Gujarat High Court
APPEAL FROM ORDER/54/2010 on 17 February, 2010
Author: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Bench: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?FQ? ? i??K# K?c??? ?c??f/kS)??e???P???:???V?\? ?\???bI.?wYJ?
b<~E??X?? ?K? xcI ??z>???cMi_\\X?z?-? .?| i?^? 8??.Iy??|?"!Q ?m? 6" ?bV K?8? ???%?p??M^B?EfV?:b^ M?r???????F,?;Q?0?� ?*?4? 4u?"??] z! `?? W?E?*? (b?O?P\}?? As vY??RHNp?? ?? P 5 ??N?? ???? h????Y Z????{?>>8j? y? q~?? ??!Y U?( ??I? ??~????'#? ??g??G????6??7?JN?o???9m????&?US?Z?u?x??}qv?b?!??q????:? / ????J??C0?U ? ?kc???????BgW]V'?+yg - ?Du =??ss>??%R:?? ?` ??? cH?'u??Su^? ???#?3??`&g" ??`?? 4$3 `?e???0??? ? ?w s?W ?\?^!?? ]?b???e}%AKy}Gn? u?w ? < ]4?Ew?_???"?????k???NJ ??P?< ?{f?? ? tT?? t??S9E?H[o? ??n?q??{??>k?? W?;?????? ???9" o??uu???2w@?UE? ?? cp?n ?? = ?? |uQ?m?_q??$!a?a ?& v ?V?}p?nGC?F?v??GH?.??:Nw?w?
?q??w?kHD?b ?
??j ???? x?_a?N???O?? ??( ??"!&??W??T?s???V?TL?? ?v ?0k $}I??? ??K?ll? ?k ???Nj??%m ??? ?_I�??(,??p? C. ??;?*|InB ?j?? C???'k+?z ? ?t ??8? ? ?_ G.? 42??? ???0?-???:???['??6?D??U??T ?R ? P?A ,??%?V?R? ??N (? }?$ q@ C?#h8???FT?? ? ?Z? ??D}? M? ?t y ?Db? ? ?w??J?b? ?j+?? c?b1~?RP s ??b? |l ?(??({?) ? ?aA?*?
}?+?zC??Xb ? ~?!?`.??p?O W?Pz?6 # /?wIBC?"??6Q G6m[??X??' &? ?bi??Fs? p ? ?S??hB%??'?Hi@s ?4^ ?@ U???a ?8D? R & (?T v )? ]?F?t??9 Uv?H2??o0? b ]?) ? ??K B N?L 9?_ =??? V5? ??[A2?Z?I? ?.j???Z???c?????\? PK ?HM ? ��>$��PK � � �?FQ<������������ ���styles.xml?ZK??6 ??W *?SeI~????4m? Rd7E??D?l$Q )???;$E?L??f??9 0??p8?3 ?_?I?{????R?? }L?/?x%-? K\??X????1???^0 ??&%??%??_?H?o??? ?? ?Eo@?qj?? ???a/ ???c 7?? ?T-? ??:]? ?w???f?Rz#?? Q????4?( i??xo n)-? ??L)6??? N3.#?M?r?
??G? R'n p??mp? d 7FQ ?TvJ??D ".?R???5? ?!??ST?u?l? nD ?R?????G?:??????g??v|???%H( 4dj\?/MT?pI????uN?? h ?? ? e?a?? ??|?xO? ?:?� ?-)? ??? ? ??K?~?.?????q?
??b#+y Z???/?i?�? ! 9?qo?+F??Q?M?u?{?QT ?Nu0P> ]?)??0?G ,it??d?Q? ? ?L?????.?DK*?,??? WR?? 7U? [?V? W$???E?Ue?(?T?8A?# ??]x8g????x ??S??E?X????F?8?
??}?.?]0tV@4(? ? ???*?xy3+?Jf??w&C=??< ?S v??"??v!?lMB?|Pp? ? ?? O?(}?lr??????2? ? ?#xy ^?? 7?
??3?J?1Y??C?[?%?y ??+? Xg uBs??G? ?? R ?Q? Z`H?%.?@ ?v?tk??r5?8z?? ?a? ?z^??l>?m s????W?^??{?N ?F?U?? ?? ??N?P v? ?? J3"?? cU?? ?6?
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 venu 2010-02-17T14:25:57 1 PT0S PK � � �?FQ<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??eT???&Z?P??^?hqw ???)Z?Cq?S?X I????)??P X)?n ? ??w?sg>?|I?:}?~?-???Z ?8? ?O????N???v?9???? ?N??? ?c ??"?$( X[Q w ?? ?8C?!? ;BG?#???( ???_?e ??nO ????q-V h? ?R? ? aw??? I?uD???? �y??\?p; ?e???]??O?d? ??1$??77 1? ;=??}?#??9?? )FT??CZ??? [??q?x?{??? C????\?bM)??p&?? D? ?F i????F???E!??6?? ?W?| ??pro? ? _y`?q???VI$?Q?? )? Y? ?? eUyh? n ???????r?>_?"V?[ ?% .? ?T??x!g ??C ???c?o{?1?pP] J??]? ?+G? ?x???i??7h?= ?`?Q[#)??2 9?bz ?7??|?H u??p? ? Ig???(?????g???????t!n?78?7|??kT?'s? ?x??f?o`? ?9Q\ER2 -ve?u???>? V ??ys?A q???`???{?7?LT ?%?\T?? u?F u??O?U??6 ?w?0Qx??C? N'?& ??{???D?? ??j'y??R???T&??[?y?Ue?$?? ?!G ? ?} Fz5???\;?F?v?9?}?#Cp?I(???????s]?n ?[? ;?W????l FN�?????V?]v? [???/f).??B?x[?S?8 RBk???H??1??w(?+?HBQ ?? ?R o? ?F??{U?V??;2kD?|/???e62?+4??VwEZp?? ?R ??{1????aLm0??x? ???dW?? ?x?S??X_?8?}??6??? q?d?a(B ?2, > ??[??????o5??OcG? ??? ?R%?,? ?b?m^:??FIe?d?5Z0???:?? ??p?+?"?? ?? T??5lC!nO?ddh?C??TU?z R? ???I??"R'?? ?Y$? �?7?J?>?L??s?h??B`?SU -u??;# a ??Z ??b*J?M `7?p?QQ?x ?D9y??S?P? ?_ "?????o?q?/?0yu(B w ?R?#{6Ml`Tx?m1ej?P???x?? ?F U??? u??? ????a?t_ ?8?rM???_BM?>?-| o=??Y?{1? t??�d&?lF5|?Z??e 5?z???^H ?? ?6?N??8| (!|y- ? C?!f?Nx? lb?K ?'�f? GG ?} ?iP?I?HLG?;???X?L? d??2!1q?? ?w ????b8??5:?? O??#U??P ? ?&?? $Z?? vyNi +????(??O??? ???y?,???J??h?R ??? +???) ???V?]@?? ?$??y?l? VD?0? %?:t??}!?Mc???A/*?g???? n s?3~ ???B?cY?
S?f?S31 ?F?? < ? ?o?$c?< CQM?_?T? ???7Js?c??R? ?!?[?dP?Gb?-^n?5?(??>?:? @?: ????/??K ,R UKn?4G* ???
?)n*???i??M S E? ??C6??}?l?9 @iW??Y?R?S??N?8?nCy?
???A ? grP?s ??~?h??0???? ? 5n/?'????? "??v?Y??? ? ?j'.z?\?`? ? ? .|??? 6??\?? r???????d?? 8*v3??v A? _cw ?G?????~? ??+?{?W#J? ??GHTq??4Ut?X?)?\?^?`"?cw{4??? %c?}?%??S??k ??? ?8Q2S?b?? ??2R ?1? ? ?O`IDZ�??.? ~ ~ ??
^??[?DN??H!i ?? ?cD?|Z ?? q_??6l ?\???n ?
R? ?V79]?? =?Ti ??E,>1? WM?+P?[)F La2? ??>??%M?jO\?? ?|???7H;?g??o?d?? ?Q=3i^? S??B??(?Pt?3? ?U"(Z{6??%??`?4??O=:1"?/??? ??? {? ??=? ?,?? ^ ?)+ ?? *???K?u ??1ed;?-} WG?? �0B{?iZ #6 f?\�?7?V ??a???w?v)?|*??-J?c??8;A?n?%??f????b?&?i?? ?> ???,??d?� ??t?Bi ? ?A ??l Q? ?n??)?????)?R(????v ?%? ?C&8?0?? ? ;kW?? ??& ?A85?_? t?? p?1??? ?@??4??"?uf\??p?S??! ????????0?P8?-$ ,?$???{?5??o?$??{?p??k{??fH? t_??]JXC0?]x?? S?i??s??a?(v?v???'??9??j? ? 8z ? ???????o??|??[???~?;???j ?A?j?
???? ?P????u@???? J~{z?E N???=$�*? -??zO??? ?1? ???_??\? m- ?
?T?z9??\?? ?9?H?$??\?{e;8 ?G!??t?I?V?0 : J Z 2,`/La??t }.? ??SZ?j>/?8?.??Ubu?} 4?? gOaQ?/??b???; ?w??Z?? ?gx?? 5<_$? ? ????[?b????[????op?p < ? ? ?? ?? ??@~??h??Q?=???j ?8 a|"@1 ???= \??)? ?iNIy??
o??^ ??7J R=Q; ^?f ????,R???^ ? ?Ut ?? ~;?oR?0^????? R?,?:??{B????3 ?J 3U?goFom??t??=" ??; | $*'???6G?Z? ??J.?h?n?c??c???)h?? 6??v? ?~? ! $ ???s(Y? L ?%)? ? ?Q ????;???[?x?????D.?? >??m&?`} ?CE??H?p1?,??K? ??? ???,??]^ H!?Q?DR??= XDarV?( k@Bh"?Y2e?=?ofw?Z\ ? p??0 ?? ? ???? ?? ???n< s?$q ?V?"i>m? X???g)9???ji-??u?M??*?-?d#/?%?58??"?pJ ?�???�? V+?w JZ?(k?
?
?? ?U???? 0??&?}C-w?? ?O ?A??B:Q?t5???)??o ?? aRl k5 ?n?Vm?e?:? ?4Q?:F2?? ? ? ??z$ ?Y? L?l?( ?? >a$?3_ &9 ?X?�?>??a??eK f?jUr??3�?G-})?s?K???C%Q? E x9? F??)??uw*?0*c? z�?VB?
1;T* ??????R?H??j ??su? ?)$ %'? ? ???n'? V ?&?tR? ??% ?? ? ????? G??a??G? |?O??G????c?B\ ?M?{#iWjv[? ??'/??e ? >y;??\??W ??p??N?Nb?????@yug"?E?c???g? ?w z@??j????c??]??+Am?5?Y]wL52 *i? ?,!EK u? U?????U?;w?[ ??]?? f??>? ???? (Z? ???{ ?BrD???CQ?? ??? %?? ?? e gWJ (?p{???6?pH>6g??j??9? xY^?+?Z?8????? P?? t?1? U?l??\G?W?? w7?JQ1x\~HK?7u?? r>2y1Z ? *? ?*?7 ??7?f??x?(5???F??I�eKgi?XTpR?????
y? 6?P~^l2????o[?? 3?^ ??1?Q??? ?l????>? !??" ????=xC (0 ??? r@??hl?O??(:?U?P?? ?K? n??Z ???l??-1 ?e??"???S hl?c??{y?T?o????/??< ??9? t~?>zH ?fV * i??E?K=?S2?�`L:? ? ?% ??\S ??!??@?*???X?R*?k}1\ ?U? ?? ???????"?H?$AE?W#?f?z 1c?b?u?? ?%??j[?9 ?????d?hU???e?:?A? )'F??7 ~?6?? ? ???{I??a5????3???| ??t ???~? ???
M? ~?n ????a???m G X? ?E?:usK ? q?
?? ?=?{? ?C?k?U ?K:4??H? u"?~(?}?A? ?1w? ?V ?? ????AZa?i6QcR???? ; %??$Z4? ?J??%QT>?r??n?^E?2?uO ? ?\J _??z??U? ??9? ^?n ??'"? Os??A?Bz+??> ?? D?????OU?> E{vv??????T ?iA?z? I?]?3- ?? ??( ?] ??p?d???{m ??F?p??.LX5R'@??1 ?? ???}?"??oY??ZQo#Qhegko?z? ?"a?6i ???1 k?m\t??b???:3?V??? l?4Z?v??f??h??~E]?? 4l?"6R?Y?^??cn ?, ?H??D???[??_\~X?;?~? ?/8? ?p?&?????!?9l ?m???\p& ?-?
?_?v+??3%"?f?? w?2?r?L%??? ? ?V? ? ??v�Y ?U!| ??? S} R5r?#?F???Ms?OE#\?i?H% }?dY/?k??c?$?p?=??k?EE???}?k?e?x ?4M?5?r{UT?]?+& |Y?m? ?? x?M???W??? ,-#?r???}| a S v?+? R?9=L?>?t??c ????r?KS?I?(????Nj?? ?
?h:??}:?`?*?!?< ?q??U5 ?c?#??sXI? =Fe ?hq}??oK?| ??qO?e?????8??|?6Q? ??v8"GH 5??t?j???_fd???N ???/?}i? ?:???% ??%?q ?Q l?T?&y?l ?pU?l??! ?7HT?q??8??o?]#?????u|G??P&?8H_T??;? ?w?|?l2?vmDeB???Q?5?u? ?k? !? }??? q?? y1gd?(?3n ?�z?m ??> k ??!?$W ?I?kF?"
3?;8?V?F?|* |WD?|???+ ?t?on?lm1???:4?z?? s?a&? ?C??i\?g??2? W?????bRo& ?,?*M_D??4& ?;??L??x? 7 4 ?4 ?i d `S?;?^?E?L??w?=??[M ?? \_? 5????:??V???d :???^?!TC ??? ?$K? ?gG?@ |????j???_ ??? ?n?? yJD-???A??[ d ??o?#/F???K f<\?????b?[?TRA?E? ? t ??`? 7?ki}� ?)? k ?@ ?8??%?)?8? ?*-v??bX B R?~???????.G?V ??K?~??4??:6K;?3 ????t?y???? UyFr>??? ??Md?e?PC??? ??z,??????}? ?8 ?iW qG#??#????g?????GQC? bvOG?? ?P??????????O?6?.pJAF???Xi=] ?P?? q� ?o?(=???[ ?VOk??3*?? ?$ S?vIY?6?lM?g"?"?!? ^fP?? ?c ???RM?e?#?=??,_??\ ??? ?uz??[/?EU???e?I???`???S?l?^ ?C \ o?? ? o ??/ F?'-?? ???1i\x??? pD ?#%?a? &??I?~v1? ??Y?M??
a??',t??�QA? ?K??}?????? ?.?? ???6 ?j?h ??kI_??}?.?*?w?(?:,c?QQ(??Rz\Yo)?# I $??f??/?r??wZ#??"???ZL?? z?x? ]`?# ??g?????G?`;8 ?? ? >??S*??}B?V?? `?xL%???8??J?)J w*?p# ? ? ??9_?1 ?????~?h ?/ l??`8?0N??e?EE???A?}?#?|IO?l?g? ??%]M??i Id?3???? ??? ~??
@??? ? ?? = ? "L?
??}?N8??) ?J??e ??D ???f^???8!F?j????'lr?m.g ?? 6?9P???g??T????T?P??r e??Y?? V ?f?G?|?j?l ?PF~sa,?o?A???n>0??T?W B-?j?" ?pe =Rz? Hb??H? ???Z ?.?Lp???? ????>?@b??Z?? vk ? ? +???=? ?????i?`?Q???`??}? ???j???S ? 9v?SS?T V UW?W&fJ 5`{?J??> :??=}?? ??YS????D? ?% ?? u??? ?T ?? ??? +RH2?> X??W$x(??? ??vi?W[ ??o ??:?6R?r??t?y?? KQ? ??? )???X H ?O????H�?? ?a?r0 V!t|Y]???? ? ??9B 2|?~?}?iw ro??B?=Rw?: ?? ???X?;?/?{(??xf ?e[+x ??? #N?8?)?i?? $??_?-? ??%??7?}P!?� ???!?#??*G???I?h? ?+W?8� my- ??
y???:q -:? ??? ?
>v??K??| ??c?@0LM?G?>?h?B???}l*???. $??,??-K??L? ?X??a ????#EY? s??'v? ?`;? ??K?#??? ? f?S[????HY?,???.??`M)'Y? ??*?e????Ku ?_S?B�c$??? 2V??w?j???%??? ?Ky????fn??5@?=k?????`!T:(Qv?v?a?T?m?Us?4 T?E[?? 5???%????????e?? ???|&??.!oq??T}??! J?? }??V!l???? -? %4???6?F Z?y K????? ? ) ?T }?S??
??ru???jX??75?'Y??f??n?5?2?l X??? ??(? H8?Q5y:?$ W?m P? ?0??T? ???[?1?*z2??? ?? 1R?J&rL?;iX?{P?`a?c? ?9y??3?*J'?? {:X???. Lsx ???D %n ?:n?y?0??: ??yX??]:]?3?N ??:?? ??'???n? xQ ???'Jd?b?4? 6? 8?]o?@ Z$O??6? ?'7 ?c???? ?*?~?? V?? ???dA?#{????'? ?R?H(K ??}?? j?dj??? ?t?'?9 b?2Che>?dH?j8;@g _???8???jv??X?? ??
?#?? ??:b+!???_E?r??":??O92??? 7?U???(x? ?D==a?&??? �??? B2'??^?F9??N/n@[I^{x ? c&???-? _q? ?d? f;=??y?? q?i???U????n?g h�?\N R???Q? ?d?? ????? ?
?"??9 n8@ y8 ? ?*0??`? ;??z?XvJ'??:??
h???'sqb?r ;?c$??^? YcrF�??? F? ???}b?(?1B ?z?? i-y????8c?_|U?f ?�i?Y?^???9l?e|? ? ?!F??'? ;f??nQ???1 ???D ??? 5?J .?"8???? ??{ ?~q?? ???P??????? ?K? ? ??ZK?d*/?Q$ e*UD ??X??a??"??qMcAHb0&?E?E??? ??? ^5?#_N?1?o?xPq?i?P?A (J ??o>p?$?f?;??6_ ?h??+??? ? ?S ?9?c?a?? ??B??[b??m?? ?gR?????'? ??g? ?Km?? ?) ?rY??]&p?aZ?Q)? ??O;eJ ?Gm?_~ ?o??:?E/?? ? Z?? A2??e?_G?????}???6 ?7O?Cp5@0??? 4?_??`W ??Sd>?&????[?? (k??x? ?yGb?+?? Q P?? ??ru\?p???o????gho?Mh*???Qq??+OP?q?[4?.?? Z? ?? ?? ?? Ct ??
:?&rl?+??` ??[?? ???????f @?0?? @?Oo??jEwM??46?#A?^TD?n???? m??ol \???m?&??2A? ?E?N?????^?? ?9 ??eA?
?w?Y?Z't?r?Y?? ??(??S?Y?7?k, "??? v?:?2? ?Lg?P|?;m 7^?gj? ???#4?$?X;7x- % ))?+??5Q?.???[?(???8,?pv? ??? PK f?Z?32��?3��PK � � �?FQ<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }??"?w?GH 2 CJ/ ?fn???od?G? ??l?$`Rb?S ??vW??:o????T ?[?z^q?@x? bv??C?2? ?/?,* !%??O?? *N?:,?]?T?%??4?\+~??R?R9 uO?\+_?EQU0?`?R \ ??� ? I??qu t ??07?WW ?b? ?1!mg? % W??v??Q??V/ w? 8x ?/ Ts oKs???? ?? ?D?X2M?? Ir}?$ 3J?Q??? - ?A?-??*0?? ? ???m$ Cn%: 27??y?)??1*W?-? ?? ?k3??yW??5?w~ -?? ?? PK w???? ��E ��PK � � �?FQ<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r? _H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g$�� ������������� ��content.xmlPK � � � �?FQ Top