The President vs The Joint Registrar Co Operative ... on 3 February, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

The President vs The Joint Registrar Co Operative ... on 3 February, 2009

Bench: N.K.Patil

' ..{$yAAf:::?£._'.A$%éﬁ. saga §<%§%é$RRQE£§¥'=g%§"€ ' $L,2R§§§§e%a§.!-'aP?% FQR .2.::;$.

E}? 75% E5. EEIGIE €'f€f2§§§~3.'f GE: i5_:%R}%_5%.T;'3'a§5J'i 2'-'(E §3x"=§;"§£§;";LC3?E €'e=',?.?l::s.§39~'§3 29338 3%.: we 3:3:-5 scam? SF xamazayaxa 33;? aasazcamaz §.&'§"E3 Tﬁiﬁ T§'iE 333 33%.? 3? F'ISr3R¥313.R'?' 33389}.-._ sssaﬁs M T VT ma %rze:~.e*s:.5 $53. .%%..3$'!"§$E %&.K.P&?§L."«':«:A.. _ wmr FE'§'IT38E€ 39.23949 GF..?;&ﬁ8 5' 5533-3 1.

1 9;=253;ag:-:3' 5 $952 ;:a::g:4E~:2 §Q»Q?Ef2.ﬁ;--€.%'#'E a;a2::;< L'§5%:;a., ' %--%ﬁJ'§é%~%€3 321$ RESQ Qmcg gr 5-.2a';::a, 1.2:-«z':<_ . gage? %¥%ALLE$%JARéh;% ,2,.;:s,:»:::»J--as..c:;2;E =§5<;- 5:33 * saga A:'«é,,:,. .:a~ei~:g:;j::<;r:;pE%*:;*¢s .g;:,,s&< as', :»2;;:m:::~;s K3 ;:::3<:»§ 'f:2§<€§1'2Ci£i2"§E mg: 3%? we-<; %3€£.';*§s9$ :2aag,La...%%gaAeJs:' 5«%§%é3:iLG§{E 5:253 $2 .... ?E?%T§G%'~%E&,$ E2; 3;; ; xx. 3 gzagagaa :;-e:§3:;~;;, a z+,::;:as:s: is»; 3 AS"-£QC§€§E3} EV») 2% ma §.:::*=VV:gx:*:' ::25£a:s=;i*:«~é§s;§2'*Q5;.:§é,is1*::iR;a"::vr;f aesaasgs amxsegzaaa a§:<;:_e:~g,. 9a%g:9A.;éA;----:A:<g2:; Raga age-a§:;s.aRg'swfg: aasgegvaeag 353 mg :i:«:§_a &;==:,;:"~r R$:3«::;ii:a?a,a Q?

~::c-s.>9ER;ezT:=~;E sscéersas » z . ' e ., EA?-%G:~'*~é,,=3RE~--$%'F{ 32:22:" gm ems:-; agzagaaggz.

- T w:;;:';aA,_ §'a%§¢§§:§_E$¥'¥§§§$ah§ eazamgzsaa 55$ {gm fw * . gas', 9: "§:«--é'.é'g::g§'§aQwag, gem ABQLE? é§f's'EA§2$ H::»:=:;¢,éa;-ﬁg, # '%?§, if %.€§éx§§'=«% ﬁﬁixﬁ, 8," mass, '§§'fE§*{f3§?'5I?§§*§f3§% §i.§C§(, §3i7§§_,§xCE'{3UTT,§:P€,5;LL§¢3:5's§"éGf3gi.{3RE.-3, £51 I RES «,:§"£5.Z2'"£§*f§L'?;

9-42.: B 'Q?' 93% EM 4-'%§'€€} 2;

§,§<Z..€e. §a$SGC§s='¥§E55E;- :5Q€~'i R3} §§rinl.~i-

"?§%%$'§%'§3ET PE'f%';"£%¥'a-E 233% ?§i..§é."} :3§*s%'{.§E§3£ $52? :53 22%} Aiiéﬁ 22? ii? {';Q?x2;."'-.~a?".§<'§'E'%J":5'§€7.'s%'°s£? Q? %?=i£}§?: §-'~'§~§ﬁJ'{§§°=§S EVQ £Ei§§%:3%~% ?%--§E §¥.r?9§}?»~§$€.} A ~ _ §3"§'£%%1'§%}_$Eg Q?" 'FHE R15 g*i§*-%?%»§?

'téiéi §i:;z"%é égiéisééi' ::::;--r .i§5%.:23i,§é%.§jL3?:?:£ :%¢.#.:w;a§13=~2§s:; «;;25§§7'..éi%% Tééigi ELSE} €"'€§U§§'.§" E{AE{?€AT.»'a}&.A' T ;"{§' 23'1}«E£1';AL€}R§;Z '>2£.P.?€«:§.13§4f} Q?' 3 G8 '5', "mas wan" P%1"'%'ET2G%é 52%;:-3% an ma %3RE§.éf¥'?%£*éﬁ.R'{ %~£E§«'sR§3*£{¥1__E%=4 =3 GRQLEP, ms am, "ma saga? Mama me: FQLLQWM3: ' GR§ER Petétéenars in t%1§s getitéen havei $c::;g%'si_1?Te*r':§%;:;£€éi%i;'f:gV the impugned aréer dated 383" C1cf::3t:er:'_'_'2{fG3 ﬁrs? respssﬁﬁeﬁi véﬁe An:%exu§e'F_fe..i:§2&' 992%

2. §--'"'e§§i§e:ﬁers 1 355%. h&§&éi;. a ré"*f§7.s §*és§de&;t ﬁﬁd Se«:::"&ia;"y sf Sree An§a"%ér;%y':3 Bank Ltd. Baﬁgaiare. This: Cﬁﬁﬁliéfﬁd the Generai V..2: 3§' --:»3S'=e'pfember 2538 by issuing August ZGGS by §§V%?"s§ a¥§ gfsg' de%§:'%§V§a?e3 téme and agerzéia :31' the S3§€§"::':&ﬁé%3§.:viB'G1;?;§? §%iaé%:iﬁ§ in the pmsazﬁce 31' 498 :'vj.._§é'%é;*:2Vi:; &;4?ﬁs. be§ﬁ § $a%§s§%&é '*€'i§"'£§"§ the gamma? of the sVéLic§V_VG'§nAe'r*:§§~«meeting on 21 52 Sapitember 2008, the V ﬁnird sﬁézsxﬁcrfzﬁeriif snﬁ caiher membarsa 3% %he Caéperaiive ' .T§"*:.$*«.:*é"':'.§§9d 3 ¢0:*:*:p§2§r":*£ bsfare éhe Regisémr ef Ct;-s §3j;:»é:'ﬂ3%§§é Sasietées Qﬁd Eh said 3L:§§°z<.'3rE':y iﬁ turf': an ﬁhe I 5' ma' ;~§%§L§é {.52.}: §<;s:.§<§~;,é;'§'i%:§;'a2 M 2r;_§%;a;ﬁ:.<.}:é§Wwj?,m7%"3§4:; {$.34 :::x? 321:: EEEGEE <;1:>:;:i::2" as' ,§iA:2.§;;:'§a:<J«. AT 2,.2.%»:z.;*;:=,1.,:';::z.:: 'ma:-=-«2<;. 135% Q? 29% am} baaég af '§"%& cosmaiiaﬁt, has éirenteé ihe juréaéiaiéfssxsé Agaéstaat R$§§$?§'3?' sf C0-0$er3%§ve Sasieﬁeﬁ free yepert 53$ 'Ea whétﬁér tésé Cﬁﬁéiiﬂi sf G:§.:é,.é'€§%V V' maaiéﬁg $3 stréstiy in (';0¥"i'§f3%§3¥'§£i :_é "?"é%e'va;:i$,.' ﬁfﬁviﬁiﬁﬁé ef the Kamataka €E;é+=.s_s;per'éié.vf& VSc::i;r:§'€zff{§:'~'z$VVV £'a<':'€% and Riﬁéﬁ read wééh tiﬁge b§re __%éi§¢:__€;§_»_»t§":' é" «.VVf:ﬁﬁ,i_§;§%g:atéve Bank. Accarcéérgiy, Regisﬁar has ssubrnitfed :f:_;==',p:1~ei'"fV"<'V_'--z:1'3' {in the basis sf {beg-éigfgzpiéié-%§*;t :¥;:é th§?é respamdeﬁi anﬁ at%;ersT' ﬂ $5!I1'£'?££LIn§CE'fiGﬁ éafed' '¥?'§"

ﬁataberivﬁﬁéﬁg resgaﬁéérﬁ, the férst §"&$§c2:f;:'%_jent, %rz §:;rn;:-- %€3s '§'r0ceeée§ am mﬁcziudeﬁ the V' §;--rs3jx;:é ;--§;'d§5<*§gs"b3f e:<jé§*%i*:'§é§%'2g his giaewar under Sectéeﬁ 28 {1} 15% f';:%.§%$a:i&d the Ccwsgreraiive Saciéty ta c':a§% Z fer §.I;:?zé».:%L§i§a5§ATg$i"°:a;"2% may meeting wiihéﬁ 'thirty éays .4 _. 'A Lﬁwe ?;§§§?:e2 5;? raceigi ea' 3 saw 3? 'E§'§€ ﬁﬁéd €3¥"€§ef and $6 .'_ ~_§{§i+;§s%*:éi:a fﬁﬁﬁﬁ regaréérgg the éacisésns taker: if": ihe géiﬁ "'-- ::%:éat%i':g. Eeing aggrieved? %: the eréef imﬁugneé passeﬁ ix hW__F'"_,_"_m__"_"___,,,..,__..

5 £5; 322:5 §%%<;§Eé :::,:i£E%§'1:§< é<;,é.2<:3~.u&."§'gais;J% s ;;;;m%;s'aL:,a}§éii;}j"'i;%§?.;2.;-am.éégmz: «:2? E}; E211 EEEGEE iffiliiii-TE' €31' K.$§=3.}€,%T,z»'a}~;L>'§ A'? E:'%?~Zfi3_z'-3. §_»'C}§<_E '~§'«J,,%"3,?=3::.='3a3§«-éi} {Z3277 2-3{}'{38 it by first raéaenéergt, ﬁeﬁfiﬂﬁﬁf heraérs feii 23$-::;es$%%2%§éT*"¥E::T ﬁféﬁeﬁf ﬁrm insﬁarzt writ petétéaﬁ, seeiéirsg ém§&.§§éé%§é'.;' miiefs as siataé supra.

3. 3 have hearﬁ Eeamed c:<}::jasr1sr;=;T§A.fiaégégféragffgr petétéanezs ﬁﬁd §€3?'¥'%é{i Va:i9m;;3s£:%"*-._ 3§pe§%§:j§...%..V fig? ms"psnder:f$.

=$_ Aﬁer carafui ;§é%§; s 3.% impugneé, %i émerges that; ?3fv'¥€1 'é":§*-.£'_S'€ eeﬁdzicted erzqaséry én s€r%r;:é'E :j'%iia§e*§%nt $TGV§§§ﬁ?§?$ ﬁf ihe Act arsé Qéjiea. Tﬁe saéﬁ auéhégétf Féaﬁﬂﬁéﬁié spgaﬁuniiy {sf hea;*§r;§_ $3 *:%3=é"§:e{%%%%{:;%'%e%és, s3r':§y reierriﬁg ihai, 8!? the V'é§£'t%'*:.aé a:a:';§:§ia §?%§"'éi§vbﬁ'sét?«&& by ﬁhiré féﬁﬁﬁﬁtiﬁﬁi 3&6 v Bank ﬁaﬁed 21$: Sepferrsber ' 2&8,'"~the..__#ép§:§rETss.;bm%t§eé ﬁy the Asgéséaﬁi Regésérar G? . '€i§~*~?1?;§1era95%§'u;:a Simieties dafeﬁ 13$ Gctczber 26% arm the §:--of§*5§ﬁij}§inezii0n sent by the $e=.:::c:)né respanden? cfated 'E53 " ;:Q5::4€éba§*' Eﬁﬁﬁ, it wmséﬁ be ammpréaée is ééfeaét the Ca- Eéi: ﬁéaéif <25 §'3;;-¥3;..§E;§}*A=':'4.-A':-'1,.§'53',,.§**L;*'*; 5A:'€<;;_.és:,{;e¥:'§é1; 2 395i; {:9 zisrgé

3);" EEESL C.{}L3P.3" £3? E{£%I{}€;'%?A}<L:% AT 112%}-iCu*&.LQE{E "'é%fP.E'»Esr.§3£7=~'${3 Q?' EQQS 5 agseméive 83:33: as canducf gpéciai aﬁﬁuai gaﬁesrai bgﬁy meetéﬁg sérzce 5% is fauna :53: $33 $i.f?f§{':§$§'1'€ §p;3::rr€z2':§i'ij§"'L:'::}f'vv_4 hearing was affﬁrdeci is ihe memﬁers #2 $3 H Zaeéd. The férst fﬁﬁfﬁﬁﬁdeﬁf w%%he'£§€i::c2§1gﬁ'§;:ct.%%§§::';ia;*§§vpér enaziify éﬁd sﬁéééﬁsuﬁ aﬁarding _§§pe::%i2'*i?2.,§: *:'§%:';f..«* $9 p'«:%:§f€"§e?1éi§;:§;"v%v"

hag éirecieiﬁ the paetitizsnem *€ﬁ""La:'::'-.:§f':'edi'.:c*.'£ 'Vzg%°§é'aE bétxﬁy {wasting in view: 61' :.:,°§_~--;'f::f::*x»::..+e¥§L.:%:*;é wﬁééa ﬁﬁﬁdifﬁﬁﬁﬁ fﬁé egfiéer and £3 submét the haiér. mt assigned my vaﬁd r'&a$%Q.;.1§ §~je*£V%é%c2:':e§*s ta eaﬁduct Sﬁéﬁiﬁ -- Mr 2 speaiféc féﬁdéﬁg ﬁg {ecordeé 'ia $:%f:3_%gffé::tf" .:é;»*%:}'i;es 1:§r§é Eéﬁ-.9, the said author??? fzag a{:;f§ép§:ed i§*§s;aV...V§f§¢§a:;§*z subméﬁeé by tﬁa Assésfaﬁt "§%_eg§$k%fa;r ,¢*§, i';?;é=~=:3;j;:¢e:'2%§ve Sacieééas and créered E9 V €iGf":::€§§.§A§'£'v§v§§%£'§§§§ §é?'£&€'3§ Md}! meeting. Fi.::*t%1&:*, if is ~___ s§g;_§%f:a3un§ ham ﬁwaéz, if/2% getéiéanerﬁ haw szﬂéméﬁaé '£§'2s~4:_'é.%2?:"x r"éE';':~§«§I datad 283' September 2838 wide ﬁxnnexure E .._§l¢ thé2 rages"? gubméﬁed ﬁy the Assivsésnt Regé\$%r3:' «:3? €39»

3.s<;:ﬁ§€_22.%§%':,A:;~' :é<;._;7:§;T§r-:g;*-mg; gag §f§"§é}éZ*?é§}}%§ §L§}§%.72~§"3,%§Tf;é%'T?%E;I§"§s§l«%§§%f:§%7§*éE:§:§Eé E33 TEE EIEGEE {TSEJRE {Z}? iigaﬁ-%};ATA.%iA 2%.? '?'£\3%3AL{}E'£ '%.'.}-°{}aEz;:_ 1 39% 53$? 25388 { :4.

.,.

éﬁemiéase Sacéetéa area ﬁaésaiaé regéy f§§€:{§ by pe%%%%em%_r'$ has :33? beét': :::3z'ss%§ereé. %% the first re§§<3;*:é_i$;§%:'V1'e-§%+:°;%. V 3 afféréeé §"&§S%!'t§b§$ aggasfusﬁty :3? T' ﬁetééésners, 'iiﬁegé wauéé have §uﬁ$i3aaj§§ia*E§a?;%%*sg%:*'_:;$§<--:x_ exgiaéneé is? d&§3§§ as is §"2f)*~f'e' _;;%ig_ :*:e:'3'%'.b5--::*3s ::é£:3é:%:§:g'v§2*;s"'% aanéusted am? Qoncéaéeé §ir%c%%§L"§V%3: c:;au§$§$ﬁ¢i§§%:§:é the we %aws af ﬁﬁe Sank a:*:i§._."j'*'iifaAs§.i§°e§é§}é--:i;';f..L§a;*r*:gf«.z§$%a§;'s$ 9f 'the:

Act and Riﬂes. 35% §i':~ ?§f'§& no such oppaﬁuﬁﬁy seéiiianars neg' ﬁne arée:fi_. any reasans (3?

é%sa£.3s$§cs:%*s_§s--' fa?' éakéﬁg Such 3 ﬁeciséers. '%*%2aerefa;~e, iii"-ss§és.:g* V§'e€~__€"§5i"."'«_:§'§;'2*;éb'S§§i?§ 3 speaking 6:69;" 3:33 :_.4-'ﬁszgff a'ffér;3.§,ﬁg%.Areééimaﬁée Qggsriunéijg is Qéfiféﬁﬁéfﬁ §éi§£§§$_§.¥§§ :§.'§f?. §'§'é$$_j..Vi§§3$%$ﬁ 3? Tiéie grérscégséés G? ﬁ3€i.§%"'£§ Z «_%i.;*$€%-:.4e.,.._ E 3;_g:'§ :if~'i%ze VEQW that 'Em émpugneci erder passeé Fééiiéﬁééﬁi carmai be saistaérzaé am $3 iﬁerefaré, .§§;3§§'§:é %ts=*§§%%2%e.

3:: ;%aé=;%.H: ifs): :-§«2;'§' %L3%~" %~;.s% .55§"E%;%;'§§:{§;é;é}i§js}:éT:§§%%.5"I'% W ';';i':;: ' .53'; :*::::;;2.';' :3; ;§;a:~;¢:;zLz;;«::::. 2 £327' 2363

5. ﬁaving rﬁgaré Ea ihe faciﬁ am €;'§:'a£:i..:§*:'2$*1:a:"§c§-:'§::.:':':':'§_V' ihe 23%, a$ ﬁaieé gbmve, ?';§"§€ W??? p$%iii§:f':__;';f%%é§'_:

fﬁéiéfiéﬁéfﬁ is déapased G? as fméawgr _ A' 3 i? ?':'?e W' mésssan ;;;ea%a3* 2?

a§iaa::;'e§.a' 31:? past' A X :2?) }''.%2e §fﬂ'€*f;.§$?'?§i2g1?§?*$€%;f ";3£::se€f. V resparrﬁenf dafed -_s§ean'r7g Na- .;§5;a2x(3~3 *2aa2s--ag% g;;§eL'A%a:;;&g:g;re ;=, is hereﬁjf' £53 'ﬁack $3 $33:

r$s,§§:?§£¢{%;~£_ ' {$1 ::§::~s:~c;c§§%;s§Ea'ér*- ----f_%f3§5 mafia?' afresﬁ aszﬁ fat: _§;{:g{*:-§:a*:%§:*'§éf'9 §8C§S§éf'§ 5:? accefﬁgéce' éazfgéi; zésffar gffarﬁsrrg fé,§§§;?a§§é._ g::;§§§s§%§3:%'E%y Q? ﬁﬁﬁfiﬁg {E ffzra f§§f§f§€§:9r;::; '§§:§;'Ja'* §'é.'S)§€?!?{§$§?f' $233? afézér ' '5Lz:§;§§;;£{?aei§§a2¥§%é§s;, sad éésgme 3?' ?§?& sgma. as ~. ré-X,ﬁé?i1?i;§§;€§£3§*;3}? &§ ﬁassééie, 3% $23}: mfg, with??? .§.. gas-"'§:;«€§' af eigfzf wéeks {ram ffmr ciafe 93' Sd/-é Iudgg AA Tigeezefgé sf 8 ssﬁy ﬁf fﬁég 5r§e;'i

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court