Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Rajendra Prasad Samariya vs M/O Finance on 23 October, 2019
2019} St be "rt ie, Ad M i g 44 ~ & eB ta 8 e + ¥ a *, ~, & GO ; 4)
2. © "a4 *s pt % 3 G 6h tpl a3 iB ied ity at fe a a ¢ Ce a o Ps 7 9 #2 HY OO . bes qo Ms 5 Q ~ 4 g ms wes, o Oo cS ah rg MO ee : be ar sie SF 8 Zo (of oe Q bee 1 ¢ Ke. AY im by % Ea ree it L > 3 es 3 a i y ~ B & oH Hee oOo 6 nt & - age cao yom 0 ie rs mM Ben, ; a i ; B® gy ho sf oe og a G . th i re he w ' O a fs Ki art as ~ Fae @ o bG a Bet cy ay a, : wy wy G8 mo Hh BS "g in A bet . tH ved E3 a 3 % @ SG Fa s «2% # wa ny, fl a) ts ri ey. ty 4 ' ' ; A G 4 "
ei wt + vg aS ao "4 be] "4 G ea 3 G fy gd a Oy 2 i mo "5 G a4 Shred os my on & BO wy ig fea
3 Mi a . . . a 6 wo od ey 'eof? 3 LUAU, LET ~ i . ra "4 vd an : C} ra ys 7" i «4 a rhea iy ef -- ae G « or $ og ce) 4 a w we 4 w 3 $e, apd vs 4 orf ea ae ad i a "| oe a 2 ef mp Og a Ma a Oe a mm aS mn 4 ~ "
sp 4 seed a Q b4 ey cs 4 * vt 3 s ° ¢ fe fe ie WD o , . " uy 3 tis e oe, w% a : a ved % ceed or " G am xa wh cd « Hf ot red & 44 ts} co oe 6 rH e '5 wn & Cars fk a ten ea eG ayeet Oh 4 OH @ 'an bt cs $ yori, Ol A Og aoe 8 Pg _ gH 8 a 4 5 3 --
. 1 Oy fad 4 me a Ot og oO & it :
* iN in * Me oe & o6 « 43 ws " CO +e Xt it ene wen, €3 in "rf Da res) as pe 35 35 S) mo ' a om chs a 0 rch a rd . 2 Ww Y '4 34 : ms oO @ Oh s 3 P @ gH + Oh, : BY Be od YE 4 ee % a bal + i ie) * ® i} M4 we Db wt ' 0 Qi rfl g j Oo "4 os be oO wl et $3 D i % ' '3 > od be a) ey ae * hel . 4 aN . Bo we Sal gh 6) a mm a aa! en in Hib it et Fy "7 Ce i tm Ot GO ee a Gn 34 ? 3 ort 44 ' a a" ea ct . hilt ce 4 2 ie A $4 he " .. ahee it eC gt 18 oe 12 ot , es es 4 oes a a hy OHO x if By $4 i? 'St G 33 3 he ft "4 ; me g a, "24 'a at 43 ad fa : i "9 aot ' ' the aa Ae va i <> on oy td out $e oes ed wr ee Cs « Ch ue ven, ie o wet a aged ' 4 oe " ts va 4 é a o ea oa 3.3 "4 fa o3 no iol 44 a ta oo fi ord ~ A an rf sf " ns j we a & a OM iv ' Oo if os Do Bed oed re) iS a uw He we ad O
5 wed oe acd +» c o 4 : 5 he ¢ hg 6 od od Of a eg iy " ay * hae sae he it fs "3 ws - w a Ci 4) ie : i + baa a im Bt "ed 1 en . ae 43 4 wd "i a i cry if a3 bee " an i?) og ea ns Cr . We ord f nt we - 7 ( asi : 5 ib . $5 ap 4 ed D 3 vn » vb « sy peed oF 4 Cs £4 2 xe s th. a b . uo y a 3 @ " an 8 a ha 4 in wy _ es aa Pe on cK wea aw oe tid cy eed 4d @ cs ed see a O ha ard i ve ed - 5 Q 5 ey Ss iy i) © " ea i " ag oe Ae ; 4 5 . ie i *y '4 os 43 & a 3 re 3 G " : o in oe pot 3 -_ :
"i ior mo ow a6) af Ma i Et @ ay © 3 cod nf us iy ud An a on re oon ian " : v a 2 i ; iD Ea ig Q ix} nee eM y ge ; .
vt i a os e ° A os txt wed ; oe fh] "> & ' "A rf a * "a Sos es ia] ~ ' . of . ty S BORE bs . a cA os is wt « Pa es oN a ne af ust 4 8 red oh Ut 3. ra veck * neal a ay os * wa % 7 s et S O ' ue ca On He Oh, {24 ne cs) us QWUSs x :
ot mics A om Tage aN we Ne as : . aye or Ion ~ feet Oe Te yet oo Pept yay SNS. mS Sek ' Lis wee GW Rites ao baAeS Rew eiepev a ebro dor Noo DPa3wrny Me ES AAS fe LAR RA ARE eRe Dea Rskp » * ™ s a aa syn:
By ox Bey hss my seers Zz tk} . OS MES wok cL 4 S . . -
: ye ray wee Paty AT Sar ese a ot Mat dace ROAD AL. CRA net at he é x Ne a ees my Yare 2 wes ee ea wae se Tas * : 220k hocks fre ALLE 2 SS SS = REE LS Aah de & ee : a = " Ag seri ca} Sarasa oF ris eryoan 7 str hhe See OW OAs SORE A Ea Se tet A a a NE NS yp Yieieg ey ey a SE eet eyes ont cyt oe et > Aiea TL Lk SRR " mt ' we . 7 SyNk hat fy SR ry we moe yy ot Eka st CASS Seid ay ae r be ade PASRIEAA * iat Www mt se bet ee soa sas bd si tory mas = Ba OE ae CR A ba wee Ee ba A Rd we BN Bet TR Nee ASD = Bern Yranhet RSstions! eha most Mek: BEANE Sa Lake RAE A AL we ee RE see a iu : saree mn ye : * as ES ae ee er ths Ww LE ea PTS an 3 eT OP Yi gu Sl teret eos Lae y wry ee ON ak SA GE a s 5 = Ae gen tee SAV ATTY oy poy tA oye Ra ee Dat ee NP BAS Nate o. fe eA AE Wo Somewe st ae PALMA EE « gfe is hes been wines AS vetcear Feam ° re Pee Deere Be dy Wop Pinte ao at a eg Ee EES che we Sd 16 ' st we. Sh x Lk Ee Ae Appra romotion ADDI 4 we A ee SS Asta ve aT teh ar z A A
- ~ 5 « Sy MS & fey weet ee oth SN sy ds at a rn a Tet LOADS sek ke etn Ui tags OR ke, Man TAG y RL . , "~ ey. can Ok . NY. art eos oo os Waapimme Kote vier, i LY, QYQicg Wile mrig a A NOMSaes Raves Sen ea NS LA LS RS eeoeten yack esd Da TL Sk tb a Framectors wn eat : sery a imal Bat Se ae te eS Ce we " AP he 8 wean a eae wa a yo cH +4 3 SPN ee ch gM oe ae EE RO ae et Sa bry 4 ¥ Ray SUR AR AS LQ 4 4 _ of Ne a te nt = ae Yt » eG ney Aint oo hea Oy Ce bee.
Reet Som es, oe Ny i 4 SS 208 y ne at 4 SPI gy cit wed eet en Dy , iD eh mt ba vet 03 4 Cy iy KE or 3 vs oe 5 * ; 3 cha bed «©: é "< og % : QB 3 ay a i o py ay 62 @ Set : ft ww 1 4 aye 4 :
' As ead v4 . w% % C3 " A : t ot Py c . fame ua in 0 a9 i rod on e é * ea ing * Ld co ei "es ia oa B® 4 4 oo, c BP a a ct 5° ay oS} as sek G ' nS fe i 3 ad bs a 3 to a3 a iD i at w 0 "3 : a we 2 * , a tis ey aa ed * va r4 ts . 1 Ch on oo Or shy 7 4% Mo 3 thy i ge mt 33 £4 im hk oe cd oO be a i mo i a 3 a D C os sd iS Dp 3 Q sre} .
WI mS ae 5) & , es :
"4 > ot i . 4 g ns fe 3 ' ft $13 ae co "4 gy aay 7 aw sed 4 64 ag + "tt = $4 iG ol ' ie o Ad n by 44 . ha i ss) MY * iQ Ch oe saecf Ww em it , et 4 wd ' gS a ana Me os 3 wn, bet as . i o O, 3 ys nt ESN wD ~ 0h, ued 3 er uy Ts ret i ey eg Cy weed gry Or 4.3 a t . o 2 a 4 et _ be © aw B o gs 38 oo a "5 ® hed :
a op ff O x g Da os 14 i od cH m3 by 2 -} od & xt B or on" '¢ oh ved Wy i ot y ira "rl "a A ' Ss > A "4 * wrek i © 5 & ° | 2 ei a Set ro bet i c on & an 42 (i ry C4 A es * fs wf | Ke os ans e 5 -
ag ha ort a) oY "
oA tet bay 4} i D "
Pa raat * a a a 5 g fh a cy g f fH z 45 ue ue .
KB.
ten, ao = oS IN ww ont 2 & © Cd Fy QD ° a ec 3 * a fet oy 44 Fs oe + Oo @
a) os ied : ms tnd "A o 3 bs 4A i ee OO a ct aS eG :
. ri . os a 4 4 "> cH 4 ' & Go ns ' Cs nA ih : ' : ay y £ % 4 Q a + <> ib " Cy 43 bts q 3 gh ° ; un ee "s os 3 md ne 3 i . » a mA As o 48 o z ol : c «s a ag t et S "cn ", ' ped © Od "es 4 Cm iB vt Ot a d eed Dy if bone Gg ' . 6 "8 ved ~ a orf of Q fo 4 oh a Choe $d "
ee nd uy ts Pac! fry : is <--F 51 uy is vef re 53 re Cy oO et oO th sed o> es st Oy ~ of : i yy ol b o * we vet set L M4 ns, e rh ' ia po 3 Ae % wm hy i Oo gt a1 "sf ' wv od ed 4 fs tb Os no sf re ary Qs y ne a $d CFs od : : ae * go 7 6 wt Ba os * us n om 5 a by @ wy i x ay ~ a . a a 3 4 "3 oe 4 3 e 2 we e 0 rf ee ay wd rom 5 go 9 Y % pon
- mg om 8 ct a mfg Bo : H gw oh Te kk tH ? ery uy aad
4 Oo ts 6 g a by; "i a cay 4 ne eh 3 eo ab G va 3 . o "et > (23 Aa 4 st - Gg S o S 8 is a o HO a & 7 3 g © : w iG & et 3 o > ws B oh og OF rt oO Gi gy nt bee) wt rt :
G, im wd on 3 ut & fi ia ct %& o wy ty OF vd wi G o by ca % a Dy &$ & a os 'i 6 wey, ved 8 Gg 4 a Cy a M4 Ss my 4 Oo sre} ~~ 6 g 4 aS are 33 oy iy "7 GO ip t £2 ° , tt} , ag nS) Se a & to ° uy 6 @ al zy red 3 i> iH Bs: GB oO 6 th, ce tA / 6 ooh @ gOS OR, i; nal fy Bu ey 4 a ey ay ay 9] a4 3 a 3 i O 9 a a @ G sf a iW Gy & ¢ t 5 43 + 8 Ch 4 a a ra a , ag i a : 6 Ra ick i fs 3 g wt (fi ? a 5 4 rn a : ot & s *- a Ld g 5 od Hg e ua 2 6 3 ort Co a -- a Ch, a i Mahe H 7 pot oe weed ord @ ved a AR = : ped te cs Mt ry ; t bs 44 Hot at "4 SU ~ ot aoa & Res C3 a 6 6 oO G a 9 * % tis "es Go o ~ref cA ey ay ba - m 13 a . t a a i & bs 4 xz a G 3 x & an ra A a 6 od a (3. te he 8 he by ty ba o fh we ' he ae a} % et ip & os 2 a cs sr " ; fay ag Ox at a4 O u & @ 4 & 6 * 7 vl 43 = s a weal a ws be ad ? es 13 th uy mi % dew, . " « a " ' ef oF . ra a 3 a " to y e 4 * 5 , po wv Pi Ey o » ' G 4 a ae 2 ss Ma ee o S 0} oa th vd
a) a ay "4 " 4) od mt > ie Us " ao AR a @ 2S S 6s oo 8 a oy wt ~ Be gy 3 : "4 ; v C as o ve Ma , a "4 At Ry ms te : ; iy rr oy ved es Ry | i d & ? -
ae as 14 . * nye 4 A on freee x "
a © 8 oS Boy 8 EB BB Be » 8 i ' et os nt 2 G i Y wed ab 3 fis o 4 . a my vd 6 4 4 Ct o> a = 2, a ' he oa 2 rnd wo 36 "on Cok vay Soe a eg ony £75 ved : bog na sgt On ti 43 x aa ie) ky we " @ "th n : " wef cn ~, s ia wt ved e G Qe wy i eo Ue > ny oo i C3 w uy a Bio ef A i 3 va mn ch bed " ed et ange cm ran 1 fa ha x % a hs w os ts 0 eg ry vol wef -- : a i 4 be eed "4 oo "7 et fu ye hy tk a 43 # cg "A "cd ma GO 1D 4 . mo TO eg ho Ded KE HG fe » ; : vg rho % a a 4 moe > eed bo G ' 43 ' oe oOo TB 42 vec fod i i Ci be wo My OB BB o£ ¢« ete O OO & 1 (4 i 2 iB i" zg QO © crs 6 iI a oO fs ig % c tor ol is o~ eho gy me Re mM oH a 6 4 - o #8 « C £3 3 oy os FR a . "ft be 1 ceed i oD SM yy} BE a Too. eG & OG fF + © v ao : o vr pS ' cs by é L a a o a 6 OR , 03 4 8 . i ni re ' of iB rt be fe ay u 5 Bet
i) 4 Bo Gr j oS OG rn "3 of a Cy th fh er Q St Ge Ui oOo 4 f COLAO ECL OOO OULULECLLLLL LLL OLLLTLL oy By td au tS mH ot Fe F Sd a ' Aa oo AE es) 3a 6 nd ops c Rb Mi 3 3 "hh i as wv 65 gi ey 4) ra . ps v ee eB a et, tg vir Sg a -- wet e 4 , oie] i} 05 i Ao bats ray bg a ot vot vn Os, ft mS Si 7 Ba ed + ef ay ; o woe O rae a re nt " i. 3 " ob. a UF ve ody Cy 9 ' "ts ot 4, {% et. ry (4 C3 . ip = ad bis (sd Ed va if to a3 ii i bes 43s tte a ved i ie 6 oO A ig * as gt god w . ed thee 5 i ted bat Yon, Ch wi ' yee L 'bt é 4 "a a a ae , 4 3 be cy "8 bai oy 03 ie CR . ca es is ua: nt +4 "a xs Me an "
a fase . 3 ae 3 , 32 ra . a @ tee ip oe ne ne 3 i co Ce cet ws ct nd g2 eee Ty 14 : 4 oe 4 es 3 re iS : ce v4 mn 2 a e 2 9 Me oS gs a boot od ie is 5 Be "4 ite et Be uy r e thet $ Bae uh £8 wy butt oo s. a, "ey c pt whey ' 4) ie @ 3 a 43
o) + & ; 4 wy i xy % a Ry yt a 3 KS , a hed . . at 3a a Pas as wy v ty a as "p ve na 3 hed "73 Moy 6 wl fo eee - a . 4 a ml % x 4 ys 5 beg boa iy xg red ra ee, a ord os ay Ci, i os on ' i ope c r& a Be a % oD het Fy ty mt ory Me os we ha ey 4 "Gs i hy a Q i @ aft 3 w i Bee bef . er _t frre pe ages * Seg cS es ' ht xo rm B sy @ poo a $3 £2 a ft a es os a gi os 43 ae "E ted i cS fe fa i £3 vy OU bet 3 vy oe ' i ho bf os a yo BR bed so . 3 hea cet &j oo is 4 ae ws werk 3 . $3 v2 w $ ay ; , ce aed 3 by a :
Sh, ws ok a i 6a Met Shy an seme a Ck eH @ ai ; s 43 Fa 3 3 ra ae g y z rai) 3h os pa AY 2 oe = 4 Awe t ae hae ake ~ o3 i t 4 ce msoect RA AS ap i whe ae AS S set ey Nee te = 1 u * aa SS
--
ye Ree sees wee ac TLS i AY ot :
wn a:
R:
"~ be Qh ores note kw Sawn tN Non Sa Soe af SaaS y 3 i 4 os a ee > Yt ' A O 8 s a J eA Aa NB ok ke as pons aS ee ¥ SA pees $4 wp £3 Chr i 3 g CFE re * . i wb iB a3 A AG im G G o G ot 44 oe x ved oa a a a 'a "i at 4 nef a4 os bea be mt me an a os 3 na: 6 > % ty ® us gees " cont «4 on at ol mm oe Ss << 4s o ws A ba aS i 5 ie ote) at wes vt ; " Med i wn 3 te) us pe i > y Pa OS [es £6) ot oes o ed Sa
4 wet ge "4 oe fs oe oS if 0 UR 3 oy " Esa) ond a ey Oh 3 . ae tog OO c3 i? a g x ;
vt ce wo OUP . ie 4 urs wed . " it 0% wd " a 5 > vd vote, s ed aa we ' . ge «a my . wo oy eed we iB ct & a 4 od @ ' te i a oF , co Cry v4 i Q ra - hes we » Eid : @ ihe ' 4 4 wy od . a ord wed ord Fat ig 0 yD ts be et i an ah wy ee 3 4 3 at a 44 ¢ m4 oa ny & x sed m4 3 Sy oS C3 1G ae i : od . ae a KS a a wee, 43 as Ad S a h Gok o TY 6 ted i ocd $5 , GM ri Bg oe MS 4 S$ 18 £ "A ad ree xy a ; € ip 5 4 ed ye ey bed td LY] 4% a 4a 4 42) went rd : 4 3 cm as ; 1D nj fa ; " 4 i vr het o 3 '4 Fe ty eal i tts we we Sy ts co) o> a st 4 a * on "eS : iD 0 ay - ny = te ( tee " B " Gs, 2 © @ B Bo GG Sg, oe wl ma oe ap o @ . t Q hy
- " belt . { ae os iY ef 4 ey oF % TG ("i ey : Fe Fd iy £4 B a U4 ie 4 3 a 3 Les Lie.
ow fy I "4 i i Bw 8 4 Q "3 , a uy o ) bed a4 os * rd e 'v4 is 3 ' hl g von "rt i G ms i ad AY net Qo 42 6 £9 XG 3 76) wy i o vert Be) Court Unien of India:
Supreme Ve.
ay ort og be:
eH dated 18.12.2014 esarwanli
--
RAoOnN Of on oF ision 3 ae Un & ¥.
U AER {Rajeev eA Bali wv.
1 Bench dec @ ASSH.
"
ow ipa Bam on 'we Welfe EN Bal Rs 0949/2013 Le AnD y 3 _ Loyess ' O.A.3 t bat x A 2 ope iD £2 "4 ia aed uw SS ae, wh "
Sw os i Nee E oO 5 wa TAS a orm ¢ & is f ' + » A:
em aN Le B ip % a os ; _ op ° & BOS @ oo. 4 goo "oe mi "3 " Ba "d ; a 58 «@ , 8 oe . "BB 3 0 : he 5 My aa 3 ee ae s 13 i f 8 3 6 ve ' ~ # wa a ! m8 ne 43 a4 ns ts wt % "es 4 m is uy a AL . 4 a % i t 4 ' het we AS a a By S Oo Eo cy D ss on) ys (4 iba $5 rm % i » wm 44 is} . : es rd Ol ev ee rs a's i uw Sw | 2 8 my OO a aK It y at 3 ed 2 mA + ta gy uf G g a By o oe t o fy * a : an e 4.3 fees " be "ret 8 7 1) aD , a 9 a mo 2) wo 4 .
a Hy a : tn me, th " 3 B © y t i os ny tS ZF 4 q o x © o 6 : os Bo ' A, at wd 19] g ay is ' ; @ > As CH sty @ he Q i ° 4 ' Hog 9 G a xg Cl w es fr th weg Ma tf Ay : CC " "a "xt a Cs a # 7 eB gs 5 Bog o FG 45 + ed wy ee ve ref y Bs » 8 ' 4" BOM ved eh e te O a oo EB a} 4) * ' ce 3 e oe w a " @ G o , w ty A we ¢ Mio Le ved G rs fh { fey
i) bet tree set i + ES.
$ Ska (Nani al No. 2665/2007 ae L Apps i 4 c State of Arunachal Pradesh and Ors.}, ain Ys .
16.05.2007 med tear week yee we mA & re See Ad sad al a 87 ra Dev Si Ors} hed +s i (Sa ~ SAGE Nak
-
ri No. 2246/1962 Appeal Government of India and Civil et wer a a ¢ ', an = x ind on SA Lt ces rt NS ot bee « = wv oats aN ' NEY ove of, om tp rs ~ . 3 is os 7 . ic? ford ib i oes MG ct ae yt on ue ig? ret - oa aie iy on ; - i, a 4 3 ph i 4 G ui . :
ind ng Ba a aed 0) te i O :
S a a cl te a a ee 3 wy + i Shut 'e fee ia '4 et £6 f ced % . o , a x Mt a4 ig ot Be 3 0 i ry $24 wh cf re 5 st ri . " : ey "na hy Cy, + IR £% "a os er : iD 3 Lb Pe Ct 3 o, is am "4 Me C3 i ed he % ed Ci wy on the tf) peed vt $4 fed , ied a ea wad * iss it ot @ ee ao "ae ee Mt : ag eens 1 * reek 8.5 re! ry ra a We " BY a wet © ky bt ef a ic tht 2 ; 4 os he a ord a ved 5A 3 ° : ' Be iv a og a e 0 3 5 as yo an ) 2 i ' » . 4 1 io 4 me L bed " "t uy ™ a j i oe c ue a yp 6 ie ie ij ba ct j 2 ; 4 G "5 na eed " aed ra ord cs ip is '5 an "ey sy a4
- . a 4 ren MY eH C5 a 4 a ok Sa rat Mn s cs , bas w © iy 4 i mn me 4 5 Q a Ma fo wd we 6 os ed A fas 5 £2, % is Me a 7 et £ " ed iB me iy ¥i4 ign he -
wp At £9 iD a SS . 4 £3 ra a 4 ' A @ Q 5 ' SQ aS 4 Yay Cj u% bing : ' > oe -ye¢ iy 2 . ea ue em i ny a io ceed £2 om . ' . hed Bp ag » ry we £ a , eh j 4 . 4 mn " oy % hed de oe ¢ ry by ° A ay a 3 . + ao . A a 3 Rs) Bo ws oo i ay wet wee 4 ee yt 44 med a w Po yw) é @ ted 43 " D 4 'a ie , wt Fe © ga bi a o Ee G oh oo Be) 3a os , uy 3 43 co a be i 4A 4 bo 43 ' a as ~ . ee , ¢ tye ey + i 43 se Uy in o ; 3 3 cy, 4 "et a 2 1% 2 ' : ms a pe bd ced £3 Pet 3 " ry e Le Ch: ah] a sad Foo ie _ "et a a s if} . i 5 $ , te a} "i As CG es i te rot ue i e d tc rm oy . a os] a aie aye G ay 3 1 «@ o os a e 4 Ba ay ,; c % Se gy. ; ad wit wrt . 4 ae as ope 42 Oo Y ee o OO u wy ays Ls we sp ie ' of : sh } = i é . ae * € my of ' th 13 ra 's bn Ae 5 i a $4 :
4 "2 She ay wp 43 oy a (2 oo :
B 7 ro Da i 44 ous t3 "6 : vet M4 vd i} ron A cs i '3 3 AA &: "pe c. was q es ae Be eS fat "a = ti 3 bey + wt | ci oH is ee tS eS Gs a KS co Aa a vy i Ch Leek ay " % SA s M2 ged ' tn hy Ae bel ba 0 "3 c ra ae ae a " ab ? eat rod 5 be cr et oy Ae i 4 ie ff +e, eee, " coh ct ay te nf - red . Lt 4 hoe ty + is os o - ot 3 : 3 a oe) ve} if me oe "y wh Sy ot om a8 a 3d Me 3 v4 ge @ & iG i 22 & ry +, + ef y oy o bes iy ee pod cs - aos aa end iz "5 nS a we : yet Pond cere ti > goed Co es 1% ees red ts e& 4 ag hed } a A we w 5 2 a ha ae m ™ iF ae th O Lt Sty 0 bef 44 4 aD hy AD i orf fe 0 AG oS A ven a i Le i .
x a a o w a vod * @ os ot "3 io As i 4 hed et 'y 7 nw As i 3.3 5 a au ft 4 ; D ed , e ' a . i ad "he eed ah 3 . 5 o uh a ey 6 Hi 5s oe ny a 'i 3 "it i Eo rf Sei 0 os % 54 a " 4 aS & 66 fj « orf a wD o oY Ch a o me ae us Et £ sy t As 42 43 be orf ord 42 ae fy a t "4 re £3 a ys Ae ' 6} Be qo rd Des : w 3} o feo @ ' © $84 i ad cd on oF iy a ig Wo. $4 ia if 7 Co "ed 8 wi o be 3 i a cl ig 3 vie ; Cy io Bek a Ww $4 "
beef % meee 0 be be Oy To wd bed w ' BALA eee ss oe We rity th a mon pop ee bed AOay yas eae A RS SA LAS Ae Ae SS Waals het Ge LON Ae LA a Be A wa ay MNS "
Pye La Aus a Wow e Soe ye AD = :
Q Mae < we ae ke wy ASS "3 Eee te 3 R as Las ate 2 SSO p Be a ' y { S raves x . we hack Ww OAS in bag@i. ang Ler sane hee Ne Ne ee ee Neat a a Net. Se ae os the Reoewosthmeann f&iutles Ryn OA Sa S 2 Lie ASE Line ile. NL eo SUSE LS OL py % Day Faye Sh a 4F " ster en de ; x Ft Pe Poy = an a x Sa whine be CAD ESSA Le yet ' + ° :
voy vse SP at it acuecan-cal hae SRE SA Sao SUS AD Re miss mA ety Me gS Mee A Ss bar BS » . 5, x es . < amanmen> Ya te sab rie ee Fo aN a tA QMGMamern da moar MOT ELEASan. t LAS Yop AT KA LE De 2 eA Ross ao Lhe dea Sue heb AAS SE sok 3 ad recrnre any aa wee Te ae ee weal x : :
Pye eta yr reascsn St a ite SA Late .
ST on se oN SO te ee ee 2 Re OSS a SE aT ey . eer es AAS Sad Se OR LL AES Na oa oe : A on = ae eed Me eee LSS A ood t + . a 4 Pty Sar ryt soe * Pao "oy ae at eA t se Hy ryan 5 Ca a CSN St ms Ls aon NO 2 we ED py oibbaetrmipc ~ eer ST fe this eat diel Ne SEM ade Ra de Lk Sot A ae BS ERS cere BAS ek a See Sores Negara.
4 a mye oa ws eo « Gk SAAS Bos ype ™ 2 :
Br RR Pe See Sum son ia doa Mya PRE 2 Meth Se ot t "
CA BARES wae ay Tow Dw an te me tog : 3 ry ; :
wk a . dk £ sy LS ee Lote 'Sa Se OS ¥ AS NS aw Se Ne ss ¥ ANd -
PANG Ce % 3 ~ ce te ee ad t AoGyk SARS ae x SA MA Wet 1 my PR od hse} oO = =y v L en go Sekt tan wa sa ate CA LO = tb} * oo rf aa TE Ek we t 4 d eat NB?
oN ri aya Sok 8 ND rs Me = ry we ae Net oN Me S rt 2 iy 3 RAK ANS pay ar Ss x St
-
4, "¢ ¥ i Yen RAS y y = we "
i 5 Ra he i 5 + a Oo
3. y ale At S oo me ut wW 4 ried 4 "
ay beh Ch 3 m4 tht Yas Ry Sok aes N "ops a 88.4 a AS thes 4} ~ up a 65% ae oO ey wo 3 ha % a is "3 vs iB oo 3 vet ay ra 4G * . in ie a OM th a : 1 a hy tH o md G we os ons a iy sepep GG Me : Le = © * wo 3 oe " ua et and p " a m 3 "
: 5 | ta ~ * sf 5 oH o & e a 35 oo o t cs ce A ~ eyed @ " a Sy s fo» ; a hy bot 5 'O ry o By uw "4 G ie € ug pad ts g i "4 wey wee "
uaa ry in 4 fey sed 43 i am ve} ot . 3 on ., ' ae ia Me " 4 oy . = a wy G " . ay re AG aD ~ 7 it $4 ° a % et Khanna ua ce mS g , 4 ved ae my @ Ld nd ae * 3 © io ' " a & 7 rea G }.
Wy a sa ts a v 2 Gs os m a 3 0 :
. s i "rf fc. a es fod vt ms we o re gy Fe aa "a ; i. it ve ue ea , Bo 8 8 om a . i 2 ot ie 6 44 : ys we an & ae ed wn ~ cs on Bi we i uy y tf vd wg a 5 3 ™ Z os a 2, J ony 2 wf wD . «4 Song 4 4 iB i 3] aw od 4 . a a L 3 44 0) a eg wp "
oy be uy ved , BD O ad Se £ oo we ved ¥) it by t ert of on " + oo td a ' D a iy #4 ky u a qs 8 Ry 5 hey i} ey sot "ed ood 0 a) m be nen "3 nee ay a @ ved is) tot © 4 ea in wi «S 43 cy yt a Se a + % ca 4 = i a fo de t ae os, St syn pecan ane x Qe Sen Am .
wt Ms oe 4 i 'ae YN SD x pre Pp Pt e % at Ne t = oc wo Woe Aah me {8 ' Awe ne = po ih % ¢ 2 a ty nota eet San hes Se NO A x mm } bed ot a afk as and Cy eRe ara ENE v th 3 y SRS 4 et 3 rot est A Spe ae += = Cas yee att eed 4 a AS SD & we nh on ee iG OM ¥ 4 Nes os 2 So we as NSkt < 4 et i 4.3 ay of * ay ge ~ ah cs oO u O he C3 ay 6 ; a + ped 5 ve yee he hue 43 i fe oe} i ib i in Ub wed go wd cs tH oy t iw % ~ ved g at . fe @ ue th 8 Wt. "as sR :
-
GE my as m= 6 "i 4 i 4h od ed 7 bo a4 oy "it wee ay Ea iy oe te a tha ree] 4 at wey an o 1 a ' Jo an ao ity os bh SSG 9 He ad 3 "
as " 0 "4 a O ats 3 ' cy o Md : rt Coty . a ab Q fe . oe wed od ' ~ a4 u a ket oa i "4 Lt ; a La a} hg ns : on 3 f3 118 ree} iis M4 | 3 Ln a a) be 43 &} 4.4 Ly Day S| , ~ ay " 7 a Ds ist gy) a0 ws ba i? iy Q oa os i & g oof ved g Cr ey o "3 gs oO L fed i . Cs <3 0 @ ' ue tbe ; " rs . 0 a pe x5 ue ot es) © 4 vn 43 w rod 0 oe as oh ta : eee 12 wt as i} oot ue ¢ 3 ne O - oa "rd 1 wa rg is "Es see 4 » 'i ue od & & f H ye a + EE "tf © a ¢ eG whe vol wy 4 KS tf 4 tS o wi i red 2 rs o «ee 5 tea, % w At a c on a a £4. fy &D tha A he ib 43 a) i ws wed : v t ved gs * x € vf i - ta ! 43 AG wy oy 63 ' 3 a n o aS ot . 03 oe 4d o> orf % ~~ ° by cA ae i oy ~ Z sed hy * ual aa 3 f as P , set Fa) gS me a i 8 er wot De Ch ip nat ba QD ay Les is} £3 aff 3 wd ip £} te ip rs a 'hed ae, wD Ane W O ge ee ies ah "a ; 4 ed he ee im & 4 +d oe P 6 a os bs he Bs 3 $4 its 3 i ' io 8 a FA At st th. . net ' oe a Me 3 +A i Ad 44 Uy baa a) a wv a xy ci ed ha " cS ct 3 a - ot ps C3 os Seve . c 4 " ' ak : S if 40 te rf KS 3 ay " os o ae é wv a "a £3 apd 5 Q) Set & ved word LS en 4 pa ue G oy oo % Be " 3 a nee £2 4 a ag od hot ed by ' x po os 3 "
fie i i i , a i s iB a fy i ee aed me th as a? ' 3 J me os oi oy a ct 4 B ' 3 eH us a wy on ? G "wo an 4 " ka egg i eo 8 @ ; f-4 fd ed ce La 7 ' D * ses a) yi m Bo bl es wt 3 " es ns ed tt " v Me 8 . bey od ms g vee oe eg ng : . 5 : ot :
by 3 £8, bed 2% id G »_ 2 5 fe 2 _ 4 5 a CD 3 Das . N a ai Seed "4 oy * » Sa a yal toy eh af oy a oes Bo oh a : " "e 3 " w ed i os vent . £6 Be) > , net id ve io O ~ " "$3 . tot i u ws 6M sr eo @ ¢ ® ot M PY eye B ' £ a eh wD mm wy > " Se 4s i mt ge > 4 is * 7 a wre ' ard rt ay aH LP : te] . g2 118 wet te + . fy uo 44 es, od i Fra ay AS a s 1 "53 em ms me tf Co 44 S i ht 3 wo ts oO ote gs ms DB Sek oy a Oy Fe) wy $4 er + "4 sy $3 w M2 od . . 2 a a ae 4 wy 2 py a i 2 ¢3 oy H ' <j £) o ' os ' eo ig wd © QD oo a ora ma re ty es ren &. at : i CA a a - vet hey a 3 oh va 44 (f 6 ; hee ae "S ky ws bel re 3 & fd a ae Ot } ® Bo ge "4 be ma mn flu ba an Gh Lt 8 " 3 At 43 we i ¢" rot * f * ny oy C% {> oe) 403 bd 3 a ~ Ch a naa in ved ' 4 ot bn tb ¥ eG "
as fy pa . i yy 5 eS ot al ql ti c} ot ce] Ra iB wt an Oo 4 « B es AO oo a ve @ 5 or . ft f ef ae
a) a 5 i 40 8 net "3 oy ey pos ye ord us ws Pas @ £3 aoe . a4 bee} eck ap O i Oo 3 7 4 cae ; as ifs Ak Db By &3 a ved ka ye as be ws " uy © : fo 5 " ; aoof "a . rc cG : oh € ; ed ty ed ¥ sae "4 Re Ss ed Cy, wed o a3 Oo ~ ip ce rd iB & Pas a ra pa a ra & i t} os me a nr ge eA iG ny MG iG 4 23 oof iG "3 on 4 oh Reef i p ct « Pee ms my « cee 4B 3 ial vt et . we $ i aot « 58) ny at "Er tg as ih 43 ~.
gn i: Ms 5 @ ies co "5 ard Beg ~ et e uk te 'cl ; cK "i " wt "rf cs 3 ; $e ees re * 3 i : he 2b aS "4, © 4 ag het ts he. ord ht os bo us ey Zz tae 4 " 4 or: ee : . tf oS et So ca . I ba vot a 4 w ss vet Z ; uit M4 3 oA fe the ms co, : us $ 2 co ay D a 3 ne - bt a 4a cy "4 iB 6 on rs: & "1 'o o * "A i st ms GO i J:
3 4 on Ee Co ba 3 it oi to ms ra ba 4 «et " " 4 3 : ven qi nS am o¢ oh sd Ch Ch cA K sed wt a a Oo 4 wt kp "4 on Cn , be ee wo vee . view re Et a) Ad ie is ct 5;
e "¢h if s 24 oa , be hs as 2 Ye ue 4 ti v 3s Ct ts ip ved oH 6 ted cl ¢ mS ed Ao w3 o . t3 yy . ' $ : one tf vs it ' gs a i yy yy Ww "a iD ue ' : a 4 hd ee + as eyed ied gt 4 y .
" oe . ad ; 3 Ls wy apd &4 yee ~r-d , Za My * i} 4 "4 ip £2, oh, : it c rs o A aed ws 4 aay 7 od be 4 a orf "Ch "t ih eet Shed 4 ; Q ise Sah BD set bg = Ne os Ve a
--
Sony R woh ay 3 a 7 oa a Be @ 's - i as v4 . AS Gh 3 43 eens "et es ify "ef @ yt re} : "i 'A aa th a Wa re) ; " a ;
a vd ' 48 tf wd ued i "4 nm 4 e ef eee o a a ' GB 0 WB a 0 'td ned Cs up is "OD ved i 3 wv ae ¢ 43
- . ie be e, a . ba 44 c AG i iD " re oo & . 03 Me ft ayy Be oo, ~ ~ fk iD 4 uy i a . rt a a BY 2 cet O d os EF i cy "ent a3 ay oY KS ms '% ty 01 oO Gi ie he '<p wy hed $2 a bet By 18 9
5. eye ce ee ACOs Net hen Sette AA G wee a NR w oy ae yee erly hae Me yy eyed bp chy Lae MM we to Ne Q ee ne we Member {A}.
, £ 'Dx. Bhagwan Saha ae § toe LEN kek oe Ae nS £ ) x BUR der Kaw in Member (7) iRhay tn