M/S S K Enterprises vs State Of Karnataka on 21 February, 2011

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M/S S K Enterprises vs State Of Karnataka on 21 February, 2011

Bench: B.V.Nagarathna

-*%%E§é?~§

£3.

rm]

9.

5%}. 

RPZE3', BY TVS MA.N'AG-§.N€3 I:).1R§€C:TC)§{
K 1% 1'-'{€}A{i), ISJXNG-ALCBR 'ti-5f30 (32?

Susi-»1I'z1;'1f1~-I_A M£.£I.)iC?.AI.,S Am') r-1c)sI>1'_rm. {:53} .£j..¥Ti'.')'-_ 
"1'1~u:=: I?3ANGA_£,{)E%ZI'£ 1~--§::s3P1'1:sxL  W "  
# 2302. R V :a>:.<:);x13 

s3<:>Lm--1 £='11\EI.) CZIRCL['~3. §%3AE'€'£}A_i,,{T>R.I€,--56{} 0.0' ,
m'1'1's E\r'EAE\§AC}1f\3(} 1.)1ma:C"r«:>1r2 .. 
M/53. SANMAN I*IO'I'E.L

_I\EO.4, R  ROAIf)

IE3/'d.\='G-A.[,OR£§~560 004 _ _ -

BY ms MANAGING Ii>1R';.:.c*_mR

M:/S. SA1'~é.MAN LODGE;    
sommi ESNEID c1RCI;:.B;. :\3<)'4;I?2uvVRQA13
BANGAi..ORE~560"O£i4_ 3 1» g "  
BY ITS MANAGING 1:>;:aRm_r:R.

SIWF. M A :;;gus:sm.«1 ;Tj§)a./'zx<:x?i'?;¥:,_j:_a. V' 7' 
No.2oQ;{1 Am-1:32V0'0/:3   

3_QLzi1jr3iI V .1-:_i:\fi':> ;;§:,1_:<CL::;' R x:...:-x:c>£xr>
ESAZN GALIQR£§»v 1550' 0-04

:;,;sxr;$:»»i1v1: $1313'-:A:s,:;>F<;R=.__  " __

A §{Ii§C}If}. PARrNra§2§r~i1'1p rrmvz
R/A'1*«.200, LP«_}{x":-1.1"--ilk/1.';.5'I'OWE';RS

, 1§<:§§:s31~»1;i;'m }EﬁV£%.'U3)1%§EJA'&rf%§ R V Ram)
» NB}:-ER so  §3'N.::> CIRCLE?

 A  ':~3;«%x;N<:;A:4<:>R1:w56(> 004

= 1. _ 335,37':f;.'§s_rv:..z3:\IAc;:Nc; [.)IREC'1"OE'{
' mf1f;::s:*Jtxrv*AraA '£¥ZA<I}
':_::z::'v~:."L;§; f£§i{}M'PA.N"xf'
 r<{?;,:.%, 3%: V §?{O1-'_'aI}

sG.g;':*:T»; EENIJJ Cf1¥.E'{CZLE%1 ¥;3;?aE'€C1«A.L(}'I.%ZE§--560804
mi ms MAi'~3A{}H\;f{} i>*AE{'E'F\§.£¥:E-?;
(4 . §¥{§~iEEéPiZ}§.'€iL3£%Z§'~E'§T$

.£3fg:  gm; :::>§::a<:>:z:.<:. {i§{}'%i~='§};'§., ;x_:';v: ;«'§::»§% 51:2 & R2:

f:j§«R.E;§§'E§.Fv§2'1§,LE§€:%.E€:_§ 1.§.1T'«§;"-'3.§.f1EE. E'§{,7{,%E5} §"'{}E{ _¥?€.L §%§'z§"§',§»'E.$§_E'§'v'E;%é'€

' "  z--:;:__:_,:<;-isz, §a.;%f§'%;". E9'<iL%E"%Z grey; E-SSJRE_Ei§:"=~,N§'§§iE%E"i,<_§.{Lff§-'§{f3E.§'§z'%? s":Eli>'%f ;>*s:>§a
225; K

3»,



%%

W1.'-XE{I'3 (j}]fi'{7L¢? }\§o,:?§€) ('1'.i'wre is no }"I.L£?71b€'I' a:53z';c;I'"aee:i

£0 i'.iIi$}, (1 prmafe }"€;?SiC3::'?'ECé? aE)uf"I.z'r1§; file sa17'ze3._
1"c)z.z,2a:'ds {he Ja;;c2nc1gc2.r fﬁiris-&.>, No.8  Iilizmi <z.r1.V(:z'.~-__ 
C{31"3'"ij}{UI_I_ ,2 E3a,r1m{1:2 L<;>dg<3d, z\:'c>/I Scmmcm  * 
G ~%~ 1, No.2, N E' M<>{oI's., §oi.:1c1.1'a:i :.»:" L-
l:3asaz.,:czr'zc1§;zm'£ Side, are r'1{).1J.§'[ifVe§_£., in' "C3'?"2(§}'i';:1:_éj€3 
I(M. 12.2%? to K.;w22,4()r:z' am j; c';Lga'3§_;j  
acquzZsi.£:'foz'2 rjgf pr()pcr{'ie:I; t f:§3  '.g§r'z)péz9;_f¢$ - $11"  "
ANNIEXLIRIS J and J») 5;  gm» p}ape:f:4':'e"sV 
H0111' fieci c:m:> ADIJIFJD f3rc){2§%?"i;; I5?{_)z'i:'i{)}"z'  
Ahr7Ied.s f'r<>{2er1g.}: "ior.L:c:;i'fis_  ,J{xg5(az'zag§i}' 
and I'3rc);Jerz',y No.4'? {J '  Properig;
{Sri .N:3us v.Shaz'1;';:'."' " 'No.5:2/ I 2
prope3r:'§__} V J :i§l.1I?'}ci§;2§.}'i4 .:3E,V firV'.-flﬁayaprakasiy,
I3:'r)_1r)i%24r;I,y::.";§\£;r5f.ZQ3 ()*:[Y:'v:,£f".s'7.Q1'V.ii}?)"§,1   Pz'opc=ri.g:,r No.18

7?1rfczrjr_;':in€;::'fj:..«.S?7r3{.Z£i1€Z:iLzrzis4sa zfncludcd a1"bz'E.rc1r'iig;;

2. VV;1§\j_g1;,1?1V<;? V{;1,IE1E;t:3i'L'..§{j."' §'}€C1€SS3€i1"y 10 $i:z3't<f 1:%}2a1.E. duz':ing

th§%.§.;<}L,1:'s;e sf é§:':b:}'1issi(3r1, Ie:a1:m:>.d {éc>u11s3€§_ {Gr p<:E':i"?Li(>'1':=t%§'ss lizis:

. fiiggd an _:T:'*:~-€§:V;.1;§~"ssi.at:i:1g i.ha%:. pet.iiTi(3£1:%r:s .1 mad 2 W:::»:.:1d nut, press;

" i"_h¥c*.§:f« 9;x:§'§é..,.__ jg.9§%'i%i,ic:2:'1s; anti z'1<:a::_>1"c§.§z'":gg§§.»: by <,m:Es:-22° {is-Liaxi

}5,!'?;._€).i i.v,""C.§2<: w':'§'£ p:'?Eii,i:>.31s.§ wa?:.'€: cfésa:32i:'_eEa«¢:ftr:.§  zmt; ;:>:"::%ss:~::%d

' ::":_r€::§§§a>,<*:: of z:g21%::':$:. }.3«:ii:i§'it}r1€*1°s 1 and 2. '§"E'1a=%re:=éf<>'i't;: HIE?
"-'_E.'}V3""¢';:§{",§°:'~3; :'n2=.1{§<? in E..E."z.e;>: ax;:"i'E'. §}i'Z'§i'€'.§{}§'§3:§ mi: 2?} 1:30 éztix" 22:5»; gs-:'E.'i§.§{:3':a.s3::'s%;

V  -13 U}  tjizééyu "».%:'§":-iffe :¢,.E'mf§E ff"z<¥iémi.:':2.1§"i.:?é:* bi: i':;?£"s:i*:";21={:i E10 2:29 i"§'E{:'.

Q

gin: £L..i.'§' Em": :%  , 



 

d€£:i$'i01*: 3% the Apex {Lauri in Hark: -«v.~« The State cf

Rajasthcm (1952 S.C.R. 110).. He has 313$ E'£3i'5.i€I'8.f€jV.§V"'1'é'.'1>E"'?.:

ihera has been §"a2-writism Shawn ta rasgondent ?~§:e;§'.'8«i*;;<3.:i§§:i7:t;_. 

anﬁ hence, be submits thai 3 d.irec1:.ien has_.isa,$f§;£:§;if   

rgspandezizi -~ authariiies ta ::o::siider_ ii:,e"«__~::;is'6.  

peiitiszmers far denatificaE;i0:1 G1' §%s§:::iusit:31 frrgin acq.'uisiii0n';*.

2:3' Cotissel for :i<3$;,.;:;'::*1df:%ffL:s"%,;?§ "a;VrV;'iyi:i-.,','z 'feLdo"'3:§r;ec1 the
gubmission made by the   ;§€I3!'i'(:3gé'.AA".fZ'¢II;;}'iS€i and the
§ear.r1ed Gevt, P§ea'€I:§1:*.haé§_%i{éé_:'V:§.d{§§1£§';§,@e'VVjs§;bmissign made
by the 3enioz:'éb1§:_n§§i:i  ﬁéspgndent No/L.

  and an peruse} 535' the
material V3915;   that the prayers Inacle in the

Writ pe_1;ié;ions"'~3.ré ism i'::>_1e:i3;*~"::)r1&§ is w:i1h ragiard ti: chaiienge

 «.vf::aé5._ }E0;_..$;h£_ aeqziisi-man r1£;»tifi.<:ati.0:':s and the secend, is

 V__s'<;:eki:1g »;{'~di.tfét=t,_i_:31'; ':0 the regﬁosrzéani »=- autgheritieg :0

C$3ﬁa§§'ﬁ&rHi§*;§ r;9§s;£éx 0f the petitienerg far d€§€€:.i:"1g thelfr Ianés

--V frem. $.£.'*.q:):§,siiLiiQn.

V' r   Thaugh the sgacsné §}I"3§f€7£" E333 1&3: bean maﬁa in

  many wgrés Eva: having :*aga§*é $20 2%? namre gf the

 §§E"3,}:"€2'§ maﬁa as a§}:ez*:2a:ii.*<;§ EEE'-§1}?=:E.£"'S :2:-=*i%;?:_ regaré is} me

8;{'E€§,E§8§?;.iQ}'§, {#55 z'E':».:é iixacé reagiziremﬁxﬁ. {sf §8;..ﬂ§ anﬁ. ﬁﬁ-EEG wiih

 



§}f:'11.i'§.iC}§'}.:%§ artci the W1'i{. axpgzrzéaisz fiieci by t:Eé<-3 petii.i0r'1€rs;. §1e1"<~3i1'1.

E-'§c4>\2v¢3vc1*. it is 'éhe (:0§1i.{3.1'1t'.2011 of the ]::?211"m?d {*.0uns;<-31 ifo"r--.»1.E"1€

p<;*.t.;'.'z,i(;2'1er3;z":§ '$113.1. the disa:pc:o:'s€1§ 03' W.P.No.8452X2GD8._b*3Q' 2.'C:i '--(}f}<
{Tie joirﬁ: ZI'}f;'.I?{1G 2-mc.1 i'.h€. a§;f1*ecr11§:1'1t: ::rt'1i'e;"'§:t.d  
I"{:?S§p(}I1Cf§€i'1'§. N'c:'}.4» w1'i}:'1 2"t%spo1':dr:%2'3.:  2.{'i'§{'1 (:..i%}<:17s.-§;'?i.;:a$3 g*;'é}?cé1i'g

21 C',£:1{.I:'-St? of a,Ct,i.o.n to the pet[i§,io3'1C'1::3 '£11.35:-; i';1.1.1.c::h «.2x:§;. é~}.}é"

pei.it,ic>m:1."s ct:-'sat: .'r:21v<>. also  to
c£eiet:§1'1g t.ht::z'.1" .1ands: fmr:'1, §j"€IC1{ii§5ii§.;.gi"i"'(if"ﬂ'¢}3()£.i'f3fi:I1.g  821316;'.
In this €:@111..€*.XEg it': is tiﬁéf'  Cc)Lm:?;eI for {he
§}(:T3..i1.i()I].<:fI17E:3 herr3j1; 1" ihzxt. :'i:}§Ht§ '   :':ﬁ.z1.11<>1~1'1.i€s have

21(,'E.f3d in 2-1  r*Q:.1gfA§if;_s_--_;.}_'1c§{14' _11L1:~..;n1'~--._:'<xfj in  12-u1c:11 as i,1'zt:y

{ie11'1c}1.i.:§ 1'1téd ﬂré'-3, 1.)1'c5pc:;?t:1c:.s_ and i,al{<31'1 p(,>:3.9€-::ssi()11 0f the

[)et§§;i.(3m:r:'s: p1'()p(::1jEi€.£§ viIi"~1_pi*a?"\:i{>1z1i,i0n of [aw emd w1'E.if:0uL

c<>1.1.sid:2_ri:1g I':}r':;>fé~ <%2:a,,s:e £121' cierxoti£'i:;:2a.ij.cJ::.

  E95.'  in  Ei,g,§E1t. of §.hf;'.S£Z'; i3a<:k;;:"<m.:';{i .{°z:<:f.s, "§'h03..

ASE3E'1fE-%:?E1'il§.{§Vf'i.E3  i'Z:}_:'if€§g€:.':{§ '£13,-' §.i'1¢:: ;."m*;iiE:i01'1e:r$ with :'2Eg2::"d if} i.h.€}-°

'zasjiigg diéééa::'§_1'é:fs.£t'1a'i.ed E3}? éizize :"<:s;3:>:1{[i€z';i, 2-:1.3é:§'§<>:"ii..1'@s=;; 21:11:? ms:

K  '-p£'e?:.yv;=:r §s::}_:i'g;;i'1't: 5(1):" €it:7§.eti<3:'1 £)f§I'::?i2° p.:"r:31:3€':;"'E'.i<:?s§ §1":.m': 2a?1:?q:.,:i§s§*;.£é:}:'":

 -P:_1;a:;:.«~i§3, 5;': be E":{f)E'§.i'5,'s§€f§€,",fI'<':'.{§..

32; E2': é"§":§sa a.;'<..;.:'§*£::'%:<;'£.1 £3. witsuizi ;2:.§s"«;<> bi? EE§':'?€'{'?i$??~§1E"};' in

" 2~:{§2-1&1'? é:::« mg' 5+:-:.z%T§:;"2.é%%;:%::é.:'>3": 2z':s'2§,:E:'?: E;}}: ihéé §f;f'é'1E'§'2€.":':{"§ i€%i,'?i'}§€3-E" ::':{;m'z;i¢;:?§

E52' :"<%:2's;:}:';:'*:<i:%u:3€  amE'E'1:'§;"i£.i_:-:3; éE'1;2_.€.. in saga; {air  §.E':s_* ';>a%i§'E.§{>:"::?:":*=,





 . i.h@i1* .. {:2-,1'

f}t'"T'i'.H,i(}1'1é?}'E5 i.1'1<111'1{ii1'1§;>; the ap;)€:§§;1t1i5.~3 ':3r;7fb1'c'-2 Ehtif Apex C()L1I'i.,
'§'1'1e Apex C'cm1't' 11()':<'?{1 aha: by o1"e:§c>.r dzziic-;=ci 28/2/ }9_§}_f3, I3

E;-H161 :;3wm=%.z's:e' i2:11'1<§s \v@:1"e ]'f£1(_T'.E:'iS,3{;?d f:"c)1:n 22(:{;L:.1's;;iii.i<ia:a'1".V..  -'

 

rna.t,t.e1' of §"£li('f'i.§ 12211":d$ (;;f1'1'":<;)1'e 1.E'1an 40 izmd <.>w1"1_r:5£=sa <){.1V'k ."§jf-711.1-«:4:

sa:'1'1e 21{T.QL.liSif'.i(f)I'1 p:'()r.3<:?edi:1g§s E32216} 't):--?r.éiI.f1._ :'téI.e%;.:.éééci" iT1"1:%> i3.t21§\¢ '

Cx(}V*3'I"Z1Z'}}€?I1i. u1'1der Sf3(T1,i()}'1  of iihrs 2:1.Iid_ '1.~}'1é?it »':§{.1:V:I}':1'ﬁ?VV:7.i";'1_lA"

the miezzse ozrders had b€E(211"K;)E:E§_3S€2C1 1-:11 :*esp:;1:.{_?£.  ::j)I'...1'_:11me .r12md--. L

€J"WI}E'.E'$ who he-Ki I101' €;'.'v'E21'1 <*fi:v;.1.i3€:1"1gec;1" «1.,.E'_1<: 21(§c;1:1is§i'.i0I'1
prc}C€c%diz'1gs and S(i§E":2.Q of; I,kfu31't'i=.. Ei12iL%_ CI'121].Ien.gec1 the
actcggaisiiiozl p1"occ_ecii11gs,..'b¢::1"c>§"e .i};e "I'-~3'1":Tg;}_'1"V-- LCbu1*1:. and é;'.}':ost:

{$2.186-E3 xsvccm ? 11c)*;'}}~'rcc§cj1'1'11é1éi1de£i._?;:~}*"'--*i':i°1€ <T:01'11mit,E':c:e fer

\>vi¥;.11d r;9.\,v211 (§i"7Ié1}_.1cj&213<1:q141i;s:'%«.i<)17_a:'1ci Wh()s€ w':".:'.i, p«::i1'1.i<'n;1s were
c§is2»I"I1isss_-3&1. «But hi 'ii2€)S'i,»_§i1'~{3a'<§t ('.2.1SCS. the 21w3.1'(.i-53 hat? been

passseci 2aé.'1";«r:I  vi'.hs:<1t{-3a£it_,é13.L. the Siziée C2()\:*e1"I1 11123131 had

w'i.i'..h.:;_*imvaré §1"{)i'1;~ ._;1(:q:2i.sit4i(31'1, whiC:.h W215; }E{,'J'l. E1116 :;:a..=3<5: {sf t:i'1<-?

"'re:e;'§:<3::{ié*:'u;5éisA, i.11ttméIi: fez' 'wi.1hci:z'2;m'21E {F0121 2-1.c:qui.sii.icm £31}

 L_f"éi~:§7<}:f:r _{>T'i»7._&31,%{:ii3_ _§;»>_z'1c§ €)VJI'§€;.'§'fi:§ £'12?:.d E3@e1'1 in *x,>"'§<}§2.1E"£c3:'1 <3! any

.€;E.i-;1_.z4:'i.::;:'§,? .;.:t*s;;;«:£:<3<§§::g;?s=s er c:{>:'1.1.:*21r}r' Lia Eaw w1r1.i<~h wzrxss a1.sés<.> r1.<>':.

:'f~€ w'ii.§3 £':§'1<? :'éii.c:2:-132% <3? t'.I:1t> EsrI"z£§ bt%§;<f2:':ci swig:1i.si:..ic.m

 

r§'12:::§'*-%}<t{'7:'1 <?z":'§:':g 2-z(:§,i<;};'1. 27:2"; £1E'1€*i:" §:)a;'E.. 0:" if 'i£»'£-15%; aizms'-4% aim: ix}

s¥;e.-®>:'2.i:§f% §':'2£:-:ﬁ£.:':%<;{;* 5.2:' §'.:'.Z2Ei'3f.E"2"2§"}-" K} e;:;";.jg: §:u.%:3§£<": i§':%'t_~> g

2



110], to the? effeczﬁt, tlmi. 21312.: raé _]'1.1:~:s1:.""z{'i:*_-: 1"€*qL1iI"€*.S "that" E:><:é.f0r'é: .21
law ('7z1§'1 %)eC(.)1'31_c:=. c)13<;?;~;1i.iv:=% ii: rz'11,1:-st {)6 ;}z'c)z111:1g21'£',:z-rj or

p11b1i.:_-:;hr:é.ci. 550 L.§'12aiT the people :'i'1z::y §i:'1Gw a.'¥3<311[: ii. is  iii}

aS:~5is¥;2;1n(:(2 to the: pe1.i1.1":}:'1ers; in as 2"n1.1cIn 2-.18 U- 1'ér SE?1('1VC:i"~.:(TfE1SE?-,

:"e:t3;£1*;.£%(.i to the I'I1€'.I'(ff paisgézigg of {he 2"€r_.e:c)Eui,i<}1'1fc::{ {hit.C<)Li:'1<;5.i1 ()'*f:"_V
i\rii:1ist.t:1*s V'.-="i1.If1€)1_I{'. furtlnaex" p11bi§.(:z11i(§'z:1. {ifP"33;'3'1Ti1:¥3§€1.'§4iOFI ~T5L1""'«'i.«-'f71:'n"T'--:

iaw \K.?'i'}f:}'€'.?i1'1. it. W8.S held 'i.ha'i. i'.h€"bjZ1l31€fA"Was i.1'1f5;1_1.fi'i€.}i'tCvE7!1., est) as r

1.

0 rnake {he law ()[)€I'£1fi\_="€ and }_1Q1u}'CC_.'J£1i"p'L1.i""Q}}i'L11'i:}.§ACE, W'£?1S not t:}1ere§c')I"e. 21 \:"ci1.1'Ci""-}5;:'1'\3,£»'_. 7 321*}; }i'r.:$3i'.2m{, C858, xlcm f1:rn1's3hi2.'1g of s':3'fr;:*;1'1z11.i(:z'z "§3:%i'"1,2ii.1--1.j.n:g 1,{)v_ dE:'..<3ig1"1 of the S0'L1t'§3 Eild I\/Iain) SI4é_::i<):§f 21_:a3d iztéiiét" re%1.:1i:ed §;2i{E'ti§3 to ihezt pe:'i.ii':i<m€i's:§ <fa.I11'10t;' k1215¢E%= 't31%f_V2éI;£'i_1'1g;'A_€)r41 1h€%'R?21ii{1i1.y of the 21c:q11iS1'ti():"; 1101* xs'0%;,--=:1ci«_giVe :1' °{.,%a:L.1séT'-~.,o'f.. aCti<)r1. to 'the pei.i1;1'0;';ers to ctllallajxage '{'Ii'r;: $3Ei1'I3'L",'E211"E_h€'~~eff()E.'1f,ﬁ"r)("I of Thff (:(m'1}')rc)1:11i.se, é?nt€re«:i " * _ i13i..§§.?.?itEE1V reg;>(}1";.Cib';';€;..P4EA().

_V ~'"%3;«.,ij*:.1 'fl}'.1i_E?s' <?m'1t:::%xé,§ ii wcmki be 1'1<%<':@ssa1:*y ix'; 21dve::r'é, E0 é;E1.u:%--s;%z:2{:i$i_%§_3;:s';:{%§b:°r€te:i E3}? i.h<:=. 2&1:-:ar:1é:*c:.i &.=se:T1§{:1" <'s3Lz:'}s<:=:i £13: §;'h:°t §'&:;<Ts;§"<w:1e;'1':- €~:A>2z':'£' ' ¥ :9. "L1.[§"i{)1'1'i'I§£3é'-3; 2:} £21 ~:.ra-asst: (sf Ramnilclai Riﬂhutta arid zarmthasrg '£5? Stafe 0f ﬁfaharashéra ﬁﬂﬁ ﬁfhﬁrsy :'e:i§'}{:::"'z&:i§ in {MR V M§§§"? SSS £238: ii: ';'1;?z_5::» E325:-i;'1 '§é.a?E<'§ ?;E':at' "a;%,'§'§tE¥'": aura;:4:.ife:ii.:%:'::.":. 2':'::':{E:'é ébg' {Em?s;?E:'§;f;:'z2<§':':2 <2! iz1.§":fai%E.:':::"'§:.:;~:"2§ §'23%z<'%iiii'.%a:%§5§ 'ax:-'E'":&;=2'é;:*§§:':.. ~,»,._~.~».wxw-/»:;«,-w.\~v»zw>aw»«//;=osm< %% ;.>'L.'1};:§;'(*. i11t"':3.r€:5.~:i i:.'1.\«'c)1v<;?ci :":';L::;'i1 2,1Cq1.1is3.ii',1'.(>:'"; })1"(){T€f;':'diI1§§S Cziiumt. ':36 iz1'{'::?1'f'CI"<-3:3 wit}: by tfiw <ZT.01.u'i.. L.t.:'1.i<3£-3:; s:f;tjc>:1g; 1'<"221s¢::s:}s are I.}"1€3.df3 01,21". for qL:2155h1'.1'1g {he 2zc%<gL.z:%:s;i£.ic.m. V b] In ca5:;e:r <31" Girias Investment and Another v. State of Kamata§t£i»Vﬁhd._ >;.~¢;_-,~'p_c}':"Vt"edV". in [(2008) 7 sec 53]. it has been 1§'::1d"Q{;;.:-. 1.f1_<};ig§h.'~ of izadiviciuais are '(.0 be .1'¢:..9g:>z:»':c;:t":%..cf;'=.;1{%q1.1.£.:sitié>:1Tfor V'i:}en%:.I"ii'. {Jf public: at .1a.rg€: <)ugghI'. 1101;' 30 be i..%gMEj;'~qi.é':3sE1ec:§.. {1} A55 fan' as the 't-c*,h{:it;i<.-'. c(>1'1Ce;"11ed, in case of and Others.

r<:;:>c;s"te§;i itﬁtV_v1 has 1:vee":1'1 held them the $L1ii.a113i1it_%J 'mf ViL:£'}t:?.'~.V§2:11ftC§'a(?C§_LI.iSi'{.iOE1 is; 21 1":1.a'{'.1.eI" of sa.t':i5;fa_ciii<.>r1 Cf Lflc 'VG()A\?_<;t1911i:1e;1£.. which has {.0 be igpassed an " * £11:-.{i ()1::E1t;4.i""1?--::--:2sQ11s and it wmtid not be Dpﬁii it}? 8.1.3 fji€.;11E*i.<s_ I'.'<:r_ 'E§i"i--diI1.gs an .s"s2.:c}1 ;f;1.:-éas. A id} V. '$2189 (sf 0m Prakash and Another v. State Raf ELF." arid ﬂthers, r<:%p<)1"t:<::r:§ in [ (1998) 6 S66 11. it. has:

x'%}i;'vi'fEE '.'§_'%£';§§{§ 1:'E'::z:f:. w§::.<;.=n E'E'12.7{§{f:§"iT;l';§.-' {IE Ezmd c>w;'}€:: hziwéaa 2i{:<:€g.}¥:,:;%{i '%;E';<§? 2-.=;.{?<;:.:is§ii.£z:::':. mg: 'w':":'i ;.3a:i§é.£<:m. §'i.k;*.£'£ Evy £2": §f"e:;%:z=" Egztzzii {>v;3:1:::%2*.<; _ 9?

{.';£1":E'§{'§€. '::§<;i% §:.'?:E':;%:"£'%31'<=?{E xi-*ii'§';. Ezafg £..h<: Eiigggjié €i.ZT<'}:.:r*'£. ..=»,=.. m\w.wm...Mv/////>ar2.«»<~,x»-ca'/,"er/2'/>>9>r/,a;.

C202':5;i.ii'.L:§.ir:)z;z:1E 1'igi2i 1'1z1$ }."3€?f3Z".'a in z;2.1'1y way vi.<}T£21t.e<1. '.1.'his.-is C()¥_EI'T. 1'.I"I€.I'C§(3E'(:'. (".'2'1E1I'10i §'i}§h'.'.E"ff;'.I'€'7 ill SEICI1 i"1"1E'1TI'{If;'.1'$L

45. IE. {}I'1('_f€? 21gg21ir1. Q1:3s€.'rv€:i illai, 21 s;<3.C(}1'14:i".:fd':;1;§f:'€iCf §ii.ig__§.:»u,i.01'3 112:9; beerzz :%:(::éé.ia1.e{3 by {§'3¢3. ;}ei4§1i»:::*:e;"ss*;..'_in Vs:r> "i-'31' <:11.zi1I::ex'1g;:é made. by ims. ];3e%t4itio:1"e:1":::--. ¢ tz:j_ 21g:.:'};u.i'5:ii.Vi{>ri'¢. is;

(:()1':<rc::1*m%d. The writ" pf,'.€ii'.i()E1-S '.21:1*£>_ "c1is1'§1i:3s3<9d 221'::: '«.:j1'é:';€'. 12'121:im2:a.ir1a':)Ie, on the <:1:1.e1.i1c%1'1ge_I§'xac1cr ti)" IliiqtLi-E§§'i,i(5£'3:.v"V "

46, in far as iphze c:r>1¢?:Vi:'e;i':;£.{(;:'1Kviih 1':-3gé11*;i'A'iV0 s;see1:;1ng de1.<3i,i.0I1 of i,1.1€§.I.' E2-1r1dSV ;_i'1*oim,.giCC;';ii'ssi[%..i§i'i1. is C0n.ce1'r1ed, pe:1,iiiiC)m~?r5:§ £3.1':é.--§:iEs3.c_} 11:31. <-3f1Ii.§'{.I<:*(ii~,'t:3; 1'11€<«S}ai(:i reiief as the pet.i£ic1_fm*,rS I].G:V';C.';€iE._§E'3'{?.zbf 3..C.E.i0n {(3 E18. Ehesea writ p<;%E,i1',i()z1s éazaseci 0.12 «Ih@-- g2:1ss:_<?;~.g_ '<)fT._' 'H-.>.s}§;(>z1de:1t. N0. in f":-,1<::t. the _p<:i.iLi0I'1<--3rs 41211:": i(1L. .£11S§'vf) Stkék thfjil' lands bei:1;_;{ {leieied {H3121 21<:€1__i.fisij§;.i§}n.%_ as 25; ":':i;1£.'t,er of :':ig,§}1':,. A(:<?02"ci§:1.§;Iy, the wﬁi. p<:i.1'%,i§3f:-3-2» 'a1§'t:;' AvC§iSE1'1i.E$Sé?C§. IT~:I<)xv€:vc%11 I ref:'21'i1'1 fmm i:11p{>s-égzg 2'm.;; ':'%c}ss$;:5s 'i:5ij_ €'§*§€$<% ma1é,1e1'§-5;

gig"

§§§§§ >5':2':z;.;<;:

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court