Karnataka High Court
Dr Suresh K N vs State Of Karnataka on 7 June, 2011
Author: H.G.Ramesh
Bench: H.G.Ramesh
1
IN THE HIGH eeuer or KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE rm DAY er' JUNE 201232'
PRESENT 'i"'"i
THE HONBLE MRiJ.S.KHE3HAR, 4_
THE HONBLE MR.JUs'riei;. T
Writ Appeal Nes.439-4 ie 4402 /20 ii A 4403j
Between
1. Dr Suresh K N V .
Aged about 39 year"s_ _ 1
is: PG, M S opthainioioggz'
JJM Medie'3r.1Co1le'ge-if - *
iVIediea1;~vG'ffi§i'er, _
Rangapu 1"a5:V.'v_Tip'i1:1'I'_ 'I'€i1u1§; I; .
T um13:ur.;Di.stri'et r
Dr J a§fa{t:1a1a7':_ ' < 'h _
Aged about i 3ze"ars"" --- '
1 S? ye ar PG, 'D V.' 'Pediréxtries
MMC «, _1\i/iysore,' Mecj_1ica1 Officer
; 'CHC, Aehoké; Puram, Mysore
i\)
3, in ffiehok, Ageriiabout 38 years
A" =. 18? yea Diploma Orthopedics
~ _ Kerripegbxvda Institute of Medical Science
Belagbldf, Sringapatna T aluk
1\/I__é1r1::1y"a District
<1. Dr' i)eepak S V
, "3Aged about 38 years
i 131 year, MB. General Medicine
VIMS, Beliary, PHC, Jigiriehaiii
Kadur Taluk
Chitradurga District
5. Dr Arutna C Mi Aged about 3?' years
ES? year, Mi). Anesthesia
PHC, Aradeshariahalii
Devarzahalii Taiuk
Barigalere Rural
6.
10.
2
Dr Niranjana B Mani Banakara
Aged about 38 years
15' year, MS. Orthopedics
JJM, Davangere
PHC, Thadakanahalh
Haveri District
Dr Santhosh Guciigere
Aged about 36 years " ._
18' year Diploma in GyI1eeofQgy:f* ..
Adiehunchanagiri Medical co11e'ge
Bellur, PHC, Thavaranfi aJ"}i_ Ham-
Savanur Taluk, Haveri D'i:§t1*iet V
Dr Ravindra Naik .
Aged about 38 ye'arTs_A 1
W year MD. Pathology _ _
KIMS, Banga10re§"P'HC', Sampige «V
i
Dr Pa;rfl:i'asara"yhVy'-._}.__V _ ' '
Aged abd11t";37year"aL.' .. " V
M S _Rari1:::iva.h"'Me'di"Ca1 Callege
Ba1f1ga_101'e, W'/.at.PHC,J..K R Sagar
Mandya Di's3tfi'et . '
' D'vr_(}irixsh N
'?Aged about 4vO.«-years
' 15$ yeai=a}\/1.8. ENT
V' 3 Medical College
L Aeazigaxoagxv/at BBMP
' _ V Ba:;g'a_ie:*e
(By 'Sriiffiaxvrivarrna Kurnar, Sr. Advocate for Sri B
V adv. ,)
Appellants
M Irishad
' --,,;3:r3.€i.'.--'
State of Karnataka
Department of Heaith aria Family Welfare
Vikasa Seudha, Didambedkar Veedhi
Bangal0re~ 56000}
Rep by its Prineipai Seeretiary
i~":l*'~
id
The Commissioner
Health and Family Welfare Services
Anandarae Circle
Bangal<:>re~5600{}9
The Director of Health and Family Welfare
Direeterate ef Health and Family
Welfare Services, Arlandarae Circle
Bar1gal<:>re~560009
Rajiv Gandhi University of Health
Kim T Block, Jayanagar, Ban'galQre.-*4
Rep byits Registrar '
Dr Laxmikantha s/0 la'temn}<ar1athl_
Aged about 39 years _
Working as Med:i(l:al_ Office_r _
Primary Health Clerltre '-- _ 1 V i _
Thyrnagondlu, Nelarnanglala T'al1:k:_': __
Bangalore _ Rtlral :Diét'1*iet _ l -. 7 ~
S/0 Dr T1E1_ippeéavafily Gbkhale'
Aged' abeut .years A H
Workirig' _l\/I5edical~ .Qffic_'er
Primary' Cefitre __
N0r1avir1ake_re;~ Tiptur 'Taluk
Tumkur District; Turnkur
'_':L'< ._ll}la.rilal -
S/'of'late._Lakshma Naik
" abqut 35 years
._ %Vv'brl'eir;g.Vaé§ Medical Officer
' , lCon1rr1r}.:1ity Health Centre
Hirjsaye, Chermarayapatna Taluk
Haslsan District, Hassan
Rashmi W/0 L S Prashanth
Aged about 35 years
Working as Medical Officer
Combined Dispensary, Vijaypura
Deyanahall: Taluk
Bangalere Rural District
16.
5
Dr Amanda Pvianehara Zulki
Aged about 37 years
Working' as Medical Officer
Taiuk Hospital, Basavana Bagewadi
Bijapur District. Bijapur
Dr Shashidhara D R
Aged about 36 years
Working as Medieai Officer
Community Health Centre
Kushalanagara, Kodagu Dis,"ric't"A e_
Madikeri
Dr Manjunatha H
Aged about 39 years »
Worldng as Medical Offieerf.._
PHC, D.S.Ha11i N ' ' '
Chitradurga Taluk A. _
Chitradurga H
Dr
Aged ''
Working a_S;Medi'eaI'~OffiCer A
C:.hikkodi5'Di_:§t17iCt._"~.__
Dr rummaht%jAar:;:jfi_'Ae"D'M
Aged about 39 years'
Werking Medical Officer
._': yam a' "e-ndlu
V Chikkaballapur District
" T "'C1h'§1;kaba11apur
; _rVDr S
"Aged about 40 years
V'v'arE;ing as Medical Officer
A 'A Aiakapura
Goxvribidanur Taluk
A Chikliabailapur District
IX.)
§\J
Chikkabaflapur
Dr Omprakash Ambure
Aged abeut, 38 years
Werking as Medical Offieer
Bx.)
Lu
21:1
25.
26.
. A_ 27;
[wt
xi}
PHQ Peta Ammapura
Yadgir District
Br Prabhuswamy H P
Aged about 4?' years
Working as Medical Officer
PHQ Rariganathapura _
Charriarajanagara District . ._
Chamarajanztgara A
Dr Shararia Gowda Chan._drasl;.el{ar " V .
Aged about 37' years O» ,
Working as Medical Office:-'._
General Hospital", *Devadi1rg.a = . ._
Raiehur District,"Rair:huri.' ; " V'
Dr Arur1kumarD
Aged ab0uJ'_35 ye.ars_ ' A _ I "
VR/orlijngg Medical Qffieer7_j~_ '
PHC, .
Kolar Distriet;?._KOlar_ K
O 'O
Aged abe._ui;'VV38%y"eVa1*s__ _ _
Wiorlaing as lV'l.edical__ Officer
Pl-lC_, Moolur _ _
Hunsur Taluk, ' .My.s'Ore
-:.,Dr_u'Sadliirrdrariath s R
_ Agledllabout .35 years
VVQrl{ing' as Medical Officer
i{§>l.adeVi, Kolar District
l"'Kelar[f_
BV; Ravikurnar
Aged about 38 years
AA Werkirig as Medical Officer
_,-PHC, Ballalasamudra
Hosadurga Taluli
Chitradurga
Dr Somashekara Kabbera
Aged about 33 years
werlirngg as Medical Offieer
3?}.
3}.
Lu
tn}
7
General Hospital, ivluriirabad
Koppala District
Koppa}
Dr Siddappa Balappa Naika
Aged about 36 years
Working as Medicai Officer
Government Hospital
Ramangar Tahik
Joida, Uttara Kannada Districtr-it 3
Dr Santhosh Kumar » _
Aged about 34 years V
Working as Medical Officertt'
General Hospital} .Aurad----~
Bidar District, 5
Dr Shashidhar V Vi
Aged about 37 years
PHC,..Dagiri1a_katte' {V M y
Davaiiagere Districtjyvs. :
I)_ay.aria,g_e"re--i:;;_ ~ 'V ' it
Worldngi as._1\"/Eedicalg Offic'§i%.\r, .. h it
fir Ai'"uria'"'£"atji'i~ _ _
Aged about
Worki_ng as" Medical-»Officer
_ General Vi-Ioshpital, Kudligi
.. «.g.Be1}ary '
S A
"Aged 35 years
as Medical Officer
A Gene_rai' Hospital, Jagahir
" Dayanagere District
Iivérfariagere
. Verikatesh M P
Aged about 34 years
Working as Medicai Officer
PHC, Y.N.Hosakote,
Pavagada Taluk
Turrikur District, Turnkar
36.
39.
40.
Dr Ravindra R Aunturi
Aged about 37 years
Working as Medical Officer
PHC, A.K.HaH, Belgaum District
Belgaum
Dr Devaraja G N
Aged about 35 years
Working as Medical Qfficer
PHC, A.V.Kottige, Hiriyur Tai1;k.._ A'
Chitradurga District ' D' A. "
Chitradurga
Dr Rarnesh V
Aged about 36 yegrrs _ V -. A
Working as Mediciai Gfficerf
PHC, Dornmasangirgi '
Aneka1Tahi}:,_ 7
Dr Rav'irt(1_réL_ Patiilei
Aged 'a_ba:m;_36"yearsf- Ac '
Wsrrkirjigfias e.diea1._Offic--er. V
PHC, Hiinasikatte _ _'
Belgauni D'isi~riAci,4ABe1g2_1um
Dr Shankar Nayak._N'= "
Aged" ieborit 38 '3:e'a1:s;'
;"vV0rking~-.a_s 'Medical Officer
_" VMadiha1.1_i_ Harapanahalli Taiuk
V _ Davanagere District Davanagere
'V Maliappa N agappa
* ' ---.crAge'd"_'8.b'QLit 39 years
A ¥VQ:'kir:.g as Medical Officer
2 Hampasagara
Hargaribommanahaiii T aluk
A ._Be11ary District, Beliary
Vishnurrrurthy H Y
Aged about 36 years
Wcrking as Medica} Officer
PHC, Bharathi Byle
Mucligere Taiuk
Cihickrriagahir Distrier
Chickmagalur
44.
45.
46.
47.
Dr Basavaraja Oiekara
Aged about 40 years,
Working as Medical Officer
PHC, Kadararriaridaiagi
Byadagi Taiuk
Haveri District, Haveri
Dr Sridhar K G
Aged about 35 years I '
Wbrking as Taluk Health Officer .. 3 4'
Chikkanayakanahalli :
Tumkur District, Turnk_u"::__
Dr Chandrakaritha K N
Aged about 39 years
Working as Medical' Officer' " ' .
VENLAC District Ho.spitD{aii'
Mangalorea. _
Dr Sharirn1§ji£éippVa_ Si; " ''
Aged §a'b:5a1t1'4~{3_Vyears} V ._ '
Working Meiriicaivilfficer
Cmnm _d11ity" i%;IeaIth"Cerif1"c"-- ' "
E3yad22.gi;"£§Iayeri D_isirict,j Haveri
Dr'Dearendrd1;rp2r
Aged" about 43 years
:.WQrki1"ig..as Medical Officer
_" ' _K0n2;r1d1_lr_ V
Sfiiindgg District, Shimoga
. A iarirrinrareja M
"'Vi;Aged7abeut 38 years
A 'xflfgiriiirig as DPMO
Be1i._ary District, Beilary
* ._DrNTriVeni K
..Aged about 38 years
53.
Working as Medical Officer
PHU, Krishnamurthypuram
Mysore
Dr Marijuia.
Aged absur 43 yesirs
Werking as Medical Officer
~12
Ex)
10
Genera} Hdspitai, Kunigai
Tumkur
Dr Babu Rae C
Aged about 44 years
Working as Medical Officer
PHC, Nirria, Humnabad Taifrxk j;
Dr Bramarambha T S V
Aged about 38 years '
Working as Medical Offiégeerr.
PHC, Muguru _
Chamarajnagarvi3is_tric'td if 1. V
Dr Kulakarrii K S O V V V
Aged about 38 years.
Working' as;..,MediCa1g O?ffiCer"f ., A'
General 'Sa:t(an1_axij«* . V
Haveri D,iStrict'; Haveri' '
Dr' atHi%i'- " 9
Aged ab0i1t...{LO.eyear:3V__ _
Wm-king as 'Medi.«r:_a'i. Officer
General Hoes p1+ja1. K:R.Pet
_1\_/Iaridya Di.strie't.,_ Mandya
" Manj uri'ath...B'
' Aged _ahQut 36 years
" V W'Q1'kii':g Medical Officer
V.PFIC;,_Haie'bidu
, V Hassarrrbistriet, Hassan
, Dr Yegananda Reddy N
Aged about 37 years
Working as Medical Officer
if «General Hospital, Kudligi
' ":Be1Iary District, Beliary
Dr Kaggaiageudar S M
Aged about 37 years
Working as Medical Officer
Urban Health Centre, Doddakeri
Hub1iTaiak, Dharwad
ll
58. Dr Kishore Kamar Rao
Aged about 43 years
Working as lvledical Officer
PHC, Irma, Karliala Taluk
Udupi District, Udupi
:39. Dr Kadarakoppa P V
Aged about 40 years
Working as Medical Officer
PHC, Shelawadi
Dharwad District, Dharwadj'
60. Dr Mahesh Kumar Y N V
Aged about 40 years '
V»/'orkir1g as Medical Officer"
MTHU, Hunsur __
Mysore District, vll\@/l3,I§5OY€A 1.
oi. Dr Parameshwarappa._R.." 1
Aged abou_t'4«__2 ye'ars"»¥ ~
Working_'Vas"t:;District 7["tiberCul*o'si.s....:
Officer; Harlot-if [)isfo:_ict, lfaxferi »
62. D.r'*Nagal:afiy<:aww .G'= . p
Aged aboi.;t..33ye.ai'a.,. -- .
W'o_r1§3'_ng as I'CiDEIyl\kl.edical Officer
Distric t, Health f<'i:_ Farriily Welfare Officer
Mysore =
" A. " Respondents
_ Harariahalli, Advocate General a / w *'«Z_ele.rapp--a, AGA for R~l to 3;
' .Sri._N.K;R.aH'ie's'h, advocate for R4; 1 lD.N.Na1r_1jiur1da Reddy, Sr. Advocate for Sri Reuben Jacob; a(fl'x=;S., for other respondents) ., A' 'l'liese Writ Appeals are filed under Section 4 of the '-Rarrtatalia High Court Act praying to set aside the order passed in Writ Petition l\los.l5539 to l55z'l2/20ll[E3Dl\l) ..,.r:lated 31/O5/2011.
These Writ Appeals coming or: for preliminary hearing this day, Chief Justice made the following:
L2 ORDEZR J.S.Efl1eha:r, CJ. {Oral} Learned counsel far U16 appellants, aftej for some time states, that the: appeflzmtsz withdraw ibis instant Writ appeafilisui '4 AT 3 Dismissed as withdrawn. MisC.W. app1icati0nSV__fi1.§;xc1 .;;;1'@f1:g .xy:ifi appeals do riot S'LJ.I'Vi"'§/.6 for gficount of the dismissal of the I The said Misc.W. applications "at?
Qggfg §:ar' § Qfifiei Eiififigg Iugiex: yes {:10