Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
A P Panda vs D/O Post on 9 August, 2023
Oi sf 2078 5 ie i Ls, We hv a faa cond pen St i Ac GAN. 260/0 mh PPS ND cere o + Xe x YY IPR Phe 3 , Superintendent i a ww ya, Counsel oAee ur ae q t t nan he , tae eee "Gs ay os, re ae ont poe on Aad eee .
ad om teit fee oS es bes "nn oo Se hee "hed Em a % es % oo ee o se *e on nares, poo were. wet pee nite :
Pog x pad ¢ 4 Seaee Deed ve iad os " _ < os ee BS fw a rae my ot pee SS wg Bs a Pe oes von % ost we sooo me ee = 253 ve . 22 oy ; F sage pat peoes a ek. goed we, ae i or on ae oe ae ae Pw i peed lice po ny tee poe me bea 44 re ny & revel ps ~~ w ah " oo ¥ ' peer , 'eat reed, ny o i ae. : a LS get pa a enna, + 'ie a pees fro we beet a jon, "ne 2 pe pes cas . : ' pod :
wa see. A, Ree eae ae wae On aes posts St if . wet yun oud on ned at reas om oa yo sy m3 ane rei oped oe ee, Ba ine 2 , heed 3 a ey he errk hy oe een Pay ' tak} csten ae Ke won os oe, wth, Yy wren ied hae tes Na ae peer) . ¢ pe ns 'P 7 'eee as " ea . va oS Sas wn Se: ys é ee. * vo a5 ~ ~ Paid es go bn pee Ba pa ts > ie pans on Shans as Nae % aod hk iS wee % a ty os fon io ne Gy st $ oo oad 'ee a Py! os atid Sater 7 a £3 asl ene. . "2 "GA road Pee mph ' ry at cas oy seen pon os ts ee) boo ty ' fit jen ot ome al oes Rage 4 "ped. a. Sok ; ss 4 rl Sanus 03 ses onal pdog apd ee as a es od Ay pace ~, , % Bead ay pa 60 Seok p= on eet a3 oes fa sad Bee j : or) me Pag ae at sat) poet Groh ot Paes pion po Lo ~ * bed on seed aed ae . a a rh Be, Ce 4 gon pen Fy hy heme et a ery n wee 4 Pot onal back bead oo on ped id on Se ae Fed bak om Gs oad geet poston ed Sab we on, ood ee OD 'a pe pang tet = week ee Es eee, *E fod os Sheed facet es ps peed at me 'eg x B bane oh, ine fo. a me bea bread in eee pons Pe, ea se rs. ' : "at ;
we wr re Lae om agen, os ee eve ees oe oad rot bid 'ned 4 sine ie On " oe ay pts tore aie anes oa seed Eee eee. ya fore 4 ses ead fears te are 4 $ eet fone we tis oe baie, ts, We ht bed "ees road to wane et 4a Pt a oe Se wet "~ bases Lat ey boost tat a 'ay fat 2 wat Paes Sa, tant Ge wn} het Fo : : a nd . fee - 3 se pind aa dich a wa le feck ton ms fe, he shea z ak red rate) 3 eet em fos dred oe wt Od . C3 ieee wae, a a on me we ' a, oer, ; bon 5 het rg oe oo we es, ace a 'veal iG pr, Pa heat oad My beten: aot yer ¢ on, ns el nye fa pees, Set eendd oud ae i "mri fen be oe sng cas eet Oey ne: sea ane fe al po, ¥ deed pend Cine * gone os res pe pang eet act 'ting? fas ogee Bye nee ae ~ cs es ns Ay on: one pat no 'boo fe ra ge oy re ws Sol 4 a P Soe ae jean . LS i rhe Piped an Ls ape pore ae wana 5, a neo peees Sage, ae Ww Cee, ne od hee ee haa yond 2% fh. al vend 43 a weak ~~ ae anne, sed os ws Sa 'sige ei ee 'det te more a cae wpe po ve cand Y a heaged sows ° "nat bed be ' 'et ee wen panend ye tae gee ct 43 ied SF "Abie , Bi Ad Jose nea ron ae week ' wa ee fr oo we fut ote pes ne) oe. oe 'mt ons ae peed aa " pen] Looe tren ton oa oe " nor ie a es ¥ ax a oe, 5 a wy en " a Posae : as coe as oS A i ty "tek = tae of ce deed Gs geek "and won oe G3 on base Put, we tft ae ee weer neeein Frags pened aed Si eaaal "eat ee ; bP reas ree oa bad Sood ~~ a £ he bse a oe a ; deed pn pores bene : 4 oe aad we rs 4 *, eal 'nel "ne ap wei nae? Feil et wove ried ae, fart eee wes Fuad "oes paves ay ae ? a fe Sod "eat he Ne fae ret aw we a va As ovat eas PAS, wot a ft can, pan ane; we ne a bor "
fo a -- ee a a ss ta he te P int oo oa 'ees v4 oad aa rr c d 1 me <A et byes - io wee ped he on od oes oa <3 os het Vs eee re, Raped $ en, ? wy i 5, ped £3 £3 hen ven . oo ces rece ed eed . ret pao wn aed [an 2 ae Se! pat Wragg tae. wee Fol pase; See te he, ae 'sd Re ed pee ne ae 'eet pe reced poe rae, Au ped ¥ Ps a Eaaed Nall ee an, z. ot fens pene, ocd hod we TF "aes Wa tet on pr seed: % ated G3 ceed 'aed aoe A pm, Tat > feet won ait vee ee] oom: F en Sect ot heme seen 3 i ot on 3 E pe : ' abet g Re a5 , ae gS a sibon, . why = 'at a per Spite yee a 'ad ay en ¢ Po _ cat bangs , gece Peas! . Leos Sandee , ais Soe, ne ere. wt be poner Fon on, yen ees oe baa Rees oe Fos oe fea es Ds oa . a os Ee a ™ & = P penees od ~ ine cone hans io mm Sook ae Ed cok bro a wet om et n, pgs a4 Sed yan en rs baa ie Lee woh "cae bork "ay , et Red Treo, poet fee pe od ee Pod we . ws pened ot AG " roan pe been 'abrri *. eee pres eed tot od aad ea ' Soe pss ad 'aed? we any ben one ty raed 4 cote) ~~ eis ie. id & on on vel oa 8 rs ~ wes: bead Ge ett ate as ie ne, ae Seton oy oe Lonae Pan tonst ord oe ' ; ae om, ~ Sex be on Set 5 pared g d :
pore, eo, eabct oom fret seen Sad vee 2 ye diy Pee ssgeal oc CSO yppelant recived £ 5% a 'ae pee wore Hoot dood wo opel:
akeament EA resp ¢ ~ Sh Fisathor "y Oy OY Ri SNR 2.
endent H e a Res ay s x orwarded § Fe Pal Fi fag bed ae wee we oes tnt aed pete ows < wae Reo Faced * * ce aed son, Kea vdual . oy:
san hdval Pays ification of ae es, i nak pn pees Peed Pie ~, > tin cored t reper % & ad submi t "t f anuary 2l4 and other 1 ° x ro | parry TOS wes ¢ AorSG 7 R revised T ae bon 4 vs decd gn) yee aaa ws eK pare % we Sd, na pon cand ot cic or dain' et on, Semil ry "sn pre bene Baad ee teat i;
..
H RX se street ine frond) pt noof wor te ae k} date ahmitted that & o. $ was initially di x y espomdennt | plete the cent pereent OTE ae gO oe we Ls ae onal ped ae itt se x eed DXA x i ant ¢ aRTaAth $3 S x z SSE PROSS Fa sheets CLC x PRED y ne ce ny + a x at Tone pafcant fo KK AY .~ eg th jaded ok j EHC ?
SUE M5 Taek Pad re oh Ls 44 tf Es ad 'whee at we acs aod s apes, = A m ial pad uid eet oc' a ae ee feponed 4 Seed, coe' ten agg ey Saat oe -- sdook ones 9603 ro ees gh 2s nh Pa ry woe, ett pat . : heed pore ood "ood one pute "red ay Bisse) ott a > pes &E Beth order as nea oB poss a nen Peed Renae Sd aed e 4, ft aoane' ie. wi Bans ee yesd Milos peri 5 nat om het tock ae ca Sh ; "
° om, yee Bot ra pee. ied ers, Pree. owe, re raaed shee : oe Ps rere, Scand a a4 deeb Paes apne eed oe, Keb "ned? £3 ee een LS m at ' e as tad we we, © enone on Cad oe oe) aes acs et Faas ty ree on vey Load nN s bod rk has' 2 Faaatl jen ¥ feet rons ae ™. Pre veee Leet cant;
ron Peal ene, we a 'ae eons ree ga non Sees ieneiny ne ot aod en a3 Seah: nie, ae rye At wk : ba iad vn ca oh is » pie poy aa x gen ne pes wt mee ar ~ Grae: 3 Tat bond gee an baad oy wen? bed foot head the Naat "a hed ay me vom ip ex ys fae : : pe '3 fod 3 7 3 7 Po "hein a end dean ed Pom oo ~~ on Pers ae oa ret " peas baal ar , $ as, "adh Qe ea awed . pe, pees ated, ree prec ty pan a oe CS a, New vee, sub ce, aye hoe heal hake o Wat ptt 2 * ' if een wh teal a bn oy, voter nto yee Sab yo, fey "ane" pane Co on Lag Beet ignar: ps6 god By yy HA hs x oe we it oe zs bs L iat nate ne, Fanos ne a "ft x ae "---- Shwe eras an a> pa Pada Bs ' om, my s "oes 3 ion 4 a Lear pees el Ha on ~~ ae at al - fm hed pees tet wu re: * roaad coraad Py, hed paced wo L if or) 'eet se 4 : @ on as me os cree f aa ; < > eee Ms me, " yee "me 'nant Gs od to tal wae fo ee So a TS at fore rm ° pened, : on 'edo Lh on *, Lea cored tet cn Lic nee os, ; me etn Yaad qaeed, Sundae nn bes pees Ws pao es "Sin te pon oo 'led " oe wed roo Peace dent wy ey ten, aad, bead Past WV aed oe eee! raed ae a 4 ne Fhe 'say Daag "ae end deed wae ~ LS La oft fat one seed Laat ro aa bon Bo cccccs nuns ee na if 3 ty oa "f g ; a a 2 a4 Pies é ae bro heed & a as enn, a3 LA px Sad we woe Bing ee ede. Broad nevis neon Rs ca = we Ci , ace MO es Fo iccceetees cen pers : Anot? et i on Meron Bn nnn nnn pion . a Sock on a ee boned ets 'aa! pam :
donk cans s rey oe ate Hi z 4 % Seg ay bade hot ae Paes porn ; yon, we a, mw ~ att ; " Aone, sree, % <2 i at pet, ~~ os et x, ' pad ot pa on we 'eee, pea ae oe . on ie 4 rm re) Pee 'at Lf, th gene an weeny ett pecers were, 7 see "at aca Heeet of ion a 'oo fhaed aie Be % slo th non Pa , pee ¢ tne eet Fangs = ; peed dent ne 5 Snood vs rae ters Fania py th "aa bao a, of oe Pad ca ay ° mead ay wy pane gr iy it rhe shed he : om 3 o pers son Pao ; yeni es oy eee os pend m wa fans eS os 3 wren, + a pe ier vent fea A "4 nape, oA dh ' 'coed ie o ; ° tant rs * ' £03 tent 4 3 Heol as pA lasach Ge Pasa 'nent HA tf A See 4 Soe oe rae os, : foes ae eeegl on, " 4G o, ee poet ~, eee, we an nd pe a mS " oo, lat ang age as xy aaa foe ; ia re me a Sood "na 'aed sean, re pe lad Loans ra Pat re Fon ¢ y a3 4 'ad shook as feos, bet bad : . "A os res ge AG Sak boat rent ra ne vate ot a work pees Fea 4 we Fane' wnas a, ny me bana 'act Doon press po tostat cd oe ea aad pars wa Pad rs eapeids > tree. Naga nee.
wows Ge Ad oo bee beaaed re pe x gr ca few casera ahass pas Lapetes Sas feed dood 5 see 2 od =< on, % bas shat oo a teed 'nee. Syd potas an ad hat pe pal gy an er f we 'mae ts Ag Sona "ned be * Ws Od a job ni 4 rey eaaal .
"y ° oS oA foi nae Jove ' Tad '. aed pa Rae ean ty eo pened p wy "nd jos dat ae thd wie BG 4 the '. ree pag 1f ches dood at vor ween L. ae wee. fee: apd ned bind * sgh hee, ey ened gy aan, ~ pen a4 aad aes Me Picea cons at ce 5 Fema? Nhe we ve tat eee, a r ier 2 a ae es ee, owes Ya orenei od bent pes we aa weal ecw apie, a whens teat ay regen ver the 8 dela
2. qs the ded the se yee & =) i as nat ¢ x Ny AR, o ee forw i 'eet grade and w ¥ i"
met ot ~ oN td "
ls PSR donot belong t i hod rs "
a3 ru bot! Sars aster w mo Postini Senor Ay pc boot .
" in, le, or 7 ae eee on i364 bese aoe on 4 oe $ fed aA ey boa 3 Pend ws Sy Sa Gs "ott oS naps Ls " > 4 5 Fad ete Let ie fe & whe Bored aa bot A oe a4 aera . oe rs i re om 'a a et 4 wg ye pees we pe ine £3 pot ws ved Yo ect ed oe eft rr a pr ee. ee % es react t " se oe ' "S oe on 7 ya te " bad eat , ee ree.
ns Me --- he Sees y P aad oa pea ice hae ge 7 ae nee he Bet é 2% see os vet . . wee ieee ak ts tea a ne aa 3 a nae 'at dens ea me we Jaw ved ite sot a ies] ne nd age wi rapt om its shook Foi pore, Sg. ~ vee road ne Fen a peas fees oy, ger ad wet Foal pre aad? et here we " pees face en] yews, we an el ae ' ~ Ls ' paps ead Reel an fre ea 2 Peed Uf peed oe wae -- ay et "ei ee pea ee om * a ay ft a rs when a 3 Be mH cid e Es Ne oo ; ; . Pan) el a ae oe eel tet regal ¢ sree ongaed ' a bok " age] pon oy, caneedd Fone bet = ws took Saad eee wD hood Peal me, i, oa, oe "sy wy ben ax mee nee yon dor yes vhok pan feet oo pare " ewe ran ov bee we ret me on tes ed oe oh ' f fe we a fo x te bead ; Bai eel ne, po pad eas lod peas aed. send, as! pee here fe ~ as bod of wenew uk een peed Gree bond ¢ 4 wh, foe ee ek 03 GD By sal re Aten hed ts * Pat Ay ia pa eee heat aad yee 'at aa bre, er bears at he sy 'et ~ fy age ; 2a is thet aoa oar ron cet pawn we i beh cate oe, al tot "she ghee 43 ween, a pana eel boken, Raed ments rn, Sabees ae : ae oie ye Me, ie rs Sree 7m gow as one al aft ec ceeers real Ft, Oe ° cs : a nan ae pend ad . "a is Sone Fang rot gy hat wh bes eect yee eh we tre, "se be fons tee shrine at se Seat By ra lawl sane ae rae, er Ee bel poe) fetes rie
5 y 'tne? ' tnadl es aed pane tf ae 5 ee pee She % oped ted pen jon oe ny oe re tat as oe oA it wy Mood aie thet sae Fikes Pie Sad ' ~ woe hed betes ad aS . neineny pat peen dt ~ ye, sin toes Bowes ee pes oe ny prey. panes, shook & "eet ed odes yo magi by : ba fae A es pas me oA ns et Eaaaad sree pend ok vs, Boge on, Sd Seat a "net eee Z pape at pay) me, Sad : . ? 4. ' £ Fare eer : fae tet ta vi non n won xX bon tft cane' " pas onal on, of oS oe col fon. os te on, era 4 F; ae tes iad ag hove oe ie ope ee oo Pa mS 'aoa %S ao nes te ' biG peers, eo my 7 sy wa fae ee bees we deed eal ° rape me pes a a pet ay aa = z 4s . Seed? Ls ee Pad one rn 7 ed § E Gh z , ve ' a wee. LL ns tA os oad os ° ° tL:
agen we Po aed has tes nerd 4 pa po, Paw, : oo eet rn node ai rare ree tba me wry wt Ao rece en on cecead ° wee 'rail a, pow Carel peer ps beet ot 3 we as dns rm tone Loe 54 ad ret o- 3 ape i ores on wy ane) tS newt wd ye = a, re Fd ' og a tt Emm pen ooh, " iif at Pon AS pod poe Pet yer a 33 ath yaees vn ne when or rane we aad mm bead ae :
ot, 5 Nee iad feos wen ia So * pee Y fond co i je . o 2 Be a oO ie ey % piers, ard ben ¢ ger ys ee eae! ¢ SA baad ad rt ; , Bed pen, Sean ad ' a3 weodg é os was, we mn, a we boot * oe EY: d an gs Fait: LE xe re, sae! aos et ed w no eee, ey red raat te?" _ te wee r ae Pated. pan ¥ nee, Ro - se ae os fon pe pede iy od a & rs ee cae bot ty aed oe com : on a a wy 6 aoe bok re a, wh ora ieee tigen a eed 3 oe seed Lasiot on e 3% eee ae i, "4 hs ae A nn) s pons ae bere om hab we aorta we a wet aes ined my shod a ee yer mE La anne a £4, oe, eng, ww oe eel tats wot ack my 'ned ee Ea ne KP fear ay Seo ia we oon pe ot ee 'ach an aoe pean oe ded. 2 Poet eae pan Sn wee oon wou, tow Be ped as bat Ee sol rene wee ~ fed Fosse coven : sy peed nes cord Kod -- ee gee carded cate) + pee wine ned * et oe ee "a oft ben Pega "eed. fe oo Ae aa awe "Aah, seinen wee od © fen rare, 4 wen fone oars whe yer " 'aed So on, Seed L% Peed yee Newt Reed wen eau pon yaaa bao rena tet word: iced ry pied ies, oy. raat Biatees ters pw 4 rane. we Prenat yer ee rae tere hed ve Seal roa "eud 2 ad es Let prrek oe x were het road feng ed raat aol aad ben pees mod eres gown pen, Past ae oto rae oe hea ve "doo len ons ws on eS bel oe sebed ry -- Eh w. oF panes " ale leat aes 'easie!" wn we od re, a y* a 4 a a yey Iron, oe we, ze w tse bed ee & % oi ge weeed ect i oe pas ve seek pee coaad 'naner & wee fon, poe fir ed opt v* a fe £ 2 heed eee t hanes eet ae) ee fed "eg pod ; cd ta iw aw pied ped det a fading m4 OY hE. CRIES EERO "ge Chevys y CAR. Se OHSG Tf LOTS post. The applicant should have raised the points that he did not YE x belong to the same grade or was junior at that point of time. After working ia the same capacity without abjecting to it back then, he could ote * oe & os ~ : AY = ~ ware STATE MIEN NY are specific and categorical about fis specific lapse in complying with the Instruction issued fo Aim vikhe letter. It ig submitted that vide his representation the applicant had sought for perusal of 37 documents which were voluminous in nature and enllecting the same required time but before any communicahan could be made fo the applicant he representation on 26.01.2017. Therelore the disciplinary authority after going through all records passed the necessary or ders. If is alse submitted that the applicant did not prefer appeal to bis ap mpellate authority Le. Director Postal Services, sam sabalpur bub sent a petition fo Respondent No, 2 who after going through the necessary documents 7k A * upheld the order of Disciplinary Authority. {tts also submitted that the contention of the applicant that if is the duty of the Accountant to de the needful work is also wrong since the applicant who was alsa DDC & 53 $3 3 3 $ 3 $ $ 3 3 $ y i r is SOTS ft Pnaaag LoS LS ed +.
ace Perrys © ree oe YS 4 whey BEERS Ss 3 y ve bane:
a?
pyicant v > g The a e te sBkeh, 3 eke ne res u SUR) for re + ny St Stig AU, any hE reque i serial Wes ~S ?
OL?
"yey Seve 23.0% at x.
a opt » Discint y 3 passed | yen As pay wi af SRQTED f re See.
RO ton 4 thed a pe x x submi ss re The applica feck'.
ative of und we me without ¢ hment ms N ed it upholding the pr ots pondent Na.
rope Res % ¥ ' x goers ued to the anglicant on 02.
xy .
~ % ¥ bit ve N x BY lene eee gore pad ms oy Sea?
erbaty PRG rep were:
' 4 wood wed nape oe, re GS & AOTS Ww ~ clocurents % thease the € eof Cas * go not the Jorumen the ¢ sorne oF x get ey NS S an af op hatic Ma Ww hment © 3UWTHS t eced f s Gut as res > ba os ted ee teed oe leat ae ft "xa?
nan Set an, aes Para z pes 1 "hee fae fast ay -
; ith ree, wetess ty aan , ; 0S wy, tae whee pad acd Sea spewed, iy hy Le an Y . om end hood as am Le pers my om : 3h
-- ese ane a a paing ry poh psc at Loe my on vprere . ora . ra vrm peed nny, "" re, oe 3 fog bo one ie eet of jews ewe hk on oated, ~ eet ay renwe mend. fon ef fs - oes het oa it ott fet Seek pa Send "st ae z oa oA So ; 'a yee Pag Fae Ro rtoon, ot As pa pete, > pane Ue boa adore ne i pete t co oe i vet bead ms ve Sue on * "wn. : pee ween ond a, Sub a ont att, sano an von my pe ba coeed fat sed sapeed os ra ected ere iy pol pend aeee poet beten peat : o a! ahead pees sek g pe ay bt bern shook pores pon ce reas os 7K panes cd , 4 wre gn rad coat os iM wetin ze, rs ga et, Aon erodes ms were ra) " aay wn Srrbeg f a pen . a rn, Ww a3 ; fons Aes inewede + a3 ae: wi oo pean : oa iy fore we we ote, yr ret pow, Sis pee) were i fan eedies ora 2 C3 '3 if 'i oi ; hed boot poe oft ve Poot $ oy at ae as . Sot 'ae aa aw Ba r cote 0S rags a thy wrt nn 4 a wee we Lp Ld s eet on Sot «, Le teas os bags' wp ied et wee "est? m4 ws, 4 ' i ae ios 23 % seat lel Oe we, rae tA ~ hao? . oe ; fy pes ews Lawes . tone rae Naot oes, yy pes) wont yee nat beac ve : eo Cored " de as dave . wy eat fh a deed ot ie who rm ma bee om whet, . we ie Wa pes begs i rn, wm eed hee, es. J on « =~ [4 age eoeecd £5 'at Sink ee pes a hos rome m OL x ee Es aD iol 1 oe. $ > em vest of onnen * apes ms ae porodk toeeed Hat tps, pa aed awe ye bed a vat ag aad meet Sots ope Bors "On oe om te ra) ys poe pon . , Randy * tbe who od pan a Aa ¥ ' th 4. 4 cae 3 " Faced 'sl Ys won et eel fa , Bs io an ~ vid seem a basi am , "eee we wet ' obeet oe nt shon$ oo d peat Pad psd ane hy fans poe ae oy wees, Favger shew Fiped nl pes ay pons pdt rn ak oe need 8 'st ws em won eee ay wives ne] ree Seine 4 nae pad gon iy Sona ee Ay on ter al os yon ; ones bus ies "4 'ines ¢ fae " re eo ra " a 2 eM - 5 wy Pose aes ee sod os 'dood wa a wi fone tk tod £% gore os yee . ops y on es 4 yore oe cord sects mous deed we ih rot peeed. ry te wloce oe ¥ iid fn oy es : 2 pon sew 'ar oO My ret Wh % ' ~ ve woke Soe iy 'had pee i ny BS ree a3 ee, tg crt, pan on) pases ' we sera ey we aS in ony ; ; Fes re eee Rd ies City oe gen we pa ne Abs tee, DESs pres Go aon' arei ore "i x Gores & wags "Ae os, sen? $7 ' z $ , ee, 2 nil Les, ats oe wy en a, ae hed, toon "era, "S 7 pra na Seat wey eens, a ; n 1s ° oS ey. olen wend, Ped : tay ee errees (fae. BR Be et sheet Qe o es Th hee ve ASR ce feB sees Say ye Mee wag Maer ore Ao when, 4 we "est pd a wt ey pees : vars im on fon wep oe bees re os a0 Lf fea a ty ay ae sooo ca nah pati 2 wd "at Jens Eee, om «<2 Saal mo cm went en "tt 4 a pees wt ve pe pos tgs peed pres ai haut 'tt So 2 Pac pee me Ro yore il a wy pe Sn jee pans] pores z "net aed : ce Poe ry ee pons re z Moree.
" Saget 'shewd See wees, aon cd ee cat fet Be 'et veel é i nee seed on ay : . é ; pe eee $ howd pee a pone ~ * 5 fen pie * Ion See ne won fe, toot wy oe ad oe Foe} Sees a : am, rs, toy ra we ryt oe ifs ened mt one ei eens opt % pais q * Lan we heed cert ad ed Ss, Kane wns vs bob Cees, terre Fast any, pas + ent "fore ye ae Z nny, : ae oy pa 3 Ls ", ' nm wn on fs 4b bet Fase "ee . < Ly "e 4A ae my fae ee fs 4 a3 eae ee Kee vat os pee ty oe oan ca wt pid 2s aed tag pe hers fee , aed ee ne td us eed ee) ZZ ° ae od tae ree poet 5 "aed * Jeg ti pee ae on vee. beet tage 4 sey rane spoees, oo ree be treed on bos tek Facac twin a koa pes ety . teat bead ore. ty ad me a pea o, we te fas) pene, on . San. oon shedt ; $ ee yee - é et we pea te, fo, : ms pore "ree eae Pak tg Roe t3 Sree' eas wre ; aero, Sora a ood, ? 'an? Lb siamo. 'cP oe ah pe werd fe, not aM aa) ee, ead secon, rake ret oe baad ~ a a" a oe cs eee aes a z "ai a > 5 vy ne a reed » Ses fat F om ay is pred id os mm a oA 'eaid) ww gee as * rere ad get Aent yet onere tet wy aod Naat pees a me tet ON , Ay Ned mA oe 'tone ed Se ee ores pao) weed fae oe oe, we, Ay eae noes ae oy arm peed ta P hag ie, vong en, peed ne "hat " Ay boat fea teh Saud Fat ore nn a a ad ore : ws Ns wt A oS nid 4 gee oe eos Jeorbu Soe see "at ys cod oon igs "6, rs fedeiny g LA es ied ae ~*~, Fa' cM pa we ' °. wy flag. og ~ pa sad eA me, m3 Snpk Board see ne haat po we 3 pad * he bei Co hen. vid! wee oo, eee Fae bead dead i on Nad wo penn Fs eS wpe vod Ps sad bases! bao bind , " bow es foe! ime an rr Lp ed pod 4 L4 aed A tad om hed peed "hoon ag e ony es Nene! 4 7, ae --~ : Lo "net oe fo von ped ee haat ao , uh oo et we fe whe. oy a ed thet a as << cA org we ie ' hoes ay ty os ~ me and us bes ie oo a teed pasa wn eat fag panes 3 oe ey ay wrens 13 ene as we haa Fito raven os wee wenee yee we as 'see teow, "eat og y ag Ras Moeed ee, ea Soacd on oo; Pe basa a Food 2 rent oi wos + eet, ae whe inne ry mE pal shoes toe oe Son Saw, Ue cree pt oed, 3 pouse peo 2 ; = eons fo eek ; weer, ' ~~ re on need 'ag ". eee eee oma "wat Mood poem, oe * ional eened pees cs goed ood Roe Sex ayy Soon. a o, os at ea orcad a wee t a on) . epee aes poms fap enn, Gs on tod a Eos qed, 3 wea "eo faed pn 23. pate re pee oF oy $5 cae cn an Sites é ees / : pas feetee caakey "ase! Neve 'att "eek x pr, apa ee ae won th Sls Pec nee cae; pons "
a tren one ae bad ee hent rae) i aa ial nee sont rae "vd. ee pode, oe nid £08 a Pay eas x aot We ek facxd oy rae fn, Mt saad we. to nok te pes one aE yee ie, ae aa Soot est . 5 ,, "at we feu o me . whens Serna? an seen, pa ne a Se ay "f tas "ah oA 7 coal aes aes hen nee, G4 ee oe A tend: soon "hood ee gon he x * id pao ree hed = tay sete, ar: apa o "ty cecoroodeee bie o, hy bey a 'ead 'te me oS ta ¢ oe, :
Creed i foot $ £ nm Me, wee y a a cad hes ¢ aS , ak ay tent A es Bea om an a wet ee: sheet ad any Z oe ate ah, ey Sere peal Cant ape Seok pea Semen gee Bot wry pees ten:
Rend peooes ws eee, ret, nal Be pd Seat ren os wht foe Pe "fs ae ths if gs vee < bon .
ae ra fee) a ue wt % ." rag a ea her hoot mes *¢ ook of hoo? ey eed poe, La 4 cd ' yee wae red hore. te ~ the es et anges, on 'oad "yrs, 3 sere ves, tree z ne wt ', a ted pea rere. ae ¢ 5 ae so ba @ ; ° a o ree ' 3 bee es: Ss vat ae, ni on ts m x pe os GA fs ie ay oh eee open dork tf aad wee we vee, 4 oe Pgsd Pn ws wears, co fe \cagl Leia Feat! rae even ol ar is pee, oo & tees oe tact, pea tS rT, } a ' a Boaped ined x Fel oe oo ye ie "st Bee thes "A "4 wee Bed Me, ae es rs, wr, :
oe wey oe: yee bor + ee pos on, vans eon rye ieee, ms seven, [on x Snwit 3 koa ia a ed bode fee we ei aaa ey on my tony oe. ten Wea vt wot me Irae owt ye oes nek Laacd aoe. Ninel ;
hey oe vot pan A ie a nd es 'nd bow im Bae oa wine aad ve tree. we, were "nat we & Aen hee ref Sy 54 a on net as pon . bee wey * "nd cad 'ay z Satay th Aon Ly ton ven ae one fo roa on Se oo ad Feed Sodl cd ah oe est om we whee anced ee airy ones oe on seo? 3 ent de ry ae nine fae, ag daily, ee pen Ccgeed nade yey x wer Bene, pace aed veh Bey aw ie soviet fey pee od at aS. ' yee. wines: fort, oad "nest "Ce "a3 es: oS dene, gon op : 2 . 'es : wt poe 8 et nt rod Sea xy ee GL en AE pak heed ne peck pon ue baie wed ret 'is 7 dot oS ard Tribunal in OKEPCising its j juni ' isdice fon of judicial review would net iy MENAGS OF Tact arrived at in the departmental : :
& case of malatides or perversity, Le, Mere Phere fe an eselaeeen he - where MHEPTe is Ao evidence 3 support 3 finding ar where a finding 7 fey w ri dois rth ¢ Wires a yity rare le Sy eyes Y Sh Wan CORSO, ay DEERE Nave arrived at that findings and so. tong as there is some evidence ts Support the conclusion arriver af by the departmental auth arity, the same has to he sustained (vide Deputy General Manager ... vs Ajai Pa Kumar Srivastava , { 2021) 2 SCC 612,). No such case has } been mad out hy the Applicant either in his defence submitted to the charge Memo nar in his appeal or before this Tribunal requiring this Tribunal to interference in the matter, pant jek feed 7 epee os ae fi Tribunal is aware of its limited scope in interference in disciplinary proceedings. In the casé of Union of India Vs. P. Gunasekhran, 2015 (2) SCC page 610, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under:
'Nooo disciplinary proceedings, the High Court is not and Cannot act asa second court of first appeal. The | hieh Court, in exercise of its powers under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, shall not venture into re-appreciation of the evidence. The High Court can only see whether:
on, pene pes ;
2 4 5 sepa, : " "ef;
road GS ea et bon ames Ps < S, re erin 5 3 aes "s sheet ae fou page ig eet be : a see, bale £7 ae 'a! fasd s % tae ye RS if ect Shane Faas po oad 'hee ei we ra pane ye Ronee its om, aa Sona eek CS Feat a Ta gt EE ey ko Sint ; co 4 a mn ad at ae aS hae stot pnd os py yt, see os ete, ny Pons acad AR ek and Coe? , a) Sp on eer » ee) é vy, ; aes "dead No, a % oy Pot, * ora es be Bow 2 Si a <i ee. lad oes areal LP o® perak is a eee, *. % an Paar ie ne = om he we Sanat es women ey 'at SoA oe a on £5 ¥ "ped lek oa ag pen, shed ates shad Ga ae a booby X een Be my we seo oe et et RE Saag on ee Gon, » cael Sener cs . minced wee, Nin eet eet -- ie pate 2 Mee peg d Mm Bh Fr & a % ty nett ee) Fa ee Wa "e ae oe a x : oa pen hss Bes we re oe eee it he spent eee aed # ra d is oat Soe} oe tars 4 Kad ae} rn on oa Peed rey on, a ead It Shedd zy a nae bot oot Eces "nah oN vee. Whe Ps a, acs sores m, wn ene ree, es 25 ca = Le Ne coed phon ; "ne PO, we posse iw Be me cen baad Brod etl . j tad ae o, pe hed eo 3 s aps mS. (os, ees pee wee, om poe pad oe oo on, Pees) ey Serre A pee, at a oad iy Sod " bor Saoia eA 1 pat Ly eo iooas peed ine ce het bat ce OY:
: box ee on, . baceed ted SKS "ned te ce a9) er wane th te, OE x oe a Ea iz rn ire ten po pe one get pee ee _ Rea yee epi sar bores Lp deed. anh foe cca Neel bes Che 6 a ag me e at ay bees 7 Poe Sy, ? aon att Bs a3 m z Laty, we Mat en cae o, - bak rom eS ye ae 'ad Dy os pared hoe 23 poe Saad "~ oe "t "3 on, bcd : eS oes ee oe 2 thot BD od ees i, 3 apaey wen np on Ko a OEE oe res fon oe ont rt ceed Poa a we eek poe ;
+3 ae ro ty ee it Gabe ie bs va os of a ss vk a ES be tee wore had ras os ons * 4 "nee ees ¥ af we fas te x ee te tod w rl a fe aS Feeed os eo be + iow a ORG te : tad eed = oad axl Fi 4 wre nad * ae Ba) a * :
ae awe tp 5 'eet eres hood hee : ae) : oy Ps i : ae ee a rien Aa Sy ; oe Ba, eet Ta we eal Pa pon Sat menees ed rs weed re Sh ome Bp "3 pad tex Son my i See ve pn ed ME see Baoan al cS 3 ina Me pee Re ao an ae eed pane: % Panes Sig Loe Nee ha * he sre pee eos teed TO Ae o New ree we , pe we : vornn RE . ean. one Oe ¥ ianead yor pa tad oe oa YF cod reg ee haat pad x4 Br, , ei, sant we pe pow ny, is a 2c a <a eae te od oy te Ts Sat ae Peed on a won Ly go. wy Ob gy Spee panes ms anne, "yes is ¥ ee ong . tend ohh we er yong 3 os fe 2g bepanct om x ars fe St. terre yo yon aa wees, tg. ee misiooed pod hows e Se ie nee 2 Son ie) pee 4 : : on oe. om o Foon, nea gee tere ; OG te aie NS . ead ton, a poss ecea mL] ui a a oe eee eed Peo A be aad cA a os a ES: eat - es. - 7 oo) Pond a Renae aes pe fo gees fp eR En a ko OS ¢ bee oa a and :
ea a a << re moe gars > amt ne shed ed x perm sacee %y if HA ey ioe oie oe wy seen ms At Coe ad. 5 fen 05, Boece oF a pas ke re wd 'ay aed oa Sees ft pn pore Last ees fen GQ eee tS pee ae fen ae on nod 'al ey re ee eee ee ee vege oS ae pon feed A een, Pilon " ee Dies yannay ou geen " peace eeben, vei Fa ys S39 pared, pore. * a coe Sy thnk i es et ay ros, pttons, ene ° pn Sn oS a reine hee "Ari etal ay pee pon Ne o ee a van, thee peg Coe Oy ed aeoeri . oes ba tee he re ; cone we oo) oS as tf oe ore ay oi w re, 'ad. he oes met > hed . ry pest a vy anet pres GF) ee jo 'hon rv, oat yon a mB wg Prac! + fan on ston oot, eae road 3 wey sere ~~ + ot 2 8 "B wy Ey Pact en rot Ke d 3 m~ wane wa cA