Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi

Jiji Joby vs North Delhi Municipal Corporation on 18 August, 2022

                                        1

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37


                   Central Administrative Tribunal
                     Principal Bench, New Delhi
                                O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                M.A. No. 1591/2016

                          This the 18th day of August, 2022

                    Hon'ble Mr. R N Singh, Member (J)
                  Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A)

              01 Jiji Joby, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 39 years, Wife of Mr. Joby K.V.,
              Resident of: 249 C, Pocket E,
              G.T.B. Enclave, Delhi: 110093.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              23.01.1996. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              02 Shanty Joseph, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Joseph Verghese,
              Resident of: 139 -B, Pocket - F,
              GTB Enclave, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              03 Rosamma Saji, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, W/o Mr. Sajimon P.M.
              Resident of: 126- C, Pocket-F,
              G.T.B. Enclave, Delhi: 110095.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              04 Mariamma T. Mathew, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 48 years, w/o Mr. Thomas Mathew,
              Resident of: 163- B, Pocket: E
              Dilshad Garden, Delhi: 110095.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
                                         2

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              01.05.1991. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              05 Amita Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Ajit Pal Singh,
              Resident of: A- 95/A, Shalimar Extn. I,
              Shalimar Garden, Ghaziabad.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.11.1995. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              06 Suni K. Shaju, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Shaji KA.
              Resident of:304 - B, Pocket-E,
              G.T.B. Enclave, Delhi: 110093.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              07 Molly V.G., Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. K.R. Biju,
              Resident of: 234 - B, Pocket: F,
              GTB Enclave, Delhi: 110093.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              24.01.1996. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.

              08 Nolly Joji, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 39 years, Wife of Mr. Joji K. Antony,
              Resident of: 47-C, Pocket: R,
              Dilshad Garden, Delhi: 110095.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              24.01.1996. Presently posted at:
              Swami Dayanand Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dilshad Garden, Shahdara, Delhi.
                                         3

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              09 Veena Singh (Paul), Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Sanjay J. Paul
              Resident of: Qtr. No.2, First Floor,
              MCD Hospital, Patparganj, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              19.04.1994. Presently posted at
              Patparganj T.B. Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation, Patparganj, Delhi.

              10 Sultana Parveen, Staff Nurse
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Shamshad
              Resident of: 15-J, Pocket.lI, EHS Flats,
              Mayur Vihar, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              in erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              19:12:1995 Presently posted at: S.P. Chest Hospital,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation, Patparganj, Delhi.

              11 Ranjeeta Singh, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Manish Singh,
              Resident of: A - 77, Dilshad Colony, Delhi:110095.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Maternity Home,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Seema Puri, Delhi.

              12 Kavita Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, wife of Mr. Sanjay Sharma,
              Resident of: HC - 3/761, Shalimar Garden Ext.1,
              Ghaziabad, U.P.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.07.1992. Presently posted at: Maternity Home,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation, Seemapuri, Delhi.

              13 Sanjay Nagpal, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. M.S. Nagpal,
              Resident of: B- 55/G -1, Dilshad Colony, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              12.05.1989. Presently posted at: Maternity Home,
              East Delhi Municipal Corporation, Seemapuri, Delhi.

              14 Karuna Malhotra, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Vinod Malhotra,
              Resident of: B- 79, Yadav Nagar,
              P.O. Samaipur, Delhi.
              Date of Appointmentworking as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
                                         4

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              10.12.1992. Presently posted at
              Girdhari Lal Memorial Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Ajmeri Gate, New Delhi.

              15 Meena Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Ashu Sharma
              Resident of: A- 72, LIG, DDA Flats,
              Motia Khan, Paharganj, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at:
              Girdhari Lal Memorial Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Ajmeri Gate, Delhi

              16 Seema Verma, the then Staff Nurse
              now A.N.S. aged about: 45 years,
              Wife of Mr. Avdhesh Verma
              Resident of: B- 3/12, MCD Flats,
              Padam Nagar, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at:
              Girdhari Lal Memorial Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Ajmeri Gate, New Delhi.

              17 Asha Dulani, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Suresh Dulani,
              Resident of: 8280/7, Roshanara Road,
              Delhi: 110007.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at:
              Hindu Rao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi

              18 Mukesh Hooda, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 40 years,
              Wife of Mr. Vijender Singh Hooda,
              Resident of 134, DDA Milansar Apartment,
              Paschim Vihar, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              23.01.1996. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                         5

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              19 Nirmala Kumari,
              the then Staff Nurse now Nursing Sister,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Krishan Kumar,
              Resident of: E - 803, Dwarkadham Apptt.,
              Sector-23, Dwarka, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              20 Sunita,
              the then Staff Nurse now Nursing Sister,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Bharat Bhushan,
              Resident of: 19/1, Indra Vikas Colony,
              Mukherjee Nagar, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              21 Usha Rani, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 46 years,
              Wife of Mr. Rajesh Kumar Sharma,
              Resident of: House no.14, Swargashram,
              Nanakram Colony, Radio Colony, Delhi: 110009.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              :03:1994 Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              22 Harjeet Kaur, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 43 years, Wife of Mr. Yashpal Anand
              Resident of: D - 2 /G, Naniwala Bagh,
              Azadpur, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              23 Rekha Gupta, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 40 years, Wife of Mr. Rakesh Gupta
              Resident of: K- 18, IIIrd Floor, Malka Ganj, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                         6

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37



              24 Madhvi, the then Staff Nurse
              aged about: 46 years, Wife of Mr. Sunil Kumar
              Resident of: 2177- 78, Shora Kothi, Sabzi Mandi,
              Delhi: 110007.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              25 Babita Dhania, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Raj Kumar Dhania
              Resident of: B- 2/5, MCD Flats,
              Padam Nagar, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              21.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              26 Manju Kumari, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 48 years, Wife of Mr. Lalit Kishore
              Resident of: D - 10, MCD Flats, Bungalow Road,
              Delhi: 110006.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              01.01.1991. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              27 Manju Chaudhary, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years,
              Wife of Mr. Pushpender K. Chaudhary
              Resident of: B- 123/1, Main Market, Bhajanpura,
              Delhi: 53.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              30.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              28 Saryoo Dutta, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, VWife of Mr. Rakesh Kumar
              Resident of: 1354, Dr. Mukherjee Nagar, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                         7

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              29 Renu Budhiraja, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 46 years, Wife of Mr. Satish Budhiraja
              Resident of. 90, Kirti Nagar, New Delhi:15.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              30 Manju Bala, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, W/o. Mr. Ashok Sharma
              Resident of: 8/105, Nehru Gali,
              Vishwas Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi: 110032.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              31 Gracy Sunny, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 51 years, Wife of Mr. T.C. Sunny
              Resident of: D - 19, MCD Flats,
              New Usmanpur, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              25.05.1988. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              32 Minakshi Tuli, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 41 years, Wife of Mr. Pradeep Tuli,
              Resident of: 2940, 2nd Floor, Street no. 3, Chuna
              Mandi, Pahar Ganj, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              33 Reema Singh, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years,
              Wife of Mr. Jai Prakash Singh,
              Resident of: D- 12, Krishan Vihar, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                         8

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              34 Deepa Bist, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Jitender Bist,
              Resident of: J- 86/8, Dilshad Colony,
              Delhi - 110095.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              30.06.1990. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              35 Thresiamma Kuruvilla, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Kuruvilla George,
              Resident of: 8737, 2"d Floor,
              Roshanara Road, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              36 Florence Martin, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years,
              Wife of Mr. Sandeep Eric Martin,
              Resident of: Qtr. 13, Malka Ganj, Delhi: 110007.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              06.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              37 Lalita, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years,
              Wife of Mr. Manmohan Lakhera
              Resident of: E - 40/2, Khazuri Colony, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi

              38 Rajvinder Kaur, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. Jitender Singh,
              Resident of: 345, Nimri Colony, Pkt. V,
              Ashok Vihar, Delhi: 110052.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              01.01.1991. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                         9

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              39 Kiran Bala, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Kamal Kumar,
              Resident of: X- 323, Street no.4,
              Raghuvar Pura, Gandhi Nagar, Delhi: 31.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              40 Sudesh Bala, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. Ashok Kumar
              Resident of: B- 123/1, Gali No.8,
              Bhajanpura, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              41 Krishna Kumari, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 41 years,
              Wife of Mr. Virender Chaudhary,
              Resident of: 100B, DDA LIG Flats,
              Rajouri Garden, Delhi: 110027.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              42 Mariamma George, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. George K. Daniel,
              Resident of: 32, Staff Quarter,
              Hindurao Hospital, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              11.05.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospita
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao. Delhi

              43 Mary Prasad, Staff Nurse.
              aged about 53 years
              Wife of Mr. Prasad J. Thomson,
              Resident of G-6, MCD, Medical Complex. Gulabi
              Bagh, Delhi: 110007.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              06.12.1989. Presently posted at Hindurao Hospital.
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                         10

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37



              44 Malti, Staff Nurse
              aged about 43 years, Wife of Mr. Raj Kumar,
              Resident of 435/436, P.G. 26, Sec-3, Rohini, New
              Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at Hindurao Hospital
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              45 Veena Kumari, Staff Nurse,
              aged about 46 years, Wife of Mr. Balbir Singh,
              Resident of E -28, Kamla Nagar, Delhi: 110007
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              46 Kukki, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about 42 years, Wife of Mr. Harminder Singh
              Resident of. 3177, 2nd Floor, Punjabi Basti,
              Roshanara Road, Sabzi Mandi, Delhi: 07.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              26.03.1994. Presently posted at Hindurao Hospital
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              47 Veena, Staff Nurse
              aged about 47 years, Wife of Mr. Sanjay Malhotra,
              Resident of: 9/924, Prem Gali, 3- B.
              Gandhi Nagar, Delhi: 110031.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              06.12.1989. Presently posted at Hindurao Hospital,

              48 Krishna Singh, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years,
              Wife of Mr. Sharad Kumar Singh,
              Resident of: C- 53, Y.P. Pitampura, Delhi: 110034.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              49 Poonam Vasudeva, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 49 years, Wife of Mr. Anil Vasudeva,
              Resident of: 303/7, Gagan Vihar, Delhi:110051
                                         11

                                                                O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                                M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              06.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              50 Bimla Pathania, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Lt. S.S. Pathania,
              Resident of: 73, MCD Flats, Nimri Colony,
              Delhi: 110052.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              51 Santosh Kumari, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. Vijay Kumar,
              Resident of: Flat no.4, Ekta Apartment,
              Shastri Park, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              06.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              52 Sunita Bahuguna, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 48 years, Wife of Mr. R.C. Bahuguna
              Resident of: 44, Ashok Park Main,
              Rohtak Road, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              11.05.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              53 Kochurani Mathew, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 49 years, Wite of Mr. sunny Mathew
              Resident of: Quarter no.3,
              Hindurao Hospital, Delhi.
              Date of Appointmentworking as Staff Nurse
              n erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              54 Indu Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 49 years,
              Daughter of Late Bodhraj Sharma,
              Resident of: 12, S.B.I. Colony, GTK Road, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
                                        12

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              55 Suja John, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 39 years, Wife of Mr. P.B. Varghese,
              Resident of: 4, Paramedical Flats,
              Hindurao Hospital, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              23.01.1996. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              56 Rekha Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 39 years, Wife of Mr. Pankaj Sharma,
              Resident of: 460, Street no.11, Bhajanpura, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              25.01.1996. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              57 Madhu Bala, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 42 years, Wife of Mr. Pradeep Sharma,
              Resident of: 460, A/1-C, Street no.15,
              Vishawas Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi: 110032.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              58 Shashibala Bhardwaj, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 47 years, Wife of Mr. Tejpal Bhardwaj,
              Resident of: C - 57, Yadav Nagar, Samaipur, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              59 Aruna Chhabra, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 41 years, Wife of Mr. Anil Kr. Chhabra,
              Resident of: 194, GTB Enclave,
              Dilshad Garden, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi
              10.10.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospita,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
                                        13

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              60 Monika Sachdeva, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 42 years, Wife of Mr. Dinesh Sachdeva,
              Resident of: C - 3/93, Sector -11, Rohini,
              New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              61 Varsha Rani Jain, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 43 years, Daughter of Late K.C. Jain,
              Resident of: 3991, Gali Ahiran,
              Pahari Dheeraj, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              62 Ragini, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 50 years, Wife of Mr. lqbal Singh,
              Resident of: WZ - 221/S-100, Vishnu Garden,
              Street no.4, New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              02.12.1988. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              63 Meena Sehgal, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 43 years, Wife of Mr. Hemant Sehgal,
              Resident of: 98-A, Old Gupta Colony,
              3 Floor, Krishna Gali, Delhí: 110009.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              26.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              64 Geeta Rani, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 43 years, Wife of Mr. Krishan,
              Resident of: 1155, Bawana, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.
                                        14

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              65 Kiran Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 40 years, Wife of Mr. Vikas Sharma,
              Resident of: 10A/8, Shakti Nagar, Delhi: 110007.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              23.01.1995. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              66 Bimla Chhetri, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 44 years, Wife of Mr. A. K. Chhetri,
              Resident of: 2/2, Old Paramedical Staff Quarter,
              Hindurao Hospital Complex, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              67 Mamta Arora, Staff Nurse
              Aged about 46 years, Wife of Mr. Arora,
              Resident of: 9980/3, Multani Dhanda,
              Paharganj, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              68 Anita Sood, the then Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 44 years, Wife of Mr. S.K. Sood,
              Resident of: T -2, Naveen Shahdara, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              69 Poonam Virdi, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 47 years, Wife of Mr. Satnam Singh,
              Resident of. 9598/14, Motia Khan, New Delhi:55.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              70 Shanti Talreja, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 49 years, Wife of Mr. Mukesh Talreja,
              Resident of: XF 14, Shiva Enclave, A-4,
              Paschim Vihar, New Delhi.
                                         15

                                                               O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                               M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              12.07.1988. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              71 Charu, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 42 years, Wife of Mr. Pankaj Gupta,
              Resident of: 10, Tankers Lane,
              Upper Anand Parbat, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              72 Rachel George, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 39 years, Wife of Mr. George Joseph,
              Resident of: 11, Paramedical Quarters,
              Hindurao Hospital Complex, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              23.01.1996. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              73 Rajuli, the then Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 50 years, Wife of Mr. Rajender Prasad,
              Resident of: B - 42, 2nd floor, Hari Nagar, Delhi - 64
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              09.12.1993. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              74 Meenakshi, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 44 years, Wife of Mr. J.P. Badhani,
              Resident of: D-27, MCD Medical Complex,
              Gulabi Bagh, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              75 Sangeeta Srivastava, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 45 years, Wife of Mr. Manish Saxena,
              Resident of: 134, GF, Vivekanand Puri, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
                                        16

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.


              76 Sarita Vats, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 44 yeare, Wife of Mr. Sanjay Vats,
              Resident of: F - 28, Pragatisheel Apartment,
              Sector 9, Rohini, New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, New Delhi.

              77 Sarita Sharma, Staff Nurse
              Aged about 46 years, Wife of Mr. Satish Sharma,
              Resident of: 1253, Gali Rangmahal,
              Behind Novelty Cinema, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              78 Anju Minocha, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 45 years, Wife of Mr. Sanjay Minocha,
              Resident of: J - 7/47, 3rd Floor,
              Rajouri Garden, New Delhi: 110027.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse .
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              79 Seema Grover, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. Naresh K Grover,
              Resident of: B- 123, New Moti Nagar, New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi sinc
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: R.B.I.P.M.T.
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              80 Lulu Shaji, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Shaji Pappachan,
              Resident of: 21 -22, Nurses Hostel,
              MVID Hospital, Kingsway Camp, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: R.B.I.P.M.T.
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
                                         17

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              81 Mary Viji, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Viji Varghese,
              Resident of: 85, TM-2, RBIPMT,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: R.B.I.P.M.T.,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              82 Lovely Antony, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Antony P..
              Resident of: B- 1/18, 2d Floor, Vindhyashree
              Apartment, Burari, Delhi: 93.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: R.B.I.P.M.T.,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              83 Bijee Geo, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 41 years, Wife of Mr. Antony P.U.
              Resident of: 13 - B, Surya Apartment, Burari,
              Delhi: 110084.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: R.B.I.P.M.T.,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              84 Kiran, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 39 years, Daughter of Mr. Girraj Kishore
              Resident of: House No. 435-436,
              Pocket G-26, First Floor, Sector 3,
              Rohini, New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              26.01.1996 Presently posted at: R.B.I.P.M.T.
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              85 Saroj Bala, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Trilok Chand
              Resident of: I- 6, 2nd Floor, MIG Flats, Prasad
              Nagar, Phase - II, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              26.03.1994. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
                                         18

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              86 Rekha, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Rakesh
              Resident of: 4212, Street Shahtara, Ajmeri,
              Delhi: 110006.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              07.05.1992. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation, Dariya Ganj,
              Delhi.

              87 Manjeet Kaur, the then Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years, Wife of Mr. Suresh Kumar
              Resident of: 16, Type-4, Sector -3,
              Sadiq Nagar, Delhi: 110094.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              88 Shabana Naz, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. Imran Khan
              Resident of: 408, Zakir Nagar West, Okhla, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              15.12.1994. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              89 Nirmal Kaur, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 49 years, Wife of Mr. Amarjit Singh
              Resident of: B-2/168, Rohini, Sector 17,
              New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              07.01.1991. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              90 Somini Philip, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. John Philip
              Resident of: 5/705, Aravali Apartments, Vaishali,
              Ghaziabad.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.
                                        19

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              91 Manju Dixit, Staff Nurse,
              aged about 42 years,
              Wife of Mr. Ajay Kumar Sharma
              Resident of I - 9830, West Gorakh Park,
              Gali No.2, Shahdara, Delhi: 32.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              92 Anita Lal, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Chaman Lal
              Resident of: 30/9- A, Hariom Gali no.1, Babarpur,
              Delhi: 110032.
              Date of Appointment working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              93 Lizy Thomas, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 51 years, Wife of Mr. Thomas John
              Resident of: 165-A, Vikrant Enclave, Mayapuri,
              Delhi: 64.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              03.12.1988. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              94 Juliet Masih, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 43 years, Wife of Mr. Arun Masih
              Resident of: 1769, Krishan Colony,
              Darya Ganj, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              05.05.1992. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              95 Rekha Massey, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 53 years, Wife of Mr. Rebunard Massey
              Resident of: Qtr. No. 6, Kasturba Hospital, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              02.06.1988. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              96 Shahin Khan, Staff Nurse,
                                         20

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              aged about: 52 years, Wife of Mohd. Salim Khan
              Resident of: Qtr. No.3, Dozana House,
              Matia Mahal, Jama Masjid, Delhi: 110006.
              Date of Appointmentworking as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              11.05.1989. Presently posted at: Kasturba Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Dariya Ganj, Delhi.

              97 Pushpa Kadwal, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years,
              Wife of Mr. Pawan Kumar Verma,
              Resident of: 129, Extn.3, Nangloi, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi
              since: 10.12.1992. Presently posted at:
              H cum Maternity Centre,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation, Jwalapuri, Delhi.

              98 Veena Bahal, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 46 years, Wife of Mr. Rajkumar Bahal,
              Resident of A5/283, IIIrd Floor,
              Paschim Vihar, Delhi: 110063.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at: MCH Jwalapuri.
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation, Jwalapuri, DE

              99 Mamta Dagar, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 43 years, Wife of Mr. Dinesh Dagar,
              Resident of: D -61, near Gaushala no.2,
              Maksudabad Colony, Najafgarh, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at
              Kanjhawala Polyclinic,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kanjhawala Village, Delhi.

              100 Daljeet Kaur, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. Paramjeet Singh
              Resident of:34, P.M. Society, B- Block,
              Vikas Puri, New Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at
              Ramesh Nagar Polyclinic,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Ramesh Nagar, New Delhi.

              101 Sureshwati Sharma, Staff Nurse,
                                         21

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. R.D. Sharma,
              Resident of: A - 1/569, Sector -6,
              Rohini, New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at
              Ayurvedic Panchkarma Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Prashant Vihar, New Delhi

              102 Puja Tomar, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 43 years, Wife of Mr. Ravinder K Tomar,
              Resident of: 181, Bharat Apartment,
              Sector-13, Rohini, New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              28.03.1994. Presently posted at:
              Gyanchand Joshi Panchkarma Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Karampura, Delhi.

              103 Rekha Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 48 years, Wife of Mr. Narender Agnihotri,
              Resident of: BE -222, Street no.5, Ist Floor,
              Hari Nagar, Delhi: 110064.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since.
              02.12.1988. Presently posted at:
              Gyanchand Joshi Panchkarma Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Karampura, Delhi.

              104 Neena Khanna, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 46 years, Wife of Mr. Vivek Khanna,
              Resident of: E - 16, 3rd Floor,.
              West Patel Nagar, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at:
              Rajeev Gandhi Panchkarma Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Rajender Nagar, Delhi.

              105 Neena Sabharwal, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 45 years, Wife of Late Jaspal Singh,
              Resident of: B - 34, New India Apartment,
              Sector 9, Rohini, New Delhi: 110085.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              11.12.1995. Presently posted at:
              Panchkarma Prashant Vihar,
                                         22

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Prashant Vihar, Delhi.

              106 Sunita Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 46 years,
              Wife of Mr. Vinod Sharma,
              Resident of: A - 200, Ashoka Enclave,
              Main Rohtak Road, Peera Garhi, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              16.12.1989. Presently posted at Nangloi Polyclinic,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation, Nangloi, Delhi.

              107 Lalita Sharma, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 47 years, Wife of M. Arun Kumar,
              Resident of: 226, Sarai Peepalthala, Azadpur, Delhi
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at: V.D. Clinic,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Roshanara Road, Delhi.

              108 Kanchan Popely, Staff Nurse,
              Aged about 42 years, Wife of Mr. Sanjeev Popely,
              Resident of: EV-20D, Pitampura, New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              04.06.1996. Presently posted at: M.V.I.D. Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Kingsway Camp, Delhi.

              109 Darshan Kaushik, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 44 years,
              Wife of Mr. Raj Kumar Sharma,
              Resident of: 8-D, DDA Flats,
              Gulabi Bagh, Delhi: 110007.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              02.01.1991. Presently posted at: Hindurao Hospital,
              North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              110 Geeta Thakur, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 43 years.
              Wife of Mr. Ajay Kumar Thakur,
              Resident of: A - 5, Rajya Sabha Awas,
              I.N.A. New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at
              Masjid Moth Polyclinic,
                                         23

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Masjid Moth, New Delhi.

              111 Rejeena Mathew, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 45 years, Wife of Mr. P.M. Mathew
              Resident of: D - 12, MCD Flats, B- BIk,
              Defence Colony, New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              01.01.1991. Presently posted at
              Sriniwaspuri Maternity Home,
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Sriniwaspuri, New Delhi.

              112 Chippy John, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. John Jolly
              Resident of: S - 8, Maternity Home, C- Blk,
              Defence Colony, New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              10.12.1992. Presently posted at: Maternity Home,
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Defence Colony, New Delhi.

              113 Leela Tiwari, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 42 years, Wife of Mr. Sanjay Tiwari,
              Resident of: C- 3/1-A, Rajouri Garden, Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              08.12.1995. Presently posted at
              v.G. Maternity Home,
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Vishnu Garden, Delhi.

              114 Sheela Seenu, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 48 years, Wife of Mr. Seenu T.R.
              Resident of: Qtr. No. S- 5,
              Matemity Centre, C- Block,
              Defence Colony, New Delhi: 110024.
              Date of Appointment working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              03.12.1988. Presently posted at: Maternity Home
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Defence Colony, Delhi.

              115 Manjeet Kaur, Staff Nurse,
              aged about 46 years, Wife of Late Sanjeev Kumar
              Resident of: 1807/9, Govindpuri Extn., Kalkaj.
              New Delhi
              Date of Appointment working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since.
                                         24

                                                             O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                             M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

              07.05.1992. Presently posted at:
              Giri Nagar Dispensary, Kalkaji,
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Bara Hindurao, Delhi.

              116 Rukhsana Siraj, Staff Nurse,
              aged about: 47 years, Wife of Mr. Sirajuddin.
              Resident of: 18- B/3, Noor Nagar, Jamia,
              Kotla, New Delhi.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since
              23.12.1995. Presently posted at: Chest Clinic,
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Nehru Nagar, New Delhi.

              117 Jayanti Devi, Staff Nurse,
              aged about 42 years, Wife of Mr. Shekhar Jayal,
              Resident of: C - 44, Gama - I,
              Greater NOIDA, Uttar Pradesh.
              Date of Appointment/working as Staff Nurse
              In erstwhile Municipal Corporation of Delhi since:
              25.03.1994. Presently posted at: Chest Clinic,
              South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              Nehru Nagar, New Delhi.
                                                                   ...Applicant

              (By Advocate: Mr. Pardeep Kumar)

                                        Versus

              01. North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              (Service to be effected upon/through its:
              Commissioner, At: Dr. S.P. Mukherjee Civic Center,
              Minto Road, New Delhi: 110002.

              02. East Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              (Service to be effected upon/through its:
              commissioner, At: 419, Udyog Sadan,
              Patparganj Industrial Area, New Delhi: 110096.]

              03. South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
              [Service to be effected upon/through its:
              Commissioner, At: Dr. S.P. Mukherjee Civic Center,
              Minto Road, New Delhi: 110002.]

              04 Government of N.C.T. Delhi,
              [Service to be effected upon/through its:
              Principal Secretary,
              At: Department of Health and Family Welfare,
              9th level, Delhi Secretariat, I.P. Estate,
              New Delhi: 110002.]
                                        25

                                                           O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                           M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37



              05 Directorate of Local Bodies,
              (Service to be effected upon/through its:
              Director, At: Government of N.C.T. Delhi,
              10th level, Delhi Secretariat, I.P.Estate,
              New Delhi: 110002.

                                                           ...Respondents

              (By Advocate : Mr. S.N. Verma)
                                        26

                                                          O.A. No. 1622/2016
                                                          M.A. No.1591/2016



Item No. 37

                            O R D E R (ORAL)


        Hon'ble Mr. R.N. Singh, Member (J):


In the present OA filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicants have prayed for the following relief(s):

"a. Quashing and setting aside of 'NDMC order no.
O(H)/NDMC/2016/1482 dated 11.03.2016 [Annexure A-1] qua applicant Staff Nurses, so long it denies, shows the benefit of 'NFSG' granted to the Applicants from a date later then 15.07.1998/their completing 03 years of eligible service;
b. Directing respondents to forthwith issue its revised operative order, in respect of applicant Staff Nurses, following the admitted, applicable decision, clarification 'Senior most persons first be awarded ACP Scheme, thereafter juniors may be considered against the upgraded posts of Nursing Personnel' [Annexure A -6] thereby granting, grading the Applicant Staff Nurses in the 'NFSG' pay scale of Rs.5500 SO00 with benefit of fixation of pay under FR 22 (1)(a)(1), in terms of its order no.AO (H)VAK/GF-105/09/1950 dated 23.02.2009 [Annexure A - 11] with effect from 15.07.1998/their completing 03 years of eligible service, as the case may be, with arrears along with interest@9 % per annum, recoverable from salaries of officers of the Corporations' for forcing the applicants into this otherwise avoidable litigation, with all consequential reliefs and benefits.

b. Directing respondents to revise, grant to the applicants, all their subsequent benefits granted under Assured Career Progression Scheme, Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme from their revised date of eligibility as determined after grant of aforesaid up-gradation as per the provisions of the Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme and to make, payment of 27 O.A. No. 1622/2016 M.A. No.1591/2016 Item No. 37 salary, arrears, as per revised fixation of pay so arrived with all consequential reliefs and benefits; c. Costs of this application may also be recovered from officers of the respondent no.1 and granted to the applicants;

d. Any other or further order or direction to grant complete relief to the applicants."

2. Pursuant to notice, the respondents have filed counter reply and have opposed the OA.

3. After arguing at length, Mr. Pardeep Kumar, learned counsel for the applicants submits that the present OA may be disposed of with liberty to the applicants to make a comprehensive representation(s) for the relief(s) sought in the present OA and with a direction to the respondents to consider and dispose of such representation(s) in a time bound manner.

4. To such a request of learned counsel for the applicants, there is no opposition from the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.

5. In the facts and circumstances, with the consent of the learned counsels for the parties and without going into the merits of the case, the present OA is disposed of with liberty to the applicants to submit an individual comprehensive representation(s) for redressal of their grievances, if any, before the competent authority under the respondents within four weeks from today and if such representations are received by the 28 O.A. No. 1622/2016 M.A. No.1591/2016 Item No. 37 respondents within the time stipulated hereinabove, they shall consider and dispose of the same by passing an appropriate reasoned and speaking order as expeditiously as possible and preferably within three months of receipt of such representation(s).

6. The OA is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. No costs.

7. Pending MA, if any, shall also stand disposed of accordingly.

        ( Tarun Shridhar )                                   ( R N Singh )
           Member (A)                                         Member (J)

        /anjali/