Karnataka High Court
Mr K C Chandrashekar Raju vs Max Hypermarket India Pvt Ltd on 3 January, 2012
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
§ EEXE' 'I'E%E?. Efififi CEZEEENF SE? Eig%f{§\§A'§Zs%f%§£'X AT L§3§§§'§QAi.C_}§€EZ Efiaivsti ihfi 33" {E21}; §3§Jar::V:z§.;*}:* EZQEZ : B E E? S R E :
E~}®E'~§'8L%: §v£R.g§U$T§CEi y3;AGaNNA';::§}§;::§;L:-. "*7]'" - "
CRL,P.§'[email protected]?7G _;"..iZQ_:3 " ' BE:TwEE:\:; A' & MR K, C CHA§\?BRAS§{EKAR f'fA;§-LE, ' 1_ PROPREETGR CHEZNGRMA RA&iJ""§'§§j§\§i}:;§;T'E£31i:£, <:,/Q THE? CHANCERY PAVILION,"-._ ' :35, RESEDENCY RQ.»'3';£2~.,__ * "
BAN(Z}&L®RE»580 925.
FETETEGNER {By Sr: AJESH zffiaifwijsi Afesfii LEGAL} AND:
IX/LAX ;1YPERa4:;g__RK»:e:T ~:N'z:s:A. PVT. LTD"
A COM_PAN'3:' :N'c:}R§«:}§{AfrE:j UNBER THE: COMPANIES 'AfCT,' ' E._9E3«€"'r;"
:~:.zw§x:€; :?£G;sT2:Rg:;w OFFICE A?
2% :<f;<3QR"{A,_B5€,¥%g'i=: s':?A§: HYPERMARKET}, 4% 35;:/3 43¢; B;5':.NNERf}HA'}i"§A RQAD. ' ' Bs:Ni;;z:L.;Q';2,E~55@ _RE;?; BY.§'E?QWER OE' A'§"§'C)RNEY EQLEER, _ '§:x§R'€; ix. §3E§3%:'§§RASEKH&R, " §E%5x:E§c2:;..;f~.;mgx§g@ERwPR@§§R?1Es,
-I841 RESPSNBENT {By $Ev1;§..Nz§L§N§% 3§v'L%'EEGG'%?:f§A .3: SR: JGSEPB Am:=4:QN':?, ' ..§£}V8. -§--'a:aR E'V'§;'$ yoavaam 5: Ca; TEES {3§?iL§i3 FELEE} if/$.%82: CRQC PSAYENQ 'KI? §::%>gs'%§ ma '§;f\§'Zi"ERE E3E?;SCEE+;§)§E'~§£;3$ EN
-~~C:C.3I'2'Q=3:'§é§3j2G:€2 33$ ?HE C$Ei_§§%T 9? mg: ;><:§? §fi3i§L.{f§v'§:é'. E%'iE§~'§.YQE{.z%,LL, B;/¥'€C:ALQRE. :'r.-'/// .-1
-.-.» . .r~ /46?é'.<r4*///rrrrr//m 2::/2,¢;}é'f//¢?*/A;é;;/Z/%"'7"' ' THESE E}EZ'§'§'§'§Q§\E CQMENG SEX} E'4'{)R ;'3;§3§'%;""£§§E§EQ'x., T§'%§.§S §}.?'aY, '§'§*'iE SQEER? §'vL5XE)3EZ TEEEZ E'{}iL{:i'%?if§\§G: " ' 'V'. « C} R E} E: R in this peiiéorz 1: /' 5 482 pmcsedimgs 2:; C.C.NG.3f5jé+,§§$3/:逥A_Em learned KEV fiddle cammf the petitioner'.
2. Théfbréei' iiécfigiigje 'gesponaent filed at 1>rivate 1?-8 of the Ni.
AC1; the trial caurt 'geek the directed €&S€ baing registeréwsi agaitzsfithfi."pfiiitigner and issue «sf s:-;umm<:*:§:s to §f;gi:fi., it §s"':}j§ié'0:'§er ihai is caikd 1;: €§'L§<3S§§Q§} by the __pei§*i§Q'n%::°.;' 735 fat as 1:315 €i:%::r:p}.air:: is €0fi€€fn${i§ it :3 i?';'i:_VV.{:é;:s:§'_~vV.c>:'f"'éiiié §€S§:G§Ed€§1€ than the €i*~§Zi$§.3S€§ egiered §:1':é;§ Evierriarazzdurii ef U}'E%C§€fS3:8fi§i§:§ 2x2'§*:2"1 131% v ""*::{>:";:;0E§§§1g13€ 9:: 153.23%'? far §€V€:iO§§'{EE'Ii'§§ 53f {',*S§'£8§11 "'§3§r:<i7:: azié 21:: pzgrszgani 3:9 éiési Ekéifiél $25 §:<3.:f:1pEa§r:an% " ""§a;:§ Rs:.2,5§,GS;3&§;'~ {yam :::ré3:'sf:$ gm zakhs: mwams {has §§3i'E§'€&§T£ frea Séfaéézéabiés Sfifiiifity fifigssieiéi i:<> E'.h<:* ;%Cw /
-'-:1'.-:1:}k/x// "% azézéazsesi 2:rL:§ i:%:€ res::€::p§: ef ibis said a;z1(3:2:7:'é:'--?§:;:sg_ "5:§i:;§€£::1 21<:1«::1{>x}sE$dg€d by 333:: :3i(7{T'iZ§§S:i€Ci. :;h;<;%i :::<3r:3jg}§,ai:3a:r1: issued a 1/:=:>ii:':<:' t0}E%:e__;:'::§éz?:$<é1:§':£::'£E";i.;f::i§i_:2g ihe MGU zmd praying '::<>_v:i_«ef'L:r:€§<--At':':--«3 :fi€:}§:Z§'{ ;* Effart 2153.8 313% 1222166 to 1:316 ar'::3it:'3§:0r ané the a.::'}:z;se@'.»"._:§1e §éVgV;'é:I fiabiii§y :0 repay aihs secu:'i3i§' was aniered §::;~:g:§. § <%,?.2C3G9. Sade?
the said to be fiepssited with iéi'1eq5;1es were dqaesited with the Agent handed ever th€ ch€queSRé;<>_VVV:13eV'C.Qfi:;p'£3,§":'iant and Gut of the 10 Cheques, Q::é15g igfgizrqjas 'ié;:s:'.V.__E§&2€3 Eakhs was hansurfid by $6 ,g;:;::';:s;g:;. ._:§:1e yémaining chagueg <33': §§,"€'3€ffiZ8C£§§E} w€3:% é£:%'_%;:s:>éf}0u:*€§; and 131:3 was §<:>}i{:W€& hf; {E36 £e::;;;>§fe;:£.::a:1{¢ éasuiag 3. iggai izaziicé: its $1116 accugété G13 "..f »_ i:['_3:';..;E3§§g 'Ska accageé failed :2} réspazxd is :%2€ Eegafi _g1{3§:i{E€:. 'Eu: 3":i§K£?€'%J€f did 139%; défiy' ihfi éspgsii: sf €318 'ch$g::es megsiieaeé iii the €{}i'E3§§8.§§:§ aszééh izéae Escrcxw Agéni. AS zfhe Qhéiqzgésss. 222333' dis§':<;=m£::«u:*€d {>33 Ea}. i%3.28i'}9 ami é:E<::3 ::;.<:a7z.:3éé{i aiéaii §1{::?:: §;:;a}; €313 21m::>;,::':*é: zzzztktéz' §2'::%{i {:i3€s:g::€$ $1: *::E":s: aiarzipiazirlzint ds/sgpVitVe reitétivéng 'iifézét-.;i::':§*{.§::§s:. {ha aé<3mpEain21::i: had :13 :}th%:r' gs i;he1:1 E3 §§%é:7 C{}I3.1p}8iITi; 21;' 3 288 0? 'ihfi C1:':P.:§'-3i§s3g§:1:g§ '<;e§£%zé':_:€:j;.u';f_VsV £38 <:»f {kg Ni Aaéi; by the accuséfi. "
3' Leariiésd €<3unse'1' V"é_§fi.. gr the petitiensr submitted' me: have taken {E16 <:Qgni2:a1: r;_:§;'T'~ and fifiiiffi greceedings;'3;kf§ fi:iab:§.e Jfer ihe fssflewréng reasons. ' ~ ~ « y forward is that the <:h€qLVzxés_'£v's§'6-- the campiainant and these c§1€§:gz;€$. aéfezfé --:3b€:ai:;€ é b}; azniawfu}; means Cszityary to nof §§éé""'3;gr$er§:$:1t betwsan SE16 pariiss and .._ i3;séV:*€§§;*f§! 58 of the: ENEQL fie? comss Effie play, is gubméitefi thai {ha {rial sear': éié :29:
censifiéisr éhs Cfimpiaizizé: avermenig in fiaiaii bat hag §>a§:§€§ €316 Gffifif 5:~fi;ai;T1:g iizsié $36 agmpiaigé; W233 §€E'EE;S€d zmé 31:3 §i*i>C%:d;ure faiéevgeé £3 31329 cofitrazfi {G Eaw. E: E3 {idem argued €:,h'.:2i. *::n.{: ;:><>*:a:er €32" a*ii;§;:*::e:¢ E133 533:; signgd éhs: d{><:mz§e::§: aiéé SEE: pefgam Whig £"€3f€'§'§"€3§ ié} filif jxfi/%;; %%(-W%77/////////////«maAA ' // / 3 <?<>§:':§3E2;:Vi:":f;, éaefefs '€323 {ff}:/i§"'i', baiow wag ma)': "£::.::} 3:13: .213 pexwy sf zitieriéegé an béhaif sf '~-;:f<3;a~;.A}:§'®.:f:':3;ér:«€i, né::~:'i C€}:1§€}f":?;i€2I1 pm f<3:war<i §%1a«::,'1«i:1'1 %';:%iv'_€;h§:': Ch€C§LE€$ §'§3i6§1tiG§Tt€é in »_c0n1;.>:3';i;::§,, Eiave béen saparaie casfis réuggfsiersd'a::d~éE1€ :ria§ iiouré ceuid me: have 153126.23 f©f é(§ié;s§dera{i§n an tins basis 0:" {he is Eawziggd by £213 res§§nde:1t., '--:':?§f'<%r6:§$éc€€§a}.3s'«.:§:'§§.:{s§_;{¢j'Sectisns 219: and 220 Q2" the 7{f:'<:::-inestiezz and ii was €0::i€r1_;:i§3:d"'V%:§':e:j§;'.:§*;}1e 3,Cei't::;s«::':'.'2___a': the best ceulid have been pros€::Cute%:I"' :%:;§airi1s;t'».a ':c%1axin1um 0f three Cheques aniy and f<5zr_ this the tried Ceyrii, erder and precgediriigs 'am 'V-_iifiZ§1é~~--"»u:G be quashed Tha §€C?iSiG§'}S r5:}é:fr§§d Q; in fiaghsrt cf tha abeve su'bmi§s:i0::3 ars she (gem; 5 s<:<: $53; :99? Cr§£é.J$2i2Z§ %:;;§:":§;;§%8'%~%:§;i%{§{ £34, 2£}G8{4) Ka::LfiJ.§S?$ zggsm Kceg V 33%;? ..;'»Z:§£3§G;§5"'4'C:*E§L,:J.2243?
5, Lsarxééd sezmgei far" aha g:>€"{é"é§Q§E€r §he:'€f:;>re * »v.-----é;:*§:.:€§ ihaéi f3G'§§&7§E:'1S§8.i"*:di§i§~§ the S'§23;§§€ at WEEECE': {E28 (18.36 is mam; §€§:di:*:§; §€iTe::::%;~ éhéé {£32 z::{:«;:§*';, 1:326:62 {tam be E38 "
;:;:_¢;.;:¢_»x/r._»rm«;« _. _,,/A_%_.-.-.-.-2 ii'§:;>£:c§i§::€:1E; {Sr tthiss Qitszsri; is ir1t:i%ff£3:"<3 83: {his 313$? qzxeziah any g1:'{}«:é€é3d§:1gSe 6' G3: the Qiher h_2_3.;:fa(%;,_ :+:é£:*';w:::§,"e:>§~.,;n;;::::' Smtfiaiéna E"vIa§;egmvda fer the 'f_;€Sf§C\33:Cii§i*}f§1"8Li"'?h%f.::'é3_}l'€;:'§'§3"{/ $L2br::i':'€€d ma: Ehfi Casfi ":;3 §iI'<>S$.-- :
axaminatian 9:" the gtompiaigiégfifi. 3%/;&"bE'i, Lnigi ifihis sstags izhs accuséd has in i1%iS pstitien.
Pi wag th€r1_ ':V'*.-ibfififs i'€C€ipf cf the accused and even as £54331' égreement entered into beixarwfi iségégiéner was 01:13; eniifled £0 9:26 far {We p£~1}'"E§1€§}fS 0? 3}} 'E516 C§i€_:;;z2€S a:'§d*-.th3;:1 €X'§€HSiO:"1 of time Wfiuié be available is p§é'§tfi*:.i:§:';:7:§r subjec: {Q the pstiiienar having maids 333; 2:950 0f the chaqzzéss meizéécaned 152 '£336 $<s?'§:€,§€:::'€;:§;«:" &§:'€€§"E}€fi§ dated E4,7.Cs§ 21:25; aa {his ..A;:Q:1zfi.§%;Aé.a-£2 was 22:}? sctgmpiisd $37 $136 psiiiigyzezz "$36 Vf:3$s§..%¥£:r:CE€n"{ had, :23 géhaf g§ filflfi "ii: a.§§r<::a:::h {he é;:<;z:::'%:, % V. ..._..E:3%:Eev5 :1 /1% 2&8 C2196. faiiawmg dishnazzz 6? iZ':§'1€€J§£i€$. 4% far 22$ the ::t<>mpé3§;£5§:{:y £3? £336 pergerz Egzmiarizégg; iii} SE36: 57'///;;€ fi %7/7//////////////M2:5»-.a "MM. _ . ' xxzr /
--->974' ""E' {E€)§}}§§&1iI3E', st:::>m{3::§:ss 21;? c<;::{*;{2r~::es:i. $:,2bm§$s:<;»§"z:é;;::d€>_is iihaég the <':::>n":;3a'::y aigx} Car: §1§:1V€ 21:1}? sf :;-."::'° £>ffi<f:ia£$ ff; Sifigééii" $.10 Ehé &ffida§»*fi;»AA:E1fid §}fi%'€f§'*?}f. :>;:A?€,§:;fr:L:~::; V ' ._ was alas exeatuted autharisirig '€h€'f€f£3ft3 :10 errar can b6 £5::j§::;d evérg wi:Eév.:rEg§3§?:i. £6 the "
savory: :~;ia/t.Em€:1t :f$<:r<:r1:§,eci..._ fighe £E{;~U,;ff;_;beiQw is Qomceraed. ' ' '~ 7, fizsfasf as; {§'":é' ':§e::'&"§§si,:§;Vifcgffilingf mars than 9:16 C0m;;ia§:1:;:€;::;:é'rn&;?£, §1<::::::'n€d Ceunsei for {hrs resp0:1d.€.?i'f'féilézixjsii «:16 ._: hifs -.cQ;,1:':'s éaaision reported in ELR QQGE3"K§'i§~§':'V-§0Q§'~V%§'--jgjcizteiid 'that SeC*€i§r3 219 sf Cr,P,C:."i;§'r:@t' the preseedirigs 23,53 138 sf :he;ExE;'§,£:e:éarefi' réiiaiise was alga piassd 0:": the 632633383 émazzrt £3 éhe ease sf Endiaga Su3§ha:':§d E_:*;{s':§;1_:str'§'&$ 'ieffgzzsiieé V3 Emmsems Enfeyagiiaggi Lémifiefi ta «cfi@':)i2i$:';:§~i::§}i'§»§'§: Sfistiarz 228(3) :3? tbs €333. p:*<>2zi§::*§ iiizai, gi (2:33-..s5<i:ri€$ sf asig 30 ceansciad iegeihar ag 'ac: farm the ' Se:":.:"%1€ %:,:*a::$a<:i,i<}::§ mars €:ff€:3:«.::€:2: 33:13:": {me €§}§I§f:3§§{€d by 2 Same '§}€E"$i'3?§L E28 may 'fie chazgeé with an& aria} 25$ G516 iirizssl fa;/* €¥§'ii§"j--g' .'ES1§ii',§'§ éfiééizits, As far Cf5;§38.{f§§§? '4 (Zxii :%% .»€§f£g /%f''f/% ))7k//////////////xaa».-.«w. \ fis V -.< R '.
{:5 §"€§E'€$€fli'é§3g b<'~:§'<::::*a% the: trig} cauri an behaif {sf éhe Ci(}I'fipE11:}}f :5 {?{}f:{7€f:'EE€'=j. :*€§§:;1n::2£ £3 p1;:<::*,::i :;.::;11"%..s%a;j;:>;:
Cant: d§<:is1'Gz": rep:>r*é;€§ in AER 2069 2$G8(EG) SCALE: 554 2:9 C921:/a::iA'Vthai«_ii-h€.;{:€§f::§;2§::;}i'{fizz 336 repregemtaé by an €3fI1}3ff}y§': fir €\n:¥:j_:f:, é3§;'~ :e:; ':<3%{:i::,V am 19 €36 .:»:u.iho:€iz€CE and é~:,:1'£"*V:::W€r'€a:?§ vifi3 '§f€:fV5€§I3§ thé }J ._ _ E cempany either by .5. r€;:~:+6'i:;2ii:§'::,11€"'L._<3r biy""-*.;;;""Vp0w€*{ Qf atierzzeyz
8. _€§>_n sé§ré:3;§th__..§f,éiEié'"éf0resaid decisiens and subrmisiwfifis _::1a'{:E€«,- A'_W1¥3a3i:1eCE ceunsei £91' the :*espc.§1de1'ft'A'$'£\;:zgfét fe.: %:~£:_€ ggééfiitien being dismisseé. 9 . §i'a§2j$%ag A:7§:::;;é'~7heard baih gides. tbs Qniy pair}:
" r fmf ' %i:.e:1_§:§a:§,§r3;t§'%fi:":v * "xifhéihés-.»»tE1€ §3€i§J:iCI1€f E133 mafia (mi 3. £23.85 for to Q1233}: the §}i'é3{T€€§§IEg§S gaazédisrsg Essfsrs ' fieurt bsigw?
EQ, At iha €m§;:~s€*{,, 32%: has {:3 b6 mafiiésiértasi-Ecii thaéi é/he = .....-$336 is {ESE}? 3% the siage £3? reitztardizzg of evédsmte 223516 132% {:<}mp§z:1i1r;2:::{ hag airwsaarijz E3z3<--::: examiyzérfi in géhief Eféii 318 'N 52 ' 4//////xx %'/'//X¢'///,',";2-';;';;;;;;;;;;;;,/4/,z,r;:»/z:;;;;;m4m;;mW,,W,,,,.- -.-..,-- M £0. .. W_.- , ~,m_N»."wwwa«ywaw haisz :3 be <::*<}s:;s szxaminesd 33:'; the p€'3:.§iI§{}.§}%j§"> "§*3g::2:é:é.:1' Saitezmdiy, E/he é::*ia_§ aizauri'; 3:215; gerusfifi 's:h<: i;;:%?;.§n;3-Esziéyizéi? hag epimzd ihzzi {H63 fagiis SW03':hifE"'i3T1€3 §E§"}:f33_}§3é§§F"i§jf¥i'if§§€: 530:3 §I1d§{?{:'1{€S Cemmissisn sf ihézfi Gffehiie 3 N.E.A::1.; The sworgz s{ate3:i1§%§i*;ViLV_ §f {ha pQf.,%za_r""=:§'§"'atibrneyVI héléer, via, G37: Ch.a;1drasei;?i'3.}jf'afgsfih'§f:c§i.g:a§.;:s at this Stags that the $0 Cheques far Rs.2,5a90@,ea::s;» arm; 053:%..§:}i::;:;:~§¥%V%'éz Smd Ban}; JgC'R<:>ad., é::h'<§: Ear: rsheques, @5233' om: Ch6{i:;§ :§Ié:s honaureé and tha V dishonoured. Issuance of iegél. §?;:;%tiC€VVVV1iV(;{_L:iIri'<:«..;§r;<:§;sed is 3130 s§0ken to by the powér O£'é;'*£.}iG':'f1é§'._ , "'§her€f3r€§ 1*: sagas: be said that €33 €::<:)u:*s: .b€i1€;_w""%%'a.g_' csiésidarafi figs avsrmenft made in She €G'i7';"§pi§:';%}'":?L;"'f§S far as thsa C'GI1'{fE:i'1'U€Z3I'i "argsd €GI}{iE1'£1iE1§ ""--. iE::e §::@.;.E1p§%:$:::{:y 8f the pawar Czf aitfirnéjg h<}§§€:* is " {:=:>::.»'j:§::":'2€é§ E335: f's§€f}: Cé):,:s:?. dscisiezza :*€§€§:"€:& is by {he ._..§€a§fi€d Cazzzzssi far éhg :'t3S§Cz§':§€3"E'£i C€}E'§'i€8 ii; the aségisgisméftés of {7:::;::":pE.€z:::33'1t and am) fix? <3s:f:i; (tan 23%:/3 " /3 7//'/7//////////w ' ' 44'?) ///4/.;45{_4_4_»,> //2' ////J' 5:: 9 "
§<>2,::1s:i if} "iiE":€% C€}I13§J§Ei§"§}£?:,§E¥£,3S <:a::~;€: 0:2 ihai; g':"<:2a::'é{§"-.1,::ig<i:£i by 'ihéér ;j:se::3Zii<2:*2é:rr'§; étcéugfxsxsi. E35 far as; Se(:§§_::%zfzs; §-E $§.,;i;:3gi--. 22$: cf {the 833$, EKG CG§:C€?31€§i,,.,f;hiS §;:'é§{:':'::--. _m_ .;::.:'_:;sé" » 1 sf 'E'irucha:r:d0<:}r Murzghazi f§}pir::1i:3:g"TT.§x?i:';}Vés '::§f":t§v:€:1*§.3} Limiissd arizfi Qthsrg Vs Mada.:_:1:3J €mera1 Marchants gm 2€)'G'<:"a "£»:A R 5i30:Gfl'}= .3?-:as*;§:;~,e2a iihai {he grevisiazza of 3§{':{§OE} am 110:
appéécabié :0 {ha 138 sf ihe Nlékci. T yeceni desissien daeided of Ifidian Suiphacid II1dL1sgi::9iési" Internatienai Limited aftar to Sections 218, 219 and 228 sf 'iaken 31$ View ihaé: Ssciiams 23%,azfiii.V22§'"';1:".€,_,_«€X€:€pt§s:: ':0 Sestiém 218$} af {he SSCQQEE f22®{E} 9f the C:'.F.{Z1i §m"-asides ':§':a§ if ii: Q§3;€' .f~;}f'i.E}§€S Q? acig %3'~.?hiCh fsrmeé gas': 3%? iE";€ game §r2:§:§~;.a{%*§i{2:1 ':5 b6 ériai 3,: (5318 trial and mare €f}§f€IE€€ iéiazfg {E36 ass: {:@mm§i%€{E by £3513 Same parasaa he: may §.;1r:23rg§§:é xvii}: anfi irieé E353? €3'£€§'jx' :»:::{:h :}ff€:":<';€. Er; {E26 €jf2;iS{3 §€§{}§"€? ii, £32": §€é€§§S £1336? Efieihé Eiigiz Ce:.3:*{: ;5<}2:r:d iizaé.
E315': ::é{>:§2';3§2,2,i§2a3"§:i :Q2--1,{§ ggiiégrggitii %.32:zE; §%:;s:3§ {:§;€%§;}.,:€5s §E*§:T~,Z+§,:i3€§3_ E33; ////////////;/5;'//////////A0//7;;(//2E;% $}Z§ (-flikkk///////////anMMM :1 {E223 §;§3*£,Vii§<:s§:«:*:r C{;:12pa:1j}; 53:: ;3re:~is€%:";E1;1%i§:3}:1= we3.r:-6 §iSh€)§1{}'LE':f'€§ with E"€ffi.':':§'}i$ Eaaymami sis'?/{}§;3'*E=:E.f draws?' ané 211: 1:16 fan: {fhequés X/':?€1i'€% §t:23:f:';:*:;.V ' G? the aéompiaim 231$ 3&1 thg <§E:é:;L€:;:s"--..A§r¢E:4i<:j{;...L'_ wieiéz:
dishonaured 9380 fm'm€d_;:3_a:°t sithsr safizé'~f:*ai:Sé;.c%ii0::"'.:
and in 'fhfj Eight sf the Cour:
teak the afaresaifi v§.éé>'a,_ L2. §:":4_ fl1v__e the CG§'£1p}€L§}'13:
mgfltigfiigi. " '€;f'3"'VVV'p1'€s€I:€2ntio:1 W633 mfuriiigéh 'Step paymenf and {he :_,2§;:;§éus€Ci whe had ezqierefi 111:8 agréeifiéfié :>ai'§fiE§'-- and '£313 reiifiipt sf the ar:1§{§a::;f Qf §{$._;2;5Q;é30,G{}G;'« is 8280 afimittad by {ha a::.<:é;s_€c§_a:i:§;.sG 9330 £201; §afy::1€::': 3? the said afizazirsi is H €,E§<%_VV.«<t€§:}r§§};:§:i:£::é:. in thfi 8;bG'v'€ céfczzmstanses, in :12}; Vieéaf. i:'ij1e'"p€:i'I:{}r;er has 3%? mafia 922% a C333 {C23 this " k::s:;z,;_:*t 'ii; iéiiérférzé ass the eviééniza :8 in pmgregs and the Vcéémgiainafié Ems been axzasminefi in shisf 312$ ha has is " * ~.-§:§e t:f{}~S=S examérzsé by 'ms aézcusedé The: {?Qf§{Z€E§{i{§f}S i;s:k€:"2 $3}: {he p€i§i;§g>;':s:r'5s iémiiisei 5122:: 27933: Wei} Em': u:'§::E§i 5"" -""'-:'-'. .-'..-c-' ' -
/6; / //A £E3E:??::Z§ 6 %f/;ZF% W777//////////up»' ' ' ' - MM..- ////m ///////2' N .............. . .~Qxx\\\\\\\\\««« m§M\\%§ \§w «w§m §§\ R.\\ x\. \\