Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Vinod Kumar Tyagi vs North Delhi Municipal Corporation on 13 December, 2017
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No.4400/2017
M.A. No.4568/2017
Wednesday, this the 13th day of December 2017
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Permod Kohli, Chairman
Hon'ble Mr. K.N. Shrivastava, Member (A)
1. Vinod Kumar Tyagi,AE (Civil), Group 'B'
S/o Late Sh. C.S.Tyagi Seniority No.as JE:491
Aged :58 yrs
R/o 9/38, Sector-3, Rajender Nagar,
Gaziabad-201005.
2. Akshay Kumar Singhal EE (Civil), Group 'A'
S/o Sh. G.D. Singhal
Seniority No.as JE : 479
Aged :56
R/o Block A-2, H.No.37, Paschim Vihar,
New Delhi-110063.
3. Ram Avtar Goel, AE (Civil),
S/o Sh. Suraj Bhan Goel
Seniority No.as JE: 596
Aged :55,
R/o 124, Kapil Vihar Pitam Pura,
Delhi-110034.
4. Surender Singh, AE (Civil),
S/o Sh. Chander Bhan Singh
Seniority No.as JE: 922/7
Aged :54 yrs,
R/o A-82, FF, Pushpanjali Enclave,
Delhi-110034.
5. Vijay Kumar Aggarwal, AE (Civil) Group 'B'
S/o Sh. R.B. Gupta
Seniority No.as JE: 575
Aged :57,
R/o A-303, GF, Meera Bagh,
New Delhi-110087.
6. Sayed Afzal Ali, AE (Civil) Group'B'
S/o Sh. Mukhtar Ahmed
Seniority No.as JE: 620
Aged :57,
2
R/o C-61, Radhey Shyam Park Extension,
Parwana Road, Khureji, New Delhi-110051.
7. Sikandar Hayat, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Latif Ahmed
Seniority No.as JE: 639
Aged :58,
R/o D-18/11, Okhla Vihar, Jamia Nagar,
New Delhi-110025.
8. Rajeev Kumar Sharma, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Om Prakash Sharma
Seniority No.as JE: 642
Aged :54,
R/o 169/A-2, 2nd Floor, Paschim Vihar,
New Delhi-110063.
9. Ashok Kumar, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Khajan Singh
Seniority No.as JE: 654
Aged :56,
R/o RZ/D-40, Dabri Extension East
New Delhi-110045.
10. Mohd. Ashraf Siddiqui, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Moin-uddin
Seniority No.as JE: 702
Aged :55,
R/o 1448, Chatta Nawab Sahib, Farash Khana
New Delhi-110006.
11. Sunil Kumar Gupta, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Prakash Chandra GuptaKhajan Singh
Seniority No.as JE: 711
Aged :53,
R/o C-490, S araswati Vihar,
New Delhi-110034.
12. Sunil Kumar Sharma, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. K.S. Sharma
Seniority No.as JE: 715
Aged :53,
R/o B-3/82, 2nd Floor Paschim Vihar
New Delhi-110063.
13. Aslam Parvez Khan, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. F.R. Khan
Seniority No.as JE: 722
Aged :57,
R/o 65/41, 2nd Floor, Punjabi Bagh West
New Delhi.
3
14. Sushil Kumar Ghauhan, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Dhir Singh Chauhan
Seniority No.as JE:751
Aged :53,
R/o AM-19, Shalimar Bagh,
New Delhi-110088.
15. Sunil Dawar, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. O.P.Dawar
Seniority No.as JE: 753
Aged :51,
R/o C-31, Shakti Nagar Extension,
New Delhi-110052.
16. Rajesh Kumar Garg, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Late Sh. Shyam Lal Garg
Seniority No.as JE: 755
Aged :50,
R/o 62, Deepali Enclave Pitampura
New Delhi-110034.
17. Suraj Parkash Sagta, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. I.D. Sagta
Seniority No.as JE: 761
Aged :51,
R/o 31, Lotus Enclave, Parwana Road
Pitampura,Delhi-110034.
18. Aditya Nashier, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. J.R. Nashier
Seniority No.as JE: 776
Aged :52
R/o 44, Suvidha Kunj, Pitam Pura
Delhi-110034.
19. Pramod Kumar Vashitha, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Late Sh. Bhim Singh Vashitha
Seniority No.as JE: 781
Aged :52,
R/o F-124, Prashant Vihar, Rohini
New Delhi-110085.
20. Arun Kumar Jain AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Mahavir Prasad Jain
Seniority No.as JE: 796
Aged :53,
R/o Pocket-A, Flat No.59B, Phase-II,
Ashok Vihar
New Delhi-110052.
4
21. Sanjeev Dara, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Upender Kumar
Seniority No.as JE: 815
Aged :52,
R/o D-145, Ist Floor, Mansarovar Garden
New Delhi-110015.
22. Rajesh Gupta, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. T.C.Gupta
Seniority No.as JE: 823
Aged :52,
R/o A-108, Ashok Vihar, Phase-I
New Delhi-110052.
23. Pradeep Kumar Chauhan, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Bhanwar Singh
Seniority No.as JE: 835
Aged :52,
R/o B-76, Shakti Apartment, Sector-9, Rohini
New Delhi-110085.
24. Sharad Kumar Gupta, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. M.L.Gupta
Seniority No.as JE: 852
Aged :53,
R/o DU-161, Pitampura
New Delhi-110034.
25. P.K.Sharma, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Suraj Bhan Sharma
Seniority No.as JE: 856
Aged :52,
R/o E-61, New Saraswati Apartment Sector-9,
Rohini, New Delhi-110085.
26. Anil Kumar Aggarwal, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Mange Ram
Seniority No.as JE: 922/39
Aged :50,
R/o 7-A, Ayodha Enclave, Sector-13,
Delhi-110085.
27. Ashish Sharma, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. B.M.Sharma
Seniority No.as JE: 927
Aged :47,
R/o 45, Ist Floor, Engineers Enclve,
Pitampura
Delhi-110034.
5
28. Rajesh Sharma, AE (Civil) Group 'B',
S/o Sh. Gian Chand Sharma
Seniority No.as JE: 928
Aged :47,
R/o D-89, Delhi Citizen Apartment Sector-13,
Rohini, Delhi-110085.
.. Applicants
(Mr. M K Bhardwaj, Advocate)
Versus
North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
Through its Commissioner,
4th Floor, Civic Centre,
Shyama Prasad Mukherjee Building,
New Delhi.
.. Respondent
O R D E R (ORAL)
Justice Permod Kohli:
The applicants have challenged the promotion of certain individuals under the reserved category. However, they are not impleaded as party respondents. In their absence, the O.A. is not maintainable.
2. At this stage, Mr. M K Bhardwaj, learned counsel for applicants seeks to withdraw this O.A. with liberty to file fresh one by impleading the necessary parties. Prayer allowed. Dismissed as withdrawn.
( K.N. Shrivastava ) ( Justice Permod Kohli ) Member (A) Chairman December 13, 2017 /sunil/