Karnataka High Court
The Spl Lao M And Mip Gulbarga vs Eranna on 28 August, 2008
Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao, B Sreenivase Gowda
{N WTHE %§!{}H {3{}€§E?:"F' G?' Kfi;§??'sh%?z'%§<£¢% {T1§R{7§£.E§"§' B¥Z?i§T§;E_,.g%.T
GU LEARGEX
mm?) THES ".§'H£t 12875 my {}21"A%}{}i}S'§' :",t>;.aA:--";s:>g ' ' 7 "' ''
?RE;SE?;!*é''E'
'THE? §~§{}?*%'B§.E: MR. J{_3S3'.£'§{.',E:Z; §{;14SR:f5::£:.:j1'£A%:2._§2A§}
zazm' V
THE HQ§\E'B§,EZ: MR, ..:::s';*z<:§: 8.§R§;Ea§282*a$§ :{:<i>§%;:?m
MW: 268'? / {";%;§_"'{--=:; V95 Ea?! 21§9,%:";.a'4
MFA 3 175; G4, Mms :i$€:i;Q4 5jg-:aj;.,s33;_a4
?¢E?% 2'€€j}.:268.Z';"{}'¥: 3. N
BETWEEN: ' '
*2 mg SP; Lag? 5£z,.raéE~§%":3§":%L;sA§{;A
'i'§~£E«?:3;;'§',f><:9E';Z¥.§C'}'E.*§f'E«~E}}§€{}%§'~fEER 19 gm
1. ?§{:§;.. ;, '§£'E:B7BAL, {fi&MP A'? §v§AF;?:{§A{}§*%
.§'U'.€{BA=Ré}a«f§i%LUK. arm 513*? ,'.;z.;>:r§:::;m;~s**:';<~:
{Egg Sig. .;§$ag,a:§§s§:1v»§s;i::§;§§§'a;~gi mag: GGV? A;'3%.f{}{7:,é§'?E: ;
"Tggégfia
531:2," B:%SAVAB%:%PPA, MMQR
rm N T
Rm. K§§M;%Lfi..PUR ;;L.aNn '§'ALE§i~{
V mg. MA.§\¥AGI§*é'{§ EEERECTGR
E~iARE\¥A'§'A}é% RERAWE-§R.i NE{}é'a?%'I {Ki}
{E-GP'§'EE BC}AR'.D§ W' E'i,(}if)¥?§ fiM§:3?«§§E<;%R 'J§:§3{}§-%§
'K
__1 S§"T§¢""TéR';v'3s.§'aT.5E°s§3l:);¥A:.' " _
I"-J
Bfi;E€G;%LGRE~Q1 RESPC}N{}E§€TE°3--
S231 : 'sf 5% MA{)%iAV& RE€}DY3A§)V{}{f&T{*Z }
MFA FILES U13 5441; GP' LA ACT,
JUf)G-B/IENT Am"; AWARD DT. 293,03 msssp;::sV__":~:a:: mcs §x;§;;.
51512090 03%; THE FEE: 09 mg :1; Affifiig; »::::;xz1:_, J:.§2:;%<;'§: {s§ei;si>§\:.;§
GIELBARGA, PARTLY ALLOWENG TE-{E :=z;;E.1:*Eg:«::€c':._§: ":~?g'-i'f:*"'z'-=;%is;;'s.§f~é §«:;:':;:?2
EZNHEENCED COMPENSA'"§'§f)§I, " ~
Mm 930.259:/94
BETW 33;»:
3 Tiéfi SP1, mg 3.4 5% M§P"£:§'£}.LIi3;§E%i»{3A4
2 'ma EXECEJTIVE ENQ;,;é$EiR ;'¥=,;r> g in
m we 1 I~§1;*«-:.;"aam_;:,:;- cam? AT..~:z»2z:Ha.:f::a,:3§§'
<;uLB;§RG5 _ p 2 ;, '"APE'E2§J£.§§Z'é'?S
:53: Sr: JA<:§;:§§«sH zarzV:,:':%fj, L":.€3§22*--<3T:'»A;:;:::L. gem' ;%E}Ef'{§{T.'.§¥'§'E;}
Am ; %
, 'A ....... ..
. TSg'..{} :<:R:s;';4:e;«w_?A
*::2_;_Q: }{;;%;3sg§§:§;:%.¥j*{_;iR
THE' §J§f§N$&iZ}IE€G DERE-{_":'§'{',}R
E{§RN.%'IZ?'xKA EERAWARE MQAM 337?}
V. --« fE{}_E'§"EE BGARB, EV FLQGR
zamgamzm VEESE~I.i
.BA:'é>GAL{}RE3 E1fE;8E3{3:'%§}fi;§'<§'§'S
923;: '
'J $5;-31$: '2; N %«€AfiH&VA R£T;£){}E'fi{}V{}C2%.TE; 330% R: 3
;%v§§<'A FELED 2:J;S. 234(3) {$22 LA Am', A<:;;a§§%;::a€f%j'--.T:*:*v§:4;_:e:
JUEEGMENT AND AWARE mi :2cs,3.s3 PASSELEQE _;:'§<s'41.§.s:.;:._:'< ::xz*{':;=K
msgzaeo ON "mi: FELE €29 TE-IE5 Hi Psfifih. C§Kfli,,. J":;s;";{:g:«;,;:3aR?;::f:§;;= 4_
GULBARGA, PA.R"FLY ALLCEWING 'i"HE3 R'EFE:Rm_:i:§::. ,.§éf§:m_?:;:;.:a2 E>j<::;2,, »
ENHAEQCED {fOES4?ENSfi;Ti£}E%§. .,
MFA 3:76/94
BETWEEDE
3. THE SPL LAS
M 5:. ME? GUL8AR{_'}Av '_
2 THE EXECUTEVE Eé\§GI§'€EEEf<T '
15;, 19$ are m..:, " 1
HEBEAL, c:A;2viir>._g;:' ;x§;s}i'ga:;A0«:q ..
a:3uL3A:2g}A.*'€A,L5';§B;_ ~. f 'V ij ,? AP§'ELLf§§'~é'}TS
{By Sri JA{;m§sT:¥:'T'%§;é:..%.;§é:>A§2<{5§:-3:,::mi,,: GGV? ABVOSATE
A53 :
.....
.M;ia_JQ'i2; Wm GA§~é§AB§+iA.R ' ,R';'€L'= E-':'AEs%A§A~§?UR £;,L;a:~££i)'f%i;§;';}.E;:£V :2 T;--15 zsszaN;%'£3:TNQ EEREGFGR V §{&5R?§A'§fRE<;é NERAWARE .NE{}APv'i LTE} C539? 3?: BQARED, iv FLGOR "A::&';BEDKAR VEE{}H§, E.a%NGAI.{}RE RE§8P'{}i'*~5§;'}E§§'€""'i"$ $3; 7s3~i§':?éq MASHAVA REDQY, ASVQCATE veg :3: ; [ EVEFA HLEE 5,13% 54$.) *3?' LA figifél Afifigiféfi? '§'§*%§:'Z- ~J_ {.?'SGMENT Aflfi AW§.RB ET', 1298,83 §3E'xSSE~i3 EN LACE ?€O1fii2j{}{} {SIN THEE FELEE SF THE} iii Afifit. CEVEL QLEQEEE {SE€,£}%'~i}, j,=:;».» QLELBARGA, PARTLY ALLOWING TFEE REFEZREEEQEEE ?E1TIT'§{.}?*§ ¥'{}R EZi'~f¥fAN€.§ED {E033/iPENSATi()N, MFA SISQIG4 BETWEEN 1 THE 393.. LAC} M $2; MEP5 I GULBARGA 2 THE EXECUTIVE Eymlwgaé ID,EPi} HEBBAL * CAMP ;;--..,_APp§§L--L.Af€'.?:§ {By Sr}. Jagadésh Mtmdargi A'1}i«§T§,.: E &N'B :
1 ABBUL. RA1~13:\;»:.AN$a3.« MAJ0%R V V % S/G M§3.HUSfi§N' "
we KAM~ALA%?UR_ ' ALANI3 TALEJIQ .
'A ..... ..' , fs*§AJ{};R .f _ $,!_{;r §aeiz*s;s"1*,A;%:~;;$;=a:.8 " . ::<ff,* Q. ;<:A5~»%L%LAPUR A:,A'1*éD f¥fA;;:_};~:
MS HAYATH MAJ0I«:---
S{{;i~.AB}}U§.. H;3sM1{} V;R*;--<:>" HAMALAPUR Aaapégz ':"m_.u;»;
V' _ £3. BHAKTAR AHMEE} ?sr'£A&{}R U S/G EVIAHAMOOBSAB R] O KAMALAPUR ALAND 'mw:«: R;as?£:';r§ég;«:§§;}1"§é" "
{By Sui: V N EviAI}H&VARE§{)QY .£aDVC}<3A.T'E..) MFA FIEEB U/S. 54(1) (3? "LA 1'fA<:31','=A.{;:é;';;«:é';5§'é"'--'.%1;+z%2:
JUDGMENT' AND AWARD DT.29.8,,r::_:3 PASSES 1N L3'V.4.x':."fA r~zc>.5t1:3';%=:}:;:=~_ on THE mag OF' THE: Eli A913,, £31m. .Ja;;3<;.§;4--v~gs.g:>:f~é;',V. GULBARGA, PARTLY ALLGWENS *:'H'E,R,§:?Ei%E:§C*§: ~§'3ET§TE{}?; §3"{'}§%3 amaamcgn C:OM?EZN'SA'§'£G§L 2 MFA NQ.3}83,'i34 BETWEEN 1 THE ::s*'1i$i§ 'L;£x::§ ?._V _ M 3:. my -C+ULB;%. r?{}2~'.
:2 THE EXECUTEVEZ E'§5(3aN':::.ER ID 113:) sN'?4C:;1,}:E{~:_BAL CA?-jAP AT MAHAGAGN
- _ G:,3_3_;:«B,gg_x;a~A TALUK -------- ~ " APPELLE-fi'~¥'§'S 533,: % 's.:-5' f J5<;g_:3:,S<}§ 'M1: ND;'%.RGi AE}9L.: Gov? ADVQCATEZ 3;, MAL:,II{_ARJuN nMAJ{)i?;..,"S/O BANSAPPA Rjuq KAMALAPUR ' gkizziliéi} ?A;,-2;}:
__SRIMA?§'}'H MAJQR, S/G mmmppa R/(L) KAMEELAPEER ALAN!) T&Li§E<; §»42§::S§3<}:m§§::*e'§'$ " (83: Sri : V N MADHAVA REEDBY' £*:E)E?{){"..A'%'§; $5-"{}§~E CERE. 5% 12} gr.5
mpg Fiifii} 1313. 54(1) 9? LA ACT, ;a;GA;.:a%"f3§?'-5"%?:vT§i§'§:
JUBGMENT Arm AWARE) DT'. 29.8.03 pasgrjzr ms LA<::'_&é{:.»§f;'.:.<;;;;aff; _ 02% THE FILE 09' THE 111 Afim; {"i¥'\.fiL- e}{,§I}~;:%§§ ,{~S;_&;I}}:}_5_'T GULBARGA, PAR'?1:y* z§LLOW{Z'~$G 'THE REF'EiREZE\§{f §§~§3?§%1T3?ff'i"€§V§~E 4.':3<i;:;a' --. ' 3%? HA}? CED C{}MP.E}NSAT1ON, Thsse appeals Cfflmifig fin bfm' $:*=i1e::é,s~. ':z.:.:s %{;SREEI}HAR RAG J, cialivemd the vijE;Zjg:)wix1g.-A7. The lands of the '§;3z'_ $2.6 parpega ssf sstabiishment of rehabilitafibiz» - has ?€.z'%; po'{.enfia}:':?;3:" refezwezzca {30'm'§, 'gas awaréedfl the "*£f§_fi%Le'«.:;""3.€€ cf Rs.2;.4G gm' gig. fiiiiiia '?f§"a€ §'€f€:I'€i1C€ (:€§§.1I.j{ .__afss<%ss:é:'l <:<}mptmSa'ai<;=m mi: Elias: 39221333 9? Eif§.V3:'D*'r~§4=.- 's_z--"'i,:'V:sé,',;"A::£:it"i=.t"~;1."3;» e§g¢cuté$df"é'b:out 5; yaarg prim ta 33$ 2:;9'zi€f£<i=a:é{23':: q¥.1eS?i'_i_j0i*:.,_ E7§;;'1§{~<'§~iS~.:'é}.ia¥3ie piece af evzlfisncft. 'T§".;€i°€ is as €i§"};'?.'3E" 'A...g.v<:H1mif€ti:§'7i33z ?,_1:é3;::3f€:r§§;c:% {°E<'m::"§. in fixizzg E316 {::3mpfrz23a§i=:*>'2";.. '"§%:s:: .. '{?£;1m.}§_§I1S8;tiGE1 A}Z1SS€SS€{§ is just arzsi pragar. Thfi a;}§€a§$ assa- ' ._%:§;ismi:$3;efi.' K Sé/-E Jadgfi Sd/u Judge