Karnataka High Court
Irshad S/O Abdul Salam Saudagar vs Mahadev Shivappa Chougale on 17 April, 2012
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
1:4 mg ééifiéé maga? :3? ;<Ama::?;:3<§ SRCUET a§;x:::;::«s 51? $%§"%ARi;':-1&8 rasygm ?:~%§$ mg 2??" ms; 5? mgza 28:2 EEFQRE "mg ;-:ss«:'g:_:* §'¥'§R§3i}S'E".¥Z§E $i§S%%,&,SH a...é;§»w: " % 'T ?v%,F,,é'sfi--§«;é,23Z5i3 29:5 §§§é_i,§;-- -1' 3 sq A' 431% 1 . .
».,m.;m3.2g.?é§»!'2e:[§:;_w2Q:L&g;g:;:3§g_g:;;g;..A ' :':iT&,.5::€2:a§23243 2am .8 EEf?a§€:_E§§xs E?<S?%§%@ S/C: ABCEUL sgazzaiv: gw~%gg%aé f7f~3§--5;§3$ "?'fE«§FsS; SC::':= :§%e:3TEA:;"$':;3':9.§§$.§»:_ ' ' . ma: ;«;3R"f"§"\:E§§ ié'\i€}'i"_%:%E'«R ?§=.R?«'%£ " ,1 ,E[:_? i 3," 1? i S . 5,, ' i§§g.§:::§..{€ iii'? %§:»A»r%% ..§'~:i%€%'i"'~'; '%.'%..jELf~f3';z'1\;1;,.,f%«'"1. , . % r-%,§7?;J; ig " 3: I'??? , '.. V '..
I ._3«,§"«§ ii:
Ea 5'%£B.i%i3E%,s' '§:«::€;;x;'¥;%A ?:%*4:5é.;<§;:Lg W'%45.GRg §i§:SE%i§§E$S ?a;:»'~G fis:;:<3;<~E.; "fag; %€;%T§<§¥2§,≫g '::f:%.'%";', ;e<:3:g:~:;'4«2:%:;.:z,, '° PK} ?\&§é'§'*s'»;'§*§'€§'ai'}3E',£ ;:s§a,:%%g§¥ {:9 5:35:
V~ ~, ' « 1 4;"
amfie %'«?i.&:%:v; §§aG;%as;§«:§ ' §\«§.§»<3-,=:;'§§:é§Sfi;{§£a§«:, grigg W3 ' '?3§33 33? ?"'??f' :és€l'"i fiafifiéééfi? "mg ?=- 25}??? §3§%S3E§ 551$ §"v€§;2£,?a§{':. §;2E§}f2{}{}%§; «%E ?" w 1 . y . , ' 5 aaggzimgg GFFECEJQ; mag? TRQCK égésggg »1--r~ -
'* 3 ' an %z..s:..,Fi T ?%¥':* fl ' 3?» r~ ' g . ,, ) .1» ; . .x., 2 ,, :,..«a.,§...=».,:?§;§«...3§*;%;, :~";i%§..?é."'f figfiwgaggsggkgg ygg {jg ;5:;,§§E ,,,.WW,M,ma/»a»~.
((!(t%6')za//////;y«»~WWW.' _ / ,...w.~..mmw.wmmmm«uwwwaw IV") ?E"?§?"E€3:§'a§ %:'i3R Cfi§V§?§§"2§§fiC§"i§€'s§ §%§"€§ §§EE%<§?'aI§ E?%§§"%§%§'~£CE?«E§?~i? 5J{'}§"«'%%3E?a§':§§1:"?E§D§'=L ?%§,:,2,3_Z;§§f .2 53 3. {:3 §}E?'a;''%§ EEN %i.%f.8zT%:E%é€E?€ §;@.;<;2?as§:;av;::?::: meg: $5933, QC{L:C{}G%< 3%.: §'*éE¥}%Z §~§@*"s"E:. §3%é§V,£§3E§'\§,£'«$§%R; BELGQUWL "" $§S"f:E§EL.G;'3:Ej?v'%.
5%'; : Sagmga £3, §,é2s€;<;:§§, A:£%§';'~V§eR §3?2.§.SHE%.;i&R%} 9% :v:2;§':-;§:§, ;x§x;.'§»...4 " _ :, §'é1&%f;i§EV S¥%§'\;'A??§a C%%Q:é{§£':LE I255: mjagyg mg: 3zg§::':§$§,, -_ . ; 'V ;ili.E$?\E,,?C§, %*€_§:"?§€§,é§\§§\f3,flzLE, 93$': §«<aL%Jé;:;9:;';:';»A'_, . 4 §2§'¢:§:€}?xé}"a; _ ,As§::2z 3223:; 'A:§§u@_;:g:s_£E <j;':*;.s;§"€;}. gm 3 :;;:::;§.; §..aA'5"';vT%:ELe;:.;;;:z' « _
4. ?:§:~;m%s§§:a;»:"3 3:52:11: §>a§,;<i5s2:§:2%;r:zé.<s;2;;2, ',&i§i;,'_.'§-TQR R2} y~'"""'"w fiésfia 7 3? W ,as;"§; §s3§3{.f'<§§'? mg §?'\;:*;.;A'-~:::";%--:..3;§33;2::i:{%§ ?;1§SE§ EN :=«:.z;,m:;:3; :::2:;;2a':>:;a sag ""?§a:~:*$:3::'*a§§ $§FE<:§§3<:, gigs? 'E"%AC§< £<:}z,:§2:%"»::;;.
V 5 E§'2§8Esi'x ;i%S§i§§;,§%,?\é:;E £'{§§'¢E§£ai'x§'{ mg L» ~»:;:: @§:»"~§é;§, W333; %3E§.%'3;ixé}%'€§K =2 S:??E'£:§;
s?{?' 444wa<wxz//xxzz,/z////;MMWmww ~ .
{M V} L%§'a§E"%""£ $iE§:§§§'=.3S ;:'i%.§':f§'€Ef;€§, 9 . éxgsg 942$ 232323 {?v€ES$E£3?z§ ?:Z§§'€€}} 2 m:.:3aE~§5s 522:2:
, ~E:"x§"§'E$ 52' {FE ?\EG;'i§;w§.é3é. §%Eil§'§é§$E§?. ; am': a; SAEé§~§A§%Ei?fl, Amt} é1?é{> "7?%i:.E.:R§Hé,;} 35:1 gags}: Sz$\LA§V§ :?§Gi£3.:*%'£};£3i:;--,, iasgas 28 Vgmgg GC£:%~§@":"E§. 8é}SE«?\§E:?_S;:3\§"aE§" . Rinasggz :5; {§'é"§~éER ;?ERI'»'% §%.,§;SE§'a§ES;§;;, $««~»f~ "?"71"'{f"
«:3 2 3""? L,&§*€E; s:'~s:v;:3::~«;,%@';:_g;--~.'.. ';§§.,C?;1£:xL§?"!§, 7""?
5 {"3 K3 fEfi§;§'»'§;'E%fé'\§E'%~" §%é:v;:§;>;§ c:é<::':;Gi;x--s,j:',V ; *5: svmsga, ::}££:B::§z:s:5_$:; &;;;;;§":Ci;;i':*;;?;E,, C},fi3C? ;9i3S"§:iI*£"§GR.E; "§§::'§-:;3;*:*;<'§&;;*as;.2;,.§;€.a2:5, iT}fi$'§F€§C"§":§<H;1?§;£xPU?%,.,.....__N. V 1' ;';';'?€ES?*:'3fx§$E§*»§"§":i:: mg:
;~"" :53; '§":~gE"v".;:fA.g":'«.fmgi:-§s::j_ :c>u%"?»§x; 3: mgf, gggggax £'2*£§%Rms*s£§ :::::»1;>g§\:s.s;;?:?:é.;:§:a;_.{;--§:?¢§§§¢:.g:?;,3§a;~ agzgzm $215 §:m:*%% --Vf,:;§§ §;r;*E ::%§* s:»§§"'22:'?:s3zag 'ma. agaggzsmzaéasi ;:".,x.*s::;2g§3;f2é3{::§"---9;::«$§'E§"':':<;'";»w.::.ia;e¥ ggzazzgsg {i3§'\§
- "' §aS§%.}_§%i;5K?'é§§§ C€}?'5?§l€¥é'§ §.f'?'§.f .5%?§5§ié£:%§'«§§' : Rf3J':.!§ §f%E?€fia%§§?, %'3s:."I':'afI} 53;; FEENEEEE :.;;§";.::i3"§';:'; .$§'i§¢5i.";i¢::%";;€"§j;&,;:,a::=¢s"§" "mg 3:;%:»:§;zs:? ,///'%r. {././Jitzzztzzzaaazz4444»,/mm?mnuww ~ / /z'4'//,»""'/ , MW ¢1N,w,flWWW¢mW»«Ww E1, S§~:.V§..§<,'v'éE§%;§§"fE;§%; :iS;'§g §<{}3"i}§i2~'"%\é?2i»§3'§§.i{ §--':{§;£E§ 4!}: 'fifififig $€€Z:C{§§:%§--'{ E5? :"x§i§'?'s§:Z §é§L%""5EL,; §,:'¥'3g S§'"§§is'§}§E§'%--§A§;{'3a§; $EL{f§.£Ji}§%'?. 2; ;<;§i.M:,;~«m.s»AAV::;as§%; zsaizaavm geaggégég @125; £}CC:%%1.;'SE?2EE$§ &A*£§§Cé§L'§"Z}%E;.__ _ &;a3*::2:' ;><i:s?:m":§RE, :*,A::ss,s:§~:;2r«:;2g@;E§_--~'--'»~. "
:<;~:;aas,&§L;R. """ _ "
j%%ESP'£3;§ii3*g"?%£7§"'E__ :. A s:z::':;§--~§:v;:"am3 ?,?'='%i§a'TJ%~§GL,,f%$\f; FSR"*R-§;.'; '- - «. 1 '~ :53 2735:; G'? :i2:;{;::.~£*;:, ;a@";:,.:%::~:*{>??%:%§'~--;f;aj':":é:3;\»=;§"§::"§"
mg wggzaa ::;:::3,!§3;2§a§ ?Ass§§=:_?é; --:xs:§az.{:}s*2-*3? :2::§;i2::aa 'mg Fiéif 3%: "§"?~§E $22.5? ?',.5%:£%C§< >:::3:«,éRj:*«:*:;'%._& %'v?,AC"%";""§E§.Q,»'i:€j?=«'§, ;::::s:z2£9:;;:g ,5; :*<:;§vE9§m3:;z"§":$..?:s"j:*::* ;'%'§§:,;3§';8z:v»§;+% .';z'\5E"'§";*% :?~§"?E"RES?
5% ?.;:\~ $3903.»: TEE Q,i*{'%"E G?' %E'?f_:':":'<:>:xsf1$2":Lag:E.é;:§§;_:2"?:€s?x:, mggg "§§~%ES am, '?§~%E CO:éR"?' :;§:.,,2:,z::?<§$s:é»~::-_' =s:'a:».:.::?w::xs$:__._ H 3% éavs £5:
:::::3;%e§:§s.35:$ are fiigcég aaagszs 'i'«%;:'"2v;:e§§§ as éiffiéiiaéfif agaéségi €323 a P72 Q."
""§:" :, :,»E§"=fiJ§?'§ Er: ?v%fi5,£§§%$Q$§§2§{.Eg'2§§§§ E
3 z3§2{;:§§ 3;; ihe féée 3? ?»€.;%,5;'I?,,, §§,%E{g5,é:;:?;.
("£3 , ' {W3 7:: :2--::;i2::;%a'é2 E .3.
V."L3;-_§'f'§.i§:;:'§«H?€GE,232'5%3gf2G§.§ am 22?5§;2§*@ ;::;
' %'rE%";;'fa§%§@$,2:§5:f2@€}§ am 2:8§2§'2:i}§§ gas by ifééi m :33?
$Qé:'§§"§?§ E:
44zM4aa//1;,///M § , . ..,.,~,M 5,! ?
(Y3 §;'{}?'%"'é§€§"':§§€§i:":m"': a.r=:§'2€:'ea§, §§"?§ii§'E§" hag gaiéaé :;:u&s;~:%a:*: E5:
ééaéiiiéy, 4? C{}:§€'3S€§ fa' 253$ Efigurer f:§':a>A § gsasiéy wag €@§::e fram 3&3" iamsafy 2G§S..?jf3,_4'j?i.{§'§m'--.:;:¥$E4{"%:,§3:§;%;"'2 ?'»~..} 885 iii: 32 §'iC?i§§'St %~:*§:a2:ie\;'.§=%:", a: Q@:?@ m;;:~g 2§;3€%?§52§{T~§, :~@%s~::_a:::. ;szT;:y%%.g;a;gg éqgrceg §;:§a%::r"z§s:%:§ have Vé;::sé2§.?§: ?é'%'-g%é%z}'§n£'$mefii ${:§§2;%€§2sai%s:": 5:": Ejsth 9:'; 252$? i§"§€ zfaimami ;'vw.<:;%«3@;;::i::§2aa':25 5:55 3'1::f€5.e§4;€;r§iV§€:é'€%: :§:4:%%V mmems «£25:
; .r:'~ > éie %a:s:5:":§r::: §"5;.a£i_.%;3:*'§~§T%.' S€5'3f""§"§V'E€.f3i--":§v."' "i:3€%€:E{}f' bass: agwggesi g:§é's':':as:a3§;'a:
'§*'§éf:";:\.é'§€;'%3§V %"E§Eé'£§ 3:"; t%':2:» ggma "%'":"i%;:.:s2&; §':'_r_.°f§<:§f §:{:€é*é';i,:§ae*:§3:f%<;z2 sf §::;.3;2§;8:§i%g'w §:;%%:%": §n:é;'§$é1;
?*§V;\:§{;&:G;:2:a;§2a%§e §'%*'§C?i§:'"<-3_V%:.;s§v";«§§%'f';f"f£2§'€?':€E§§ aréd Seam? hag %§$€:':EfS§~;*?i 333% 3% §%:':":%.} 5&3? "%"s*§§:;a;s":a§ flag iakga :;éé&;§§::§€;§ :a%:*z*::"~5s::;:;.::%:§€;:: Q? $33,: Z?§,3§:ES'~ :;<;§%:%: H 3 ' , (W(-Vfll//x///1////a»wmwAW 53 fa: sf :§°:;= iagwasés ijsrrzgfiamg $3 agnaermég Q mgigérgaséi giaéeas' 3325?, ifée a<:C%§efi% §'%§€ff ascwfgféfi €%S:3£2 §"E§£§§'E%,. is :28: as eya wimassea, no 4-:-zrxx//////a);%/flfl Staiazgi &g téée i:§a%::é&§2:§ have 5G;"§i§£' f":'§i %§3{7:'§€jf'§"<€*§ at 33,353 %:?2€;23 5:3 5 aaziderzcg as raggré ta.'-ihéflsuf?:§§4:2éT%:.:§i,A3£<:_§::§s3:':{é;'--. }{é*;~, véezzxg $3; 5% i~I33£§é"£"%€.3, I féw <:az2é"¥:>;:"%.f:§:::fz if Sag' U} mag,s:sss'T;1:;;%é:;}?2a§§55:25 2§.8é2,f2§$§ fiéeé by ihe di:;~m;:;se£§ .é§3§§" fV§;~?;~;é.?€:>s.232é3;"2§E.S 22?55,f';ii i fig?-é<_§ §3§*"=f%3é':§.§;3§§*:*2'5s;'éf:§"'g3E98 a§§<:.> ééfimégsefi' V'7ff».§:;§'§§'%'§2é"traésferréé is the °'§":*:":3;;::a;i 'mwmmm iii mm»?
i:':f;:§ £17,:
M ' z4zmw,,4.,,,,,##, /37 /,,