State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner ( ... vs Shri Kalubhai Chaganbhai Raval on 16 June, 2009
=>»z.ua§ «gm Fa.cu¢.s3. afizzm, ~=g=a'2m. mm, zmaxma wflés. vishauoj wcna -*~**"""*:--» €i=2%M'aa<«z x€::a"1zra $5 siimvm $:7£¥tzef'H'1as 'si:.t1'7£:.-?; £4: :r>i1a"i~1v§£*»am <«1;€<1.1~z;{'~'a{%1 zvm, 'JSv:2m,Té§: aéa W11, ésuzm. 27:5; wtetctta.
$.'3z<3L~we.
fétggiz.
hevfmva : vii acaaggaua? em-t<>u€>' wzza 1$:,1a1.::€trfljg$aa,aa.,§.1::t»::, E%.v?u:. .5321». $3 °a'13?a..*<»u.gg~st, §{%ii.i§5i3t all <>aT§..2?1'<*mE'z.'-ail, ikvai, %?2.t':.é..+a azé 23zs<5Ez3«a {3':,§?~§l*'!>"é£ :i?.3' HERRR 2«'m":3«a;. : : $519" &.a3":.meg @511 (:s£1_5§i.=%>;.=«>gg§v*sL, ffiaumaz ilwre. nzzaa } =1. '2-{'~fl*-T.-i.*1.l a»'wi1aL-+. :t>'si£¢:§= 2»;-T5; '~£.%23t~'$£3;l M1 a»a,v-{lea arm-:=.~'1 §;1Lr»v;«iI ME f3.<4J:3, gécu Hi"-'3t waazsfz-:'i. i5trL«{i'q':1 an 3-*«tE"%'~i"L §«u.-:x=af1 mi €1=u'-ti éeuiv'; #3:.
= szfiaxa «i.=a;\t.=a;'ae Cm. *<zmea<uz. aw. was «am Fi<1R*§l %'a.2?a.
».-u.3~:>,-'«:;'oa~t: 2%' viii'; 5%. gm 3% *3 =:'E=u,%:1~i1 $¢fi*w.«. mm: @352 .:s»=2.<u=~d.. Mai sir.
:a:.:Ht<=uuu-7:. met'! °.=:s.2uom=-xi «*»-z\.%1~£§ 3 83:3: aéiqzsffi aim zaii €329; r4az.:»;-uw»s.::«1z»t1V<'3:m.z =»w«§'a Qmvfl mil cm atewfi ail 5&3 wt au.«:é1 rilswll gm. 3. €L:z»Ea«'1 naféimi <12. astvtz tlwarvu 9,3. amen ex': c':a<<a--£1a $1-i --::2'iq.;s?s3: gt.::t;,:3c:2e3;*~»» 333:.
=a;m=u<faz>?~'. $€i3«;.t%l'13z §ss's g.-23 23»: :a>{uru»'=si'l avtii uistts aL8:z<fi'i svueil 2»:1:=2"=.m2iL~i 281a. nvtiiu :u.21~u riuma 112 §;_I,.\»1-:;«<::s<:»,-'~« 33%.
axuzqzmfiz zséiaa -gaqsaii qua Vs iiéav-."£»'s. 4&1 gsfica "y..'£E,'i7H.§'¥- :;='3a.<:.=§v:{'r. «mo: *1; am: czwmz 2.1 main ggcil M151.
«a-=1't=~ue'i-u awuvu ;,,m*zm:«:,'~- cm: *-l.{3':!."i§s'3t'fLi~tE. 3,1,3'; aim gaze: 3,1.w»3§7§§»-- vi: 2um<u<:u=?: emwflazi aflfica «fit 9: 'u:<:a 2&1 uiazvvi <12. a£--.1*t3.':*~{L=$*uE~.?: aizsiiu an %tB(l=u°'a1 :<..rv.ms.15't =:ui'2..
2<u'*~:,1rsw:u ssimafiik 3,_1.3:::oc:;'~ '*i<"3**£t'§§s<3I34VFe'»t1'~Li*§t."
(3% :fm gsmii ~tl¥.¥;"d 2238 afitxzaw: =eew;;<mu$t ezavfil era erwfirez amsa .=s75;<~: 23;. '
3. «Mes,-uaé s-,'-aituw. i-ya eiasmtuzz «EN 39191 $.51 ufll EiP4.L'=lLifli ci'~'.T': wk, 'wfisw emuqa-zm szalqxz.-tz gm sxilntéi «-éia. €13-L-"i. at'; was? simtél. 33:1'; 3.-i*>i1*1*4.m5i macia $73.
'if. {=€iu.1e.vu*.wT: Eva =3u~$L Es, 5'-:'¥2+aei't avail. smazz ml}: °3iet$.::a Emfizca *eS--s;%;>:i.2§=¢i «:u...Iz,.-'%,.-"'ae efl. m.e,!ao;'"<:<< giii avail aimtal sR"{§ '11-sii 32¢: €511 wk akusiasgim '%€¥.¢iiévE sis mu '*.(:'."-R am '#1 aliuefmaz %ii1~2{1 ilram %§'..=+; "1i:"$>'i 2&3:
ma ??m1@L'x:3:»§ '5ir'il'vi.~ z':'.:°mz week: «£151 7*';I.5sl'§"';?; vi. 1>LtdL£*i."3'i',"3'.Vi'%<33§\Si(:ifl amt tvtvlai M31 §t+;'§'w:21 "E:'1<i'~ik<3t¥3 1312 23J§.3i.= 2.-gmicwru '°4=£l€i Emvu £1'-*1'H'1 smm Wei}. $€1<:.t§.'lv{¥ «kg 2'1 3-=.'t; M: Ma <»i.'=t en? °mL :;oo:<~:~.r::a:wa4.i sziuzaizi xfssfisra wit arm §3'«{L$'<{L a?1=i we 'vL*iil3l'1d.§2L$i12{!.*iifiil'31i"{1i7i ma mfiea. zztmzuuxzelt :it."W.;"tC3,s'Q3'ei1. $1": §t.v'4;v€~?:''»3'.<''"*''i'3.» 3;: $3§Hi'€3vit w,um'«~Li. wu szfirez. a'$t2s.1§§1vu. {ski ~ji.'i<'::-{L [>Lsv:=z so {§%.q.2mi. sqctzai aazéieia eaéi. <*£.R*:u?~. :;oaz'«-zaomi 3,mx<>g'-ev=:"iaL1a'E-1:1>u.c:.1=>1ivm a:suvJ.=s.1€1<:--u =<»¢v'; zsmzeiiit iuiusl aw zvmm ssméi $'~*fi=;.92"z%3't eéleii M vi.'t<: Mai, r::.=m,='z';:ao<:ravu SW £§33£l€-3:111-11<iPti g:..>ro,3oe;'- =~2.»;=u >.-m<:w.i %ru,<?m. :~1s2m2"t am': =;g.a:-resasw azluzsiiéz aim; *i»'5}.>:£l<=¥.'§€LLB'1=t3..%t1'i£<2_i<*1i3t 6+1 ::.=§=:zm .a3x;€1. ai::*2.u?: °l&:~':3 sii %<:<:<: gift mania «mil 'M1 .sm<;ru-{i am am mrla *i8iL 'i'-ig 2».-1 =a,»:::;x'-«<:xm'Zi *é?sa:zf3-a~i1 «aha (mail zizzm °t,{:{:"i §?=i'L wt. am: $~"».:.51&t. gm; mufi 2211:}. 9. M 21?:
.5 wen. £1. =u:r::: ayiivtl am 92': ::i2s=m+'a. mu 9's7t_£53.@. 3 3: mu. as=:°L=~u§1¥i ggaqqlni. waa -aa"z M1 s:-"€i>~us~."l*-s?'a H£?5.--'itislt xii %:g=~:=.'Ri1 wee §%iix<fi 5:'-{id z:i'~'%LE.t.?i 33'i""ii"'i.\ 3,t.<1<1 ::1u:,=*~ =<--z+'s; mafia zrwmx ;;1...*~mo<:§~ iiw gea ggwee-35" M: aim awe' mil fimaqx aaii fésaslfriin --'3,é%€1 '+113,' is-z'1=v:zmr v.-a;sl'mv{'z wt 1'-'mq~:u°»tv': "E: 921% an muqtvzi anal 1&1 mu aim :3 Peru 9% <1; am <2z.1=*::"?:tr1cm 2»;-E "Emails zmavu §gt.\z.<>,<3<>0,-*« wk sziqza 1»a=E~u% gz.'ecs,»;x:2c2g'-«-11 aw, aim"; r:::'izu.a was .a=ZeG..
'4. azazqztaxii ~+':,<u.vu 2¢<a.;v>w.i §;ww'i: 111:1': rmzq <:£"L¥3.<a '99 E, 2&1 *v:;::3--e:reil ::s2'ttu.e."t =3' £m=z.mi -z':.a£1 aw xérit r'w?I»i H1335 am;-it wt mu }s=.1<3.:~; -1<~>'Z7. 2:15}. eimtvfi mii fimaélsfiaa ti1..£:.sa. =21?! :{1:?zei1~t'1m:2+. milcilzm =3Lss.=; ace:-rii a'r,é.Nm=3($1) 4151 aztisuefi. m:~.°. 32621111 =:u_€t<»s, 23>. Hiuxélii $1 we. ~iL%A$.%<.i. °'2i"~'f.i wia «it E': :*a;.mu-xi. mafia :3: 2x9: ::iv.~m ~:1:.$a.'1 *5'; $1.55 2m "Pit =*.§:.s{'i *1 asfm {E1 E7: s-:»e;--«-»s:{v:?x.)«z'£ smaii 2.1 313i mu ma :<€1tua'i3i 3541 QLER-1..
E. <zz"ieu€i2?«.. rimm =§t°3uS«~wxi. ailuczacia um?s.s:Zl Emvzz. vZl.=§tssa.vi': wxvu
-'§zs;{2-[e as-{:1 Eiw emu stzsaii mu z»%t~'=1..<2;miMa;3ia 22:3: kaiaivu zrxtzfifii 'guru 13 gm; wau€:;<'«; 2213?. s2'1%1:%«.,*1i3ii3'4t§gw*-t+{\ mi': rmsfl zété 53*.
e. 2?v?a:.c~;v:;~e.: qsla all =3'm.£z..<xe; I-«A. aazwgluzvza-3; eziuutaquii mrfia «.2. ssfiureti :§.q:1a».»: §=-Elm %3*$%=,§L3mi, <u..a;'2_,=\as 9:51 <1t.t;"i<::;'<:e gffl say-«ii sxiezzzfi M33; -:'=.s€=. 312:: cm are-1 e*3'iw:€:§m x€:cfl.s,v2V 535 zébi ac-we ml. iii '<'RWE§1&'3a5 éviidi >'3.«sarm ma ~1«::m M, ems: 2?nwé11-33:2 *3:-aim zwu. ace.-u «£1531 ikstfire vi. mu v1'..%"z.°7;r.\4,:>.c~:s;:s><i: wit £1 a={<I>1 siE:?;i'~E. aqua >»u.3Lez "'l'¢fl. zyimélil vfizxziniul 23;; am -tram aoozm-aecnmi z="r»i -€..a<: tam *~il.:Si.£.s.«Zi EH C3'~U.&<£i mé
-=>:v~=.*s'iA s:'3.<--i1 2:191 tii..'%'i§"iOfO?f*tl ivy '§'_,,l_."l$~'3't7'a;¢*'*~$'~E;'»l"1.i§;§.a gaqqmi w.i?¢c«u. iooxmzezmuxi :«:a't=v.§fl,=§: 3&3' :11"-:'l'Q $95. vim: Earfl ifiméii. mafia rzefi Sufi <:ii.'i'{f1G;r'Q3'*t£ 21*: 8%' W: asqzfi Em e *is§i'--%i '~&§E gavqtfi 89;. vuvtcmgi Mtrig 4 »$.2fl.. dzgzuzia ¢:»,'1zus."t:31 \«i':+.~tav{'¢ azmzmi agget zzafém $9 3:, 2<;m*~cw{i ofi=v:s.
¢ \ w.:e.2ra;'~« W531 a2'1e=ua'1vu \«fi.¥»£{.n aksxisvani W ,a2,<».mi 32l¥.33J3.L §x.2:arr.s,=*«~ (Ks;
$*»;'1au€':-u zeuuem mu .wu=»+;i 1*il3{€fl~::E wax fitétomii rig: am. $14 Em mi} mm €11-1 v:.%fi., am: 3: ssfuuelg gag; 934.. egg; *5 E, 2::2<;~x~2.ooqaiL «e: €'t:>€1:§i 521*? rim: 915.6. Elsa %C2<."é':~*wE<3~t3% ggiii *3: '«'=.==§-5 £:1'.ClL?=t§;3>li53;{:§ E: fir:{ta.s:£1 gzqmi w,<g «six». Pm RH1 2:55:24 Pm ~1,2fi M mmqzsrxuiz utmzvu mtani °mt?='.et 5 2:, :z~:>o%s--;1.s::~cau>zi s3m:i ggawzrfl g5L.nxe3e;«-vt1 smvai. zzuéaeii 2:131 emu-x.s.s zacsssumaéooe 'ii 3}..?Q3Q\3§~ ma <tz.<:,r%§¥<><>a-1.: aim: _75L'tE,'§.2§;'~-{Q fir gaqlfii sum': asutlee. Q $1 xaitmz $::'i*w':il araaarwonmi M vi.*'*IL* ¢'t3L~:?{3. V:m'<'s. 9{=n,<zr4.L 233212 am E33 =<.mq.m': 2-uét, swat 3 5=:'iim':iivil =m*2~, «L153 3%! in? am" {:2 2% $2'i%(.t€E\£td1vii'Iii.i§z.$.-{i t-.3» Gum; essgaw. 2a='a.a sis mi ezsm am; ~*%-§u»3:<<s. 2% 3:, eizamit .s?zaS :'»_.s.<u mt, aiza «=23 33:1 :--;2'mz«l1 $23' 2% rimfl veg'! B: ulna emit. sis aim: 2:1: :3-Fa 15*: van: rt :2: =.s»3.'1tuzii nix': rimveii 21% wgél i'w:ct<u «get; mu: 1&1 aél atam «ii. Mg tag :17': =;i=:m azaail 5&3' 'W3. -1 aim §°.§'+i 9m=t=:u siimszi 2-gm 4 am, "nix; €13: u'L=é?:§s.-it. 3.3»: itzqrw 3*-Eizuél exaam en»; swim quid: 2-:§r+.~{i 2:3,: Q33, um viii {mail 51 aim «mt P1211 2r.:>m*>--c:<wi wui gz.ueae.:'-{i gswaii .$;'~2atmi =2u€-i~T:v:'t. éz mt": gz.m,a::>~§§-- #2131. gi..=i§*UL=L§-~-{L nu man wit fifial érfi, 3131 v: aewil &¥1tua"{«'1 gm. 3;L.u.e_,1m:;'»-- fitaiewil wizvt.-1 £3: 31 {am 10¢'.§»'3'-?>_{):3'{Ei'i ééiuzéi cw: 3:¥,i'¥.9t'5£l 6:3?-13?. am 939. stints}-R gut. wt mil azitrst s;.a~.¢ <>t:.L=s fa,-man sssaaza {9 3.231 Cfieimzeii i>:_t'~v=s.L»'-si cxuria an {aura asnfiuzéi am: Q'-mcu ems. am I§I.N.= MA. cauvanfi. ism a:3zu;:i+'; 2>tm<:u3<ti Qruélt-R v; éza 6:, sfltuéi 3+. am {am 3~':tZ<§. 3: 3_g.uez*:u.«.,.~'-~ ~:2u='a* »'wLa.ru «»§.§s%.§uiFL :3 £223'; ha 23», itwlmzit aaxuqzui :»ué1»:+'=1 sim wax-~ou mi! 3&1 'mm': % '1~LW'vfi ntauzl sauna"; wit "Cs 3:, cruwi am-til aazefl =:?u§l =';'(* 5 revszcxmi amt} <1': 1;: asm, «await =z=.2mfl a»:.:.'1~3. mama E; w»: ='e:szca.ru. gym 2?; Rafi hilikt at-iym: wg'-'a Sm «us: 2§1*»'S 4121 ism gem a2<m:imz.51s3s. ' (~13 avuila aim: €32. s~2r.mi2:u.5i {:3 EL. §1¢.'=~x.~u gsvmi :§'%€.=:.Q 5%": £21 g.%'»~'-*1. we. .*:5:;¢L¥.7-'ii Mac'; w:w~r'>_mu M1 g;m~:~,2s=.z,-*'- fémwil 4>:tm<:mi mam aim 'Canaan. 2:24; am :?=.vi~*1.=2~ <><.'<ivt:, £3.33 aeliwzi *4;E§H1 cuimz-ii 2.2 as: om: jv3:.\:.ef»r:a<:,.="~ dzilfi §_§£'<£'7£§'"Li 32§,E.3t<":t .-3 aailw, ggbfi rzmaeii. =.s=m1 ~--'2as3am'i aii $v§Latv§i~% €'2u.21,eu.L awe-1 ma vj~;.sL=:=;u»zi mafia <m=2.r-iE am we 32'}. e>u.§i<«{i «mi =2: wt am 9. g,--3==ic£1'%=<;34, cl we. 1:: age our-2: mé: ggfl-lE~,'a.'%f:;'-» ggsaqtni mafia 8;
czfliwafi am -:*-i§§."3:l :'sa.'1aua't%. 3.'s<1<1.1-{E %£3ti?-iLfi3,t5-i gait s~2r:a.mi 242.51 (3) %L81i¢w!'%.t?;{ ::~"flm;.'i.-': 2:519: wxzviafis ma. 2:t~'Tt §=?f'i§=u;xa 'bi~°§.vil j»5:.*«.<>rso;"»{a>iE*;
gtihu 5t I§.'~?£'R 3,21} ggsqqiwia gm azczmi s:»u5¢ §. w;e.r»u mi =>i~*1 §uf§' asacmi camel: 'd%fi.
Mi'? .5 &_.é'<:>a:«u gasaéa t_~y;~:'--{E 2>1r«,:.<w~zi. °>::a{;R 3%..
~*;wm.r.\"_fi_ ,,____' ," _ V {":z;2.€iZ.%«a§%'$ 3 W _ {Gi2<'i,{33.!t5 '-Enzih l'*s%ilEi!§L:); 3711:.-{Q ' Qlsw '