Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Amol Ramdas Bunde vs Deptt Of Posts on 21 December, 2022
a & EN ot oe | , nn "he 3 fe von, se on G Bs 3S bs ws i ay af weed v4 in ; ee " Poood ee bea ia a, cal a en wo oye ea a mh og ee) , 2% BB oG oe a e GS Oe ~ Bt book Es : ORG yee a) a oa eh So % ig on 4 ay 8 ¥ oe red TD £ ip tek Co a oo on 'Ss ' Zs Rene ie ae itll bic » Bem 8 B Ba pee Sw we ae spon "4 oe Foes 6 BA Be emt wes me 8) 12) ove cf i od or fg 3 ee 2 4 ae art TAS be? a3 ie, 4 prod pe xe 8) Heo fd Co C3 Toh oS i Sos ee Noe 3 od te a Oe |. BS "pA oe c ia re wed arr ae > Be wi PA PR Zz , & fod oO pa ve en ve vo koa oH ay $B «get Gil oe oa t 1 F cy wt oS e . * 2 kee * Sook os wt iF4 Oo 2% 25 is [my Soh Neva cl yon ae' at re a Sot pe ae} ee oo ee rs 3 Nae ih aol wn Zz, Oe OES t A te fos ee cod Gy fos oe wy Op bee 7 i Oh Gy ga eS re pont So a 2 e Os , Gee kei at ° ee ro SO es oe ria oe a ae (OO Lh Ye Sel en fo ae 'of BB on ae :
ad im ta sg "ie, ot ba as Se pees em ise See, oy my pried i Ld beak a he B a 5 C4 OR ab pt pet tee ne) phe a 4 gem aD eed ga g be pe Shad UE on pom oh yet of 03 ot fon ek pot ON Se oh oy es fo nt oy "Bh, ia ' we us ee Gb be 'geal ' nt ne leek er hE ane ES ag ae , Oe aa jp, pte, my a e, ie a: OO ma %.
i.
Tumb Fe * ort, & 3 J :
ector of Postal Ser ay rh, * oy! N j fe oe ne 33% Th x <f ES Tyvocate} £ ¢ A eh Myr. RR. Shetty, C i} J f x ember if car, 23 ea Ber: Hon'e Shri, Justice MG, Sew! & a ORE + oh i uashment of the order date.
x seek wt r rl al by espondent no. 2, whereby the a * Services i cant have b f the appl brief are that ot DEES a i z 2 A. ty hoy My 3 ce nds 7 8 ay eg oiS in harn oF y= ou adeest . "4 P Kew Gk ae ae , . a iy r Le tet tone 4 Fe pa & & 8 8 & e & ¢ & | a faa i a gs i o de oS 'e a " : £3 wpe ren fat '. ed a3 ie a3 Pas ty goa ae:
ea 2 Taek Reed pes £3 ' we 3 wd os x5, nan ans nr " ° 4 md Co;
me feet hee rns me : a | ag ee re oa wee of e [ab "gf is, Gj ah 3 2 ed (oh A OM cs my Fs see ae a os "re inj oy ns yO it a nt sa ng oo 'thet gers afond gerd: ft yore ips eee ai ig pts fet ont bond + ek pron on peed ve iM aed os OS rae Kd f cA ' Sod ierd {4 a a i = a a oh eet key ers Le 'hood Hood ers ret . [nea ch feet ad =
"4 a Ra ct tae a aeons gd # rng 4 mers 2 an oe; re % pork ' "i bad w poet on on, thor on ood bed a, : % C4 ct GS tA Ca "3 ra :
ane 2 id a Oo 8 gee oh rie R op Be K ve mai Bet ee S %3 ta) grey ~ pase! ra , a in tet Sy o mf OS ¢ 5 © | @ & z x P a oy iD ; me eo bed oe none Sy i Pe wo oo cn a Feed SB og G ss Bg . « a re rr ee ma. * Re ; sed ns om nas co ref rg oy wt mS pee a5 gs a my es iD ee oO Ff & OU bed eb nn < ar Far 3 ee "nt ES et ws m des 5 4 oes © fea aS ps o ct ord oo e C cS ao a ae "4 ee Bi 4, Rd oh ea op Ge ct bi oe Ln ihe ce a oi "eet o iC 8 BD EB B Cb 3 " es oy cts u ' as oF a Ci ro ay £3 3 he a3 ues Sie [a tA oe She a geet } 453 trod, a i mel wit ered cas eo SF mp a . . € s nr ~ a) 33 D ps ed ce fe by, a ie . xi 'hy ie rs 4 = oe bo oe i x cn co we ea ey as oO f 8 2 8 & SB 2 8 Go og * s te ad ° Fs ia 4 es ; te hes no Cy Dit Pests st * re tha ' de viet ie aa Hy gy oO ; thd re bite aes . gon
- &£ £€ €@ 2 8S ¢g 2 8 gs Go op Oe ot ca ry fot pene' Sy bet a th phe bed a ae a ae G3 hed 4 Bing 4 o plied gt set tet of ves is 2; "Ch . 2 oa oy ad ca cp ret Bs B " 6€ 8 @ . 8 8 8 8 a 3 6 oy te OD stun iS -- a A 5D) pe tp ao @ £2 9 +s 4 8 ££ B&B g 8 re gy tacaed (e y i ab, reset poo a a Sen, Fo ay EG 6 Be an a be wo e Oy iS ra fa, oi ie a a os a ca i ad iy £4 oe fooeh bot tA % nei wel Chu ben, es) Ene , "aod Melb ress ie ral 4 ott :
SS 2 oh :
7 : Mee % wm iB S ae a Sanh 43 ca we poe) +H aa a ra ted feat aoe pooch aS F ee bea
5 oa oo ty, ie og , Bw Rm & By eS Gh By ed ia foe os ns wn ra hit vcd fe 'e a a eo ra ied S od a) me i 3 ec P = om Si > ae od gs ee " 7 sed on - pint fod et fy pes a beet eA ee fo Sand ahewd a oe Bad td ine bas) Oh rip Cy ile Bo fog tt moO oe Aye fet trod oy aa c 2 a a cy rs spon e aM * oe a", a + rf by, fd wy ia pm ae fu ~ dot . a x me e 90 oe wy ae, g ae) 3 pe 3 reek iS rt st gt / po a ae : ket fs ' 3 tog go eas: Seat at 4 t be sand. "
. mw ee ped oa oy oe "dred Ob a> te as: a ro vs oa @ a cs Sn? Bo he ron a ed Bo ty Cth * pred sreegt O rrr fas! ow ¢3 ht 3 bead be wa ie isl i aed rae! ra fos: tS ded vot oe 2 5 oe 5 € © S C OG 2 bod od. is ves rot Ct peed gt ee sey, Pe Fe) oA fem ec a, ie gt es is] 'fh ree oe) ie) ated ut w a) oe sect wot a3 Be So tay <A ou xe et Keds wh es ea em 3 : , et o fa ot <4 o oem fhe rt om rf 63 . - ee a3 ras 43 sont hy fe ud book oS 2 & 3 £ 2 ¢ SS Be wot wees oe 2 oo pind : eet e opt 3 an ee er ae; es Ga 7 feed 4 . veh : oft by, ea) LA i? peek we ae Tt bareeed ea . eon 4 us fy Pods pea « 23 and , ase 7 ee nS; foi oh : tot ry Ot wy feeb io Sbeve.
a OE Go " @ 8 & { : tak + whe recA Med ey Ane beck oo ot a8 ron ae int mS ro} det ok ced 3 ae ee; s ylond on rt we C3 oe . S a Re by * Se es if acne cs Or BS 44 "at ae 2S @t é hed ne ob 4 weed a cy ere « pat coool set pot & 7 tH SF yt 4 fies ea a Lad i ra a a u ae 04 hea on phot 4 oi mn me et fi it 7 qa lag' d an aed co 9] Gh K oo pa xo chin Ch. "
pails np Pat ng aS rs 63 chook eA deed : Aeet £5 bend Os 23 Deed te : C5 ras cS ax Po & * ee Le: rged A 2 £4 we nd oe a oe) 2 = om iS eat oy she & 3 % ty ee es we send a me fx, i a] oD Gs wed nS 3 yok apa Ch on ee : thead por. 5 ee ey he aR " me es ay "eh me & @ ' & S & Ss ce rn - nn iS 4 a a oon bed oy c "ted cD a Js eho ta Rs by oy fo et i im - cs Pa o~ io na sos aoe ae yy co ree fea oo os 5, ood re Co i 4, pian food iP et aa a3 nn ane is é oe : ao PS ca rok Rid P oS Saeed f. bara meeer, .
<a "tet oa sed -
"<I ra ie ZA x uy Gs hed Paras es th fy ee Ey Sabi ae, 'f AB GLA, No. 885 /ea09 period of one month from the date of service of notics, Or 20% May, 2022, the applicant preferred representation to respondent no. 4 Le. The Director of Postal Services. The applicant contended that the notice of termination isstied by the respondent no. 2 violated the principles of natural justice. No opportunity of personal hearing was afforded to the applicant. The impugned notice of termination js silent and did not assign any reason, contains no reason for inflicting the harsh punishment of termination of services of the applicant.
§ On receipt of notice of termination, applicant enquired with the Dahthanda Folice Station, District Akola. Tt was revealed in Bis enquiry that FIR was registered against the applicant under Section asA of the Maharashtra Prevention at Gambling Act, 1887 alongwith re oe inal AA ryt vary hs & YW OVEN other accused persons, Accor cung to the applicant he was framed in a false cage. Therefore, the applicant filed Cruninal Application (APIA Ne. 2 Nonwble High Court of Bombay, epee A £ quashing of PTE Teo eta ee 7 CNTR z SER bearing CR, No. 6 . ae . s e% "i ~e Ph Rs vee" re ai feu Re iM phen "bed we "3 (B Pd Oy bon es a "= i & a ae Oo ee es ed thet f - td ay foi rey sere ie f. wy o Io Ps x ae
- 3 ue nee gs a m m4 hat a 3 cA Se za Sha te io hu wy med th a ras e be, ae we a +R i ke cm 8 SOG ace mt C3 aged Be rc4 ; 4 ia "of BE ford ar ea Bhi ee $0 e © ef es se ms £6 os rs By vA Ke a ras ae fra pe wt * pa oo ood "lhewd * opt iy a3 a3 oy a eee) . ig oo boot 4 3 me oo hed w tes rey Fe see '5 mA i ea] ae a ay oo el Led f Mag ae } : ae cm So os eet get ie Bo ~ 8 5 a oy G 8 B S 2 &§ my fe fy 0 ma a ; o aa we fa . , * ys v pas F , esa eee aa £4 th an "i ae) a oot ~ 4 ey ee Ga we epee op aa eae . foes ca Rise rie) i isi oe, a) baa 4 wet ny a gy oh Co C3 ees , ee aa ns Ee rs a & = ~ S, = ££ . ee i a 2 @ SB 2 ones 3 8 Se ££ #. ee es , t o4 +4 A si re Bo oe "ch "Ee aa on mt wh a Oa, C3 mh pon orn om cr es pe . ay oy hed a er é oa a) Pe, - opt 4 ber #) phe er as a A of wong re i te cae : 4 cv fot pe wy as oo iy a3 D i: eh id * ae 4 : , 7; wa : o> d wok ty, ma a z er Ga th ee t oS 3 io "a ee ns py Oo > ot '6 on bx i ot aa "4 oa it <pony pied e eee ES poe Pet br oe : ga 4 me od os Dy ay eh , $i Ga es cl a, ay Ys ise! ie Oy ret é te "if Oo sheet 8 wp Se : wy pn mo "Geno Be Z cd sae we 3 as Mee, 1 a i gon, ' al 7 a -- a oe Ss 5 re ied bn, ea ae ea ot "eS ei ve ; Bea he z ; i ' 4 an ; ;
eo " a fo if Tet yn pit ret 3 , pea io a ret ey heed . a3 'tos ae : 3 bed r a =, ie es oy "3 a 63 ca os oA '3 Ss nm 8 oi mB A eS > a " 8 & & Mm shoud os * fap) "Ee i * aA he res raf " bet rat a ee a 3 OF ao 31 we 4 i ee em S oy : a ete & mM 2 ay fo ' x cA bi *: me oy ie a pea 2 Thad ms EG f : Pa ee os ry > 4 a res 4 $ : H aed , rE ; rn é ou, ae veh Bf = a , iS ne", Ho 3 Oo ee - "3 as it J G2 ia 0 a3 i peony % ad a3 a Ch , , se bt cr abet Pie ae . oat i ae . £4 et mm i a rok a ge yea os pes ped cpt % 3 Md wrens pos a 4 "eg oy ine we ee! es ey a Lo weet 74 ms iD apy ma, so ra wa a te pono peeess 4 phe ry. a a at' "2% 5 Be oR ® 25 a ae) © a fet "
a el v3 we ot ™ es, thecl ate (rood reper Ap "
pete tans ee St Me gated fens : a Cet. a ire! ee bet , mt Sohn bt heed as 7 bat poh ee ie . SB Bp BB Bm sm © 2 ote on a: nn? ar ef ot Bo, 48 86 ¢ FS £ = 2 8 wo os ae nn ee : a « OG th 8 & a © mt tg . & & 2 € 2 » © mye 7 re ap "s rend : raed 4 ot ae pe "f peel ie gd ve 4 are we sent oy na se om best ee by is ie: eS 5 fo a + ret whee! pi 3] FED : ~, oo Ch a ie Sach 08 eae we ee ; ~~ 3 4 a 5 ne f ager$ BS ie ud ay th oe fea oe £ ia oy Cpe CO mA ee fa - Nye | a % preen soe, ones ee 14 froth 1o8 hd Cy w ag' ye 4 Sa ees few a [es g oa fen ~ wpe rhe iS $ - pa tga oon deeds wed & ae ce Ay aS i fot eas om Sd a es red, fhe eed a mB A ° BS mem fC fF eo "3 Gn EG wa Pax : ost he Fa] : on » t3 ad iE oy wy A 4 ig a4 sot £3 rt gi on hot 6 'ne poet on pps i as a bey oe wh ra on 2 es a o ha 6 a spot og rm ae whe ay os oa is pa $ * rf % pak nak Lae ce 53 cee te. age aS me hie te vied ff Bm ge fT 8 Fs a Bay , Bo F Bf OB % ee "teh pie oy " Ea So a cs ae re 0 ' ss bok get ' renee cl peed ent, es Paw * ay xt 60 yes jet £4 ee at aS en: cc pies ae i bak. a ws, ae we LA "pa Soa oS ae a ' £y 4 os og a3 os mG orn gS ee ee eS of a 7 a. i & a Gt ehek be sod srecet a food oy ined % een; ass 4 ; poet got a teed ba ied me ay ne, a 63 e @& § nr es! ee ay be we a e a3 C5, a " oa ee cs ise eg weed ws & Se es 4s eh Se Ad mee e4 a peer, ed sored A oa we aa ane en oe bed th oe ad ee fete Soot an ay oe vk ~ ae) fra fed pe tee , erage ee pee 4 fon hh os en ope pes ee ee 5 "ta as 6 oa We be ua ng a3 poet spot % hog a "to ™ ae =: font a 3 eo red : co oe Be ia oes vag Ebes fo a oe nied Oi ra wedend ia - SO : Xs. ic Co if te prank ad a A ted i ea soos ded 8) br 9) 4 "eget me & hed th ms CA ohn Ch, + phe ; aed : foes fy Le weed es trek ot nd bot i ey - Ch v & 4 cet Speed * : ; Z a" ¢ a peid shod 2 ah mam S a ee A ; 8 & & 8 e B rs . me im ch tea fee tyed re " et a a BG a3 pos bod cae ee a3 oe fem Fo ca US ci Mes Pees nda a el got et aaa ae oped oe hes oi re prod ot Qo ed to po pink yd bea pre ee Gt a3 % spe ehcod * EAD ed, 'eed res i Ps ease Cheek Bs aa od . rt rent ra ae © Head om uA io a i} fo be ta ci ps wy : um po poet Spe 1 ood pe 6 4 ars herd wk = oy abet eee bea dhend ve pee ayes "3 ay spot OS os em pooek bond oe " wh Les nk Ahead q Ks ps, a ms Ga o pd fax! oH x38) eet speed t ae fhe bs red Be ok ay me a oS iD a aes " i mh ms ge rot Bd oy Sa : ro oat oad ages o ae wo ; Lob rh a we G3 rt ey cy a ca i f 3 By be recs ms" 4 mtg 5 ot a ee Ries ee os G 2 ot mak 3 an ved 55 ae " a f be o A Js sg 4 es es Ww ds fos fa iS ces i "4 hoe 4 ot be o ded ae ie 4 a3 od Cc i ed a we & a em eo fed Ge i : ig ie & 24 " ss) cS eri xe aad ioe od oe be a : $3 ' ne ae co 5 mos rn re et & fA ai bog Sy He £64 oo a be beses) i) ape bo To ine a ba Se > ss ag ua fed ork a « oS fe 4 us wD fed 4 fee o 6 8 w. # 9g F&F & O "2 th fo te oy es "3 foe ie i> wa cue pot pan ; ; seni ° ea a fot a a s 2 2 8 & Ss £ © @ ws & @ mB ££ Ss i 'tat Feel Ce. pant ry oe way Siege _ +. had Pee nye, - :
ES pon my we ap m5 am bh ae Pe SS "dl oo v4 be ow ie Se et ce bee So rm ee ad ee hed oo now, as oa "35 teed Gs ores P rok oe ned. afer ye teeet weed whet ad ae i c oan ayn a6: ios) +3 oe wo pe bet et ape GS ao a wi servi a cs, Ea cot a aS a: wh ie cas a4 oy ca food acer' ty barnes ga ot : 4 : tee: ons mS sheet hee! ¥ ' % £3 kd hy : i af ' cs hod eed sheet : y Had ee pe ay ied 5 a3 4 ee wer npg | eT Cee men "i Oat a ag Hees ie 4 i fF tok "3 & ae 44 fee:
farsa oon "SI pa ond ud Bos "abool ' Mai ee - J peed : Ewe beh tn fa as nt £ cs ted + yeh ct ay mo oO ty ei * te oy x oa on ae id he i cit Bid ts 3 tes % a} Sod ah oe ee a ee ve "Font es ves ea ws a A ; be io ; se:
ee iy cad oe we 1a] oe taped ; = 3 OM hekide a re pooein "i Poot i3 ft Ped ee 2 fot Hh ms ic a Ge 3 we em ae cs Sock pr ed ioe) ® te u) faa ae a ee) pet oo 4
- pent u A tay $ Ps " ee i oe ve oo Be ep fe CA Ay Sed ee 2 YQ a ad a ms oe ie a a4 fos oo tet fe ce wo a rn . & 6 © & JA a & iS we "Ch rr Ly @ a3 re 3 ree a .
" jets iro open Fax sae . : asi ec Pica fees pare ° gen a3 re oo Lag - iad seed tg & preert god thnk ae) © Soni a int Feel aa oy oo a pct ' pa Pook ca - a C4 i i Cr od ree 143 *pet oa ws os "" & 4 4 QB fe a OS 6 me ms 5B GO @ oA ae 3 Cs igo " bine red ' el Poe 4 rote ; iol rr eal me re plod : fas agend th tos . ' oe ron et Seed: ie Soom aa) Fae oO bn nee ; 4 al es Gf g¢ 8 = 2 2 & weet ~ > pe pes met sh ' aan oh , ee oo oe a fe 3 it ot ae om oe re pee front ica & # ms, 2» 5 7 3 ge a So @ ae & i eS FS og 8 bd ape, eo £5 rn oe. ated x, fodng iy Ped re { if shoes aga Exe & Ee Nay ae es e fod a o ae oo 4h
5 wre ; , ": gee ae a pt z est oy % foe em . OS Sor 2 8 te a xe ; Pe a ed o£ we 8 a Ky 43 et : ee oe ar, wget el soem ae) aS ioe! ke Sos ie 6) sroeet ot reed a pa poled, Sod me) ee a ~ fe dood aby Pas) oe oe . j ion. ee) ron a at tony a + pen oheok Ft ; : i a0 * i { in te 3 38 " SS -¢ 'e s Sn ne ef eon 2 og yw Se GB wg ¥ pees Ss a : 4 'ah ? sood st A a ood based ee G3 fa Go S € & & € 4S ns eas 'BO Be moog Pg or baa ae et i) 3 pvt 4 he oa be ry j et : % font "4 we oF oa a on bp a3 es Pent ad + pk ie ae ay "ee , & : eo , 4 ; ;
me a "te $7 pee rat G3 be scene cd a Bet oo eS Poe § § @ BS eo ee a os a ne ie rh 4 he ae vat "
Z Mae, LO ayn, ae s, "ae re *, ie, A LBB aye, as, eee eek iid ? 'eek oF) the g ey Spend ant ; we ha he f as fos peck 4 oka og "A oO oy Chet ae ih reer , f oo en oom mS Ye Bg -« iy @ 8 ° a ne oe ay os Cae eS sepeey os Sb Ag On o ; t is " Se "oe "3 i 7 i ; w oh es oO i i E 4 id 5 8 a 8 "a a oe nr rs iS itn £3 pa fd bea a3 ra od hag 55 oy wo ine 4 ty oo re a -- ne oe ee sa aie a) i Oo oo i ie Be ke ried 3 a £3 a a el i rf wm A B ' B fo Et af He ao mo ff 2 ow mo 5 B f ¢ Pat i ped "3 ow heed 1 = frre cs y 2 wed "oe Kad 4 a tos as ae) tool speed prt @ 2 5 ane fe Os 2S 8 & OR i gg oe i Oi ; enn fos re fe ll os ae 5 aed 4 44 re wy * £3 pone 'a on ae i ue fhe reer a i tal - eS wy : ae bot as oD oy iA iA moss rss Ea 2 Pr oad . ts i ag wet 4 4 "n het aed at at ay aM 4 ' -_ ce cog 8 a8 8 Gos So F og gq of fea Tent bas et Bes ; as By so oo a fe Cot C4, peas pan a em, Tite s, vy if re oa , oe TAF
- ay : ue Sa ; yn ag G 6 toad at et nae ass ted Sy & rs nce - a bed iA C 3 be ba ore fet rig or a ot a La ae f Gg mi & 3 & £ HS & a 8 ae ~ a ie o red od ; pei + red a gerd oo igen ; ad ed a ta ¥ ap aS yreed fond, aa best Soc, a a % " Can a fae su 5 on "be pe pei py ind om fee s ong ed pons os. "ed any: se ted a c eo aes Pt ors oo) ' oe « cs a 2 es Ca os 'ea os pent mm JS wn ey re A, _ ire A 's, "cs ty "Cy ot 5 ff bet bod & ved Ae ee oe a as 2 ye a SS c a as it fe ne et re a3 ey Foy ee fe ped "ys the os "
ee * Anew a 2 , ; pod $e 4 ® B #8 iad mS eG TS a Cy el a ns go to ¢y "3 cos by, cara er ca my a a a. of ot be aD % , a re mm i iT pa a os ms aa ae ¢ oe peed boar ' pa 7 oF 2 Pe he penoeg * ae tA on ® fe j co ane races 1 dea a3 bee a wee my eek es 3 4 j ' , x 4 Upeod £ bed ies a 2 | Bog 3 8 2 2 & sy ne e 6 EB Y o , ent te § 4 'a ae " ike 2 < £ oe << ey i fy a ae ae cs poly & Sed at fo a Sy fe a ogo deed <, Crete fe ey Oe ° 650 + " 4 ee fy hee, yt tka rey oF a8) ts C% eed ert * ah, C4 vee ee et teh 5 a ve a ; rg x io :
oe a fost ' DB ie , rion ee ba ES i co ao § cs a is es ot o ce a) Sas &, = "es a a ie A a} yo fy ey Gf bom os 7 " ol et a wo oo ; ; a3 y * é 3 ped fd cn nr oF ra food ae) a wen a aa het aa ss fod oi te ae e Ke 5 £ # ° fot ae meee Conad cet wees inford a 2 re ro pee ot pdiog a a aA -, ee cook an Oe & oo a: a rs oe 4 foot ad cy 18 oy us . tec fs vt ye ~ 3 4 " SS ;
ms 4 cH wa a OD Ps 6 SS o os nts iq SD oft & a cs wt Chis ead re pened, ay aged om he Sate ae Lease ea sen 4 TRAC 5 ae a:
Siew ew 20 om 'bie, POD, te, or Peneigae aoe le » ae) By Ay ¥ * ak oe & tf He < 3 aS, ple al x TN refore, the p c cant and th ts ng the app :
Yl thout hea * Wi Lap it f mot been followed, According to ¥ ~ g bey ha fice sd so al du > a re an , OF a 3 'he t Qr f of sh Dande, learned counsel ] pplicant 2 arashtra Pr 3 a es) } Re
"6 wh 4 'tet BS 42 GH . 'eG on:
a 9 # g¢ © 8 ~ ey ce) a: oe iy SA ty os ' nn) | mo" ple cs ed on rs Ge te be ts seed ob, S aS) pont oo bs tect as as Peed hot oe ome gt oo es asad ae * ves ee povod pa ee Z ee he vee . pa ot eh a be a a3 tabs Anh heed aS i or . fim, at +e i By Peet pea be es
-; ager as as cf ice ry Gy is 9 #4 ed cas bet "
yoo A bark 4 "4 : bh ot ie uy got re AS te oe A a. ning fs . : 4 -, ee e & & Bog g 8 8 of of © 5 & Bed teks ES ms, ee i Ly wes A wy . at 5 et aj eat oe ; ; pode ' Pond on rat ' ' Lk C3 BS ry oe cy fog ay ns: = a ; is Ci Se re a Spoke ot ms oo oS re 0 is nese ub os + faa a fat od poo w " Pee wa a0 " pod ih oon ia Bod ran * ia is ee oy fed 7 3 et roel Cr Oo & cl gs te o Aan ee Ea PA £3 ys Fg a £3 o om +s a : wick ae var "a Be om o 3 rab) seri tod ¢ ame) pe sa fod 3 ren oS ' ee o Be ey aff Ke 0 we Sp ae i if ca ty prt & a " ye es eed sot - as) pea re a ie Bo i 2 8S 5 8 & 2 8 8 ; i j 3 : j fre, pee pont a te ei BS a $e 5 oe we cE he beet i oy < mt - By Al G3 a oo 4 od fe eon os ; - hs os poe o aan $5: a ee & fh oo B re ete ceed oc tevert a oy mp a ' prem, pean: crs reek ~ 2 6 6 Ff ee 7 > 8 g 6 "3 : on ner . por, Cat , , "tg '4 Be me Eo B Son tg is Boek faced en Cs ro aad iat ye 3 ; 13 bra ry , By " "eh 4 4 : ee ' fd eh a " ; g Sf Bh ws 3 & BS 4 US Sh ms ot ge C ial eat oe a 4 . thee ry Beck 'a oO ahead , Co prec Po, 3 pled ou errr tH orn Pedy bs et ee . ; oa o Cy en eg 6 a ee oh oad ™ pak B q ane foes ; ce oe. 5 4 3 aheod co keh G sree, ey 2 hs fe Gf a3 ime apr 8 8 8 2 x es g 5 8 DO @ 8 , 8 £ ae)
i) : cs ae rd , , j 7 ps ed ss : ° ue 6 6 8 Ff 8 & Ss @ &£ S$ & 6 @ & uy en Ss ¢@ o g¢ @ ™ ay i ay eh ' eg ft & AS ae oa Edieg fa iy Bes 3 po 2 & ne 7 a de 8 Bo oo Herat a) es " as a phd ved ; fies : a3 pas tie inet ed res eo pehood one Heed Pesan] Band Cy eed ao : "53 ba perch me eo et "a orn rd & $7 oof om png to te bat im) ES o cD ts} ret hr te rr oe C3 a ce Gl ta Pa i e Pe a i, ror : Fol a - i oo a a et mm | Go Bu _ g¢ & & Bm ie ve eer mo EP Re Q eS 2 x a Gh, ge ba bray a bod | Pea oa pa as aed, ~ ot re "t cm Bb SB 8 > «2 & & 5 es o a Pao ae te é en i £ ag haat s 53 8 8 2 8 & tH Gf mG oe re i: ae! pues ore a ree ea oe "
x Theos , oe oo kon co bo, we PF a A bs we ES job ded a, x e eo ro C3 re oS sad eel Ee ws : et 'at .
a © oa or , mo wf ¢ rss * se te oe oe re. wy '8s 3 Ce @ be fos @ & ws fe ob spud ° pont ot CA us ah i. @ 2 by re mo OR @ a EE va ed ages . Om Cy a Ch wt a oe ¢ 'et 6 ed wr od "ad an: A x ' eof fs aheee cmd o. iy 5 9 gy te oI a res ep rt +s iG Ga oe y ; os ~~ os A 2 8 > F Ss & 6g | 8 a aa a3 al } oF F bee an A a ta Coe poh a yor i: -
Fy : 23 wo g & > Ss a pa rm a . meh red ao os i ee oe i Pe & on me sped wed oe pened fond pa Re ion ta aan O " o % me fa Ss: ho 7% " w a wt A og Bo Fa bd fos oh te a OS By es Be age Chet cd ers ie! " ed 'eed x, he t : ; i Lise wy eed be ; 2 ¢@ § @ § € = z & ~ fd fod ot uf pe # by a ed o, ns
3 3 8 8 mR Mag BOR ss 5 wy thé Saban 4 of : ' £ 7%, tent a ie om . ot me ay A fo 7s ae Re a ce a v4 a we a bes " & ® & ae me i Be fy fom fry a S ; iS wi @ va f as ns a ipo oe | rf ann = yf we Sg oc , lh eB Ss 2 8 oe 2 om m & ey} 3 ' en x ne) oe BE Crags ra & a ox be .
ne res Feed ned ' & in om Po em yd " 28 6 Bf . 6s aS 8 2 -
F te hie ee on 7 ta) fm, ' * bas bs Sina? i ren Boe a3 oa sped ' i nd a a ad x Fes pm, bea nood i Vice? bs, f ped ; i 4, :
s B 2 € & seed pond veers estat, rat aes es ee OUNTE o Re cS £ a oe rere, rant. A mobi LCS en, The ey ave aris d not kh | cash and mobile phone wou a No. 1003 2022 of 2 a 4 10 x A * ~ aS al BERSE Beare 2 the iY LORS * allewat s a pplicat ;
< a re Fal € applicant f 2 £ fowas aware that he was ra re ae hes fen) iD cn coed nee BB ¢ ras bg peatot OF a ne | t 2 Sy & services of the applicant without assigning any reason and this fact had been made known to the an £ san . oe <eomet : ~. awe we eee od . a ay ne me ehh _ a Therefore, bis services were terminated whhout any ree Varleas 4 aye ery wemiates beet acktia Lhayelenm reason. Rules do not contemplate that while issuing termination order, the concerned employee needs to be x co eard. Therefore, there is no question of violation of principles of natural justice. It is his contention that being a probationer, the emplover has the right to terminate the services of the applicant without assigning any reason. Mr. RVR. Shetty, further contended that the services of the Postman are highhy sensitive in nature. He has to carry confidential correspondence and deliver ff to the addressee. He has to handle cash while delivering money orders to the concerned person. A person having a 2 Fed
9) fx gS rae iy a rn"
bs > 63 on rey Ge ie & a oe 4 pes:72 2
Os & Si
a) criminal background, the Nor CERE arye contrition rm Services. {Peretore Me t 2 soo ' * i ral ep % ry ep eegy } of % Rate ". Ket aS a mr appdcant fies Dean rignthy terreinated from service. He eee wey fai hy Sage Paes DQ ayency further submitted that Rule 5 of rylees ote eo ee Pe Kas wa Ls ws * a ae Cas Cos ie a "a woh wo ro ag me pod ee nal nm ; Pn ey tage as by eq bot is <a 3 ne 5 4 pas ey Q a8 bf , me i a 3 whe Faxs boc wy w "it tht i a ae nd oon, * (ar se) A. ie wpe 2 2 oy Soh gi oa phot da bed eG a * eS red roe Cy on Pp a & % bank wd Bet be " OK = & inet rc oe a on eas on pa ao i oy Ao Gy * 3 03 4 oo oo se 'a we rs oS ea boy rae a hs oy ° ee p z "hg aE bod ee wi hy os ~~ Oy v ped . A ; op fa, mn, ur, ' ar "Ga reek oa e 1s 2 e o im @ 4, shed vee oe ban , ; ? gee, o i oe s cS a 6 4 a8 is 5G e , % aca were pt eS BM , % aan vod is) we om fy Ok om, gh ° ae en! a ae rr hes ee phot ' i, jek "4 ae i poo, oe 8 a ay En, desk Fh ook ae post boats Caek . 'ot es & ite bene, eres a eC aot bos oS ad ve _ SG - Go OS me. mM 2 ; ot £ » wd ret A oy ix, ond fe " @ oh ae od ba so ty fA , ma i "e a Se bo "Le: oh: oe, i 3 Bs , ve Bs: =, we $ ce i ie * oe wm eS es A heed ee a . Se 2, vn es 3 ee eS ma Sym a ars, mf a Po ried wy Ty ne: ae : Py pod ; fond Pontos pe rer, he "} ' Pe, . gg & - 2% 6 ¢ i, BS or de a 3 e rae a is Pe os n ea es Sp : | me Bo bm eh i 8 i ? bes Ltn ; oe ay j a Ae gy ee i "ee | m i 5 pl me Lf ee Ca et os 2 > ge ey OBL eS "oO ep og _ ¢ & 3 Ly pe , é Lee gy. rn on ayers , aos & & 6 ¢ @ BO 5 2 eg a oh oP Sod ey ms Pad ee A ee Pm, bon oe » pom pee pe j a . wis sea! gn ; g se for foo, es wh ota cA A Soh ie Pies Soak re ps be wh ae me tA a wn ee Br, ae Bo Zoe Y eo % mG Ds ee 3 a B a Ys ' 4 poo jo 4 .
Ease a 2 ro ee bu 7% B til tofth bs we a LA fd fos ' ' : Ss ae: A 0 8 Boe = Fm 5 SD mG ad a pm wg a bug fee Se oe be ~ 'ent dS fevt el <P we al po s mg a Sean? a os 5 Fs a sa ore oO By oa Se? ee it ke Mn 74 Seog?
ot es cen, "enn?
ae) bre ee wf Cy OG 'Steet aaa eat wes peed wank rk a % £ bed ee a . rh red ot hee ae ay ; 1 4 ~ oe , os A a 63 ap *E5 L, ret te os Ly bape , get at of ted pe i a "fe we "hes bed fi "pat oe a prerk e 2 , my a Byok 45 me Ss ; pf oped 4. ioe) ms ch) font, cate gti Ca whee 7 cy tei! Qo SB So Ff 4s a yo ™ & ee nh pao) oo 23 -; is bral : a ie a "x oo bo we we ates wee £3 het oy is me ex a3 4 wey feed CG baa vate " weet ms apes z a . Oh : Me steed éj ot "a es & j ¢ 3 pe bed jot pond men phen oe KG as " 'hea a tt viet 1 #3 oe ov set 'i oS vk oh we 4 fay S 4 io bed ra re 2 Cc 2 ot ct , a wi as i my, ee he et oS oe a oS ex ; eee fae) alee as aan wher » fs a pe hei bee @ has of ", ? . Le ay cael het i 4 aa reer t : % % a 6. So a 3 v7 oy vt "4 Sd 4 a ¢ * : os 44 pal ne om " a bs ae sete nc a oe a3 > he Gh ks a a8 P te 8 FR Bo & re . et * cot AS "ee pot "5 veh an fe oe 8 mo ag ea fe & Bm. Pha sat anne me cred tes oe Sa oe os oth ca af a os mm os cA md prheot "Cy ey ola "ee ¢ j a 1 ees F : bead gree ia - ¥ . as oot Hag es mo a eB ap a Bo ae ~ aired oa ac os 5 ; cof ret te A d ot chook ss 2 we 2 gt OU So "es Byte on we "eae! ee eee) as way are be tad heed. Oe Tha 7 bee, . oe as Dard v9 sae OR geen Br oe hess agent Ex "sipes Fits to pees og we pe' ee ae be on % a 3 td rn 4 Fa seg! got ¢ : gre sa pegoth ch og teed ot os CO ery or bee, ne QA "he Fes) bet as ot . ri Aped ip i 5 on Peg %, G3 rien mh, ms het * ed : % Eats et a } "ert oe be eee the uy toet { & oy is nig x of aS peed C4 bh kody bac nd ith ooh iS fe oot Beat 3 ~ wet hed heed - egret ie ed hot ee the oo red get f os ey ¢ $77 re ey cs on mB Pat 5 in pe 1 et a ke 3 fe fot £ 3 oem ord red Cs pari i oS oo wee cone? sgeed aa 8) é Sood eo] rhea bhef wa 4 oo = ct * Hg ne oA Got ee we ta frome tet C as oD Elect oh oe be us , ee 4 4 ry ca) an lewd Ke 4 ; ban 5. 3 ns ei. « 7% Z 4% ete gf mw wo a be a arcs Sg Ce pon its Se seo = ae bon Sodas sae 2 he phn ped ee ee tod a a a i 4 ; ret re oe Faas Eos, £ 4 ® gt ae 4 oe on 4 ve pot , vi ly, wy oy tod i el 5 a 4 teak es ee mh 3 aa age £13 a Seon $3 goed, G3 on cae £ Sed = '4 tid a oy ee. pe "et BS coe oe OC fs re "ed 'Ds 4 . . ft mgred Spo poved pon Ch 1 ot pod es oa o sea . ise
--_ 'es ad ae ina iy ry "Gs Boas on ane bid a wi a - cS a o 2 OS Pee ro oA i f a j tet 4 : é * 3 rem .
m4 Bb Bb & oS 8 ae a a , ve : be rd ped i i , : ad ae ape A ¥ a7 4 prresd , dag ry edt - fond th By gy a res cy oe 2 13 et & pee - if Ps re hy gs he oo B 5A sad ae oo ba po eg at foc ves ough ie * me cre Pe a a ia Bi fom ths a aae! good oi & nk 4 pede poreeh 4 Pees pe d ab she tf pone fed sore £7, pot im wot ec good mS nay, tA hE A, & fs Baht "at ree yo +e s yy ; d ae booby pana Pig hi Pe ae a) we _ ae ts . es tod . Ph be hes a pen, 1% 2 "ot eyed yey :
nye old wey me FS Free, ce) wd Wa ¥ "a ee, ms "onan res rae, Ry stk LP crn a , 4 ere , poet Post oe a eS @ gt as oe mg EQ ae ' nn ; a | bs oa ws Sent os am ae) gi 2S Ce: By aes ae ef 8 eR a mB OR & a oa ed wee ee as oy by - res 3 ree et ' fa a3 vee oe fe aC Sg Bs fe rn aot need ged vo oe oa os beg ~ "oot i a re a Ee tose won 4 rend vy mt to pod Co A Ro fo vt r oy, Ee me Ce os "fend a Pee ood mo ber eA agent ey * a my ions vat fad tes ay % G a3 a a ee fa aed = ba on 4 2 € ort @ oA £ S * iss wo es sha , : is a | Bot re Py Sh gS "et nA 3 ne on a th Be OS AE ee) tans rd be me a " _ Ss a dee ba Fd oh en pe ho Port g pd oe "od Fa > fea poeod re ' e a eG ~ €@ 8 & © SF we. 9 & 7, cA 2 Fone soo as ' r &3 * 4 3 ed bared he "Hbeed : 5 : ite a tok ' a on oe of ; & me we a rae Drev or geet cat ty Nae Oy yee Peas ae Li oA WA gy j cs 3 ao ong Q Wh is oe ies ty oa ot ne " e. S ot y a an ° a ee a ree rn @ F ~@ & Go 8 G & re BS fe a ee Sf ef OS & & cs cA en LP oA rh od Po a 3 # xg io ae) oy res 3 a3 43 i, ag "ft wad oo iy eed Gi ue rr aid a ae " " caf # A Se Seed oe bo % hes a te ies ae ea a 2 et aod -
= God 3 ££ ¢ & oS 2 F g FF Fe ' : Conan 3 : 4 So ms Peat weboatt Laan ren rere ; ms "A " B os 'ered fn a ied ¢ pera, oS an pe 3 oA Sa ees os xg. ras be Aro :
& © " 68 3 « Sw © £ Bog 8 © eB 2 'abet "et o. "yn den fas! rehet on ed i ' a ae GES 8 6 oF ve g & 8 ¢ ee ee 2 aa 4 3 C ape a fae} Soot eyes C3 oped 4 ed is os) head os on en wend ay 2 bx ay ; ee me be 9 42 8 Js ae "a € 2 G > i bm an mG r3 a3 pit 7 Re woe ~ iol vg see ka ax a ies vs: 4 hood Ci a is Ra as é o 5 j ne es € 2 # mR So Xa 2 8 8 & © re wed a fe Passe oo 1 ae a rick a oked tet oy
-- te So @ 2 'sg 3 e § & € eB se . a a <, Be " ves eho ad o ' vs o teed ee ms oe] me Reng fos Be . & if iso) ie , rd eG a BB g 8 BS S& wy on a a 'Pp m i a Be ; bh feo fons , ro Pee 3 551 ot "4 ot A spon oe Oe ra ' ba : bet ga mn ; Ss Y oS A ot ees oe as a can St pod es ~ P ae wee bn es a peed oS " ¥ wiper peers weed ry Col me ir a3 go ct co aes niet dont feos a "4 & So a 68 '@ 2 & S$ &@ & BB 4 am ~ j on iS "ee 3 CG GS og we BG » & fF 8, See Gos S og & es £ & a 8 8 a 3 fi : i a got ¥ a ; 4 er oot oe ne "ad aN pe a3 t i ip x ob d % fons apo 5 33 4 oa peed oe wed co ere 5 a ae [en fe oe ded Eo hr ma % me & & a a OB 9 Shy c eo 4 oF oF we em 6 sie ewes 4 4 oh "
i om aa mie ad be eA ce Ba}
5 3 bie cs Ea es Ae eh oS d 4 A OO 2 GB % 2D PANIDD apy % x OF cancellation of candidature fer ivi:
information, the employer may take notice of Special clrounmtances of the cage, ff ary, whis giving Such informadion, $8.3 The employer shall take into consideration the SOvernment anersinstructions/rules, apolicable to the smplayes, at the time of tak g the decision. pats AW Ray son aw ane Sng -- . Sane tay ae on . peek $8.2 While passing order of tannination of sarviess . % 3&4 in case there is suppression information of lavalyement in « criminal cas 3 iy & eo, a am bie 4 & post in question, the employer may, in is discretion, ignore such Suppression of fact or false informaiion by candoning the lapse. $8.4.2. Where conviction has been recardad in case which Is not trivial in nature, employer may cance! candidature or terminate services of the employes, 38.4.5 Hf acquittal had already been recorded in a case involving moral turnitude or offence of heinoua/serlous mature, on technical ground anid if is act a case of clean acquittal, or benefit of reasonable doubt has been given, the employer may consider all relevant facts avaliable as 45 aniecedenta, and may take appropriate decision as fo the candnusnce of the employes, SSS In @ case where the employes has madé declaration truthfully of a conchided crimine! case, the smiployer stil fas the Nigh! t consider anteredanis, and cannet be campedied to appoint with fact has bean truthfully declared ferfication form regarding pendency of aee of frivind nature, aimployer, in facts cas oF the taea, in ite digeretion may Ne candidate subieet te decision of such ge et wos ti G & person againel whom mulisis criminal cases were pending may not be proper. 38.8 f criminal case was pending but net Known te the candidate ef the time of Ming the form, stilt May heave adyerss impact and the appointing authority would take decision afer considering ths serigueness of ths orien, 38.8 In case the employes is confirmed In service, holding Ospartmental enquiry would be necesss ry before passing order 'of termination/ramoval or Uisniissal on the ground of suppression ar submitting faise infermation in verficaticn forrn, 38.90 Far determining supgression ar false information aftestationivarification form has to be speciic, not vague. Only such information which WAS Fequired to be speciically mentioned has to be discioses. HN information not asked for but fs relevant comes to knowledge of the stiployer the game can be considered in an oblective manner while addressing the question of finess. However, in such cases action cannot be taken on basis of suppression or submitting false information as to a fact which was net even asked for.
$8.11 Before a person is held guilty of suppressio verl or suggestio faisi, knowledge of the fact must be attributable to him."
i§. In para 38. 8, it has been observed by the Hon'ble authority would take decision after considering the + 5 ae sy ry x zt ng. s wpe scaers sikey eee a wy} ey oy} EP or ee om ayy "Ms ay seriousness of fhe crime. In para a8.a, has heen held thet ar { v => ubmitting of att ACS nt 8 y lered b rt geveet py a Sed! a 3 re ¢ Sheet weg nd bork , ; om 2 3S "© 8 « 8 € 6 8 B@ B82 2 ire Foe . a pts 3 wa ss Y go oA w ne go" oe Be EOE ie = a 4 ie %: rant a - sa Pic fa % a as) oo os oi se « ri yhed 6 ct fee) tes 5) e. 2 3 fa 2 perk vos ord oe she i a wo: w& al fon & ; & ae od ie w 3 poet ae cea t8 ty iw toot tans ios bane ee fied po (a6 oes : yy Page pers 4 ro ia apes a whet Ey: ose rg oA 15 a On % 4 233 be » we tS pe wy eos e ' ret < va G3 ei! foot a pam ie im be Gf w rr rr = ad is ee os rd oe a G3 ~~ eee = Fi rey e ay apo ra mi aa wo ' » re * Be ae on 3 me ES % ro ws bs o ese:
a & & So > 3 4 4 9 € 3 sen Fa) roa fat ad ae Se ry Z oor Bed oe) red Coa peel ° ?
ae pas or febend ces a) weal Co od tt beh 5% pod a ci z ree ies ig tA aged 5 og 4 a oo aa oA 4 et cd : monk net pet 3 ood ce ies fo ; wt : "East oy ms x; on 5 a " fae x oo ioe en aA " ent sees rs a 3 aes cs or es oe 3 ai: Bed Cteet spe : an] weet Ch "3 nee beat dy ped it cm = ty z a get uD grbont A bate heed y 5 tel font " xa pe aS ct oS Sat 0, wat ere required to move fo r 4 On ccc! oh, Jon $2 bes : Co a © ~ ms : e re: eens, hd ", , y } ee TA @ a nh es c 5 8 Bo RF ey Ho me te i a ee : ee ed a a aos ; mS 2, oh oy ee oa ae i res eS th io . eo , © 6 8 2 b Be GS BT Fe 7 mt ae ae) fede i thy oA ae . S er ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee * Ai pape, det a as io rrr = oer eed reer i on rt en yr fea i, oa a3 as fot prod eo 'ee:
go Go Ss tg o & 2 & = Focal 3 eg fet £e pwd 2a : aa £ " wee "Tr id fag] ms wy ri a oe cy aa on wm win fos oS os vt sa on ae fot ont re fog ert } 4 ved be f a) es ei Cc a SA we mt = 25 a oc > 2 = so es wo we get ioe Pa] Y oe o Fa ° Caen en ° Seok Bo & 2 Oo 8 Goma Bm . Sf ae 'a oS cent Cy het ed os 7s 8 oe a C3 Cy es & Ps ab Bet Q oe cs re '= C3 en ne Je a a ie (nS CN aa aa me hi a BS mt ee ees ee ep ba es ne a4 a coo , Pd a Bp ee} ae ee as & igs my fe CT io ay ace as bes Bm Eg oe & FF 3S £ FO a 'ntoed cei) oo wa pa % con oe a aah bot ti oe, = Sei en al a a ct ae a fa a) it o wake Se a et ee ae "po oO arc ot "cA 2 fe oft gy Dy be ' abort i a ; A ts Ate ert oad 5 rer a oa ; nob PP ba 4 4 a iv fem) 4 Ut 4 sat iy of i657 Lh tia 20) te i" fori, ork £ . : fn a ss eo Bs a © teheod eh sit . -- rey é x4 oe é al 'ot 6 OUD Go mt Sea aes fe rod 4 tae Fase wh i "ed ee pes Hy oA t ocd it oo A 4 a bea oe? TS agen te ; ot ed "eo pod Ce re GS es ane é x Poe [ea hers are ee ra wth acs a nee GA bas o pe es a beg hs wee aa wheat pet mt Cn ay eet OM ae gs ; as t red fon c . : ' i € t bea oy cae : pion ao 7 ' od . p 'oe! nas eid" eed on dé Law! ie) Pec! oh ba is Ge f @ © 5 ££ 8 2 sheet ' ws ner Ses i) "hse shee?
; mS "ft a3 cred sores * om) oy ie = -- & & 2 & g 2 6 & 7 8S & o FP SB 2 ce te 1] a iti 18 Pa od d co pe nbd pe ; fot Be an rps ipod re ot stead ta geet id Fendi fobd ee: prek ied cs sree cy ring . weit "yr oad re to & >t po hase 77 "he j eG as ene . U; ok . ac o prow :
A G & 4 @ 8 «= -& an :
oo gh, past 3 gt 7 yo Dey font : pion yoreed peaeed ew i 2 8 & 8B FG @ & ee bs tneh cae} hs %, fed gronnd es ci tase] oh POR it Bes eet a rhea 4 £ 7 5 8 "-- 3 ¢ 8 BB Be a 8 4 S ' ee £3 Ze Be ¥ zo : het oped a if? cs fea ee eer ee ' Le ee tat 4 od Aoad Seat "4 er bape vhs £7 3 oo Peed " cy Adeod, . Pr ving tea ie Resse Pee oD a3 Saal CH Pork a ; pat ahead Feat had uaa) we oa wn a3 Sec fe cas ' pee ced A or4
a) peor i oe ded Aocb : A si shad iat "iy oe 'GC te BB ge & Ga B 28 5 0 3 gt ae pent a) wr, Ee: ise) whe ee ped, @ pon, "pa oy poet Fre) "peed ar he : "Book : 7 4 go ft ina pages oe $y eek (s En , ; ca aes a3 eed po oa oF pee rs a bie ad cj os a (ct sot 3 os fond a3 a3 tes ; on fle ee spel :
oA a i SA BB hor a rn es oe me Go BD ig is fod . a wy ts ; HO spo a oo pees ) bed o « pe "3 63 : nse Hose wy poe Ponck pik te wy ree fot ee: pe 4 ms 4 cok tong rae) S pares, es fora Biss booed go tech bot on Ove aS heed Kec' & "eg my iG fas font on ma ao heck i: om:
re pe) 61 ' a oon ee i zi erect ve oe " ms ee "gd bes et a co : es: oo me chy Sed fos ae 5 DE Ge § OE " oped phn feted Ce pans a ze bent pa ey bs i Joo "4 a ee af ' a ae oe " a3 tS gs nn ers oe "eS on hedei ant oe toe Oe Loe gee a] greek om rege 2 S Go OB 2B S a a, ° "s pe if ce . 5 es ya thoek om pre mh swt wg yen % peo re ae 5 tans bebe fate oA fens ace co, ea 'i , ez i test ey oe pean? "Ey oe oy kak ns ne we "tay we jrock # ¥ yerd L f an oh om < 7 gs hood wee ° "net weet Coke 's A lied al pen pa teeth ee bol ey oe sot On orem, Ate ttcan, a LE pssaty 4 regrey. ae "3 ve, 63 Ct : a3 cis Sad & : a : bas 4 AG g¢ 22 228 3 a oad Pa gn oo " Apo OS se Sted + 2 | Bes fs ; , os ee 4 eu % 2p 2 FP & S 6 3 § $ 6 f poe B 2S 8 @ & Y " 8 8 ag oa ne oS 2 : Z ss 4 my fe om aie ae nea eye or co he bee rs pod és a5 pork red : i rot rook 43 the ced - tf) Esa ded vt ro 4 bed iat % tod of} deat 1" i) WEG a "eed i tet Fo oy is food * ie nek rt a3 Sod 5 o aes aS whe care ees pad : oP y as a + ps id Ce ia paws prod bs aS, Jon a3 a fax ce a Pe th 3 Taped iD te ae uy la erst e3 ag Ee 3 ed ; 4 wy PS as ae th a3 Pia revel a: ns 24 ben & oe Bogs cf Oo 8 8 @ ' fel so weg. Boda © A fe oe " i pho steed: sf wot <0 t hee et oh a be fet. oe fos - ed 4 3 C5 ed i fe ew z 5 4 : " a ; 4 a 7 3 nebo as 4 cS os ' ee on tA oe} iG Ae pont sae pokes rs 5 6 Bh og yp Bef s to "2 eS i Xahoot Bd pe C cy he eo 3 § 8 Bm ¢ oa - OC yu » ge of 8 | - 9 O 2 wm o ££ & my fs th AG 3 4 $3 fot} pace Wa Cee ag wg eos we yok i aos a ee the wh pay 3 es yes ids tt "tad : a pret ot pa ot grr oa 0 nA B ee a: xg ss Ras 4 -
uF ag pes GA SS é ? oie mea Fan a iB re Pe, ae ya fog oa on oor} pbc ; a & & x 5 Oo 8% & Re x » srheel o : : ; :
oo ; rood gol es io g eae ct ted es o vee Foot cS ; é * cn a et . ian heed & ws es o oe ad ei inehonk Aa oS of so % § fe _ at mi B mS A o ca fot 63 emf pam ee ries a vet 2, ped en grt 4 eet is] ia : BF "5 & § 3 4 o & = (5S Be oy eB < £26 * 8 rey em heed - te ay foot 4 ih ay ' oooh did ae sn: a '. tee real ; ay oh oa te mt ped ra "ns et i i ope a4 = 5 Ey € 2 % & © :
aed % oe 4. y & : A 3 "pa Be ve oe 5 S at & os a ge #8 ae 53 oa ee on ae ER a 3 of gon rey ot 2, bed 3 z ' ee m4 ae Reed wo rs ve irs] 4 pau ds pooon a3 EF sae wy GA Rint bea) cs oA - ty oy es. oa bol ry es & a te. ord 4 oa oy oe a & i (a i ee os wt 3 a ~~ 4 + pon z ago a nase pe cc) oy pa fet ee BO oy ES ~ ££ ¢ # 2 ee ore a ' * { "deol Ete! " spe fat ore se 4 bud pon on A a3 po ened Me uriee: an -, 4 en x Ay TR dont « pan ood i fant bef 5 a ed th 63 wot es 4 oy ea ry bos 3 fered 4f9 Eo ay pb wd ee) i. & Rees P : Ck 3 xe rs os Be aie 3 4 a4 ee a ok) j * "ahead ha ios tr nd og we ' fons i a coe oe ; GB hed ead 'aed oon ie ws 4 4 cs me -- ve , efeb % . ' - me wee aan cal 43 ee it a 2 ya a3 fet ae ps th EG perk pos as peed test spot vyer 'ed oF ky OL} th ve, we fp aa 4 ve 5 i SP "S Mag we a" "a rey fee shed 4 toes P wa ; be id fas: F e, ee Kes ko % weed ks a en pee fag vee Sos on enna (ed aM, i oo ey oa oe oo pd fe ae bia foe) ae neal ta a ™ Ln hs ory te reo we) hd ) za ws ody aon ae od 6 mS phe tered nt, 2 t big <-- ; we is eH, <3 j steed : feat vies es 3 4 ay ' at om @ a fe i oat a3 ci as Oo Th 5 my od by fd i i a es io wd Sod ns) oe oo roe a fe a af i a » ed rs i) vert ma the by bod ie 04 q i to (ba " a +7 fon + 6 Fad oe et . 4 Foal Fg" a we Boge ret 24 x4 2) tied tes af fed Hy eo os a set ae gs ro CA og ved wy * te a 4 cae " "re 4) a nS as ee ee = mg "5 Eh Gi i ve a oa Ba eh a mm vee Ea ay a 4 os A & me me 8 Be my Se 5 Pp "4 Ld Pm es tia oj igs had ay res aS bd} tA Fe im bea tt pas ee body oa ES _ bas oss fy aaa aj yet % a eat ot tode fora a3 oP Gg ae) cote nt seer oot CH ms 3 cs ; pos pees) ei rd : i a ye, yy hit as fe ee ? . reset po 3 yee c A. LA weit, 4 2 8 6p 2 & be & S$ & & ms 'aliak prerel ; ved Lee ¢ Ve) 5 3 fot LS es ta tal a LS oe ot oi reed oh vent oe ie oped wobec ' Prete, a S 8 » §€ EF 2 Gi ee Ee S oo uA body fs ioe "= a i aes bs ° Y "ft od roe bok on a a arent. ae by, "heat = es 3 z baegs + att 3 " Sead m doh foal om tats me wn ra} me bed fea et "2 * m er ' jp as i 5 @ sf ® 2 £ b& Be gy "3 ws eS GS ce 3 a = 9 a3 mE th A ce fod ra oe j a oe) me "Cn rome Biss "A me ws as o. bong ta oe an z ipod tia ae Sara a oA é ib : fon ee oe oe @? fc fe a a SB GB Be e ££ & o 8 ep i S3 moO & . nas pes od yee t,. %, 'hy re Pe a ei 3 8 b fe 8 eo |e & CS A & Bie oo a) Poh ta lm +3 ~ a : £ cy ob % phd gee { ay tired ib GC S 6 & & a ee oo os ee 7 ee % ie; " * ib wre 2 - S$ ¢ GB 2 * « 8 B we, -
Coy yen Heed book CS mn ved i te ace ped ee whet bes a3 ved . ae 5 ce font o bed a3 '<. 4 os es veces es a = Ff es eo 6 8 8 @ ~ Gf 8 is oe hed poten Pics 3 £ é a "a a 3 3 et
- fF es 2 & & 2 8 Sf £2 2 © 2 eS wpe ca ei thet " 8 a a ey te ae a Ue es ; s) ch 6h + Ci a pee \ ood fers ca rae, 'a on og ted is Pe pee Aa ae a ¥ ry Me a an os poe & a ¥ r * rot oy 4 ae es) fo se % re fot & te ise oe tos i ae cr ER mS aa Ae my, ead at frodey a pa a hi oF Oy Sagecd th fee oe eS ou P : oe Faend ae grr, ga x aad to Wt . heal oF . C 4 a om ox, we foot i Co a oS, aa fe . 2s, in bod © eg Cr "ecg " ent ee rt et a3 me :
bat & ie # oe oD Fs as cet on fo ae . ~ a 7 porn, *: ter Z o © § 6&6 8 a ene 3 8g 2 © BoB 6 bey bet hs es ed om ca Soaad pre oa os 31 3 8) prt ed ox a ay co pie io Eo on aod Og is ea) od too8 thy bg ue ae og KS op 4m s nn ne: pol vet ee be Be et po ' oti i nat 4 ' ? oA at ee j i ree or ce neg « a a ky bs eo 6 AG ee me ae 3 fe ws wkd re es ie a a 83 eas x a ad So em ren ae 7 tho oe hes a A ae Co gram G3 7 oe a tA nes Bs tet fc £] it nn es iy os Be oS ae: % a & m & 7 Ed ie wg i hy gt tA st ast i} " sd pe weet ei 2 ses SG & ce mye an o GT OE cs t , md cae o sa ; : ; shoed C pa pias rn pare a es ves "S 4 "e 3 es . Se fa Fok oe mee Eom SB SE «ey Bo 8 & fo eB a omy GB op ® oom F&F Gg 8 a 6&6 | BE © B 8G AS a eee « 5, -- ] ee acl a toed , pod , $ 4 = a ah enh ae "S 5 Og oo 2 Oo ew & a Fy 3 ae a me OM got ree dos i fn ees om ae vi aA fat $2 fae iP) GA ae ede re) a ad os ie ad pd rol eri ed - Cag tod ten a Lf het on Si pel.
£5 Gi Fond , ~ i i se : * cs w &y. 63 hot 0) ee to Bw 7 8, OR cg an fo SCR BS a 8 © 5 OB Lie poren, oth - 4 , > fof = 3 tend oy geet 4 a "th 'we oo o we : oS % aan 2 oan inet me te ox bey en me tht en 2 CG a3 ia ee : ae , : <r Zz Mei ra eS wk o oH gu x a Gs ro aaa ce; ve es | a) fie: . 3 me wr ae psa C3 prong tan Soa (y . os Pe oy yr Boek ee os on ; ted ' peek ha Go ao G3 se 2 a Aes iy we feed fom, aod fa ed eek ead ty ae o 3 , rod . eed on ne = UG B a 2 + Oo 8 af 6 2 2 of eo 8 g ¢ Steed pot shan BS = iS} Bs rood et oa os ae * ay * "' ao Be) as i si 4 ma d © co te Ae! oe mg a oh ee 4 fd ee oS oes ee rh et be oo o} "
a3 fod re os pn oy wy og cod 2, " : es nt ra eA GH io i a "3 a ma B. og re oO 43 ae oo os C3 A kd se ca oot "4 > pe Ar i og eu "3 a2 grt toot iy yy be :
m6 | ae or B F&F © & S g 8 & is f - ' i selon eg "dod > age bas * , &, fia . pews £, ae as . tp io o7 OD tot Le) 7 is vhes . a pod seed fea ee a z es 4 wk 9 iat me ts 5 3 ee y ar 2 2y 3s 4, peed ise ne m a "ey Sha oo sf ke my ies 5 ae Son Fons &3 a ars pat *S, Fes ae tal rg ce ot zt feet spon te oe F xe 4) z ! steak Seed iy gor ren, B 2 @ . 2 & F & eo BB a eo * & & 3 ~~ ref) ea % i] 4f 3 eo fa $ baw be oy o ee ae) eB FB a oS S oR Ff (f 2 8 4. £ £ 8 a v, me wo 8 be OB Go th = 2 & x by i ra re peer " hs ee my ae Be g wh " ae as th a ° Ss 2 2 & & "= 3 BG eB a ee GF ow Oo ma as a3 a} Ca, vi # a a en ps en f z is fd "4 4 ot eo casi oy ow & a Q Q et a "« Db © wef oe aed ves wel "en ay oS wD pd cy "rs a as a oe oS et on of a aia _ ; en ce C3 om oo ro 2 6 ¢ obed oi io oo and ie ded oo Ce ie Soe 4 e age a 4 a3 a as bo chen 3 bet Th, 53 sont Fad m Soha mn joes leone fot iy (3) A ried be ia aheod ragt ered pai a) ie A rt po oy ths GS a £3 a oe bs vet ", ae 7 oo Be = Bs "4 % bes "ent dod Beet cm) oA : i, ea a theed hoot " 2 & ® B 6 gg w 6 & Bs nn te a3 . 4 rs weet 3 wn YY "a oe oo a aaeee "
Soe 6 & 8 , yes prebmnesin, ae pot we 2011. Charge was framed on wh April, 2oi. The Hon'ble supreme Court held in nara ip as under:
* Peis cannot Re disputed that the candidate who infers toa participate in the selection srocesa is always required to furnish correct formation relating to his character and antecedents in the veriiicationfatiestatio; form befere and after Induction inte service, ft is alse 5 equally trus that the person who has supgressed the material infarmation or has made false declaration indee fas no unfettered right of sesking aspointment or continully in service, but et least has a right not to be dealt with arbitrarily and power has to be judiciously exercised by the competent authority in ® reasonakie manner with objectivity having dus regard to the facts of the case on hand. ff goes without saying that the yardstick/standard which has to be applied with regard toa adiudgcing suitability of the incumbent always depends upon the nature of post, nature of duties, affect of suppression aver sullability to be considered by the authority on due diligence of various aspects bat no hard end fast rule of tharnb can be Jafe dows in this rd ne Fee Ee ee ww whee Cay at the seers gay Kae OF application to the facts of the case in hand. | 7 x 4s * oy a Soe £ -pyexony & Rebar Sy ee Ae ty a yds Petes PERLE EY Anolner(supes), fasre was evidence of false criminal . cer cpoe eat ok case of trivial mature which came to x 33 * . th 3 RS SR aS eh. y & hey ce Seer ae Pag aah yes ep tsk a peng § SSP RE SLES PPR CPS Se ee Srey eee Phot cre ERS APPSLeeTt cap a> ATH, BOLL. OforS [ke Chargesheet A oy ea oe / 3 'a4 pon ie) Fs Fo ' a oa Tha pot + wed bh fae ty a3 tet ss a Feed a prt ey 3 o ws ce feet a @ fi : #7 a w ce a te rn ee me & Ered os : = soe # re & i eg hod es Soa * is awe Fata! ri} CS ye SY 3 i ~ 2g ; € & oe ae o3 pont GA a ' aI Lae Nees -
oy i ae i = re a cs os heed Execs | Sia ms : os Q. $3 bea bool fos "D fags i oy "4 a : eS Oe ef fod on 5 a ont ~ s Soh pa hed Sunt Gs Brock thi ' m 4 ed Aes 4 OB a ea oa ye prnee yond f oe, et apeel Hi oe " yg beast >) oa ' [ee] spent o ir eS 2 : ia os Go eA ei in "3 veeek pe) ces my ae f& & ca fot veers a cas he Ps ci oad fod "3 "ie oe ie ca 63 fe Be hed 4 ps os mm iv - A ae cae Se » he ea wi a 5 " Boe oS td a ee zs fs tod a te oe oS heck we wi " eS ae ie 2 5 os eS "et be | oF 5 aa fet Oo 2b eB 2 = © cf eG ® 2 5 2 & Se feck my ES ba is pe ms Di td by CO i, ao a a oe be nn es pe) fa ae oS on a ~ oy ms, mae if fos weet on eet ra as s ro) a ta pe co "i ee aed a es ) eet S Ea mo me oon :
CA is: ae pei Pen "s x om ua yong ot Avs "yet corer iss 4 ¢ ¥ ry, Eatted i Fg sanae! ng Pig Pie oRp Bag fica pon AG wy bed aed ee won is Kon oe si 3 vot ee oS Pat G2 Pees "a $3 ne wy oo 4 i is te . tek, "ot Xn bor * . a to ot a st ae ereeet og £ ra Bo be ot 2 8 ba ol a fF a an: ane mg mt Wee DD 3 6 © JE Sw 'cB Oe B+ es eet a3 meee inheed net 7 i 4 chev ae Es nt od a Hy LS ; oe es eo te fa fy boa 4 2 C3 ea ee & - mo gy P gp oo "C3 aoe) ao i £5 ad bef es: ee a Hed oh hoy hy * c iA poet kA pee pan poeed ; a a & « rs a Q LY, reed v3 ren feel . boot ; mi roe a fy a ae OG Oo 5 & 6G & ce peed yt ' : p re as 5 4 pect cot pe - 4 tes m4 aid " ui a ee ew ae 3] det , Z open *% heed vd fen ie es aged reegs ie fe ~ ey bt rr 3 os gt ™ $3 x4 tA a oe ers es ; gt ptned hy ae aa ct oy ra oe 5a gn ea Cand So of [a 4 t3 e a ined foeh bs rent ne, % Zz oe a :
c "ao & 5 ¢ nn? ne: my oe % faa -- foot 4 a ded
"5 det oh rs f a L, red tity Bees oo 5 ge 0) Go fy be a a "ee Ye iS oy Pi aS we | ag poet ea a3 e oa rtd ea "
3 °S toe care) Cy ess * A a £5 "4 oO .
en Gem tat rd ee. ; wy hes g ty . C es " red a 4K F jms '4 OP Pa, o ee ett wey x4 cL ¢ i Z ' gH : as Coed cH wt al 2 oy age pd be By oe ee) oo 4 | faa i rind & oo oy a ey ee; ot we oe 4 = mS fe be fort , mo pa ee Ca re as nea Ai we at ° ze ve ; rd ; ty a oS ah oo ° 4 Oe i, ge © ee oS & RB Ss 5 a ae 2 st oS '3 wy Ss G a Sw . & # ae i. ' ro ma 4 Se a ae ' se vo x A 8 3 " 8 SG B @ a & es an aN 4 beg Gh got 3 Shel % Sed "
fi oles Be Hy a co ies ood co phe ps Fe oe oS Cod CA ry bork ps a ' ss we me tos ea hp ft QO ae fs e ae , ae < boi" 3 4 ann as roel Bm oh "es oe nn ae ; ; a os " a a g a a ; £ 8 a pe Gs Ee "cs be sn ies ao eo bed 'haat WA oan: pene Psd ' er fed Es 8) xt pont po us fan 'at eyed if wont 3 4 fan oe * yer i) a, <> vs on a .
mg ee & & 4 SF & a ¢3 re4 fo a es ha aa Fd es me ea ooh yd : ot 2 bed wyed feed fast yd cd pnd fo a 06 ioe, * rd tet, an thes me G4 xe ; te > £3 4 a fe "4 mB uy zi 2 -
ie a het SA by a xed 3 » Bred - th "Se de ; mn ia geen é ne ah "i at ad at tent foes % eo . om rm ns, ; es " a cs ne a ay ny om : >. al 2 - 8 @ 3s & 2 & 2 a fn ng Fes" of : : oS ci 3 if fit. is genet * ad 2 bet mi a9) pal ms ey aS om sets ined on Cs of ptt ewe ; ra Gs 2 a oe . € "oh rood ay 2 2 #8 ¢£ Da we ee s rs wet £3 on bee et Fei ps ey rh ea pee ieok is t fr 4% foo ed phon Pond eS fo + gen, G3 oA spre hood mo ce ey e he pre é a pot weg 3 3 ost a ces a 8 : Ss A PF Bs es 4 apa : G2 j oak . ae of , aes Os am aS a 6 & § Bo ra ® ; ! Host 3 ; int ny : ; bon a2 cm 3 wi es seeeb fa po ee Ri 7 as red ' geet pio reek ct ct my wy ot Fant Shah ae £3 pees, ce Pee' ere, a ning ay fa Fae ae : ape ? rs a3 Zs) [o y me a eo og 6B eg poe a 2 B48 2 8 Be se 4 is a coos, an » ered rez ng pie gr ; tt got ca we ya: fe) aa os os) us Uy fay = a :
wre £ : aA real a fo head +94 thy oo nga ~ eer "wt of ree a5 £5 x we ts 3 wa hoof me es oy ° "Ey oes 1S i roa vk e tod % nn ae et 2 @& a § 8 .
my wel an fe fel be OB in ae fot "eet pottete tae, AiO foe fie y ' Po $rpert o me * a Fy ees ried, wis) Y iG OR i eed 4 ms Ym a gk as SR tae a oe on ees at a an ee a rn ae i fe we os ba geSeEe EY 2 ae m 8 st Oe ge be me ee as fo & & w BA gg gag kis" i & Bs Omg : W% a Oh ae abe head ' eee ara LP 'be. eS pe Le * ba ii ans Cae . ret EG tae + Fs Se FE wy FEEL BET ui ® Se mn BEBE BS wt tent % i ed a oF te foe mY > i Oe Oo bs bed. soe : BE eee got when ee A ase i Oe é i, Gp BE tee BP yes ee ew ERBEERE S * OER Bs Boa oe Ge ee be o B 8 Peo ec kw yw & "2 & re om wg gy Bebe, AE ae oe 8 pe ; wom gem oh m & ge ES
a) ced bp am" Bue Ee" Be oe GUS EE wy. oe» ry ea a4 e B 4 2S 'Be tl ie % . BB "iy ee ey : a we ee a ies hoe ae KE te ae ; oA gy So BG ae oe 3 wy & 24 oh Jeo Stn ye ~ fot oA OO ag pe Ou SS rs "oS wd ib ke i EB a "3 Sue 2, ml ESS SE 2 gy = a a or ef a S"ssh8ee5 8488225 ch ee PRB EGE E eas Seat " 4 Bo S53 a D % & wm HR me 2 ; Age % i ee on fe Om 4 Bom 45 es a wm Oe ao" 3 & Sa ORE el ea ino wy MD og van SD ed We ey 73 ie % ° Sy Bf 7% A te op aa Bos i oa wa Go & Se hE PBE EEF > Bs a ie te bis 2 (oS as Fe A Gop eS 8 he et Q nein a's ee Bs & > oy 2 6 fo 'of 3 wg i ee OF ck fa os rs EBS of EB gw ew BS " of es be, " =" 9B SS4¢eG2 we oe & % ee mS mE aes Se EEK EB sf @ faa Res pod a) vO os Se | 8% BT em 3 2 as A Bs me See SPA GR Ee g BY ws %, ae i 2 mh FES BG EF G 2G 8 5 Oe "gy ee ote oe ee ee oa CA bat Spe 6 mE Ss ar a ae 7 2 me 6 a ne ay Bt 2g % mos Ym ey Go ae ri z A fe cx 4 be 8 fe ° 'ha Suma eg eeeegs . g BES yO Oo x me % mB PE eo ag ee. BF aod sped che C2 'oa ; 5 yaks ae commune' Son ot "a bos a ip ES wg Bs hh % te 5 ne oo mi * th 2 tee, ey, "wor Bo & yr ? oy 4 a ie eo Bs. & a | ~ fen oe yor sso Sic Go AS & aie ee ft oe yo bas BS sme @ gy pes ee pea c cares et ge banat bs foe ; us , pg 2 eels oe or 8 es pity, "pe . a ced e wm i he g3 oo 2 B 8 tnd ee SSS Reb ORS ses "on fret ee a 8 OF 2 > ° Ps pest rit ae ae yea a ca as nt os ae ay Pas ed tot peewee, rein tecae eee my al ES: om ae Ran aliaged and the result of the trial is net suSicieny. in the said shuation, the employer cannot be compelad ta Sive sopohiivient to the ceaadidate,"
a4. As held in the case of Pawan Kummer Vs. Urion of India and Another (swpra) standards whick have to be applied with regard to adjudging suitability of the mmrdiysenk' alwawe Aewoes GaAs #4 Eh 3 moumipent always depends upon the nature of the Bast, nature of duty, effect of suppression over suitability has to be considered by the authorities on due diligence of vatious aspects. Considering the nature of allegations it cannot be said that the applicant is a suitable person for discharging the duties of the Postman.
25. As indicated earlier the entire text of the judgment tthe Hon'ble Bombay High Court is not preduced, so carmot be gauged ag to whell cher the proceedings were quashed on technical grounds or on merits of the matter.
eek cooper tr =a SP SQ oyery hy eyed. None OS 5 Pras Therefore, smaply beeause chargesheet under Section 128 a siatean Deacenaa aw FF ae ETS . OMe tex of the Maharashtra Prevention of Gambling Act, 1889 is ax 5 po 4 Heck teodk Sie aa a TR cy Bg oot oi sn = ca ne 4 bes fet spe B DB i ons so; A uA ee ° a re thd. wd ree ' (3 it L . ae Pa) BO ra aa ot a a be bess teed + " al oe bea ie as Fitiad ge od, em oi e mo ay a it snk : oh ok po toe c os nf si pea aD : revel nt red ae "et ve cad oa 5 a hod Ee bei pon oe) bolt pepe Lb eed "3 fl oo Ye on sect foot, 43 Lok -- or L Sat ' hy os : on rere is ane be ar Ene es "
. e GA ih aa etens feed o gs nett oy ¥ £ 2 ig te pod ct syed ee a Ch pom Ks oy OS es a zi oA Ee : _ oA ms oy ret te te va, shoo bot a a £3 tags yon aN ae geeend 4 aha weed ree im fate Oo a bens) ee ae Un
a) foot "" : el ay sl fi ret ; . a oe > ek, psd 7 A therd tt £o4, Ean D a 4 waend peat Sheet ape pee aA " fron! an ~ oy ed wh pa eae a] pa fet os pot food 3 ie, fi Fen E f Seep whet wy ro « ba et is eet io Drea gen fay oved wared cod ta, # eet ws - rj 4 Cs ae e a oS god phd of ded a a a fv aa 2) ci + pe "neh a "Kt ; v4 td m4 = gh Pad . y 3 fe Met et be x ns oe ce as os 4 og "A ' 9) ies 13 fa fond iy Soe tye aS yon ¢ 4 ' shond is tent "g4 ; bred isd 'a G a) " a 4 f oe sent ee head TRA tah S ford road ou wont we ; cA a ee aie ae ibe bet ae a tees "dee a a] teed bod bs od 3 6h o i; & S&S G S| 8B a a a ors 5. "ats pone trdh poe ie aes ye aes oO Aprih ae xs pus cad ! a pees ¥ Bee § oe we oe) S £ st : Po pee fh * hs ben, ci a wn ; fot sd a of 4 Ba a oi ne hed an fia ss) get * pert Cy Gi ox wy bee. ee) oon oA a 4s AG ct ae ni me oy Pr, psa ot oh "po 5 i Let #3 & pan ea ped bak ee Bs "é "s ot prs, Soh Ben petord fy a 4X5 g no S : bed Lae oe Pot vn C3 yon, a % ; 4 be whent ee poy a is ca Pa nn o bg é iy % beg ont ad ue art | ied Cl bet bag repeal f ral , Snot a6 et Lord a vey ae wor, 2 DP 6 Rk oe Bo o> teat fo at % cy a te ga ~ py, oheod co ioe co a4 nek Poo ' see v4, rt 58 "ted a fo) A me 4 fs on a m3 ey hoot rs ison 'fond od 4 pa os roel ved Ch ire mn ne nr ' w . fed Bo ee By ag oo Wry fa 'hood a3 nth a ag orm Gy bs) no tank green te . oe, ot Sot } pi 23 ts geteed week my np bet heel ¢ oo rs g ree é3 . QO 'nbeed es ost rbot 4 "Cy ' Co a ee) a ct mM ts ra o on rs ae b. et ens ron bea io} Sabowy ae "Ch Ngan on a an eed " Wy & 6 6 6 9 & Be GC F -- & A he 2 Te ws. oh. Leet raed. eyes ced "
Pogart - * ; pwnd eet of 4 E3 ren aod ee oo 1 as opoot tect is aa G2 64 3 oy 5 om o oe Me a GD ¢ pas ri oS ft nc, P7 <1 Ci ag ee cs ph rit 3 bed ,; al O et fet 3 Son eal oy yea me fet 'seh gS bieses z Rapoet hols wt a fre mo mt me cS oS bor ob been, 3 ¢ vA aa ve a pind Eo nn oe) rhe me Ue bea nn nt "i faba B ee ° od api a tied ty pos en te vA ae:
hs pat ee boa ' ret ni ae eed Seda OS bat "A wy i a ee oe ans > a k oe a4 he Sd 1 3 as a by ot a 3 Oi bey 83 wh Gs ae ve ie 5 Si aS oe mks Go 6 aS co 2 a ee * 2 8 &€ £& 8 2 FB x
--
acts be ? Op ERG ae Se ea Gf} a) sed 7 ae ye ica oo £3 fas 5 oh om rs oe) ie Ee tee a C3 ca Frag a ES ss 4 , ---- --
BS gs & & Ag eS 2362 @ rn ae a ES ; ' q ee qi OO" LEG t fe i su x iS post bod a ° B ad be 4 GEG ee) a % &) ai oe 3 oo OM Bm ag a Bm pet rad ai ee ED pn, ee ya, eg Py gy Be OZ gy F B a peek pe 4 ome en ay ge en oe "rd tad eae aa a ay me i. TR ome et : oe me 2 wD Os 5 ga hy, bo pn yes ra wn Ay oa sre tea gry ee * Sins % cee i, eA Es, ey, "2 On : fr, ' Sy hed @ th Hh ye par ped ae lok gee me GB RS Sete ci a Bs bed pot, yw ben ay og ae las co tort 4 Fok a Le Be Bd vege, yy fe Og :) ted cs Bp ye age EP OE ne 6 g ay 3F ae Yrar fan and Orber =~.
WS S agoohited on of a Max Cova %
3) Nora pea x fe ed A fs vine HE cn ee *. ¥ Sens: Ore on ong & 8 2& &@ fo OB we Gm be ge & rs i foo fy St il BE Stowe le & oe 3 ff z ~ i OR SE a Prof Ze pam 1% Te ra We yey aS, yO bore eo om GEE 'ee oan ee oe. BA gen 62 8 ¢ be he ri sored a bon i) fn te Mh os us & % ms oi} oe 3 ven 3 to TE see GRE ed len Gy © ee ce aa Bag ae aes ee a2 4 @ be het at ¥ ee 4 & ", Meh! "ei oe ea "¢8 3 wh me nee we Ce gy Te Od gi ae IG Sed : Fs veg GB we oe A 8 ee GY AOS a an Gd eS RS os Bg es i, 43 Ky es ee we fd me ee oe fod tee £5 * Fhe oy te oo w inj om Bm & i Be Ee um pm ig "Fi 6) % x bo Sn ls BO Oe. ee EG co ee pot Ks Ue wm is4 a oe 3 Rasa Penm oe feo gett oon bt Se 2 2 ee SF ge fos os "hed Ny, fm wpe UR Tey Bore gm oe Od BE ng Ue bot $3 we cal ae bis 2 3. £3 Fa) apy ven ge a yn th 43 badnod, B If) bon rs I eS gg oe OR OG os rs "te vet es ; pao soma Sie oe be 32 ty BB oe BE te tt apm, BS 6 28 Ahee be Bs ee & ee © ' ie fe be Se ge ee By Ga a Eke Bee ty Yn Be bade! fa! . eA a oe we eg rey oe a "he y C253 gs awe i G HOS ee me 5 y" rd ha wen "
tod yet heat recent 8 (<a) Eebeoh Cy qh wh a is heed oO, i 43 SS be 4% 3 Se in BERPEEAECZGEE*A RZ EE SB BOY DB wh te om ou 5 ow & we Re 6G AG pe wo SE eRe EOP PREZ AA MB Be & _ eM S ee Oe Ee, BP Bee BE ° jo ge ea, Sew, es a as oy ke ie Te te a RE eg fins ea gs EY ba Bn, tee :
ts it, a ve MS rome mB Oe to oe fs BO Be ge ee oe Qn Ge, 8 EB Em am | a es ee ce i Be = &e ee ae? & y Zz Sy M? th ne per x Qs sed ca) bea a 3 Ares ay ica aaa BB » ee Ps wel ios PF. Bee ® Eg om & Bey Ba BEB % SR, SubG eek Ew % mm Oa ees ty Ae a ew oe mm BBB ay Sm BERS BD ge Sg ge ee a th SO a oh. te wt g° ORE Em EB Ee ge "Geena gent fF ohew 228 7 ee io See OR ee @ Ewe Be . we BoM ee he ae OB em om 4 ee GO we fy Tee gee owe "Ue EA ms 4 hd gy, TD re Wh, Ce KE 257 @ a WY "_ GEG E BF ot Be Gg Pgs B @ 4, Be wm & et te en 5 a4 , ge 43 ee. . ? la oe q ? pt e Se. Lys "Aart ce BEESE EE & # wm 8 43 2 © gy BF ey me ee i GF, Bom fom ee ke ge fe ke a j fet BS Ee gee UE Be Bw BO RFGAEEB HM Bee SB ame 8 Ee ed B&O owe BE ew wa TH Sg BR 177 baa a a e# hie ee EO ee wm ge ee Sescy b Beeso"seaguag & SE Sh EGY ook Be A ge eR Re wa OMS de 3 C4 o> 9m TE "ee yg BOE BP Se GK gm Be Uwe oe BP Se" a oa a ee ae nt a & & a pe ee Sh ge ap 0h ne oR ms ee ge Eg o> ft te"
ra he DI ge ad TF ge vem see apt f ee Dh Bt ee @ & DO ie hos bes yy Tow te PE, Bt "gp oe ES ye ag Go Se ge Oy OB te tee gy BE ot ye ey be, Oe Ay ay 8 te y a a wn ae ees BE OnABBEBEE . BE "ee BG oS UY + gy HA Se -B 9 22% BPe,geeeees eg eee ext eee "a SE gee mm Bae & me ye Oe 8G ee ee Met SD Sy wo Fic SN ote ce an ree oy ae Gr a fo S. by my ge os are wy A re Se Se ee ip Re Dw, op WE wo o hm Bo A ee BOO eB o a Be sg 2 pie Ss Bw | we &EDER EE" 2a Ge WA EE Bm cd Oe Baa SRR TD SB, oe GD a ee Oy 4 ae Bim "p> ty OR fey 40, dead , ne cs ane Samer ad eT esos ny OS we eK ad th. & vpy "im TN yn ie ; wi, Th. Oo OE $5 Oy pe ee Ee a tee OG Baw oe a Gyre BGE wb. 2 Es Se oclmae SS Oe Oey $A ae en ea pee ee + 3 23 "i when fea feed y OM & 2G Be os ty fh oe 4, Be Bg iG % of He SB wa ta wy Weg a SO o em FS a a ft 4 Bg or a gs 3B prin TE ae CREE» GE w by 6 EAS Oe Bie a D sin oe we Gu Be pe i Me oe a BB Be Ba a Eee" ga TE gs fe OOo 6 Bw 8 &m @ 2G oo fa ge ae YS BE Re © gs Ae io ha SE EER Go BH fas i a Bf Se phn, hk Co oh, as it oO Sey po a 2 & 2 ge, Thee Cy , ob geet ey tae ame Gy tig AE ger Ch wd te bn 8. ae RE OG, Oe a oe oe teed "OF Sugg, See fe te he Boe & St OS ote oe es ae - ta Be ge ES ie oe ed PO BP ow »@ BBS wy Bw Se EBM yw BOG : ee ee 2 ER & GS we fo ee ey Ff eel i Gp pe St Be: ae By ae By, OO rea Se bebn Seen HER pe Boe. toe -4 Fad oe : yo Jos Yong ; ' San a Sane ae OEE 2, BREE BRED eg Boe Rm aw SER PRES SBE Ee 2 2 tho hie 8 EB G mB oe a, Bg be ee GE & Pe ah eed sree WEB. cms SE EL, BPE BE, ster, Pet cial af Ax, Ss NS <a aes aa Ar a niga A % RSS
- oA , 3. a3 ood -
sae ie tae ring j repos . rs ie eee: ere a3, "4% 4 @ 8 & 4a EG GA ot pen deed. of eees rs at bho wen pate ae "ort 7 KS goher OS ay # ripen, pea oe ahmed C3 - Sgerd . ber 3 * A fr eat tt2 Bt oh F fa od ork cag wee EG De a toe ms oe os it en mo oe as es ee i yrs ca oy $id: e spees ia peeon C oat . ie an ~ we oat vee geet ave pes) pena A ye oa _ ey 2 feo 2 ot oe prs ane i cs 7 isa' £5 ww 4 7 £ os, eee * San cea Roe G3 ot . JG ae eae & yenecd landed im bts ot poe yan ca ms oh a 8 OB ao" Ge ed 1 pont, ret ° hy bet A a ft ed Be a3 A geek os on Ay wun ws WM oF @ : bs chet GS peed "S oa al Noe Oo sehen 4 Bs Nee q * io ard tang . 55 2286 88 & fe "2 os , 5 & F 2 CX fae yy te Bh te 4 i bg "a g we . an es td pee B22 888 BEB, % ~ 2 ¢ 3s yo § eo Ps oy we gy te Sy Hs ES wm, SA pe ee, a3 4 , cord ke i at Be bee , op ty B ty ed ae pepari went ; u ed wed o4 tired wD a oe BB ew w me ed et oe og : oo oS 4 Be ie ae Bom ew oS es 6 Gf ao oe Ys oe oy boo fe Be ; rt : € eS i ba . x * P Ton g 4 2» & i oe a x a a "nd Wa & be 's 3 ee a ai "4 ie OB we a epee ae 7 os - a> 3 SS 8G g EB OB. 'od a SS fo es cal iss i se © eo z tome Yh hee. 'Soe it, . aes z a agree peteed: haage] 4 te. 7 te ge aS be TD be ge 43 GG ba okt ps iy took ~ ed Se Sn, wor fog he a ae: iB a, ) zed oe 53 o cy Be oy po fe $e 7 ene Tn a4 Ant Oy ; ae pa % O83 wn nea La %. bor $5 4? ate ve hyn 3g t oA peel $ ¢ 6 wed BRE be Et ee 8 < Cm 3 8 gg & a a vb an a $ s, Ese a , -" ' sa 3 vi re:
an ans seead , ie ~% ee ae ; wees . 'am ved saa wm ben a oa, BZ 5 % » bed ct re '<, 0 ae a efin a 13 fet :
ye Ca oh 'oe a a i eB iad se Aa ret wy ty "4 oe me £3 dad me a a3 ar SE gm ok we ie WA a i a A 3 oot eS rho ' rh Bmaasd BUS» B wget ~ B a ce Spa ayy ye an de Rog " tt : ' bee iA ro . ee we oo, ' apes rn: 2 w o sd ra ws ie ' fo a £5 : "Sh 4 yo ; os the f 7 Pa OF; 0 ¥ e oa yoeed oS ee gt Bo an te B 3 ob e 5 ae Cont on +4 reed ms ne Bee gs we erie 3 be ee a fed rahe '! ge 4 5 z a oe 5 te 3 of Prana tat geet, ' a nee Box me a BBE a" e oy oe 4 a " re . Bs) Pr food os ie GT i ae oe nM SS G4 plone , F i 54 oe ee fh ee gee ez) Se ed £ a ond g ' ne oo i weed + 6 2 a * ob & Be Oh vg ng 5. - a 08) 4g x & ee moe a be i oica et gg op " ; < a Fr ert im es fan _, a3 re a5 et nee gee : oped o, al i iret & poe oO ge ae Yn fae net: ¢ 4 nnd, a a pa iy a8 ne ogy AE re $8 be oo ri 4 fined fern CA ed pert "Be . % ae te camer ay x gs S e £ BB a pon mm tm pe . hora 6a ye thy Ba ;
fi on ae ie fre nb os ay ae ih} aoa ae " ee oy 4 SE GE om ey eB m5 te Sees a rt 2% st ve 4 a ae 4 oo £5 GB ad a oa is es wi ie hee ta Tra aes ee SE ree 0) i) me 1 a a 4 : Ze "ee od . ° oy ae dood re Se , # Fa "Lhe mm, in by sod : a) ood inet " oo prt eo a ° ey 63 an ae a os a be oe ce Cy [; A a rsa ays [a my poy + neal 's Ge & A Bae » & # a Y "oe a ne £ ae t 3 ; ' ¢ oe uy 7 S Mf ; eS ge a 6 Bow ay te io oO ; a be Ch at ts ie m8 BES BEEPS y ot OR = gd @ go 2 6 oh 4 ye ae ed ba ip, yo at tee 2S 7% eed. nid can rn es bo ba be : os _ wy ; :
" 6 8 oe ee ge Es "tes " a a oe i F Pa UE OE tb gS ' ms i i eG an a fe mp En te % 7 , % pod a oe oy ke tee "on nes [om yee: body a :
oe ik Be ee bee BY See wes * i: 6 in eS be hp Xm, OF be Sp ot ™ beige pein Piséa 4 *, yr gy OS we 3 ge Be gh Sh, She (os ge SES TESCO oe A a Lon weed Pa Ww & S The ay robat <3 G ay = Me corel ey 3 (Justicé MG. Sewltk ay} RS es Peember 73 es wir we } re (Dr. Bhagwan 8a! Wember CA} iN a * fac/