Gauhati High Court
Page No.# 1/12 vs Sh. H. Lalfakzuala And 26 Ors on 19 April, 2021
Author: K.R. Surana
Bench: Kalyan Rai Surana, Soumitra Saikia
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010051592021
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/104/2021
THE STATE OF MIZORAM AND 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF MIZORAM,
AIZAWL, MIZORAM- 796001.
2: THE COMMISSIONER/SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM
PWD
AIZAWL
MIZORAM
PIN- 796001.
3: THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM
DP AND AR
(GSW)
AIZAWL
MIZORAM
PIN- 796001.
4: THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF
PWD
GOVERNMENT OF MIZORAM
AIZAWL
PIN- 796001
VERSUS
SH. H. LALFAKZUALA AND 26 ORS.
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO, PWD, KOLASIB DIVISION, KOLASIB.
2:SH. JOHN LALCHHUANAWMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KAWRTHAH DIVISION
KAWRTHAH
Page No.# 2/12
MAMIT DISTRICT.
3:SH. C. LALENKAWLA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION III
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
4:SH. R. LALRINMAWIA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PIU WORLD BANK
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
5:SH. ZODINGLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
HMUIFANG DIVISION
AIBAWK
AIZAWL DISTRICT.
6:SH. C. LALTHANGVELA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-I
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
7:SH. LALNUNTLUANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KHAWZAWL DIVISION
KHAWZAWL
CHAMPHAI DISTRICT.
8:SH. C. LALCHHUANAWMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NEC DIVISION
CHAMPHAI.
9:SH. DENGCHUNGNUNGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION II
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
Page No.# 3/12
AIZAWL.
10:SH. R. LALPEKA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
E IN C OFFICE PWD
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
11:SMT. MALSAWMDAWGLIANI
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL BUILDING DIVISION
TREASURY SQUARE.
12:SMT. VANSANGPUII
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PIU WORLD BANK
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
13:SMT. LALBIAKSANGI
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PROJECT DIVISION-III
BABUTLANG
AIZAWL.
14:SH. P. C. DAVID LALRINLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
CHIEF ENGINEER ROADS OFFICE
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
15:SH. LALREMRUATA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
HMUIFANG DIVISION
AIBAWK
AIZAWL DISTRICT.
16:SH. R. LALDUHTHLANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF TRANSPORT
CHALTLANG
Page No.# 4/12
AIZAWL.
17:SH. LALNGAISANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PROJECT DIVISION II
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
18:SH. LALRAMSANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KOLASIB DIVISION
KOLASIB DISTRICT.
19:SH. LALBIAKNUNGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PROJECT DIVISION II
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
20:SH. LALCHHUANAWMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
ROAD FUN BOARD
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
21:SH. ZOHMINGLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD NORTH DIVISION
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
22:SH. P.C. ZOKHUMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD SOUTH DIVISION
TREASURY SQUARE
AIZAWL.
23:SH. LALDUHZUALA SAILO
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
SERCHHIP DIVISION
SERCHHIP DISTRICT.
Page No.# 5/12
24:SH. K. LUAIMINTHANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
QUALITY CONTROL DIVISION
ZUANGTUI
AIZAWL.
25:SH. SAMUEL ZOTHANKHUMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD SOUTH DIVISION
TREASURY SQUARE
AIZAWL.
26:SH. JIMMY VANLALSIAMA BAWIKHAR
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-II
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
27:SH. DAVID LALTANPUIA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD SOUTH DIVISON
TREASURY SQUARE
AIZAWL
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR A D CHOUDHURY
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. K N CHOUDHURY
Linked Case : WA/106/2021
THE STATE OF MIZORAM AND 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF MIZORAM
AIZAWL
MIZORAM- 796001.
2: THE COMMISSIONER/SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM
PWD
AIZAWL
Page No.# 6/12
MIZORAM
PIN- 796001.
3: THE SECRETARY TO THE GOV. OF MIZORAM
DP AND AR
(GSW)
AIZAWL
MIZORAM
PIN- 796001.
4: THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF
PWD
GOVT. OF MIZORAM
AIZAWL
PIN- 796001.
VERSUS
SMT. LALTLANTHANGI RALTE AND 34 ORS.
SR. A.E./SDO
PWD (ENVIRONMENT)
PIU
CE (ROADS)
PWD
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
2:SH. V. LALHMUNMAWIA
SR. A.E./SDO
PWD
S AND I SUB-DIVSION
PWD
SAITUAL.
3:SH. JOSEPH REMMAWIA
SR. A.E./SDO
PWD
ENGINEER IN CHIEF OFFICE
PWD
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
4:SH. H. LALNUNPUIA
SR. A.E./SDO
PWD
ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF OFFICE
PWD
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
5:SH. S. R. LALRAMTHANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
Page No.# 7/12
PWD
PIU (ADB)
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
6:SMT. JENNY LALRAMCHHUANI
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD NORTH DIVISION.
7:SH. KAPHMINGLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-I
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
8:SH. C. LALTHANGVELA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-I
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
9:SH. LALNUNTLUANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KHAWZAWL DIVISION
KHAWZAWL
CHAMPHAI DISTRICT.
10:SH. C. LALCHHUANAWMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NEC DIVISON
CHAMPHAI.
11:SH. DENGCHUNGNUNGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-II
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
12:SH. R. LALPEKA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
E IN C OFFICE PWD
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
13:SMT. MALSAWMDAWNGLIANI
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL BUILDING DIVISION
Page No.# 8/12
TRESURY SQUARE.
14:SMT. VANSANGPUII
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PIU WORLD BANK
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL/
15:SMT. R. LALBIAKSANGI
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PROJECT DIVSION-III
BABUTLANG
AIZAWL.
16:SH. P.C. DAVID LALRINLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
CHIEF ENGINEER ROADS OFFICE
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
17:SH. LALREMRUATA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
HMUIFANG DIVISION
AIBAWK
AIZAWL DISTRICT.
18:SH. R. LALDUHTHLANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF TRANSPORT
CHALTLANG
AIZAWL.
19:SH. LALNGAISANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PROJECT DIVISION-II
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
20:SH. LALRAMSANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KOLASIB DIVSION
KOLASIB DISTRICT
21:SH. LALBIAKNUNGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PROJECT DIVSION-II
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
Page No.# 9/12
22:SH. LALCHHUANAWMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
ROAD FUN BOARD
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
23:SH. ZOHMINGLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD NORTH DIVISION
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
24:SH. P. C. ZOKHUMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD SOUTH DIVISION
TREASURY SQUARE
AIZAWL.
25:SH. LALDUHZUALA SAILO
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
SERCHHIP DIVSION
SERCHHIP DISTRICT.
26:SH. K. LUIMINTHANGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
QUALITY CONTROL DIVISION
ZUANGTUI
AIZAWL.
27:SH. SAMUEL ZOTHANKHUMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD SOUTH DIVISION
TREASURY SQUARE
AIZAWL.
28:SH. JIMMY VANLALSIAMA BAWIKHAR
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-II
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
29:SH. DAVID LALTANPUIA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
AIZAWL ROAD SOUTH DIVISION
TREASURY SQUARE
AIZAWL.
30:SH. LALFAKZUALA
Page No.# 10/12
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KOLASIB DIVISION
KOLASIB.
31:SH. JOHN LALCHHUANAWMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
KAWRTHAH DIVISION
KAWRTHAH
MAMIT DISTRICT.
32:SH. C. LALENKAWLA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION-III
RAMHLUN VENGCHHAK
AIZAWL.
33:SH. R. LALRINMAWIA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
PIU WORLD BANK
TUIKHUAHTLANG
AIZAWL.
34:SH. ZODINGLIANA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
HMUIFANG DIVISION
AIBAWK
AIZAWL DISTRICT.
35:SH. R. LALCHUNGNUNGA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
WESTERN CIRCLE
LAIPUITLANG
AIZAWL.
------------
Advocate for : MR A D CHOUDHURY
Advocate for : MR. K N CHOUDHURY appearing for SMT. LALTLANTHANGI
RALTE AND 34 ORS.
Linked Case : WA/103/2021
THE STATE OF MIZORAM AND 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF MIZORAM
AIZAWL
MIZORAM- 796001.
Page No.# 11/12
2: THE COMMISSIONER/SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM
PWD
AIZAWL
MIZORAM
PIN- 796001.
3: THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM
DP AND AR
(GSW)
AIZAWL
MIZORAM
PIN- 796001.
4: THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF
PWD
GOVT OF MIZORAM
AIZAWL
PIN- 796001.
VERSUS
SH. C. LALDINTLUANGA AND ANR.
SR. A.E/SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER
PWD
ROAD SUB DIVISION
PWD
LUNGLEI.
2:SH. P.C. CHHIARKIMA
SENIOR ASSISTANT ENGINEER/SDO
PWD
SDO (TC) PWD
KHAWZAWL DIVISION.
------------
Advocate for : ADDL. A.G.
MIZORAM
Advocate for : appearing for SH. C. LALDINTLUANGA AND ANR.
Page No.# 12/12
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
ORDER
Date : 19.04.2021 (K.R. Surana, J) Both sides are duly represented. On the prayer made by Mr. D.J. Das, learned counsel for the private respondent/caveator, matter stands adjourned today.
List after 2 (two) weeks on a date to be fixed by the office.
JUDGE JUDGE Comparing Assistant