Karnataka High Court
Sri V Krishnappa vs State Of Karnataka on 20 September, 2011
Bench: Manjula Chellur, S.N.Satyanarayana
EN "E'H§: E"{§{}H {?{}{}§§£"§" OE? EfiAR?€A'§'£§KA, S£§N{§:'%§,{}RE §..}E%[?E';E} Tffiiifi 'E"'}§§ii 2%"? Ef}Z»§'z.' {E39 SE3:-§3'.E'E3ME%§jR§ §'2{§__ § E PR E3-SE'.;E\J"E' TE-Eff: Hi}T\2"E"3E,EZ MFES, a37'U§5s'="i."ECEi EX/§.:'E?'§&U§,A 5% N E} _ mg: HQ1\§"§i%E,.E1 EVER. JUS'§'ECE $.'%:;%; ';s=;;§ipg%z§§:g%§§g'§%;;VA'mg ¥VRE'i';'§PP§Z-g%.L N<}.§,%{}3 {>3 '::»:::é@@ ~ = a §E'§'W' Sré. V. §'E:§'iS§'1§1&ipp€i S X 0 \r'm1Ege1t.appe1 Aged a§_">0u:: '?4»_ years ' -.
R€S§_di;";g a1t'."i."h§§:<£h.: Viiieigs V E%e1.;2ga1<)re No:~f.E1'--'Efz1}11§§;""'" ' Bemga,§0:°e E?;u;"23.E;.};}'§si:§§=c§: g » {By 3§."',7 . f\E2;11*:_f'§a;?jV:3;vd2: Sr; {iamilsgei 82 Sri. K. L%a<;%§:§_2§_{i3.';éfjifigim§*:--:h;~- }§.€§E"(}{iféiEi€iE§ ;XE'€E}: " " _ % 7;; ;%E.2:é.<=2 aéf 'E';:::*'i":z1§.i;--:Ea:é3;._ p:°{:~f=%:*?::1 §1€1é:§-. Egfgs fies A §*.:;§*§"::;:-é§3a»_]% ;'E§<:*.c.:'{;%i',i2";;s§ . 'V.Elks:§:;;2;2.<'§'.:;7a€%:2"é. 0%" R€f'J"§*;§'§'i1€? $52; ..E3'§§.€E£§,:§§;§f"§.;';
H _ E",-"BE: }'$g:°:25'_%:é::<r§~§,§I2;?§;} 'i&=:e:{.§£?_::_é_ Ag§;:E<}%;:;::--'58@ {E9 E "§_'E'::: $'g}€:<t:£zrsE 1I}:::§:va,:é:j»; {:{'.}§"§i§E}§E%%$§{'}§'E%2ff2'
--- .. E§;1:'1§;"2§%:3§s:;% E}§:',°§"§.f.'§:{3§;' V If2';~.{_",'1 iiéffiax? ?§§:::1és;«:~::;%ss E'£~."{.1«. §€_<:a:.-:.:.§M, §".§§f-3§E§§é£E€};"{i--§§§{} {}{f}§§ ' .,,,?;PP.E'2E_,£AN'E' x"?
.. :3? 'T L '- £3':
1»)
3. ;;'7:3:"'£. A31}2?:z':::y2=1ssw22.r::y '§'s:mp=§1.:
"E'§1i.::cfh.2;
E%21§'1g.j2;a:E<>§'i=% f'«§02'"£:§'1 'E'aE1.z..k §f%2:m;§z1§c>:"¢*r %:i}:s§::-msgj EQESSP{3.E§§§_'§§4?~§'§if$ §.:~;:~§> Bzzssgg-:.v2;«::'21§ K2:r§é.{i«:i§:, Pfl. {}m:"'i.. Aziv. E35722" H {Ry Sri. E" R S:.3E>%321:T1_n2-2, S3: C:>1,.:m:-:<:ti V' EFL K, R. Sm3§va.sz::_ P;-:r2:v21.I'£§1:3;::'3,;fkiiy. fcsfr '§'§3}"f. '4 V '§h.§$ Wait: Ap;>§:a.E iii-3 fiiafrd °z.%;:1:.<ier $€?{','€i'{'>i'3 mfg s::E":£3:_ Karznazffiia E-fig}: Cmgri; As: §');$:*'e':_!":':;;§ in 5:5: :3z.:<:i%;i€ ":;i%1§3 {§I'€§€I"
&at':etcE 85..Q4~,2;GQ6 pass:-zgci i:3.'?v';'§?f_:'?\J7 €§:2 i®5;'i;"2G{} 5. Thisg Wm. Appaafi ha:-'wfizig;'béC::.:._v.§i<%g:r§§'.. zmé E"'€;*.fS€'E"§~'z';"?{§,, e:::>m§:'3g 0:": for.ii}$53310§:_1*s<'§é::i:a::':fi'~.£j§_&1.:éEgrneér:i.» §'§"§§§%§ (fay MA_?'£2§EEEA C.§€'.E:§;:Eg:_§'.;R;'a§,'_,"{§€:i17§?}f'é{}§ lililiff ifiiénwing; _ E§§}§}21A§'f€E'?§§§}x,' §§*zr:*: 21.§ii';g_=%<?.§Ea1m': --,<.«s€:<-_=-tzzma :9 '£39 b::%i":';:°{~: this {f:}w§§, Vim --ssé3%%a:;i2;E <}{:z::23.si{}:1s~; §§£'f§}Ei§}.'1§:§ <:?<}§'.:§i:':nz§.t:§<}n <2? sf3{'.'-1;:.;:p;1._§'f:<;:§%'v%f§§;gE:::S in Em; f£§_.§'€}i,i'{', "£"'Z':<"~: ;'}§'::3s'se%22%. 2-3p§'3ea.§ is §'Ei«:f:{E:--.z:§;$22.£.E:§--a::gT:=fizafi :;:"{ia'%§° 9:' £"E':{.>: §<f*23.§'§'1€f(§ $i:':§jiE3 Jz.;€§g§€= in
--V '§g*',EE}.44"Z'§<:l';;3§{;%5£§,:"2G{}5 {,§2;._'E:§;?{E f§w4e,2{}€}€§ 2>v%"s_:;%.:f<:=:::': §:%i{:?% :}:'{.E:%:"
E3 3i%{'%i:.-2% 3% 3:,::é.::%; {3:2§:1§:2§s:§s%§<}:[§{::* ;<.5:"a:_.3°'2:f::'z':_.? , ,, 37> »....
$1.
<.§<?<;tL2p:a:::'::;r3; 2*'ig§'1i'.:~s> in §2'1§~"{)E}i" of thczr 2::§}_g}&%§§2m¥;: <:z1Im'%_--.€_:<3 be ism: a:a;;i<'§:;?2
2. Em Earivf 'iihif £'2':<'%i::~; '£i§'1a::.'i: §{i?{§ m {EEG *~€'E "%;s:xT ~ §'}E"'€S€',§1E', appegfi gem: {£I'"3;{§€}"i ._ 'f£'h€: })}.'€Sé'?§1€l apgxsiiarzi. fi£€:i"':.{<3r§f§1 *:"::>,1'?. :i;=3u?.::h ~%i'=22.:i31:i,*r.. ta Ex: 2'eje,<:I1:e€i an 215.E9??._%§}3 J€lh%:'fAh'i;3{1'":si'§_VF:/"§V'_iEfi'{§Vi5£'E1L'V: Hff: "
E%"2as:i aka} fz;ii_<::<"§ {aim 11:3} ur1d.:-3:".:R:;:£fie._7{»4} "<'>"§7..:fh;-:::? Mysere {E9{§:Ei<fi.<::z1s and C§*12:ri'i'.21?bE'£:;¥'Ez:a:i%1s: A%)§§.E'§§Zi{}?fl1 Qfiuicfsg, E95? '?:'3 ' V : ... ' V' .
'E'_h.§s §<)z"":./2'; :30} f-.:a:i;%<;xQ {2.23;:':"3i? f€}; bf: :<'.§-;:;j:t<:i:is~ta:E;A In Z"£;*,E:3§§€'.{?E GE" sy"
'i"~Ee<3f?? 'go gm":'V«;::f.,,__§--v.._;::?%"€:"._V2Q' §._.{L§E"3"§.£3.;':'-3 s,~:iiL.zat,é*; at T E':i:1<i§i.: vi--_§i2:géé; V.:?hz3,§,§é?':2g'i':'7ag§ 32:3 <'§z"§§:%:° (3%? ii'1{3 "E'r§bm12;--:i, ea wr:?'£4 §}{:'."'§',}§":'.§E{'},?.'";'u {A} 9? I923} €i'é1H1€;': 315; ha fiéeé by the ,.::gp:pé%§E;mi., V " '--L§"7f;§_;j____5:1§}t:;é;': iiéiizéé"; §:::f; bi'? aaEE<>v»:{_>:{i 2§;:7;.<i ihgi V{;T{.);'L':::f€E.'«3fé'm.zm<£&:e:E '::.§":e :*;:3a,.'£.>:.€'::° Ea} §:1":a;% 'E"§§}:,maE 355 ms ::ie'=;=-_%;{§fe:z*:<:s: ':,-;i[§ j:1::-"fig. in 2m<§ §":E'"::% {i"=f§€§€E}{f%;': .E1.::.a§§ §:.<:> %§@= Eat? ii: me Q 2:i=:'E{%;iE:§<}n ::.E €§€1¥£.'.E,i§E'Ei3§"§{',$= '?£"":1_§,é-3: itzsizésza {:13 big": €i§§5;=§§}{.}E¥;€?€;'§ 5);? am $32:E§ss§%:;z2<:%':":'::E}?, Eh:-2': 'E'2°§b:m2:'§ E32? ié'.:=_~:: {;:'<§€:* {f%;é§;':e%<T§ Z%§fEf;? EEEQ'? gg§*z:::T'1%::3<§ {:}<?.c%:.§pa.:_:':.<'%§ ':":*g_§h 2:: §%;*:2:<>:.,::" :3? :1 {he :;:ppE%§E2::'2_E: E{ri$%11'121.;);3a& emd £:§*1::: game «:::2;m'1.<:: 'is; Eye aiimiierzagggmi E3}; %.i'1e: '<.s:mp§<::< W 1%"? :°<%s'~;sp=::>;2<§€;::'1'£. §':€fm§_:3 in §7§5.P.2225i;'E§}§§:3. '£"E"z::i» s';;m:w (,'&:éI§E{"T' €10 E38 <£isrE1és:§:se::{§ szm ii}. §§}§}§€%. 5Xg.;;_>;:'i:%w_-?<;E §',}§?' Eh $s:.z':2é? ihizé E-§="<"5 ';*{~*:§':s)g§§9::*r39és;T¥;Vcf.;*?=;:_j§; E1s3rz;*:iz'1 fflegé writ: 21ppe::z1 in 'Jx-3"A §\'.¥<}.2;9®1'- a3§"--:§:§}§%§§ M {.'&iE"i"§€E £0 be:-3~ a3:Es;:sw€::7§ _r<:<m2az:{ii:'1g E;§:'2'e:=:»--zfn;ai:-'4;:§3:"_VJ:jé1£'§: §*:.€:--f'f.;E2é':~ Tgfiibu "E1211.
3. '§'h:;'% vi§£2zggt:*1*s§ er}? "i"?1:i:f1€i~?;.:.z i'1afi,-«*i;1g gfiis-::'17:'a.. ?:i'<§"§~:f:10W "
€;i':.;2%. in %:h£;é retrord (sf gightg isri-««'<if(§%s.<fg:é&~=:::: of '§I3§{?--..%1§i3{)V€ swgid s;:.:r¥<?:§,f zmrzzba-3.r., {he :'2a_i%:nLé::of§;,E§'&: :?s}:>§§<%%§22.:*;,"€; 'bei;1;_.§ {'i§E'£',ff"E"€€§ :§E3r 1ih«::%; :gr:::a1"s_§' .'E-f%}'€i3E}¥§£.%E§5--€::i;»' 286.1 ami :3";21€i{:?: s;c:>m:>,~ int%:r;3<}12:i;§wr>':1§~:= iii" i.§';v;% »--§é:%i:€:;1:.::* :'<:<:<>r{§$, {3E'3.£§H{~?iEg§r3{i {E162 §21:::€;§ %§<:£?.:»:°:*: in-33%. '§i}€%pu§',§,I C{'>§}"E;i'£"i§SSi{}E'E§f§' :.2:'1dé=::' §§€:{f§i§€}EE LE " ;f_ <'_2f'«.._?::f:fi: E.,,a.n€§ E¥E';s:é*»,--'s:*::m:':: A<:1i. '"§'%3e3% E}sz;f_>*::%_:3»' }€"J;_>f%;*_::2:?§:5;:§€;::::%:1'" §12:vér":;;g ggom-'E §h:':;:,:g;T§3 figige :"{:7:c::::"<§$ ::.f€}'§"i{?f'§-Ei2{.§f;%.i§£ é:%*::::if'. "éfise :';?2'E'{§":; 32:: E5} £"'f;°f{_'?{}Z"{§E§ 'ass:-"2?§.§-:»2-5 §"§:a<§;:'-5:
V5::§f§;fi§§"€E§'E§L'-Eéééi é'%;.E'3€§ i:E':f3. §"};E'i.Z"E§€:': £2? £:§'1a=: p';'§%§r,m':i;: e~':p§e§Ea3:':§: w2::§:; " , i:2sVs:;é:--:°§{*:af§ wé%:.E':<:m% 2m},.r {,:'§*<'§e~§*' 2,25% §:';a:;:;<T:;§&:-';.;, Eéka? ;2'::,:€.;»2;§'._§{}':'1 £i{.3<':m":1<:%:'1i'.;s: w,é;_E.E ;':0':' ;'3:'{m3. §}€'}':'r:'::*j:§€','.';':=»'¢S:':§.§{)EE., in {>i".E'2:3:" %_-a«-"__0:"'(is%;§ .§":€:'. <.:§p§:'1:?{;i ":"'.E.'mé. if.;E':e% <§<;§:..%1;.:m:;%;'1.i:55; z"<:;'};1?.s-:<§ ':,.1;;=<'2z;".
§§pé3<":.i;':z.§ E._}e§§%;.:%:.jg {f<,>:":§. ."3§;.<~s..<:~;i<'}:'::::§° "i3f€f.'Z"€,'? .2';'.§_:;i 5§T.Ts;'§L":"1:'::é£?:f".§ V' {:i<>::.m1*: emss <3? :22: %'{:£.:~*z2i.i:>:'1; '§'§'1§%:f<:tf2'7{:5:'<:% ;-- 332 ':{i§.}:;>:z-%A:%{§. _ :' E: i,:+.r'§.'§ p{:::fé1':§:3;': flit"-:Cl by the 3"? ressps:z':d<:?:}:.«'=i_ 'sir-:'2fi;2i<iz .' fig-3 »;2;a;"~:':-se:.v>':.*£2}':~';l:i'~. t._E':.2?:'i. Eihéf §{3<:*m%s ::;'i,;?::3d§ <3? 'é:§j}€:'*=.'ar<:Z%";.aE«§:.V 'e}:€t"_"'_='§.1*é'e:: ifénzpitr :2§122.E§é;%r1g€:d by %:i"m V:1;;pcéE§a#::':'%f "%:.é3:°€§%§r; ::i€r&e:.sé;%':*vé;s:2. :30 '$36 :°e§€3<?:i',e{i. ;'ig§;g2_'ievc=:{§ 3:3}--" .é.§"ze?'*:»§éraiV{:£ __.;i}§'{§.:a:? Cf '§',§"§{:? §ear':T2:%<§. s§1?.::g§E:3 {}1,zdgc3 ézh:::g}';'&%&;§::'2i: ;:§:§.j§'>c'e2:§éS;_"EEE:f:_§§by tine 21pp&Ei2m€:. 5, A::::z;ai;~5:i'::1g"::<;:_V'é::;%%<i:s_ Eé':-i':"z":1V'«sj:*,<.E 5%-5,=.:':§<3:* <:{:=m'1&%;{:%E E'v'§2;*. E*J;;;.13;1?1.z:'s,_£ia--. E7{&?{4§é'§3.%f"- "":«:§;;'}é?§§z.i:'z€.§ éhfi: E€:;2::'";'2.{>;£§ S§§1§{§,{':
fiidgeg at "*;§;::*;1;§ E: i:.{:-» " {iis3<::.:$s.3e{i }_<is<:L.:s:; E€%'iI::1§'E{§i Sf §.§"2é3' 5%?" §3*{}'§":€i€'?E?i'. ";'_£v«:::?;f;;'f§=-f;1:1=:--; i?'vri:,:.r§.E':};' §}:"a=2fe::r°_:°*§i'ig; iS%:"E"i§. §}:::%:i§'.§<>3'_3 :ff§:':§V'¥Z'3'EfE§'?{§%§f§V:*?§E'.:'$,?'§j€'§. E'§:i?"é?'J :2?' $216: }"E.,I{§§__,~_f,iEI"1§'.?Zi'E§'. 8? {he §.}évé5_3§<}:':
§5s>s::_c.:»: géi '--%;'£;:§:g:=éimm: :3: 39%;: {2} ;s<:m 25$; {.E'}'§§} in ?;.E":a=: ':>§"' %.;;a§.mNm :2. ;%;'m:§'_E: <}:«-* §£;:_§€::f;a'5:a§«:;@ ;3g_:%s§> ..:"{}'i"§?i"E%ZE%2E§¢ "'i'§':§;% 3"? E"€;?;%é§}§}§'E{I'§€jEE'1E'. :"<%§32*é-'::>:%<?':'2€,§:-:{.§ E5? ::':';'és? ' I'E§"%';":S f1;'E":m izy s:'?:§2;:im::-1; 'is; ':i;>€ &';{::% ;i:.:*cT1§':z;:_E<_ sf ?,.< ,i"§'§E.§§§€% E E é2<t{_t<:::"<£if:"1g 'av i;.E2s3 k?az°':-':::1-:{§ (*<m.11:+:s<1%§, Si") fag' gags; r§g3;_E1iT <35 fiiiéé-:i% e:a_pp:3:E§az":i. 31$ 23 £:€i%IV'\EE:iE-'§E..g ii. {:21i'1:'m€ béé {§{f{fE{.§€.'{§ E322.ss€:{§ <:;»:": fizsé r€:§:{>2'{sis; :':;é§'<~7:'r':*E%§§. {:12 E22 éhé? s>2'{'Eé:=::'s-5; af ?:.E'z€: u{§»§3f€'f£5j§£%§ EV}«:*;31,:{:§; {3z'>m.r:':is;s§<;;§":.€rr z:::1<i 5-1:0 ifir éiéé 32$ i?:'}.'§§V_:§;.i'{'fES= i:E'E. :£??._§-*5' _ R'§"C they E:§1"fi*. aié §:3£;e:':§3s::2E3;¥;.s:d €ff§'I?f,3"i.€%i~3 2::'f__~:*.E 'i:§':.z%§3vs-éf%.;:;m~:; _{.;E1£'.'. " " ap;3a§i.22:_";'§: has no :2-'sé-%n1bia:'2<:€ $1' '»3f§§2;§?§;§i' §'}5'Ti'JE.€?%'{%'i:'j-T»'€Iu§:f£~..'fl5§.iEtA p:°ope:*.:"i:§; in <;;.:e$€f..i{>:1 213V'é:_'«-13:21:12':-i,» A§"'5%_:'~»..3,Vs the v ' _§ur§$ciiL:*::ia:3E1 isssgzmsz he ra=%§i<::;_<s
2. (2980; 2 sc: <;:4%.é%;9.3g swag, 'mgaags z:m' M13 Q'§H:EE%:S %Je'rs=;i;i1%?- V{}.T{§f»j}'«a§1:4»fi;.i§"'»'"S'§'EE3L TUBES MAZE§{§'{§R"3§%;§§{;*"3ifV4;i":E'~§3:E;":..V.§fi}'E'E£%r§E§$;
2, .,z:iR .; rmg: {',{}E'v'EP'E'}'{<f}LLE«:L§% ANE} ;a:§':??iE'{>R §§i?%?§iE:§m§'*<>V§ E?€§_i>EA. agzmz ZPE€AE§AS?r§, zxsws " §'>E;;;;¥%: _AN{}f:*§-£23423 K3 'ggaazygamf i\E£=JE"?§£§N @533 " % V :5, ;;:4.%5§j'.v::A_T;<3§;%:§ ;~:_a:: 222%; E"v'E:%_§~§_£i§,£%_§§f:§.E-EfxziE %"L{}U§% * V'E§A_§§,4LSuvss;Zéffiiiéfi (:2? mi>:;%; zsmii 2§:s::;<;% 3;: S:z§3réE:m»::=. 54:5 -- f:§'§'_s'%,'§"Ei mragg-; 9:? gzfazrzszfa ~ .3: 53%-§f%.§'§.Ei}E%§% §'_}4§,;'Y§,§§i:*§f {}E%';§.
.,.,..,,..«.._.fl(.',.............,,»..w;.»,,...,u/z N':
:°€r:2'12::.I*:di:"ig 'i'hti":'. n121§"%€:" '£9 EE':::=r S§)£;"f{"T§€'z§ §}€"§}:.2%'§.-' ~,,<.>:*:m":i:~:;:::;E::'>m%r. E_E::'2i&>sas§ 2:: :'{;:E%:ér:;t:'::%:% féééiéiéf...-.1;tT}{'ii.ES s:;'§,;3..:2d%. {E§.ss;p:,.2:::_:-'E :*.<::2::§<;E E."E{}'€" 'mi ye:-*:iZs.::<::--::i1 §::é<;%%k:3:"«<::=: 'E:.§*m ""
§'}z::p1.:'£:§,-=" {§r:f2mmi:s:;$i<f::':<:ér". SE,I3.E',}$€f{Z§i.§{?I"£§'§}"'i §_%1é: e':§_:"*ii'§€;*&sV'{;§'":.%i_§ij S§}€{_'§:::'i§ §T><:pm.;,r {3c§r1'm:i$:e;i€>2";<3:" E::'*;'"'?xEzf;, §_NA_.,.{"_:E'€:;.{E_/25834; 2G{}«:'} ;_§a§1:i"£é<>1_'1.er,i'<:EaEma:'::: %h:'%i=§5:1.:';r::ik>::' ::;é3i'er:"€€Vi». "-~.:<'>'~_ ;'E~}riH1§vz?:é; Mu2."£'hj_J 2:15.-:2 2::.1'CE"a2'?:i»: <3'§v'.._L§:'§*;«:;-',1 {@131 pie 221".§'*§a1£§§::.irig him as 2?"? r<:s:;§3<>z'1de':'1L v'_E_"§1é}z.:g§::'"}§f::*§é;:*1i:jj;?"--:0 <.:i1a:E§€:t'13g.j§e warm: Siizmdi mi' Srir:ivas~2 -V.'_?'r"'{.g:'§.»3,1:P§V.%:':>§.:i:¢';-L :"{:$e.z"ve:i in W.A.29§E g' .i§¥iQ9..:2?:'j;>: :e;'L£z_;:%1. :.{f3i§.é1§}'€3i'i'gi§_f-ifigigiffiff ta; E29: 2;::iv2:;':C:e{§ by §_{3."§:;éE'::ée[a5.;:2.§::§:«*:v 1.35%' ;;p;')'é3§}2:x:.1: §"§i';§"€fii'TL On é.I'"z@ <}i.%1~3:"
§:2m~:L iiixvgm {.}§}S$€;§'§"§{K?€§"E'E«§:§':f'§ 1E'%:ea;&:~: E2/§2;..:_r'Lhj.;' :A?ha 31:3; {3§3j€:<:E:ir1;g; {2<':<::.agé$:,:1<:}2' :*§§;:E;:§;.s;-§;e€§r'§-;_;j {€s>::£'ir;f:f:f:<.E in §'ér:2»*<:s:,::' <1}? :::§3;3eE§2z3:2.i:. ."E{§§$'%§§§.2?;;§:sApz§" .Ej:;::;s-S; 2':<.}§ ;§3§:%{.§ any 2fs;3§}§§<:=;taE2E§.:;'§ e§€:E':a:::" E2': fsgmz }.%.;1<'}_? é;::V"§f::§s;:'§" E}-éE2Ej§:£,§ §%e§"<;;:':":2s:; E§.{3'§'. £31' in ffszn. N :13, E zs::1€§{=:_r E§':2é;:}g_i:s:%; ,§:.§I:s£{§§ii:§{1}§'§ ;'§::z1 §.§%§§§a '%~§'s::'§{':é:
V§:?{3'fESi§{§{?§f§:§3;§;§ E:E:.<"-2 <%E;i:§.m G5 S2"i§':§:fa.$; §'¢Ea,2§f%;:E'2§; ::%:=:i;'a.2§{E §':<:é':
E,J{.§{":'\i.rE§,;}' f=j=3€..§'::I'E{.§.§ as? :°§E':f;; %:aa.3s; :25)': §';:::.§s;é?=<%: ' 2,25% ; <i:Z}3%:3%2"i=*<:%:;:§ §;'§§i"}iT§'xfi'E. . X' {§u_:'-:;%€:§{.§:': <3»?
, ,,,.,....wm.._._.,...........Lw....,¢-.w..'.,.;
. V,'/W mi 33, L€?.2iE"E"i§f{i c;%.<.>'L::'§sseE fem: éiiim 21g:spe:'i%a::E: 1"€?fi';?f$ {:3 {ha €i€3{.'fiS§{}IE in E€A1%'E;4:1"~ENA's 63:36': ':_'»:%f<;::Te<«:<i "E0 s5upzf:;=:'",*é<} L.» 3' <':<mi:e>,3*:(i§; E'.§1at;. ihiif 331-'? :"es'p<>§'1<iem: Srizzivzza R'TE§§"?;:'z3~ §";;{_2{ §::s<:"2..:s; s;{.2;i:1£§i ':0 <:%12:iE:%§'1g<é €:E':.€: <>:*<§€:' sf ihe:-? S..rE:2<:é_<_§:%.u:1§ E}§€:;;_s;:*;'§é " Ca>:'n§z:i:;sE0m::° asé; d;e3:v<}E:<3~:'3:~,; 0? 1.1515; 'i.&?'{§3§}EG 'z§_}>E3:1:7€i?"-IE{}~.'§Z'%:E1C§¥,A' in :i:%":é: ;'53Ch€Z?1'I}€ (if "the ;'%._{:'t.,.9 -{}n p7<;=.zf:1?':~3z1E <>§" ff:3.:f @r§::irE.;=*. ju:ig;na8:_*:%'. it Séfifizl, in tbs ssiaifii :f:21ss;%"a:g;§éi:9i: §E;g2m the: €;<5:nan':. seekginf 0r::€:u "'&1iTi{? :*isaT':"=;.ts'--,w._"§1i'1~% _a' §;i£:21i:§<>n fag _. . g V _ AA _ :'eg§.$:i.<--:ringg the: a:»1mh2;k.. 3:3=§3c::€;s:p3:fi%::" zsmd sac) aizm Taéxssiiciezi" xaéhcy 2a%__g. t;h%;: ..'¥;:;:z°as:f--:>f;f§CéEf' in £:harge {sf the €i€m;3E:i§'., w%;::"i+2% §§':3a;:r".i;ié's:a a"§:..'E3s.. e:E«:::<.:*<:)>i,€:~e;~:-3 mregintamzsii s2.2..:s:rh 2:§;3Eé<:a.:':i£3::";. ~ in "€'hé3_i:' ~::<';7'1%:--:ef{;:%:>:E; iihésir Lasrzismips helgi §1h:;i§;i €;.%:€»,;%f4€:%:§:»%i{%@$ {f%i:_:é..;_:EVe:1 neé. E1211.»-*6 :§:"3.a':1?:1%,;.21§:'::=%{i may aa§)p1§<:a*:;i§>:1 as:-:«..€_i'::?:f:%~.:;3 :'1{§ <Je$E:€:<§ righi. in i:§i:::%n::. 'E7'E:em§'<}r§x E§L'.i€;'iI' 'x, §_;:f3'§'*:--"£-:%-",--:'E:;£"V§;%::fé_"_~E¢;:::%E§i:'é,E'§21*i: €§§€';'f'1£'{,}§.('*fx&'7§,="$ {sf "{:e=:rz2pE<: §":2?§'%?'i? gm §3§.2a:":€: in tzhz-*:~ :E":1a_:--'§i:S';z5%S€§<:>§§'a:§o§: 3352?."
E46 333-; gagzgézaai; Eihiza 1?E"28 Z%3;a:':'1<%::.%; <':a:>a,::':§as:>:§5 Eirir. ;'%;z:§":i:€ii~;Ea {ifé'z_::'::%{§{§§ ::"<:'::?"'::=:»::°:"°é~':{i E1: {E§3E%?} E§.{3«§€5 £3: E:§:é:% _ Iii} IX/im"t.E1y is; §:eE'3.{7:w21 ass .':§'§"('.'h£:1K 2'}? "tries: €:é3§1":'p}e:% Elfiéi Eihez? &?vi<Ei2:'2<?€ 0f %.%'::=-.% :5.§;*s§;%5:.':E2.1.:':.t £5; Eiifiéé} EU izhisr: s::%§fe>.<?é: E3<:*£b:'::% EEEE? §:§§}€{fié:1§ EI3:;-7pz:£:§g §Ii<>::rm3is=sss:;i{'>:1@:' 2153 :":%fe%r:"v:%{.E in §§"E§;'i :>:f_{ie:?s :1)?" the Sgwztigzi. §}€;*:§3¥..1'i_'}!" C€.>I31Z?1ié%5Si(}£1€E', £83 in £13115: ;3;"s:.s:s€.;'1i. C2188 {}:":{;' hezzss f;:<:} s::é€:<;% ':==;f1€:fi:.§éf i.§':€:% ' 22 eiiani: is; é:=ni',i*{ied fez' mtcu a::i:C,V9 :*i;r"?1£:7,23.s3;4i::.€:*:z1;:1"i:,';* *Ez"§'1 E3519 €}I'{§€3E'S 9%" i:h<3s }T}ep'u£i:; C{mm1is;<3:.;m3;ez' at',:3;1f:i*;>s3:*;i.1:?:§"'€I}"
's;,§1<:~'§"€;': .2: 9122212' finiimg étlzai €:%1é§'%»'r1a:mté"0f'E§'2%s éi.ppeEE;1I1£, §<Z:*i§;}f:11ap;3a was Eéflfi", ff§{i;§f_E{§ ii: iha ;§:311{1§ti;e§§ in F%"E'€Z2 far the year E9?'§--'i2 E10 §§'?5~"2'8 ;};:'i:_iV 'ijz:i;a€:: '0:?i_='§jh:€ i§"£E=:§€;Z'fi'§i§.G'1'1 {if {he}. ::a¥;z2:3__ 0:? i<;:'i§:.b%'z:1§};:3a§f-:35; -:n§.&d€ 2§"§"£§{'f§"E s;?v§{£e2r;J:: frag:
'aha §§i.'f£'&%':*@z1i:~h.afiri i>'a:;*:*:.§§§g,:f zlmai aE.s.=:s{:: <:§§§i?1::1;€:'::%i; in}; usrzad 21:}? w:"'§§'§_:%:§}: iihx: s;aé§E.__v:'1am<:j=. Eh: aésssa :re:%i§:2'$ to Ehéa §'a=:é?r.. 'ihéiil {EH33 .:'::;:.«%:%_':::=: @315 -.$f§T'r~.€1":.i%Ja&; Eé€;.:rii.h:; {Gr '§..E"2<;*: %'.§*:*§::3;j}§{5 'be§:";g ...» z;::}:§31'§...2?.::3.::%€ii%;--__ i'i;13§':'¥i {mm E:E:§:': §c>ag_§;§.:'::':§:~:;;-,3; zmgé E2.-'ziief {:1}, 'V :s1§3§:é§E'§9:'z2;€:. §i':'§;¢:s'E:':§":2?;g:§p2.>{;-4%. §'§é3;EE"i€;'f <:::'m:9: $5: be ;?2.a:i{.Es:a::§, {EH1}? V.:»i':%;?.<::j §:'5}?i§~"?{§ :";.:22m:?: 3%' £%:°m§va..:§ ?s;E:§.:°E:§:.§; {iéifiéif is be {i;§3f:@::'_::%2i'§. :/gé. €:<>§:a:z1:': :1<':LE2 0% ?i'.§'3Ef E5{'£'€'i. €35 {i:{}i,§§"ETé€%, %;i%2_§:=;=; Y.) {,31'{.1€r;" W2-':53 ss::'£}_§e<%§'. '£0 Ehgjr <:§§;%:;:_§_s§{.>'11 5}? the £3-Sgééécitizxi }1}a=:~;;>z,:i?,y {,5';::':z:':is;sé{'>m:::" w}"::§Eé-;? <:':<'3:.1$.§<fi_€r:*i:'1_§g; Ehiff app§i<721i?:£.<'::': sf {E16 ;}:;3§}§:%.§E.2:2,:':E' Ekfi' §__;.";m_£ 0? <}<':<>z..:p;?a:":<'?}.,? :'i;§E':E:$. 51$ :*£g'hfl§; <>%i)s€::*s:::%<.i £337 £119 E§22_:*:.1r;*:7§ s;§3:;g§Es';*. ;J'a.1<:Eg{: me {'i1"1:.'iiiE'fiT'§.Q':'?§' ':§7<;,§2*' P:
§E:'-§§:"=iI.,i.':"i£'E{."?€: oi' {T}iI.Tt{if§'1§'}2?LE'3(?.:g£ ri;_.g;jEzt.s; wag E';-:34 ;:>21i§i ::°e:<9__<%i§3%:.;_' _ fi"{L¥?iE Kiifit E<.:n21.:2 c.>b::;23Zne:":d; {far}: §%3;;:f§I:?z1"-::- 5-'agr:<%1.:§%:u :21} Servim C{>--:)§;e:";ai%:::W%;' " T 5'_'i5v{}{f'§f'_/€;;'}---'.' " <i<}<é1.xm€-3:":i:: \:v'{:»uE{i bi? 1<><)i{<:*@_"i:"m".<; {is 52:26 1;;-*}:::§:t§=}.e?:1" --'::§1:% v r a.'pp§_§<::2:m'?_. '~fiJ&'1:'Lé i.'.i2§i'.iR--'§i'i'.i__I"i§j '£he<V..1;.;:.::*:va;,i_&;"'*:§z:' m:.::':".'-- §'h§;:7E<1:z:rné:€i s;1?:':g>;£e J:,:dg§@ <i:():':<%§us:§<"-réfi 'E31331; _ WE' u;§2=::*_»v:V:§ an ha-*:haif Q"? Ei§"a::: E.€E?§§§§{?"A.§j??1{§ Eicigf %;.i':z:.=, '%i€:':z1::::: in kiss; §>e1"5;0::1a.i isaigymiaéijf-.. $.37: %:,'§}<é;:~ ,-~pi"'(}iZ';*{:Ef;','€§.'§;F.'1§.-_§§;'« p<é:"E:z3§:zi§:§g {.0 z§.§§:_2€::»;;,:_re {Zn ii.E:§§;v~.{i{f,:v;.1:~%; haé ztkszaréy {}§3.§§'1€E{f§ fizz,-'ii: 'z:E2ez=e " rs;3J;1:;;._ '%;:'::s-s%:fz::i<;;;': sf "1:E"':'€:5 zxanze Sf £':§'m E?i§'}}J€Efi£7i£'YE',. 'a2'£'h.a*:. gt-:'>V7s::;;Tii§4%;f%grVV":.§z::i; %ET; '";§:=:§=;i:~=;'é'£?2T2§:'r§=& 223:»: 0:': '§:§'2<: <::§.1€ eff {izzaixz 2, -*<'2a.2§<§ 2:§{§g;{? ':39. %fi3_':é <?r§:.a=::*i<>;'T: "£19 <'%<;§:s:-;§i'i<::';° §i§IE.€j <%2T:$§% s:,:»§ Eiééf ":42§:>§3€%E§f:21¢:»:s[V;_'?;§'. Ei§s:_%E':';i%;§:§}«* Em: yzzéai :fa:é::<%§§;3'i' <_:2::.§'1:§<";i <§:é<':§,€§a% {.319 " ;=as£.2:.ii1;.é%s {sf §E§{?: 2;:g:zg;3£:E%2.~:.:§§', 2:.:.';<:§ i_":":. faaféi §i.::'-(EX. §:»af§<E {';::*: bi?:§'1&.F.E§ u .,.:§3Z5 "§.,'§.'%:.<;:% ii:::3's.§;§<:: '£3: -é',}§""{'§{'3E' Eff} E:z:a2.:§% a-7-§":i'.§'.§.€:-':57; §.;2;:: :"a:%;<%:'z::<z ' i?2E:é.1§31'2_2 rats. "
" j"§f:»:'::+:;_' 3"?
r&%<:<s:'£%s; f.§'3€w has; i:::.'2 béé §E%€§E'£"}{'?f »:2rd:'3:" €§§i"¥;','€'.'.*§§'i'}§ fez' §EELZ§I2E'§'i{}§'E <3? iiha-. {'?§"};§fI'i€fé:§, Er: i.E2=:% a§3sa:&%::1<":&=; <35' zmy Exzzsa: ff}? E:;:T:_<i*E2 {*E"2:;.:é;.g<: if ':*,:E';:;% {3;:%{.:*§é:*:$ :.>:':{:':% %':a:'='~.: is §£§€.'f{? €:_§j:;zé.'~.<;§:::;f:E': £.'E"£€i§'§€S am': §;':<3:':es.isE: in Eh E? €':}?"é?f 0%' $212:-*' .E3v<>.:.';§V__ ¢3iTiE*:':%:§'aa5 [ :; ihere is ins:Ei:':21!.;?m:'1 af i!1f{EF§}:}}€:i.§{.}§': <)f.'é*,..i*:?{3"-3¢':Es ":ss".z*E:?.<:% Wri:;£z1§;;' and the ink 2m:% c§_Ef§'<22'<§:-32$: :3;.ie2 }:.*z:i£e'».§1':'g=§é'r:"£%:g§l§"--- ¢'§E.V§1T'.»é:":: name af ?:Zh€3 a§:>pe:§E2mt:.
19' E}é;*,fi;H1?E;e*E3; spm: §f1f'5§Z?§'_3?€?'TE;,§,;~€'}i'§.,_v'€?'v'"(){Ski-.E'}{)f._f%7i€C}1'E"i€3 to {he ::15s;s2T.s3t.a:3£:e af éghé-3"e:«_~g>p:éi'§;1r§f}zzéffsséid. in {E16 {72:$s3 of c;@W:>Am NA§'~JU§APP.éi"$' ~ 3:: <:a::-36 :;h{-2;?
§g{}£":iiE:;§éi:i_§}S:; ._ Ev;<;3VEfii "';:= 323:4; :3; z':1<£ar: ::£::%:é_;l}'?§'3;$<:%§ £'%:}.r i;h<:=: _r&§$p<>::<i{%:;§:s 4;é;:,:pgp<:s§:§{e:i_f§éé % "§Ti§;§%";. {i0's;.2_§'i:'S iéréim". §z1§'i'.i£:»,~:EEy ' -- E?§:2%;;%331"*<}f :§"s;%s§'g§€:§':'*:A%:i€:'*;EA 1%.} '@2225; ii': ba 2;: Eé%.:.%s=.-;:;éa% V' 3 " ;;3§>;}i:'a?ta2i:i<}:": ETVEES fiiesqi uzhéztih 'i3€£§.%§ M:'€;%§ée;§é:'§;:-§iV{;=V S:.:%>s;€:£;::<5:_':iE.§J ha {tégziniaézé téfméii ht? 2%,--';2.§;;.a2av "§':V's*,=m1.:'":§:. ?'E.'§':§%= Efiggh {2£:::,a:"E: rezééiéééi €_?§'§§§ {Tm ;§z';E§§32§z*zi}722'$ €?'§x"§{i€'3§E{3£:"'f. E: .§'a:'E<:{§ E10 :";<>E:§e:?:{: 'é:Zréa:; "';_¥«:'":§*éég:E§';r §:§':€& §'"§éE?£..§"§":€:'f 5.}? E'{?EEs§§f,}E'E€§€;?E'"i'§,.:'E ;2m{,%;'<':»:" S{,§§}E}2£.§'E%:=;'£.% ;?:_g:>§}:3a:.§":i%<§ is': §'.§'2é:: R.7§.'xi'7L '§"'§':%::"::é 22:22:35; z:'.2<:s :"§':;:.§;'€::=.:":'22.E €s'.":!éi';?§%f.§§'é'.'f é.E':§3 §"§%_g'}2 {Ti<:s:.2;"é; ii} %,>};~ 'Km ' g: ' .=é{,{;§§f;§£1E'§Vj_?..
;321ss:«: i.h:*: pres§21z";3p*£"i{>z'f: :12)» be a§r2':vv:": f::i":::>m {he 'r<3<:€_}:*r:i ('if 1'§g§EEE.S. '§'§1€: E'ii§.,§E'1 C<m:'% 2:2;>;:)€32;2;§"s_%-2 §"<?:» §12rs:€= _§.)E2:2..+::a=:{§ mzzgéfig-::$.i.$ 0:"; Eéééf s3§:»<>€. §;:'*:s:s;::e<":"{;:?{:s:': m2%.{.i:':? by SE36: '_§'§*§E:;1::':z-£5.
Efiiggfh C{}L§.7{'§1 {fW'€f§"§{§{}kE?{§ Eihiif fazrt '::h2::§:. {he s;g':«:§%%--: §;':s;§;<;%eE€:i_<>:1 nrzzada £31 £986 a.m.E :'~;i.:<:'§zj ' §:':s~9;p&cEé(>n {Em :10: ha-mm: 2;: E"€;',§€:?'V7z'-'iIE"f£{?€*. {Em E3a:-sh: 15313923. The :'e:V€;%1fi:.J::"é§ €33: ;«%';1'ié3:=: is pagi. p€:*ri€>d and \:v<:;*§». " $§fA§'€%é1{i 3: "
m_::r1":ber «:1? ye213*s ;Lq§i (;:{}".{1'§I§.'€:1.iv;?_€:'i;€§'A **é«.-§.§}H a§:sp:2§:1{.€::§ (E21313 A E"i1*:cii1:?':g_>_;V';°€::::<}rz:ie:trr§TE3é:; {E36 aapgyeliate:1u%;.§1<}:z"§:'€3;:fags'é1§$i::~:°ei€§'wi;i:'1{:®: ' V it is $.ig17:f_f£§'<:a:?§,§i¥";%:{} §':.(§i,g"'ihai the EEEEEEEQI sf S:.:--bba1r;§§2%"<3:}'m3.:£,é;Ems;'.héifisgeif $.15: he E::i~}g:~: §.;¥.'i"£{§E€§3?€;§»fig 'Ej,*s:2*-:: ;<ésva._::"?:: iazxci <:§<.>£:%.:=s mezsé: 21§;§3e:.;'i:° in €i.':;§: p2:E:2%1"§::.'~;:%$ 2§i'i€i E1:"C <:>s:"i':me:::i::,<_»s if %'.E:::-: suit. Vizmd ézi: V_;'.m§,;..'-i:§1';f:se: "é§'€,§:£7§ 23$ é:>w§1<3z' 0:' 213 23 R:-Téiffi sstsewzi ya g 1-'fi.'3'i£E§E¥%{ft{§ §,3.§}{}¥'€?$ 'V §},;%¥«:s3_:;*1.;'"'--§§_@ié§: Eras a;§§:"n§i:i:Ei{§§jg»' E§}":zizt:€{§22_§i' <2? '§',§5"i{% % 'T } " «, E3332 gaéf 112:?
'A '£':.;<?::"€:§'":";;'z: 2%:
§s':1:vEéf"'E,;::';é§vwgéiizié {ha-réé is 3.5} §:*:2::E':m°§:2:E 43:": §"{fi?€f§§"{§ i;{;§.::;~%";{';%%;a% 'i:.h:-{:1 €;h:':r A/f§~'3'% :*:3rs:;g::<:sm"Ez;=;:':§: §§.:?;s?t32;a:":2}r22 £:':E.§'§.§§{':é'§;'::fi{§ Elm Eéjféiéifz' §i2':<3 f-i§{3.§.E} Ezmd £223': 'E€am::;=*:s':-=§2::*a §i'}mr;.:':f't.T: E.}aa:.i.§',3:.
Eg;:§..:'2:::§ '§";riE§:T::':.2i§ 32:}?
'::as;~;€;*;.§°§€§s::§ in {:::;:':§%%:z"r%.:}'? €iI§'T:.€E <2{'%<::.2 '§;3i:":e:":a;-' ':*§*5§'2;'%_':s::~s . Ev; ,. 5:
if :1 f::>;:'§': 2.: I121? €jf§:y' iizzs ..
E33. 'i~'i€\,"§' <3? Ezhe 21_E><>w3 C§i3€;<?1.1;;<%s.s+;E{):'2 amzi <>E);«;r:5rva1i.§{>n$, aw. £.}.§'é'?f ef {E29 {;%§}§§1é{}§Ts. %'.'§":{:% €Z§p§;}€2.'i§ {§€fTE§€E',E""%?€%E% ix} ci.§;<;22nf:§:~:-7;:-1--;s;'%<.E mzgi 2z::%a7<::'<§ing§y {i§s~:»;:1'2i§~;st;ed. iv.
Séfi » Sak