Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

Ramakrishna vs Ayesha Mohiddin on 25 March, 2011

Author: Jawad Rahim

Bench: Jawad Rahim

aha setéiicmer §':ere§§";_, ézavérzg maaséreé it by as: iraésantagm sf gaie mm 2;S.é.2QQ2 fmm mar gramimsiher-Léfigamma. Eéérsgg %:§':e:*2 gm flag sass €X€%"'€%S§E'%g right 3% mz%;§%&;r$§f:§'§_. ' $1; xfzacaydéng %;{;: her; gaiétémey was i;*:':fu%f:?;té3;'_§fV~1';3§%3~~. ienazsi in tém wemégag in cguegiégn E3! her_;3.:',é§:%~$:V;ie%${$@_r~§fi"4' ' Eétéa an a msnthéy refit @f éemséi 0? Rs,38,,@s9;~ reV.:E;s_;j;é5;%b§'aé._"'@n :e:~§+r;§.';§a%:§s§:::

iananayx fig is a zjhmnéc de?a::j'§i:é_:Mr' in §é'yrr:i5'a'::§f efifent $33 hafi faéien in arraarg, %£%;"€"-E%"2ad_"'§mV;t:AQ;:a%£é§~§%.e§ §he a"m9u§:i. 5} She '?%.é§'§§"§€§' ave;fi:féd_t§9%éVE§§;:E§'i§.§;;i:;:;[_'é:;f..En a éE§a@§Qa%:€§ CfifldEtE€$'é"'s"¥'*EE'%:€55V§"§;§$'g§f:,; :'*:j'{;ef::véV%:aiffe"'é»es$eEétE0r: am ghe énienas ii; jéér neegé, She {ms ssught £33 avmtiim z2%*'M%'§5%s .s;$V§§;§'{;'§?_v:§~§:_':;'se§ 9;' Sgcéiarz 2'?(2} sf {ha fiat, .4,1,,€$;.3i §}§v'§Ei§%.¢.,7§E5E€.?%"VEfifiififié evéafiém &::€é@:2 éaéfiaiég: §%:*:3:ir"ag »3;};':a§Vre%a:'%:Aé:*:$«%':';v;:f; af éanfiiaraf aszzé terzawi §Ei*iix'*a§§3§F'§ her 3% §"':*?§3.'§"~.~%,'j':§§"'é§ E'-§Ek .i£§f§i=§§ raga??? gfieaéféaaéiy awrreé fie imam; $§"E§'y* ~V :§s:§4?csr'j=£é::§.i5c§ be tééa mama? sf ihe §E'€f§§§3*§"§'§§ E5: iguegiégr: %"~£?'i§ ig.,%§a':;§-._uirzéamfieé him Er: im ggéméfig, L§§"E§5§'E'im3 §"§§§ A':;ja:é'-g9as:E:§§ $23': ésém :0 §@EZ% iééé §I%i'{2§€¥'§'g' if} gzsegiéan $5}? a " "';;%a§:;a§§% samségggzésgz Q? rm rggam &%§\°'&\"<*2?s€*;%?é.$&€§{<<§§£%2é&<w%§§s%,?§:<.'\\\\\*m .
gf §;};z; V n if " 5.?
g} Ya da 3:2, ieamed §;r£aE guége has canducieé an &§°'%£§é§%E""';;' an we giga 9? the imam: in $25 a§g§§£3%%@r2 E.§F'%§GE"
§&§t%ez'*: =4i3{2j: 0? am fiat. Bath gédeg §'%5"v'iE éefi §sré;§é';fi:::§; §=:::uEa:r' and fi€}CL£E'§"E€§'§E§§";.2', zfmaigsséng £5; Eea:'§zed..~§:'.i§§,§;2;*f§:'::_é._ W $2' ~W%.W "°*'"O.%f% sgénefi respanéérzé-Eandiasfig evifienaa c:;six;2;e&'g"g§§'3;5':A§f:'::=.4§Eéa§ am evidence 3? Em petiié§§':§r--»tef§an§: as"*§d"«f:§21Q§;;._.: éamé 2@.é.2@:8 é§§§":"§ESS&{'§ 'fig a§g:;«5§:§%:.té@n §:.:%sf§é'r '$&{".€§%{:+;r': '=. 43$} Q? 2339 fiat h} it ég :z':3'teria§ ~3:;:s :§§€é_'Aéfggzé?-%:Ah&reaV§4§Ae%% without Cmfiuctészg Iarsg furtiwar §:"":¢;:'s_i:"§;%"f<*,?r:a: {I}? the geiitiafi %*E§eé by%--t%'2§"'$;ré=§fié'f;;:<::3'§--:é}:;_iéarriadfgajége hag §3SS€fi the geaendvgrétégérwaséé"f§:_.S;.?;4{}T3T_:§"ifiiiaéwmg the getiiéan, dégeciémg Em :e:2an%iL§:._eA tag éx£§£te"e§.}§'nfi§r £§3u$§ {G} :2? §§£:§a:": 23(2) %§§,_3"'é':a%%:_%§vr;§i€? i§ agai-a§ie::% in %:§"2§§ reafégéenk &;e_g€";';'é'i._:<:€§e;r:;§a§ Q? the imgugneé sréezj. it §§ fi@i:§r;:%::% ._'§m;": g+2;vf%e",§z rajecaéng a§§2%§<::&§§@§": mags" §EE{i§§§'E é«3{2} fiéefi 'w?
B8 Sfiiiiifififif h9;:&i:':§ %:?2§3 §85§T§§ *é;:*%§§ Ezsége hag iakem

2.39;: §f§"%§§ age gag' yaggeé aha §I'§"'7§{3L}§§'%?r'F3§ gféar rgigrémg cage téza Wa53.##23§ :a:2'e:a€§w:»z2z4a Zr'. Thegefare, the cguestiasn Es, whether summary szdar sf €a;§'£i§fir: csufifi bé gagseé mafia: 5251.338 {0} 9?"

$EC?ZE§§"§; ?;"?{2} 0? :%":e As: if mg Qiea ragarémg %a::.*%<VV;:):§f__§L:.;V"a§ ¥'§§:3i§:§f'%S§'"}§§ sf éandééré aw tenant is re;'e€:i:eé_ 8; Necegsaréiy 'zghé §?§§GSEi§§F'{S® C8F':'%»'7&'7S'S;é"';€_i§:'é"7wijE-;?':V be €€S§€§ by 551% C@fiS§€€;"'€LjS G? the §r:z:;v%§§@T5fs:A9s é'f.f_:}":~éV";3 c:€§%v.E?}é:::§i2_A Qfifiiaijfi a zmxz---&5Dstam*"e C§au$é Er: sub?5.;eé::%Q{: «i:i}A..éj:;.f.._S§<§té<3E2 Z? and the right 02' éefenae en§r5§tafi Er: .S<§{it§::§;G{"e #1:; 3f=.!§"'E§C§§ emxésageg 'Ems: L "Eff, :I'??.:'r:g;ecifE:§s2 Eaénanig against e:zzE--§'%:%.§r";:{1};3i:§'=£V<}%:w§»f:'¥<2$ta%§:§%~r:g' anything ta {$73 :.:os:§r_aé*§._«V getvsliagnéefi-.V.\ $6: _' my gtiser Eaw QE' ::»f:z:%E:ra§*:3 é':a:% "@:§*<;§»§5:*"::i;r"(:fec?e§ 5%: the r&cav§rgs sf3<:é$$es3é.;er§--..§f_é::s__~;,?"g§re{*:*2%seS ghaéi be fiéaéfi by E?'-2 C.€.3us"'£*,, li'"}_%si"er:f_%~~éi:t Euége $3' §-i§g%': Cam'? in j'%v*a*§;e:_§r assffzimzé éabéizéré agaérsgi a tenanig, save a§g$';»:j§:.z§a?é:§«%.:2..:;.:;§--se£*:%ere{2}f' '::@s;:E§'§:@_ ééfiajji} Q? the fiat fig aim reievazéi whigh :3': 1% %'%':'.'§ 3't€$ '?jég2.§ ?m£efi:;:$ $3 '$9 faééwjeé by %:h& Qmzri: {2} _ ?zé£.:_.§?§i§§* '§'J§'%§s:f§"E §:"e;'u§§:::%a1§E3z a§fe~:::§$ any gargan '"--...@3E":a§§ be mafia $3; Em €s'Z}E£§"§:' zméar 'ma gig:
_.5wéf'.§'e::a:;%: géasmg him: a ;'&§3:2r:§§3%& Q§§{:ri:,:§2§?:'~' 5?' ghearsgérgg gaugg gggaérxgi {fig §§'"{§E%E" ggramgeé is be §?:3§E am? amégéi Efiég sfijeaiéeégf if gag, am?
,. ,«;;..
any tZ':?2f§C?€?'%C€ he may §§'(3€§{,§C€ fin gusaort Sf {ha same have gear: cangédered by tbs Cr;:;:*i:."' Thus Seaééan $2511} :3 €.:C2§'%gs"':.¥8:'2§ with Seczém 2:?{1f3 .23?-.:h€ £6231 feavérsg aw adage far fisubi that the :eg%3ia§§u%fé §j:§é'$V' :' M-
§i'iC{','3¥"§€}§"a§i§§ a giear £'"€E3S§€"§C'E§G§'§ in sub~5&r:":;"§_;ér2.j={.:i5{}kzff §€C5:ET0£'} 2?' 3:' {be AC3 tééai 3:129 §ra'e§fér"§ecsi;ee_;fr;%;*"f§::§:»*;é*:i;?"'. gf §3£%SSE.§SfQ!? 53%" any ;f?f€f'i"3§SE?§ shai§'«!3e'---aéadé 'E578 xi:-§;§',:r§, ' fligfrfci 55335? 52;" ffiigh C9s,;z'Z°'-v.,§§"%*~._Afaaréhui :2fAj§?:5?éV":V}éié:§'fc:zs:? V agafnsgr fire zmarsf sgzza as ;:>:':;;<€;:§9:':*'-a__ :;na'e :""'5:;;:§-gecéian 52;" "E"hes*ef§:'e; méegg §':*Q:.::*:§:.:_V¥:rjs%;§3'a§&»<§A En ciaugés {3} ie {5} §? $v;;b~~€€.u€?%@§%°5:E¢E "$éa:i:§"cm~-2:"? sf téw Em: am mafié @232, 9:53: 1:2?' ax»:':é;§i§;:;"§g ,;':aa+_E?:':§§té§€. 1,3. 5%-:2§aEe%.,{.=eé%23%é""%§ e::rr.::'§r eazéfiien améer ihege ~§§3:.g§é3;:_--S€£.f;A%3:": §2°':;a:é'"%%ie fiat furiher mianrfiaigea ma: e:r§;": L:;t;%:$;'.;**:@é;';~{:i§a";:§it ..%_§":;e:;ghz 5:': my 9? {he {}?"Qi,§F%§§ enagmgygiaé §s%:§_a€:§&$; ii} {Q} §f fiestém 2? {2} a? ifia Az:::;, 'saw grgfer "v_§§§?§€§§";§;?'§j£§§§$§§§§§9' §§f&€°§$ §i?§? yarfiesg gfrafi fig mafia ' §;2}5:§§;_$ afgggri gage? §§§§'§ fig? aasfffsaasf §§§f§?§§ §;§m 3 §"é:£§$§;§§§£ éfifififiésfigfy §§ $§msa:§§§§ aggggg §§§§§§§;§§ éfga §§$§%&°é?% A ggi, ..
Sactisrss 22(2), éZ(1} arefi £3 9? we act, aw §:a"2.;e is axamémé whether %:E'*;%$ mass? m ma Case 3:' 5.é$.i._;3iJ§¢§;£.L:"wV%:€::~;V. @493 fiwzn éaw gwwmétting grgni 0?' §asmr:éa«:f§z .{;a:<.§'Vi&r '9?1; %'zf§£"{§i'}f'£ gnaw" aiaugé {G} a? .§e:i.%'::%:*'é mi': _s9'§jé5:E?e;é' <35: tfia piea 9% the ies'*:a§':L Sh §é :*::_sé.>§z@§ ii:.§':_--s=%"f.a::t;é':.4"é-fifi C§§"C£EmSE&i"%CE3S iakm §§"§E§ ca;r:g>%.§é:jat§§n §y':hé§;£é=%;%t'"én the gaéé fiaaégégn, ii fig s;.<3.§:": ta'r'§;a;*r%:_}t1'~B?';a§zsEaE"as"2e:i" anétfier §a:es'§§::meé the sréer fl§f_j_'!e:x}§s:%§"Q%: agamgi imam unée: S&C'E§§G£'§_ (ff;_:'g2r;a£ '2f_§L'} .§f'ééfaé Eéamataka Rfifii éfiagtzimi fiaggig' ";4§§E,'1V'__{:'ég:1éa~§gc§"f%_ "':{'a:'.<,:.;s"sg $éi:'@%"§§ §§'t3§.,§E"E§S amayagsés "'2*;:~i~.3efi {W EC§§§Q'.»-"~,f§EE§ was guéstaééééai '§4:*,;f'i:;_'%é.€%':f:':§;§:3€":: {5} '{#§':a:*%.:_ "a:_;_'é£'in.=§t mzhsm ardar 5:21' €'v'§i'fi",ECifi ' unai"'-3$_}ri%V'au5ég {£1}, {3} ané zjj} Q?" Seciésa 22(1) wag paéééé; agsgéieci the game £{Z3§"'%i€§"§:i§§figT é: i':@ V'~%?fw;é'_%r1.a;:a§<a $193? C-i?2§7%:?G§ £u:%:, 3351; having '-:..v,:r;e:vé~%;:;"fmgeaiafi am %:?':& ggtéiisaer fiavérzg mi . '_§:4.;::;4::e:*: $$C€;'.";S $3 gmenscg ihé graiszézsfi 32:3 maxing 5:3: Ea:-izméeé the zaireggfinéémg garrjmgéans $52 the ;3.s*"a$%r:': §<3?fE8'€!:"é§r:5 Refit ,fa<::t, 1%??? Léféifiéi' ysséaiah eagésiissn wag gfiasgm, iéisa ;>e%é:é<:m rés:-Q: §'?£§'2:'§ 33%;': rrzaéniaériaié 352$? 6';-?I:"§€§f%"' of ¥';:'s.«'%C§§§fi :«::=::E$' E*'s§a:e*s §i1?%§?'i wstggssé, {*3} "?"§":e:~; gecsnfi grzsamci urged zaiagg, :.r+.:ét£";:;%€,:?.:_ énxrsmng aéauga {0} cu? {ha flaw éanfléaré asuésé mi haw gcught fer e*g.z"§'§r.*'t'§'Q'=ré."'§,';,'=«€__" -1- V aha imam: amdér that ciauae am 5;f'%°:g ':i§urt CO£i?G ram: ésave gaggefl' ?:;b;e~;>A»:v»r<:fer :mde;*'£:§=::*;§:3m.:'A. 2Z?{2} wiihzsut rsc<3»rd§m;;=__ 3 §Z83.fé§§§'*§f:E:§. Vf§r:S7é£<'_:§.__ on tfiaég égssage.
This gem": §"€§éf"I"é?"§§ ta Em §£{}'?_§;;§f§f{)C¥7}§€§!'§:§:V'§:;E"0'J%i§S§Qn§ in §@€'i;¥@:*s 2?{;':) <3? 3% ;~:é,_éi;;..en.§a€:mén%;,~.§;é';w Kamaiaka Rent flit'; :§%9; agénefi En §a§f§g'r'"ap%';v 12¢'; a;~',*L"~::;a""a1::-'..;e;V;.*:"

'.,;,§T£ée4%*?:.%.V1§S néé d§$g}'Qté'§§éa§"'i%:§ Q§'€S€f"¥§ As:-' é.g:g;:~1_5£ca.if;i_g"=..t@'-5€i~:§ Vpmmégeg in §:.:'s*:s':%.:{<:vé*:.~, §1<">§»"§1;F&'€vJf'§$V"$fl'F ighe amiy ether V..c;.g&§'?.:E_§r'i'-1:;,_s:=;éE§--»._V be 'Q~F'1i....V':E§';€ avaéiabie §§é:3T£'§3.é'§_§ as i";a7'e§...E_>§=;e:'--2 meaztfeé fig; {fig gariziiss-;s'e2%s:.<§"@v'§%';:%g%':-are E8: in; if there :5 E%€G*§€ ':3?'..§;s=%§s:-i&_§'ég«"e:*de§'s anger {he <:§@::fé:i:;3:3§*:r,"§§r2{g 'g}:f{:;v%3§e:2§ of Eng $s"eserz%:

_ §x§€§' _§'§:a:=..v':av%'::E§Q:": gaiiiém ééaving been é:<;*§§é".}¥°e.»'€§"'--%§?:é 'the E"$€:T%_§§?€€°'§"§€E"E§, 5?' Sage i-I';'.i§seq age W8§"§§ QCCi§§a§§€§E":i 9? the _ §£*E"§jZ§%i:.;é'§E§"$; wet: if ii ég mt énéésatafi, if _"z:ra§§'; E:.e j.$afeE%g éfiferreé that ii $3 ursfier 'W:%é_:c;:--..;ss'is:'é:r%§é0':':$ 2:2? $§€'¥:§§§'2 2?{2}{:} wizésfz £fi?'§"{Z*$QG§'§fi7E§ is 32% grgvégéema G? §€<,:i:'s:m "~--.;?:§.%:f:}{t;%2e} anger {he airs' éasci, in fat:
" _§?§§ §%"§%"§§§G§"§§ sf §E£;'i§€§§'3 21?'{2j:{;*f: 0? fésé fimgeni £5: we mi 5% rsgemug am gs gmcé: aa figééféfifj a Eanfiéaré §!Z%§:§~{§E%§ fm' @2.zé€%§:::::": Q? 5 ieszanz as': E%':& grmézéfifi 9% ggaraéngé L253 azzé <§£§:s§ai§::;a Tha maégsrfié £252 raiazg mg £'§$§?§3J mafia sat

3 mm far gagging an Gmer 0? evésgtéan .T améer Em gravigieng :3? §ec:%tm 2?:f2}{s1'}_;~~_ . af mg wager}: fiat %:%"*2<::ug§"; mi Ufiéfif a{i:.%:.r_' » @t§*:a:" gzmazégésrzf' ~ ' ' EVE??? mg Gégaragiaiésrg, the firs? §rs:_;ej'zfi tsazag'é*=;;>€--sf§~';*asE's~:**§V.", 3.6, Ragaméyzg 'fiche s.e;e§C@§':d'.jc:;;*§.;;r2é L:;*_<A;_';Aé:f: t§*:€'--.. tenant $234: the iandésré hax:i'r2.g""~::ot §§2'2i°=C3.§<fi'fi z:§3§{,'bS8 {0} cf $539 new ena€€m@:2E_,V:*'€Eze fi,%"§'€F_ €)f '€f«'éCiiS£"'§ 'uhdé?" that grzzvéséan wag mi @armi_$'s§8f-£3)'5'{%"s.E§;§"-v':v:>§::*j?: 9b$e:*ve§ :33 feéfews:

2:';§...i '7?"§iQ{§:§,§§A.__v€'i":«e'"Cfi%:.Ez"fi §§é me? have {}.§€5S§'§§ is «.§Cé:r_:%.i<«.§:r:te éihe grmsésiarsg sf %%%% ~Tv$T;e:c.tée::§:::;3 £2-it-he W&;=;~e:';i Ag: in the Eight ' af"'5'._-fh,e'=_ a«;:_p'?'§é¢a%*.%5_i:: made by ma . "rasgfiefs§'e.:f;i;--»~:é;:.a%:§:s, the resgondenb §§'f3aF§§$ ':'::a3:§»_'%«-3»E%:l%e:2fv:': mg mg: defemte that ?:--§'§ere is-_nGi._Vre'i«e%'§§s:ss%sé$ of "'§as*2d««Eeré" am ":e:'<t::":}§;*§%t:"'a§' between the gaiétéaners am $29 r5'e5g%s..{2.ne:§ent§, if 5 éefenae Q? ihig %*:a.i;2m;~:= and Seen €5§<€§"'§ up 5%' {ha Eanagéi avaabée ia make gem §"2E3 cage; than . '~..§&§§E;§F'.&E {G make gaeé §L£z.:'§""§ éesfgnce §§$% €ij<:>r§::i§z':;s€:e§ am %nde§%né§r:%; grauné £5?
' gééssségég an iéféfif :12? €%£E£:':§s;f':?"3 mg mg Cami éiflfiflf §e:%§a:: 2?{2}{§} $2' me ,fi4c.?::;
" ??'2;§::g%2 the '"E"r§a§ ijazm: %:§:§ €29? rgaarfigé 3 £a§§§§§'§€:5§ fififiifég Q5': éhég &S$8€E,, gxaaééfiaiéaa 5%' aha E'¥"§3i&§"%§§ 5;": yaceyé ézseéf %§"':§§€§§f§§ ihai fine ;*§§g:::s':fier%%:~ 3Z§§"%3fE§j§ %"v'€.}L§§{Z§ ééave guffgrgé am §:sé5:%a:': Qfdéf zméér é':'§":§§ §:m;%$§s;éz: $33? F335 ihé Traéi Ceurt *besi:0we{§ Eta a{%';&s';§£c2:*: m aspesi af 5% m&t%erf' '-
ii Laamaé €G:3%""i2&§ fa: iéfm §"§g§3U§'§;i§§?7:'5fi:%.§§?%fi§C;?'E{jV_ "

maid rm': gaént 54;: fmm Ehe' §é:é':;§«._éeci-5§€;.§f:«_::::; "s;:g?« Gbservaiém: Sf thig isuri {baa 'gua€mé3':*y"' Gr:i:e_:% :.'sf ';9vé'r:i:%0s*i'--.. cauéfi be gagged agaéast thé hég defame regaréing §ac%<'.g§ ja3§a5'§" §':;"?;%§§:i:VVE:'v§;~:7z;_sE*':§;;;;; ;ia§E' §:E"23i: Ems wart mg abgerveé J éa fauiéfi at ggaragragh vg:_;§;§Vj?€VV'V%2ag ebgerzseé, £5 éefersce ':.}§§"§ E;~§§%s."..VF"F:§f§_'§:.§:.V§:_"e; "*b:e°e:V_z': 'v%f:a§«:e7§*'e and 12% tenanf: E3 una§E£f:'<s-<'Tr%e§§<j;E ?';--E~§"*<'§sé;""géwén faéiure ta {EfEa§<§ ggm' gash d§--§g;~'::e'3§$'c{ '::<;ér:s"$é':A:;§§§ an énéegendezzi grgzzné fgr gagging as'?-:;%a§.§:* §,:_fA:.fa%§'a:.%:-§Lé:3{2 umjes' Sectéar: ;:''.?{2) Q? the A ;%£:_~'~'.,§tV $f=:'<;>;;§é :9%é'aa.:":....€:E';3£: zfaéfigre 3:': we 955°: 9? 'me 'zermaé %C}:V '§'TEg3§<a§vV';3,?€:}':Z?.s§Sufi? ééfagfise smégtémieg an Efééfigfiéfiéfifié _r*z::u'r3x§ fcér-"--%f,f;:*'§é:2;*§:'z his gvéaiéaa mafia: cgéaage 52:3, bu? ifiés __ x X g c$s;ré'§éaé,:2§: $§s'n§e<:E Eéégt gummgsfig Grée: £2? i€V§Ci§{§E": maéé figié éiafzifififié figgféaséng him :3? %:%'2& §:*::§&fas.=$§bé'& :"§g§';: :3? &[.%§§m§ §:'«$ar:§€g%' flfiiiism 42:3} gf me mi, éirastefi €33 daaéde 13% sage after givéag G§QG%""'E€£5"E§'E'y' to ihe ieaaai gg emsésggeé Eififief §eci:%sn fisZ{i} fif the flag: 335 éissszge C5? 8% game 9:"; mew: is": accgrdaniaz wifi": éaw';T' "*.T S5}/'é 'gig,/v§§1* M < \ mmwwm