Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
R K Chopra vs Sh. Vikas Gupta, Commissioner, ... on 30 April, 2026
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
C.P. No. 154/2026
IN
O.A. No.4407/2018
No.
This the 30thh day of April, 2026
Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg,
Garg Member (J)
Hon'ble Dr. Anand S Khati,
Khati Member (A)
1. RAJ KUMAR CHOPRA Retired Drawing
Teacher, Group B Aged about 76 Years S/o Late
Sh. K. K. Chopra R/o 4232, ATS-ONE
ATS
HAMLET, SECTOR-104, 104, NOIDA-201304,
NOIDA
UTTAR PRADESH, INDIA..
2. ABHILASHA JAIN Retired Head Mistress,
Group B Aged about 73 Years W/o Mr. R. C.
JAIN, R/o E-1/4,
1/4, Near Shikha Girls Hostal and
Shreeji Mart, Pushpa Mission Hospital Road,
Rishi Nagar, Ujjain. M.P. 456010
3. AJAY KUMAR SINHA Retired Principal,
Group A Aged about 69 Years. S/ o Late Sh. U S
Sinha R/o D-14, Purshopttam
urshopttam Vihar, Goleka
Mandir, Bhind Road, Gwalior, M. P.-474005
P.
4. ANJALI CHATTERJEE Retired PRT, Group C
Aged about 72 Years W/ o SH. Anjali Chatterjee
R/o Flat No. 404, LA Gomera, Bldg No. 7,
Mathias Ocean Park, Dona Paula, Talegao,
Tiswadi, N Goa, 403004,
03004, Goa
5. Baldev Raj Tandon Retired PGT, Group B
Aged about 76 Years S/o Shri Amar Nath Tandon
R/o C-2-8,
8, Jiwan Jyoti Apartments, Near Rohit
Kunj, Pitampura New Delhi 110034
6. Banishree Das Retired TGT, Group B Aged
about 71 Years W/o Sh. Susant Das R/o: Flat No.
11-B,
B, Shivshakti CGHS Ltd., Sector 10, Plot 10,
Page 1 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
Dwarka, New Delhi 110075.
7. Bansi Lal Menaria Retired Principal, Group A
Aged about 75 Years S/o Moti Lal Menaria R/o
273, Hiran Magari, Sector-8,
8, Udaipur-313002.
Udaipur
8. Bhushan Grover Retired Assistant, Group B
Aged about 72 Years S/o Late Shri H. C. Grover
R/o: Flat No. 663, Bahawal Pur, CGHS Ltd., Plot
No. 7, Sector-4,
4, Dwarka, New Delhi 110078.
9. Bindu Sinha Retired TGT,, Group B Aged about
72 Years W/ o Late B. S. Sinha R/o P-604,
P
Anupam Apartment, East Arjun Nagar, Near
Karkardooma Court, New Delhi 110032
10. Braham Deo Lal Das Retired TGT, Group B
Aged about 70 Years S/o Hari Nandan Lal Das,
R/o Munger Road, Behind Church,
Ch Bari
Dariyapur, Jamalpur, District Munger, (Bihar)
Pin-811214
11. Chhanda Dutta Chowdhury, Retired TGT,
Group B Aged about 73 Years W/ o Bhaskar
Dutta Chowdhury, R/o 48, Model Town, Balia,
Garia, Kolkata-700084
12. Deepali Chatterjee expired, Retired
Retir
Headmistress, Group B Aged about 78 Years W/o
Late Nitya Nanda Chatterjee, R/o 122 A,
Banamali Naskar Road, Behala, Kolkata-700060
Kolkata
13. Deep Kumar Mamgain Retired TGT, Group B
Aged about 71 Years S/o Late Sh. Jagannath
Mamgain R/o Lane 10A, Ekta Vihar,
Sahastrashara Road, Behind Khalanga Park,
Dehradun 248001
14. Geeta Bhattacharya Retired Headmistress,
Group B Aged about 83 Years W/o Late Surendra
Nath Bhattacharya R/o D-3, 3, Purbachal Cluster 1,
Sector 3, Salt Lake City, Kolkata 700097
Page 2 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
15. Harish Chandra
ndra Agarwal Retired EO, Group A
Aged about 75 Years S/o Late Shri Dharam Dutt
Agarwal R/o Flat No. 569, Roasewood
Aptts.,Sec.-13-A; Phase-2,
2, Dwarka,
New Delhi-110078
16. Heather D'Souza Retired Headmistress, Group
B Aged about 76 Years D/o Late Victor D'Souza
R/o Ahrihant Colony, Penta Mala, Kothi Road,
Opposite Sitaban Lawn, Ahilya Nagar-414001
Nagar
17. Indra Diwan Retired TGT, Group B Aged
about 81 Years W/o Mr. Sushil Kumar R/o Q1/19
DLF Phase-2,2, VTC Sikandarpur (68), Ghosi Post
Office DIFQE, Distt., Gurgaon,
gaon, Haryana-122002
Haryana
18. Jayprakash Bhimashankar Joshi Retired LDC,
Group C Aged about 71 Years S/o Late Sh.
Bhimashankar M. Joshi R/o D-22,
D Soni Pole No.
4, Wadi, Vadodara-390017
390017 (Gujrat)
19. Juthika Chowdhury, (Retired PRT, Group C)
(Now Deceased: Following
owing legal heirs) A. B.
Payoja Choudhury (Daughter) Pranab Kumar
Chowdhury (Husband) Both: R/o: Ram Krishna
Cottage, J/M-2/2,
2/2, Aswini Nagar, P.S. Baguiati,
Zarda Bagan, Hatiara Road, Near Bandhu Mahal
Club, Kolkata-700159
20. K. Girija Retired TGT, Group B Aged about
77 Years W/o G. Raghu R/o H No. 11-13-764,
11
Plot no. 37, Sai Brindavanam Road no. 3, Green
Hills Colony, K.V. Rangareddy District,
Saroomagar Telangana-500035
500035
21. Kawaljit Kaur AnandRetired TGT, Group B
Aged about 75 Years W/o Mr. Trilok Singh
Anand R/o Flat No. 210, Sector 12, Pkt. 2.
(Dwarkadheesh Apartments), New Delhi-110075.
Delhi
22. Kiran Bala Maini Retired PGT, Group 'B'
Page 3 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
Aged about 73 Years W/o Mr. Rattan Kumar
Maini R/o 464/3, Mehrauli, New Delhi-110030
Delhi
23. Kiran Gupta Retired PGT, Group B Aged
about 79 Years W/o NC Gupta R/o GH 14, Flat
No. 933, Paschim Vihar New Delhi-110087
Delhi
24. Kishanbhai Govindlal Rana Retired UDC,
Group C Aged about 69 Years S7o Govind lal L.
Rana. R/o F-404,
404, Emperean Comt Yard, Opp.
Akshar .Akshar Plot, Paradise Nr. Deeps Party
B/H Narayanvadi Hotel, Post Atladara-390012.
Atladara
25. Krishna Vijayversiya Retired PRT, Group C
Aged about 72 Years W/o Cdr. D. K. Gupta
(Retd.) R/o B-2/101A,
2/101A, Safderjung Enclave New
Delhi 110029
26. Lipika Dey Retired PGT, Group B Aged about
73 Years
ears W7 o Mr. Swapan Kumar Dey R/o
Lichubagan, Maniktala, Ichapur 24 PGS (N) W.
B.-743144
27. M. Surya Kumari Retired Head Mistress,
Group BAged about 66 Years W/o 151,
Vaishnawi Garden, ST BL Projects, Kapujagaje
Rajupeta, Visakhapatnam, R/o Andhra Pradesh-
534099
28. Madhu Dhamejani Retired PRT, Group CX
Aged about 70 Years W/ o Dr. Chetan Lal
Dhamejani R/o Flat No. J-1103,
1103, Roystonea,
Magarpatta City, Hadapsar, Pune-411013
Pune
(Maharashtra)
29. Malti M. Maharishi Retired PGT, Group B
Aged about 74 Years W/o Mahendra Nath
Maharishi R/o B 604, Doordarshan Apt, Plot no.
9, Sector 45, Gurugram, Haryana-122003
Haryana
30. Maya Nandi Retired TGT, Group B Aged
about 76 Years W/o Mr. Prabir Nandi R/o P-231,
P
CIT Scheme VII M, Sanmilita Housing Society,
Page 4 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
Kolkata 700054.
31. Meeta Pratap Singh Retired Yoga Teacher,
Group B Aged about 71 Years W/o Late
Raghvendra Pratap Singh R/o 83, South Park
Apartments, Near B-Block,
Block, Gurudwara, Kalkaji,
New Delhi 110019.
32. Mina Roychowdhury Retired PRT, Group C
Aged about 69 Yearss W/o Mr. Swapan Kumar
Roychowdhmy R/o Swabhumi Residency, Flat -
L/1, P-12,
12, Motijheel Avenue, Kolkata-700074
Kolkata
33. Mira Basu Retired PRT, Group C Aged about
73 Years W/o Nikhil Kumar Basu R/o Perajete
Corporative Housing Society Ltd.New Town-DC-
Town
150 Street No. 314, Cal-700156
700156
34. Nirendra Nath Sarkar Retired TGT, Group B
Aged about 80 Years S/o Nipendra Nath Sarkar
R/o Cudipta Ghosh, A.C. Chaterjee Bye Lane,
Harerpukurdhar, P/o Chandar Nagar, Distt.
Hoogly-712136
35. Paramjeet Ahuja Retire Retired Principal,
Principa
Group A Aged about 76 Years W/ o Gurdit Singh
R/o S-392,
392, Greater Kailash Part-1,
Part New Delhi-
110048.
36. Prabha Gupta Retired PRT, Group C Aged
about 98 Years W/o Mr. Deepak Kumar R/o 98,
Khurbura, Dehradun, U.K.-248001
248001
37. Puran Singh Khatri Retired PET,
PE Group B
Aged about 75 Years S/o Shri Surat Singh R/o
87/A, Road No. 2, Mahipalpur Extn. New Delhi-
Delhi
110037.
38. Raghubir Prasad Mathur Retired Librarian,
Group B Aged about 78 Years S/o Late Sh.
J.N.P.Mathur R/o Flat No. 1014, U.F. Apts. P. No.
9, Sector 6, Dwarka, New Delhi-110075.
Delhi
Page 5 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
39. Ram Buksh Retired Lab Assistant, Group D
Aged about 71 Years S/o Late Ram Niwaz R/o
VPO, Manadech, Thana-Amanganj,Disttt.
Amanganj,Disttt.
Faizabad (U.P.)-224121
40. Raman Bala Kapoor Retired TGT, Group B
Aged about 81 Years D/o Late Sh. Madan Lal
Kapoor R/o 432, Mathura Road, Jangpura, New
Delhi 110014
41. Rani Mehra, Retired TGT, Group B Expired
W/o Mr. Ashok Kumar R/o G-20,
G Sector-12,
Noida (U.P.)
42. Reeba Ghosh expired,
43. Roopshikha Agrawal Retired PRT, Group C
Aged about 70 Years W/o Mr. Haridas Agrawal
R/o Flat No. 22/201, Ravi Nagar, Neatric Terrace
Gwalior. (M.Ρ.)
44. Ruchi Gulati Retd. Head Mistress, Group B
Aged about 64 Years W/o Mr. RK Gulati 42-E,
42
Nehru Park Colony, Bareilly, U. P.-243122
P.
45. Sabita Mukherjee Retired
d Librarian, Group B
Aged about 78 Years W/o Mr. M. S. Mukherjee
R/o Village South Kamragu, Jhorahat Howrah,
WB-733102
46. Santosh Rawat Retired TGT, Group B Aged
about 69 Years S/o Mr. V. S. Rawat R/o H. No. 5,
Dwarika Puri, Extn., P.O. Kanwali, GMS Road,
Road
Dehradun, (U.K.)
47. Sarbani Das Retired TGT, Group B Aged
about 75 Years W/ o Late Sushoran Das R/o
Loknath Abashan, A-1,1, 120/5 Purbachal Kalitala
Road, Kolkata 700078.
48. Satyabrata Pal Retired Head Mistress, Group
B Aged about 74 Years S/o Late Rohini
Roh Kumar
Pal R/o SJDA Composite Complex, MIG-83,
MIG
Page 6 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
P.O.-Danguajhar Dist.-Jalpaiguri,
Jalpaiguri, W.B. 735121.
49. Sephali Maiti Retired PRT, Group C Aged
about 71 Years W/o Mr. Jaladhar Maiti R/o B-4,
B
Sourav Abasan, FB-5/2, Sec--III, Salt Lake City,
Kolkata-700097, W.B.
50. Shashi Bala Saxena Retired Head Mistress,
Group B Aged about 73 Years S/o Mr. G. P.
Saxena R/o H. No. 7, H-9,
9, G-II,
G Phase-One
M.D.D.A. Colony, Indirapuram, G.M.S. Road,
Dehradun, (U.Κ.)-248001
51. Shukla Khosla Retired TGT, Group B Aged
about 80 Years
ars W/o Satya Deo Khosla R/o H. No.
1062, Sector-21,
21, Gurgaon 122016, Haryana. 52.
52. Sikha Devi Retired PRT, Group C Aged about
78 Years W/o Apurba Sarkar R/o 44A, Rody Park
(East), Karba Kolkata-700078,
700078, WB India
53. Samriti Arya Retired Librarian, Group
Grou J3
Aged about 76 Years W/o Mr. o. P. Arya. R/o JO
G-4, Pocket -2,
2, DbA SFS Flats, Naraina Vihar
New Delhi 110028.
54. Subodh Ranjan Maji Retired TGT, Group B
Aged about 75 Years S/o Late Gour Mohan-Maji
Mohan
R/o 4, Tinpukur Badra, Jaya Appts., Flat-A,
Flat First
Floor, Kolkata 700079.
55. Sudha Gupta Retired Head Mistress, Group B
Aged about 71 Years W/o Dr. S. K. Gupta. R/o
6/304, Malviya Nagar, Jaipur-302017.
Jaipur
56. Sukanti Kumari Das Retired PRT, Group C
Aged about 67 Years W/o Niranjan Dash Debjyoti
Apartment, R/o Nitasha Valley, H. No. NV-V2
NV
Naugan, Malipada, Bhubneshwar Distt. Khurdha,
Orrisa-753001
57. Surekha Jain Retired PGT, Group A Aged
about 74 Years W/o Ramesh Chand Jain 47, E-1,
E
Page 7 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
Sector 11, Faridabad-121006
121006 (Halyana)
58. Sushim Kumar Das Retired. TGT, Group B.
Aged about 75 Years S/o Rabindra Nath Das R/o
Basudevpur Danesvpur, Distt. Paschim MAtripur,
WB-1216776
59. Varsha Nern Jain Retired PGT, Group B Aged
about 75 Years. W/o Mr. Nern Kumar Jain R/o
C1/501, Uniworld Gardens-2 2 Sector-47,
Sector Gurgaon-
122018.
60. Vijai Pal Singh Raghav, Retired Prindpal,
Group A Expired S/o Late Sh. H. Singh
R/o H. No. 22, Jagriti Vihar, Sector-23,
Sector
Ghaziabad, (U.P.)
61. Vimla Nanda, Retired TGT, Group B
Aged about 78 Years W/o Sh. T. R. Nanda
R/o 2-J-12,
12, Jawahar Nagar, Jaipur-302004.
Ja
...Applicant
..Applicants/Petitioners
(By Advocate: Ms. Priyanka Bhardwaj for Mr. M. K. Bhardwaj
Bhardwaj)
Versus
1. Sh. Vikas Gupta, Commissioner, Kendriya
Vidhyalaya Sanghthan Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi.
...Respondent/Alleged
.Respondent/Alleged Contemnor
(By Advocate: Mr. S Rajappa, Ms. G. Dhivyasri, Mr. R Gowrishankar
Gowrishankar)
Page 8 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'
Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026
IN
O.A. No. 4407/2018
ORDER (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Garg Member (J):--
At the outset, learned counsel for the respondents submits that similar issues are pending consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in matters arising from Bharti Bahuguna & Ors. v. Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan & Ors., Ors., W.P.(C) No. 3172/2019, and that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has granted stay on the operation of the judgment in the said matter.
2. On the other hand, learned counsel for the applicants submits that the applicants may be granted liberty to revive the present Contempt Petition in accor accordance dance with law, if so required in future.
3. We have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties.
4. In view of the submission made by learned counsel for the respondents that similar issues are pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and further considering the request made by learned counsel for the applicants, we are of the view that no useful purpo purpose would be served in keeping the present Contempt Petition pending at this stage.
Page 9 of 10 SNEHA 2026.05.04 MEENA 11:05:04+05'30' Item No. 57(Court-4) C.P. No.154/2026 IN O.A. No. 4407/2018
5. Accordingly, the present Contempt Petition is closed with liberty to the applicants to revive the same, if so required, in accordance with law. Notices issued, if any, are discharged.
6. All pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(Dr.
Dr. Anand S Khati
Khati)) (Manish
Manish Garg
Garg)
Member (A) Member (J)
/sm//
Page 10 of 10
SNEHA 2026.05.04
MEENA 11:05:04+05'30'