Central Administrative Tribunal - Allahabad
Sanjay vs Military Engineer Services (Mes) on 6 September, 2024
(Open Court)
Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad
Bench Allahabad
****
Original Application No.1027/2024
This is the 06th Day of September 2024.
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Joshi, Member (J)
1. MES No 425721, Sanjay, aged about 57 years, S/o Late Munni Lal
working as MCM FGM in GE (W) Agra.
2. MES No 449094, Mukendra Singh, S/o Sh Bijendra Singh working as
MCM (FGM) in GE (E) Agra
3. MES No 440618, Ram Avtar Singh, S/o Late Jagvir Singh working as
FGM HS-II in GE (E) Agra.
4. MES No 426669, Faran, S/o Ali Mohammad working as Ref/Mech
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
5. MES No 425908, Satish Chandra, S/o Late Tara Chand working as
FGM (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
6. MES No 426668, Mukesh Kumar Verma, S/o Sh Dal Chandra working
as Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
7. MES No 425914, Akash Deep Bhola, S/o Sh Subhash Bhola working as
Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
8. MES No 425683, Mata Prasad, S/o Sh Ram Ratan working as MCM
Elect in GE (E) Agra.
9. MES No 425233, Gyan Singh, S/o Late Badri Prasad working as MCM
Ref/Mech in GE (E) Agra.
10. MES No 425901, Govind Singh, S/o Sh Vijay Singh working as FGM
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
11. MES No 508581, Ram Sewak Galav, S/o Late Summar Singh working
as MCM (FGM) in GE (E) Agra.
12. MES No 425601, Khem Chand, S/o Late Kali Charan working as
MCM (FGM) in GE (E) Agra.
13. MES No 425911, Rinku Solankey, S/o Sh Suresh Babu working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
14. MES No 425592, Prem Dutt Sharma, S/o Late Gaya Prasad Sharma
working as MCM Elect in GE (E) Agra, Retd on 31.01.2023.
15. MES No 375727, Deepak Kumar, S/o Late Lakhpat Singh working as
Elect HS-II in GE (E) Agra.
16. MES No 425899, Rajendra Singh, S/o Sh Samundra Singh working as
Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
17. MES No 426673, Ravijot Singh, S/o Sh Badam Singh Yadav working
as Painter (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.2
18. MES No 425906, Jitendra Kushwah, S/o Sh Shivram Kushwah
working as Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
19. MES No 426691, Kusum, W/o Sh Sunil Kumar working as Carpt (SK)
in GE (E) Agra.
20. MES No 426692, Brijesh Singh, S/o Sh Bachhu Singh working as Mate
(SSK) in GE (E) Agra.
21. MES No IN/115965H, Dalbir Singh, S/o Late Raghubir Singh working
as Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
22. MES No 425910, Rinkesh Kumar Meena, S/o Sh Bharat Lal Meena
working as Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
23. MES No 425562, Mahesh Singh, S/o Sh Gopal Singh working as MCM
(FGM) in GE (E) Agra, Retd on 31.03.2023
24. MES No 424243, Hare Ram Prasad, S/o Late Shiv Nath Ram working
as Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
25. MES No 483896, Pavan Kumar, S/o Late Manroop Singh working as
Elect HS-II in GE (E) Agra.
26. MES No 425521, Shyam Sunder Verma, S/o Late Hira Lal working as
VM (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
27. MES No 425644, Manik Chand, S/o Late Chirangi Lal working as
MCM (Carpt) in GE (E) Agra.
28. MES No 425791, Suresh Chand, S/o Sh Om Prakash working as FGM
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
29. MES No 373580, Girish Pal, S/o Sh Khetal Singh working as MCM
Elect in GE (E) Agra.
30. MES No 15337222X, Suresh Chand, S/o Sh Shri Chand working as
Painter (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
31. MES No 425912, Man Singh Chahar, S/o Sh Tikam Singh Chahar
working as Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
32. MES No 425763, Rameshwar Singh, S/o Late Pratap Singh working as
Mason (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
33. MES No 425918, Dheeri Singh, S/o Sh Mata Prasad working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
34. MES No 1586531X, Tikam Singh, S/o Sh Kailash Chand working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
35. MES No 425587, Rajendra Singh, S/o Sh Hari Shankar Singh Chauhan
working as MCM Elect in GE (E) Agra.
36. MES No 1488598A, Phal Singh, S/o Sh Chhiddu Singh working as
Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
37. MES No 425726, Ram Prakash, S/o Sh Babu Lal working as MCM
Elect in GE (E) Agra.
38. MES No 369918, Inder Kumar, S/o Sh Kishan Lal working as
Ref/Mech (HS-II) in GE (E) Agra, Retd on 31.07.2021.
39. MES No 425904, Netrapal Singh, S/o Sh Gulab Singh working as
RefMech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.3
40. MES No 425530, Rajeev Kumar Mishra, S/o Sh Virendra Pal Mishra
working as MCM Ref/Mech in GE (E) Agra.
41. MES No 471390, Dharm Vir Singh, S/o Sh Vijay Singh working as
Ref/Mech (HS-II) in GE (E) Agra.
42. MES No 425900, Rinku, S/o Sh Chandravir Singh working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
43. MES No 425591, Subhash Chandra Sharma, S/o Late Radhe Shyam
Sharma working as MCM Elect in GE (E) Agra.
44. MES No 425868, Ajay Kumar, S/o Sh Murari Lal working as FGM
HS-II in GE (E) Agra.
45. MES No 425802, Rajendra Kumar, S/o Late Jang Bahdur working as
Mason (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
46. MES No 425913, Ved Prakash, S/o Sh Balvir Singh working as P/Ftr
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
47. MES No 425915, Vinod Kumar, S/o Sh Sobharam working as FGM
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
48. MES No 315328, Lekhraj, S/o Sh Goverdhan Singh working as Carpt
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
49. MES No 425660, Rambir Singh, S/o Late Udayvir Singh working as
MCM (FGM) in GE (E) Agra.
50. MES No 425684, Suresh Chandra, S/o Late Bhikam Singh working as
MCM (Elect) in GE (E) Agra, Retd on 31.03.2020 as JE.
51. MES No 457566, Murari Lal, S/o Sh Mohar Singh working as MCM
Ref/Mech in GE (E) Agra Retd on 30.06.2018.
52. MES No 425903, Arvind Kumar, S/o Sh Vikram Singh working as
Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
53. MES No 425773, Rakesh Kumar, S/o Late Durga Prasad working as
Mason (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
54. MES No T-15114E, Praveen Kumar, S/o Sh Samundra Singh working
as Painter (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
55. MES No 425735, Raj Kumar Gulati, S/o Late KL Gulati working as
FGM HS-II in GE (E) Agra.
56. MES No 425768, Manoj Kumar Sharma, S/o Late Chakkhan Lal
working as Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
57. MES No 425710, Bhupendra Singh, S/o Late Lajja Ram working as
P/Ftr (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
58. MES No 425869, Rajveer Singh Tomar, S/o Late Sh Bhagirath Singh
working as Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
59. MES No 483804, Mukesh Chandra, S/o Late Sohan Lal working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
60. MES No 1490933X, Raj Kumar, S/o Sh Jai Narayan Sharma working as
Carpt (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
61. MES No 425525, Khyali Ram, S/o Sh Khem Chand working as Carpt
(SK) GE (E) Agra, Retd on 30.06.2024.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.4
62. MES No 425907, Mohd Sarfraj, S/o Sh Shahabuddin working as FGM
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
63. MES No 483985, Sohan Singh, S/o Sh Bhawani Singh working as Mate
FGM in GE (E) Agra.
64. MES No 3182460H, Gauri Shankar, S/o Late Sukh Ram working as
P/Ftr (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
65. MES No T-1741, Tejveer Singh, S/o Om Prakash working as Mate in
GE (E) Agra.
66. MES No 425909, Ram Kishore Meena, S/o Sh Mishra Ram working as
Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
67. MES No 425772, Ram Prakash, S/o Sh Sawal Das working as FGM
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
68. MES No 470160, Shaukat Ali, S/o Sh Rajwali working as FGM HS-II in
GE (E) Agra.
69. MES No 425799, Raja Ram, S/o Sh Shri Chand working as Elect (SK)
in GE (E) Agra.
70. MES No 14551933W, Jai Singh, S/o Late Lekh Raj Singh working as
Elect (SK) in GE (E) Agra.
71. MES No 426404, Roshan Lal, S/o Late Bhamar Singh working as Carpt
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
72. MES No T-1446, Nand Kishore, S/o Sh Shiv Nath working as Elect
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
73. MES No 427012, Vivek Kumar, S/o Sh Raj Kumar working as Mate
(SSK) in GE (E) Agra.
74. MES No 425897, Monu Yadav, S/o Sh Tej Singh working as Ref/Mech
(SK) in GE (E) Agra.
75. MES No 471376, Santosh Kumar, S/o Sh Gulab Singh working as Elect
(SK) in AGE R&D Agra.
76. MES No 425731, Bhuri Singh, S/o Late Karan Singh working as Elect
(HS-II) in AGE R&D Agra.
77. MES No 141497, Balvikash Tiwary, S/o Sh Achandra Shekhar Tiwary
working as P/Ftr (SK) in AGE R&D Agra.
78. MES No 1489040X, Rajendra Singh, S/o Sh Phal Singh working as
Elect (SK) in AGE R&D Agra.
79. MES No 424201, Santosh Kumar, S/o Late Shripal working as FGM
(SK) in AGE R&D Agra.
80. MES No 471501, Abadh Bihari, S/o Late Rambharosi Lal working as
MCM FGM in AGE R&D Agra.
81. MES No 421726, Rajiv Kumar Bhadauria, S/o Late Jas Karan Singh
working as FGM (SK) in AGE R&D Agra.
82. MES No 426676, Sachin Kumar, S/o Late Hukum Singh working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in AGE R&D Agra.
83. MES No 449134, Rajvir Singh, S/o Sh Tara Chand working as Elect
HS-II in GE (W) Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.5
84. MES No 426671, Kuldeep Chaudhary, S/o Sh Rajvir Singh working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
85. MES No 427025, Amod Prakash Hasija, S/o Sh Subash Chandra
Hasija working as Mate (SS) in GE (W) Agra.
86. MES No 471377, Virendra Kumar, S/o Sh Bashanti Lal working as
Elect (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
87. MES No 483800, Sunil Kumar, S/o Sh Pitam Singh working as
Ref/Mech HS-II in GE (W) Agra.
88. MES No 426695, Yogesh Chandra, S/o Sh Ram Roop working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
89. MES No 425843, Shashipal, S/o Late Fool Singh working as P/Ftr (SK)
in GE (W) Agra.
90. MES No 425719, Shyam Baboo, S/o Late Shiv Charan working as
MCM Ref/Mech in GE (W) Agra.
91. MES No 449224, Jitendra Singh, S/o Sh Basdev Singh working as Mate
(SS) in GE (W) Agra.
92. MES No 426679, Naveen Kumar, S/o Sh Nemi Chand working as
Painter (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
93. MES No 375934, Raghvendra, S/o Sh Niranjan Singh working as Elect
(SK) in GE (W) Agra.
94. MES No 426693, Gaurav Raj, S/o Late Chaman Singh working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
95. MES No 426685, Saurabh Singh Pratihar, S/o Sh Brij Mohan working
as Elect (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
96. MES No 374385, Hari Pratap Singh, S/o Sh Shyam Singh working as
MCM Elect in GE (W) Agra.
97. MES No 427020, Sanjeev, S/o Sh Hemant Singh working as Mate (SS)
in GE (W) Agra.
98. MES No 608371, Sanjay Singh, S/o Sh Lokendra Singh working as
Mate (SS) in GE (W) Agra.
99. MES No 423331, Rajesh Kumar Batra, S/o Late BR Batra working as
MCM Ref/Mech in GE (W) Agra.
100. MES No 424403, Anil Kumar, S/o Sh Hakim Singh working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
101. MES No 425889, Santosh Kumar, S/o Late Indrajeet Singh working as
FGM (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
102. MES No 425886, Govind Sharma, S/o Sh Rameshwar Dayal Singh
working as Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
103. MES No 168051, Hakim Singh, S/o Late Gaheshi Lal working as MCM
FGM in GE (E) Agra.
104. MES No 440616, Krishanvir, S/o Sh Rajvir Singh working as FGM
HS-II in GE (W) Agra.
105. MES No 425760, Raj Kumar, S/o Late Suraj Pal working as Elect HS-II
in GE (W) Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.6
106. MES No 425779, Pratap Singh, S/o Late Pyare Lal working as Mason
(SK) in GE (W) Agra.
107. MES No 425934, Bhoora Singh, S/o Sh Lajja Ram working as FGM
(SK) in GE (W) Agra.
108. MES No 425933, Pankaj Tomar, S/o Late Durjan Singh working as
Carpt (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
109. MES No 281681, Umashankar, S/o Sh Ravindra Kumar working as
Mate (SS) in GE (W) Agra (01.02.2020 to 10.07.2023 in Agra).
110. MES No 485698, Ranjeet, S/o Late Mohan Lal working as P/Ftr (SK)
in GE (W) Agra.
111. MES No T-136, Upendra Kumar, S/o Sh Radhe Shyam working as
Mate (SS) in GE (W) Agra.
112. MES No 314896, Ganga Singh, S/o Late Nathi Lal working as MCM
Carpt in GE (W) Agra.
113. MES No 425938, Yashpal Singh, S/o Sh Mahipal Singh working as
Elect (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
114. MES No 425892, Manoj Kumar, S/o Sh Suresh Chandra working as
Ref/Mech (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
115. MES No 465588, Shailesh Kumar, S/o Sh Ramhet working as Mate
(SS) in GE (W) Agra.
116. MES No 462345, Raj Kumar, S/o Late Murari Lal Mahamana working
as MCM FGM in GE (W) Agra, Retd on 31.07.2024
117. MES No 425732, Virendra Singh, S/o Late Shiv Charan working as
FGM (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
118. MES No 425894, Jitendra Singh, S/o Sh Jag Mohan Singh working as
FGM (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
119. MES No 1492249, Sanju Singh, S/o Sh Dasrath Singh working as
Painter (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
120. MES No T-5495, BK Saxena, S/o Late Puran Chand Saxena working as
MCM Elect in GE (W) Agra Retd on 31.01.2024.
121. MES No 374060, Kapoor Chand, S/o Late Fusiya Ram working as
MCM Elect in GE (W) Agra, Retd on 31.07.2023.
122. MES No 192829, Rajveer Singh, S/o Late Tursi Ram working as Elect
(HS-I) in GE (W) Agra, Retd on 31.03.2021.
123. MES No 760528N, Surendra Singh, S/o Late Sh Bhagwan Singh as
Mate (SSK) in GE (W) Agra.
124. MES No 6826619L, Suresh Balmiki, S/o Late Sh Kishan working as
Mason (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
125. MES No 316483, Satyavir Singh, S/o Sh Phool Singh working as FGM
(SK) in GE (W) Agra.
126. MES No 425566, Mahesh Kumar, S/o Sh Om Prakash working as
MCM FGM in GE (W) Agra.
127. MES No 425871, Savitri Devi, D/o Late Ram Prakash Sharma working
as FGM (HS-II) in GE (W) Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.7
128. MES No 425919, Suneel Kumar, S/o Sh Netrapal Singh working as
FGM (SK) in GE (W) Agra.
129. MES No 168106, Sumitra Devi, S/o Sh Raghunath Singh working as
MCM FGM in GE (W) Agra.
130. MES No T-1877, Kshetrapal Singh, S/o Late Ram Ratan working as
Mate (SS) in GE (W) Agra.
131. MES No 426697, Mohani Gandhi, D/o Sh Boby Gandhi working as
Mate (SS) in GE (W) Agra.
132. MES No 425225, Shyam Babu, S/o Late Shiv Charan Lal working as
Elect HS-I in GE (W) Agra.
133. MES No 425535, Satish Chand, S/o Late Tara Chand working as FGM
HS-I in GE (W) Agra, Retd on 31.12.2022.
134. MES No 423325, Ramkumar Seni, S/o Sh Sadider Kishore working as
MCM Ref/Mech in GE (W) Agra, Retd on 30.09.2023.
135. MES No 425869, Sunita Devi, W/o Ram Prakash working as FGM
HS-II in GE (W) Agra.
136. MES No 425866, Tirath Kumar, S/o Sh Raj Kumar working as Elect
(SK) in GE (W) Agra.
137. MES No 427024, Sarjeet Singh, S/o Late Chunni Lal working as Mate
(Carpt) in GE (W) Agra.
138. MES No 425724, Bharat Kumar, S/o Sh OP Srivastava working as
MCM Elect in GE (W) Agra.
139. MES No 425681, Mihi Lala, S/o Late Ram Bharosi working as MCM
Elect in GE (W) Agra, Retd on 31.12.2020.
140. MES No 425694, Hakim Singh, S/o Sh Ved Ram working as MCM
P/Ftr in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
141. MES No 424389, Manish Sharma, S/o Sh Mahesh Dutt Sharma
working as Mason (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
142. MES No 404609, Bavlesh Kumar, S/o Sh Ram Kishan working as
P/Ftr (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
143. MES No 424410, Anil Kumar, S/o Sh Shiv Shankar working as P/Ftr
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
144. MES No 15336856F, Chhavi Nandan, S/o Sh Khyali Ram working as
P/Ftr (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
145. MES No 424220, Jay Prakash, S/o Late Bheji Ram working as FGM
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
146. MES No 433434, Bhagwan Dayal, S/o Late Pyare Lal working as Carpt
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
147. MES No 404607, Nem Prakash, S/o Sh Ram Singh working as Elect
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
148. MES No 425939, Raj Ratan, S/o Sh Rajesh Babu working as Ref/Mech
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
149. MES No 424388, Padam Singh, S/o Late Natholi Singh working as
Elect (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.8
150. MES No 424226, Rajendra Kumar, S/o Late Harish Chandra working
as Painter (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
151. MES No 424415, Gaurav Kumar, S/o Sh Bhajan Lal working as Carpt
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
152. MES No 424412, Kamal Singh, S/o Sh Ram Kishan working as Carpt
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
153. MES No 424392, Neeraj Sharma, S/o Sh Surendra Kumar Sharma
working as Carpt (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
154. MES No 168061, Raguraj Singh, S/o Late Rajveer Singh working as
Carpt (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
155. MES No 424409, Vinay Sharma, S/o Sh SR Sharma working as Elect
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
156. MES No 425517, Nahar Singh, S/o Late Jasram working as Carpt (SK)
in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
157. MES No 425529, Damodar, S/o Late Ramswroop working as Carpt
(HS-I) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
158. MES No 425942, Narendra Kumar, S/o Sh Rakesh Kumar working as
Elect (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
159. MES No 424191, Noor Mohmmad, S/o Late Dani working as Elect
HS-II in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
160. MES No 423865, Dharmendra, S/o Sh Santosh working as Ref/Mech
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
161. MES No 424274, Mishrilal Kanaujiya, S/o Sh Hila Lal Kanaujiya
working as FGM (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
162. MES No 424227, Dinesh Kumar, S/o Late Sohan Lal working as FGM
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
163. MES No 424221, Shelesh Kumar, S/o Late Devi Singh working as
FGM (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
164. MES No 424417, Neeraj K Yadav, S/o Sh BR Yadav working as Mate
(SSK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
165. MES No 1497405W, Ram Prakash, S/o Sh Jay Prakash Sharma
working as Mate (SSK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
166. MES No 375715, Lovekesh Kumar, S/o Sh Satya Prakash working as
FGM (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
167. MES No 424418, Nek Singh Meena, S/o Sh Rambhajan Meena
working as Elect (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
168. MES No 423478, Bhim Singh, S/o Late Maharaj Singh working as
MCM FGM in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
169. MES No 424222, Bhim Singh, S/o Late Shiv Hari Singh working as
P/Ftr (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, in Agra.
170. MES No 424192, Maya Devi, W/o Brahm Kumar working as Painter
HS-II in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
171. MES No 424406, Jitendra Kumar, S/o Sh Ramji Lal working as Elect
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.9
172. MES No 425690, Vishnu Kumar Dharmesh, S/o Late Roshan Lal
working as MCM Elect in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra, Retd on
30.06.2023.
173. MES No 425697, Rameshwar, S/o Late Ram Prasad working as MCM
Elect in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra, Retd on 30.04.2023.
174. MES No 425707, Balbir Singh, S/o Late Deep Chand working as MCM
Elect in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra, Retd on 31.05.2023.
175. MES No 425527, Pramod Kumar, S/o Late Ram Swaroop Sharma
working as P/Ftr (SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra, Retd on 31.01.2023.
176. MES No 424407, Sachin Gautam, S/o Late Shambhu working as FGM
(SK) in GE (AF) Tech Area, Agra.
177. MES No 425577, Gopi Chand, S/o Sh Vedariya Ram working as MCM
Mason in GE (AF) Adm Area, Agra.
178. MES No 424386, Mamta, S/o Late Subedar Singh working as Painter
(SK) in GE (AF) Adm Area, Agra.
179. MES No 424382, Gajendra Singh, Amar Singh working as FGM (SK) in
GE (AF) Adm Area, Agra.
180. MES No 424384, Sonu, Omkar Singh FGM (SK) in GE (AF) Adm Area,
Agra.
181. MES No 424193, Mohan Singh, Late Tathi Lal Mason (SK) in GE (AF)
Adm Area, Agra.
182. MES No 421870, Om Prakash, S/o Late Ram Khilona working as Elect
HS-II in GE (W) Mathura.
183. MES No 424114, Rajender Singh, S/o Sh Mohan Singh working as
MCM Elect in GE (W) Mathura.
184. MES No 15369993A, Ambrish Kumar Sharma, S/o Sh Sita Ram
Sharma working as Mate (SSK) in GE (W) Mathura.
185. MES No 1578568K, Prem Pal, S/o Late Chet Ram working as Carpt
(SK) in GE (W) Mathura.
186. MES No 428166, Rajender Singh, S/o Sh Gulab Singh working as
MCM FGM in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.12.2019.
187. MES No 425687, Tej Singh, S/o Late Gopi Ram working as MCM FGM
in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 30.09.2023
188. MES No 484958, Narain Dass Gaur, S/o Late Jagannath Prasad
working as MCM FGM in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 30.06.2024.
189. MES No 507344, Shyam Babu, S/o Late Ram Ji Lal working as MCM
FGM in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.12.2020.
190. MES No 425395, Amarjit Singh, S/o Late Nathi Ram working as MCM
FGM in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.07.2023.
191. MES No 196304, Khajan Singh, S/o Sh Ram Gopal Sharma working as
Elect HS-II in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.03.2024.
192. MES No 470187, Sultan Ahmed, S/o Late Nizamuddin working as
P/Ftr (HS-I) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.07.2023.
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.10
193. MES No 485221, Hira Lal, S/o Sh Rati Ram working as Ref/Mech
(HS-I) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 30.06.2020.
194. MES No 425558, Bhagwati Prasad, S/o Late Birval working as Elect
(HS-I) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.07.2023.
195. MES No 168589, Dalvir Singh, S/o Sh Rambhal Singh working as
P/Ftr (HS-II) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 30.12.2019.
196. MES No 425764, Khem Chand, S/o Sh Govinda Ram working as
Mason (HS-I) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.03.2020.
197. MES No 525806, Bhajji, S/o Sh Samanta working as Mason (HS-II) in
GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.03.2021.
198. MES No 448191, Inder Singh, S/o Sh Chinta Singh working as P/Ftr
(HS-I) in GE (W) Mathura. Retd on 31.07.2021.
199. Smt Hemlata W/o Late Purshottam Lal Sharma, (MES No 167689),
D.O.B-04.01.1963, Ref/Mech (HS-I) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on
31.01.2023 & Expired on 24.07.2024
200. MES No 428142, Bhagwan Singh, S/o Late Lala Ram working as
Mason (SK) in GE (W) Mathura, Retd on 31.01.2018.
201. MES No 425737, Vipin Kumar, S/o Sh Banwari Lal working as MCM
Mason in GE (E) Mathura.
202. MES No 425553, Hari Singh, S/o Sh Bhoori Singh working as MCM
P/Ftr in GE (E) Mathura, Retd on 31.10.2022.
203. MES No 425585, Charan Das, S/o Sh Budh Sen working as MCM
P/Ftr in GE (E) Mathura, Retd on 30.11.2022.
...........Applicants
By Advocates: Shri M.K. Upadhyay
Shri Sachin Upadhyay
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary to Govt. of India, Ministry of
Defence, New Delhi-110011. (Email: [email protected]).
2. HQ Engineer-in-Chief, Ministry of Defence, Kashmir House,
Rajaji Marg, Army HQ, New Delhi-110001 (Email
[email protected])
3. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, C/o 56 APO.
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Lucknow Zone, Lucknow
5. HQ, Commander Works Engineer, 112 Taj Road, Agra Cantt
6. Controller of Defence Accounts, Meerut Cantt, Meerut.
........... Respondents
By Advocate: Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan
SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
Page No.11
ORDER
Heard M.K. Upadhyay alongwith Shri Sachin Upadhyay, learned counsel for the applicants and Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan, learned Sr. Standing Counsel, who has accepted notice on behalf of the respondents, are present.
2. Although the matter has been listed under the head of 'Fresh Admission' the same is heard and decided today itself with the consent of learned counsels appearing for both parties.
3. By way of the instant original application filed under section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act 1985, the applicants have prayed for a direction to the respondents to pay dress allowance w.e.f. 01.07.2017 in terms of the O.M dated 31.08.2017 issued by the Department of Personnel & Training and 02.08.2017 issued by the Ministry of Finance, Department of Expenditure, New Delhi along with arrears and admissible interest.
4. In support of the claim of the applicants, the learned counsel for the applicant cited the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 1228/2019 - MES No. 372437, Gurmit Singh & others Vs. Union of India & Ors wherein the applicants were held entitled for dress allowance pursuant to the aforesaid O.Ms dated 31.08.2017 and 02.08.2017. Learned counsel for the applicants also contended that for redressal of the aforesaid grievance, a letter dated 23.01.2023 (Annexure A-6 of the OA) has already been written to the HQ, Commander Works Engineer, 112 Taj Road, Agra Cantt (Respondent No. 5) by Shri Sanjay, General Secretary Military Engineering Services Karamchari Sangh, Recognized By Bhartiya Pratirakasha Majdoor Sangh and Bhartiya Mazdoor Sangh, registered under Trade Union Act XVI of 1926 (Applicant No. 1) followed by reminder dated 16.08.2024 and 31.08.2024 signed by all the applicants and they will be satisfied if a direction is given to the Respondent No. 5 to decide their claim in the light of the order dated SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA Page No.12 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 1228/2019 (Supra).
5. On the other hand, Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan, learned counsel for the respondents states that no such direction can be given at this stage.
6. However, having regard to the innocuous prayer made by the learned counsel for the applicants, the OA is disposed of with direction to the HQ, Commander Works Engineer, 112 Taj Road, Agra Cantt (Respondent No. 5) to consider the claim of the applicants in the light of the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 1228/2019 (Supra) and pass a reasoned and speaking order within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. The applicants are directed to file a copy of the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 1228/2019 as well as O.M dated 31.08.2017 and 02.08.2017 along with certified copy of this order before the respondent no. 5. A copy of the reasoned and speaking order shall be communicated to the applicants forthwith.
7. With the above direction, the O.A is disposed of.
8. There shall be no order as to costs.
All pending M.As, if any, shall be treated as disposed of. The registry will take appropriate action in this regard for removing the M.As.
(Justice Rajiv Joshi) Member (J) Sushil SUSHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA