Karnataka High Court
The State Through Bemalkheda vs Ashok Dama S/O Padmaji Dama on 14 January, 2011
Author: K.Bhakthavatsala
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala
pm;
:13 THE Hifiii ۤ'{}'R2" QB'
CXRCXIET BENQI-K A'? G'E.}'L§ARfi.,&
E3A'E'iE~1£} "SE-EEE THEQ 14%-5 :'>;§<{ 0:: J;%N :,L:a.E2*y' 23 - ..
PREESENE'
2:1-£3 xmrmm 3:: JUSTICE K.§3AK*r§fiY&':§
EENEE _ i J T' A. A mm XiGN"BLE Mr. JUsTzcL§";aR®:'§g.¢@aé;$ SRIMINAL A§>':s§;;:'§, }V:2-Q09 {A;?'"~ V BE1'§'WEEE\E:
'I'%1€S%;:;:':.e, _, Thrgagfi Bemazkmia _ .,¢.APPELLz%'I\§T
{By s:m.A;:_::::-5&3/:Aa..i;;<::D$%gé.2§ 5?:-:§""' AND: ' V I V Ashak D3.'m3., _ B,/'@,Pa§:::{a_§§ §::1r;::a;" . _ V H ' ..... .. y 3V'51O€§1i.i._ 9' _ Rf 10, B&r:{:ai};;E;é:{%2?. 'T'j3§"E'.'i§i$ H.u::i1;>.;3..2é;t:ad" 'fiiegs.-p. Q' ~ . ' *--.__,B§&m: A' ' H '.,:2;ESP@:\3:">§:m I1 / . Sri .Sac%:§fi«;_'§:§ahaj an, §'%:::§.<:z:s Ciifiiifi} A Czimémafi A§p€:»2§ ES féiaé umier Seciien 3'?8{E.} & {3} ¢:z.§3;{"3§;'--';3-j.2* ihe Arsidfi. SE3? fog" the Staiia p§'E}}-7'§'i'E§;,_§ :52 gram, iezwss in {Q6 ' ff-a:*};"2,appea§ agairisaé ihs Judgeizzaiéi, éE;.3€%.,84.2Q8§ in 36$-i~f~:§§'.{}£'1S Casa T §'_13e:3';.@5g"Gfi {Bagged by ihaé E331. S~&'SS§0§}S Judge Bidar, a{':§s.z§'{.'?:.ir:gf Abiiée respanéfinifziétctzzsséi feat" °§,§"§£3 :}f§'€;r:{:<:§2, gt),/'1,3.,z';<,%.:3§39 332. 584 ami V33? Sf EPC, "fifzia €z"i.mi.:";.;-':1 zagzgaai :::>:§2i:*2g 9:: {er fiizaé ';§2é3a:"§§1g, éhig sizzjgy §}!'.§"~:K§33{2£1'§{i§'§&7£V8.E.:T§é1§%15 LE5. :§€E.i.2:1:3£d EEK"; §{}EE{}w'i'n§.:';:w J S I} G-1'v§E~:',i'~§:".E' 'f'E':is is Siaie 2:;3ps:;»:§ fiieci u.n:':€;*::" S£:Cié<>n 3?E?v--§§.'} zizgiéiv '{'3}:""{.:£' Cr-P,C.., athaiiegaging ihffi J'¥.,3.d.§}'}(1€i1?L déiififi»..3{:3.C}'5i:2'Q{§§}' .i:i'1EE;_§:§w E' '-i§1 V S«C.N<}.4§j2GC}5 an iihe {fife 0§P1"'incipaE JV
2. Sm£,.Anu.ra&h2: M.D%:sai$ Eeavfnéti Aaidf." SPZE3-1a;§:'3€aring far the app6E2ani.,iSt_ai',a- $:;2:;:1':it;~:LEf:i'::«_2:z_':. hQé§$A riéia. ;)I'€3p€r'i:.; appreciafiézd the evifiemfe af part:i<é::§2irE;g, the %3:;}:_z§<:d wsimess. S§:€"f;§:;'i§'1e:; _ {he incispendeni
-eye--witn€sS haé of pms€C'L1i'::i.o:r1, the evifieméas of uf€7VEVi£s:E:>'i<: and ?;;"u5t»wmfE.hy". Bu:
the Trial C%§;E~,Ei'£ {ha aciéused fer ihe offezazres unéer Secéign 353$ 332;V1.5Ae-éafié 33? Sf "EEC.
'S: Sri§E3.:;:chi;1_ Exziahajein, 'é?Jh{} wag a§}§}0§:r"3{:@d as amE£:uS {turiafi :15 §1:f€:%_;;i. ::?f;;sé'.::esg§:§~fisEe:'1€;"acc:'2;Es;<id Sllbiiéfifi zhai éghe preaecuiisn éfiéieriy féi§e;§"§4b-wing heme fine ggtiiit is "iihéf :1<:<::usé3fi fézzsr the (}f§t'i'1C€S ._..;:E%s:g-3:§,Lagai:3st him zamd {he "Wig? Court, am ;:,::"<:p:'3r' 3.p§}1"é3€fi8_?3;i{}fl GE §.5'§i:€' "<*}§'£-"{i73.§::d €§€%€i,§.ETI':S§}§',&1§"}-=' s;%.*=,-*:'{%<2m:£: g}§23:<:§;%<:E by E'I§'":€3 §>§'<3ssz;é:E.L:'éi:>:L ..;{'€a::<>:~:i?;<:*d an ayflsz" {If a<:::§2,:£Eii;aE azzd ihzzm is :10 iiiegaiiéy 0:' §:1§*i:°:1";§'§iy V "if: 3.31:: img:a:gr1<:d. &uég:;2'ns3z1:.
3 \__w_m, "fizéi: 838%' sf :;'.',z3€3 g::z'<3$§2<:2,1%;,.i;;3zT1 3:5; Ehai. £35é~£2E wha was wasrkiag :15; E-ieargi Sensiiziéafie :--3:£ E3€3':'1a§§:.h.e{§22; E3<>E£C€ S£'.ai§:'::'1., Eegiggezi a ctampiaim sizaiing é,.'i:aé, an Q4é.Q2.2@Gfi. :*€f;:z:,:*mtCE the W-*21:"§'Ei§i'§.:
agaimfi: tfm aezcuaed, 'E'her:':a§t<:1: he zinc? 2m0t:he2* E30_Ei'C.:§2 C1t';::"$%iI.,r::.Ei2§.;e V. §3f%V.§fNa1H§d€2=* R2};i',§1C}{§ Weréz ez:Z1r::si:.€;1_, ...,:v;i§,h 'Ef;2mc§" summozxs and ax;aTrrar:€.s; in 0i;.h<::* atrimiiéai <:;'as:=~-3. '»'.€j§e~ §?':i;:.esV' §%;z:fE'i3'a:::" siafieé in ihe compiaizxi, thai an ®€*f G'?,.20G'6 abQ*:fi, :33@e §';,. what; hfi and RW9 were Ijjsag' Siaikahana Saunstha at Bemalkheda, E?1e.3.;9:"s3;m€; iE2§_fe :VL'.a:;{:;w<i}g§A:;=;:'€3'a'i_b» and {aid that firm Caurf; has isgued w3,rra_:;?€ Em wig?' he wag fiat attending t'E':_€j.. azscused became angry and a}§§us_edAvv--i:1--w;;1igar ianguzage and gicked up quafrei anti "s1§§de:7'J;§K knife from his packet and 3f§C1v:€EI§§3{€:'C§'§:"i,'G ugéaég é:;:2.L§:};7';e s%1';.ar;"1e1<:h 95 311v'; and 22% avaided the fix sustaiixed izagftity 1:9 his right palm. it E3 a§£i,:> é¥g;E,€{§v i'E;a1:,i:2{::é@:":¥: wzszs w1lE;z1eSss%3§§ by ?.W.§fE\-Eérefléaniaz 33.313 6%/hxg/;.£d'%K ¥*E,_Q:1. '{h%;~: bassig csf me ::an1g>3ai.m., '£1163 §@§Ec{: regiSfi:£::'€é {he V :i:j;1s~:_t"5 'a§;'<3_"'inxs€s%.Eg§23},:3é Eiiéii iaid €:E1a:*gge«se%*:€:e3E. zagairsst. {E35 accugegi T E75?' me e§§ez1{t:3$ afiegad giggaiizsi ihem. As:r€u:=§s:::E §}iE3Ei{§Ei'ai'§ :':<:»?:' g_§'z.;§1'§j;
ééréai ::.'E:;§§.:"m:"tz:§ ii} Em §:"i€.*.::E= "§'§'ze §}}i°{}f§s'-3{?'L§¥Li(}§1 *e;@:'2:. H; E'???-.§ by REE sand R/E.G.L D:.:::i:1,_;;" {he ccmrssazz 9%' <%r0;<§:e=;~<;%:~;a::1i11aziéégzt sf §>.'§J,'E§, §3as;5g3<}'ré. was zizariiéséd. ass E;:x;.,E}~i. The ?c"i{T{':%.iS%3€'3 afidaitaé :'eb:1?ia§ €vi.dé:nC<::. '§'§:€ 'f1'éaE C<>:z;'t a€j=i'.€§*z* arg::ar::e:1i$. g2<3m:53i§"sg am: and d0Cun1ent.f;:ry...ev'ic§52ncé"'=;:ii»::e:i%::i_7.:>r;V V recard, cama fie éi £:<:m.£:§us'i.0r: £.hz;;i: {he ;3:*{:4§e::%.§tié;I1 :E'E1§§'éZ*§i. '::{é hams: the gziifi 31:} the zictcusad for €.h«:>:_ ei:éf.E§e:1.c:s'-éés ievééiiéai a«ga;i--nVs%;V:€.he accussé and t'he;'€§'0r<,a rscarfiedi a:1_m9§éi=ié:*"V:;V§ a<: q{2.3:.::_21§a _7 This is;
imgugned in {his appazri
§" The aifiegearfig .. 2:3; aboui
L2,. 1% mean. The can the same day at
abcui ';2.5Q fi--. :V1§,;* Qariificatfi 3f the
compiainant W"&1S examined by
PW.5/Br.E{._E\Eara;§%4*é::2';°€g:E§§;g--. pf§r;18.1"}7 §""i€:«:;ii1:":. Centre Q"? at. abaut LSO gm" asceréing ta érzarfipiaéiziani hag? susiainsci simpie irigigrgaz %Ji2:,,, {tut '*--...i::§u:*y 02-'::§'.'V;*£{s§:j1*_1t:.T";;f2',a;,¥ah 336211" %..hu§:1b mea$u:°2Zr1g__: 2' X E13,', Wheream 'she
--.V_T«T'_:";"«i?§.Qf<E__1>-gas S:3§:Q.itt%:d {<2 Cfliiff {H3 99.82.2005 at abaui. 1,39 gm- ' _'_V €.}.:3. 'ii{§.§2:2_Q€%8 i"i:;~;eE.§, ms: acczzgeé was arresied amé afier receréiag; '";r{{§:':':1':,£§;.:"}; $ta'E€:me::':'a'. 0%.' 'abs a{:{:u§:;:d 55¢; E353: E:'.ix.§?~§? me §%2E.,€3§E j§«:.r1if€:
seized 2,1:2=:i&:* P'am:§:.2:r:e:::1a,»'EZx.}7"~3 {{§:":E§;'iE£'§E1§§, élhffi $3316 '§e3;w€e::
j2,§5* EREEE. éii} 35$ ;3:::<:j,%( En. ?a:*a Ekéafi {sf ié":z;>: i:::;3'z:.g:'z€,<§_ €.§:.:c'§gm&3né. tbs 'E':°ia'£: Czmfi. hm; £§S<7:;:;<,:s;<:€2 2':%.:>{:u%: %;.§%2{:= {=2;§{§€:2:::é:*: 9%" G11 ihéi <}i.Ir"2.€r E':az:d§ EU»-'~f.§i3 321353 éhzaégi i4§":<:: §'){)§.i{f€;'; €j§>§:s»;{23.E3Ee:s «Wm weréz §€'_'§,}'E.E.3§,€C§ ":5: a1;:>p;"€2E":ez§d ;?:<:m.z.i-:'s<:>,<i, zzxpprehamcéeci the 2:»:%£:::_s{~:{% in his Eiflufifix in §3'EE1'2i N(;.2.I Qf f;'.he §}'I}§}1;2.§g§I}é;'td J?;if.'§§.{§I}€§1?:;;':V{},"*=f!i"'.fféj;'Ti§;3t§ Ceurt. has absssrved that very sggixmre sf' ?v'E.G,i .§3fé:$e::§V'@:i:*~ l'Oh1Hf.Eif}' s%:,22%er::{:m, is u.::be3:1£e3vab§5 anci; £*h<:: ;:~'vi<§s3:3Cé'=-:%Vi7 E3';"J£s,5;-3 u is E} itanmot "be accepted H; base cor1*;ri"€:;.i<"§:>%'_iQ " 3 E11 [E53 é:3_;"s{; ihafi the en.iire case appears; :1'; be L:Qvr1::3,0C'{€c§' '~:-and s£.Ta.ge':«.;:;:a.naag§@d in . L' baa}: a case against the {:1'.'("f::'/'s,3.S3IE3dV_..._{)%;;» {)'fi§3 s{:{}:'€.__c>':* _§,h_e athega Therefarey the '"£'r£a£ Court hE1;'S3-?."ti'3:€?O:¥"f1'§€3§§ ;1£{'L?§§"{{éi"~,{)f acquittai. ?'= The }'}I'C3Sf3€7T1J.*;§.O'§i difi-iii n0't'..:p:fQii:;€:§~; i.}";':;,« éfllegeci warrant. or sumqmons :E:§suéd' *'i::>5V5»'L_E:e'?:§i§:%c:,2:s;:§-iéa '£'§1;éV%r€r3r case af tha: prssecuiimri is that P.Ws.E. and SE} ;1ig;f§';*QTg1::%.hi€:;i'.&he £1C(':"L'3Sf;'fd amt? questioned him why he did :10: 2Z{ f§€1§§.E§E.€ {3;0'::Lr'iV ate, anci aé éhaij. time, Eiheii accused ;§?iS's"3E1i:e.d'I3:/W~ wha W2';E:"§Vn unifargri. Thffii" exzidences cazmei; be a{:'€3€§_3f€fi\a1E"E'€§«,Ei{:§éfl__vtifjflfi in the absence 0? c::0:°:'<:?o0:"2:€_ie3n. F':,:r?:h€:: miiiifii reétfiééry Qf "§¥;%c2,{§oz1/.EX'§.®,.'Eg'kn§:'€ said in be Eiéi-pi in {he packs? aétzévgiii and {he SE-lffifi '$33.3 g>mdu{te«:§ b::§Tc>3:{-:~ §3.E?s£Z}Gfi '}"'§'z€ st4e3{4§f .535 p:°0s«3»::ui.§<>n isg net; :'e1§9;¥:;Ee zmgé a<:::é:;}t2:b§e. The Tréaé _§ :iii,::'£,;1r:as~; righi,§y E'%3C{}I'd€{§ an e:}:'cE€:~r 0%" a1<:::gu%f;'.'€:zi':, :19 gémzti _ gfaiazizfzé Ea: E"E3'i-"fiEE"S§€ E226 :;:':§;m§;fm::d Qazdgrzisiéé. 8, in %:'.E":€: 37%:-s:;uE'§, 3325 paw i;.E":<~: Ebéimssézgg <'}:*»:§<::": 5' 5 ,5 .5 :5 $3 \ '''''~~«-----.--,.,... .
NE "file a1§3ps:%a.i f'22§§S eziéd Eézsj :~;a:"m=. is herd};-* (§.:§;<_~:rméss<%£§. S§'§.SElChiE} Reézzhaijzin. 2-;z:3.§.<:z.:;<§ C'i§'E"i8.€' 21ss;si:'-:;i;<3.e:§ '§,h:€"'€«<:>5§;':f_§:' E-'sis: fix hiss £136: :12. Rs;e.5,GfiG/~. The R€:'f§_§§S§.Z'};" E5; €§i§T%E.(3f£"€~§x i€é;:;n3;:jv' game. 11:} the gmzicug {3ur§a»:--:.
#4533' "1 %i:;::'s ELL . . ' ' y\%x.>..'\':' '~>n..,NM;'Mw {Mi 13* J2"
W?
bnfi