Karnataka High Court
B Udayakumar Shetty vs State Of Karnataka on 17 August, 2010
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, K.Govindarajulu
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 177" DAY OF AUGUST, 20
PRESENT:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE v.o. E 1 E
AND
mi": HON'8LE MR. JUSTICE K.c;omNsiwi;
M1sc.w.42E1%7/2010 E V
WRIT PETITION NC')-.«99"t__35¥7L2/20 10
BETWEEN:
1. B. Udayak.iim_ar V
S / o »K.;;1iaZEier:';y*a1i;ia
Aged >
Tahsiidaii'.'f-.,:* w E
Ankola %'I'a'11,ik.fjj , .. ,, " 2
Axlkoiag . ._ _
Lfttara KaI1nada' District.
~ _ A _ Kathyayaiii Devi
V "D/'vo_S.hr.i_; Shivashankarappa,
_ --._Aged'_~4_O=y'ears,
A Assistant Director,
Directorate of Social Security &
A Pensions, Revenue Department,
a ' '*-Vth Floor, Gate No.III,
' Building,
Bangalore -- 560 001.
5-5' V4 .V
l'~J
B.S. Marijunatha Swarny
S/0 Shri. BN. Sadasiva,
Aged 36 years,
Tahsildar,
O/o Regional Commissioner,
Shanthinagar,
Bangalore. 1
Ms. Rashml
D/o Shrl. lVI.N. GurL:--raj~.,_l§ao.;' '
Aged 35 years.
Tahslldar,
Doddaballapu'1*.fl'faiu;l%, 3; .i ~ _
Doddaballapur,
Bangalore Rural. 'V V.
K. Ra_1i.1lV§olgalLreera "" "
S/ o gS}l?fi1--..V P{i*1shnja.. xl\21ogaV'ee»ra
Aged ..
Talhsildfar, 'fig "
. .
Kundapuf', _ '
_ Udupi Disi1*ici§-
. u . Rémganathé ..... <4 \
" 'V S/'oi Kenchappa,
;Age.d" 39 years,
' '*~'Spee'ialfTahsildar,
Barigalore North Additional
Taiiik, yelahanka.
Bangalore Rural District.
. '' '':Dayanar1da Bhandari
S/o Shri. Seetharam Bhandari,
Aged 39 years,
Tahsildar,
Hosakote Taluk, .
Bangalore Rural District.
Ms. K.T. Shanthala
D/o Shri. Thimmaiah,
Aged 37 years, '
Tahsildar, "
BBMP, Corporation Building
Hudson Circle, V' V
Shanthinagar, B'
Bangalore ~ 560027. sa,,,.PET1'rroNERs
(By Sri. N :,B. Bhat, Adxfocateis
AND:
1.
State of I:a:*nata::a~ ,
By "Ch.ief;SeV€5rctary'--to A "
G;9vernrnen.t_, . .
Vidhana So'ufdha,_. .. , 4'
Bangalore 4- 560 .
.. i?I;3'.ncipaI" Secretary to
A "-~--Government of Karnataka,
" ~ ._Re.Ven'ue" Department,
I » "Bangaijor7e -- 560 001.
Karrzaiaka Public Service
or s Commission,
Park House,
B Bangalore -- 560 001.
By its Secretary.
Dr. S.L. Vzmikyal
S/0 Dr. Shankareppa
L. Vanikyal,
Aged 38 years,
R/0 Naganur Post,
Shorapur Taluk,
Gulbarga District. ' A
Sharanabasa ppa KQAte_ppago_i' ' "
S/0 Marthandappa K.Q:teppago.l, '
Aged 36 years, _ 2
C/0 Shri. S.R, rPati1,,<'" *
No.10--585, Brah}iampur_,' '
Near Venkavva MarRé=;i:',' . .
Gulbargaa 585""1'O~3} "
Dr.
S/0 Sgh1tf_1'g.';.VShiV'an'ir1:a ._
'
R/0 sad:3:*aIfi@et;.rgV A
Laxim'pu_r' A
sh'orapur-f1'a1u;:, A
_('}u1b"a-rga Dir'-.stA1"i1'cV't";"
- Pradsan néi" """ 'A A
' = .. _ 0. V Maikareddy,
A . 40 .y.E:ars,
A."-«R/O -'1'S~h.garada Krupa",
Baysaweshwar N agar,
Chifradurga.
gArM.s.N. Babu
" "S/0 M.D. Sannadoddaiah,
Aged 33 years,
Residing at No.I.?.35/I,
10.
11.
Housing Board,
KR. Extension,
Tiptur.
I-I.K. Krishna Murthy,
S/o Shri. Kannappa,
Aged 34 years, I
R/ o Mandagalaie, ;
Kanle Post, Sagar Taluk, '
Shimoga ~»~ 577 430.
C. Nagaraju V "jg
S/o Shri. Chikim.n_na, "
Aged 38 years, . 2
R/o No.348, 15AI*1'erȣ2un;5}-ag
1st ~
BaHg€110i.rf:_ -- 560 079;
* .
S",/o' Shri. Han i1vr;j{an{.ayya,
Aged 38 years,
_RVesid"i-ng at Nc=..FB~~44,
" HAL Old T.QWI'}.S1}ip.
"V§,ma'napu.ra"'Post,
__B.a11ga_Ior.e -- 560 017.
.
S/_'o' Shri. H .13. Hanumantharaju, Aged 35 years.
A. R'/0 No.65, RVR Nilaya, '' ';4~"' cross, Nanjappa Gardens. ' "Babusapalya, Kalyana Nagar, Bangalore --» 560 043.
13.
14.
15.
16. (.3 M.N. Rajendra Prasad S/0 Shri. M.J. Neelakanta, Aged 35 years.
Residing at No.73/3, Kote Street, Saiigrama, K.R. Nagar taluk, Mysore District. I Sheelavant Shivakumar S/o Mailikarjunappa'«sheelaikants.1fl Aged about 37 years, Sri, Guru Nivas...'No..?:/'9''}.O,/12/18, " "
Prashant Nagar {B1, Raj.a;p£1'ff -. _ Extension, Guibarga ~{4'585.--~«1,O5;_j __ Guibarga, , * a Mahe-sh S/0 Bhi1§fiash'ani§a'f; Ag-e«d_Aab.0u'ti§S4 years, P:;a1yan"I\J;aga'r, = A' Sindgi E_"i86~«1"28'.~,_'i'si--.,1' i _GeetVa"'Kou.1,a,giA'=. _;D/'so Ira;5p..a,_ _ '- Age.d about 36'years. __f{,/o«.C4_/_€)B.R. Deshpande, . P1oa:..No.V'4.1', IMair1. "~.Samr§anf'C0lony, X 580 030.
Rarriesh Desai, S/0 Shrikantappa Desai, "Aged about 36 years, 'V Residing at Basapur Yalavatti Post, Hanagai Taluk, Haven' District.
18.
19.
20.
21. Shankaragoud Somanal S/0 Shivappa.
Aged about :31 years, Residing at Jammaiadirmi, Muddebihai Taluk, Bijapur District. C.J. Krishna Kumar S/0 Late G.S. Janardhanadflaio, Aged about 42 years,=.__ R/0 Tailor Khazi Mohaiia Behind Ideal C(3!.lege,~<"' " 9
Chitradurga -- 51717 501 1 S. Yogeshwaa S/0 Aged.
Resiciingat Dum'a:.ha1"Ii'i'Road, Ma1aVag0p'p.anP0st'.--. A "
ShimogasD.i_s't.ric:V, 1 S13_lfIf}Qg1E1._ 1 S. Rapas1'ee'.'« A P.\/if Sree Ramareddy, " 'aI:)out 3513/ears, V --. _Re_si.d'i.rj1'gv at N0.14»1--1-42,
- Iieh'es.iLa3?o*ut, IA Cross, "*vVidya'i'ariyapura. 1''-«...Ba._r'1'ga1'0re »_ 560 097. Swetha "(Z/0 G.N. Nagendra Aged about 4} years, Residing at i\io.i'7--24, Brahmins Vaiiey,
23.
24.
25. Madlkeri, Kodagu ~ 571 201.
Prajna Ammembala D/0 Prof. A.V. Naada. Aged about 32 years, Residing at 1\E0.Appellant'6:
Professors Quarters, Hampi Kannada Uni>ve_:rsit'y..A - Vidyaran P.O. Hospet_fi"a'luk,"' ~ _ Beliary District. G.V. Nagaraj VA --_ S/0 Venkateshappa, Aged about 44 years; ' R/0 Gunuéur Vlia Vafth-uAf~;t"_j~~.VV ' 'V ' Bangaléfgrejf' "" M 3/0 Ha1tiun3_a«iah.,V"-.,._ . ' Aged 'about .34 'ty.ears Resi~di11g at (3/0 Govindaraju 1_\?eert,ikL}'I1t6:;*« Atétharahalli Post, " 4_{I)0d dabaI'1Vapvt}HrA7Faluk, » _ VSid1*amap__pa S,/b-..S'h1?.isV?_*1ailBiradar, . "'vAgedVa;b.é)ut 37 years, "'««..Re.\V'd-ix-ig at Charadihal Post, Ixadiffaluk, .. Bijapur District. .V Raghavendra S/o Late S. Venkatram. Aged about 35 years,
28.
29.
30. 9
R/0 No.51, 16"' Cross, 33" Main, JP. Nagar, 6"' Phase, Banglaore -- 560 078. MP. Maruthi S/0 Pancha, I Aged about 33 years, , A' Residing at C / 0 BS'. Palaksh; No.26, K.K. Annexe, .. ' High Grounds, Bangalore -- 5€~«O._O0 ' Q"; S.N. Rudresha _ . ' S/0 Late ANe_1gendrap'pa'; . Aged abdi'1,t,-'36:3re:;1r*sA, es K0da__1gaTh_a51«ii,';'--_ " ,_ . ' Chic}gjaji_u;f Via' . Holalkere T;?11uk--, Chitratiizrga"Di's1;ri£:j';.-- i R.s1;gma:5%r , T _S_/0 S'.~H.' R.&i'ma.ch'andraiah. ,, (Aged ab o'u.t, 36 «years, flNi,O,66.0, HI Main, Aravind-a__ N agar, s A P.'I,§zs,Q1~e"'e--;_;570 023. Bavs'ajf£1raj Ramappa Somannavar S/0; Mani Ramappa. Aged. about 37 years, " "~«Yadaha1li Post.
-=B1las1'I'a1uk, Bagalkot District.
32.
33.
34.
35. Patharaju S/o Veerarnaraiah, Aged about 35 years. Mann Post, Tyamagondlu Via Nelamangala Taluk -- 562 132, Bangalore Rural Disf:rict._ B. Venkatesha S/o Byrappa, V, Aged about 43 years, No.33 / 34, Buvaneshwar.1L1:1agar2..' Hebbal Kernpapul'.
Bangalore -- u Shivaswamy S / o Late Seer'egow~d:g,]"-- V. Aged_.abo_u'é_ V ' C / o Jav-ar;eg0awd.a;'~:,'e_' ._ 7 No;-24 /'Qa, A'é3>::%'?. C'ros.s, ' "
1;9m Mama, .1 B_loc_k,. a Bangalore' Nar1}'V'1in de .GovAVd»a A V' 4 Chif{k.agnneg V Gowda.
-- Aged about 3-Vlyears. r ggrzalagapura, Bandalli Post. " - KOI1egaI'r-Taluk. "*wCha11éojarajanagar District. "Ii.ya'$ Ahmed Isamadi _ ' .. S/o' Makhtum Hussain Ismadi, "Aged about 38 years. k' 'Kharadi Mohalla, PB. Road, Hubli -- 580 028.
37.
38.
39.
40. Pujar Veeramallappa S/0 Late P. Veerabhadrappa, Aged about 42 years, Near Neeranna Temple. Old Bus Stand, Harapanahalli, Davanagere Dlstrtct. T.N. Krishnamurthy S/ o A. Narayana, Aged about 39 years,f Thimmasandra, Kannamangala Post, Madhure HoI:>lI.,.---- A Doddaballapur T_aj1uk., Bangalore Rural District} dd ' V. " V S/ o Vasar1.tha'ppa;?.7fA * Aged :55 ygéars, No.279*,?;NaAras1p.uI=a, _ _-- R'/o Vidya1'a'nyap"t2.1fVa Post, Bangalore-9550 o97; 5L; Bheorna 'Nail; Q Lakshhiana naik. gt about 39 years, V _ " R./?"o_yVMéutiyammanahalli Thanda, " --._i~ios;i'e«t Taiuk, .' ' Belvlaxfyyw. Dlstrlct. Asha AA . ' D/o T.S. Shankar, ' " Aged about 37 years, No.320, I Main Road, 8"] Block, Koramangala, ,« Bangalore --~» 560 035.
42. SM. Mangaia D/0 Munikailappa, Aged about 35 years. Mailur Village 8: Post, Sidlaghatta Taluk, Kolar District -- 562 102. A'
43. B.V. Krishnaveni D / o M. Venkatakrishna'p,p_a,_V Aged about 41y'ears,;="
4"' Block, I Block, _ Jayanagai', ' V' C/0 Shashikala*--NL1rs«eI'j;§; t i BangaIore:"36(i!. oi if ft .
44. R. i H D / o Ram,ah.ar1t%;m aiah-, Aged: ab_o_ut 53;' 1...Vy'ear*s_, - __ ~ I No.528,'1_ 'C? Cfoss;«_.3'=*7<?.'Stage, 4"] Block, Bas'a.veshW"aranagar, Bangaiore o';?9;itt _ vfi; Shyalaja t » VD/.,oV Ram'a,Vii'nge Gowda, Aged ~:~1bio'utf'30 years, two' s.He.tt1§airigowda, Sal-igrarn-a';' ~ KR. ~~Na;.gar Taluk, * Mysore District. a Saroja % __£)/o B.H. Benakappa, Aged about 39 years,
47.
48.
49. C/0 J.K. Kurubar, Naregal Post.
Hanagal Taluk.
Haveri District. Y.N. Chandramman D/0 Nanjegowcia, Aged about 42 years. C/0 Nanjegowda, Yalanahalli, Hirisave Hobii, Channarayapaytngt Taltik'; Hassan District ?'3. % +55. F'.V.P0orr11'ma D/0 FAB'. ";'ff:.f1ka:?es:haeha§;. "
Aged__.abo.ut--..3;2 ' ' C / 0 O_sr--a_g»i Gérd.e'n.'; .. Msehen;1hé&3;:~'.w A.-_'--:-.61 2 1":
GAQwri.bAidaen;_1'rM'I'al_i1-k, -- I K0381' _DistriCt_. V. Thabaissizms Zak': efé AbidAAu?.. .....
A about 83 years.
._C',/Vo«l\/Is:é'r.__Taj Ahmed, Haspital.'-Main Road, "'HolaV'é13'1:ihaiIi - 572 121. "'4«..Ko:'a"La.gere Taluk, 'I'umkur District. .. Premila A D/0 K. Mahadevappa, Aged about 37 years, 2~274~/4. Jagat.
51.
52.
53.
~54.
Guibarga --~ 585 101. AM. Shylaja Priyadarshini D/0 Shanmukaiah A.M., Aged about 35 years, No.67/1. Devanagotri, Shankar Mutt Road, I Shankarpuram, * Bangalore -~ 560 004.; HE. Chetanashri D/o D.K. Eregowdya. . Aged about 35 years, N o. 15, VishamanavaV_D%oij!ole*i?§oa;§:§»;__ Kuvempu _Na_gar.;"'"'" 1: _ - Mysore M. Ra\,*ik':J._Inar"" ' _ s/eat./mdaiarr, - Aged aAb'o.t:t.,V_4«Ey y=e_a1~,s_, . j Cauxfery' RV0a"d..V t « Koilegal. ' A' V Chamaraj naa'gar'~_ District. ;So.mal--ing Harggm » .VS/Qfiotpaly. V Agetd..VabVo-at 40 years.
"'DeVar"a_ Gennur Post, A "-~.Bij_a'pur' Taluk & District. ' , _.N. : Usha Rani /0 Chikkananjaiah. V' Aged about 88 years. No.2222. 9"? Main. E Block, Rajajinagar 2"' Stage,
56.
57.
58. A " A59.
Bangalore -- 560 010. S.Y. Bhajantri S/o yellappa.
Aged about 38 years, Shindogi Post, Saudatti Taluk. I Belgaum District -- 591 1 'A P.N. Lokesh * S/0 P. Nagendrappa, _ Aged about 32vy'ears,.<'"""
Sangameshwara.Ni}Aa3za;{_' ; A A Diwatar Nagar, _ , Koppal -- F83 23'1"' - K. Ke.s'l1"a.1_/éé3i€i:Vj&t' -- S/o K,K--.ifi__Svhafma;'~i_' '. A Aged abouE"§~1 years, 1\'oo.255'.oa.:m_Ag.Ma:fiA,aeg A I Du.basipa1ya;.R;\[f"Cgo--}1ege Post. Mysore» Road'; .
_B_anga'i»ofe -_ ".560 059.
" 'Nagaraj Sefiy ,5/_Q'Ra_r1'ga Setty. Agejéggabdout 54 years. . ""NO.7;'V'.D§/Irifi}, I Main, ""«..4'1*1..__'I311a"se, 707, CH8; Layout, .. Yeiahanka New Town. . Bangalore -- 560 064. N. Mohammed Zubair S/o Nannemiya Sab,
61.
62.
63. I 6 Aged about 36 years, Md. Zubalr Narasapur. Shikaripur Taluk. Shlmoga Dlstrlct. R. Suma D/o Rangalah Aged about 37 years. NQ862, 6*" Main.
Raghavendra Block,' Srinagar, Bangalore -- 560 050. N. Th1ppeswarr1y'-,ffi.. S/0 Nagappa, .
Aged ab0_ut.__41 },7'ea'r's, Bellaghattfg.-Post 5577 "51d7*r} * 'FhirL1Va11.LiI?u'1V;H0bl.i; 'A. ' Chitragdurga T'a1u'k:_& on NagesfiifaigF*.. ,Hofi.na11i S / oxF4akee1*appa Hormalli. Aged ab out 33 "years. go ._§fgTahs1Idars.. Offlee, " "H'ukke1fi -- 591309 * -. __£3.eIgau_1"r1 District. A"-_C;'VI§i'anjg'iifiath S/go Chlnnappa.
Aged about 35 years, NoV..3O-4, I Mam Road. A 'A ' «Byatarayanapura, V' v Bangalore --- 560 092.
65.
66.
67.
68. E. Balakrishnappa S/0 Erappa.
Aged about 35 years. Makalarahalli Post, Hiriyur Taluk.
Chitradurga District. C.N. Manjunath ;
S/o Late C.M. Narayan_appa.,_ Aged about 36 years, ' V H.K. I-Ially Post, Chintamani 'I'a}u..}_{, Kolar District. "
RajashreeA'JainaTpi.'zrft "
D/0 I""I.Z:';'£"i}§El.i1'1a:f)u2f,"A 2 Aged__.ab'o_u5t_.3f2 ' ' Rajaslfireei;Bha'Jafi;,"_' ._ 7 Opp. .An;jufii;an C.o11ege';"'~~"
a Prashant Na1"Wfar:"'''*-..,, ' S_/ 0 Bheemalshankar, ', ._iAge:d about «-40 years, _ "C/To Gaohohin, ~ _ Veerap_u'r__Road, A Ud9%:maf€aI'» " . ""Havei*i'j, ..RESPONDENTS fl'i'he PI-oijosved Respondents /Interveners Balakrishna 'S/o Lokayya Naik. Age 36 years.
W/0 Assistant Labour Commissioner,
70.
71.
72.
73. Division III, Karmika Bhavana, Bannergatta Road, Bangaiore ~-- 29. Sripad S. Boiashetty S/o Subbanna.
Aged about 38 years, ' W/a Assistant Labour Cof:mi«i_sAsi0ri€2r;'~.o «. " '' Davanagere.
M.S. Chidanancia S/o MB. Shankayayya "jé Age: 43 years, " A 7 ' "
W/ a Assistant Lab'our'.'Con1.1"r1i's--s_ior1er. Be1gaum.f JohI1Sof1.._K}.G:7, '' " ' S/0 'l'.,K;ii__G;&_(f3orge,«.. .. A Agezia/i2"yeai€:s",-- " A W/a_ I.4aboi.uf "Ofi"i<:_ér_,_ -- ' Ch_ikmaga1u.if;. DVhara'm=;Vsh..
,, . / o M ah'adex(_a_iah, A S'7_years, 4, ., .. W/_a~ Lab~ou.r Officer. A war.
A _ 74.
Nagaraj S/ot.K.N_ Badappa, " A :._Agé': 42 years, A. 'AW/a Labour Officer, Haveri.
I9
75. D.G. Nagesh S/0 Sonnegowda, Age: 42 years, W/ a Labour Officer, Mangalore.
76. Guru Prasad H.L I T. S/o Lakshminarayana Rat», Age: 34 years, W/a Labour Officer, Hassan.
77. S. Revanna S/0 Siddappa, Age: 44 years, -
W/a La;i"3oi"31?.'Offi.cer,'"° at [By Shri;-. "1€:hai1.e'ndra',""~C/ Respondent 21,33. 41,44,[ 64, 'Ranghanath S W JOD for Respondent ' Sheela Krishnan, Additional Gov'ern'n*1en't.»r. Advocate for Respondent No.1,__2, Shri.~_f€rishn'a S. Dixit, for lrnpleading Applifizant on "Mic.W,.iefi217/2010, Respondent No.3, 13,- 18, 19, 20. 22. 28, 30, 42, 43. 52, 55. ~59 .a_r'id'i57'v are Served) *=2=** . " ""I,\/li.scl;.V'V;4'\f{'.V..e1'éii,217/2010 is filed under Articles 226 anc:1'~22,"{" 'of~'the Constitution of India and order 1 'Rule 10'; and also Section 151 of Code of Civil ,Procedur'e, 1908 praying to permit the Applicants =herei"n to come on record as Respondent Nos. 69 to or"in the alternative as interveners in the above Writ Petition. ' 2{} This Misc.W. Coming on for Orders this'--..;1ay, V.G.SABH_AHIT J., made the foii0wi_r1g:« " V Heard(H1hfiseANJW1421?/2Di0fLJeh-hh The impleading ap1:*iVi'ca_.tioI'jA'v~ie, the * %' averment made theirfeapphceitione. ' not controverted and as necessary parties for ":the point that arises for Writ petitions. The cause--tif;1eMf0' Sd/m Judge Sd[-
fudge