Patna High Court
Munmun Pandit vs The State Of Bihar on 3 April, 2019
Author: Mohit Kumar Shah
Bench: Mohit Kumar Shah
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6489 of 2019
======================================================
1. Munmun Pandit Resident of , Village -Newdelliyan Sambikapath P.S. Dehari
on Sone District -Rohtas posted at U.M.S.Baghaila District Rohtas
2. Pramod Kumar Tiwary son of Yugal Kishore Tiwary Resident of Village
Kanchanpath P.S.Shivsagar District -Rohtas, Posted at M.S.Darihat District-
Rohtas
3. Chhote lal singh son of Kedar singh Resident of Baghi P.S. Rampur District-
Kaimur posted at Gautam M.S. New Dillian , Dehari ,District Rohtas
4. Birendra kumar Gupta son of Brajbhushan Prasad Gupta Resident of Village
-Jaipur P.S. Sasaram District Rohtas posted at Sarawagi M.S.Dehari District
- Rohtas
5. Akhileshwar Kumar Singh son of Bashishth Narayan singh Resident of
village -Munji P.S.-Karakat , District -Rohtas posted at P.S.Nawagarh
.Dehari District-Rohtas
6. Vinod Prasad @ Binod Prasad Son of Damodar Prasad Resident of Milki
P.S. Sasaram District - Rohras posted at M.S, Jamua , District -Rohtas.
7. Alim Ansari Son of Moiddin Ansari village Nawadih P.S.Amjhor District -
Rohtas Buxar posted at .M.S, Akabarpur District -Rohtas.
8. Paramanand Son of Dasarath Ram Resident of village -Dalelganj
P.S.Sasaram District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Tendua Dusadhi ,Dehari
Rohtas.
9. Suryanath singh Son of Jairam Singh Resident of village-Pokhraha
P.S.Nasaeiganj District- Rohtas Posted at M.S.Tendua Dusadhi , Dehari
District - Rohtas.
10. Gopal kumar son of Sheo Murat Resident of New Dillian ,P.S.-Dehari
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Bheria Saura ,Dehari , District - Rohtas .
11. Vijay Kumar son of Rampravesh Prasad Resident of village -Biseni P.S-
Akorhi Gola District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Bhaluari ,Dehari District
-Rohtas.
12. Md Eqabal son of Ms Shahban resident of Station road Dehari on sone P.S.-
Dehari District - Rohtas posted at U.P.SLALGanj, Dehari District-Rohtas.
13. Amar Nath Pandit son of Sarju Pandit Resident of village-Itimha
P.S.Nasariganj District -Rohtas Posted at P.S. Tarbangala District -Rohtas.
14. Umesh Prasad s/o Rajdeo Ram Resident of village - Bhatouli P.S. Indrapuri
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Shankarpur Bardihan, Dehari, District
-Rohtas.
15. Saroj kumar son of Laxaman Prasad Resident of village -Darihat P.S Darihat
.District -Rohtas posted at M.S.Darihat ,Dehari District Rohtas.
16. Md Sohail Ahemad son of Mohd Shakur Resident of Nilkothi P.S.Dehari
District -Rohtas Posted at .M.S.Maharajganj ,Tilouthu District- Rohtas
17. Shamin Ahemad son of Samsuddin Ahemad Resident of village-
Kamarnganj, P.S.Dehari District - Rohtas Posted as M.S Tilouthu District -
Rohtas
Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019
2/8
18. Sunil Prasad son of Murali choudhari Resident of Maharajganj P.S.Sasaram
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Tilouthu District - Rohtas.
19. Sheogovind Sharma son of Chandradeo Sharma resident of Nawahatta
P.S.Nwhatta District Rohtas Posted at Girls M.S.Pathkaulia, Rohtas .
20. Kalim Ahemad son of Samsuddin Ahemad Residentof village-Kamaranganj
P.S.Indrapuri District Rohtas posted at Urdu M.S.BOYS Tilouthu District
-Rohtas.
21. Vinod kumar singh son of Dasarth singh Resident of village Tilouthu P.S.-
Tilouthu District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Chandanpura District - Rohtas
22. Sanjay Kumar son of Yamuna Singh Resident of ward no 27,Nagar Parishad
Colony P.S Dehari District- Rohtas Munger posted at M.S..Sheoganj District
Rohtas .
23. Ravindra Nath son of Dharam Raj Sharna Resident of Sonbarsa P.S.
Dargaon District-Rohtas Posted at M.S.Laxaman Bigha Dehari ,Rohtas.
24. Rambali Prasad son of Balrup Prasad Resident of village- Bhatouli
P.S.Indrapuri -Rohtas Posted at M.S. Durga pur ,Dehari ,Rohtas .
25. Ajay kumar son of AnantuPal Resident of village Dhantolia P.S.Dehari
District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Durgapur ,Dehari District - Rohtas.
26. Ajit kumar Choudhari son of Harihar Choudhay Resident of Village
-Jakhibigha P.S. Dehari District Rohtas posted at M.S.Tetrah District -
Rohtas
27. Shaista Khatoon Sakhawat Hussain Resident of village- Barah Patthar,
Dehari, District -Rohtas posted at Rastrya M.S. .Dehari District-Rohtas
28. Sanjay Kumar son of Thakur Abhay Prakash singh Resident of Gehua P.S.
Chand District - Kaimur posted at Deo Narain singh M.S, Makarai Dehari
29. Rajesh Kumar son of Sharda Prasad village -Mangawarlia ,P.S. Rajpur
District - Rohtas posted at .M.S, Khairahan District -Rohtas.
30. Pradip Kumar Singh son of Mohit Narayan singh Resident of village
-Mirzapur P.S.Tilouthu District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Dhelabag , Rohtas.
31. Anil kumar Verma Son of Rambansh Lal Resident of village-Vishunpur
P.S.Rajpur District- Rohtas Posted at Deo Narayan singh M.S.Makarain ,
Dehari District - Rohtas.
32. Md Nashim son of Md. Sarif Resident of Barah Patthar ,P.S.-Dehari District
-Rohtas Posted at M.S.Manikpur , District - Rohtas .
33. Kumari Kanchan Mala Son of Jagdeo Thakur Resident of Nilkothi
P.S.,Dehari District - Rohtas Posted at P.S.Barah Patthar ,Dehari District
-Rohtas.
34. Md Gulam Sarwar son of Md Jalaluddin resident of Nilkothi , P.S.-Dehari
District - Rohtas posted at M.S.Ghongha Diliyan , Dehari District-Rohtas.
35. Sri Bhagwan singh son of Ram brichh singh Resident of village-Thakurai
Parasia P.S.Nasariganj District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Chilbila ,Dehari
District -Rohtas.
36. Gopal ji Prasad S/o Ram lakhan Prasad Resident of Kalisthan P.S.Dehari
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Sheoganj , Dehari, District -Rohtas.
Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019
3/8
37. Rajiv Ranjan Pandey son of Sharada Nand Pandey Resident of village
-Milki P.S.Dinara District -Rohtas posted at Girls M.S.Darihat ,Dehari
.District Rohtas.
38. Israr Ahemad son of Manur Ahemad Resident of Amiyawar P.S.Nasariganj
District -Rohtas Posted at .Girls M.S.Darihat ,Dehari, District- Rohtas
39. Jagdish Narayan son of Ganesh Ram Prajapati Resident of village-Tirgun
P.S.Dehari District - Rohtas Posted at Girls M.S Darihat ,Dehari District -
Rohtas
40. Rajiv Ranjan Kumar son of Rameshwar Pandey Resident of Maldaha
P.S.Sheosagar District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Shankarpur Bardihan , District
- Rohtas.
41. Kamal kumar Ranjan son of Pramod Kumar resident of Balia kothi
P.S.Nasariganj District Rohtas Posted at M.S. Maudihan Dehari , ,Rohtas .
42. Shahid Sallal son of Taiyab Ansari Residentof village-Nilkothi P.S.Dehari
District Rohtas posted at Isalamia urdu M.S.Dehari District -Rohtas.
43. Imteyaj Ahemad son of Md Nizamussin Resident of village- Jakkishahid
P.S.-Sasram District -Rohtas Posted at Isalamia urdu M.S.Dehari .
44. Malti kumari Daughter of Kameshwar Prasad Singh Resident of village
Torana P.S. Sheosagar District-Rohtas posted at Isalamia urdu M.S.Dehari
District- Rohtas.
45. Isalam Ansari son of Gulam Rasul Ansari Resident of Kudawa P.S.Sasaram
District-Rohtas Posted at Isalamia urdu M.S.Dehari District - Rohtas.
46. Gayatri Kumari daughter of Gajadhar Choudhari Resident of kudawa
P.S.Sasaram District- Kaimur posted at Islamia Urdu M.S. Dehari ,
Dehari ,District Rohtas
47. Mostaqur Rasid son of Sarhuddin Ansari Resident of Idgah Mohall P.S.
Dehari District Rohtas posted at M.S.Tippa Nauhatta District - Rohtas
48. Om Prakash Gupta son of Lallan Prasad Gupta Resident of village Uradhiya
P.S.-Karakat , District -Rohtas posted at Indira Awas P.S.Bisanpur Nauhtta .
49. Pravir Kumar son of Yugul Kishor Ram Resident of Tilokhar P.S.Chutia
District - Rohras posted at M.S, Piparadih , District -Rohtas.
50. Shanti kumari Daughter of Vijendra kumar village-Haribanshpur P.S.Dinara
District - Rohtas posted at P.S, Ambedkar Nagar ,Dehari, Rohtas .
51. Nand kishor singh son of Brij Bihari singh Resident of village -Goshaldih
P.S.Suryapura District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Dharahara ,Dehari Rohtas.
52. Tauqeer Ahemad Ansari Son of Abdul Hamid Ansari Resident of village-
Banauli P.S.Chenari District- Rohtas Posted at Sarawagi M.S.Dehari ,
Rohtas.
53. Rameshwar Prasad Gupta son of Gurucharan Prasad Gupta Resident of Mani
,P.S. Nokha District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Bharhuriya Bazar ,Dehari ,
54. Rajiv Ranjan Upadhyay son of Kunwar Prasad Upadhyay Resident of
village -Mangrawn P.S.-Nasariganj District - Rohtas Posted at M.S. Tadwa,
Dehari District -Rohtas.
55. Byakhya Narayan son of Brij Nath singh Resident of village- Pokhrahan P.S
Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019
4/8
Nasariganj District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Barawan kala Dehari ,Rihtas
56. Vijay Kumar Son of Kamata Ram Resident of village- Ghari, Sohagi,
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Baeawan kala , Dehari, District -Rohtas.
57. Manoj kumar son of Laxaman Prasad Resident of village and P.S -Darihat
District -Rohtas posted at M.S.Dahaur, Dehari District Rohtas.
58. Gyan chand Gupta son of Khobhari Ram Gupta Resident of East Mohan
Bigaha P.S.Dehri District -Rohtas Posted at .M.S.Madhurampur Dehari
District- Rohtas
59. Jagdish Prasad son of Dhanpat Sahay Residentof village- kenwa , P.S.-
Chainpur District - Rohtas Posted as Town M.S Dehari District - Rohtas
60. Dharamdeo Prasad son of Hari Prasad Resident of Baradihtola P.S.Nokha
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Mahadewa ,Dehari District - Rohtas.
61. Premchand Prasad son of Chhotelal resident of Trigun P.S.Dehari District
Rohtas Posted at M.S.Sheoganj ,Dehari ,Rohtas .
62. Nand kishore Prasad son of khobhari Prasad Residentof village- Berkup P.S.,
Darihat District Rohtas posted at M.S.Bheriya ,Dehari District -Rohtas.
63. Ganesh Prasad Singh son of Puenmasi Ram Resident of village Mahavirganj
P.S. Karakat District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Paduhar ,Dehari District -
Rohtas
64. Ashok kumar son of Firangi Ram Resident of Tirgun Dehari P.S. Dehari
District- Rohtas posted at M.S. Brahmsthan ,Makarain , Dehari District-
Rohtas.
65. Chanchala Dwivedi son of Dr Chandan Dwivedi Resident of Jakhi Bigaha
P.S,Dehri District-Rohtas Posted at M.S.Sheoganj Dehari ,Rohtas.
66. Ram pravesh Ram son of Satya Narayan Ram Resident of village- Khadej
p.s. Kargahar District -Rohtas Posted at M.S. Sebeya ,Rajpur ,Rohtas .
67. Govind Choudhari son of Badshah Choudhari Resident of Nokha P.S.Nokha
District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Nachania ,Rajpur District - Rohtas.
68. Bhagwan kumar son of Shobhnath Ram Resident of Village -Kaithi
P.S.chenari District Rohtas posted at M.S.Dhobdihan District - Rohtas
69. Vijay Kumar son of RamBilash Prasad Resident of village- Asiya P.S.
Natwar , District -Rohtas posted at M.S. Rajandih ,Rajpur District-Rohtas
70. Md Imteyaz Ali son of Md Akabar Ali Resident of Garh Nokha P.S.-Nokha
District -Rohtas Posted at Sarvoday M.S.Nokha District -Rohtas.
71. Manoj kumar son of Harilal Prasad Resident of village -Ghordihan
P.S.Nokha District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Bishunpur ,Rajpur District
-Rohtas.
72. Ashok Kumar Sinha son of Jagdish Prasad Resident of village -Motha
P.S.Karakat District -Rohtas posted at M.S.Bharhuriya North ,Dehari
District Rohtas.
73. Nasim Akhtar son of Abdul Hamid Resident of Barah Pathar P.S.Dehari
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Kerapa ,Tilouthu District- Rohtas
74. Ashok Kumar son of Saryu Prasad Resident of village-Barawan Baraicha ,
P.S.Baghaila District - Rohtas Posted as P.S. Amarpur ,Rajpur District -
Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019
5/8
Rohtas
75. Bhanu Pratap Gupta S/o Nathuni Prasad R/o Patiya, P.s. Sasaram, District-
Rohtas posted at M.S. Mahadeva Dehari, District-Rohtas
76. Raj bansh Shah son of Kameshwar Shah resident of Fazalganj P.S. Sasaram
District Rohtas Posted at Girls M.S.Bharkuria North ,Dehri Rohtas .
77. Usha kumari daughter/ wife of Rajbansh Shah Resident of village- Fazalganj
P.S.Sasaram District Rohtas posted at M.S Berkup Dehri District -Rohtas.
78. Vinod kumar Shah son of Darmdeo Sah Resident of village Sakhara P.S.-
Rajpur District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Barana ,Rajpur District - Rohtas
79. Sanjay Kumar son of Keshav Prasad Singh Resident of Balapur P.S. Baxar
District- Baxar posted at M.S. Bagaha Khoh ,Rajpur District- Rohtas.
80. Ashok Kumar Singh son of Mukhdeo Singh Resident of Bhorama P.S.
Sasaram District-Rohtas Posted at M.S.Chanda Akorhi Gola , Dehari
,Rohtas.
81. Bhupendra Singh Achyut son of IshwarDayal Singh Resident of village-
Makarain P.S.Dalmiya Nagar District -Rohtas Posted at M.S. Baghakoh
Akorigola .
82. Ravindra kumar son of Fleshwar Ram Resident of village Samhuta
P.S.Kargahar District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Chandi ,Dehari District -
Rohtas.
83. Shobh Nath Pal son of Laxman Pal Resident of Village -Dharahara P.S-
Darihat District Rohtas posted at M.S.Kusumhara ,Akorhigola District -
Rohtas
84. Sheo kumar Subai son of Rama Ram Resident of village- and P.S -Darihat ,
District -Rohtas posted at M.S. Koupa . Akorhigola District-Rohtas
85. Abhay Kumar son of Ram Lakhan Pandit Resident of New Sidhouli P.S.
Dalmian Nagar District - Kaimur posted at M.S. Madhuram Pur , Dehari .
86. Subhash Sharma son of Narsingh Sharma village -Moudiha ,P.S Nokha
District - Rohtas posted at M.S,Chhapra ,Akorhigola District -Rohtas.
87. Ram Dinesh Choudhary son of Raghu Nath Choudhary Resident of village -
Jhabarmal Gali P.S.Dehari District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Pakdiya ,Dehri .
88. Rajdeo Das Son of Ram Nihora Das Resident of village- Gangouli
P.S.Dalmiyanagar District- Rohtas Posted at M.S. Japrawarpur
Akorhigola ,Dehri, Rohtas.
89. Ram Keshi Ram son of Ramdhari Ram Resident of Khadej ,P.S.-Kargahar
District -Rohtas Posted at P.S.Pyarepur ,Akorhigola , District - Rohtas .
90. Nand Kishor Sharma son of Vishwanath Sharma Resident of Amaratha P.S.
Karakat District - Rohtas Posted at M..S.Benikala Akorhi gola ,Dehari .
91. Sunil kumar Sharma son of Harihar Prasad Sharma resident of Tetrah ,
P.S.Akorhi Gola District - Rohtas posted at M.S.Bhim Karup , Akorhi Gola .
92. Rajesh kumar son of Ram Chandra Prasad Resident of village and P.S
-Darihat District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Bararahi ,Akorhigola ,Dehari
District -Rohtas.
93. Rajendra Choudhary son of Bihari Choudhari Resident of Sheoganj
Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019
6/8
P.S.Dehari District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Gobardhanpur ,Akorhigola ,
Dehari, Rohtas.
94. Rajeshwar Prasad son of Ram Awatar Singh Resident of village -Torna
P.S.Sheosagar District -Rohtas posted at M.S.Tendua kala ,Akorhigola
95. Shyam Narayan son of Ganesh Ram Prajapati Resident of Trigun Dehari
P.S.Dehari District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Barahi Akorhigola ,Dehari,
96. Surendra Ram Jagdidh Narayan son of Indrasan Ram Resident of village-
Karup District - Rohtas Posted at M.S Chandi Akorhi Gola ,Dehari ,Rohtas
97. Rampravesh singh son of Ramdeo singh Resident of village and P.S-Darihat
District -Rohtas Posted at M.S.Yadawan ,Akorhi gola ,Dehari , Rohtas.
98. Dineshwar Prasad Singh son of Ramraj singh resident of Kanha Bahura
P.S.Karakat District Rohtas Posted at M.S. Lalki Aheri , Akorhigola
,Rohtas .
99. Kameshwar Prasad son of Chandrama Prasad Resident of village- Kudwa
P.S.Sasaram District Rohtas posted at Girls M.S.pokhrahan , Nasariganj
100 Md Jawed son of Abdul Rehaman Resident of village and P.S.Nasariganj
. District -Rohtas Posted at Girls M.S.Pokhara ,Nasariganj ,Rohtas .
101 Md Nurul Hoda son of Muhaddin Ansari Resident of village kharpa
. P.S.Akorhigola District-Rohtas posted at urdu M.S.Pokharan ,Nasariganj
District- Rohtas.
102 Bikram kumar Subai son of Nand Kumar Resident of village and P.S.Darihat
. District-Rohtas Posted at uradu M.S. Salukpur ,AkorhiGola District -
,Rohtas.
103 Suresh Kumar Singh son of Brijbihari singh Resident of Dusadhi Bazar
. P.S.Piro District- Bhojpur posted at M.S.Bheriya Dehari ,District Rohtas
104 Pawan Kumar Choubey son of Raghunandan Choubey Resident of Parchha
. P.S.Chutiya District- Rohtas posted at M.S.Ramdihra on sone ,Rohtas .
105 Bharat Prasad Sharma son of Ram Prasad Sharma Resident of village Bank
. P.S.Akorhigola District -Rohtas posted at M.S.Bhimkarup , Akorhigola .
106 Ganesh Prasad son of Jwala Prasad Resident of Bararhi BidesiTola
. P.S.Akorhi gola District - Rohras posted at M.S, Chandi Akorhigola .
107 Utim Narayan singh son of Baleshwar singh village-Bikrambigha
. P.S.Nasariganj District - Rohtas posted at M.S,Lohradih Tilouthu District
-Rohtas.
108 Krishana Kant Pandey son of Kapil Pandey Resident of village -Jamorhi P.S
. Dinara District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Mahdewa ,Dehri Rohtas.
109 Ashok kumar Singh Son of Ramraj Singh Resident of village- Kandh
. Bahuaea P.S Karakat District- Rohtas Posted at M.S.Majhar Bigha , Dehari.
110 Birendra Kumar son of Ram Lakhan Pandit Resident of New Sidhouli P.S.
. Dalminya Nagar District -Rohtas Posted at Girls M.S.Akorhi gola ,Dehri ,
111. Brij kishore Thakur son of Banshi Thakur Resident of village -Denari P.S.-
Karakat District - Rohtas Posted at M.S.Bank Akorhi gola , Rohtas.
112 Ram Dayal Choudhary son of Kapil deo choudhary village Sheoganj ,Dehari
. ,District -Rohtas posted at Sheoganj Dehari
Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019
7/8
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State Of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of
Education, Government of Bihar, Patna
2. The Principal Secretary Department of Education, Government of Bihar,
Patna
3. The Principal Secretary Department of Finance, Government of Bihar, Patna
4. The Director Primary Education, Government of Bihar, Patna
5. The Regional Deputy Director of Education Patna
6. The District Education Officer Rohtas
7. The District Program Officer (Establishment) Rohtas
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Arabind Nath Pandey
For the Respondent/s : Mr.Smt. Binita Singh (Sc28)
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MOHIT KUMAR SHAH
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 03-04-2019
1. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned counsel appearing for the State.
2. The present writ petition is filed for issuing a direction upon the respondents to grant senior pay-scale on completion of a period of 12 years.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the issue raised in the present writ petition is no more res integra. A coordinate Bench of this Court had already decided the issue vide order dated 31.03.2011 passed in C.W.J.C. no. 6139 of 2007 (Ram Ashis Tiwary and others v. The State of Bihar and others) and the order of the Writ Patna High Court CWJC No.6489 of 2019 dt.03-04-2019 8/8 Court was affirmed in L.P.A. no. 756 of 2015 dated 16.08.2017.
4. In above view of the matter, the present writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondent no. 7 to examine the case of the petitioners in light of the decision of the Writ Court in C.W.J.C. no. 6139 of 2007 dated 31.03.2011 as affirmed in L.P.A. no. 756 of 2015 dated 16.08.2017 and the final decision in this regard must be taken by the respondent no. 7 within a period of two months from the date of receipt/ production of a copy of this order and all consequential benefits including the monetary benefit should be extended to the petitioners within a period of one month thereafter.
5. The writ petition stands disposed of on the aforesaid terms.
(Mohit Kumar Shah, J) rinkee/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR CAV DATE NA Uploading Date 04.04.2019 Transmission Date NA