Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur
Dinesh Babu Dubey vs State on 20 August, 2018
Author: G.R. Moolchandani
Bench: G.R. Moolchandani
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 119/2010
Dinesh Babu Dubey son of Shri Ram Das Dubey, by caste
Brahman, Resident of B-105, Nandpuri Colony, Hawa Sarak, 22
Godown, Jaipur
---Complainant-Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Rajasthan through its Public Prosecutor
----Respondent
2. Deependra Singh son of Shri Prem Pal Singh, by caste Rajput, Resident of C-486, Nirman Nagar, Ajmer Road, Jaipur
---Accused-Respondent Connected With S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 124/2010 Dinesh Babu Dubey son of Shri Ram Das Dubey, by caste Brahman, Resident of B-105, Nandpuri Colony, Hawa Sarak, 22 Godown, Jaipur
---Complainant-Petitioner Versus
1. The State of Rajasthan through its Public Prosecutor
----Respondent
2. Rajendra Prasad Sharma s/o Late Shri Prahlad Ram Sharma
3. Smt Kamlawati Sharma wife of Shri Rajendra Prasad Sharma Both by caste Brahmin, Residents of B-1, Sunder Vihar, Sewage Farm, 22 Godown, Police Station Mahesh Nagar, Jaipur
4. Kamal Kumar Sharma son of Shri Shrawan Kumar Sharma
5. Smt. Kavita Sharma wife of Shri Kamal Kumar Sharma Both by caste Brahman, Residents of B-106, Nandpuri Colony, Hawa Sarak, 22 Godown, Police Station Sodala, Jaipur For Petitioner(s) : Mr. V.R. Bajwa with Mr. Amar Kumar For Respondent(s) : Mr. Ram Ratan Gurjar, PP Mr. Dinesh Dixit with Mr. Nilesh Pareek for Mr. A.K. Bajpai HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G.R. MOOLCHANDANI Judgment reserved on :: 8th August 2018 Judgment pronounced on :: 20th August 2018 Judgment (2 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] By way of these petitions, common order dated 09.12.2009 passed by Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No.4, Jaipur City, Jaipur in context of Criminal Revision Nos.379/2009 (821/2009) and 380/2009 (679/2009) has been assailed, whereby order passed by trial court for taking cognizance and issuance of process against accused respondent(s) has been remitted back to redecide by the revisional court, both the revisions have arisen out of similar order, so are being decided together by a single order.
In nutshell, a complaint was preferred under the provisions of Section 156 sub-clause (3) of CrPC by complainant father-in-law of deceased Smt. Rinku Sharma, which was sent by the trial court for investigation, the investigation was culminated in F.R, and learned court below after hearing complainant- protester having been convinced on the basis of prima facie evidence, took cognizance against accused Deependra Singh, Rajendra Prasad, Smt. Kamlawati Sharma, Kamal Kumar Sharma and Smt. Kavita Sharma for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201 read with 120-B of IPC and summoned the accused persons through bailable warrants.
Aggrieved, Deependra Singh and Rajendra Prasad & others preferred two respective revisions against the order of cognizance and revisional court while quashing the cognizance remitted the matter to the trial for re-consideration.
Contents of FIR, lodged by Shri Dinesh Babu Dubey, father-in-law of deceased, reads as under :-
Ekkuuh; U;k;ky; vfrfjDr flfoy U;k;k/kh'k ¼dŒ[kŒ½ ,oa U;kf;d eftŒ Øe la[;k 23 t;iqj 'kgj t;iqj ifjokn i= la[;k 48@2007 fnus'k ckcq nqcs iq= (3 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] Jh jkenkl nqcs tkfr czkg~e.k fuoklh ch&105] uUniqjh ckbZl xksnke t;iqj ifjoknh cuke 1- nhisUnz flag iq= Jh izseiky flag tkfr jktiwr] fuoklh lh&486] fuekZ.k uxj vtesj jksM+] t;iqj 2- dey 'kekZ iq= Jh Jo.k dqekj 'kekZ tkfr czkg~e.k fuoklh ch&106] uUniqjh dkWyksuh ckbZl xksnke] t;iqj 3- Jh jktsUnz izlkn 'kekZ iq= Jh izgykn jk; 'kekZ tkfr czkg~e.k fuoklh ch&1] lqUnj fogkj Lost QkeZ lksM+kyk] t;iqj 4- Jherh deyk 'kekZ iRuh Jh jktsUnz izlkn 'kekZ fuoklh ch&1 lqUnj fogkj Lost QkeZ lksM+kyk] 5- Jherh dfork 'kekZ iRuh Jh dey 'kekZ tkfr czkg~e.k fuoklh ch&106] uUniqjh dkWyksuh ckbZl xksnke] t;iqj vfHk;qDr x.k ifjokn i= vUrxZr /kkjk 190 n.M izfd;k lafgrk vijk/k vUrxZRk /kkjk 302] 201]120ch HkkŒnŒlŒ egksn;] ifjoknh dk ifjokn i= fuEu :is.k izLrqr gSA 1- ;g fd ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs dk fookg fnukad 4-05-2003 dks vfHk;qDr la[;k rhu o pkj dh iq=h o vfHk;qDr la[;k ikap dh cgu fjadw 'kekZ ds lkFk t;iqj fgUnw jhfr fjokt ds vuqlkj laiUu gqvkA ftlds i'pkr ifjoknh] ifjoknh dh iRuh] ifjoknh dk iq= o iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ifjoknh ds edku ch&105] uUniqjh ckbZl xksnke] t;iqj esa lkFk&lkFk jgus yxsA ¼2½ ;g fd ifjoknh] ifjoknh dh iRuh o iq= lqfer nqcs us Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks fookg ds i'pkr I;kj o lEeku ds lkFk vius ;gk¡ j[kk rFkk ifjoknh us iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds vkxzg ij Lo;a ds [kpsZ ij T;ksfr jko Qwys egkfo|ky; esa Lukrd dh f'k{kk] rSjkdh izf'k{k.k ,oa ,e-vkj- Vsªfuax dkslZ iw.kZ djok;saA rFkk vkus tkus ds fy, Lo;a dh vk; ls dkbZusfVd uksok LdwVj [kjhn dj fn;kA ifjoknh dh iq=o/kq us mDr f'k{kk iw.kZ gksus ij loZizFke Vsxksj bUVjus'kuy Ldwy ekuljksoj] t;iqj esa Lohfeax dksp ds :i esa ukSdjh djuk izkjEHk fd;k rRi'pkr~ Jherh fjadw 'kekZ us Øeokj ;wfuVsd gsYFk ds;j] uksokVst o flIyk uked nokbZ dEifu;ksa esa crkSj esfM+dy fjiztsfVo ukSdjh dhA ¼3½ ;g fd ifjoknh dh iq=o/kw Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ukSdjh djus lsa Lokoyach gks x;hA ftl dkj.k ls mlus Lora= o LoPNan thou fcrkuk 'kq: dj fn;k ,oa Jherh fjaadw 'kekZ us ifr lqfer nqcs ls ifjoknh ls vyx jgus dk ncko Mkyus yxhA ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs viuh xzLrh cpkus ds mís'; ls iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dh ckr ekudj vizSy 2005 esa ifjoknh ls vyx jgus dk fu.kZ; ysdj ifjoknh ds Lo;a ds edku la[;k ,&42&ch] lqUnj fogkj Lost QkeZ] t;iqj esa iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds lkFk jguk izkjaHk dj fn;kA ifjoknh ds iq+= lqfer nqcs dks nqcbZ esa ukSdjh dk izLrko feyus ij iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds ncko esa edku la[;k ,&42&ch] lqUnj fogkj Lost QkeZ t;iqj dks NksM+dj uoEcj 2005 esa edku la[;k 24@143 o:.k iFk] ekuljksoj] t;iqj esa Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds lkFk fdjk;s ij jgus yxkA ¼4½ ;g fd ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs fnukad 28-11-2005 dks nqcbZ pyk x;kA lqfer nqcs ds nqcbZ tkus ds Ik'pkr ifjoknh o ifjoknh dh iRuh us iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks vius lkFk jgus ds fy, dgk fdUrq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ us ifjoknh ds lkFk jgus ls Li"V euk dj fn;kA nks ekg i'pkr gh ekuljksoj fLFkr fdjk;s dk edku NksM+dj vU; edku IykV la[;k 51] egknso uxj f}rh; Lost QkeZ jkeuxj foLrkj t;iqj esa fdjk;s ij vdsyh jgus yxhA ¼5½ ;g fd ifjoknh dk iq= lqfer nqcs nqcbZ esa gksus ds dkj.k ifjoknh o mldh iRuh dbZ erZck iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks laHkkyus mlds fdjk;s ds edku ij ekuljksoj tkrs rks ogka ij dHkh vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o dHkh vHkh vfHk;qDr la[;k nks o ikap o dbZ erZck dbZ vutku iq:"k cSBs feysA vfHk;qDr la[;k nks ifjoknh dh iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds lxs thtk o vfHk;qDRk la[;k ikap Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dh lxh cM+h cgu gSA ifjoknh }kjk Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ls dbZ vutku yksxks ls vkus tkus ds ckjs esa iwNus ij mlus dksbZ larks"k tud mÙkj ugha fn;kA ftl ij ifjoknh us iq=o/kq (4 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks le>kuk pkgk rks Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ifjoknh ls ukjkt jgus yxhA ¼6½ ;g fd fnukad 26-01-2006 dks ifjoknh dk iq= lqfer nqcs nqcbZ esa ukSdjh ls lUrq"V ugha gksus ds dkj.k okil t;iqj vk x;k rFkk iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds lkFk edku IykV la[;k 51] egknso uxj f}rh; Lost QkeZ] t;iqj esa lkFk jgus x;kA ¼7½ ;g fd ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs dks nqcbZ ls vkus ds i'pkr iRuh fjadw 'kekZ dk O;ogkj cnyk cnyk utj vkus yxk o ek= pkj ikap fnuksa esa gh lqfer nqcs dks tkudkjh izkIr gqbZ fd Jherh fjadw 'kekZ us Lora= o LoPNan thou 'kSyh ds dkj.k mlds dbZ iq:"kks la voS/k laca/k gSA eq[; :i ls Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds uktk;t laca/k vfHk;qDr nhisUnz o dey 'kekZ ls gksus dk irk pykA rFkk Jherh fjadw 'kekZ iw.kZ :i ls vfHk;qDr nhisUnz o dey 'kekZ ds cgdkosa esa gSA ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs dks ;g Hkh tkudkjh izkIr gqbZ fd nhisUnz o dey 'kekZ Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dk nSfgd 'kks"k.k gh ugha vfirq vkfFkZd 'kks"k.k Hkh dj jgsa gSA vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d nhisUnz o nks dey 'kekZ vk;s fnu cgkus cukdj :i;sa ysdj v;~;'kh djrs FksA ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs us iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o nks ,oa vU; iq:"k fe=ksa ls feyus o uktk;t laca/k u j[kus o :i;sa u nsus gsrq le>kus dh dksf'k'k dh rks yM+kbZ >xM+k dks vkenk gks x;h rFkk Jherh fjadw 'kekZ lqfer nqcs ls vR;f/kd ukjkt gks x;h rFkk vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o nks ds ncko esa vkdj lqfer nqcs dks lkFk j[kus ls badkj dj fn;k ftl dkj.k ls fnukad 02-02-2006 dks ifjoknh dk iq= lqfer nqcs iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks lkr fnu i'pkr~ gh fdjk;s ds edku 51] egknso uxj f}rh; Lost QkeZ] t;iqj esa NksM+dj ifjoknh ds lkFk jgus yxk o leLr ?kVuk ifjoknh dks crk;h ftl ij ifjoknh us iq= lqfer nqcs dks /khjt j[kus dk dgk ifjoknh ] ifjoknh dh iRuh] ifjoknh ds cM+s iq= vk'kh"k nqcs o cM+h iq=o/kq us Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks le>kus dh dksf'k'k dh fdarq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ij dksbZ izHkko ugha iM+k vfirq mlus vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o nks ds lkFk csjksdVksd voS/k laca/k j[kus yxs blds ckotwn Hkh ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs us vius oSokfgd thou dks 'kkafriw.kZ cuk;s j[kus ds fy;s vius vf/koDrk ds ekQZr iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks fnukad 16-02-2006 dks nkEiR; vf/kdkjksa dh iquZLFkkiuk gsrq uksfVl izsf"kr djok;kA ¼8½ ;g fd Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks vfHk;qDr nhisUnz o dey 'kekZ us lqfer nqcs ds fo:) cgdkdj >wBs o euxa<r rF;ksa ds vk/kkj ij fnukad 22-02-2006 dks uksfVl dk tokc iszf"kr djok;k ftlesa uksfVl esa vafdr rF;ksa dks badkj dj ifjoknh] ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs] ifjoknh dh iRuh ds fo:) izrkM+Ukk o ngst ekaxus ds >wBs o cscqfu;kn vkjksi yxkdj >wBk o eqdnek ntZ djkus dh /kedh nh x;hA ¼9½ ;g fd ifjoknh dh iq=o/kq Jherh fjadq 'kekZ ds tokc uksfVl ls ifjoknh dk iq= grizHk gks x;k rFkk ekufld :i ls ijs'kku jgus yxk ftl ij ifjoknh us iq= lqfer nqcs dks ekg viSzy 2006 t;iqj ls fQjkstkckn mlds thtk t;izdk'k 'kekZ ds ikl Hkst fn;kA tgk¡ ij lqfer nqcs us viuk O;olk; 'kq: dj fn;k o thtk t;izdk'k 'kekZ ds ikl okys edku esa fdjk;s ij jgus yxkA ¼10½ ;g fd ifjoknh dh iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ekg viSzy 2006 rd edku la[;k 51] egknso uxj f}rh; Lost QkeZ] t;iqj esa fdjk;s ij vdsyh jghA rRi'pkr~ mlus mDr fdjk;s dk edku cnydj u;s fdjk;s ds edku Þdqekor ¶yksj feyÞ la[;k ,Q&1 jkeuxj foLrkj] Lost QkeZ esa vdsyh vxLr 2006 rd jghA ifjoknh dh iq=o/kq ekg flarcj 2006 ls vius ekrk firk ds lkFk jgus yxhA ¼11½ ;g fd ifjoknh o ifjoknh dk iq= lqfer nqcs us Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks le>kus dh fujarj dksf'k'k dh ftl ij vpkud 4 flarcj 2006 Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs ds lkFk jgus fQjkstkckn vk x;h tgk¡ ij og vkt fnu rd jgh rFkk mlds ckn viuk lkeku ykus ds fy, dgdj okil t;iqj vk x;hA (5 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] rFkk fnukad 02-10-2006 dks vfHk;qDr la[;k rhu us Bkdqj VªkaliksVZ daiuh ds ek/;e ls ?kjsyw lkeku fQjkstkckn fHktok fn;kA ¼12½ ;g fd fnukad 05-10-2006 dks ifjoknh dh iq=o/kq Jherh fjadw 'kekZ vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d ds lkFk iqu% ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs ds ikl fQjkstkckn vk x;h rFkk vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d ds cgdkosa esa vkdj Jherh fjadq 'kekZ us lqfer nqcs dks rykd nsus ds fy, ncko Mkyus yxhA Jherh fjadq 'kekZ vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d ds lkFk lqfer nqcs ds edku ij fnukad 09-10-2006 rd jgh rFkk lqfer nqcs ds lkeus gh fjadq 'kekZ o vfHk;qDRk la[;k ,d vkifÙktud fLFkfr esa lksrs o 'kjkc dk lsou djrs FksA fnukad 09-10-2006 dks vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d us lqfer nqcs dks iRuh Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ls rykd ysus ds fy, dgk fdarq lqfer nqcs }kjk badkj djus ij vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d lqfer nqcs ls ekjihV djus dk vkenk gks x;k ftl ij vklikl ds yksx vk tkus ds dkj.k vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d us lqfer nqcs dks tku ls ekjus dh o ngst izrkM+uk ds >wBs eqdnesa esa Qalkus dh /kedh nsdj lqfer nqcs dk dherh lkeku o dkxtkr dh vVSph tcju mBkdj vk x;kA ftl ij lqfer nqcs us iqfyl Fkkuk ykbZu ikj] fQjkstkckn esa fnukad 13-10-2006 dks fjiksVZ Hkh ntZ djok;hA ¼13½ ;g fd vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o Jherh fjadq 'kekZ } kjk fQjkstkckn esa lqfer nqcs ds lkFk fd;s crkZo dh tkudkjh lqfer nqcs us vius firk vFkkZr ifjoknh dks nh ftl ij ifjoknh ,oa ifjoknh dh iRuh vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d ds ?kj x;k tgka ij vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d nhisUnz dh iRuh Jherh nhIrh feyh ftlus ifjoknh dks crk;k fd vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d Jherh fjadq 'kekZ ds dkj.k mls vk;s fnu ekjihV djrk gS rFkk vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d nhisUnz us Lo;a o Jherh fjadq 'kekZ ds chp esa viuh iRuh Jherh nhIrh dks ck/kk ekudj mls Mjkus ds mís'; ls fnukad 19-08-2006 dks tgj [kkdj vkRegR;k djus dh dksf'k'k dh Fkh RkFkk vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d }kjk vkRegR;k djus ds iz;kl ds dkj.k Hk;Hkhr gksdj Jherh fjadq 'kekZ Mjds ekjs lqfer nqcs ds ikl 04-09-2006 dks fQjkstkckn pyh x;h FkhA vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d dh iRuh nhIrh us i= fy[kdj vius ihgj eka&cki dks nsus gsrq ifjoknh dks fn;k ftlesa vafdr fd;k fd Þfjadq ds Åij [kk;k gS fjadw ds Åij eq>s ekjrk gS ,d ckj blus esjk flj QkM+ fn;k vkSj nl efgus ls esjs lkFk cqjk O;ogkj djrk gSA eSa dqN dgrs gwW rks eq>s ekjrk gSA ;gka ls xq:okj ¼05-09-2006½ dks fjadw ds lkFk pyk x;kA vxj eq>s dqN gqvk rks bldk ftEesnkj nhisUnz o fjadw gSÞ gLrk{kj nhIrh ¼14½ ;g fd ifjoknh us ijs'kku gksdj vius cM+s iq= vk'kh"k nqcs tks fd usoh esa fo'kk[kkiÍue esa dk;Zjr gS dks leLr rF;ksa ls lwfpr fd;kA ifjoknh dk cM+k iq= fnukad 18 vDVwcj 2006 dks t;iqj vk x;k ftlus Jherh fjadq 'kekZ dks o mlds ekrk firk dks le>k;k ftl ij Jherh fjadq 'kekZ vius ifr Jh lqfer nqcs ds lkFk fo'kk[kkiÍue tkus dks rS;kj gks x;h o fnuakd 28-10-2006 ds fy;s fo'kk[kkue tkus ds fy, pkj fVdV Hkh vfxze cwafdx djok;h fdarq fjadw 'kekZ us dqN le; iwoZ gh bu yksxksa ds lkFk fo'kk[kkiÍue tkus ls euk dj fn;k] ugh x;hA ftl ij ifjoknh dk cM+k iq= vk'kh"k o vk'kh"k dh iRuh o lqfer nqcs fnukad 28-10-2006 dks fo'kk[kkiÍue pys x;sA ¼15½ ;g gS fd vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d vknru vijk/kh gS ftlds fo:) Fkkuk ';keuxj esa dbZ eqdnesa ntZ gS vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o vfHk;qDr la[;k nks Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dk nSfgd o vkfFkZd 'kks"k.k djrs FksA vfHk;qDr la[;k nks Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ls feyus os vkfFkZd enn ysus esa vfHk;qDr la[;k ikap vius ifr vfHk;qDr la[;k nks dks iw.kZ enn djrh FkhA Jherh fjadq 'kekZ us cSad _.k izkIr dj vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d o nks o ikap dks fn;kA ¼16½ ;g fd ifjoknh ds iq= lqfer nqcs us fo'kk[kiÍue ls VsfyQksu ij ifjoknh dks crk;k fd fnukad 28-11-2006 dks iRuh Jherh fjadq 'kekZ ls mldh ckrphr gqbZ gS Jherh fjadw (6 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] 'kekZ ckrphr djrs gq, dkQh isj'kku yxh rFkk mlus lqfer nqcs ls dgk fd og 12 yk[k :i;s nsdj rykd ys ys vU;Fkk etcwjh o'k mls lqfer nqcs ds fo:) ngst dk >wBk eqdnek ntZ djokuk iM+sxkA ftl ij ifjoknh viuh iq=o/kq Jherh fjaadw 'kekZ ls feyk o Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dk le>k;k fd og ifjoknh dks lkjh ckr crk;sA ftl ij Jherh fjadw 'kekZ us ifjoknh dks crk;k fd vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d] nks o ikap ds ncko esa vkdj mlus ifjoknh ifr lqfer nqcs] ifjoknh dh iRuh deys'k nqcs ds fo:) fnukad 04-12-2006 dks U;kf;d eftLVsªV ØeŒ 12 t;iqj 'kgj t;iqj ds le{k Hkkjrh; n.M lafgrk dh /kkjk 406] 498, o 120 ch ds rgr bLrxklk izLrqr dj fn;k gSA Jherh fjadq 'kekZ us ifjoknh dks crk;k fd mlls vfHk;qDr la[;k ,d] nks ,oa ikap dks 12 yk[k :i;sa ekaxrs gS ftl ij ifjoknh us Jherh fjadw 'kekZ dks le>k;k rks Jherh fjadw 'kekZ us U;k;ky; esa izLrqr bLrxklk okfil ysdj vius ifr lqfer nqcs ds lkFk jgus dh ea'kk crk;h A ifjoknh dks 3&4 jkst esa bLrxklk okil ysdj ifjoknh ds ?kj vkus dk vk'oklu fn;kA ¼17½ ;g fd fnukad 14-12-2006 dks vfHk;qDr la[;k nks us ifjoknh dks lwpuk nh fd Jherh fjadw 'kekZ us vkRegR;k dj yh gS ftl ij ifjoknh us mlh fnu iqfyl Fkkuk lksM+kyk esas Jherh fjadw 'kekZ ds e`R;q ds okLrfod dkj.k irk yxkus gsrw fjiksVZ izLrqr dh ftl ij iqfyl }kjk vkt rd dksbZ dk;Zokgh ugha gqbZ gSA ¼18½ ;g fd fjadw 'kekZ us vkRegR;k ugha fd cfYd mldh gR;k gqbZ gSA ftl laca/k esa fuEu lk{; esa fcUnqvksa ij xgjkbZ ls vuqla/kku fd;s tkus ls fLFkfr Li"V gks tk;sxhA ¼d½ ;g fd fnukad 05-10-2006 ls 09-10-2006 rd fjadw 'kekZ o nhisUnz flag fQjkstkckn esa vkifÙktud fLFkfr esa iayx ij ,d lkFk CkSBS gq, ,oa 'kjkc ] ch;j ihrs Fks ftldh QksVkst miyC/k gSA ¼[k½ ;g fd fjadw 'kekZ dh e`R;q fnukad 14-12-2006 dks izkRk% 5 cts ds yxHkx gksuk fpfdRldh; lk{; ls izdV gqvk gS izkr% bl le; ?kj ij dksbZ ekStwn uk gks ;g laHko ugha gS tcfd fjadw 'kekZ ds firk Jh jktsUnz 'kekZ us ?kj ij fdlh Hkh O;fDr dk ugha gksuk viuh ,Q0vkbZ0vkj esa crk;k gS ,oe~ ekSds dh lk{; Hkh lekIr dh gSA rFkk iqfyl dks lwpuk fn;s fcuk gh lh/ks gkWfLiVy ugha tkuk lansg izdV djrk gSA ¼x½ ;g fd fjadw 'kekZ ds eksckby Qksu uacj 9829922737 ij ekg fnlEcj tuojh 2006 dh dkWy fMVsYl esa 105 ckj nhisUnz flag mlds eksckby uacj 9829880849 ij ckrs gqbZ gSA bl VsfyQksu fjdkWMZ ls gh nksuks ds e/; ds laca/kksa dh xgjkbZ ls vuqla/kku fd;s tkus ls fLFkfr Li"V gks tk;sxhA ¼?k½ ;g fd nhisUnz dk mldh iRuh nhIrh ls fjadw ls laca/kksa dks ysdj >xM+k gqvk A bl dkj.k fnukad 19-08-2006 dks nhisUnz us vkRegR;k dk iz;kl fd;k tks nhIrh ds i= ,oa esfM+dy fjdkMZ ls Li"V gSA ¼M½ ;g fd nhisUnz] dey 'kekZ ,oa fjdaw 'kekZ ds eksckby uacj tks ekg fnlacj&tuojh 2006 rd vkil esa ckrphr gqbZ fd dkWy fMVsy izkIr dj xgjkbZ ls vuqla/kku djk;s tkus ls fLFkfr Li"V gksxhA ¼p½ ;g fd fjadq 'kekZ Lora= fopkjksa ds jgrs gq, ,slh dksbZ ifjfLFkfr;k¡ ugha Fkh tks mls vkRegR;k ds fy;s izsfjr djrh fuf'pr gh mldh gR;k dh x;h gSA ¼19½ ;g fd mi;qZDRk of.kZr rF;ksa lsa ,oa fjdkWMZ ls ifjoknh dks lansg gh ugha cfYd iw.kZ fo'okl gS fd fjadw 'kekZ us vkRegR;k ugha fd cfYd mldh vfHk;qDrx.k la[;k ,d ls ikap us lkft'k dj gR;k dh gS ftl ckcr~ ifjoknh us iwoZ esa fnukad 14-12-2006 dks gh iqfyl Fkkuk lksM+kyk esa fjiksVZ ns fn Fkh vfHk;qDr x.k us vijk/k varxZr /kkjk 302] 201] 120ch dkfjr fd;k gSA ftl lEcU/k esa vuqla/kku fd;s tkuk U;k;fgr esa vko';d gSA ¼20½ ;g fd ekuuh; U;k;ky; dks izdj.k dks Jo.k xzg.k ,ao fuf.kZr djus ds vf/kdkj izkIr gS vr% ifjokn izLrqr dj izkFkZuk gS fd ifjokn ds rF;ksa ,ao lk{;ksa dks e/; utj j[krs gq, izdj.k dks vuqla/kku gsrq vaarxZr /kkjk 156 n.M izfd;k lafgrk iaqfyl Fkkuk egs'k uxj dks fHktok;k tkosaA t;iqj fnukad (7 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] 11-07-07 ,lMh ifjoknh fnus'k ckcw nqcs iq= Jh jkefuokl nqcs tkfr czkg~e.k] fuoklh ch&105 uUniqjh ckbZl xksnke] t;iqjA Heard rival submissions, learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that unnatural death of deceased Smt. Rinku Sharma has occurred in the premises of her father and the accused persons have failed to discharge burden saddled under Section 106 of the Evidence Act, autopsy report evidently discloses that hyoid bone of the deceased was not found broken nor the cartilage rings were impacted, which is unnatural in case of death by hanging, had there been death by suicidal hanging, then the cartilage ring and the hyoid bone would have certainly been affected, viscera report has disclosed that Diazepam sedative was administered to the deceased, referring testimony of Dr. Suman Dutta learned counsel has urged that Doctor has opined that after administration of sedative Diazepam, victim could not have been able to hang herself due to insobriety, so theory of suicide by hanging is improbable, scene of the incident was also intermeddled with and was deliberately altered, which has got serious repercussions on the fairness of the investigation.
It has further been added that "prima facie" evidence is enough to formulate opinion for taking cognizance, which has rightly been determined by the trial court but ignoring all the incriminatory factual aspects, revisional court has set aside the order of trial court by remitting the matter for decision afresh, which is not sustainable under the eye of law and deserves to be quashed. Relying upon the following authorities : Anil Saran v. State of Bihar & Anr 1996 Cri.L.J. 408, Ajay Mehra & Anr v. Durgesh Babu & Ors 2001 (1) Supreme (Cr.) 606, Bhushan (8 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] Kumar & Anr v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr JT 2012 (4) SC 127, Baikunth Singh v. State of Bihar & Ors JT 2009 (1) SC 146, Jagdish Ram v. State of Rajasthan & Anr JT 2004 (3) SC 202, Dy Chief Controller of Imports & Exports v. Roshanlal Agarwal & Ors JT 2003(2) SC 370, Fakhruddin Ahmad v. State of Uttaranchal & Anr JT 2008 (10) SC 240, Nathi Lal & Ors v. State of U.P. & Anr 1990 (Supp) SCC 145, Mitthulal & Anr v. The State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1975 SC 149, and Harishchandra Prasad Mani & Ors v. State of Jharkhand & Anr JT 2007 (3) SC 229, it has been further urged that the finding of revisional court is not sustainable, so the petition be allowed and order dated 25.4.2009 passed by trial court be restored.
Learned Public Prosecutor has contended that the order passed by learned trial court is correct and does not need to be interfered with. Learned counsel for the other respondents have contended that there is no wrong in the findings of revisional court and revisional court has given a chance to the court of JM No.12, Jaipur City, Jaipur to re-look into the evidence and pass order afresh, which won't affect veracity, hence petition lacks merit, so it be dismissed.
Having heard both the side a circumspect perusal was given to the material available on the record, it emerges that in support of protest petition, complainant Dinesh Babu Dubey, complainant-father-in-law (sasur) of deceased Smt. Rinku Sharma has produced several witnesses. PW1 Sapna Bansal, a neighbour of deceased resident of Swarn Path, Mansarovar, Jaipur, has stated that in 2005 a boy and a girl had rented house of Dinesh Kumar, name of the girl was Rinku and name of the boy was Deependra, (9 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] she has further stated that she had talking terms with Rinku, who was engaged in trade of medicines, Smt. Rinku had apprised her that Deependra was her husband, they had resided there for 2½ months on rent and in January 2006 they vacated the said premises, she has also stated that she can very well recognize Deependra and Rinku. PW2 Rajendra Kumar Prajapati, a shopkeeper has stated that Smt. Rinku Sharma used to buy goods from his shop, Deependra who used to visit her was accustomed of buying Bidi, Gutkha, Cigarette from his shop on credit borrowing, amount of ₹ 200-250/- had became due against him, so he demanded it from Deependra. Deependra went away and informed Smt. Rinku Sharma that the shopkeeper was demanding money.
Rinku, Deependra and Sumit came to his shop and Smt. Rinku retorted why shopkeeper was demanding due money from Deependra, she will pay for him. Sumit asked Smt. Rinku wherefore she was intermeddling in the affairs of Deependra's due, then Smt. Rinku Sharma asked her husband Sumit to be quite and she was to pay for Deependra's due and an altercation had taken place between Sumit and Rinku on this count at his shop, at that time Smt. Rinku Sharma paid borrowing cash qua Deependra.
Witness Vandana (PW3) has stated that Smt. Rinku Sharma had rented a house at Firozabad near her house, where she had introduced Deependra as her cousin (bua's son). Similar statement has been rendered by PW4 Renu. Complainant Dinesh Babu has also been examined and he has narrated incriminatory against the accused persons.
(10 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] Apex court in B. Jagdish & Anr v. State of Andhra Pradesh & Anr (2009) 1 SCC 681, has held that "material brought on record by complainant, even if given face value and taken to be correct in its entirety, cannot be said as disclosing no offence". In Arun Bhandari v. State of U.P. (2013) 2 SCC 801, Apex court has observed : "Neither the FIR nor the protest petition was mala fide, frivolous or vexatious - Not a case where there is no substance in the complaint - The final report of the investigation officer and the entire case diary prima facie makes out a case against the husband and the wife".
Perusal of record reflects that testimony of Dr. Suman Dutta, who has been examined on 2.1.2009 discloses that he had conducted autopsy on the body of deceased Smt. Rinku Sharma, daughter of Shri Rajendra Kumar Sharma wife of Sumit Dubey on 14.12.2006, she was brought dead in the hospital, in cross- examination she has specifically mentioned that hyoid bone and cartilage were intact and ring of trachea was also intact, there was no bone fracture and no dislocation was found in the neck bone, opinion regarding cause of death was kept in abeyance till receipt of FSL report, after receipt of FSL report opinion pertaining to cause of death was given that deceased had consumed Diazepam prior to her death and cause of death was ante mortem hanging, it has also been stated that consumed quantity or dosage of Diazepam cannot be opined, contents of Diazepam were found in stomach, small intestine, liver, spleen, kidney and blood. FSL report dated 22.12.2006 has got mentioning of result of chemical examination, disclosing that positive test for presence of (11 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] Diazepam, tranquilizing drug was found in stomach, small intestine, liver, spleen, kidney and blood.
Learned trial court while passing impugned order with respect to taking of cognizance has dealt the material thoroughly and the trial court has observed :-
D;ksafd e`rdk fjadw dh xnZu dh dksbZ Hkh gM~Mh dk u rks vfLFkHkax gqvk gSA vkSj u gh fMlyksds'ku gqvk ijUrq e`R;q dk dkj.k Qk¡lh ij yVduk crk;k gSA bu rF;ksa dks ns[krs gq, vuqla/kku esa vo'; gh deh gksuk n`f"Vxr gksrk gSA i=koyh ds voyksdu ls ;g rF; Hkh Li"V :i ls izekf.kr gksrk gS fd e`rdk fjadw vius ifr o mlds ifjokj okyksa ds dgus lquus esas ugha Fkh vkSj LoPNUn thou th jgh Fkh] e`rdk fjadw dh iksLVekVZe fjiksVZ ds vuqlkj e`rdk dh e`R;q fnukad 14-12-06 dks vy lqcg vius ihgj esa gqbZ Fkh vkSj iksLVekVZe fjiksVZ ls e`R;q lqcg 4&5 cts gksuk n`f"Vxr gksrk gS vkSj ml oDr ?kj esa fdlh Hkh lnL; dk ugha gksuk vius vki esa 'kadk iSnk djus okyk rF; gSA e`rdk }kjk vf/kd ek=k esa Mk;thike dk lsou djus ds mijkar Lo;a }kjk vkRegR;k djus gsrq Qkalh dk Qank cukuk o ml ij yVd tkuk vius vki esa vlaHko lh ckr gS D;ksafd Mk;thike ds vR;f/kd lsou ls O;fDr cslq/k gks tkrk gSA mijksDr bu rF; ifjfLFkfr;ksa dks lexz :i ls ns[krs gq, izFke n`"V~;k vijk/k vUrxZr /kkjk 302] 120ch o 201 Hkk-na-la- dk ?kfVr gksuk izdV gksrk gSA vr% mijksDRk foospu ls vfHk;qDr la[;k 1 nhisUnzflag] vfHk;qDr la[;k 2 dey 'kekZ] vfHk;qDr la[;k 3 jktsUnz izlkn] o vfHk;qDr la[;k 4 deyk o vfHk;qDr la[;k 5 Jherh dfork 'kekZ ds fo:) vijk/k vURkxZr /kkjk 302] 120 ch&201 Hkk-na-la- ds vijk/k esa izlaKku fy;k tkrk gSA It emerges from the evidence produced in support of protest petition and material available on the record that deceased Smt. Rinku Sharma was habitual of living with Deependra and use to incur his expenditures and paying for his borrowings, deceased did introduce Deependra with others distinctively sometime as her husband, some time as her cousin, complainant had found deceased Smt. Rinku living with Deependra quibbling with her, accused persons have not come forward even to lodge FIR. Entire afore-discussed evidence prima facie brings out a case necessitating cognizance.
Thus learned trial court has correctly determined decision to take cognizance against the accused persons on the (12 of 12) [CRLMP-119/2010] basis of prima facie evidence and revisional court has fallen into error, while quashing the order impugned and remitting the matter for re-consideration.
In the result, both the petition, S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition Nos.119/2010 and 124/2010 are allowed and order impugned dated 09.12.2009 passed by Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No.4, Jaipur City, Jaipur is quashed and set aside, let record of the court below be transmitted back promptly, learned trial court is directed to proceed with the trial expeditiously.
(G.R. MOOLCHANDANI),J db/72-73 Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)