Karnataka High Court
Shri.Basanagouda S/O Gangappa Modagi vs The State Of Karnataka on 28 September, 2020
Author: S.R. Krishna Kumar
Bench: S.R. Krishna Kumar
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 28 T H DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2020
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S.R. KRISHNA KUMAR
W.P.NO.126776/2020 & WP NOs.129208-
129402/2020(CS-EL/M)
BETWEEN:
Membership
No.
1. Shri Basanagouda s/o Gangappa Modagi
Aged: 65 years, Occ.: Agriculture 17
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
2. Shri. Ningappa s/o Appayya Warimani
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture 66
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
3. Shri. Mallappa Appanna Bhavikatti
Aged: 75 years, Occ.: Agriculture 179
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
4. Shri. Vishwanath s/o Bajirao Deshpande
Aged: 76 years, Occ.: Agriculture 257
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
5 Shri. Ishwar s/o Shivmurtyappa Bellad
Aged: 77 years, Occ.: Agriculture 298
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
6. Shri. Rajshekhargoud s/o Rudragouda
Patil
332
Aged: 80 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
2
7. Shri. Kalgoud s/o Basavaneppa Padguri
Aged: 76 years, Occ.: Agriculture 348
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
8. Shri. Nagappa s/o Laxman Tukkar
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Agriculture 395
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
9. Shri. Shivarai s/o Laxman Tukkar
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Agriculture 396
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
10. Shri. Jivanrao s/o Shankarrao Deshpande
Aged: years, Occ.: Agriculture 417
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
11. Shri. Maruti s/o Appanna Tukkar
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Agriculture 471
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
12. Shri. Kallappa s/o Ningappa Katavi
Aged: 73 years, Occ.: Agriculture
473
R/o: Ramapur, At/po Hudali, Tal. & Dist.:
Belagavi-591346
13. Shri. Somaling s/o Bhimappa Malagali
(Pai)
504
Aged: 80 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
14. Shri. Shetteppa s/o Shivarayappa
Khanaganni
540
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
15. Shri. Channappa s/o Somappa Malagali
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture 634
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
3
16. Shri. Rudragouda s/o Basappa Gidageri
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 807
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
17. Shri. Ashok s/o Sidappa Pyati
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 816
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
18. Shri. Virupaxi s/o Shivarayappa Malagali
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 893
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
19. Shri. Arvind s/o Gopalappa Deshpande
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture 900
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
20. Shri. Vishwanath s/o Govindappa Pattar
Aged: 78 years, Occ.: Agriculture 901
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
21. Smt. Akkavva w/o Gurusidda Tarabari
Aged: 66 years, Occ.: Agriculture
931
R/o: Rangdoli, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
22. Shri. Fakir s/o Yallappa Masti
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 958
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
23. Smt. Sushilavva w/o Goudappa Sutgatti
Aged: 56 years, Occ.: Household Work 983
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
24. Smt. Sangavva w/o Maruti Mangutti
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Household Work 993
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
25. Shri. Ningappa s/o Basappa Pyati
998
Aged: 75 years, Occ.: Agriculture
4
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
26. Shri. Basangouda s/o Maruti Sutgatti
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1004
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
27. Shri. Maruti s/o Ninagappa Katavi
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture
1013
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
28. Shri. Adiveppa s/o Somalingappa Malagali
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1015
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
29. Smt. Satyavva w/o Shivangouda Bhdrakali
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Household Work 1052
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
30. Shri. Malagouda s/o Ningappa Bhadrakali
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1056
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
31. Shri. Shivalingappa s/o Mallappa Katavi
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture
1059
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
32. Shri. Subendra Kadappa Bhadrakali
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1060
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
33. Shri. Chandrakant Ningappa Tukkar
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1086
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
34. Shri. Basavannia Kallappa Gidageri
Aged: 70 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1088
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
5
35. Shri. Ashok s/o Gangappa Tukkar
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1090
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
36. Shri. Sidlingappa s/o Gurasidappa Tarbari
Aged: 56 years, Occ.: Agriculture
1099
R/o: Rangdoli, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
37. Shri. Shivalingappa s/o Gangappa
Warimani
1100
Aged: 54 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
38. Shri. Hanamant s/o Gurunath Joshi
Aged: 65 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1101
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
39. Shri. Shankar s/o Vishwanath Pattar
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1110
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
40. Shri. Bapugouda s/o Shivangouda Patil
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1118
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
41. Shri. Basavraj s/o Gangappa
Yamkanmardi
1133
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
42. Shri. Irappa s/o Satappa Yanni
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1150
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
43. Shri. Lokesh s/o Ningappa Madiwalar
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1157
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
6
44. Shri. Rachappa s/o Chinnappa Thaikar
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1178
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
45. Shri. Raju s/o Ramchandra Kammar
Aged: 53 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1186
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
46. Shri. Nagappa s/o Basavanneppa Modagi
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1230
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
47. Shri. Gangaram s/o Suresh Kammar
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1240
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
48. Shri. Shankar s/o Gangappa Warimani
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1254
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
49. Shri. Shivanand s/o Gangappa Warimani
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1255
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
50. Shri. Basavraj s/o Mallappa Pawadi
Aged: 54 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1275
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
51. Shri. Shivaji s/o Ramchandra Bhagat
Aged: 65 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1282
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
52. Shri. Sagar s/o Ashok Tukkar
Aged: 36 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1295
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
53. Shri. Chandrakant s/o Maruti Mangutti
1308
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture
7
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
54. Smt. Sangavva w/o Dundappa Basatti
Aged: 56 years, Occ.: Household Work 1310
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
55. Shri. Shivangouda s/o Ningappa Pawadi
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1312
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
56. Shri. Mahantesh s/o Basappa Tukkar
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1315
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
57. Shri. Laxman s/o Ningappa Tukkar
Aged: 42 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1322
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
58. Shri. Mallikarjun s/o Basalingayya
Hiremath
1331
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
59. Shri. Sidgouda s/o Shivangouda
Bhadrakali
1342
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
60. Shri. Ashok s/o Mallappa Kanti
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1348
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
61. Shri. Sunil s/o Shivarayappa Tukkar
Aged: 44 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1357
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
62. Shri. Suresh s/o Laxman Badiger
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1362
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
8
63. Shri. Babu s/o Laxman Badiger
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1363
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
64. Shri. Nagendra s/o Vasudev Kadam
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1367
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
65. Shri. Laxman s/o Ramappa Tukkar
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1375
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
66. Shri. Mallikarjun s/o Shankar Tukkar
Aged: 47 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1396
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
67. Shri. Mohan s/o Chandrappa Malagi
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1397
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
68. Shri. Nagaraj s/o Mahadev Pattar
Aged: 46 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1406
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
69. Shri. Ishwar s/o Basalingappa Kodli
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1415
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
70. Shri. Basappa s/o Basalingappa Kodli
Aged: 56 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1417
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
71. Shri. Vinayak s/o Sadashiv Sdeshapande
Aged: 42 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1423
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
72. Shri. Virupaxi s/o Vishnu Deshpande
1424
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture
9
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
73. Shri. Basappa s/o Malappa Tukkar
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1446
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
74. Shri. Srishail s/o Baslingayya Hiremath
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1448
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
75. Shri. Bhimarai s/o Mallappa Kalasai
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1469
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
76. Shri. Lakappa s/o Muddappa Malagi
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1474
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
77. Shri. Balakrishna s/o Ningappa Tukkar
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1489
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
78. Shri. Vilas s/o Nagappa Tukkar
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1513
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
79. Smt. Tulasavva w/o Shankar Tukkar
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Household Work 1537
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
80. Shri. Shivanand s/o Nagappa Padaguri
Aged: 46 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1541
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
81. Smt. Mamata w/o Mohan Chinchani
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Household Work 1545
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
82. Smt. Mahadevi w/o Basavraj Malagi 1546
10
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Household Work
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
83. Shri. Ningappa s/o Bhimarai Khanduri
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1562
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
84. Shri. Balappa s/o Gangadhar Malagali
Aged: 63 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1572
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
85. Smt. Sharada w/o Govind Deshpande
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Household Work 1573
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
86. Shri. Somalinga s/o Bhimappa Malagali
Aged: years, Occ.: Agriculture 1594
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
87. Shri. Arun s/o Shivarayappa Tukkar
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1597
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
88. Shri. Mallappa s/o Appayya Tukkar
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1625
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
89. Shri. Maruti s/o Shivappa Daneppagol
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1632
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
90. Shri. Basavaraj s/o Somalingappa Malagali
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1647
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
91. Smt. Gouravva s/o Maruti Mutnal
Aged: 65 years, Occ.: Household Work 1650
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
11
92. Shri. Sunil s/o Basappa Korennavar
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1661
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
93. Shri. Shivaji s/o Basavanni Katavi
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture
1663
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
94. Shri. Basavaraj s/o Mudappa Malagi
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1691
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
95. Shri. Ramesh @ Ramappa s/o
Chanabasappa Malagi
1701
Aged: 43 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
96 Shri. Yallappa s/o Mallappa Badakari
Aged: 61 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1704
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
97 Shri. Malanayak s/o Valmik Hegnayak
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1705
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
98 Shri. Siddappa s/o Kallappa Bhadrashetti
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1710
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
99 Shri. Virupaxi s/o Kallappa Bhadrashetti
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1711
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
100 Shri. Nirmalkumar s/o Padmappa Nilajagi
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1743
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
101 Shri. Anil s/o Fakirappa Tukkar 1746
12
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
102 Shri. Shankar s/o Shivarayappa Malagali
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1755
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
103 Smt. Goura w/o Vittal Tukkar
Aged: 49 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1770
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
104 Smt. Tangevva w/o Shekhar Malagi
Aged: 57 years, Occ.: Household Work 1777
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
105 Shri. Kalmesh s/o Basappa Malagali
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1778
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
106 Smt. Sangavva w/o Gangadhar Malagali
Aged: 65 years, Occ.: Household Work 1805
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
107 Shri. Sangappa s/o Gangadhar Malagali
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1806
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
108 Shri. Shekhargouda s/o Lakanagouda
Modagi
1811
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
109 Smt. Savita w/o Sidgouda Managutti
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Household Work 1824
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
110 Shri. Basavaraj s/o Bhimappa Bhushi
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1827
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
13
111 Shri. Subhash s/o Bhimappa Bhushi
Aged: 68 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
112 Smt. B. Rajeshawri B. Hiratangi
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Household Work 1849
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
113 Smt. Balavva w/o Yallappa Talluri
Aged: 73 years, Occ.: Household Work 1867
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
114 Smt. Kamalaxi w/o Yallappa Talluri
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Household Work 1868
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
115 Shri. Anand s/o Vasudev Chavan
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1871
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
116 Shri. Fakir s/o Mallappa Badakari
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1874
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
117 Shri. Sattyappa s/o Basavanni Hogarti
Aged: 60 1878years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
118 Shri. Mohan s/o Gangappa Naik
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1888
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
119 Shri. Basavanni s/o Sannamallappa
Hulmani
Aged: 56 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1896
R/o: Randholli, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
14
120 Shri. Shankar s/o Satyappa Hulamani
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1900
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
121 Shri. Santosh s/o Shankar Majjagi
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1904
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
122 Shri. Santosh s/o Basavaraj Kalgudi
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1912
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
123 Shri. Siddappa s/o Appayya Tukkar
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1915
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
124 Shri. Rudragouda s/o Kallappa Gidageri
Aged: 62 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1917
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
125 Shri. Basavaraj s/o Shivappa Malagi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1929
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
126 Shri. Shivaraj s/o Sangappa Malagali
Aged: 32 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1966
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
127 Shri. Basangouda s/o Shankar Modagi
Aged: 34 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2015
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
128 Shri. Ravi s/o Vishwanath Chavan
Aged: 32 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2019
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
129 Smt. Shivaleela w/o Maruti Malagali
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2021
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
15
130 Shri. Balappa s/o Appayya Tukkar
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2022
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
131 Shri. Pundlik s/o Rudrappa Jalager
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture
2024
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
132 Shri. Channappa s/o Basavneppa
Hulamani
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2028
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
133 Smt. Jayshree w/o Mahesh Warimani
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Household Work 2029
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
134 Shri. Nagappa s/o Balappa Bharnatti
Aged: 61 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2037
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
135 Shri. Siddappa s/o Virupaxi Thiakar
Aged: 51 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2044
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
136 Shri. Adiveppa s/o Somalinga Malagali
Aged: 4 8years, Occ.: Agriculture 2045
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
137 Shri. Balesh s/o Appanna Naik
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2065
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
138 Shri. Maruti s/o Kallappa Malagali
Aged: 47 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2083
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
16
139 Smt. Sharada w/o Sadashiv Benchannavar
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2095
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
140 Shri. Shankar s/o Somaling Revadigar
Aged: 42 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2100
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
141 Smt. Kamalaxi w/o Virupaxi Malagali
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Household Work 2012
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
142 Shri.Basangoud s/o Maruti Ramapuri
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2012
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
143 Shri. Siddappa s/o Mookappa Muttennavar
Aged: 32 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2111
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
144 Shri. Sunil s/o Fakirappa Tukkar
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2122
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
145 Shri. Chintamni s/o Vishnupant
Deshpande
2126
Aged: years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
146 Shri. Anand s/o Vishwanth Pattar
Aged: 51 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2131
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
147 Shri. Adiveppa s/o Somalingappa Malagali
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2147
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
148 Shri. Basappagouda s/o Kadappa 2056
17
Bhadrakali
Aged: 53 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
149 Smt. Parvati w/o Mallappa Heganaik
Aged: 52 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2160
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
150 Shri. Abhijit s/o Shivaji Bhagat
Aged: 38 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2161
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
151 Shri. Vinod Rajshekhargoud Patil
Aged: 44 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2162
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
152 Shri. Sanju Somling Malagali
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2170
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
153 Smt. Meenaxi w/o Ashok Magadum
Aged: 42 years, Occ.: Household Work 2177
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
154 Shri. Anil s/o Mallappa Gundlur
Aged: 37 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2183
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
155 Smt. Shankuntala w/o Basavaraj
Sangannavar
2185
Aged: 39 years, Occ.: Household Work
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
156 Shri. Shivangouda s/o Yalagouda Padguri
Aged: 41 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2189
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
157 Shri. Shivashankar s/o Maruti Malagali
2191
Aged: 30 years, Occ.: Agriculture
18
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
158 Smt. Parvati w/o Maruti Malagali
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2193
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
159 Kumari Nirmala d/o Maruti Malagali
Aged: 29 years, Occ.: Household Work 2194
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
160 Smt. Mushavva w/o Ningappa Bharnatti
Aged: 58 years, Occ.: Household Work 2196
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
161 Smt. Gouravva w/o Lagmanna Andakar
Aged: 57 years, Occ.: Household Work 2197
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
162 Shri. Chanabassu w/o Fakirappa Modagi
Aged: 55 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2201
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
163 Shri. Siddangouda w/o Lakkangouda
Modagi
2211
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
164 Shri. Basappa s/o Gangappa Tukkar
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2229
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
165 Shri. Sanju s/o Chandrappa Malagali
Aged: 34 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2239
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
166 Shri. Goudappa s/o Basavaneeppa Padguri
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1271
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
19
167 Shri. Kallappa s/o Irappa Gavannavar
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1281
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
168 Smt. Lata w/o Shivaji Bhagat
Aged: 55years, Occ.: Household Work 1468
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
169 Smt. Shailaja w/o Sadashiv Deshpande
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1478
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
170 Smt. Savitri w/o Basawanni Gavannavar
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Household Work 1823
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
171 Shri. Sanjay s/o Appanna Jabagoudar
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1842
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
172 Shri. Murugendra s/o Virupaxi Aragavi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Coolie 1843
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
173 Shri. Sanju s/o Satyappa Kurabet
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1844
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
174 Shri. Prabhu s/o Rachayya Hiremath
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Coolie 1851
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
175 Shri. Rajedra s/o Shivaputrappa Malagi
Aged: 35 years, Occ.: Agriculture 1997
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
176 Shri. Ramappa s/o Nagappa Masti
2087
Aged: 51 years, Occ.: Coolie
20
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
177 Smt. Mahananda w/o Balagouda Sutagatti
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2090
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
178 Shri. Mallappa s/o Shivappa Katavi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture
2097
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
179 Shri. Irappa s/o Mallapa Katavi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Coolie
2098
R/o: Ramapur, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-
591346
180 Smt. Savitri w/o Mallikarjun Malagi
Aged: 43 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2105
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
181 Shri. Shivanappa s/o Basawaneppa
Khanagani @ Khanagouda
2115
Aged: 60 years, Occ.: Coolie
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
182 Shri. Shivangouda s/o Rudragouda Patil
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2158
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
183 Shri. Shankargouda s/o Rudragouda Patil
Aged: 42 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2157
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
184 Shri. Basangouda s/o Rudragouda Patil
Aged: 42 years, Occ.: Coolie 2179
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
185 Shri. Mallikarjun s/o Balappa Mugalihal
2200
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture
21
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
186 Shri. Holeppa s/o Ningappa Khocharagi
Aged: 50 years, Occ.: Coolie 2215
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
187 Shri. Lagamappa s/o Ningappa Khocharagi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Coolie 2214
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
188 Shri. Shankar s/o Adiveppa Wali
Aged: 54 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2250
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
189 Smt. Shailaja w/o Sadanand Wali
Aged: 48 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2251
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
190 Smt. Sudha w/o Shankar Wali
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2252
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
191 Shri. Kalmesh s/o Sangappa Malagali
Aged: 46 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2256
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
192 Shri. Basangoud s/o Nagappa Pawadi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Coolie 2258
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
193 Shri. Kareppa s/o Maruti Dandai
Aged: 35 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2260
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
194 Shri. Somashekhar s/o Maruti Malagali
Aged: 35 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2263
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
22
195 Smt. Mahadevi w/o A. Hegganaik
Aged: 40 years, Occ.: Agriculture 2264
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
196 Shri. Rayappa s/o Bhimappa Hiratangi
Aged: 45 years, Occ.: Coolie 2265
R/o: Hudali, Tal. & Dist.: Belagavi-591346
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI ANAND KUMAR ASHTEK AR & AKSHAY
KATTI, ADVOCAT ES)
AND
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
6TH FLOOR, M.S. BUILDING,
BENAGALURU - 560 001
2. THE PRESIDENT
THE HUDALI PRATHAMIK KIRISHI
PATTIN SAHAKARI SANGHA NIYAMITHA
HUDALI, TAL. & DIST.: BELAGAVI - 591 346
3. THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
THE HUDALI PRATHAMIK KIRISHI
PATTIN SAHAKARI SANGHA NIYAMITHA
HUDALI, TAL. & DIST.: BELAGAVI - 591 346
4. THE RETURNING OFFICER
THE HUDALI PRATHAMIK KIRISHI
PATTIN SAHAKARI SANGHA NIYAMITHA
HUDALI, TAL. & DIST.: BELAGAVI - 591 346
5. THE DISTRICT CO-OPERATIVE ELECTION OFFICER
AND DEPUTY REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
BELAGAVI DISTRICT
DIST.: BELAGAVI - 590 001
23
6. THE CO-OPERATIVE ELECTION COMMISSION
REPRESENTED BY
ITS COMMISSIONER
3RD FLOOR, TTMC A-BLOCK,
SHANTINAGAR,
BENGALURU - 560027
... RESPONDENTS
(BY SRIS.S.HIREMATH AGA FOR R- 1.
SRI H.L.HAVA RA GI, ADVOCAT E F OR R4- 6
RESPOND ENT NO.3 A CK WITHOUT S EAL)
THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER
ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION
OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
APPROPRIATE NATURE AND DECLARE THAT SEC.
20(2)(A-IV) OF THE KARNATAKA CO-OPERATIVE
SOCIETIES ACT IS ULTRA VIRES OF ARTICLE 243ZI AND
243ZO OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, 1950, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY & ETC.
THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS
THIS DAY, THE COURT, MADE THE FOLLOWING:
24
ORDER
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and learned counsel for the respondents.
2. Both counsel submit that the issues in controversy in these petitions are squarely covered by the earlier decisions of co- ordinate benches of this Court in the cases of
(i) Shekappa s/o Shivappa Saravand and others V/s State of Karnataka, W.P.No.136699/2020 and connected matters dated 28.02.2020;
(ii) Chapparadahalli Vageesh and others V/s State of Karnataka, W.P. Nos.138960-139031/2020 dated 11.03.2020;
(iii) Tadakal Woman Milk Producers Co-
operative Society Limited and others V/s State of Karnataka and others, W.P.Nos.204109-113/2018 25 and connected matters dated 13.03.2020.
3. Under these circumstances, these petitions are also disposed off in terms of the aforesaid decisions in Shekappa's case, Chapparadahalli Vageesh's case and Tadakal Woman Milk Producers Co- operative Society Limited's case supra.
Ordered accordingly.
Sd/-
JUDGE CLK