Sri Kumar @ Prasanna Kumar vs The State By C C B Police on 10 December, 2008

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Sri Kumar @ Prasanna Kumar vs The State By C C B Police on 10 December, 2008

Bench: Jawad Rahim

IE4 1%" T???" *r1'EGi'*i CCvi}R"'i" (3? i'<ARﬁ?sTAi={A 9'??? BA?€f:?sLC;?---E M723 "nus ma :0?" EBAY or DECEMSER; .?.*3§s:-

7éEF{}RE fxio. 323 G? 2363 EE'§"\@"€'EE}'§:

4

.3, . }§m §"\.i 4 m _ S ERI 'riU?v'3;'-'xii :"';Rzi%$s?«?~&%':i;€i"i+€%.j?v€ﬁéf%_.

Sit? Mi.}£3DA?PA _ ;

was $866? 33 ':*Ez'>=;R£a' R;'i5."'%" a§~;"*;.5:?*, 3Rmvs.ai?-5%, V a EEW "rt-:,.a,%sL::=*£:T, B§;.N~3AL."}RE' * 'f:;'<:z '.'_::'- F.§*i1i'2§%%¢§:*sE;¢x"'§=vi}5t'~.$;'€I:[N 3A':'ARA;'vis'% RAG . ,..,r:n..s-'€ 34- vggage ';?=:{:.*3%* ?\§E:§H""'?'£";EV':?'=.E,E €.*0:~smt3§=4§ .9-§ caegg, 'i_V§A~G£i.§Z R.QA,fl3 3%. as 1"' A _-an r'-' ' ' rag %..::xLa:r;_:

mi .17» in 6 "E 3} 4.7:' 3'7'! *7} 3 5:: s?:;=<e:;a:ssm%{ :4 ma: 52-1'; 5% :3 mam :'G'!E;QV' ;@EéQU? asvgms .3-:;;«r'v:*»'%éT':'=aE:i3;~.Z?*:': 11, G;?s?xiESHA a:..a»:::<.:

. :=:P&;:::§¢E,:~4ALLEswAR.AM §;'%%£2iLC:aE L SEE Rﬁ\3E3i-'§ 51?} SEE Cﬁﬁﬁfi "-~,§1QEEZ? ﬁa..il"5Qi.§"¥"' ZEYEARS

-A " §;'3'%"':"%*i£i . 32, ﬁiS'§'%%ﬁ:GR.ﬁs?v§§x Lf§'?"G {ET K_1%§*'§;3.§{SHIPALYA msssaasae &.{L/ M8,. 3US'?'IfE"3.f\?é2;;¢;§_; A ﬁx"! $RE §Hz3z?%iAF;3eTH'f iii SHAH Sit} 55 F2 $Hi3.H AGES ABCJLET 55 '{Eﬁt.R.S R,r',=5'£"§" ?*§§.".Iv.32, SEr"{PE?'éTI?é$ R0538 §<Zi..}MARA PARK WEST &"-'KMSALORE M3 Ak £5"? s'*iR.?,F*T.SIﬁDﬁ\?v$§aLL§xP;7;'-E, " j ¥"i'{LARL.I73-.ZAH ASS¢L5CI,ﬁ'~,TES, A$\!E'i.} ANS:

3. WE S"i":'>a'f'E BY :3 C. 3 P€::i..E{'fE'v--.

§".'%".:'~'--»"E":" V 5 . » V ' "i'5'1¥"Gﬁ\LGRE ' " I _ V , RES?GN€:E?ﬁ' {EY ER: $i3S3'RAMA§i'fA.'v*Bﬁﬁ;T,;.%i'C<'3?) '%'§+»:zs i=E'?"Vﬁ"i':'?z__:%i' iS'F E'i;E'§' ws.3§?{:) cam: 52* 'E'?-EE ﬁ:E:'sz'{':""'§'. 'F:QR"~.Ti-'%E' ,.§ETi'§€{Gfé§R ?RA':'E?~éG ';':~2m' 'ms F' E §~;c::'§%3~:V.§ £ﬁ'LiR"¥'V.:'*'iﬁa'é"'- Es' FLEﬁ§$;§'£:': TC': 3%? ziiSIsTrE "ms ~.%z%a::>%%:;$*%:a%r; 3z;**:3%:5z--»:'r Aﬁﬁ Cx'ﬁ?fv"E:C"?IQ§\é SRQER ft-3 »?"'fE','»3,1.$.i3r?*«51'9.§if'*5$E§ Y THE fﬁii A984... '$5.3; :'*3:5e.'t'§i"ié'xi.§_ 3 "§§zf%:§G:'i%i;f:'§.§ mas cam :*»:Q.15c;:::3;'a*; Q Arm FzE.S§ 3a;':2g3:»éa"§*sf;?a§4a £G?é%;'£C¥EG?~£ $3953 m'.24.3.a3 Fﬁzfrfé «%:vi:%a':£--z, ?~'aA':'Gf~§ALL :,s;x::';', sAmAmr-:5 an .f.,C.§.l;-§§;Z5€1§-éfﬁi Aﬁﬁ T?-iEK*.-.?§'€ Maui? Ti-Eﬁ .$ gmﬁmesas Fﬁﬁfvé mg amsxscs ;=;':.s;*$. '22 ma as as' xémaamm mazca Am' 2:4 c.:.:~m.2sa§?;a2, E"i'C., "WES ?E'¥'E'F'ii.'2'2%"i ES CQFEING €72?' FQR A§s'*?ES$E27*?~é Yiwéiﬁ §P€'z' TEES CQUR3" ?v"2i-'xE.'3E THE F633 a".3V$'E§"~i*S:-

W Na CvR§ER Tﬁe wmiicteé actuseﬁ are ii': ¥'E'\§i3iﬁ'£": ur:ﬁerj.S:a;%E.r;~:":

5"':

3?? €'r'.?.

aﬁairxsi the iuﬁament in ﬁée.£52::€33;"2i.";§3 passed era :1.§.m3? _f;::;*z--fi'}:f*:%r:é'¥'e§«« t§":é jilﬁﬁméﬁi 'pasﬁeﬁ 'ms ﬁre js3risV=:jicii_-ezsiéié --E$i:a'QV§;i;i'§*'E2Vi'é:__ :'£."e.2ae§?;'2£;:3::. dated 2~4.3_\.2ﬁi?:3<~._€en «agemi fa': the cffenceg punishaiéée urssiar '£é~;-'7.:ci".%.§z':$ ':.=""'3*._a§ ';':'§ Si': sf the :2; T' rr":éé:.'i::2:-24*'*§$"-Ei$iaéi""f:;3z' aa'm§sS§§ﬁ,. %-ie'§':::* 'me Eéaffééﬁ :'3é"ea*r':2r1':e.§:t'-?§e£2'£:iez' 3?"? F333 ﬁifﬁf iimarzrya aha': #9..

'"«.._A%2a3L__i;:*a%<:_s:=;;r: :f_mt§:é"f:::--:%----«iE3e State, 3* iﬁﬁééﬁi, the matter is ' 32:3 3<;%-3: _ ua»_*fe.vr"%fiT§:a§ §§S§G§§§, "V3, ' maieriai aciusaiécﬁ er': the éasés éf whiﬁft ',i§":e ";:é%§:§§m3z'3 Wéfé arraiﬁééeé, iriaﬁ arxd aitirnaiaiv {fV»:§%"si;.i:te€i, as ﬁéfﬁﬁ f§"'QT¥'n the reéerﬁg, ravaai that an .' §}g%.2§§:;, the Assistant §§§""£'E?T:§$$§Q"I"3&?' cf ﬁaéiie, Cis, aaﬁﬁéiéfﬁ, aiimg cm iﬁfﬂfméfiﬁﬁ réceivéé that £?E"&?'if'E§SéS it $30.33,, $wi$s Campiexg 63%' fioozi, Race Coursa mad, ﬁaﬁaaéere is beérzg izfséﬁ far qambiirag, féiﬁéﬁ it anti' fi';"i:«1:.;A':*'s:§ tﬁereiﬁ apfgiiaﬁées iii-ie twe Teievisiénﬁ, ceéi ;;:?:énva:§§,'v7LI§a§ié'«T«* récérﬁers aﬁﬁ cash cf R§.?,S6€'a:'~;~..._Hé: a'E"$"e{--'If'E1;r%: €;';. V' naiaﬁoéée arm' re§§st'r$. The ﬁéffzéz 'fvéiéée Zssvéﬁaﬁ 6'.' areserme sf Eiéﬁﬁﬁéﬁ cm s':.:st};::§:_f;~?:r1_ tbs?' thziﬁé ari'2.jcies>§.iere * ' 533%': éf the gambi§';=:§._, Sei:e2;r'é=wa$; i*«é;:i'::-'rfteéfat High Srcuﬁés ?a§ice Staiicm i.'§r:- fiﬁﬁ.ﬁva§'i's{f;:f:téie ream': $2' the Assistaﬁt C<::srz"":'r":f"_:fi§3_i<::":e*-:':'*"' {if §f2i_%'ce.t';«.VfCCB«;: VC.W.2 -33% rstiﬁ féﬁiﬁiéféé 5. :I;3a.s}1:é:" ..}_ag*_:ii~..._ gafiér V .im:e§iE§aiEen, fiiesc

4.. 'The j§ﬁ*5;;£.Sé3e€i__ "£3.;F?: fé ms: iﬁ iris? 5§éf":'e frze j§r%s§'§ciiana'%" Ej«v**:ag.i:'=;*:;"z*af'v%,é""a':'z§ $2': the bias czf {sat ﬁuiiiy, *-Lérigi §'§$S"""%.i!ée'£": Cﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁiéii i}i.2¥"'§§"I§ ﬁréaé, ihé _p§?;:Té1er:é;:E.z:.§:2ééégégiiéneé twa wéizaeﬁges éﬁﬁ aiaaféé reiiarzte Héefariievﬁ .5: %}& f.;§'E§¥'§éS, Cﬂfaﬁiﬁéfiﬁﬁ the evié'm:é an feﬁﬁfé $21' £2536 é¢'i:§--::%ér2is 3:15 21 "rrraieriaé cbjecis. The acéaseﬁ 'u "'--é§'=V'=.e;_ éégfrﬁeé tiriai Léssége fﬁﬁﬁﬁ E: was saxfficéeﬁi if.) éﬁiéﬁiiﬁh :_§i%a%r'§a aaairmi the acfizgsaa? f" 3' the eﬁerzﬁeg uf:-*:de:* Secféeas 'fﬁ aim' 8% :3?' ﬁze §§iEz:e ﬁacf. araé Cﬁﬁﬁéﬁiiéﬁifyf, €ﬁ7:""i'1§§C"'i@§ 5% _ ' .!I'£" ' 5.7;.-4 , EN»! 29%. 'r«:"é§%i'z§ Cﬁmfﬁﬁﬁ gaming heme, &ic.~' _ ?gny Eéfﬁéﬁ wim-

Ea} ﬂ""'\ 1:31' '0-us' Wm."

-...m Giﬁéﬁﬁ, keegjs 0%: uses any ':':u§iﬁi2';_ef';"'-:f.§:m%jj'; %a§~':i,j eﬁcissuré, vehitie, vﬁsﬁééé-,«'§r'_4 ai_.ai:¢v]_f5r-jihé- ﬁﬁffiﬁﬁé sf 3 éémmaﬁ ci;:arni'_§i§4§1c$u;s1é:_:"

bemﬁ the éwﬁef -gr ::'c~:§J'*;:ier ;:3'? j §:fI_V é.}"uf€:?*s 'msiiﬁirzg, mam, ten'E,:&-n:§0su;=e,'vééiiﬁfa, Vﬁﬁﬁé mu».-

3?" aiaée §<:r":miir:§;:V%'s*' 'wi_iif;:§%"i,¥"aaréﬁits the game ta '£33 "c:§é2%1é*3', ?w;.;:vg:r:i::iVivajii; --..i<_;a§t Q?' users? ':33:

any eiher ;,::e,:=3é_r:..f:;sé"f tEf3e";ii%.;r*;:%::év$::~*' afsresaiaf; ir":a3"'§¥f:}=2 éareg "«;r"r:i'a'~rifia§&_;ir"ze?z'2t sf, G?" any '§'r:é§5rz_vﬁe%-:'fV'ai::§s&£t{is1 3:': ;i§'f:V§'ucii§2§ the i3E§Si§'1&$$ Q5. "aria":a§3:%*:=,§L§_i§€3E_?I§; mam, tent, erzciasure, "" VE?";§ﬁv3VVi"ﬁ,.,. ¥?E§§é3,' er fﬁiﬁﬁé éﬁéfééﬁ, stcupéeé, :vi§f";:,i.,a':"r*aEi':§ wétﬁ sin §<fe;.-"si__ §f" i.iSé'-3 fer iira éijféizsé afizrésaiﬁj :3? A. ftiffiiﬁfﬁéﬁ mane? far the §.'2E§§"E§S& é\s3;"z:";?e$'§r S 3;l1E¥'"§i§E'iS fréaaeniiﬁa am: $137551 «""_~v_..§a;:~§;§':;i§z's:§, mam, teat, enaiasure, vefsicia, Véﬁﬁéi, ' ﬁr isiase, Si?":3§§, érﬁ C§Iﬁ'sz7i§:i§§1¥'L ﬁg izmnisheﬁ witﬁ §:°r:;32*isesm":';ea*':t which may axieﬁé ta me yes: aim?' with ﬁne:

ﬁréviéeé that,-

a} WM».

far 3 firét éfferzae, Si..§C§'3 im§r§$anme":1t shaii rm ﬁe éass than three *E}"a£Z}¥'2?i§'"§$ and fine siwaii mt Ea' iesg ifzaﬁ ﬁve hunéreé rnxaees;

&V%\~/ £032 {*3} far a $ecér:é érssiarsce, suth im¥:riscﬁm;er:ij":z_has.iv§ 223% $9 Eass than six: manths aria ﬁi§§3"*s%1:.;é.§__j::é'Q:' be §é§S~; than fivé huﬁﬁred rupees;__a§"e2.ﬁ L"

(:3; fér 3 ihird es' Sﬁﬁfgéfﬁﬁéfif afféﬁﬁei <§_i:,€ﬁ, V' imﬁrisoﬁmeﬁt sﬁaii inst ie;=.;5'~t_ﬁ§ﬁ' thmssanﬁ raga s.

S. 5: reaéiraﬁ af't"r*;§:s ;§'r9;§}~is::i€:iiLTv;??_r:e'i;£i<:er~,=. it ciaar that 3 §)é'§"S€§3?'2 ceuiﬁ '§4E-- ﬁ&;é:i'l':£é§ t é_"V.%:a§é~.',%::--§n°£m§%.'ied an éfféaﬁté if E §{EE§§ ﬁ§:1:¥ E::"'£ '.ﬁiE"§I§_§.ﬁé_ Q_? 'essés '*9ef_ﬁyf_ ézuiidiraﬁ, mom, teﬁi, :3?' M!"

ea':cicsa,§v;*&*,*,-V:;§E%;i€ié1;§:_;v&$se§..'of';*:v£§r'*é fer tﬁe j','3TL§E"";§§Sé $3? 3 aémrﬁésx §a:rra'iir§§*~fiii's.::_§,§sa§;»"§%'=7§?ie:~§?e2fe:'e, thé ihrusi is that the iiiéﬁé ?'f'I§.£Sf~i'3_ &,-at' t_§:é._i'irr:'€e 9?" raid, shawﬁ ta bé 'ages? as a §§§?§§3'f3f37;".%ﬁ%§§§SE, A"'EE.%.:+..s:3§Iy fﬁéﬁ that what is seized ﬂaring §;§..b~a:r:%%:s::s aémissiﬁia in evideﬁce uﬁder Secﬁan 3.»; WE 55$' 2* 5 :*c,,7--§hfit5:=: envisages mat:

E 2:» I, J..i:;.

3-E33 * 352}. PE'§Si.§m7£3iiiié mas? sf keegzisag sf gaming Er: iémman §a':°x*:i<r:§-%w:.s$&.- {1} V%§'ﬁé%"§ am: iﬁﬁiruméﬁt ef éémiﬁﬁ ﬁes ﬁeéfs seized Er: any ﬁiliiﬁiﬁé, ream, tent, enciessre, vahitée, vesseé at' aiacfa arztereé er ﬁéaféﬁéﬁ ! .. -.L I I2 1.

2'3 he an 5? §§?!'ﬁ"ui'"¥§T. ?.'v'v'.2 ié the aﬁiy.-sine: #"""?"

induigaﬁ Qfficer wiw ﬁﬁéﬁiéﬁ aééui ra§i~'5irat%::~23 6?' FI:'.VR':;."._"';"--§f§"""=«é; aresacutian, far agwexsiaineé fééﬁéflﬁ, has ex.éV:¢{:'%sé§'*T "

airy' metnﬁer 43? the raiiiing £33???-i'ﬁ'E"---fléﬁiﬁ w§'i*:é1esée$'A.tév.. éS1'.Eﬁ3§iS§"I that §ei22.:r& 23223 effaéteﬁ as é:§_i1ér'r9aC'iéﬁ--.i,r; ._ Tiiarafafré, in the absence sf évfi}rii'£=2:?:a& §e'??z_ic:'r:.V;éaa§"'2.éé§i§*:§ﬁ the "

aérziraf arf tﬁe arééecuiiécgrs, ihe---éiqviﬁétige -:>?*:"i'véz.:.r:vs*ﬁ is téé feabie ta maid ihai we Ei*:ara5&._é'§::§r:éz':'f_%%:é~ acczsseé far the éfferzie aﬁﬁef $.C~3€1i§.CI¥1 '.«'f§' Héf §i1e. .fxﬁi=yia§ 'trim. has?' shérgéi' '::?"r":e"-:Vaa%i:1;ée§'?:2§i..--ti1& oﬁeﬁéa aznﬁer ﬁectiérs 86 ef i?*: é__g5.€:t. "'~.:"s.,E 6 vEI";;ei;.::i::32t., ésﬁv iiéfséﬁ fczumé ii'! the ':3¥3C& sf "--v.§§ivf§:§'i§?';_§§.A Cﬁiiifi iiéﬁfrésiaé and can such arrest it is rwi "e,=::;:é:::§aérf'f:§r._:ifLe Dfﬁﬁééﬁfiﬁﬁ ta estabiiéﬁ that he was at tiia«:"'%::ariiéu?§.a:*:: firm in the active aét af aamizxiirzq, it i§ ._éE"3€}u§§'?_ if his iiféﬁéflﬁé Es Shawn in the cambimg muse. ' "_r%::e %%;_f§re, is Eimeéke ﬁéﬁiiéﬁ 86, thé first thing mat the ﬁ§?3§e:utien haﬁ fr: éﬁfébﬁﬁﬁ is the izsiace sf ﬁafﬁ¥;?§§é"'§§ 3:16 the §er'sﬁr: arrestéﬁ wag in ihat ﬁfﬁfﬁiééﬁ. %*v'it§w2st estéhriiﬁhirrg ﬁée fact tiéai the gjiaié where the ﬁEi§ti§F"Ié£"§ §~i37/ 3.2 were awaited, was a eamfziiné muse, ii canrzezi ﬁe haicié frzai Séatéara 32'} was rightéy inwkeﬁ. Er: iﬁe t§rcumsi;:%:*r;Te$, G?! beiﬁ ihe %;":€3i.£¥"ﬁS,, cnrrvéétiaﬁ is. uﬁs;2S_i'ai%:af;q~5é;.. Carzseqaeniiy, the judgments «if 2312 triai aigjd é%s;§.. V' the Sé§S§€'.1¥"z$ "surf éazﬁer ffﬁfﬁ Eégééi i'f§fE:':TiEi§as,-- rims: set asiée:

21,. In the résszii, t%:'éL«L.;7r'tea-visi:::2é** ._i_s"'-za §*icfx}*'s.jéﬁ".V The :'.":§"}3E'§&$ iexséiieﬁ agaénsi ':.hjé ﬁéiitiu-%§er%}L'aA:=é :3*i§é'i3a?'%gaé. §i~:'y7;'13,i2;.a'38 'JK

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court