:éé2'§ fagégaizi-21%. fiiesi :.:3i§{i€:' E'}fi{'f'€i(}E'} 3'£'€%§E§ €::E3.€_'§ ':33; %i.h'-5T: 2:§.{%;§\';'{:*::;VC:§.%L€',s. E21}? L%3e;? 2%§>p%3EEz2,i2é.: g:=:°2:zj.;'§§':§,; ix} 36$, ;~';é}~:».éz:Ei% iiézzsr {';:°{§e::'~::"
*:::é' Z;};iI?+'i'§_i3:Z§._'i':§.E:i: iii". E§%-- E.2--§5 g}2:i::;s:;%z.:§5 Ex}-* §Z%':.:*: 2363!? & Z'/{XEE zififigi . LE%'%9;2::;1g;;';zA§{::'::3 £2": {1{fi=N{;=:';§2§%'§5;"'{}'E§ 2:€?§z:§%:i.§:2g ':.%"::';>, §"€E=3*}€}§"E;{§€-}'1"i'.-- ~_a:_'%::{:{:':~s'¥:é'{§ §%":s'§" i.E:<~;% <§§'f€:z":<té: §}1..1:E'E§$§'§£3,§."fi{f z_.:;'2éa%:" ;§~Z«i*,£.7":',§{'>§': GE"
.V ,3 2'-%.{:'é.,
4 {".',ri.5% 8é%§:§§;'€}EE C;'w {ta A5) 584 5%; é?;85j{)é'§ ' Y§".'i€;'.E:'>€3 {f:*i:.§1.inz-L}; ?%.g.};>€.-aE$ hazvmgg I',}Eff%3:.'§}. hészwré zssmé :*«:?ss€:*"ve:=,-{L ::a§'::1i;':;»;{ {}':".i_ .%'<;3:" §31"{}Z"£E}E,I.i'T:€jf€ffB€?§}§. {3£'_§'L1d__§.;:'11:%:'1i., i..E'1is3 (1223,.-' i.}:€-. C{>L.E§'§.. <%:3.'§.*§.V<3;"'@{§ {E23 i}:}3E<>wé:2;;:
J' §;TI§GE!IE1%"'E' "E'.§.":& €%.§J§}€f§£?iE"i';. ham <i§:;:.E§:%11g;;€%§i %;'.E'3c: <;3'1"'c_i.<;?:.';s: sf__2§.zi.z§%.»:§'i':E.g?éi V' C6 §\E<3s¢3?.;72?;2G{}L 3264,E,ff;3';®G§ ;é; z:d"3§E¢8"E:5;§2€§{§?'3_ .i:"::é:5V«'%:"$%:1 {"T§':£:1§'§:g:€ zzrzzéer Sémziiegz E38 <3? ihas E:"§S;f;.V1:'2;:;?s1e*:éé~,--§§§*;"§,:{€€:._ {h€E.'€i'EE1::if{,€EE" czaééeai as»; "E.E":é: E:<:::E.' .§E:=:r'
2. AH z.h.<3s<:*: n:21é,t.é:1*3_éir:': 'a'..§%_.§«;:--:j:;. L'*é,a._;;;:6:E§}~;r::* fez' §:<:»nssicE€:ra.?..§<m 2:5 ?;h.<:z*&3- are {?<}:"1";::"z{}":: q11esé;i.<2i':s,{;:€_E2:=§<.r g-mg? 'f3;_i:7'aj_§~ :13": i§'}€fE5€ stzzsses, (flit?1€§:5:§:%{i§V§2iEE§, ~§1.é'ff'§7§f?i§'¥ _ {he <:<>:':1p£.:::é::22.z1%. ?§3<::§m:e ihiic Tgizai C{m:'f. _a>iJE:::%ri:~2;:5§' .:i4'i*:e"'::;::§é§;g:si§n{§<5i":*:.:as age éifiaé E}.{?C.¥.E;§§€{§ in 223:} §i.h€r:::e% <t:::*~?;s:":$, A €33. é<~::%s;§;0§":<§;€:::3é*, in {f3"§'.5?%£'€{;,{*§§%4if2§G{4§ E§E£;', wifié <15 t.E*:a:% :?é;%s;§:}é:'§:*;§EiA:::2\'::ii;-{jE*§.£%.%'<2i35%3 zmgi {S85 ;'2{}€3€i§x us, E: %..E:e:°- {,'iEE.§%€% 05 233.8 2i§3'§i§£3?EEE':£§§, zézzaé. i.E':::é ra-:;<:=;»;:s:}:':<:E».:--:'.n:',;<:;
,.:2:§}:}'§T{}2§{fhéf{§ ééég" §"%.2'3z:;zi:{:i;"§% :s25;55s:Ess'é;§.§':«:%€ af §5%';:%§. §{iéiZ?{}{}f ~ E'{é§,3%i}}®QG,f ~ ~ E¥i:é,3"f:,€'}{§{};-'~ E"i;'f§E$_'§}éE{)?':..§:'%7{f'§}x' €52" i'.E':<? <§:;':=::éi%:9s'§'..§::: §:3:,:z*;:}{}:~5%3 a=.:.:':{:§ <:»"
K, ;=«~.Nm_
5 {ma 9s2:~::'s,/<35 <1: zw cm 21$' 15384 é§85;'€}€5 'z,{,)\;%J:?J'{§5§ E.'E":::=: :*a?§>2~:§;:':':§=%:':2 sf i;'E1a% {iL.1€'§'~Ig <*.E'1e<;1.1s3ss for the a.§'<}:'e:%522.i:§ .€=:':..::;a;. §'§i"'£::?'3:": 'Bf; éhzs 1"§%§;§:s<>:'1:'£€;3:1i..s+s arzcré «:31: p:*:?3;e§':%.a;E§{}:'1 0? $229 55932:? {,'ih{'.C§L1€?f.':§a iiéey :":3?;:.:':'":":e.«:i wiiéz 2.2:'; fi§'.'£{§%Z.§E'EE§%"f§"iEiffiE',7 :3? §;%":§s':.,*;.E?§i(:%é3::":%. Efizzstisé. .5': Eaggzii :":::>i§<::£;%. 2s;aI:;*:; ;;:j§i:*€3..::' '§'§::§%:f_f;'.' Ax. mpifg. 3:': ihié <'rir<7.a.2:1":ssi.2::'1s:%6::<:a £1239: gzygispeléaizfi, féieizi 27: c;"::};1':v§:}'§e>2Vi%§f. §§;2E:f éhe aliazwseaizi €E§1':"1E'§,§{i'..
$5 §'}m"'i:r1g the maxi, Vin.' 22.3 é'i?._s:%$:% '£:.hrfs23,%;% A .€I.v'.'3-f'I.«§:'f5*}§;: '§.i;:s:9"' {iG¥§"E1}3§a§i"i8.ZfE§ was eX2m'1'i:1ed £18 '5=?'?v'.§ z;';1?i{i._ {.2 {<33 {§€?<?L3r11e':3Es:;
51);':-:axE>,§ ta: RE} wazra :z1:;1s.':'}i<{jfg§.;~ ._ "§7h_':}: §;¥;.§:§:e.;_:2.»::'§:":~§, sf." §.'§1e: r<}spe:>'ndem.s were r<:%::<:::*£ie{§ 11.:1{§€.:° S€5a:*%;;§:f>:'2 'f,%_E3'.7€i:'iE-7*,é3.V héxzéé __é3T-3; §?::'>'u.E<§ be saen ifism Ehff g'a:ci§;§:11§€n'§;.',j..fie ':'":?:sp;§;:--?::"i:::'2V%. 2:s.Q:--::_,.:_$§§§i '§,¥&'.iS €.}:?:72§1}.}:§}€f{§ 21$ 'ed :21 i:§.":e:=, efiziatiéifiziééz §":h§: <;§::>{rzzmé3:11'%;.éfs EEW. E. £3 ._1=a€€ ::1Vé:"'%::;3'v.EV"§""i3'«?"_.'fé_<E; _' E-i:>«:s;(Efi}.} £0 E333 we::'é- §"ii.'E'Z'§.1'"§i.€;§5;._ Tile 'E':"'i21E élfcauré a;?."i,€~§" hezzrizigg file V <'::>:2;1ss;¢j§ E.1i;::':; ;a;t€;¥;;i§'£V{%{§ $72"-:42 f{c%:sg}<>:'2e:k::::'i'.f zzmi a;.;;§::"§§:v<;t<§ E31,? mg:
zfiaésiizf €35" :4éL;:é;':,:§é.E.:?g%g %,E*:i~é _;}r€:<:;:2:1i. E-i§}§}€':'.E}§S §E21ix'%'?. E::<3€:.': iii:-:<{é E: §5§3i'*:1;é%;:%a-éss:§2:z"§; 'iii? mc:"m".::.}'n E.'::';=.=;"°€. 'iikzgzi. %;'.Zr:s-5, 8.§}§}if'§2%.§}§l aE:=i-sis Efiegé {Xi ';_::§3'2%§4§2,f:?;{}{§E agziéizsi. aha? :'€s«;g}{':'1'1<'Es:%:'1§. {E:2:§s;E}a:2{iL 's51f;é{i§"{?§:E'§ 521$}. :"&::~.-2§_}<}:':{§§é1'H'. 'c'¥;{3{§§Z2}i'E."§,{;'f{§ <35 '£:.§1£% ;<e;2£..2i{,§ <:E*:é1:§";;g&. .'1'_.{%§§g_§'1"'§£::%:$<§ E13}; é.§':s:r ;::<'%{g:,::é§.E,;2E '£5: ?2:1%':isi«; {fiz"§»;":'%'§$£§ 5' 21{}{}%S 3' E7} {.T:'3..§& €3«Et§;':%,f®Ei~ Cffzv {Ir}. 55:3. 68% 5%: £3«8Ei%;'{3€§ bézerz. §1Eh:%£i w§':i<'_%':2 E"2as:~; %:»eei': §:e:a;'::i 21§<>':.':.gjwéi?1 *i.h€:'~%€;% ;1;)ps:%z§E.$ zmsci {ii5?,i§.}€f}§E3ti'E{§ <2? 'e§_; Sfifgfiéifziiit_§1,1{§§§§"E'}€3E":§., §_'}2'.i&':'sS€i?{§ ii<;{iz:§g'. 5%" E Ezzaw §':e;=:.r<§ 232$ '§:=:z'z.§f:':§3:{% {'_'.{}'i§§.'1.E;§*;"?§ €<:sr E3«:>§..§:z '§:}"!«€::":I,:}:E.):i'§"°:§.,%:§:.?.53:«€.:'%i Q) 'EEm:.:g§: %3(;=é:'h {Em a::<::us15;;eE .a.§g1.1<;éc§ ' :::zer§':s <35 I;Eé:e :z1a§::.::*:*ss, an §z§E1:s%r<3:":i. iiiég §§'F£}{f€;"*€fdEI1§.§S b<:>.§<::'€;% Sthe. 'F:"§a§ Ceuri: '1TVi;1f¥"'*.«:3:V:Ai"' am'; if. $3 reievznfi: 'ii; zaaie 'iizai. A:§':;?a=Vz:3"':° €.:EV1<3r.
c{>:r::;:>iz:im2z..n:, xwra msi. aélyzfifbed js:.>.§:':?'*E:.i..;%:21§_ i1§3c§e3:" E1365? p1*m-"i§;i.c>r:s <1? C%1a.g;>'i:<;%r° }{'€'EEE'----£:§j .:3f'.¥;hi-1:-1' §C'L:*;"?i}"'5fi3 --..EiZa1{é§:: ef the (321863 have b<_>.€.:: $5€3§.)£i.E"E1?~<f~3'§J ':.2"§{;'::§'."§~3-iii: ::':";i:3;**1.uégazjfiééijyj Elie Trig} Cam. wE"::£.E€: £:{.{hs;§efE{%:':i.§:::;;; 3:'; E.§ié:*_§€3 zxppeais :"€i3s3m'€:d is: {hit ::§+:>cm};:€::"ii:is% E§.xs;¢;?}fiEr "*%.;c::§ jE§T;é§ ,Fz5JE."§i€j'.§} "x5J€'{"€;', p:rf{:=d:.:{:e{§ 3231 CC §'*€<3,826_<}2j ;2:§5{§I:E ézmi "V5251. 3:'; ~~;"iz";§;' <25 i.E1.€<s:aé3 itzzséess. .E€f€_:" §é:s:" 21%;{,:>:*e<:ia:i..i.::g 'ma? .{a€;:E',.s; <2? §,h::?:s€ <:a&.;:*:s:; éghe iii":(iii:-:":'::§é::;%ssV..;3;:§:ff:§§€.€::§ in m"§{§z~3:'::;:€ ii': {iii §T~;?<2,E§§.3',;8»:'-'2«§:"",;/'2;€}{"3éE ziazzzmé, E3:-5 ::"3:'--§.§_7:ss'i:_§.::;:-.s;"*s:?:<i§',.* é.§n§§:$;~§ £%*:é::<é:: E3 3f:.;§:':'é: 32:23.'; «:2? 2;}? '?'i.§"i€:-;*f~.§é*, '§'§':£.-3 3"E'§E-ii {?<}2;'_:"'§: 32:'; §}éi§'£'if:'-3 E2 ii} E4 <3? éiiat j:.:<§;;§:":1e::"£.. E2325 <':7{3E'12%;§<§€:'€%£§ if €..§:{: '§_°€:.s;§2§::.é:zT2;{.'ea*;%:'":%:s§ in aii §§":{i'.E§i"." ¥i:':"::'@€ {'72z5=;<3::v:s§ '§>2::%»'5{§ VV 0:": §%:5::;;,E},§ ii} §}.;:'§ E-':'i1'1{".§. Etsiifasgé 1%};-.:.é 2:': ;'>":':;}?:32:;%.:e?;<=: {;§a'->=;§::*:":sTe;§: §":;:s:.a §}§?€f§'2 ,5"
"3 crux aaggog czar «cm. Ag. §8rE» & 685586 :'ais€<:i 'Sf; ihsr £"€S'§§§:§€i"1i$ arid in ibis ::{::1€;€:<'i,, the 'E"r§aE Csuri mréerszzi acguiiiaé mifiging upém $16 mid fiificuffififiifi *e.x;:""§4:i;.;é*:;%:§_':'%;«:%§r€ infasé rm': gm-Ciucgéi in ihfizfifi C3363 E-Efhraie M $2-*i§€:"1{:€ in {$36 saga "aha E353: §fl€S ::s.{>'L gerggifé. '::ZT€§£€i':~E%':§iE'.T§C€b ._ ' '$19 fie3CE}§E'§€§§.'§S in {fig aéihey cagrég; '.§'§};e% §:22:;§%:}1zé;§:_; gméutéeé eiiher 6:16 C&:'i1Zfiea& CQ'§§§s X€FQ%.:"'v'{;%%§#iéSv§~;::§:.%E1;i;; "_ fiQC%.,1E§":€n"E$ anfi the}! amid have n=;g~:::§e:§ ~;£";i?:.:eV."V<:*:§aV§ es with' cangazat in name of E0 :3';-5 §E1av& E36621 graéucafi ané eazezx. {fig fiat enierad ihzé witnesg 'max 3.3 2":<:);:* i;'?JA':€%§;>'€'£'¢;I%§_§._Ii;%i*ifi0r: sf D'¥?sE12. Bu? $26 Trig: Cazizgfi cL e':i,a§i';igi€:*{;*«.t;:<:>:/1 {ha €'é'§§€E1{§E anfi éas:ume:§?:ft s§"§2*:a}1 'i§'1£:?S€ 'ihrae cases and &f{€§' cer§:S--§.<j;éri:§g;--é§:'ss.3§eE§€ de;:}e3::1di:;g aspen the Saifi dasunégerfgs aid €326' Ssésidsréazéé has granteé an azfier cf acqzsiitaig 'V ' «--a;;§1§<:E:f_:' '£15 2_:if§1i7§"G'§€§' in E:;=;--2:a §"E";~ iii;-e:--"Ci:*c:::'§:3:a§:s&S', E 32:: 9% the zggmiszn that 113% ;§ra§sf:>:§:,a.:i§E; .a5§i;'§:*§ifi€§ 'ay $23 Tyéai €::::3;:=%; $3 ayranaazzs 322$ Eliegai ' Viazizégfh '§:2a;<3"ca::s&§ §z:;§:,:$'t§c*e fig ths §a§°'{§@:§ amé §*E§"E%§"fi 25 :32: giéagr " _ é.,:;,°2:;::'%§:>.A" §X.€€",§"i,' 3% as': aséfiiz €;}:_€ gréera ai' asqs,§;§§;*f£a§ azné razrzié V. .?§;:}:%: §;§'§E ':§m'§"E6:°3 :19 E326 '§'ria': €G§.,'i3.'"i. $9 §£::z**:z3.§.% fifié pariiag i.;::: E6225 5"' m 31> (.',§"'LA €iE.%3/'{"JE§ Cfv;
Cri. A53. {$84 €?S8F>f{3€§ !;i";.:': e?v'id:%z'2{é<? zmé §.h(;'f'i"€;?Ei§Wi,t1'E§", :1'; (§f':.:%;;:}{):e;§;t< <1}? EEEQT {':£i-3.5365. in ;32<':<:<::'zi2m::%€ WEEE": E2123.
:2' 'f§."E'1.:'-é éeamsrzi <;*<>z,2:':;s;§*.E 3%}: 3121:: ;_-*:§3g3e*;t~i§.:2:m§'. £13.54; }'}:%'£{}.{If€f{§ :":=.Ei;2:1{:e gm £E':€: s:%:3<?'§§;%§<3;': 0%' E236 fX§}{f.':'~; C'»=::n..:2"i ri2§r:{3:"i.é;%d SC 28338 §E3E;2?iI"i§§£i§i}E}£1 2: §\'§.{}§}aI"I} w§"z<:1"€::i:'7: ii. ézas Ezaéiigii _« V' Apa-'ix {§:>2.::'i &.E1aE'. é3>:;i.s«s§'.ez:c€=, of §é%g2:.1l§; 2: :11aEi:<;ér G?§}:*e§3'L1r::1'§::E.i{}:':. une:Eg3:f S€%<;4{.E::f:é'.V_EA.3§ 'i.':°ia§ Csmfig ss§'1.aiEIE. i.21E:£:: £n'{.<:'} {:<}':1s§€%;'&2%%:'f:'.»!:'%;ion '§i1éi'='§};{'§LET2V{§§_§}g€%¢Lééiiéi '%_%e:}::v.n in ?:i'::;'. de(.%§&~.>,.i:3;': F§3fé1?E'f€;?C§ 3:; :=?~:*a.:§§f52§»";'A. {?'£'s§.2'I'"Vf§:3€ 0:' ihe §3r@<~,e€.<j§:":;g::'s( ET 3;{:g:1§E1£'.:2§ in ':§'§§::>§'s:=§.i%8'?2%j2:QQ1, 32§¥E§;'2GG§ gaazzd _ 32835;} 2%} '1 22,:f€":;<,jéf 2;1:<:;2*<'JZé% amd the §"§:g>:Ez".<%:"s; 2=.I;;*€% zf€:::1§"i,"£,<3:d %2;1<:';<: its t.§f1::,"§':*::T:§ '{'§:::é%;_af'::..._f{};" §;§\f§:":g_; am. €}§}p€}i"§.'a.E'§'1§ii}? {<3 a:E'":€: Efiéifilififfi Es fiééazi §§i'§::i7e;?'§'§<':§:":2;%%=£§, §'a;i3:::1.é~E%'§.>:>s;§% cf 'i_.§'E€3 ft§£§é..E{"i'E€if E2': .:2=s_{%.:':«:é:"§§2;a.'s::.<;:€ "as-*ié,§: i;:w~.;?. Ezjéf {.233-;=, i'§'E.E?:§'§.€3'§"E5£- an-": {BE EE'i<': },.«-*:2.:;1;:" 2{E{}%.Z.. %H:a'§':E: z'.§";:":
,'§::21§'€1§1e$am:=:{E§z'{%g?é;.a%§;§ 21.0 §I}€? %'§3"f,'.5-5-:«€:'I'"E;i.. ';*:>e%iE'{>ra'=. '§"ha:: '.§"r§21§ €Z{}:.::"i {E31 s .' E
-- --2;.i; E%§--2{}E E. "§'E':€ {i;::;:.§I"':.. s5;§'2;:E§ %.§?:%,=.§+;:z aim §}§§{}'1"§E,}«' '» €53 <':::~s.;-3, £<3E%%£'i% ;<'>:;:'; 2:': ;*w <:'::-;' A;~;D ESE?»-'l,--. 52;. €53€~E%§§;'é'}£,S imssisa gmézi ::Eis':sp{';::e;z:é {::%"%.E'1<:%§:': §3r:%§'E?s"212?3Ey w§*:.};'1m 5:339: mm'1E':E":s~>; §':'{§:'13 "§..%1:-E e:£::.'E'::: <3? <tr<3:":::'1"§'s..:::%:'t;,:%.§m'1 {sf 'ibis; {1}}-'-g-3%-74%;": _ ?§§@E