Karnataka High Court
Asst Commissioner And Land Acquisition ... vs Smt Sushmitha W/O Chandrasekhar Patil on 26 March, 2009
Bench: Anand Byrareddy, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
.' "Ema .L.§§i;:s1é:::1.§'§iAi:a,
-no.7 A WA 303{3~3{}3?;':2(}{3'-'§ Ir: 'Z'Ei§%Z £--iii}?-€ ::<}:;§%';' 5}? §{fXE2.?%,%'i'A}<;% <:::%2<:a_s§*;' £:z:%::zs§:::.;=§ M <3{}£,§-?>AR€3fi ~ "
E'}fifE'E§i} 'Ems; *:';a:: :25T%i HAY (.2? Maggi % PREs§NT V 'V H 'ma i§<:}m3L§e: ;»q;»'e¢J:;::3*z*:V<:E: A»§4s;a;€:3; A':3':"::é;§-§§':1».>;,.%:**x4' . . . V V V' 2
-'m:«:: H<_>§-z*;:a:,2: MR§g;;,:1s~;}'2c:°:&2:...A;':;i.'§*<§%;2-»a;§3{":§%;a;i;;a &§3w:3A w..a..1e¢;'3Q3fi~.3§3:;? ,.{';2§'e;34'* . §%%§'§'W§%;RN: 'V ' V' 'i"h.€': Asst. ' _ zmé £z€i§I{§ A€:q_1:i:4iti55£:' }i}fii£:::::1',' Bifiexrg V ____ " '«1.;:__ _ * 'E15,-ziuk. &, I}i:;%'L Eéiéigazji _ 1'; ' _ HA:>P§:LLAN*r {EB}; Srzi S: S. §{x;§3:2,1'111a3};, . Tb " ~ .. §'s1'€D:
. W Ci:a _t1:;£.1":r;1é;'i?:;t1-zzar §3'ati};,, ?%§g'&: % {3«:~.;:":' ..§f§01i$f;§1Q1£i,v. ' ' Rjs kifizazi Césiazijg E§i::§:1fi- iéisi; aiaar.
5'? iiajnjapisé, _ '~.f:'§;'rO Aaifivappafi , A.ge:£i- 4°?' }5'€:31'S, " __ " ' « " €,}cI§:: Ag;::~icuEture.
V V 'i;%V,_ E-":'ai;a;3, " S/0 Agiavapya, figecfi -<'%:$ yeam, €}(3<:?: §:gi'iCE11t1}.1'f:'i.
§?:*:3pon<}ents 2 52. 3 am R] 0 J.P¢Nagar, Bi€§€:%1', Dist"... Bidar.
. S§hiv.21m:zrthy, Sf 0 Gurushairana, fige: 38 years, See: Business, 3%; 0 Bidzar, I3:E.st., Bidar.
Ravi, Sfo Kafiayya, Age: 30 years, (399: B11siI3.es$, V 1?] <2» Ragilavezxdm C')c:;1::;ny--,._ Bidar, Bis: Biciar.
. Smt. S¥1}OCh&}f1.':§..~::"
WI 0 31:, Agfiz 43;j,:€8rS,' "
f}<:<t: Hoiigehoid, ' V R/o Biéar, Eiist, z3ida;~.,_ , Eiubhash, Sjo Maiifiiappag' A. V'
2 ' ..... .. V C}<:<:: £3uS'i1;1<:$S,_ §z,:.o"ai;m:~,' Efiidagz Hg:;t::fian::§é'1_R}:é, Sf <3 "f:§i&€:1_€ifé};§11ap;}£i, ' . Vfiggg: 4:?'-.. years,
-« L ' " -- __ €Z3:;::::: [3.gr§g;5£1ii:11re§ ' . '££{<}E3§dar, Eiist Biziaz", Shivappa, " Agét; 33 j;e;,%;z';<:», V ' Cficsc: Sérviceg §€,!{: Eidar, Biszt. EE:'»i£;i2i§', WA 3C%3§~3i}3'? f '2{3@4 'QJA 3{}3{3a3{}3? ,3 '2{§'{E<% ii}. "€'.%1{é Bisziar Sziilaéiara Safiékazfi §<;ar$<:ha.n€: Rim p1{;yt%::"::'; §~§€3"a:s%:t:g €f{>--o;3€:rat§s:e ;'f$<:><>ir:é!:j'g;, A.3.§a?3a:1.
3. 3. $2113., §€a}:3am.21'th 85$, .. Wis; iaira Mchanimezi Za,11::nc'111:~idiI;, figs: E58 j€E§?&I'S, O<i:<::=: Hcmfitéhoid, Rf <3 !%.§iabafi., Taiuiz 52. Bist. Bieziar.
2.2. Sidrama, S] 0 Gmrappa, Page: 38 years, __ .
G::::::AgriC11i'n_1re asiid ' Business, Bi::1ar,. _' ' , _ _ V_ .
sfiéfifanagar 4' _
Taluk 5:, Digi': Erzigig-:::,.*;'. " . .,,.§'~?E:"i:E=§P{,}§'€D1?§f~I'I';§
(E3? :<'v.Vswani§%;L: <§(:"{%;:; %
Sri V.Ra;:ga:'Cf%fig,"3§d*a,_fb:j 23 E} to 9 6:3 ¥<?~ 112} '§"hi§; Wifiii Aggjeéii Séiieigéggiiiar Se{;"'{.im:3; 4 9E' 13:5 E='~Zarr:aiaka E-{fig} {i€::'u1'§. fie? '§3?ja3='332ig ix; $?;é: { afiiaié {Em csrdszér jfiafifififi in aim Writ 1-'é:t%i_é<f:vn ;_T{§{3:-7-'% 1§;,..;:,j :]:84.s;; 2:90 ; §i fw----£%iSfi€.§G; 20$: 2. {Eatcd 95. 1 3 mag. g%;§3_.;€8} szésmizig 0:1 fa}: kxaéaiézzg tacéajg z%?%PsE'€ D .____;rm%A§2&é'i§:t:§*; é}v'.:{§;€..3iiVfi:%Z€j§ {Em faéiawizzg:
JIIDGMEHT Vi} "Ls, "'I'*¥;i:§_:. a§:$§:_}e3} <:0m§3:;g 2323. far hsaxizlg, {E16 {Z§~::s'iie:*;'2.::3m:§t Azivsatais fig 3r;§;':»33*éE. 21% 2:ez1gfi":.
Wfla 3{}3{'~i%C}.Z3?;'2{§{>% {"32 'E'h:5 {axis as: s§:23.i::£'§4 are that r€$p03:.i{%i€:m.s .1 {<3 {he pu:'{?h.2::§5:"s af :'2:r:=;f£:i::-miai Siiffs §1'€)II: the iééih r:é§;p<3r2d.;:1_:*;$ :v}"ié.«::i2 V is $1. §'€',gi-fE§t£'.":I'8E;"§ Eimzséfig C0~0p€%r£~:tive S<:1s<:%i4:ét§;; it is S'i£i'§.€§:{:§' }-'§9}3:e:.V_'3'3;"i;é*;€'§:
hati a:*:{';:z§3."€*.(i land mfiasming 3 a.c:'€:&;J g'¥;x:_zt:é.i'si.' "iii ';¥*§::.€f>':"3 V' :::f Aliahati Viiiags, Bizéar Tailiii, for f0z111ai.i0:1:_':'2f.¥3§t€i$ "E0V'§',}{? '}f5Ei"€§Vi¥;i§:£§ i'€)"'.A --' Eht: mtzmjbttafs cf fi1:';'f $(1é{.'i{fi'fy'. Tias ?i€,I£:§}%iiS§§'ié}E'v1."j;}iT'{K"{3*§Z(iV'§}fV§'§f;'E§v:'1c'3'%;'iI£g %;:{:¥'<A:.:1 iziiiiiaisai uiaiitzr €Z.TiE1aptr:é:"-iE £3?" E;:111:§ }'K:*{;"$f:i§;iti<';i;::. éaci, 1894 é_:h<:z*a15:"zT:a_f*§4€::' z'€ft:r3:é:e:% is .'..§§1e::? .§i6£."; ».§,-;fl£};(}I'iZ:i',' Vfi1€ Sacirzty' 132213 proésiciafi with the szaici 1:::fi{'i VA afamsaid, The:
agjpsiiani herein %.:as:i*i1owsvé:f"*iii£fi:éi€.¢€i__ pzé:)<:c§e*::9}.£;tig3 0:1 Lira f(:::)t3L:'1g '€113? €316 SCfi?ic:ty"i;a{3 _ :.»¥it3?Ti;a.%£{1"t:1r,£c* C<3:f:d§ti01;$ 01' gtfaflt 311$ Eiiim pu:";:>::>s€ '§:';1' v:=*§3i(:h fisfi §é%.f{}_{§ -$1?éx9§'~z»;€#c;35_éi3t::(i--~ ami hat} §§:iSSf3{§ 21:1 Gfiifif 131316131" §§c£.*€i0.::. 44éA of §§h.e"r": ?i:f,i4_€%}2'%'r3'§%;§::g €3.36 said .§;~m:i&;. "T'E":3?S 'was; that $2.:%:3k'é{r% : "3§I§£~'.i§T:IiT{*:£" .:§}§<:?§*;:5;i§{:::_:g£: §1éé§?0.:--<:=:3----«E;.§":::% ézearmsii Sitzgis Jzzifige ii; §RRP,E'€:_>x»'3 '§84"E~ %és:,":.;'2:;>'<f:i' :--V .c;; at §'%:3*é<:.;%3é€2{}/ 2&3 .1, ' V' v.{l%3. 2¢5;a;z"§:{:§~:;?E'T:Sé::g§:: Jufiigf: bf; hig 01:13:' giattgi 0:"§.¥;1.2{}£}3 E133 _ §j§{f§€§, §h:'»:i',"i'.12r§:%;. résp0§:{i%:::tS~»pi1:'€rh3.s€r$ have p;*:::éu.::f::{§ C€§"§i§.C€1i€fS E0 §:_$';é5}§::ii$.§:"« $13: may 'W€%i'€ the m€"I11bfi}"S of ihé 2" .:'€$p<3r:£§€::§;?~Saqtisiry __;é:';f%:£ 'Q13: thig fat: ezrmié ';3;€}t his (£i:;§>u%,:+:§§. E<"'21:*ther, in so far as 13:36 €§}£€5§7€3iSi:'t s:?:»f fiat: pmvm" 7:3}; £133 ?s$S§§'é§L8Z}'¥, éikyggimisgioixez' "zxmistr $~3::'%3l:31'1. V' <«'%»7§~!'§ 2;}? E§_':{:"i Air: §&_2a$ c<;§;<:£:r:1€a.::§, ii: ix m:eii:::e<:§. '{3}; ma'-: 153331622 Siizgiz': 8 WEE 3£}3€§«3{}3?;'2£}€}'§ :3 &t:£,§gc% ':}::e§§ '£336: Ezmd 'W83 a<::q:x:§;t"*€{£ 1:m:§§~%1" {TiE2€«:;"3f€r~'i?'§§ <3? $.18 Am. '£'iI:1e £i€if,§E.1.i§§'§"§;i{1}§} 1m~:.ie:" {fiT.§:a§';Ei:1'~i§ 01' {E26 z'§{_::§T fzsaz" 'L325: bttxazzfiit Sc;;<7i»:=tf;§r' t:':::::§§§3i1g ma §"€€.§%Ei_"£"€EIE§';'.}"£E of ma: S<:.~=:7i::i§; is feta" 3 p:.:E'3Ei=:.*. :v1;'._:j§}fc*:;é: .. e:§'a.ii %.%:€=.m§7£>:'5:, $3.25 §.t"Z8}"fi{3€§ Efiizzgic &u:,§g£: has ayizaeé, ibuat ':§<%é:id::;--«[{14g"a_ :?«soz.:§<i Efaéiaréz imfs a§3g:21f.g*:2:ti<31;3. at €133 arid §:§3<%n{:£€,' €'.%j_1::%;:::a1r*::§a:é1f'p,2;a;5?;$€{§ 2)? 1};%:_ 'x fass.§s€:2«ur.:t {»€}Z}.'1I1}.iSS.EQn€i" was Wfi:E1§;~:1§. j1a1i%§s:%i'i;_::té€311! §.§ '*;a:§':s,;:;'i:3:<v>'*£.§r.?i<3+:i §>js:' thfi: 1;tf:a§:'§';.:éz:% Sizzgifr Jtlfi gs: €:§<:a§. t:;E3l£:.;5§¥';siStc';';z'3":. .%3a€} :iot. égggmai 11:3i'i:::£:$ to {ha §u:'atb;;a§srs "*£'}T'}'€f"'§.§§1£}1lgZ1fE{§ amier ami €123 ertim" $2215; Timed <';;«3{3"4"tA§:s_.;Z3 (':Lr3i1::f.':V::z;"'§ in thatig {hare was viaéaiism 0f p£'i§3C§§l}:$; .§_:f iL§£fiL'£i E'Eé.;E:: J§1.i$'£'.J:£3f§_' i11g:'§ie Girifir having btiezfl asged Wét:'%10u§'AiSei'1:in '3.i.2{3E<ia:§€%~._*;(: thfi 11r{':k:aTsr::rs-r€:s }{3I1{'§f:.f}f.S. 3? £3 33' V. . . _ --.
this, wh.i<:*%:. és m':{i€:"::é}::és.§§:21}ga_fi;:.tbs §;}f€ff.4§€iZ§i :::;'}§3s3§,. S4. rP%§€§3'{}EI3Vf?i"{1f1"§C§§i fis{§.V{?€fx'3,§{f13 w<:>u.§c:.i '£?i:":h€fii{:'}"1flj§-' 2::z"gm%: éhat 3;: this V" '§_§.£{E.E 3:?" §E'§15f§ii?if}f2; cf Ehé': §:cq:1§sii:i::):1i2 §;§*r;>{%aEr€{i§1}g$, 'ihé: §;:t:s;e1i:'£' :"::$§;;r5:t;;:f§:a;3ajii.~;;s%;:;r:<i§1?:é§s;:-Em §3%J"iI"€ :29: £315: m€::31'b€:*s ref {her Sacéety anii ii fig V3vi£E.2 £i§.§"'«?§.f£§'§,fEvfi'f1€;ITv§}.{3ti¥t?: af actguirizzgg fittés vaEu:«::%3l€ _§)1'(;tp€I'{:§2', 1:313: fi;v:«:}r ::V"v}','1«?';§'\V?'%E? "Semi .Z:i1§TiEi€ §::.1$§_1bE:r$ {if the 30013:}; avian thmigiz ihejg Vi?¥:Z'I'fi 319$ f'h.%:5' ."€I}3%}§::E:§}}'€€$ 91'' 131% fc'Ei(?'€(i}I'}' who vsam :§up;3e:>S€:d {(3 $36 fhé? ':£}§1'I§€ffi;"f3:i%1"i€S sf ihéi a:3qué3i:i<):: and it is GI}. this érauzzi 'éihai. the §"_§§is;é$ta.z2t {'i€;mmés§:;:é<}r:&§'° ham. §.:1.it'_iat£z§. gtzracztetiziizgis and $1213 pa:~:«$::z:£ €325': aréiiirs fazrfiéifing €318 Eazliisz far Vi<3Eafi:i_<f;r; :31" $215 §:€mz:i§tir,3m;. 'T'h€ % WA 303{"}--3{§§3? ,3 2(°3{34 C35 éléevernmmit Advocate Wmzki f'u1"'th€r ctoatezzfi that :10§4Wi_fi=:_sTta:1{iing that the a<%q11iSi'i.§011 was uzieiisr {iiiapfmwii 0f ihsz Qf providillg 2: vaiuzsziéifi iami far the §)'i.lI'§}{3S€?i of digairib:::t'.i{:ii=.;Jz:::';:::"2Lg 'i"h¢:::'~--_ mfrmbers of £126: §"¥::>u$iI1g S(}€,'i€t:%__y*' has %I;€'.__f"I§1 ?3.}af§3az=i?»l§? -.§?i0_ZélflE'f§€§<..a§}<3A' the pmvisisn ef E-aw zmder X&?h.iCh Elm métigtr is fiasésed xA?:>i£E;*§,vt§.1€::'€%'f9:4€ _§§i.€i;;3.<: irate ingigrziiicaficf: when Iiltimaiidy Vis31;}ug:it:<:i'V%31'i§6:rgévas; imistidfid is zmda the miscrhief anii *£.E:;:re:i_'?i>rt:_.V is; $218.. altfimzative, ha xvauici ~:'.'e:31?:;'i£":n.é that {"216 Siam must §i'i0'$'§d.::{i" __€§pp{)r£:1111i?y {£3 taka €7(>r:'€:;:tive 3}3.€iaSE,ii'f§S '£3.12, f¥1is ;ixEg?;:*:»i~.' ()5. Bfi that 35:: ii. ¥";7":".'€§:_§§"~;,i.'.V§;{'*§;V'i¥;"§..¥:itiZi éégzijy' izifmnity in the rzéasanézxg of the Efiaijzsti 'Sii":a§;£{3=-_V{}'m;ig«::: "£31 '$2.9 far as $116: finrlings that the p11r<:h:e1sci"s xvers ~mc:inh"é:;j73 .. e3'i--'._ the Socisty pzims is the sale tfitffié exe<:a1tsd 'i>§2 Jghc their {avatar in respect cf {he Siifis and fjz.1:9§}":a:5r "17;baf"'n:r'1€:r impugmid. was bad as ii wag paaseéé mliier S€t;.i?;;¥u.=Z:)§§."'4~f4?s: f3is3}i€I'if"£353: a€?Q"£.1;§Si€i0I1 was 1211511521" iihapieigfii Of the Act ' ".:u3Ci f11ri:§"_:€:r ma; i 0 }'i§1t3m béiiilg no n{:si§<::x:*. is {$16 }f'€iS}}i'.)I1(§{f3.1f'S pgisr to Eihs
-A ijjimpzzglzad. z(}.IV'j('2ifiI' having bfifiii passaefi, the IEa&§0i1.§£1g ef the learniégi ' Et§ii:§;1::.g,§:i§ig:: on mass Counts €a£.'12'1If}§'. §3@§.ui€.fit:i. WP: i'3£}3G~§3(}3?{2{§f§4 'mi 536:. Thé: aitézmativs g}r21§;cr urgeii by 11116 State as {S1} c<)r";':::(?_?£.iv§::"««_'_T'~v. 1I}€{--,i8E},E'f;fS hfiiflg tiakéffi, is 3 mattrzr for {E16 Statrfi E0 purstic if _!;E*at3 '7' 3:; pcmnits.
£3? '§'£1a gmuntis raised ii": tint: appsaji are h'(l'§R?i:'i"li€I' 2101; fi'm..11dV " €.::1::ab.i:=: zrmd henczt E116 appeal saiemtis {£is:x:nis:a;ezi.'"* f %Ssifi5 KR